2 h 17 min · 6,598 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching presents emptiness as the object of analytical meditation, using the reasoning of dependent arising to refute inherent existence, first of the self and then of phenomena. It covers the preliminary practices, including the seven-limbed puja and guru devotion, as necessary preparation for realising emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 18m
UUID: 41a5724e-b8cd-4c08-9f8d-e0283521b9c0
Words: 6,594
So therefore, when one attends the dharma teaching, both the teacher himself who utters a dharma teaching and the listener who listens to the dharma teaching must generate the same good motivation. It is on the basis of this good motivation, on the basis of this good motivation alone, that they will both be able to accumulate vast amounts of merit. So the best is to generate bodhichitta within one’s mind stream, which is the supreme, good motivation. And to do this, we should envision ourselves surrounded by sentient beings as vast and as numberless as space. And first generate within our mind infinite compassion, praying that they be free of all suffering and of all the causes of suffering.
Thereafter generate within our mind the wish that they be endowed with all happiness and all the causes of happiness and specifically the supreme happiness of full enlightenment. In dependence upon this powerful motivation of bodhichitta, we must then determine resolutely that we shall meditate on the very essence, the very heart of the dharma, which is the understanding of emptiness. And in dependence on this understanding of emptiness, we will attain full enlightenment for the benefit of all beings. It is in dependence on just how vast the motivation is that the vastness of the deed can be ascertained, and in dependence on the vastness of the deeds we have engaged in that the vastness of the effects can be ascertained. Therefore, the vastness of the effects produced is directly dependent on the vastness of the motivation.
So there will be great benefit if we endeavor to do this, whether we are actually able to do so or not. So with this as a goal, the goal of familiarizing our mind with this meditation, we shall now meditate on bodhichitta for three minutes or so. So in a very famous quote, Tsongkhapa refers to those who can apprehend the very essence of the Buddha’s teachings, which is emptiness, as the fortunate ones, the blessed ones. They are fortunate in that they understand the very nature of phenomena. So then in dependence upon the happiness which arises from this realization of just how fortunate we are, then the mind becomes very loose and relaxed, a very happy mind.
And then in such a happy mind, there is no place for anger. Moreover, the quote adds that we should sit in a relaxed position, which Rinpoche demonstrated on the throne, just sit back quietly and loosely as it were. And then we should carefully avoid the three faults of the vessel, which are the inappropriate attitudes of the listener during a dharma teaching. So Buddha Śākyamūni said in this respect, may the mind not be contaminated by hindrances or pollutions. What is meant by this is that when we listen to a dharma teaching, our mind should not be contaminated by desire or hatred.
It should be a straight, actually an honest mind. So this is the first fault, which is the fault of the vessel being contaminated. The second fault, entails having one’s mind running left and right and being distracted during the teachings. Now if the the mind runs hither and thither and is not concentrated, then the teachings will not enter in the mind and the mind or the attitude of this listener is compared to that of an upside down vessel, an upside down vase in which no water can enter even should water be poured on it. So this is the second fault.
So it is only if the mind is single pointedly concentrated on the teachings which it is listening to that there is benefit. So, the third thought we should avoid is that of forgetfulness. Our mind should grasp the teachings powerfully through the force of memory, through the force of recollection and not let them flee from us. And then, in dependence on this powerful grasping of this of the mind, this powerful memory and recollection, the teachings will be of benefit. Otherwise, the simile given is that of a vase, which is pierced, a vase which has a hole at its bottom and which can never then be filled with water.
However much we pour in the vase, that much and more flows out. So therefore, be carefully aware of this and abandon these three faults and then with a tight mind, with a strict mind as it were, you know, hold the teachings carefully to your heart. So the topic of our conference today is emptiness and vipassana which apprehends emptiness. Now in general, are many forms of vipassana. There are Vipassanas, which apprehend conventional phenomenas, and Vipassanas, and in other words, analytical meditations, which apprehend many other forms of phenomena.
Our specific focus today is a vipassana, which apprehends emptiness. To study it carefully, we need to understand the object it apprehends, is emptiness. And to understand emptiness correctly, we have to understand clearly the object which is refuted by emptiness. If want the very pith, the very target, which is targeted by the notion of emptiness. Now, this was developed in great detail by the glorious Candrakīrti, who was developing and explicating the thought of the great Nāgārjuna, who taught emptiness exactly as it were, if as if emptiness were something in the palm of his hand to be presented to others.
