2 h 25 min · 16,810 words · 20 November 2010
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues the Three Principles of the Path, focusing on bodhicitta. It covers the sufferings of cyclic existence, the method and wisdom aspects of the path, and the kinds and advantages of bodhicitta. It then presents the sevenfold cause-and-effect instruction and the equalizing and exchanging of self and others, with a closing question session.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 25m
UUID: 9d6689eb-7450-4373-a51d-5b73c92ce3d6
Date: 2010-11-20
Words: 16,806
Thank you very much, Chris. So it’s a pleasure to see so many known faces here. And, for those of you who are new, in my own name and in the name of the Tibetan Buddhist Institute, I would like to greet you here. Now, talks are really something between seminars and presentations of the Dharma, and especially since we are covering the three principles of the path, we are in the very core of the Buddhist teachings. Therefore, it is appropriate for us, in keeping with Khensur Rinpoche’s tradition, to first generate a good motivation to listen to these teachings, and then for those of you who are Buddhist, to take refuge.
We will take refuge together. Those of you who are not are welcome to sit down and relax. So first, generating the motivation, which is going to define what result we can expect from these teachings. Our motivation should not be self centered, we should not be here for our own sake. We should be here for the sake of others, not for the sake of a couple others, our friends, our relatives, nor even for the sake of all human beings, but for the sake all beings with consciousness, what we call sentient beings.
If we listen to the teachings with that motivation, which is the most powerful motivation we can have, to try to benefit all beings with consciousness, then the teachings we listen to can and will become a cause for ourselves benefiting all these beings. Especially if we listen to these teachings with the motivation to attain a state of unalloyed perfection, which we call Buddhahood. A state where all of the qualities are accomplished and all of the faults are eliminated. Not for our own sake, but for the sake of others exclusively. There is no more powerful motivation than this.
This is a motivation which we call bodhicitta, the mind of enlightenment. This is a motivation we must try to generate before listening to these teachings. So we will therefore meditate on this for a short minute or so. Thank you very much. And at present, since these are Buddhist teachings, those of you who are Buddhist, and only those of you who are Buddhist, we will take refuge together.
I myself will stand, you can remain seated. We will take refuge in Sanskrit because of the uncommon blessings of the Sanskrit tongue. So we will all repeat together the refuge stanzas. So we have been presenting what is known as the Three Principles of the Path, which is one of the core texts Je Tsongkhapa wrote for one of his foremost lay disciples. Last time we presented the first of the three principles of the path, which is known sometimes as renunciation, but which we prefer to call definite emergence, that will to be liberated from the totality of cyclic existence.
There are two other principles of the path, which are respectively what we will cover today: bodhicitta, the mind wishing for full enlightenment for the sake of all living beings, and the view realizing emptiness, which is the means to attain liberation both from the cycle of lives for oneself and to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all others. Last time, as a prelude to the teachings, we gave a short introduction to the life of the founder of the Geluk tradition, Je Tsongkhapa, who lived between 1357 and 1419, and who was the greatest reformer of the Buddhist tradition in Tibet, who reintroduced pure and authentic Dharma where it had greatly degenerated in Tibet. We mentioned briefly some of the deeds of Je Tsongkhapa. Today, I would like to give some background as an introduction to the life of Khensur Rinpoche, who is our teacher here at the Tibetan Buddhist Institute and whom we can see as a worthy successor of Je Tsongkhapa. I think it is a characteristic of all of us that we seldom do appreciate what we have.
In Khensur Rinpoche, we have one of the very last of the lineage holders who has come out of Tibet, who was trained in Tibet. It is widely believed to this day by Rinpoche students in India that Rinpoche was an unrecognized reincarnated Lama because of some of the deeds Rinpoche performed as a very young child. When one sees pictures of Rinpoche as young, there is an extraordinary purity which is very obvious on pictures taken at that early date. He came from a very wealthy family in Tibet, in the East Of Tibet. He abandoned all his family had to offer to travel some 3,000 kilometers on foot to study in Lhasa at Sera Je Monastery.
He studied with the greatest of his age and became disciples of teachers who are mythical at present. Rinpoche was a personal disciple of Khyabje Pabongka Rinpoche, who composed Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, which is one of the root texts for the practice of Lamrim. Rinpoche was a personal disciple of Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche, the junior tutor of the Dalai Lama. When Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche came to India, Rinpoche, in the horrific conditions which succeeded the Chinese invasion of Tibet in 1959, reorganized studies among the monks who had fled Chinese occupation, Chinese communist occupation. He reorganized these studies with my late teacher Geshe Rabten and many other of these great beings in Buksa.
Buksa was a prison camp in the North Of India. It had been built by the British to house the Indian independence fighters. Conditions were horrific. And yet, despite these conditions, despite the heat, despite the fact that literally scorpions were set to fall from the ceiling onto people, Rinpoche and the likes of Khensur Rinpoche started training and continued training the Geshes who now are present throughout Buddhist centers in the West. Rinpoche was then sent to the South Of India when it was decided to reconstruct Seraje Monastery in India.
The decision was taken to reconstruct the monastery in the far South Of India, as far as possible, from the Chinese Tibetan border, in a jungle area. When Rinpoche arrived in that area, all of the monks were given one pail, one axe, and one tarp, and they were set forth to cut down, to deforest, the trees in the jungle. Rinpoche himself was put aside by the other monks and told that he was too high a teacher to waste his time doing this, that they would work and he would meditate for them. And therefore Rinpoche told me that he stayed in a small tent made of a tarp doing retreats, and at the end of the day, when the monks came back exhausted, he would start teaching, so that the continuum of the teachings was not lost. Khensur Rinpoche became abbot of Seraje monastery.
He was one of the founders of the school at Seraje monastery for which he gathered funds worldwide so that the young Tibetan refugees who came to become monks should have some modicum of studies. It is something the monastery owes to Rinpoche against great opposition from some of the more traditional teachers who felt there was no point in a secular education for young monks. And on top of this, Khensur Rinpoche then engaged in the three year long retreat, which he had been instructed personally by Kyabje Trijang Rinpoche, the junior tutor of the Dalai Lama, to perform. His attainments during the retreat have become part of Khensur Rinpoche’s legend. It is perhaps not my place here to talk about them.
In the future, some of you may ask Rinpoche. Suffice it to say that he is considered in all the monasteries as the lineage holder of the practice of Vajrayoginī, and as one of the very great living masters. At present, he is the dean of all of the former abbots of Sera Je monastery. So we are very fortunate to have a teacher of that caliber who, at the request of others, at the request first of a major sponsor of Seraje monastery, and then explicitly at the request of His Holiness the Dalai Lama, stayed in Adelaide for more than twenty years, when the monastery from there on the side could not understand why precisely he was bothering to be in this small Australian town by the sea. As I said, we often do not appreciate what we have, and we are very fortunate that Rinpoche has resisted calls from his monastery to return, and has stayed here seeing some sort of long-term benefit which we do not fully understand.
Personally, I became Rinpoche’s student at Seraje Monastery. Rinpoche in Singapore asked me to come here to translate for him. From my side, decision was very easy, because I saw at Seraje Monastery where I got an idea of who Khensur Rinpoche was. Then for a teacher like that, it is not difficult to leave everything in Switzerland and come to the end of the world. So I get images of being a new crocodile Dundee in Australia.
But I said to some Australian friends here, it’s become quite civilized since those days. So from my standpoint, I see myself as, as I said last time, the loudspeaker. The mouthpiece, first and foremost for Khensur Rinpoche and for all my other teachers. And I will try to bridge as much as I can as a Westerner who is automatically as a Westerner between the West and this Tibetan tradition. I will try to bridge things to make them as accessible as I can without, however, ever betraying them.
That has to be our boundary. So last time we covered the presentation of definite emergence, the wish to escape from the cycle of lives, which we traverse endlessly, to escape from suffering. I would like, at present, because we did not have time last time, and will usher our topic today, to give a thorough presentation of the nature of suffering from the Buddhist standpoint. This is indispensable both to generate definite emergence and to eventually generate bodhicitta. Without an understanding of what suffering is, in other words, without an understanding of our actual situation, we can generate neither of these.
When we say suffering in the West, we refer to pain. In other words, we mean physical suffering and possibly for some of us mental suffering, anguish. This is a very, very narrow understanding of the term, which has caused great problems in the transmission of Buddhism to the West. The Buddhist understanding of suffering is far more all encompassing. Suffering is everything which can lead eventually to suffering.
I suppose this is the best possible definition from a Buddhist standpoint of suffering. In other words, everything which has within it the potential to lead to physical pain, to mental anguish, to a sense of dissatisfaction or transience. Then there are numerous presentations of suffering, an eightfold presentation of suffering, a sixfold and a threefold presentation of suffering. You have a handout with these presentations, which we will cover at present the modalities of suffering. And we will start in reverse order.
Instead of starting with the three sufferings and moving up to the sixth and the eighth, we will start with the most elaborate presentation, the eight sufferings, because it is the easiest to understand, is the most cognate with our experience. So the eight sufferings you can see listed are the sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death, encountering what is unpleasant, not encountering what is pleasant, not getting what one wants, and the suffering of the five appropriated aggregates. Every single being in the cycle of life, in cyclic existence, experiences at least one of these eight sufferings. In the case of human beings, we experience all eight. We experience a suffering of birth, of aging, of sickness, and of death.
