48 min · 2,286 words · 10 April 1993
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continuing a talk on dying, the teacher explains how the discriminating mind at death can be guided toward positive states by remembering the lama, Buddha, Sangha and Dharma, which shapes the next rebirth. Karma is explained in three types according to when its results ripen, with actions towards parents and teachers ripening most quickly. The session closes with meditation on bodhicitta, reasoning through the three scopes of the path.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1993-04-10
Duration: 49 min
UUID: e6a89484-cabb-48b0-9b17-edf5f4c40c9b
Words: 2,282
Full state, a positive state, then one will take a positive type of rebirth. On the other hand, if it’s in a negative state, one will take a negative type of rebirth. So the consciousness at the time of death has two stages. One in which is a conceptual consciousness, a thinking consciousness which is able to discriminate between positive and negative. But there is also a stage of a more subtle consciousness which is not able to make this discrimination.
It is not able to think in terms of positive and negative. So while while this in the the in dying state, while the mind is still able to consider, is able to discriminate between positive and negative is in that, has that ability, then it’s extremely beneficial if someone who is accompanying the dying, who is with the dying person speaks to them very gently and reminding them to think about positive things. For example, think about their spiritual teacher, their lama, think about the Buddha, think about the Sangha, think about the Dharma. Trying to help them to remember these things at the moment of death while they’re still able to think in terms of positives and negatives. Discriminatory consciousness ceases, then a consciousness which is not able to discriminate in terms of positive or negative arises.
So if the mind, but the type of mind which is then induced, this subtle mind, is induced by the quality of the discriminatory mind, this mind which was able to think. So if the mind is in the process of death, is in a positive state, is able to discriminate in terms of positive terms, then this will, as the coarse consciousness begins to recede and the subtle consciousness begins to rise which cannot discriminate, it will induce a positive state even though it will induce a positive state of mind. And then if there is a continuity which continues on of this positive state, and this positive state will bring about a positive type of rebirth. On the other hand for someone who has been practicing the Dharma, has meditated, they will not need assistance at the time of death. They can induce the positive states of mind They can meditate on love or compassion, bodhicitta, emptiness.
They can think about their lama and this will induce a positive state. On the other hand, if, you know, for someone who has not practiced the Dharma or has not practiced it well, then if they were at during this discriminatory consciousness were to generate anger or attachment, a negative state to the mind, then this would lead as a continuity of that negative state to a negative rebirth. So whether one is a practitioner of Dharma or not, if one is able to use some method for inducing in the dying person a positive state, a skillful state of mind, then this will ensure a skillful rebirth. On the other hand, whether one is a practitioner of Dharma or not, if at the time of death one develops these negative states, negative states such anger attachment, then this will have a continuum of leading into a negative state of rebirth. So the thinking, know, reflecting upon on this this fact is extremely important and it’s it will be a very very beneficial if you consider this.
So though there’s no pain in the dissolution process of the elements as the body begins to break down where the earth element and the water element, etc, begin to dissolve, even though they’re not experiencing pain there does arise fear which could induce attachment, induce anger. So this could occur. Various appearances may arise to the dying consciousness one way. For some maybe who has a very skillful states of mind, maybe their spiritual teacher, the appearance of their spiritual teacher arises and they have, they’re drawn toward that. They have a liking for that and this will help to the mind to take a positive rebirth.
On the other hand, some might have this sense that they’re being crushed under the earth or some terrible appearance arises and this will have the tendency to induce the consciousness to take a negative rebirth. Yes. Are you likely to know? Are you likely to know? You mean, do you have amongst your and the So it’s possible that you may know if you have clairvoyance.
But if you don’t have clairvoyance then you probably don’t. No. But someday when you take rebirth as a celestial being and you look around, that’s all you’ll see is celestial beings just like we see looking around us now we see human beings where you’ll see celestial beings. On the other hand, when you take rebirth in hell, what you’ll see is other hell beings. Yes.
So the nerve, and we we say that we go for refuge to the Buddha. It’s not as if the Buddha can somehow take us and save us from all harm. That it is that that the Buddha through out of their compassion compassion, shows shows what is to be adopted and what is to be rejected and then we put that into practice and this is what actually protects us through our practice. But we are able to practice through the kindness of the Buddha so this is the way they afford us refuge. But they cannot, they are not a savior in that way.
And likewise with respect to our Lama. The Lama is the one who shows us the path, shows us how to practice, and if we, in practicing well, then our death will go well. But we will, if we have, we can remember our Lama at the time of death, then this will be an extremely favorable condition for taking a positive rebirth. Additionally, in the intermediate state, the bardo, if we have a strong affinity with our Lama, if we have kept our samaya commitments in connection with him or her, then there is a strong possibility that we will think of our Lama in the intermediate state. If we think of Lama, then he will appear or she will appear to us and be able to help us through the bardo, will be able to teach us and show us the path.