So because the topic which we are going to be dealing with today, emptiness, and is an extremely profound and a difficult topic, Acharya Candrakīrti said, ordinary beings must again and again recollect the meaning of emptiness and bring it to their minds. The glorious Candrakīrti wrote his monumental treatise, Madhyamakāvatāra entering into the middle way with Bodhisattvas as intended trainees of the treatise. In other words, it was primarily of benefit to Bodhisattvas. We ourselves do not qualify, but we can nonetheless recollect repeatedly the meaning of emptiness and the term emptiness as best we understand it, and independence on this and through generating faith within our mind that emptiness is the actual reality of phenomena, strong karmic imprints will be implanted in our mind and these will eventually mature. One can see as a sign of this maturation the fact that some people when they hear the word emptiness pronounced, almost squirm with delight and feel a natural attraction to the notion.
This is a sign of strong karmic imprints. So, the rather difficult criterion for being an appropriate intended trainee for the teachings on emptiness is that when you hear the term emptiness, your eyes should glisten with tears, your hair should stand on end, and you should be thrilled at the very thought of studying this. Therefore, it is said that there is great benefit in teaching emptiness to such a trainee who has as it were the karmic seeds for the realization of emptiness implanted within his mind stream. Such a trainee upon hearing explanations of about emptiness will benefit tremendously from them and will then engage in the practice of the other perfections, giving morality, patience, energy, meditation, and wisdom. So Rinpoche is quite convinced that most of you are trainees of that extraordinary caliber.
Are you crying? So Jetsungpa says that the best trainees have those signs and if one can have those signs, then it obviously is very beneficial. Otherwise, it is adequate to have faith and firm conviction in the notion of emptiness and to beware of the generation of wrong views regarding emptiness, which are very dangerous indeed. So, one who upon reflecting upon emptiness comes to the conclusion that nothing whatsoever exists has fallen into an extreme of wrong views. This is an erroneous view, which is technically called the extreme of nihilism.
It is not the case that because phenomena are empty of inherent existence, they do not exist. Far from there, emptiness is all about existence. So it is said that those of little merit are not able to generate the requisite doubts regarding the nature of phenomena. But when those of great merit start doubting the mode of appearance of phenomena and start wondering whether really phenomena exist in the way they appear, At that moment, it is said that saṃsāra is torn apart in the same way as a suit of new clothes can be torn to shreds. So the glorious Je Tsongkhapa asked Mañjuśrī when he perceived him in a direct vision, what were the prerequisites for realizing emptiness?
And the glorious Mañjuśrī answered Je Tsongkhapa, first and foremost, purify all your faults and all your obstructions, Then put effort into perceiving the Guru as indissociable from the Yidam. And finally, study carefully the great texts and meditate upon them and independence on these three factors, you will realize emptiness. So it is said that when these three preconditions are mixed as it were, are practiced in conjunction, then the realization of emptiness will come rapidly. So the first condition is to purify one’s faults, one’s negative karma. This is absolutely fundamental in In practice.
In our case, probably most of the day is spent in worldly activities and accumulating money. Instead of this, we should put great effort in purifying our minds and on this basis then, we will increase our stock of merit and eventually be able to attain these realizations. So the purification of faults is absolutely fundamental. When we speak of faults, what do we mean by the term fault? We mean non virtuous, the non virtuous deeds of the past, which are the cause of non virtuous karma.
This non virtuous karma crushes us as it were, it prevents us from gaining any realizations when we meditate. Je Tsongkhapa said in a famous quote, for we are able to memorize the words, the meaning does not dawn on the mind and there are no realizations from meditation. This is a clear sign of mental afflictions due to past non virtuous karma. If we purify the non virtuous karma, then the realizations will arise almost by themselves. So all the obstructions which arise in the context of our practice diseases linked to the channels or whichever difficulties we face are all problems which are linked to the non purification of the non virtues we carry within us.
Therefore, we must purify these non virtues and confess them. So as to purifying the non virtues within our mind stream, how shall we proceed? The great masters of the past, starting with Guru Serlingpa, his student Atisha and the glorious Je Tsongkhapa, all felt that the best way to purify the mind of its faults are what can be called the six preliminary practices. These are actually practices which enable us to conjoin our practice with the realizations to bind them together as it were. So what are these six preliminary practices?
