1 h 25 min · 10,282 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the four greatnesses of the Lamrim (stages of the path): that all teachings are consistent, that all scriptures can be taken as instructions, that the Buddha’s ultimate thought (the three fundamentals of renunciation, bodhichitta and correct view) can be discovered easily through the Lamrim, and that one avoids abandoning the Dharma. It then turns to the value of study and to showing respect to the Dharma and its teachers.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 25m
UUID: 90e9e476-41ae-4968-845d-1fc10256e377
Words: 10,278
The stages of the path to enlightenment. So you should make Bodhichitta motive and feel. I should achieve Buddhahood for the sake of most ancient beings. I shall therefore listen to these profound instructions on the stages of path to enlightenment and put them properly into practice. Only then should you listen.
What is the dharma you are about to hear? It is in Mahāyāna dharma, dharma that leads the fortunate to the level of Buddhahood. Today I shall teach the second of these headings. The greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instruction. Lamrim has four greatnesses and three features that distinguish it from the other great classical teachings.
The four greatnesses are as follows. The greatness of allowing you to realize that all the teachings are consistent. The greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions. The greatness of allowing you to easily discover the true thinking of the victorious one. The greatness of allowing you to save yourself from the worst misdeeds.
So which is it now we are talking about the four greatness of the Lamrim. The greatness of allowing you to realize that all the teachings are consistent, which is the first of the four greatnesses. The teachings here refer to the scriptures of the victorious one. As Bhāvaviveka’s commentary to the lamp of wisdom says, teachings mean the following, the scriptures of the Bhagavan that teaches our distortion to things God and humans wishing to gain the nectar like state should know, the things they should abandon, the things they should make manifest, and the things they should meditate upon. Realizing that all the teachings are consistent means that each person would put these teachings into practice in order to be enlightened.
To be consistent means to be harmonious. Hīnayāna, Hīnayāna, Vinaya, and Tantras, etcetera, seem to contradict each other from a literal point of view, but they are all either the main practice to take us to enlightenment or a by way leading to enlightenment. They are therefore consistent. Suppose you have come down with a high fever, initially your doctor will forbid you meat, alcohol, and so on. He tells you these could prove fatal for you if you don’t give them up.
But later, when the fever has passed, the crisis is over, and there is now excess of the wind humor, the doctor will instruct you to take meat, alcohol, etc. But only one person is being told these things. Now, only one person is being told these things. And there is only one person saying them. The two statements, the earlier one forbidding the meat and alcohol and the later one allowing them, seem to be inconsistent, but this is not so.
Both of them were meant to cure the one patient. You may similarly feel the Hīnayāna, Mahāyāna, the Sutras Tantras were tailored for particular disciples, so all of these teachings are not mandatory in one person’s practice in order to become enlightened. Again, this is not so. The speaker was telling the one person about the practices to enlightenment. When that person was at the level of the small and medium scope, the first explained the Hīnayāna basket of teachings.
That person was to meditate on things like impermanence and suffering. After some improvement, the person was now at the level of the great scope, so the Mahāyāna basket was explained. He now received explanations into bodhichitta, the six perfections, and so on. And when that person became a suitable vessel for the Tantras, the Buddhas explained the Vajrayana, two stages of the highest yoga Tantras, and the Tantric practices. And all these practices are appropriate for a person just you yourself to follow in order to be enlightened.
Hence, any one of the victorious one scriptures belongs to either the mainstream of the path or one of its byways. Not one of these scriptures is superfluous to a person’s practice leading to enlightenment. The main concern of a bodhisattva is to work for the sake of sentient beings. Thus, bodhisattvas must teach the three paths that will lead the three types of disciples, the Śrāvaka, Pratyekabuddha, and bodhisattva to their particular form of liberation. But unless bodhisattvas know these paths themselves, they cannot teach them to others.
Dharmakīrti says in his Pramāna Vartika Karika, the means to these ends are obscure. It is difficult to discuss them. The path leading to an understanding of the paths belonging to the three vehicles is something Bodhisattvas should develop in their mind streams in order to be sure different routes to achieve some benefit for others. It says in his sūtra, actually the middle length perfection of wisdom sūtra, also bodhisattva, in order to develop in all the paths, be it the path of the Śrāvaka, the path of the Buddha, or the path of the Bodhisattva. Bodhisattvas understand all the paths.
In we find those who would work for the sake of being should benefit the world by knowing the paths. Another point. The goal is Buddhahood, and this is a state possessing all good qualities. All faults have been eliminated. In order to achieve this state, the Mahāyāna path must cause all presence for it to come to an end and must bring every good quality into effect.