So if if we if we request to that we always be near our lama whether it be at death, the intermediate state, or or in the future, if we have that make these very strong requests, then at those times we will generate and if we think that request has in fact been answered, we will generate a faith at these times. We will have faith in the Lama that he is going to be there in a state in the future. And this faith is a very positive state of mind. It is in itself positive. So it’s going to induce a positive situation for us.
Just this the actual faith itself. Itself. So, for example, if one has faith in the Buddha, then if we can be mindful of that and generate that faith that we’ve developed over our life by, for example, if at the time of death we had a picture of the Buddha, then this would stimulate this mindfulness of the Buddha and our faith would arise and this faith would help us, would induce induce the consciousness to take a positive rebirth. Yes. So with respect to karma in this context there are three types.
Three different types in this context of karma. There is the karma which is accumulated in this life and the result is experienced in this life. There is the karma which is accumulated in this life but the result is experienced in the next life. And the third, the karma which is accumulated in this life and the result is experienced in a life after the next life or any succeeding life. So two or more lives afterwards.
For example, a type of karma which is accumulated in the result of experience in this life, those types of actions which are committed with respect to our parents or spiritual teacher very part whether they’re negative or positive the results of these can be experienced in this life itself. And other types of actions accumulated such as killing, stealing, etc, whether positive or negative, the result can be experienced in the next life. Those actions have middling power. So these first types of actions which are experienced in this life are extremely powerful actions. Those who have middling power, the various types of actions, the result will be experienced in the next life.
Those of minor power, the result will be experienced in two or more lives. So perhaps this this view hasn’t become very current in the West this way. But it’s very clear to in Tibet, it was very clear in Tibet that these actions against one is committed with respect to one’s parents or spiritual teachers, lamas, the result is experienced in this life both positive and also negative. So think Westerners should examine this and investigate how the outcomes of how children treat their parents over the course of their life. You know, whether they fought with their parents, whether they did a lot of nasty things to their parents or on the other hand positive things and see what kind of how their life turns out for these different individuals.
So this is a, actions accumulated in this life which result is experienced in the same life. I’m not sure if Westerners accept this doctrine, but the Buddha said that because our parents and our lama are of the greatest benefit to us to us in this life, those actions which are committed with respect to them are of the most powerful and therefore they have they will bring about the quickest results. To induce them to ripen. So through practice of tonglen, giving and taking, one can bring about one can induce the suffering that would have you would have experienced in the future and you can experience it now. For example, if we carry on a very powerful practice where we purify our negativities, we accumulate a great deal of merit.
Then this will have the effect that future negativities, types of suffering which would have been experienced in the future. For example, even the suffering of having been born as a hell being will fall upon us now in the form of a headache or a toothache. Some people think that in practicing Dharma. Many people think that in practicing Dharma that we go through a lot of hardships. We have a lot of troubles. We experience a lot of suffering.
And there are these ripening effects of future negativities upon us now. But this is really a wonderful thing to experience because that ensures that in the future we will experience only happiness. So the suffering and the difficulties are not due to our practice of Dharma. They are due to a result of negative actions that we’ve accumulated in the past. We should consider that.
Okay. Okay. Begin with meditation. Can you hear me okay? A little bit louder.
We have achieved a special basis of a human life by means of which we can bring about the welfare of both ourselves and others. This life which we all possess has the potential to free ourselves and others from suffering. Therefore, we should try to make effort implementing the methods whereby to bring an end to both our the sufferings of ourselves and others. If our motivation for implementing these methods is a kind hearted attitude that of the awakening heart, we can be sure that from this motivation will flow forth fruitful types of conduct and beneficial results and that we can benefit both ourselves and others by freeing them from their problems. So we’re going to begin with cultivating the kindhearted attitude of the awakening heart.
How do we proceed in meditating and cultivating the kind heart attitude of the awakening heart? So we need to develop a very powerful attitude which cherishes all living beings and wishes to lead them to a stage where they have complete freedom from suffering and they have complete happiness. But if we were to question, well do I actually have that ability to bring about that in? At present we do not. If we were to go on to question one, who does have such an ability?
And through investigating, we would come to understand it is only a Buddha who has that full capacity. Therefore, if if I were to attain a state of Buddhahood, then I could just like a Buddha begin to lead all living beings to a state where they’re free of their suffering, they have complete happiness. Therefore, I myself must remove all my various faults. I myself must bring to consummation all my excellent qualities. I must I myself must must attain the state of a Buddha.
Therefore, I I must commit myself to this being to achieving the state of Buddhahood. In order to achieve Buddhahood, I must practice the path of the being of vast perspective. In order to practice proficiently the path of the being of vast perspective, I must, as a prerequisite, practice the path of the being of middling perspective. In order to practice that path proficiently, I must, as a prerequisite, practice the path of the being of narrow perspective. Therefore, in order to achieve that end, I am now going to listen to, reflect upon, and meditate well the path of the being of narrow perspective to develop such motivation.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- samaya dam tsig (Tib)
- Sacred word of honor; the pledges and commitments made by a disciple at an initiation to keep tantric vows for life or to perform certain practices connected with the deity, such as daily sadhana recitation... LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.