First and foremost, we should clear the place where we shall meditate. And secondly, set up appropriate basis for practice, in this case, statues of the Buddha, of Ārya Maitreya, of Mañjuśrī, of Je Tsongkhapa, of Atisha. These statues should be pure and beautifully adorned and then we should make pure offerings to these statues as much as we can, whether they are great offerings or small offerings. And these offerings can be offerings of flower or of incense with a beautiful smell. And then we set down a cushion on the meditation seat, as has been previously explained, the back of the cushion should be higher and the front part lower.
And after doing so, we offer prostrations. And then we must powerfully expel from our mind stream all afflictions and non virtues, and try to generate within our mind stream virtue and specifically a powerful positive motivation, such as bodhichitta on the basis of love and compassion. And then we need a base to accumulate merit with respect to and that base with respect to which we accumulate merit is the tree of accumulation of the collections. We visualize in front of ourselves a tree which is bearing our teachers, our Gurus, Buddhas, Buddha Śākyamūni, Aryamaitreya, the various Buddhas of all times, in a somewhat similar fashion to the way this is done in the Guru Puja, in the Lama Chöpa. UNIDENTIFIED So it may be difficult for us to visualize this in detail, but that is not important.
The most important is that we have a strong conviction that the our gurus and the Buddhas of all three times are in front of us. This strong conviction will be enough for them to immediately come in our presence because they see us from afar and their only wish is to help us. Therefore, the moment we think powerfully of them, they will naturally come. We are devoid both of faith and of the object of visualization. But if we had faith in the object of visualization, then wherever we visualize the Buddhas, whether it be on our crown, on our heart, or in the space in front of us, they will immediately assemble.
And then independence on this visualization, we can engage in a brief or in an extensive set of practices, which are called the seven limbed pujas. The first limb of the seven limbed puja is the limb of offering, the second limb is the limb of prostration, and the third limb is a limb of confession of faults. Then we have the limb of rejoicing and after that, we have the limb of requesting the presence of the Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas And we request them to do the to benefit sentient beings, to do the welfare of sentient beings. We request them not to depart into nirvana, but to turn the wheel of the dharma for the benefit of sentient beings. Then if we have the possibility to do so, it would be very beneficial to offer the Mandala at this point.
We visualize as Rinpoche showed the Mudra with his hands, in the center of the Mandala Mount Meru, the four continents, the four main continents in the four directions, the eight subcontinents, and then we visualize above the Mandala itself, our bodies and all the offerings we can make of whichever nature we have the capacity to do so. We offer all of these and after this, we then dedicate the merit accrued through the sevenfold or the seven limbed puja to all sentient beings attaining full enlightenment. So the Amitābha Dharma Center has several booklets on how to perform the seven limbed Puja, so it is not necessary at this point to enter into more details. It is just important to keep in mind that the goal of this Puja is to complete as far as possible the accumulations as a preliminary to our practice. So perform it in a condensed way as best you can.
At this point, we should visualize the Gurus of the various lineages such as the lineages of the profound view, the lineage of the vast conduct, the lineage of instantaneous blessing and the various other lineages in front of us dissolving progressively into Buddha Śākyamūni and Buddha Śākyamūni coming onto our crown. So if you can study and recite these texts, it would be very good. So now the time has come to meditate on emptiness. On our crown, we visualize our root guru who is the abridgement or who encompasses all the Buddhas of all three times in the form of Buddha Śākyamūni. So when we meditate on emptiness, it is not sufficient to just sit in meditation posture and bring the term emptiness to mind.
Well, this may implant some karmic imprints within the mind stream, which will make us in the future inclined to be interested in the view in emptiness, this can in no way lead to the realization of emptiness. To realize emptiness analysis is indispensable. We must analyze carefully and ask ourselves in the same way as if we were checking whether an object is amid a collection of other objects, is this emptiness, is that emptiness, what can I call emptiness? And this analysis must be done through valid cognition, through Pramāna. Then through the alternates of analytical and fixative or concentrative meditation, progressively, we will attain the realization of emptiness.
Without this, there is no realization of emptiness. So the analytical mind which investigates emptiness can broadly speaking, infinity number be subsumed into five, which include among the other, the royal mind which analyzes emptiness through interdependence, the mind which analyzes emptiness through the simile of the diamond slivers, and the mind which analyzes emptiness through the presence or absence of the objects in its causes and conditions. There are various such ways of analyzing phenomena, and generally speaking, they are grouped into five. So in general, in the Lamrim, we rely on the techniques of analysis, which were pioneered by the Acharya Candrakīrti to understand the nature of phenomena. Buddha Śākyamūni and Je Tsongkhapa said that of the countless reasonings establishing emptiness and specifically from among the five in his reasonings establishing emptiness, the supreme one, the king of reasonings, is a reasoning of interdependence.