Since there is not a single scripture that does not eliminate some type of fault or cause some type of good quality to be developed, surely all the scriptures are to be included among the divisions of the Mahāyāna. Let us examine the question of scriptural consistency in more detail. There are two ways: how you should understand that all the transmitted teachings, that is the presentations of the subject matter, are consistent, and how you should understand that the realized teachings, that is the subject matter itself, are consistent. The three baskets of four classes of tantra and so forth go to make up the scriptures in their commentaries. And as I have already explained, they constitute a harmonious practice to take a person to his or her enlightenment.
This is how all transmitted teachings are to be understood as being consistent. The subject matter of these teachings can be included in the various topics of the three scopes. Small scope covers the causes to achieve the high rebirth states of the gods and humans. These causes are in fact the ethics of abandoning the 10 non virtues and so forth. The medium scope includes practices that will cause one to gain the definite excellence of liberation, such practices as abandoning the first two of the four truths, working towards the last two of these truths, and the practice of the three higher trainings, the great scope contains the practices that bring about the definite excellence of omniscience.
Such practices are development of bodhichitta, the six perfections, etc. Hence, all the subject matter forms a harmonious practice that will take a person to enlightenment and should be understood as being completely consistent. Domtönpa, one of the kings of the Dharma said, So the understanding we are trying to develop in Lamrim Buddha is the understanding of all of the teachings of the Buddha as teachings to be put into practice within the continuum of one person. Returning to the text, Domtönpa, one of the kings of the Dharma, said, my lama knows how to take all the teachings as the four corners of a four sided path. These are his exact words, but they have been interpreted in many ways.
The four corners are the three scopes with the tantra making the fourth. Or no matter how you throw one of a pair of dice, a square face would always come up. Similarly, each meditation topic includes a whole path within it. One could follow these interpretations. But my own precious guru, my refuge and protector told me, when you pull one of the four corners of a square mat, you move the whole mat.
Similarly, the subject matter. So Jambayang says all of these teachings are to be put in practice within the continuum of one being who is trying to eliminate suffering from his continuum. Returning to the text, when you pull one of the corners of a square mat, you move the whole mat. Similarly, the subject matter of a particular scripture plus its commentaries bores down to the practice that will enlighten a person. You are, as it were, tugging at one of the corners of this practice.
This is a very important interpretation. So we should endeavor to practice each one of these outlines as they are presented. The second of the four greatness is the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions. If you have not met with this system of the stages of the path through enlightenment, all the scriptures will not present themselves to you as instructions, but the supreme supreme instructions of the victorious one scriptures and the great classics that comment on these scriptures. There has never been in this world a better teacher than the Bhagavan, the transcendent fully accomplished destroyer of all defilements.
His scriptures are the best instructions of all. Maitreya’s sublime continuum of the great vehicle says, What scholar in this world is greater than the victorious one? With omniscience. With omissions, he knows Satya supreme and everything the others do not. So do not tamper with anything this sage puts in his own sutras because that would destroy Śākyamūni’s system.
It would harm the holy dharma. These days, no one regards the strict scriptures of the victorious one, for example, the kangyo, the translated word of Buddha, as something to be put into practice, only as something meant to be recited in ceremonies. People do study the classics of the two forerunners, Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, that comment on these scriptures, but only so that they can quote them in debate. Even the most learned of scholars, when about to So said that apart from the two wheels, which is a wheel of scriptural transmission and the wheel of realization, there is nothing else to practice. Returning to the text, people do study the classics of the two forerunners, Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, that comment on these scriptures, but only so that they can quote them in debate.
Even the most learned of scholars, when about to embark on some meditation practice, do not know how to integrate any of these texts into their practice despite their lifelong study and contemplation of them. They go to people who have the reputation of being great meditators but really know nothing. For they study some sadhana, how to observe the conscious working of the mind. Then they slavishly meditate on these things. Great Tsongkhapa had this to say, they have studied much, yet are poor in dharma.
Blame it on their not taking the scriptures as instructions. That is, it is damaging not to take the scriptures as being instructions. For example, there was a Geshe at our monastery who visited his homeland in Kham requested a Nyingma lama for practical instructions and then meditated in the lama’s brief instructions. Because of this, the local people claimed that Gelukpa dharma is definitely only for debate, never something to be practiced, and everyone ignored the Gelugpa teachings. I feel the Geshe set a bad example.
I find this most saddening. You must put into practice anything whose meaning you have determined through study or contemplation, and the meaning of whatever you practice should have been ascertained to study and contemplation. If you ascertain one thing through study and contemplation and then practice something else, it is like putting out a racetrack with someone and then using another piece of land for your horse race. The uses these very words. Perhaps they require some interpretation.
