48 min · 2,910 words · 11 April 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains karma as intentional action, arising from motivation, that is skillful or unskillful. It sets out the four distinct modes of karma: results are definite, actions are amplified, uncommitted actions do not produce results, and committed actions are not dissipated. It concludes that understanding these leads one to abandon unskillful actions and cultivate skillful ones.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-04-11
Duration: 49 min
UUID: e9c37887-8971-4019-9192-d0a5b53a8429
Words: 2,906
And bringing about the growth of that sprout. So therefore, do not apply though it is a cause, we do not apply the term karma to the action of the seed. We apply the term karma when the action is a motivation. Let me give an example. If we were sitting in our room And we thought to go to work today.
And we thought, well, today I’m going to talk to this particular person. And so the activity of speaking to this person is precipitated by some sort of motivation, an intention. This intention could be negative or could be positive. The actual activity itself could be neutral and it could be negative or it could be positive. If we are motivated out of, for example, attachment or hatred and we speak that way, you know, a very afflictive emotions.
And out of this motivation we speak in such a way that the other person, it brings dislike, the other person doesn’t like what we’re saying. It hurts them in some way. Then this is an unskillful action. This way of acting is, this action is karma precipitated by a motivation creating karma. In this case, it would be an unskillful karma.
Why? Because it is the bringing of harm. On the other hand, if we, out of a sense of wanting to benefit, we spoke to someone and they gained a great liking out of what we said, they were happy with what we said, then this would be bringing a benefit and therefore it would be a skillful action. And this would be a, this is a karma and would be a positive karma. So that which brings benefit is the activity which is precipitated out of a motivation which brings benefit is a skillful action or a skillful karma.
A activity which is precipitated out of a negative action and which brings harm is unskillful action or a negative karma. So, you know, some people so in a in a way karma is work. Some people say I don’t have any work. I’m of work. I don’t have any place to go.
Other people say I have work. Some people talk about what they work. What’s your job? Oh, I’m a secretary, I’m a salesperson, I work in a restaurant. So these are work.
In Tibetan language, the word for work is made up of two syllables, la ka. La means action. Ka means difficult. Difficult actions are work. So it is the first syllable which is being translated as karma.
That is to say just action is what is being translated as karma. So some people think that karma is only applies to Buddhists but this is not the case. No matter who they may be, they’re involved in actions. Actions karma is simply activities. If our activity, for example, is motivated by healthy attitude and we enact a, we speak or act physically, flowing forth from healthy motivations would be positive activities or positive karma.
Motivations, activities of our body and speech which flow out from unhealthy attitudes or motivations or intentions would be negative activities or negative karma. Activities and karma are synonymous, same. Motivation precedes all our activities whether the activity be mental, physical or verbal. So first there is the motivation, the intention, and then flowing out some type of activity, some type of action. And depending upon the quality of that motivation, quality of that motivation will determine the quality of the activity.
If that motivation is negative or positive, the activity flowing which that precipitates will be accordingly negative or positive. There if in addition we were to So there is a motivation, an internal factor, and then for example, if we’re taking an example of saying something to someone, we speak to someone either in a harsh fashion or in a caring fashion, then this the internal factor becomes externalized. And then if in addition there is some conclusion reached within our own mind, again, having thought, you know, having hurt someone through your speech thinking, I’m glad I did that. There’s almost a sense of rejoicing in the act. On the other hand, you know, having talking talked well to someone brought them happiness, I’m glad I did that.
So if an action has these three components of a motivation, the activity, and then some sort of concluding attitude of rejoicing in affirming that that was what you wanted to do, then it’s considered a complete action and it’s extremely powerful. Give an example, if someone were to kill an enemy, first off they would develop motivation thinking again and again that I want to kill this person. And then out of that motivation then anger would arise in their mind and out of that anger then they would actually engage in the activity. Maybe they would take a gun and kill the person and that person would experience a great deal of suffering and as a completion to the activity, I did well. I’m glad I did that.
Then the action would be complete and it’d be extremely powerful. So this way of a complete action in terms of the presence of all these components is an extremely powerful type of action in which there is both the component of having acted in terms of the cause and effect within the environment and also in terms of the internal cause and effect, in terms of attitudes, of motivation and rejoicing in the conclusion of the act. And therefore, it’s going to produce an extremely powerful it is an extremely powerful unskillful action. So just as we applied this manner of creating a powerful action with respect to killing the same can be applied to other types of unskillful actions exactly. So for example not only killing but stealing, sexual improprieties, lying, divisive speech, harmful types of speech, idle chatter, hurtful intention, covetousness, and wrong views.