So the principal benefit of the reasoning, which depends upon interdependent arising and which was praised as such by the Buddha, arises from the fact that it prevents us from falling into the two extremes of reification and nihilism or the extreme of existence and nihilism. In as much as a correct understanding of emptiness is a correct understanding of the middle way, the middle ground between the extremes of existence and nihilism. Now, if we understand emptiness independence upon dependent arising, this understanding independence upon dependent arising will prevent us from falling into the extreme of existence and will prevent us from falling into the extreme of non existence. Otherwise, if we have fallen into the extreme of existence, we have no understanding of emptiness. And if we fall into the extreme of nihilism, we will also have no understanding whatsoever of emptiness.
So Buddha Śākyamūni said that through the understanding of the dharma, we get the understanding and the realization of Buddhahood. Now, it is similar with respect to the relationship between dependent arising and emptiness. Through the understanding of dependent arising, we will gain the understanding of emptiness, And through the understanding of emptiness, we will then attain full enlightenment. Therefore, it is very important to first and foremost gain a clear understanding of dependent arising. So in general, are two broad understandings of emptiness of dependent arising, excuse me, of interdependence, a coarse one and a subtle one.
Moreover, the understandings of interdependent arising or interdependence may be divided into three. One, for those of, very weak capacities, this is a form of interdependence which is easy to understand, the second for those of middling capacity, and the last for those of greater capacity. While it is good to understand the latter two, it is adequate to understand the first one because on this basis, it may be possible to understand emptiness and therefore to progress towards full enlightenment. So the first reasoning establishing interdependence hinges on an understanding of causality. We all have a broad understanding of what causality means from a given cause, a given effect is produced.
For instance, if one were to plant a seed in the field, first we put the seed in the field, and from that seed a sprout arises. Now at the time of the seed, there is no sprout, and at the time of the sprout, there is no seed left apart from the thin skin, the thin covering which covered the seed, Therefore, is a non meeting of the cause and the effect. At the time of the cause, there is no effect, and at the time of the effect, there is no cause. Following this reasoning to its logical conclusion, we can establish interdependence on the basis of causality. Therefore, this initial presentation of causal interdependence relies on the fact that we have somewhat of an understanding of causality.
For instance, we are aware of the fact that planting a seed in the field gives rise to crops, that parents give rise to children and the various other instances of causality. So in a famous quote, Chanda Kirti identifies the many forms of selflessness, which actually can be resumed into two broad categories, the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena. To give another quote from the Heart sūtra, the passage in the Heart sūtra, the five Skandhas are empty of their own nature, refers specifically to the five Skandhas, that is a Skanda of form, feelings, recognition, volition, and consciousness being empty of any inherently nature from their own side. This quote alludes to the selflessness of phenomena. So, this quote indicates through indicating the emptiness of inherent existence of the five aggregates, five Skandhas, the emptiness of or the selflessness of phenomena.
Now, the I which arises as an imputation, independence upon the five aggregates, when it is perceived as inherently existent, it’s being negated as such is the emptiness of persons. So these five aggregates are not the I. The I arises independence upon an imputation on the basis of these five aggregates. And this I which arises independence upon an imputation on the basis of the five aggregates is that which performs the various functions we refer to in ordinary speech when we say, I am sleeping, I am walking, I am thinking, etcetera. So when we first start meditating on emptiness, we must meditate as yogis upon the emptiness of that I.
So we meditate first upon the emptiness of inherent existence of the I, in other words, the selflessness of persons, because it is an easier topic to meditate upon than to meditate upon the selflessness of phenomena, which is somewhat more difficult. So we must meditate therefore on the emptiness of the I. How shall we do this? Well, we take this I and we analyze carefully again and again, whether it is established by its own nature, whether it is inherently established, or whether it is not established by its own nature. So again and again we check, is it established by its own nature, or is it not established by its own nature.