You’re about to hold a horse race and put out a particular place saying, this is going to be the racetrack tomorrow, yet on the actual day of the race, you hold it somewhere else. So if you’re unable to take the scriptures as instructions, it’s important that you have not comprehended the stages of the path to enlightenment. But with this comprehension comes the knowledge that all classical literature of the Victorious One scriptures, for example, can be included within the Lamrim framework, that they are things to be completely put into practice. Once he occupied the Ganden throne. After completing his monastic training, he received many instructions from a Lama teacher.
For instance, Tsongkhapa, three fundamentals of the path. He was introduced to the way to meditate on the thought contained in the entire body of sūtra and tantra. He later said he had come to understand that during his studies of the vast field of classical literature, he had in fact been studying the great stages of the path. This showed that the scriptures were for him instructions. When that great adept, Lofsan Namgyal, was given the oral transmission of the 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sūtra, the Aśtasāhasrikā Prajñāpāramitā sūtra, he remarked from time to time, If only I were not too old.
This is something I should meditate on. When you understand the Lamrim, all your debating practice in the monastery courtyard would also come under the Lamrim. You would take this debating practice as a form of meditation instruction. Suppose you were developing the you were debating the development of bodhichitta, you would instantly draw a comparison with the section of the great scope that deals with training the mind for bodhichitta, or you would compare a debate on the 12 independent links with a medium scope, or you would do the same with a debate on the dhyana concentration states of the form realm and the level of the formless realm, and compare these with a mental quiescent section of the lamrim. Even when reciting some dharma ritual, you should be able to integrate into the lamrim no matter from what scripture the recitation was taken.
You would even be able to do this readily when chancing on a page of a book left to rot in a wayside shrine. Once when I was very young, I saw a discarded page in a wayside shrine on Pabonka Monastery. The page was one of the songs by the seventh Dalai Lama, Kelzang Gyatso. The young being, the rhododendron, flies from brightly colored flower to flower. See how quickly it moves from one to the next.
Now my song explains this image. Many people in these degenerate times have impure minds and wallow in trivia. See how they are one moment friends and next enemies. I have not found a constant friend. In other words, I readily associated my experience of the shrine with a section in the medium scope dealing with saṃsāra’s pain of uncertainty.
Dromtönpa asked Rinchen Pelle, a great scholar, for the meaning of the word kadam, literally scripture instruction. Rinchen Pelle’s reply was: to have even a single letter from the scriptures appear to you as an instruction not to be ignored. This pleased so much He said in praise before giving a public teaching. Today, a scholar has extended my my thinking. It is as he said.
Therefore, all scriptures, even that discarded page in the wayside shrine, Make up the instructions that lead a person to enlightenment. This applies to you and your enlightenment. This is if Buddha and the other authors had given these scriptures especially for you. Such an attitude will give you utmost faith in all of them. As one yogi, Jangchopri Anshan, said, we are not told to find instructions for gaining enlightenment in some anthology of spells.
We should look upon all scriptures as instructions. We must think this way. These words strike at the very root, so taking all the scripture as instructions has much point to it. You might wonder, is it really enough to study just the Lamrim? The meaning of the scriptures and their commentary is contained within the Lamrim right from the section on relying on a spiritual guide to the mental quiescent section.
A particular lamrim may have an elaborate set of headings, and another set may be brief. Some of these headings require analytical meditation, while others demand fixation meditation. When you have mastered the framework of these headings, you will know which type of meditation to apply to each heading. With this understanding, you will readily associate any scripture you come across with the practice of a particular Lamrim meditation topic. This shows you are taking the scripture as instructions.
Here’s an easy analogy that my precious lama used to give. Suppose a person who has no store of rice, wheat, beans and so on happens to find a handful of rice, he will not know what to do with it and will probably just throw it away. So if you have not grasped the full structure of the path and chance in some scriptural text, you will not realize what you are to associate it with. You will not know how to put that scripture into practice. If you happen to have just one pound each of rice, wheat, and beans, and you acquire another handful of rice, you will happily add that rice to your food supply.
If you have a complete grasp of the framework of Lamrim meditation topics, you will readily associate any scripture at all with a particular Lamrim heading. Also note, there is a difference between the realization that all scripture is consistent and that of taking all scripture as instructions. Having the first does not necessarily mean you have the second, but if you have the second, you necessarily have the first. Greatness, the greatness of allowing you to easily discover the true thinking of the victorious one. The scriptures and their commentaries are, as I have already said, the best of instructions, yet you cannot discover the ultimate thoughts of the victorious one merely by referring to these great classics from your guru in the stages of the path to enlightenment, as a frame of reference, despite the fact that the subject matter of these classics embodies the victorious one’s ultimate thoughts.