And one of our Western tragedies is that in the quite laudable aim to alleviate these sufferings, they have been evacuated from public view. They are no longer present for us. None of us realizes what birth entails. I lived many years in India where people give birth in the main room of the family shack. Everyone is witness to the agonies and the travails of birth, and to the possible death of either mother or child.
From the little children in the family to the husband who has made the child. Birth is not a pleasant experience, birth is feared. Every single time, birth opens a possibility of death for the mother. In our case, individually, we have no memories of our birth. Psychologists such as Rank believe that this is largely because birth is such a traumatic experience.
It is evacuated from consciousness. I personally feel one of the strongest arguments in favor of the acquisition of clairvoyance by the great Buddhist yogis is Chandra Gomin’s depiction of the suffering of birth in one of his works. It is impossible to describe the sufferings of birth that well if one has not lived through them. So it seems to me obvious that this great Indian yogi, Chandra Gomin, remembered the sufferings of his own birth. Chandra Gomin describes being compressed as between two walls in a suffocating situation without knowing when will it emerge into the light, and then emerging as a newborn infant in a state of shock faced with massive sensory stimuli and feeling that one is being flayed alive at the first contact.
These are sufferings we do not remember, yet they herald our coming into this life. Then the sufferings of aging are sufferings which we refuse to acknowledge. From a Buddhist standpoint, aging starts at birth. Aging is not something which starts at age 50, 60, 70, or depending how many times you go to the plastic surgeon, 80 or 90. You know?
Aging starts at the very instant of birth. From a Buddhist perspective, the body which is impermanent is being destroyed instant by instant. The sufferings of aging reveal themselves. And a great Tibetan practitioner said that If the sufferings of aging fell upon us all at once, they would be so insupportable that we have to be grateful for the fact that they happen all the time. If one day you were 25 and you woke up the next morning at age 72, barely able to get out of bed, incontinent, dimwitted, being told quietly by your family that there’s nothing to worry about, dad or mom, we’ll take care of it.
This would be horrific. But we become accustomed to these sufferings of aging. And therefore, it is only if we reflect upon them that we become aware of them. Our Western obsession with aesthetic surgery, of plastic surgery, does not help. Those who are able to give up makeup and plastic surgery are face to face with the suffering of aging each day when they look at themselves in the mirror.
Then the sufferings of death are sufferings which are completely occulted from our society. In my own life, I saw many people die. Most of the deaths were ugly and hard. Deaths do not occur as in the movies. Typically, death occurs, everything stops.
If death occurs through physiological shock, the vows and the bladder void. If it occurs in a long process of decay, the person progressively sinks into a state of incapacity or senescence. I remember in India seeing an old woman dying of hunger in Mysore, who came to beg for food for me. She was in the final stages, because it was in the early 40 degrees, and she was shivering of cold. I gave her what I thought I could give her without it being stolen from her.
Had I given too much, it would have been stolen at once. I thought if I give 500 rupees, it would be stolen. I gave 100, trying not to be seen. I don’t think she was able to put it to good use. She must have died shortly after.
In the monasteries, saw beggars die on the street. The death of a human being is in no way different from the death of a dog. When a dog dies and when a human being dies, is fear. Then there is a process of complete physiological collapse. And very swiftly what we are oblivious to in our civilized societies, decomposition and decay sets in.
That body which was an object of attraction and desire, this charming person with whom we were conversing, within a matter of a couple hours in the hot latitudes, after consciousness has left, starts to stink. The stench becomes unbearable. It is something one can only know if one has experienced it once. This is a suffering we haven’t gone through not one time, but over and over again. The four first of the eight sufferings are sufferings which every one of us has experienced in almost every single life we have lived.
We have been born again and again. We have aged again and again. We have been ill again and again. Again and again, we have faced the terror and the fear of death before leaving everything and starting the cycle all over again. This is the Buddhist understanding of what is called cyclic existence.
This is why we strive to escape from it. Then the four remaining of the eight sufferings are the suffering of encountering what is unpleasant. It is our lot in life, we would not like it to be so, but we periodically stumble in situations which are exactly what we do not want, not encountering what is pleasant even though we wish to, not getting what we want, and the most broad category of all, the five appropriated aggregates, which is a fundamental statement that everything which constitutes our being, both bodily and mental, is of the nature of suffering, is of the nature if not of physical and mental pain, then of dissatisfaction of transience, of ephemerity, and ultimately can only lead to the same. These eight sufferings are an elaborated presentation of these six sufferings which are a more fundamental set of characteristics of cyclic existence, what we call saṃsāra. And the way to reflect on these six sufferings and on suffering in general is to connect this with our own life, not to just look at this as some sort of odd Indian presentation of the nature of things, To ask ourselves, is this true?
Many in this room are above 50, some are above 60. Those of you who are young have had disappointment and hardship. Check. Is it true that when all is said and done, the nature of my life is unsatisfactory? It never lives up to what I hope it should live up to or not.
Therefore, if you reflect on the six sufferings, the first of the six sufferings is uncertainty. This is a core experience of our lives, which in developed countries is occulted. Our lives are totally uncertain. We project ourselves in a future for which we have no guarantees. In this room, most of you probably have mortgages.
Most of you have incurred a lot of debt. Australia Australians are said to be the most indebted, developed citizens in the world at present. You have incurred debt because you have desires which don’t correspond to your status. Otherwise, you would live within your means. Incurring debt means that you are working on the assumption the future is certain.
You’re projecting yourself into a fantasized certain future, in which the job you have, you will have or you’ll have a better job, the relationship you are in will last or will improve, your health will remain the same or will improve, The global financial situation be the same or will improve. And the situation in Australia is not going to degenerate sharply economically. These are fantasies. When we speak of mortgage stress in this country, we speak of the direct consequence for people of the fantasy of the certainty of cyclic existence. Precisely because cyclic existence is completely uncertain, and not only financially, but just in terms of our lives, our lives may just stop like this.
Crossing the street one moment of inattention is enough for that life to cease. Precisely for that reason, projecting oneself in the future for this life is a very silly business indeed. The second characteristic of cyclic existence is insatiability. This is perhaps most evident in developed capitalist societies. Appetites are impossible to satisfy.
Contentment is unknown. However much we have, we need more. Now this is not just a feature of capitalist societies fueled by debt, a means of leading us to satisfy desires we cannot afford. It is a feature of our lot throughout the cycle of lives. Nothing has ever been good enough.
Health has never been good enough. Food has never been good enough. Relationships have never been good enough. Teachers have never been good enough. This constant insatiability is a source of tremendous suffering because these expectations are impossible to satisfy.
They are fantasized expectations. Then the two following of the six sufferings are the sufferings of repeated death and repeated birth. If we reflect on the fact that life after life we are being reborn, Life after life, we die. We can see the horrific piling up of suffering this would lead to. These are not the experiences we are facing or many of us are facing of impending death or death in a couple of years is not something exceptional, not to be thought about too much.
It is something we have faced millions of times in the past without ever finding a solution to it. It is something we will face millions of times in the future, unless we try to address the issue now. The fifth suffering is one you can see especially in the last two three years in almost all developed societies, falling repeatedly from high to low status. This happens from life to life, when human beings are reborn as animals, or even lower in the evolutionary chain. It also happens within this life, when someone who has taken on too much debt, someone whose appetites have been uncontrolled, crashes socially.
We know many such cases of people who had a house and who have ended up living in buses, of people who had a car and whose car has been repossessed, of people who sent their children to public schools and then, to their embarrassment, have to send their children excuse me, to private schools, and then have to send them to pub to public schools. We see this around us. We tend to hide from it. But this is a reality of human existence and a reality of existence in general. And then, the sixth suffering is perhaps the most tragic of all.
It is solitude. We are completely alone. We desperately try to create the illusion of company, and much of a human life and actually much of the life of other beings, animals and non animal beings, is dedicated to creating this fantasy of company. I would put it to you that perhaps much drug usage and alcohol usage as disinhibitors is designed to facilitate social contact. To make us forget what?
The fact that at the beginning of our life and at the end, we will be completely alone. We are born in solitude. We die in solitude. And for that matter, those of you who have experienced personal tragedies in your life know that when the going gets tough, you will be alone. All the friends you think you have will leave you.
Those of you who are young may not believe this, but this is something one learns through life experience. Friends will leave you, family will leave you. You are left alone. Friends you have when you are young, handsome, and rich, as I was. I had many friends.
Then when I started hiding the fact that I was rich, friendship dropped quite sharply. And when I became older, it dropped even more. This is the nature of things. And this disillusionment with human relations is the beginning of wisdom for us. When we realize that we are completely alone, much of the effort we make in this life is absurd.
We go out every Friday and Saturday night to meet people. We get drunk. We often commit a tremendous amount of non virtuous karma in the process. For what? Then we try to find the right partner, the right husband, the right wife, mister right, who will enable us to move up in the social ladder, give us a lifestyle we want, be presentable, be fun, enable us to have the right children.
For what? We have a 50 divorce rate. I think it is seventy five percent for second marriages, in that range, in all developed countries. Children are massively a disappointment. Children do not take care of their parents.
One sacrifices oneself for children to basically be abandoned by them when one is elderly. All this for what? The fantasy of self perpetuation. The fantasy of companionship. So these are the six sufferings which have traveled with us throughout cyclic existence.
And finally, we will present the most abstract presentation of suffering, the threefold presentation of suffering. And I’m succumbing to the well known Geluk advice of emphasizing suffering. There were some friends of mine, who was in Spain, and they came over to visit Khensur Rinpoche. And we were chatting before one of Rinpoche’s teachings. And one of them said to me, he would never say this to Westerners, but he said to me in Tibet, he said, you know, it’s a real problem in Spain.