So in order for us to be able to consider karma in terms of unskillful activities that we begin to develop in our practice of implementing these what is to be adopted and rejected. The Buddha taught what is called the four distinct modes of karma. The four distinct modes of karma that the results of karma are infallible, that the results of actions committed are magnified, that the results of uncommitted actions are not experienced, and that actions once committed are not dissipated. So in general there are three types of karma. There are skillful karmas, unskillful karmas and unspecified karmas.
But all karma is enacted out through what are called the three doors. That is to say the body, speech and mind. Either it’s a mental karma or verbal karma or a physical karma. There’s no other way to express karma. In terms of this last type of karma we mentioned was unspecified karma.
Is a karma but it’s such that it does has very little power and therefore it’s not able to bring about either an experience of suffering or happiness. It brings about a neutral result, a neutral experience. So the results of actions are definite or infallible as I mentioned before. That is to say from a skillful action only happiness can result. There’s never any suffering.
In general, we can talk about three levels of skillful action. Those of great, middling, and minor skillful actions. From great, skillful actions only happiness results. Never any suffering. From middling skillful actions only happiness results.
Never any suffering. From minor skillful actions only happiness results. No suffering whatsoever. So this is the the infallibility of the relationship of of action of of skillful actions. Only happiness can result from it.
Never any suffering. Likewise, this holds true for unskillful actions, the three levels of unskillful actions of great, middling, and minor, and likewise there is this corresponding result that only suffering arises from unskillful actions no matter what the degree may be. Never any happiness. So this is definite relationship between actions and results, the infallible relationship. We can exemplify this in terms of external phenomena.
If we were to plant wheat seeds, then wheat No other type of variety of plant will arise. If we plant barley, only barley plants arise. No other type of plant will arise. If we plant rice, if we plant fruit seed, if we plant chili seeds, then only those specific types of results will arise. No other types will arise, no other variety.
So we can refine that, what we just said and say mainly the result of planting rice would be rice, but also there are the leaves of the rice, the stem of the rice plant, which are not rice. This would hold true also for internal, if we were to practice, the result of practicing ethics is a human embodiment and that acts as the basis of happiness, but it’s not necessarily happiness. The Buddha said that whatever actions are created a concordant result will arise. That is to say from skillful actions a concordant result of happiness. From unskillful actions a concordant result of unhappiness or suffering will arise.
Those actions which benefit living beings are said to be skillful actions. Having created a skillful action toward others that as a result we ourselves will be benefited, that as a result we will be brought happiness. On the other hand, unskillful actions are those types of actions which bring harm to living beings. As a result, we in the future ourselves will be brought harm. So whatever benefit we enact outwards to others will be returned to ourselves as benefit as a result.
Whatever harm that we enact toward others will as a result bring harm to This opportunity that we’ve had to spend this comfortable weekend and receive teachings in this way, in this relaxed manner is result of skillful actions that we’ve created. But still within that context, some people had headaches, some people had pains in their knees and their legs. That’s all a result of unskillful action. Some were just that complete bliss. They had no pain whatsoever.
That’s a result of their skillful actions in the past. Even the even the cooling the feeling refreshed from a cool breeze is is the result of a skillful action. So if we we develop this conviction in this relation, the relationship between actions and the results in that we don’t we want happiness, we realize that from skillful actions happiness arises, never any suffering. So we’ll make effort in creating skillful actions. On the one hand, and understanding that we don’t want suffering, that from unskillful actions, suffering arises, never happiness, we will begin to abandon unskillful actions.
So this is and through this conviction, we engage very powerfully in the in the the practice of abandoning and cultivating. So the the second distinct mode of karma is that actions are augmentative or amplifying. That great actions produce great results, but even insignificant actions can be amplified bringing great results. So the way we could Better. If we were to present an analogy, even if we had a huge vessel and we were just simply to drop to allow to drop water drops of water.