In order to discover these thoughts, you must grapple with these texts for a long time. If you will depend on the Lamrim, you will easily discover them without such a struggle. So Khensur Rinpoche says that independence on the second outline, which is having all scriptures appear to one as instructions to practice, one is able then to engage in ornaments of the path from Guru Yoga all the way to the practice of compassion. If on the other hand one thinks that some teachings are high and some teachings are low, then it is a clear sign that to oneself, all scriptures have not risen as instructions. Every single aspect of Buddhist teachings is of benefit all the way from Vinaya up to tantra and depending on guru.
So to say that one aspect of the Buddhist teachings is not of benefit or meaningless for us is a clear indication that to us all scriptures have not arisen as old instructions. If this outline were absent, then a very important element of one’s practice would be missing. So to engage in the practice of Lamrim, it is absolutely essential to have this realization. Returning to our reading of the third greatness. Perhaps you are wondering what are these thoughts of victorious one.
My own precious guru, my refuge and protector, told me that in general they are taken to be the three scopes, but even more importantly they come down to the necessity of practicing the three fundamentals of the path. This is The great Tsongkhapa clarified the victorious one’s ultimate thoughts on the correct view in the three fundamentals of the path. Tsongkhapa said, the appearance of things are mutually interdependent is no illusion, But there are those who understand emptiness to be something devoid of this appearance. As long as these two seem separate to you, you will never realize the thought of the great one. Actually, is saying that you have not understood the thought of the victorious one unless you have realized the correct view, implying that it’s the strength of your realization of that view that enables you to finally hit on his thoughts.
In the same poem, Tsongkhapa says, the import of the essence of all the Victor scriptures. This refers to the fundamental of renunciation. He goes on to say, the path praised by the holy victors and their children. This refers to the fundamental of bodhichitta. Lastly, he says, the gateway for the fortunate wanting liberation.
This refers to the fundamental of the correct view. Thus, by implication, you still need the other two fundamentals, renunciation and bodhichitta. So when you depend on the Lamrim, you will easily discover that the subject matter of the great classic same at developing these three fundamentals in your mind stream. You will then have easily discovered the thought of the victorious one. Suppose the great classics were an ocean.
The thoughts of the victorious the three fundamentals of the path, for example, would be the jewels within that ocean. The is like the boat. The guru who teaches the is like the captain. So, Rinpoche is giving you the example of how we cook rice or barley. If you take rice or barley and want to cook it, it’s not just a matter of taking a handful of rice and barley.
We also need boiling water, salt and the requisite experience to cook rice or barley. Otherwise, just holding a handful of rice or barley will not lead us to our meal, which is what we brought. So it’s the same thing with Buddhist teachings. Every single one of Buddhist teachings is essential to the preparation of full enlightenment, which can be compared to a meal. We need the requisite amount of salt, requisite amount of boiling water, the requisite amount of rice or barley, and they must all be mixed in the correct way and in the correct sequence.
So likewise, we must endeavor to regenerate in our mind the realization that all the scriptures are like all instructions. And for instance, when we are meditating on the fact that all the composite phenomena are necessarily impermanent, we should use various scriptural quotes to ascertain this. And then gradually, by ascertaining each topic in its requisite sequence, then the various non virtues will be purified from our mind. It’s quite amusing, in which it says, see that some people have a lot of food and they don’t know what to do with it. On the other hand, in the monastery, we don’t have a lot of food, we have some other good cooks.
So they make the best with the limited amount they have. So even for an ordinary monk, a simple monk, if all the scriptures arise as instructions as all instructions, then he takes them in his mind and puts them in practice. And this is really the meaning of having the teachings arise as instructions. So Khensur Rinpoche points out that the text underlines the fact that if one has the realization that all scriptures are consistent, then one does not necessarily have the realization that all scriptures are instructions. But if we have the realization that all scriptures are instructions, we necessarily have the realization that all scriptures are consistent.
So we will stop here for today. Third of the fourth greatnesses of Lamrim. So, there are many points regarding this third transmission, which must be understood in the light of the divisions of the text. So third outline is under is the greatness which leads us to understand easily all the teachings of the Buddha as teachings to be put into practice. In other words, as oral instructions.
So the scriptures that I have are as I have always said the best of instructions. Now it is important in the scriptures of the Buddha to understand the ultimate thought of the victorious one as Rinpoche says. And searching for that ultimate thought is critical. So if we cannot find the ultimate thought of the victorious one in these scriptures, it’s a clear indication we have not realized the third greatness. I will now start reading directly as I’m just giving the oral transmission.