They say we’re obsessed with suffering. That’s what we talk about. They say we’re morbid. The truth of the matter is it’s up to you to see whether this is the case or not. It’s up to you to analyze.
But analyzing must be done not in the light of philosophy, but by connecting Buddhist philosophy with your own life experience. And then you will see. The threefold presentation of suffering sees the sufferings of cyclic existence as divided in what is known as the suffering of suffering, which is pain. Pain or mental anguish. The suffering of change and all encompassing suffering.
The suffering of suffering or pain is particularly evident in undeveloped countries, but it is something we see in developed nations. Many here work in palliative care. You can see firsthand what the suffering of suffering is, what happens when cancer declares, what happens when someone suffers from Alzheimer’s. You can see this with your own eyes, you know. This is the lot of reincarnation in the cycle of lives.
The suffering of change is more difficult to understand. The suffering of change, the presentation of the suffering of change, rests on the Buddhist realization that everything which we call happiness is or arises through a change in the thresholds of suffering. This change in the threshold of suffering is called happiness. When the threshold of suffering increases sharply, and therefore our experienced suffering drops, we have a sensation of ease. This sensation of ease is happiness.
We were alone. We meet someone. We get in a relationship. And then our threshold of suffering increases. We are obsessed with the relationship.
We experience far fewer of the ordinary vagaries of life. We think we are happy. We think we are happy until this threshold drops back to its previous level, and this drop is experienced as great suffering when the relationship ends. This is a suffering of change. Every single happy experience can be understood in these terms.
Otherwise, if the experience we call happiness was happy in its very nature, however long it lasted, the happiness would remain the same. Yet we can experience firsthand that whatever happy experience it is, over time becomes irritating. If you are having a massage, it’s very pleasant at first. Your pain from shoulders are relieved. Until the muscle strain has been relieved, an irritation starts.
If the massage were to continue, it would turn into pain. It is the same experience, which is revealing its true nature. If its true nature was happy, it would never change. It will always be happy. And the final of the three sufferings is all encompassing suffering.
This is the Buddhist assertion that even neutral experiences, because they can lead to suffering, because they lend themselves to the arising of suffering, are of the nature of suffering. Now it is only through understanding the eightfold, sixfold, and threefold subdivisions of suffering that we can get a sense of compassion for ourselves. Looking upon our own suffering, we see, Apo, I am undergoing all this. And this has been going on for ages. Life after life after life after life, it will go on indefinitely.
My situation is miserable. I must get out of this. From this arises definite emergence. And when we extend this experience empathetically to all beings, think thinking these eight, six, and three sufferings which I am experiencing, every single one of us in this room, everyone I can see is also experiencing, then a tremendous feeling of empathy arises. And one thinks from one’s own side, it’s not appropriate for me alone to escape from this morass of suffering, which the Buddha described like a pit of fire.
I must help everyone else because there is no difference between myself and them. We are the same. We experience exactly the same thing. Therefore, an understanding of suffering is indispensable for generating definite emergence, and an understanding of suffering is indispensable for generating bodhicitta. It is especially important in the case of bodhicitta because if we do not understand the more subtle forms of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering, we will not be able to develop compassion for people who are doing well in life.
It’s very easy to have a strong feeling of empathy and compassion for a beggar or a waif who is sold into child prostitution in a third world country. It is extremely easy to have this empathetic sense. It is very difficult to have compassion for Bill Gates. Yet, the situation of Bill Gates and that of the waif in the third world country are fundamentally the same. It’s only a difference of timing.
What the waif in the third world country is living now, Bill Gates has lived and probably will live again. What Bill Gates is living now, the waif in the third world country has lived and may live again. So reflecting on the fact that the happiness of someone who is extraordinarily wealthy or powerful is actually nothing else but the suffering of change. And that the neutral feelings experienced, for instance, by the gods in the formless realms are nothing else but all pervasive suffering. We can generate compassion even for those beings.
Otherwise, any compassion we generate is going to be partial. And it’s perhaps the biggest problem, I would say, of the Western understanding of compassion. The Western understanding of compassion is a compassion for beings undergoing the suffering of suffering. It is not a compassion for all sentient beings. So it is a partial compassion because our understanding of suffering is narrow and limited.
And this is why Je Tsongkhapa says in Considering your own sufferings create the determination to be free. Thinking about other sufferings create compassion. This meditation of suffer on suffering is therefore the foundation, as we said, for both the path of the being of middling and of great scope. Now generally speaking, the first principle of the path which we saw last time, definite emergence, acts as the cause for liberation from cyclic existence. Through definite emergence, we strive for being free from our own suffering, attaining what is known as a state of peace, where the cause delusions, the delusions which are the nature of afflictions, are eliminated.
In that state, there is no suffering. There is only happiness. It is an extraordinary temptation for the practitioner to just strive for liberation, and this is the focus of the being of middling scope. However, such a state, the state of liberation, becoming an arhat, in other words, is a state in which all suffering has been eliminated, and the obstructions of the kleshas. Jñeyavarana, the obstructions to omniscience, have not been eliminated.
And therefore one cannot say that all the faults have been eliminated, nor can one say that all the qualities have been attained. It is moreover a particularly pernicious state for one wishing to engage in the Mahāyāna. Because having reached arhathood, since there is no suffering, should one wish later on to engage in the it is extremely difficult to generate compassion. It’s much more difficult for an arhat to generate compassion than for one like us. We have firsthand experience of at least the suffering of suffering and some understanding of the suffering of change.
An arhat has none of this. An arhat therefore cannot construct any empathy with other sentient beings. And it is said that it takes longer for an Arhat who enters the Mahāyāna to reach full enlightenment than for an ordinary being deluded as us to travel directly to the state of full enlightenment. Precisely because the arhat cannot generate compassion with ease. Wisdom is powerfully generated, but the method aspect of the path is weak.
Now this distinction of method and wisdom is an important one for us, and I will enter into some detail into it here, before the break. Fundamentally, When we wish to attain full enlightenment, we wish to attain the four bodies of a Buddha, which are subdivided, broadly speaking, into two. The form body, which is a body which Buddha manifests for the benefit of others, and the truth body, which is the actual realizations of the Buddha. They are known as the Rūpakāya and the Dharmakāya. These two bodies have their respective causes.
The cause of the form body is the method aspect of the path. The sum total of practices connected with the development of all of the qualities which are not wisdom. Compassion, enthusiasm, bodhicitta, ethics, all of these are the cause of the form body of the Buddha. They are the method aspect of the path. The wisdom aspect of the path is a cause of the dharmakaya.
By wisdom aspect of the path, we mean that mind or that wisdom which realizes emptiness. Both are necessary. Now, both renunciation and bodhicitta are part of the method aspect of the path. So the first two of the three principles of the path are part of the method aspect of the path. The view of emptiness is part of the wisdom aspect of the path.
Renunciation can act only as a cause for liberation. It can never act as a cause for enlightenment. It is focused on one’s own welfare. bodhicitta, however, can only act as a cause for full enlightenment. And therefore, the method aspect of a path is often compared in age or was often compared in ancient India with the father.
Because in ancient India, the male or the father defined the caste of the child and gave the child actually in many societies to this day his name. On the other hand, the wisdom aspect of the path, in other words, the wisdom realizing emptiness, is often compared with a mother, which, with different fathers, can give rise to different results, child, children of different castes or different names. So this wisdom realizing emptiness, if it’s associated with renunciation, gives rise to liberation. The self same wisdom, if it’s associated with bodhicitta, gives rise to full enlightenment. The wisdom has not changed.
The wisdom needed to become an Arhat and the wisdom needed to become a fully enlightened being are the same from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint. The only difference between Arhat, that’s what someone who has attained liberation, and a fully enlightened being is the method aspect of the path, which is renunciation for the Arhat, bodhicitta for the fully enlightened being. For this reason, Je Tsongkhapa says, you must hold the training in bodhicitta as the core instruction. Of the three principles of the path, bodhicitta is the most important because bodhicitta is the exclusive and uncommon cause of full enlightenment. Renunciation cannot be a cause for full enlightenment, and the view realizing emptiness is not the exclusive and uncommon cause of full enlightenment.
It is a cause both of liberation and of full enlightenment. To give a metaphor here, when one speaks of common and uncommon causes, it’s a little bit the same thing as when we plant a seed. Now these agricultural metaphors are very potent for the Tibetans. In our societies, they carry less weight, but we can still understand what is being said. If you were to plant a seed of wheat and expect to gain, as a result, a sheaf of wheat, You have common causes which lead to the maturation of the seed of wheat, that is water, manure, sunlight.
They are common because they will lead to the maturation of all seeds. They would also lead a seed of rice to maturation. And you have uncommon results, which is a seed of wheat itself. A seed of wheat cannot give rise to anything but a sheaf of wheat. Now the common causes are the wisdom aspect of the path.
They can give rise to liberation or full enlightenment. The uncommon or specific causes are the method aspect of the path. This is why in a Buddhist context, motivation is fundamental. The deed is secondary. This is why before this teaching we meditated or tried to meditate on bodhicitta.
This motivation basically impels what we do during this teaching to act as a cause towards for enlightenment. Therefore, the great scope, the scope of the being of great capacity, is actually in the lamrim the main body of the path. We travel from the beginning on the path of the great scope. We just train in aspects of the path of the being of small and middling capacity, are shared with the being of great scope. In the same way as, let’s say, if you were to go to Paris, you have to travel via Singapore.