Drip water. Drip drops of water one at a time. Even though those drops are extremely small, if we were to continually drip drops of water, eventually, even no matter how huge the vessel, it would it would fill up completely. So if each day we engage in skillful action, even if it’s only a rather insignificant skillful action, but we do it today and then we do it tomorrow and the day after and the week after and the month after and the year after, eventually it’s a very powerful skillful action. If if we were to give even a crumb, a morsel of food, just a little tiny bit of food to a dog or a cat out of sense of compassion, but with the motivation of the awakening heart, thinking: I am practicing in order to attain Buddhahood for the sake of all living beings, I am practicing generosity with that as one’s motivation even though you’re only giving a tiny morsel of food.
It creates a skillful action equal to all of space. Why is how does this come about? That living beings are as infinite as space. And if we have the motivation of seeking, of giving in order to benefit all living beings for the purpose of benefiting all living beings. Then we create a skillful action for each in terms of each of those innumerable living beings.
And since they are innumerable as space, we create a skillful action with respect to each of them creating a skillful action equal to space. And that skillful action will be will will not be exhausted until we achieve Buddhahood. So even from insignificant action, great results can arise. The same holds true for unskillful actions. Even from insignificant unskillful actions, a type of unskillful action can be accumulated such that it is not exhausted till the end of time.
So this is the the process of amplification of the action. I I give one example. If someone has the motivation of a practitioner of narrow perspective and thinking I’m going to practice generosity in order to attain a human life in the future and makes an act of generosity. So one is not there’s no thought about other living beings. One is only concerned about oneself.
If if if that skillful action is not destroyed by anger in the interval, then tomorrow that skillful action will have doubled. The day after tomorrow it will have been four times, next day eight, so forth. After one month, it’s it’s a huge amount of skillful action. So these actions are increasing in their potency and the same holds true for unskillful actions. For example, if we said some harsh word to somebody today, tomorrow the unskillful action would have doubled doubling again and doubling again, doubling again, increasing and amplifying in the same manner.
So what are we to do in such a case? What’s the method we can make use of? If in the evening we recollect that over the course of the day that we spoke harshly to someone and develop a sense of regret around having harmed that person in that way and then committing oneself not to act that way tomorrow. And we can then maybe cultivating the awakening heart, meditating on emptiness, cultivating some antidote, then we can completely we can stop this amplifying effect. So in within Buddhism, there is vast variety of methods we can implement in our practices.
If we were to give to an analogy in terms of external phenomena of the of this amplifying effect, if we were to plant a fruit seed Fruit seed is is extremely small. Small. We plant it in the earth and then eventually it it can produce a very large tree with branches and leaves. And additionally, fruit begins to grow. And year after year, more fruit is produced.
Year after year, a tremendous amount of fruit can be produced from a single seed. So to give a rather humorous example, exemplifying this, the way we’ve been discussing amplification of actions. A long time ago in India, there were some monks who were going on their alms round and they came to a stream and one of the monks very adeptly jumped over the stream and and the monk behind said, oh, he jumped over that just like a monkey!. From from that having said that in that way, this monk took rebirth 500 times as a monkey. And the same holds true: one monk was chanting in the evening, and this monk had a very very unpleasant voice like like the howling of a dog.
And one monk said, you sound like a dog howling, and this monk took rebirth as a dog 500 times. So even from insignificant words, harsh words spoken in that way, a great results can arise. So the third distinct mode of karma is the results of uncommitted actions are not experienced. So what what is being sought to be understood here is that if we don’t commit a particular action, we will not experience the result of that action. Results of uncommitted actions are not experienced.
If don’t commit a particular skillful action, we will not experience the resultant happiness of that action. If we don’t commit a particular unskillful action, we will not experience the resultant suffering of that particular action. Just in general, if we don’t go to work, we don’t get a salary. So if you know, without doing the action, then no result is experienced. So if we go back to the second distinct mode of action for a moment where it was that actions are highly amplified, that the result of coming to a conviction in this relationship of actions and the result is that seeing even from insignificant unskillful actions greatly amplified resultant suffering can occur then we will abandon even unskillful actions minor insignificant unskillful actions.
On one hand, and seeing the reverse of the situation that even from insignificant skillful actions, greatly amplified resultant happiness can arise. We will practice, engage in, cultivate even insignificant skillful actions. So having seen the relationship between actions uncommitted do not bring about a result.
Key terms in this teaching
- three doors go sum (Tib)
- Body, speech and mind. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.