The scriptures and their commentaries are, as I have already said, the best of instructions. Yet, you cannot discover the ultimate thoughts of the victorious one merely by referring to those great classics or any instruction from your guru on the stages of the path of enlightenment as your frame of reference despite the fact that the subject matter of these classics embodies the victorious one’s ultimate thoughts. In order to discover these thoughts, you must grapple with these texts for a long time. If you depend on the Lamrim, you will easily discover them without such a struggle. Perhaps you are wondering, what are these thoughts of the victorious one?
My own precious guru, my refuge and protector told me that in general, they are taken to be the three scopes. But even more importantly, they come down to the necessity of practicing the three fundamentals of the path. Is this sure? Correct. Now Rinpoche says, as an oral commentary to this, that it’s important to generate an incontrovertible realization of the thought of the Buddha.
In other words, a realization which cannot be turned back, which will not change. Returning to the text, the great Tsongkhapa, clarified the victorious one’s ultimate thoughts on the correct view and the three fundamentals of the path, Je Tsongkhapa said. The appearance of things are mutually interdependent is no illusion. There are those who understand emptiness to be something devoid of this appearance. As long as these two seem separate to you, you will never realize the thoughts of the great one.
So said is it’s critical to get a realization of emptiness and specifically of the emptiness of the aggregates. Without this realization of the empty of the emptiness of the aggregates, we are not able to progress in our practice. Continuing with text, actually, this is saying that you have not understood the thought of the victorious one unless you have realized the correct view, implying that this is the strength of your real realization of that view that enables you to finally hit on his thoughts. So underlines how critical it is for our practice to have a clear realization of emptiness. Without this, we cannot understand the ultimate thought of a victorious one.
In the same poem, Tsongkhapa says, the importance of the essence of all the Victor scriptures, this refers to the fundamental of renunciation. He goes on to say, the path praised by the holy victors and their children, this refers to the fundamental of bodhichitta. Lastly, he says, the gateway for the fortunes wanting liberation, this refers to the fundamental of the correct view. Thus, by implication, you still need the other two fundamentals, renunciation and bodhichitta. So when you depend on the Lamrim, you would easily discover that the subject matter of the great classics aims at developing these three fundamentals in your mind screen.
You would then have easily discovered the thought of the victorious one. So number two, this is it says this is a clear statement of the three fundamentals of the path, which is renunciation, bodhichitta, and the view, which is wisdom, which realizes emptiness. So says that these passages and the three principles of the path, which teach explicitly the wisdom which realizes emptiness teach implicitly the renunciation and. And then points out that even the treatises on secret mantra teach implicitly both renunciation and bodhichitta. So to develop bodhichitta, we need to have developed a great compassion.
To develop great compassion, we must have developed renunciation. Without that realization of renunciation, none of these superior aspects of the past will arise in our mind stream. It’s only the basis on the realization of the suffering others undergo within cyclic existence that it is possible to generate compassion for them and the thought of renunciation, which in turn are the basis on which bodhichitta arises. So meditation on the suffering of that existence is a fundamental basis on which all of the other realizations such as the three aspects of the path will arise. So Rinpoche points out that it is impossible to desire to liberate others from suffering if we ourselves don’t want to be free from suffering.
And it’s impossible for ourselves to want to be free from suffering unless we have realized that we travel in existence after existence within a cycle of suffering. Without these three principles of the path, there is no practice of tantra. So continues independence on this practice of and specifically on its subject matter, the three principles of the path. It is possible to generate in our mind their realization easily. Continuing with the transmission of the text.
You will then have easily discovered the thought of the victorious one. Suppose the great classics were an ocean. The thoughts of the victorious one, the three fundamentals of the path, for example, would be the jewels in that ocean. The is like the boat. The guru teaches the lamrim is like the captain.
Although the ocean contains these jewels, you would only lose your life if you search for them without a boat. If you do not make similar use of the Lamrim, it will be difficult for you to discover the thought of the victorious one even though you consult these great treatises. You should depend on a guru, the skilful captain, get on board the boat, the Lamrim, and you will easily find the jewels in the classics, the ultimate thought of the victorious ones. So without an understanding of the, it is impossible to apprehend the thought of the victorious ones. Now the fourth greatness is a greatness to allow ourselves to save ourselves from the worst misdeeds.
Here, the great sages of the path and other texts explicitly teach that you should not do anything that will give you the karma and the resulting obscuration that goes with abandoning the dharma. But if you have not taken the first three of these four greatest to heart, you will forever be making petty distinctions that cause you to respect one part of the dharma more than another. Distinctions such as Mahāyāna versus Hīnayāna or theoretical dharma versus practical dharma. Abandoning some part of the dharma produces a continual stream of the direst type of karma. The obstructions that result are most serious.