But even though you’re traveling via Singapore, you’re not going to stop in Singapore for long because your goal is Paris. So someone traveling to Paris is someone who is basically traveling on the great vehicle. They train on aspects of the past shared as being of small scope, traveling to Singapore, but that’s not their main focus. They’re not going to make a particular effort to get a nice hotel in Singapore or get a long stay visa because they’re going on. So in our practice, our main focus is a generation of bodhicitta.
Renunciation in the view are subsidiary practices we train in for this. bodhicitta is the main road leading us to full enlightenment. The fact that the motivation, bodhicitta, striving to attain the state of full enlightenment for the sake of every single suffering sentient being, defines whether a practice is a practice of the great vehicle or not. It’s fundamental when we engage in advanced practices. It’s a common misunderstanding to think that because one practices tantra, because one engages in Deity Yoga, one will be attaining full enlightenment.
This is not the case at all. If the motivation of bodhicitta is absent, that tantric practice cannot be a cause for full enlightenment. If renunciation is absent, that tantric practice will not be a cause for liberation, but only for rebirth and cyclic existence. If renunciation to this life is absent, that tantric practice will certainly become a cause for rebirth in a lower realm. Because in tantra one uses delusions on the path.
This is why when Atisha came to Tibet, he was asked to exorcise a ghost, which was a ghost of a yogi who had practiced the Yamāntaka tantra, but who had not had bodhicitta, and who had, through his practice of Yamāntaka, become a ghost. Atisha had to exorcise this ghost casting tormas, because it had become an evil spirit. So the highest practice led to what? To rebirth as a preta, ghosts fallen in the family of hungry ghosts of pretas. And this is why the practice of bodhicitta is fundamental.
Whatever our practice is, before engaging in the practice, ten-fifteen minutes must be set aside to generate the motivation. At least renunciation, preferably bodhicitta. If that is not done, the practice will not bear fruit. It is a waste of time. People who practice Buddhist meditation in this life to calm the mind gain just that.
They calm the mind in this life. As for the results for future lives, nothing can be said. Probably they will have a calmer mind in future lives, but that practice will never act as a cause for liberation and will never act as a cause for enlightenment. Because that motivation was not set. The same thing as when you open a blocked fund in a bank, you define how long the money will be held in the fund.
If you go to your banker and you want to have the privilege of high interest rates, you have to block money in an account for a long period of time. You’ll get the high interest rates. If you put it in a short term account and you don’t tell the banker anything, the 5%, 6% are not going to come your way. So that initial definition of the goal, of the focus, is generating the motivation. This is why the great Kadampa Geshe of yore said that everyone has images of deities, everyone has Anutara Yoga tantra initiations, Everyone is reciting mantras.
The problem is that nobody has any Dharma to contemplate. Dharma starts with the practice of the being of small scope. Mantra in and of itself is not Dharma. Visualizations are not Dharma. Tantric sadhanas without the three principles of the path are not Dharma.
They do not benefit us. Great bodhisattvas, on the other hand, attain the siddhis through the power of their realizations. It was said in Tibet that Jetsün Milarepa, who was a very great yogi, was very afflicted by the fact that the Kichu River in Lhasa had flooded and was threatening all of the lower areas of Lhasa. He was not a tantric practitioner. He just went to the side, the border of the Kichu River and inscribed on a slate tablet, by the power of truth, if it is true that I, if it is true that I am a bodhisattva, am a bodhisattva, may the waters of the river recede, and the waters of the river recede, the power of his bodhicitta gave him siddhi.
And this is why when Dromtonpa, who was Atisha’s foremost lay disciple, was told of the practice of one of the very great Kadampa Geshe’s, Geshe Kamapa. He praised him highly. They did not say that Geshe Kamapa was in solitary retreat practicing a yidam. They didn’t say he was practicing vipassana or Satipatthana. They didn’t say he was living in a monastery.
Dromtonpa was told, He lives at the head of a ravine. Sometimes his eyes are half closed, sometimes he cries. That’s all he ever does. Dromtonpa said, he is really putting Dharma into practice. In other words, Geshe Kamapa’s sole practice was bodhicitta.
And this is what my teacher, the late Geshe Rabten, who was the foremost scholar in Pramāna in the Tibetan tradition. First, the examiner, and then the counselor of His Holiness the Dalai Lama said. He said, after many years of practice, I have realized the only thing of worth is bodhicitta. So on these words, I think we will take a short tea break. So we will now enter into the gist of the topic, and I would first like to say that from my side, all I can do is really convey what I have heard from my teachers.
I personally only know the words. I have had no access to these experiences. Then here we have in the person of Khensur Rinpoche, without the shadow of a doubt, a great bodhisattva. So, to receive teachings on bodhicitta from a Bodhisattva is to have the opportunity to generate some sort of feeling of what bodhicitta might be. We do not have access to bodhicitta, but by the inspiration of a great Bodhisattva we can get that sense.
That’s why for these teachings I edited carefully and we reprinted the section on bodhicitta in Khensur Rinpoche’s Three Principles of the Path. I would heartily suggest to all of you to get it and to read it carefully. Rinpoche teaches from experience. I merely convey words. This is a very different thing.
The only advantage I have is I speak your language, I speak English. So then I will try to present the topic in as structured a fashion as possible, but I would very much encourage you to revert to Khensur Rinpoche’s commentary, especially as a foundation for your meditation. So, to start with, in strong Tibetan tradition, I know westerners don’t do this, I would like to quote a beautiful passage of Chandra Gomin, who was a great lay bodhisattva, who said, the ground supports the world without calculating its burden.’ This is, in a nutshell, the essence of how a bodhisattva practices. A bodhisattva works for the welfare of others without ever calculating how much it might cost him or her. It is a limitless process of giving and help for the benefit of others.
And then if we enter into a more detailed attempt to understand what bodhicitta is, we have to rely on the five treatises of Maitreya, specifically on Maitreya’s ornament of realization, the Abhisamayālamkāra, in which Maitreya says, The generation of the mind is for the sake of others to strive for authentic and complete enlightenment. This is a definition of bodhicitta which is imparted to Asaṇga by Maitreya. On the basis of this definition, one can clearly see that in as much as bodhicitta is a striving, it is necessarily a mental factor from within the twofold division of minds and mental factors, and not a primary mind. Maitreya, in turn, later on in the Abhisamayālamkāra, subdivides bodhicitta using a series of metaphors, and this is the handout on the 22 bodhicittas according to Maitreya, which I will not comment. I will just read you the root quote because it is of such poetic weight.
Moreover, there are two twenty two aspects of bodhicitta. In other words, bodhicitta there are 22 similes of bodhicitta. Earth, gold, moon and fire, a treasure and a mine, an ocean, a vajra, a mountain, medicine, a spiritual friend, a wish-fulfilling gem, the sun and a melody, a king, a treasure trove and an elephant, a youth spring water and a lute, a river and a cloud. Each of these similes illustrates one of the features of bodhicitta. For instance, bodhicitta, this is a commentary of the composer of the monastic textbooks of Serage Monastery, where I I was a monk.
bodhicitta is taught to be akin to the earth because it is the basis of all beings. So we just comment this one example, and I would let you read by yourselves all 22 examples and try to delve into the meaning. When it is said that bodhicitta is the basis of all beings, what is being said? What is being said is that the basis for hope for all beings is a presence of bodhicitta in the mind of the Bodhisattvas and in the mind of the Buddhas. Otherwise, there is no basis, no earth, no basis for hope for beings.
Beings are just lost in the darkness. It is because great beings have generated bodhicitta in the mind that there is a foundation beneath beings. Each of these similes should be brought in our meditation. When we meditate on bodhicitta, it is extraordinarily helpful to meditate first on the root verse of Maitreya. bodhicitta is generating for the sake of others, simply the wish to attain full enlightenment.
And then to meditate on all 22 similes, one by one. Thinking, bodhicitta is like the earth. bodhicitta is like gold. Why? bodhicitta is like fire.
Why? bodhicitta is stable like a mountain. Why? Each of these similes enables us to inject poetry into our meditation, and therefore to bring the emotions to at play in our meditation in a constructive way. Then the divisions of bodhicitta.
bodhicitta arises at the instant one enters in the first of the five paths of a bodhisattva, the path of accumulation. Before the path of accumulation of a bodhisattva, there is no bodhicitta. bodhicitta in turn is subdivided into four. The bodhicitta of the two first paths, or the path of accumulation and preparation, where the Bodhisattva actually operates mainly through the power of faith. Because on the two first paths, the path of accumulation and preparation, the Bodhisattva has not had a direct experience of emptiness, of reality.
From the path of seeing onwards, the Bodhisattva has a direct experience of emptiness. And therefore, the second subdivision of bodhicitta is bodhicitta on the impure grounds, the first to seventh ground, which are the path of seeing and the second to seventh ground which are part of the path of meditation. This is bodhicitta purified by insight, because for the first time at this level bodhicitta coexists with the realization of emptiness within one continuum. They are not simultaneous, and they will not be until full enlightenment. But from the path of seeing onwards, the Bodhisattva has realized emptiness, and that realization suffuses his experience.