And eventually, will come to the realization that this I is not established by its own nature, Its establishment by its own own nature is nonexistent. That realization that the I’s establishment by its own nature is nonexistent is the moment we have realized emptiness. So, the I’s being established by its own nature, the I’s being inherently established is the object of negation, the object of refutation of this meditation. And this object of refutation, this object of negation can only be refuted through reasoning. It cannot be refuted, for instance, through mantras or other practices of a similar nature.
Only through reasoning can it be eliminated. So what is the purpose of understanding that the I is not inherently existent? The notion that the I is inherently existent and the mind which apprehends the I as inherently existent is actually the ignorance which apprehends the inherent existence of phenomena. This ignorance which apprehends the inherent existence of phenomena arises naturally in our mind and is itself at the root of the afflictions, which are attached to some phenomena and reject other phenomena. It’s on the basis of these afflictions that non virtuous karma is accumulated, and on the basis of this non virtuous karma, we undergo suffering.
If we want to eliminate the result of suffering, we have to eliminate the non virtuous karma, and to eliminate the non virtuous karma, we must eliminate the afflictions which have given rise to it. These afflictions can only be eliminated by cutting the root, which is this ignorance apprehending the inherent existence of phenomena. And when we have cut that, then suffering will no longer arise. So if we observe our minds, we will see that this inherently existent I arises naturally in our mind. It is what arises in our mind when we say I I or my mine, you see.
This is actually a mistaken view. It is not the case that there is no I, there is an I which is a dependently arisen I, which arises independence on causes and conditions. In our case, we have taken a human rebirth. This rebirth is a result of virtuous deeds done in the past, a virtuous karma. Cooperative conditions might in our case, however, be afflictions, because we are still bound to saṃsāra.
So we have actually taken a rebirth and there is such a thing as an I, which is a dependent arising. However, the I which is not a dependent arising, which exists inherently from its own side by its own nature, such an I does not exist. The mind which apprehends the existence of such an I is a mistaken mind, it’s a wrong mind. We can see within our own mind stream that whenever strong emotions arise, a very powerful sense of this I which exists independently of any conditions, of anything outside of it, arises very powerfully. It rises to the fore of our mind.
It takes control of it as it were. This is the inherently existent I, which is the object of negation. The non existence of this inherently existent I is emptiness. Therefore, emptiness itself is not a non existent, emptiness is an existence because it is a non existence of a non existent. It is a non existence of the inherently existing I, which itself does not exist.
So Rinpoche says, to give an example, those of us who have studied definitions in Buddhist logic would posit an example, the subject I, or for instance, the subject Rinpoche’s book. Now, we would say using the royal reasoning of interdependence, the subject I is not inherently existent, because it is a dependent arising. Therefore, from the reason of dependent arising, from the reason of interdependence, we draw the conclusion that the I is not inherently existent. Its inherent existence is a nonexistent. So, to understand emptiness and to meditate on emptiness, first, the object of negation, which is the inherent existence of the self, of the I, must arise powerfully in the mind.
Otherwise, if we do not know what we want to negate, we can’t even get started. So first, this object of negation, what is negated, must arise powerfully in the mind, and then we analyze it to see whether it exists in the way it appears or not. Is this I which appears to be inherently existent, something which actually exists, so is it an illusion? Upon analysis, we find it does not exist. And then by refuting this object of negation, we gain the realization of emptiness.
So for instance, if we take to give an example of this rather difficult subject, if we take an example, we might wonder whether a scientist has attended this dharma meeting or not. Now, we might just ask a question, is there a scientist among you or not? Now, if we don’t know the defining characteristics of a scientist, what he looks like, then we will have no way of saying whether there is or not a scientist. First, we must know what a scientist looks like, and on that basis alone, we can say whether among this group of dharma practitioner, there is a scientist lost among us or not. So before we’re able to say that somebody isn’t here, a man isn’t here, first, we must know who this somebody is.
If we don’t know who this somebody is, we have no way of saying whether he is here or not. So it’s the same thing with this inherently existent I. We have to ask ourselves, has this inherently existent I come, is he here or not? Well, to know this, first we have to know what an inherently existent I looks like, otherwise we have no way of deciding whether it is here or not. Once we know exactly what it looks like, we can instantaneously decide whether he is here or not, whether he exists or not.
So therefore, we must proceed thus when we are analyzing this topic. We must first ask ourselves, if there were such a thing as an inherently existing I, what would it look like? What would it be like? And then on this basis, analyze carefully and draw the consequences of this premise. If there were such a thing as an inherently existing I, then this and this could be deduced from it.