The sūtra weaving everything together says, Mañjuśrī, the obstructions that result from the karma of abandoning the holy dharma are subtle. Mañjuśrī, one abandons the dharma when one considers some the to be good, some to be bad. Whoever abandons the Dharma also as a result disparages the. He also speaks badly of the Sangha. One abandons the Dharma when one claims this scripture is correct and this one is incorrect.
One abandoned the dharma by claiming this was taught for bodhisattvas or this was taught for shavakas. One abandoned the dharma by claiming this was taught for pratyeka buddhas. One abandoned the dharma by claiming this is not one of the things a bodhisattvas should train in. So discriminating between the teachings of the Buddha, Rinpoche says, is abandoning the dharma. Continuing with the transmission of the text, abandoning the dharma is an extremely dangerous action for as a king of single pointed concentration sūtra.
The Samādhi Rāja sūtra says, abandoning the sūtra basket is far heavier sin than destroying all the stupas in the Southern Continent. Abandoning the sūtra basket is a far heavier sin than killing as many ahats as there are grains of sand at the bottom of the Ganges. If you are convinced about the first three of these three great greatnesses, you will not ignore any of the Victor’s teachings. You will pay the same respect to all of them for their old things to be put into practice. So among these four greatnesses, Rinpoche says, are now talking of the three first.
Returning to the text, you would save yourself from holding some of the dharma to be good and some bad, the biggest contributing factor to abandoning the dharma. Also, if you think over the ways to devote yourself properly to your spiritual guide, you will rid yourself of any karmic obscurations you may have in relation to him or her. And when you become convinced about, for instance, the truth of the optimum human rebirth or impermanence, you will automatically cease doing misdeeds related to clinging to this life. It will stop your wayward behavior associated with self cherishing when you pursue the meditation topic on the development of bodhichitta. You then train in the meditation topic of selflessness, at which time you bring your your grasping at yourself to an end.
You automatically stop all your most wayward and undharmic behavior as a result of developing the realization of each of the Lamrim meditation topics. Returning to the text, let me give you an illustration to explain how these first three greatest promote your development. Suppose you are going to paint a religious picture. As you know, you must set up the right condition. You must have every single tool that will aid you in painting, a canvas, paints, brushes, etcetera.
This knowledge is analogous to the realization that all scripture is consistent. You must know how to paint, how to make use of these tools, just as you should take all the scriptures as pieces of instruction. And making a good job of the painting is similar to discovering with ease the thoughts of the victorious one. These four greatnesses are conventionally taken in two ways. The four greatnesses of the presentation, that is the actual words used, and the four greatnesses of the subject matter, that is the meaning of these words.
The scriptures themselves have the four associated with presentation. However, it is said to be more important that the person comes to have the four associated with the subject matter or the topic. So it is important to understand all branches of the scripture of the Buddha as being totally noncontradictory, and this can only be done in the light of Lamrim. Moreover, we should endeavor to take them all as instructions for our practice, and this is one of the four greatnesses we are discussing. So painting a tanka is taken here as an example of the way we should relate to the scriptures.
The tanka is our goal, which is full enlightenment, and the tools needed to produce it, all the various branches of scripture which we need to master. Is commenting the passage we have just read. So we have completed the third of the four greatnesses of Lamrim. Concluding with the text, this concludes the four greatnesses of Lamrim. And in addition to these four, three further features, the Lamrim is complete because it contains all the subject matter of sūtra and tantra.
It is easy to put into practice because it emphasizes the steps in taming the mind. It The is complete because it contains all the subject matter of sūtra and tantra. What is impossible for the to include all the actual words of the scriptures and commentaries, it does contain and teach all their key meanings. Even the smallest Lamrim text does this. The whole meaning of these scriptures and commentaries come under the three scopes of the Lamrim.
So Rinpoche gives you a commentary on this and says that the very essence of Buddhist teaching is a development of the mind of enlightenment. There is no other instruction apart from this. Everything else is subservient to the generation of bodhichitta. Everything acts as a substantial cause for the generation of bodhichitta. As to the different realizations, they are mainly formulated from the standpoint of nominal distinctions, but they are all tools which enable us to generate bodhichitta.
So when we talk of the concordant substantial cause for the attainment of full enlightenment, we are talking of liberation. But in this context, what is meant by liberation is actually omniscience, full enlightenment. Returning to the text, what is impossible for the to include all the actual words of the scriptures and commentary does contain and teach all their key meanings. Even the smallest text does is the whole meaning of these scriptures and commentaries come under the three telescopes of the Lamrim. The Lamrim includes and teaches the subject matter of the whole body of scriptures and commentaries.