When he realizes, when he generates bodhicitta after realizing emptiness, that bodhicitta is purified by insight into emptiness. Then the third subdivision is completely matured bodhicitta on the three last grounds. These are the three last grounds of the path of meditation, the eighth, ninth and tenth ground. During these three last grounds from the Prāsaṇgika standpoint, klesha varana, the afflictions, are completely eliminated. While the practitioner of the Hīnayāna, eliminates completely the afflictions upon becoming an Arhat.
The bodhisattva from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika eliminates completely the afflictions at the end of the seventh ground. All that remains during the eighth, ninth and tenth ground are the obscurations to omniscience. And the fourth subdivision of bodhicitta is the bodhicitta which has abandoned all obstructions, on the Buddha ground. In other words, bodhicitta within the mind of a fully enlightened being. Now it is a position of the bodhicitta monastery, there are debates about this, it’s a position of Seraje monastery that Buddhas have bodhicitta.
Kedrup Je, for instance, in a very challenging text asserts that Buddhas do not have bodhicitta because they will be striving for what they have already. But then that would mean the Buddha is not a Mahāyāna practitioner, which is very awkward. So this is just the sort of topics we debate, or the monks of Sera Je debate. Now, regarding the mode of generation of bodhicitta, there are three different types of bodhicitta. We have king like bodhicitta, shepherd like bodhicitta and ferryman like bodhicitta.
These are different in terms, not so much of the bodhicitta itself which is attained as of the motivation of the bodhisattva. Of these three, it is said that the only which can be actually generated is king like bodhicitta. King like bodhicitta is a bodhicitta which, like a king, wishes to become fully enlightened first, and then, after becoming oneself a Buddha, to lead all sentient beings without exception to that state. Now it is taught in all of the commentaries on bodhicitta that this is actually the only realistic form of bodhicitta, because it is only when we ourselves are fully enlightened that we can benefit others to the maximum. Until that point, our capacity to benefit others is very limited.
That does not mean we should not try, but in terms of capacity, our capacity is very limited. The second bodhicitta is a shepherd like bodhicitta. Many accounts of the shepherd like bodhicitta occur in sūtra, and in Chinese Buddhism it is emphasized. This is motivation of a bodhisattva who, like a shepherd with a flock of sheep, pushes his flock in front of him and comes last. Such a bodhisattva takes the vow to attain full enlightenment after all sentient beings, and to stay in the cyclic existence until all sentient beings have attained enlightenment, and only then himself to attain full enlightenment.
This is considered to be unrealistic in the Gelug tradition since such a bodhisattva does not have the capacity to perform what he wants to do. But the vow itself is said to be the vow Avalokiteśvara took and is extraordinarily powerful since it is the ultimate form of cherishing others. The third form of bodhicitta is ferryman like bodhicitta, where like a ferryman, the bodhisattva travels together with all beings to full enlightenment. There are in addition two other subdivisions of bodhicitta. In terms of coarseness and subtleness, we have conventional and ultimate bodhicitta.
Conventional bodhicitta is that bodhicitta which is a wish to attain for enlightenment for the sake of all beings. Ultimate bodhicitta is that bodhicitta arising within the mind of an ārya being who has realized emptiness. Ultimate bodhicitta is only present from the path of seeing upwards. Finally, in terms of nature, we have the twofold distinction many of you know between aspiring and engaging bodhicitta. Aspiring bodhicitta is that wish to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings.
That wish is what one tries to generate through the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta. Engaging bodhicitta is actually traveling on the path of the Bodhisattva. It is that bodhicitta which engages in the practice or in training in the six perfections. So first engaging bodhicitta must be created, then first aspiring bodhicitta must be created, then engaging bodhicitta can be created. It’s exactly the same thing as wishing to go to Paris and going to Paris.
Engage aspiring bodhicitta is wishing to go to Paris. Engaging bodhicitta is purchasing the ticket and starting the travel. Then I will perhaps cover only very briefly the advantages of developing bodhicitta, relying actually on Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s presentation more than on Pabongka Rinpoche. There are five main advantages and one meditates on these advantages to enhance one’s motivation to generate bodhicitta. The first is that bodhicitta is the gateway to the Mahāyāna.
In other words, without bodhicitta there is no Mahāyāna. No practice is a practice of the great vehicle, whatever its name and however high it might be, if that motivation is absent. tantra is not a Mahāyāna practice without bodhicitta. As we said earlier, without refuge it is not a Buddhist practice. Moreover, having generated bodhicitta, uninterrupted merit is accrued in dependence on it.
This is one of the extraordinary features of bodhicitta. Once bodhicitta has been generated in the mind of the Bodhisattva, whatever the Bodhisattva does in daily life, walking, drinking, eating, sleeping, because it is done with this motivation, is transformed as by a magical elixir into the cause for only full enlightenment. The life of the bodhisattva becomes a cause for full enlightenment. The third feature is that it is the foremost means of purification. It purifies all of the thoughts we have accumulated as perhaps no other antidote can, Because having generated the wish to benefit all beings and to attain the state of perfection for them, any thoughts we committed towards them pale in comparison with such a motivation.
They are just eliminated by it. The fourth is fairly tried, one accumulates fresh causes for rebirth in the higher realms, this is not the motivation at all at this level. However, what is pointed out is that the previously accumulated merits increase and this is one feature of bodhicitta, that it infuses all of the past karma we have accumulated, the past virtuous karma, and turns it into much more powerful motors for full enlightenment. Then what I would like to focus upon today is the actual procedure for developing bodhicitta. But before doing this, we will read the stanza in the translation of the three principles of the path.
I have only translated today the section on bodhicitta which you can, as you can see, is quite short. And I think the reason Je Tsongkhapa gives in stanza 5.1 has to be the foremost one for generating bodhicitta. However, should that definite emergence not be held by the perfect mind of bodhicitta, inasmuch as it will not become the cause of the perfect bliss of enlightenment, the intelligent generate the supreme mind of enlightenment. So this should be fairly self evident in the light of the explanation during the previous hour. Renunciation or definite emergence alone, which is not subsumed under bodhicitta, cannot act as a cause for enlightenment.
Therefore, the intelligent, the wise, those who strive for the ultimate goal for themselves and for others generate bodhicitta since this is the cause for full enlightenment. How do we generate this bodhicitta? And perhaps you should now turn to the large handout. I apologize for the size, there’s no way to do this in anything short smaller than this. The methods for generating bodhicitta.
Basically, there are two main methods in a series of synthesis. The two main methods are given to the left and in the center: the sevenfold cause and effect instruction and the fivefold equalizing of self and others. Then to the right you have the synthesis which is the main one used in meditation in the Gelug tradition, Pabongka Rinpoche’s 11-point synthesis of these two methods. There are synthesis due to the fifth Dalai Lama of thirteen and fifteen subdivisions each, but Pabongka Rinpoche’s one comprises these. If we were to look at this chart time wise, we would be standing here.
In other words, we are ordinary beings who have not even started to trade in the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta, or the interchange of self and others. Traveling through these paths, we will reach a point where we generate bodhicitta and at that point, when aspiring bodhicitta is generated, we will have become a bodhisattva on the path of accumulation. It’s at that point that we start traveling the bodhisattva path. Until then, we are not even close. Now, two lineages were transmitted separately in India.
The sevenfold cause and effect lineage is a lineage which comes from Buddha Śākyamūni and was transmitted to Maitreya, from Maitreya to Asaṇga, to the great lay bodhisattva Chandra Gomin, to Candrakīrti, and then to the Indian guru who lived in Sumatra, Suvarnadvipi, and from him to Atisha. It is from Atisha that the sevenfold cause and effect lineage was transmitted to Tibet, to the Kadampa Geshe and eventually reached Jetsongkhapa. The second lineage, the interchange of self and others, which actually in Tibetan is the fivefold equalizing and interchanging of self and others, I just summarized it, interchange of self and others, is the lineage which comes from the Buddha to Nāgārjuna, and is indicated or taught in Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali, in his precious garland. And from Nāgārjuna was transmitted down to Śāntideva and then also to Suvarnadvipi, the Indian guru of Sumatra, who is a juncture, who transmitted this lineage as well to Atisha. Atisha transmitted it separately in Tibet.
The first lineage, the seven fold cause and effect lineage, is an exoteric lineage, a public transmission. The second lineage, interchange of self and others, was a secret transmission, an esoteric transmission, because it was considered too difficult for ordinary practitioners to engage in. Teaching it publicly might lead people to stand back in dismay, as it were, and perhaps even leave the practice of the Mahāyāna. The sevenfold cause and effect lineage was transmitted through the great Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Chekawa. Geshe Chekawa also received the fivefold lineage of the interchange of self and others secretly.
And it is to Geshe Chekawa that we owe the public transmission of this lineage, because Geshe Chekawa felt this lineage would be actually of benefit to the students, and he started teaching it publicly for the first time in the twelfth century. So this lineage was transmitted, in other words, for 17 secretly. From Geshe Chekhawa, these two lineages were transmitted separately down to Je Tsongkhapa. Je Tsongkhapa for the first time in Lamrim Chenmo taught them together and taught that the interchange of self and others must be practiced on top of the sevenfold cause and effect lineage. But Je Tsongkhapa does not explicitly in Lamrim Chenmo how this is to be done.
This is very much part of the oral transmission, which passed on from Je Tsongkhapa to the fifth Dalai Lama, where he actually explicitly states it in an untranslated text which Lamrim teachings given in India, Chris was there, from the mouth of Mañjuśrī. And then a synthesis was made by Pabongka Rinpoche in Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand in an 11-point procedure. So what we will do is we will cover together the seven fold cause instruction first, then the fivefold equalizing of self and others, and then cover briefly Pabongka Rinpoche’s presentation which will be self evident. You will see the great advantages there is in fusing these two. So if we take the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, initially, until Kamalaśīla’s Bhāvanākrama, the stages of meditation, equanimity was not taught as a prelude to the sevenfold cause and effect instruction.