Now, we analyze carefully, we will find that if there were such a thing as an inherently existing I, then such an I would be an I which existed from its own side, which which existed from its own power independently of any causes and conditions. On the other hand, if there is no such thing as an inherently existing I, if there is merely a dependently arising or a dependently existing I, then such an I would be an I which does not exist from its own side, which does not exist independently or of its own power. Now, these two notions of an I, an inherently existing I on the one hand, and a non inherently existing, dependently arising I on the other hand, are mutually incompatible. What we mean by this is if that, if an inherently existing I existed, then necessarily, a non inherently existing, dependently arising I would not exist. On the other hand, if a dependently existing, non inherently arising I existed, then necessarily an inherently existing I would not exist.
These two are mutually incompatible, they cannot exist simultaneously, they cannot coexist. And then if we analyze carefully, we will see that what exists, is this non inherently existent, dependently arising I. What does not exist is this inherently existing I. The non existence of this inherently existing I is what we call emptiness. Emptiness itself exists.
It’s an existing phenomenon. It is not a nonexistent phenomenon. So if we then analyze the I, we will find that our I is a dependent arising. It arises independence on causes and conditions. And when we meditate on this, we meditate thus, we take the royal reasoning, the royal syllogism, and we formulate it like this.
The subject I, it follows it is not an inherently existent phenomenon, because it is a dependent arising, as for instance, in the case of the a reflection in a mirror. This is a classical Indian syllogism. Now, if we analyze this syllogism, what we find is that it is very profound in the way it leads us to emptiness. Because through our understanding that I is a dependent arising, in other words, that the subject I arises independence on causes and conditions, the extreme of eternalism, the extreme of existence is immediately blocked. For through our understanding that I is or is not endowed with inherent existent, the other extreme is also blocked.
Therefore, this reasoning, the royal reasoning on emptiness, the royal reasoning on interdependence, excuse me, simultaneously prevents us from falling in both extremes, the extreme of eternalism and the extreme of nihilism and leads us on the middle road towards an understanding of emptiness, which is the fact that the I lacks even the slightest atom of existence from its own side. So the famous quote in the Heart sūtra, Moreover, all five aggregates are totally empty of nature, clearly indicates that this inherently nature inherently existing nature does not exist and is the object of refutation. This inherently existent nature is therefore what we refute in meditation. However, the quote in the Heart sūtra which states, form is empty, the objects of hearing are empty, sounds are empty, smells are empty, tastes are empty, and bodily sensations are empty, is a quote which has to be explained. This quote is not a quote which asserts literally that forms do not exist.
There is no intended trainee for which the statement forms do not exist would be of benefit. Instead, this quote, forms do not exist, sounds do not exist, objects of smell, etcetera do not exist, actually asserts that forms do not inherently exist, sounds do not inherently exist, smells do not inherently exist, etcetera. This is how this quote must be interpreted. Good. So then once we have identified clearly the object of negation and have posited a refutation of this object of negation, then it is on this that we must focus single pointedly our mind, and specifically the mind of Shine, we spoke about a while back, a couple days ago.
We basically use the mind of Shine, Shamatha. We use the mind of Shine, Shamatha, as a basis, And on this very firm basis, then the subject of emptiness is analyzed repeatedly by the wisdom which understands emptiness. Time and over again, it is analyzed in the context of Shamatha. And eventually, as we pursue this analysis, a great bliss of body and mind arise. The arising of this bliss of body and mind is a sign that we have realized the vipassana which analyzes emptiness.
And on the basis of this vipassana which analyzes emptiness on the foundation of Shine, then we can eliminate all of the afflictive emotions, we eliminate their consequences karma, and then we can attain liberation and full enlightenment. So then we must analyze repeatedly along these lines whether the I, the self exists inherently or not. And we must also beseech our gurus very powerfully for the blessings to realize this. To be quite frank, without the direct blessings of the guru, there is no such thing as the realization of emptiness. Our minds are so coarse, they are so dull, they are so stiff, they are hard like stones, and no realizations can dawn within our minds.
So again and again, we must beseech the Guru who is seen as indissociable with the Yidam, with our personal form, the personal form of the Buddha we practice most for their blessings. It is the case indeed that we could beseech all the Buddhas for their blessings, But in a sense, all the Buddhas are like space. They are infinite, but their blessings extend on all beings. Our Gurus act somewhat like a magnifying glass. Without a magnifying glass, the light of the sun can in no way set tinder alight, even though the overall heat of the sun is there.