Great Songkampas said the following in a letter to Lama Omapa. The instruction from Dipankara Srijan at the stages of the path through enlightenment seem to incorporate within its teachings all instructions concerning the scriptures and their commentaries. If one knows how to teach or study it, there not only seem to be a mixture of instructions for one’s practice, but also a synthesis of all scriptures. Therefore, I do not teach a long list of different types of discourses. The teachings of the other schools have various list of teachings.
The four great teachings of the preliminary practices are just taking refuge in, like, teachings of the main practices, etcetera. Even so, the original Kadampas and we knew Kadampas, the Gelukpas in other words, traditionally spent with such long list and teach everything according to the Lamrim. The Lamp on the Path, the Bodipattapadipa, teaches a synthesis of the entire subject matter of the scriptures within the space of three pages. All the other Lamrim texts similarly compress all this material because they take the lamp on the path as their root text. Points out that the root of all of the Lamrim text, which is composed, is Pandit Atisha’s Bodhipathapradīpa.
Returning the text, all the other Lamrim texts similarly compress all this material because they take the lamp on the path of their root text. Thus, Je Tsongkhapa said, it condenses the essence of all scriptures by teaching and studying this system even a short while. One gains the benefit of discussing and discussing all the holy dharma, contemplate its meaning for that is certain to be powerful. In other words, the study, contemplation, teaching, and receiving of a teaching on the Lamrim are study contemplation and learning about the full meaning of the scriptures and their commentaries. When you perform even a single sequence of retrospective meditations on the Lamrim, this meditative practice encompasses the meaning of the scriptures and commentaries.
Rinpoche is now giving the transmission of the quote from Geshe Tölungpa, the great Kadam figure. Geshe Tölungpa said, when I teach you the stages of the path to enlightenment, you gain a conceptual understanding of all the world’s books and volumes. All these books feel that gray haired old monk has plucked out our very hearts and shudder at the thought. So says it is as if the text of the very essence of everything which is written in this world. We take to the text. How true?
Because if a discourse on the Lamrim has gone well and the audience has been attentive, the essence of all the world’s books have been discussed in that discourse. Thus, on the one hand, the lamrim includes the meaning of all the scriptures within it. One on the other, it is a key to open up the scriptures. There could be no better summary of the dharma. So that is why Geshe Tölungpa said on the subject of teaching the Lamrim, I have butchered the great yak of the dharma.
People who think at the lower level may not understand the more elaborate labyrinth texts. They can still depend on a short text, for instance, one of the concise teachings that has a full Lamrim framework. The concise teaching is still able to lead them along the path. But if the text leaves out even one of the topics of meditation, it cannot lead anybody along the path. So is at the passage of text where said he butchered the great yak of the dharma, and he said it’s a very powerful and rather gruesome example.
But it really means that extracted all the parts of the yak in the same way one extracts all the parts of the dharma. So says it is absolutely essential to follow the outlines in their precise sequence to gain the respective realizations. Returning to the text, take the medicine for fever called camphor twenty-five. You do not need to go out and obtain a bulky package of each of its 25 ingredients, and then take them individually as long as the medicine has been compounded properly. With all the 25, it’ll quickly bring down the fever.
But even if one of the ingredients is missing, the medicine will not rid you the fever no matter how much of it you take. Now that you have been fortunate enough to meet with this royal instruction, ought to specialize in it. Now the second characteristic of the three characteristics we are studying at present is that lamrim is easy to put into practice because it emphasizes the steps for taming the mind. We have undergone the many varied sufferings of saṃsāra, and we have gained the highest bliss saṃsāra has to offer. Our own minds are responsible for these things.
Nothing is said to be better than the Lamrim for taming the mind. So says that all of the realms we see around us, the world we see of us, they’re merely the product of the erroneous mind within us. Should we desire to live in a different environment, we merely have to change our minds. Returning to the text, nothing is said to be better than the lamrim for taming the mind. The lamrim plays a great emphasis on the means for achieving this.
The lamrim is therefore easy to put into practice. So to practice the Dharma, Rinpoche says, it’s important to practice the Dharma and to have access to the Dharma. To have access to the Dharma, we must find a spiritual friend and rely on him. Then relying on him, we engage in the practice of all the stages, and we’ll achieve the requisite realizations. Now the third characteristic, Lamrim is superior to the other traditions because it contains instructions from two gurus who were schooled in the tradition of the two forerunners.
The guru who belonged to Nāgārjuna school was Vidyakokila. Guru Suvarnadwipa belonged to Asaṇga school. This teaching is enriched by their instructions, therefore superior superior to all other traditions. As said, the stages of the path to enlightenment stem from Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, the crest jewels of the world scholar whose fame among beings stand out like a banner. Not even Maitreya’s Abhisamayalankara has these three features.