It must have been practiced, it was simply not taught explicitly. If one engages in an attempt to train a bodhicitta without equanimity, then one incurs a very real danger of having biased love and biased compassion towards beings. It would be much easier to have empathy and compassion for someone one likes and having love for someone one likes and for someone one doesn’t like. So for this reason, Kamalaśīla taught that before training in the sevenfold cause and effect procedure, one had to train in equanimity. In other words, the equanimity which is talked of here is equalizing our perception of others, seeing everyone as equal, as the same, which is exactly what we do not do at present.
Our present condition is one where we are tremendously attached to family and friends. There is a large proportion of the population and of living beings who are completely indifferent to us. We pay lip service to their value as living beings. There’s a small minority of persons whom we loathe. Now on this basis, it is not possible to generate impartial love or impartial compassion, let alone bodhicitta.
Therefore, first, have to equalize our perception of all beings. And there are two ways to do this. Je Tsongkhapa in Lamrim Chenmo teaches the traditional procedure, which is to start with the easiest, with a neutral being. But he referred over and again to the neutral Australian, probably someone from Alice Springs. But he has never met, has no particular feelings for, or Queensland if you prefer.
Then we start by seeing that there’s no particular reason to either actively like or actively dislike this person. It is self evident. And then after this In Je Tsongkhapa’s procedure, we take a friend. We reflect on the fact that this friend in this life is someone who in past lives has certainly harmed us. We can take it for granted.
Past lives are infinite in number. This very friend in this life must have been an enemy in a past life, not one time but many times. And for that matter, in this very life, friends and enemies switch constantly. Those of you who have been married and who are divorced can have a very clear experiential understanding of this one. You go from indifference to infatuation to, at best indifference, more often hatred or loathing.
Now, the person on the other end is the same. The person has not changed in the slightest. It’s our mind which has changed. When the person was of no benefit to us, there were neutral feelings. When the person enabled us to satisfy our lust, there was attachment.
When the person ceased to satisfy our lust and became someone who was contrary to our projects, maybe to our financial well-being even, there was loathing. Finally, when the divorce is over, ten, fifteen, twenty years later, there is indifference. Indifference. With respect to one person, this is a cycle of emotions. Reflecting in this way, we can see that this is only from our side, it’s not from the side of the person.
There’s no justification for this. The only justification is the self benefit we have accrued from the person. When they help us, I like them. When they harm me, I hate them. When they neither help me nor harm me, I couldn’t care less.
This is our present state. Then there’s no justification at all for this state of mind. I mean, a childish state of mind, it’s infantile. The second means of training in equanimity is the one taught by the fifth Dalai Lama from the mouth of Mañjuśrī, which is expounded in Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, which is much more powerful. It’s part of the oral tradition, where one actually visualizes in space in front of oneself three persons.
Someone one loves dearly, let’s say one’s mother in this life. Someone one hates, let’s say the business partner who caused your bankruptcy. And someone towards whom one is completely neutral. One has just never met perhaps a Russian engineer. And then one analyzes them simultaneously.
One takes a person to whom one feels extraordinarily close and one thinks, My mother in this life, yes, she was kind to me. But in past lives, this mother I can see here harmed me savagely. There’s no particular reason for me to be attached to her as I am. Keeping this in mind, one looks at the business partner who bankrupted us, and one thinks, This business partner who bankrupted me caused the bankruptcy of my business, but in past lives, he was my best friend or my wife. It’s just a minor fault compared to past kindness.
Why should I resent it to this degree? And finally, keeping both of them in mind, one looks at the last Russian engineer, poor Russian engineer, and one thinks, he has neither harmed me nor helped me. There’s no particular reason to have any emotion towards you. Then looking at these three beings together visualized in space, one thinks, there is no difference between them. They are the same.
The only difference is my experience, my egotistical experience of being hurt or harmed by them. And then one extends this to all beings. And thinks all beings are exactly the same. This is how one trains in equanimity. Now, the training in equanimity within the context of the sevenfold cause and effect instruction and the training in equanimity within the context of the interchange of self and others are different.
So I will, in this context, open a brief parenthesis. Within the context of what we are studying now, the seven foot cause and effect instruction, we train in equanimity through reflecting on the fact that all beings ultimately are the same, since if we look at the sum total of harm and help over the sum total of lives, it is identical for all beings. The balance ledger is the same. In the context of the interchange of self and others, we have a different means of training in equanimity. We train in equanimity through thinking, all beings are identical to me in that both I and them are the same in wanting not to suffer at all and in wanting a maximum of happiness.
Looking at it in that way, I cannot postulate a difference between me and others. These are two different ways of training in equanimity which are complementary. So after this, returning to the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, one trains in recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mother. This is said to be the most difficult point. The reasonings to be held are as follows: from a Buddhist standpoint there are four types of births: birth from an egg, from a womb, from moisture and miraculous.
So this would correspond to non mammalian birth, mammalian births, then births from moisture would probably be mitosis, meiosis and sporulation. And miraculous birth is not acknowledged by science, it would be birth by emanation. Of these four births, in two births from an egg, in other words, ooviparous births, and mammalian births we have mothers. Then in this life we know we have a mother. In past lives, if we had mammalian or oviparous births, we had mothers.
We have an infinite number of past lives, it is beginningless. Therefore, we must have an infinite number of such births and an infinite number of mothers. On the other hand, cyclic existence itself is not infinite. There is an end to cyclic existence. There’s a point where all sentient beings will have been enlightened.
Therefore, although the number of sentient beings is extraordinarily high and perhaps uncountable, it is not infinite in the sense that the number of past lives is infinite. Therefore, there are more such past lives than there are sentient beings, and in the large majority of those past lives I have mothers. It seems fairly self evident that every sentient being has been my mother, and maybe not just once, but many times over. If this is the case, it is not possible for me to give a single sentient being of whom I can say with certainty he or she has never been my mother. And this is the most difficult point to understand.
One has to analyze, think, meditate, until one gets a strong sense that oneself has had an infinite number of past lives, and one has had an infinite number of mothers which are different sentient beings. These reasonings do not hold if we don’t believe in past and future lives. So those who do not subscribe to past and future lives must generate that certainty empirically using Stevenson’s research or relying on Dharmakīrti’s reasonings in Pramāna Vartikam that the substantial cause of the mind, which is a phenomenon which is of the nature of clarity and knowledge, can only be a phenomenon which is of the same substantial type. No material phenomenon can be of that substantial type. Therefore, the cause of the first moment of mind after delivery is necessary the cause, is necessary necessarily the last moment of mind before delivery.
There can be no other cause which is the substantial cause of that. And the substantial cause of that is necessarily the first moment of mind when mind enters in the egg at conception. Now in as much as this necessarily has a cause which is of the same substantial type as it, its substantial cause can only be the last moment of the mind of the Bardo being just before taking that rebirth. And in this way, using Dharmakīrti’s reasonings, one can move backwards to establish that mind is infinite in the past. Therefore, the number of past lives is infinite in the past.
Likewise, self evidently, is infinite in the future. If these reasonings do not operate for you, then relying on Stevenson’s research, I think, a very powerful means to do so. His research on reincarnation and biology, cases of the reincarnation type, which we covered here many times. At this point, one then recollects the kindness of mother sentient beings. We’ve established all beings have been our mother in a past life.
Then we start with our mother in this life, and we think, what my mother has done for me? I have this precious human rebirth because of my parents, otherwise I wouldn’t have it. Thanks to my mother I have it. Then she bore me within her. She endured tremendous discomfort all the way to a pregnancy which leads to a delivery, which in much of the world does not occur without anesthetic.
I was in great pain. And then when I was born, instead of seeing me as repulsive, covered with placenta and blood, she saw me as the most cherished being she could have. She took me and warmed me with her own flesh. She fed me with her own substance, with her own milk. Everything we have in this life, we owe to our Mother.
In the West, we are extraordinarily hard hearted and egotistical in this respect. Our mother, to start with, fed us with her own substance. She cleaned our feces and our urine. Much of the world does not have things like Pampers. It is done by hand.
The washing is done by hand. Our mothers did this for us. Then, we learned to speak looking at our mother’s face. It is through looking at our mother’s lips that we learned language. No one but our mother taught us language.
We learned to walk at the instigation of our mother. We learned to dress ourselves. We learned to go to the toilet. We were taken to school because our mother insisted that we go to school, often against the advice of other members of the family, who saw us as much more useful, especially in third world countries, working in the fields. It is our mothers throughout our life who has stood up for us at the cost of her own welfare.
Our mothers have done everything for us. You see in poor countries, many single mothers prostitute themselves for their child. It’s the only way to make money. They do not even think of what they’re going to be undergoing. All this for their child, you know.
You see in the animal realm, there are animals which sacrifice their life for their cubs, for their kittens. There was a case I read a couple months ago of a cat which chased a bear away from its kittens. This is what the love of a mother can do. This cat was so terrifying in her maternal love, she caused a brown bear to flee. Now the kindness of beings taunts us back in time is of that nature.
Life after life after life after life. As human beings, as animals, where a she wolf will sacrifice herself for her cubs, as insects, you know. The kindness of mother sentient beings is something we cannot begin to imagine. We have to recollect this. And then the fifth Dalai Lama says, we must recollect this until we start shuddering.