With a magnifying glass, the light of the sun is concentrated in one point, and thanks to this, the tinder can be set aflame. Our Guru is akin to a magnifying glass. Another simile Rinpoche has given is the simile of crops. If the seed has been sown in the land, and conditions such as water and manure are present, but the sunlight which is the blessings of the spiritual teacher is not present, then because this sunlight which is the blessings of the spiritual teacher, which gives rise to warmth, the effectiveness of the blessings of a spiritual teacher, by its absence prevents the crops for which all other cooperative conditions are present from growing. So, Khensur Rinpoche would like to recount a small anecdote which will illustrate this point.
Of yore in Tibet, there was a very famous disciple of Atisha. His name was Dromtönpa. He was an emanation of the Buddha of compassion Avalokiteśvara. This disciple who was the closest disciple of Atisha once came to Atisha and said, oh Lord, I have a question. How is it that in Tibet, there are so many meditators, but not one has attained any realizations?
And Atisha looked at him and he laughed, and he said, you Tibetans, you meditate, but you do not see your teachers, your gurus as other than ordinary. You see them as perfectly ordinary, you do not see them as Buddhas. From where could the realizations come? This is a very essence of our practice, all the realizations of the Mahāyāna come through the blessings of the spiritual teacher. This is an oral transmission you just received.
Therefore, is said that if we beseech powerfully the Guru Yidam, the indissociable union of the Guru with whichever Yidam is one’s Yidam, it may be the glorious Yamāntaka, it may be Vajrayoginī, it may be Tārā, it may be, you know, Heruka, whichever Yidam we venerate. If we visualize the Guru Yidam as one and beseech for the blessings, most certainly we will receive them. There’s no such thing as a spiritual practice where the Yidam is elevated and the guru is pushed into the dust. No. Yes.
If you have any questions, we have very little time left, but you’re welcome to ask them, not more than five minutes. So the first question is, somebody’s relative had visions of deities during meditation and was wondering whether this was actual or not. But she says in general, if one has visions of Buddhas or Bodhisattvas such as Amitābha or Mañjuśrī meditation, this is very beneficial. As for visions of ordinary worldly deities, they have no power to be of ultimate benefit to us, and therefore these visions are totally irrelevant. The second question is a question about the refuge prayer.
When we recite in the refuge prayer, I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, the Sangha, by the merit I create, etcetera. These eyes, what eye do they refer to? So Rinpoche said, these eyes, I go for refuge, definitely exist. These are the conventional eyes, a conventional eye definitely exist, the reasonings on emptiness do not refute the conventional eye. This eye does not refer to the inherently existing eye, which does not exist.
As for the visualization to be adopted when one recites a refuge prayer, Rinpoche had entered into that yesterday, it’s a matter of seeing in front of oneself, you know, if possible the tree of refuge or the tree of accumulation of the collections. On this, we visualize Buddha Śākyamūni surrounded by the deities, and we imagine that Buddha Śākyamūni is indissociable from our teachers. Regarding the first question about the appearance of deities, Rinpoche says that Ārya Asaṇga, for instance, beseeched the glorious Maitreya repeatedly and eventually received a vision of Maitreya. Others have received vision of Tārā. This is very beneficial.
So we have completed this cycle of teachings. As you may know, six teachings were requested. They were only time to give four. But from your side, you put great effort in attending the teachings and listening well. And Rinpoche did his very best to explain clearly the matters which were to be taught.
And we have all accumulated during this process, virtuous karmic imprints, which we should dedicate for the well-being of His Holiness of Dalai Lama and all teachers, as well as for the well-being of all the monks in the monasteries. So you have all put great effort in listening to these teachings and Rinpoche would like to ask you to please practice what was taught. Otherwise, there will have been no benefit in these teachings. It is through practice that we can gain the various realizations which we should attain. So on behalf of Kopan Monastery, we would like to offer deep gratitude to Rinpoche for his great kindness in coming to the monastery to give this series of teachings.
Thank you very much, Rinpoche. Please rise to see Rinpoche off.
Key terms in this teaching
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- yidam ishtadevata (Skt)
- Literally, "mind-bound." One's own personal, main - or, as Lama Yeshe used to say, favorite - deity for tantric practice. The deity with which a practitioner has the strongest connection. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.