Hair stand on our body and tears arise in our eyes. This is the measure of the success in this meditation. Until then it has not had an impact, it’s just an intellectual trip. When that happens, we pass to the next step. And we think, I must repay their kindness.
What sort of a person would accept to receive all this? And then, when his mother in this life and his mothers from past lives are benighted by ignorance, are wandering, lost, without knowing the difference between what to do and what to abstain from. What sort of person would take care of his and only his interest? An extraordinarily base person. Someone who doesn’t have the milk of human kindness.
And at this point, this strong sense, I must repay their kindness, has to arise within our mind. It is at this point that we give rise to love. Love, which is point four in the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, is the wish to place all these beings in a state of happiness, which has the causes of happiness. Now, in the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, love is generated first as a prelude to great compassion. Whereas, for instance, in the seven, the equalizing of self and others, and especially reading of it, love is actually generated after.
There’s a bit of a debate about this, and the fifth Dalai Lama points out that there is no particular reason karmically for which love has to be generated before or after great compassion. As a matter of fact, love is explicitly taught in the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, whereas it is not taught in the interchange of self and others or Pabongka Rinpoche’s presentation, not because it is absent in the latter presentations, but simply because Je Tsongkhapa, who gave the transmission of the sevenfold cause and effect transmission, wanted to emphasize the importance of generating love. Love arises in the other transmissions as a byproduct, as we will see a bit later on. And then, having generated love, we generate great compassion, which is actually the seed of bodhicitta. Maitreya says in Mahayānasūtrālamkara, it says, I assert that its seed is great compassion.
It here is bodhicitta. So once great compassion is generated, which is that mind which cannot stand the suffering of infinite mother sentient beings, at that point the generation of bodhicitta becomes unavoidable. Until then, it is not certain that bodhicitta will be generated. From the point onwards where great compassion is generated, we can say the momentum has arisen. And then in generation, in dependence on great compassion, thinks of the infinite suffering of sentient beings, and it is suggested at this point to take a being such as a sheep, for instance, or in Australia, cattle being led to the stockyards on the point of being slaughtered.
And if you can see films of this, this is very helpful for the mind to watch these movies. And you can see the fear in the animal which is approaching its death. You can imagine the horrific suffering and use this as a motor to meditate on the suffering of all beings. In our developed societies, we do not realize that our daily life is assured by the death of other beings. We buy meat in plastic packages, we buy milk in containers, we do not realize that cows are kept prisoner and milk is stolen from their calves for our sake.
We do not realize that animals are slaughtered, often in horrific conditions for our sake. Or in the case of the eggs which we eat, we do not even think of the suffering of chickens, which are basically kept cramped in tiny cages and just are there their short miserable life of atrophy to produce and produce and produce eggs. So we should take many examples here from the animal realm, from human beings who suffer, suffer from cancer, from AIDS, or have mental suffering from depression. And then meditate on their suffering and generate a sense that this is insupportable, because we are intimately connected to them. They have been our mothers in past lives.
Not only our mothers, our fathers, our friends, our brothers, our sisters. The relationships are extraordinarily close. And at this point, we give rise to the sixth state of mind, the wholehearted resolve, which is a resolution, which says, I I will lead them out of this state. I do not know how, but I will do this. And then we examine our own condition to see, Can I do this?
And we can see clearly that all we can do for others at present is short term, it’s contingent. We can help financially the poor, we can become members of Oxfam or Medecins Sans Frontieres, but we’re just treating the surface causes, we’re not addressing the root causes. The misery in the world is infinite. Our help is a drop in the ocean of misery. What do we do to eradicate the root causes?
How do we, having taken this responsibility, fulfill our pledge? And if we examine carefully, and this is where I think the oral instruction of the fifth Dalai Lama is very powerful. He says, at this point, reflecting on the qualities of the body, speech, mind of the object of refuge meditated upon in the context of refuge. So at this point, meditating on the qualities of refuge, we should generate the resolve, I myself will become an ultimate refuge. I will become a fully enlightened being.
This is bodhicitta. When this is generated, have generated aspiring bodhicitta. Then we engage in training and engaging bodhicitta. So this is the sevenfold cause and effect instruction and I must apologize we’re going to go over time, so I hope it is okay with most of you. I will try to compress things so there’s a little bit of time for questions.
Then the instructions on the equalizing and interchanging of self and others, as we said are rooted in Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvali. And they start with a process of equalizing self and others, which is the equanimity of the interchange of self and others we talked about, where one reflects on the fact that ourselves and all sentient beings are exactly the same, in all wishing to be happy and all not wishing to be miserable. There is no difference. And then, once we have equalized ourselves with others in this way, we engage in a twin meditation. And it is because this is difficult to understand that this instruction was kept secret.
The first is that we reflect on the thoughts of egotism, of what is called self-cherishing. And the second is that we reflect on the qualities of other cherishing, in other words altruism. Now to understand clearly the faults of egotism and the qualities of altruism is difficult. We live in a society and in a world in which taking care of number one is good. Number one is ourselves.
Taking care and being worried about others is a sign of weakness. In such a society to practice interchange of self and others is very difficult. Perhaps more difficult than in the past. So we have to reflect very carefully. If we believe in past and future lives, we can see that self-cherishing is a byproduct of the mind which apprehends a true existence of the self, and that the two operate in tandem.
self-cherishing is rooted in the innate mind which apprehends the true existence of the self, And as a mind which values ourselves over and above others, thinking, I will take care of myself, I will protect myself, it says I. Others will take care of themselves. I won’t harm them, but, know, man has to do what a man has to do. That’s what you hear all the time. Now, on the basis of this mind in past lives, we have accumulated a huge amount of non virtue.
All the non virtuous deeds we check, the 10 non virtuous deeds of body, speech and mind, killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, harsh words, divisive speech, idle talk, covetousness, ill will, wrong views, all have been accumulated through egotism, through self-cherishing. On the other hand, through sincere other cherishing, a mind which is totally dedicated to others, through profound altruism, no non virtue is accumulated ever. Only virtue is accumulated. It is through practicing other cherishing altruism that the Buddhas became enlightened, that Mahabodhisattvas like Mahatma Gandhi became such a force for the good. We do not know whether Mahatma Gandhi was a bodhisattva or not.
We have no access to his mind. But we can say he was practicing other cherishing. We can say he fought against self-cherishing. Every single great human being in history fought against self-cherishing and practiced other cherishing. However far back we go down in time, in the non-Buddhist traditions, in Christianity, the Rabbi Yeshua HaNatzri, Jesus Christ, taught foremost other cherishing.
It is present in Jewish, in the Muslim, in the Christian, in the Hindu, in the Buddhist traditions, all of the religious traditions. But we can see in addition, if we look even at this life, and this is where it is quite shocking that the studies have revealed this recently, that the greater the egotism, this was established by cognitive scientists, the greater the suffering of the person. The greater the altruism, the more people are involved in charity work, the more their mind is focused on a large number of others to help, the happier they are, even within this very life of ours. And we probably know many cases around us of people who do not spend a lot of time worrying about themselves, don’t seem to have a lot, and yet are extraordinarily happy. And I certainly in my life knew extraordinarily wealthy people.
My family was very close friends with the family of a Swiss private banker. They were partners in the Swiss private bank. They were worth nine figures. Some of the most unhappy people I ever knew. Miserable.
Miserable. And yet money fell from the sky, you know, from the sky. So reflecting on this, we can begin to understand the faults of self-cherishing and the advantages of cherishing others. And then in the context of Śāntideva’s teaching, of the interchange of self and others, the way we train is we practice Tonglen, we practice giving and taking. We practice giving and taking, and this is the core instruction which is which was secret because it is a very difficult instruction.
By visualizing, in Śāntideva’s tradition, all sentient beings in front of us. But the fifth Dalai Lama suggests to start with one’s mother because it’s easier. And then one visualizes that from one’s own right nostril, all of one’s qualities, one’s good karma and one’s happiness leaves one’s body and is given to one’s mother. It enters her body and her mind through her left nostril and suffuses her. We give up everything good within us completely to her, or if we can from the beginning to all sentient beings.
And then, when we inhale, we imagine that from our mother’s body visualized in front of us in space, all of her non virtues, all of her unhappiness, all of her misery, which has been accumulated over infinite lives, comes into us through our left nostril. We take it within our own mind, within our heart, and it piles up like a black heap at our heart. In this constant flow, we visualize we are giving light, energy and beauty to our mother, and we are taking upon ourselves darkness, suffering and filth. This we conjoin with breathing. Breathing in and out.
When we breathe out, we give our happiness, when we breathe in, we take suffering. And then, having trained with our mother, the fifth Dalai Lama says, we extend this to our parents and our relatives, because it’s easier at the beginning. And then from this, we extend this to our friends, then to neutral persons, then to our enemies, then to all beings. Now, this practice was an esoteric practice because it’s very difficult for an only person to give away what they think is theirs. Strictly speaking, is not possible to give one’s virtuous karma to another person.
One’s virtuous karma is part of one’s own mind stream. One’s happiness is part of one’s own mind stream. The own virtuous karma of another person is part of their mind stream. Their unhappiness is part of their mind stream. But this visualization is extraordinarily powerful in destroying self-cherishing at our heart.
There’s no more powerful visualization than this to become convinced of the existence of past and future lives, convinced that karma operates, and then give everything good one has to another, and take all the suffering upon oneself. And then on this basis, Pabongka Rinpoche fused these two sets of instructions, and this is Pabongka Rinpoche’s 11-point procedure. The lineage of which goes back to the fifth Dalai Lama, and from the fifth Dalai Lama downwards to Dagpo Rinpoche, Pabongka Rinpoche’s teacher, Pabongka Rinpoche himself, and our glorious teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, who fleshed out in his teachings, and I would really suggest that you read them, because it is the oral instruction of a practitioner and the direct disciple of Pabongka Rinpoche, who fleshed out all of these three lineages. So we can see, and it should be fairly self evident in your chart, that the fivefold equalizing and interchanging of self and others is injected within the sevenfold cause and effect instruction between section three, repaying their kindness, and section six, wholehearted resolve. You can see sections five to nine of the fivefold equalizing of self and others which fit in here.
Now the preliminaries are the same, they’re fleshed out a bit. Equanimity becomes an independent step in Pabongka Rinpoche’s presentation, whereas previously it had been added by Kamalaśīla. Equanimity is trained in the two techniques we explained, Je Tsongkhapa’s technique or the fifth Dalai Lama’s technique. Recognizing all sentient beings as one’s mother is trained in exactly the same way, Pabongka Rinpoche’s technique. Recollecting their kindness is subdivided in two.
Recollecting their kindness, and a special recollection of their kindness, which is a state of mind which from one’s own side wishes to repay the kindness of beings and which prepares for the wholehearted resolve of point 10. At this point, one trains in equalizing self and others using the technique for equalizing self and others explained here, that all sentient beings and myself are equal in wishing to be free from suffering and in wishing for happiness. Reflection on the faults of self-cherishing and the qualities of cherishing others is identical to points two and three, a fivefold interchange of self and others. And in points eight and nine, Pabongka Rinpoche’s 11-point summary, the practice of Tonglen is directly connected with training in love and compassion. This is why the practice of love and compassion is implicitly present within Pabongka Rinpoche’s outline, even though it is not explicitly taught.
First, one engages in taking in Pabongka Rinpoche’s practice, as opposed to giving in the case of the interchange of self and others. And when one engages in taking, which is taking the suffering of others upon oneself, one trains in compassion simultaneously. So one visualizes the suffering of others maturing upon oneself. And then one trains in giving, in Pabongka Rinpoche’s tradition, and at this point, simultaneously one trains in love, the wish for all beings to have happiness in the causes of happiness. And on this basis one generates whole hearted resolve and bodhicitta.
Now I will conclude with some key points that Rinpoche conveyed which are really very much part of the oral transmission and then I would be open to your questions. The first point Rinpoche emphasized is that there are major differences between the sevenfold cause and effect practice in exchanging self and others. Not only is the equanimity in the two practices different, as Rinpoche emphasized, but in addition, both the love and the compassion generated in the context of the exchange of self in others are much more powerful than those which can be generated alone by the sevenfold cause and effect instruction. The reason for this is that when we train the sevenfold cause and effect instruction, we are recollecting the kindness sentient being showed to us when they were our mothers, and only them. Whereas when we train in the interchange of self and others, we are recollecting the kindness beings are showing to us on a daily basis in every single one of our lives.
Therefore the basis is much greater, both for the generation of compassion and the generation of love. As a result, the bodhicitta generated in dependence on the interchange of self and others is much more powerful. So I would like to quote here Rinpoche directly, The instructions on the interchange of self and others, because they give us access to an understanding of the kindness of sentient beings who have not directly been our fathers and mothers in this life or in any immediately preceding life are much more powerful. This is a sort of fleshing of the bare bones instructions which one can only get from a lineage master. Then from my side, I think we have finished, and what I would like us to do is to dedicate the merit we have accumulated today, all of us, during these teachings.
First and foremost to all sentient beings being free from suffering and the causes of suffering, and attaining happiness and the causes of happiness, and then to the long life of all our precious teachers, specifically, Khensur Rinpoche himself himself, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, and all our teachers. Since this very precious human rebirth everyone in this room of us has, we have as a result of practicing the instructions of our teachers in past lives. Thank you very much. Then, if you have questions to ask, I’m very happy to try to answer them. Yes.
The very best practice for those of us who have busy lives is when we get up in the morning to try to generate bodhicitta as best we can. If we can do it with the 11 instruction, that is good. At the beginning, it may be difficult. Therefore, it’s better to start with the seven point instruction, which is short, which just prints it out, keeps it by one’s bed. Takes five, ten minutes.
One does it while one is still in bed, the first thing in the day. One creates an equanimity, recollecting that all sentient beings are one’s mother, their kindness repaying their kindness, love, compassion, the great resolve and bodhicitta. And one tries to generate a feeling of bodhicitta. And with this one thinks, I will live my day. That’s very powerful training.
And then, with practice, one can inject in that the training of the interchange of self and others in the way which Pabongka Rinpoche taught it, and that should be enough. Khensur Rinpoche was suggesting to do this every day, and he said if one does this in the morning, and if in the evening one reflects on the faults one has committed during the day, and one confesses them and purifies, that is enough. Then a human life would have been well spent. Does that answer your question? Anne, I think you had a question.
Are unfortunately many forms of lives which are lower. The problem in a nutshell is that as westerners we tend to believe only what we can see. Then, the lower realms which we can see stop with the animal realm. There are such beings as spirits, which we in the West do not believe in. If one lives in India or in the East for a while, then I think their existence becomes fairly evident.
Many of those beings belong to the category of hungry ghosts. In other words, they are beings with tremendous desire, unsatisfied desire, cupidity. And then it is said there are even realms which we call the hell realms, realms of tremendous war, tremendous suffering, realms in which there is only suffering. I think spirits, can get an understanding of the existence of through thinking that if the mind is non material, which is more or less necessary for reincarnation to occur, one then could see how the mind would exist without a material envelope or could exist without a material envelope. Then such beings can be higher or lower beings.
As for the hell realms, think one can understand their existence by induction. If one reflects on the fact that the mind is impermanent, it can change for the better or for the worst. Being impermanent and lacking inherent existence can actually change infinitely for the better and infinitely for the worse. We can see within this very life that there are human beings whose minds are tremendously evil minds. I mean, we just have to read the news, there were such cases.
One sees on the faces of these beings great evil written. Then one can extrapolate and think, there are even more evil forms of mind than this. And eventually there are minds which are so evil that they are in a state of infinite suffering, infinite hatred. This would be the hell realms. So these are the lower realms.
Yes. The idea the idea is if we’re talking of king like bodhicitta, which is the only realistic bodhicitta, The idea is ourselves to attain a state of maximum capacity. It’s actually a state of omniscience. Buddhahood is a state of omniscience, of all knowingness, where we know everything. We can see the mental continuum of every single being.
We can see their karmic predispositions, going back thousands and billions of lives. Then, from once a being is fully enlightened, he can see exactly what to say to that person, what to do to connect, which we cannot do at present. He knows the sum total of the karmic background of that being. This is what is meant by skill in means. Then, with that wisdom, the fully enlightened being can do whatever it takes to help that person.
Can teach, can take them out for a cup of coffee, can manifest a magical emanation, can destroy them. Because the fully enlightened mind is a mind of omniscience which understands exactly where that being comes from. In our case, when we try to help others, it’s like blundering in the dark. We don’t have a clue. We have a reasonably decent motivation, heavily infected with self-cherishing.
Then we have no skill and means whatsoever because we don’t know where the other person is at. We would like to say the right thing. Sometimes it has exactly the opposite effects. I mean, we could say perhaps that the welfare state is a case in point of goodwill gone awry. The best motivation in the world.
Have the recipients of welfare aid really been helped. The results do not show it, you know. The results show almost the opposite. So, realizing this, we think, well, however hard I try, materially, in my limited state of understanding, if I try to help others, I cannot help them. If I try to teach, I don’t know what they need.
I may say the wrong thing. So I must first develop maximum capacity. Therefore I must become enlightened myself. Not for my own sake, but for the sake of others. Does that answer your question?
Yes. Both. We engage within our limited capacity in training in the perfections of generosity, for instance, we can do patience. Generosity means not just giving money or food, but giving teachings as a practice of generosity. But with full awareness that it’s unclear how beneficial that is, and therefore I think our practice has to be foremost, but our practice not for ourselves, our practice for others.
Does that answer your question? Atisha says in the Bodhipathapradīpa, the lamp of the Bodhisattva path, that until we have śamatha, we cannot help others. Because until we have śamatha, we don’t have the clairvoyances. Without the clairvoyances, which means telepathy, or seeing the past and future lives of others, we cannot help people. We do not know who people are.
All we see is the face, we see a mask, we see what people tell us. If you have a fair amount of life experience, you will see or you will know that what people tell you and what is actually going on in their lives are like this. If you act at this level and this is what is happening, there’s no benefit. So if one attains śamatha, one starts to become helpful to others. One can see within their mind, one can say, yes, this person actually tells me that they have a relationship problem, but the truth of the matter is not that at all.
It is this and this. And then you address the truth of the matter. I know for myself, at least two of my teachers clearly had pure telepathy. Once I became very close to them, would go to see them, didn’t have to ask any question. They would look at me, they would start speaking.
That is when one is able to be helpful to others. Does that answer your question? If there are no other questions, then I think we can call it a day.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- five appropriated aggregates
- The last of the eight types of suffering; how we suffer because the aggregates are "appropriated" or controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
- The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.