Even the king of tantras, the Guhyasamāja Tantra, does not have them. These two texts do not contain all the subject matter of sūtra and tantra, nor do they emphasize the taming of the mind. Now that you are fortunate enough to study, contemplate, and meditate on this Lamrim with these greatnesses and features, you should not be satisfied with incomplete or speechless instructions. It is vital for you to put the utmost effort into this past. So we have completed the second major heading, the greatness of the dharma.
So of the four major characteristics of the great the Dharma, we have finished the two first ones, Rinpoche says. So we’re now at the third of these headings. The right way to teach and listen to the dharma that has these two greatnesses. This is the most important heading. Naktso Lotsawa, a great meditator, said, the best preliminary instruction is on the right way to teach and listen.
Cherish it. In other words, this heading will determine whether the following teachings will have any effect on your mind stream. It will be difficult for you to translate my teaching into contemplation and meditation if you get this heading wrong. He says you would be wrong about all the topics until the fifteenth day of the lunar month. If you took the wrong topic, it’d be like missing the first day of the lunar month.
Points out that to listen, we must first set a strong and clear motivation. The way to listen to dharma. There are three headings at this point, the way to listen to dharma, the way to teach dharma, and what things a disciple and teacher should do together at the end. Regarding the way to listen to dharma, there are three subheadings, contemplating the benefits of studying the dharma, how to show respect for the dharma and its teacher, the actual way to listen to it. So returning to the transmission of the text, contemplating the benefits of studying the dharma, it is vital to contemplate first the benefits of studying the dharma because only then will you develop the strong desire to study it.
So Rinpoche says, when we are talking of hearing, what do we mean? We actually mean to enjoy what we listen and to generate a strong aspiration to listen to it. This is the way we can actually benefit from the teachings. We don’t meant mean by listening just to attend to a teaching and use our ear consciousness. It is vital to contemplate first the benefits of studying the dharma because only then when you develop the strong desire to study it, if the contemplation is done properly, you will be extremely happy to embark on such a study.
In the saying of the Buddha, we find, owing to your study, you understand dharma, owing to your study, you stop sinning, owing to your study, you abandon the meaningless, owing to your study, you achieve nirvana. In other words, by virtue of your study you will know all the key points for modifying your behavior. You will understand the meaning of the Vinaya basket and as a result will stop sinning by following the high training of ethics. You will understand the meaning of the sūtra basket that as a result you will come to abandon such meaningless things as trivial distractions by thought of the high training and single point of concentration. And you will understand the meaning of the Abhidhamma basket and so come to abandon delusions by means of the high training and wisdom.
Hence your study will enable you to reach nirvana. In the Jātaka, it said study is a lamp to dispel the darkness of benightedness. It’s a best of possession. Seas cannot rob you of it. It is a weapon to defeat your enemy, your blindness to all things.
It is your best friend who instructs you on the means, say relative, who will not desert you when you are poor. It’s a medicine against sorrow that does you no harm. It’s the best task force to dispatch against your misdeeds. It is a supreme fund of fame and glory. You could have no better talent.
When meeting gifted people, you would impress the scholars in any assembly. So in relation to these hearing these teachings, Impraji says, we should then generate bodhichitta and use that to attain full enlightenment. Returning to the text, study is like a lamp to dispel the darkness of ignorance. My own precious guru told me that when you know only one letter of the alphabet, you have rid yourself of darkness concerning it. You have added your stock of wisdom.
So when you know the other letters, you have dispelled your ignorance about them too, and that even more to your wisdom. Without any study, we would not be able to recognize the letter r even if if it was as large as a donkey’s head. We would just have to shake our head in bewilderment. Just think about the people in your family who know nothing at all, and you will understand my point. So Rinpoche is now giving the oral transmission of the passage from the Jatakas, which we read earlier.
So commenting on the example of the ignorant person versus a person who knows a letter of Ka in Tibetan says, among two people, an only person and a monk, the monk is superior. Likewise, among two people, one who does not know to read or write and the one who knows the alphabet, The one who knows the alphabet is superior. Returning to the text, the amount of ignorance we manage to rid ourselves of similarly depends on how much study we have done. The light of our wisdom has grown proportionately. In the sayings of the Buddha, we find, though a person may be most familiar with the house, he will not see any visual form on a pitch black room despite his eyes, likewise, the disciple may be discerning it under his studies.
He will not know sin from virtue. When a person with sight has a lamp with him, he will see visual forms. So too, through study, a person will know virtue from sin. In other words, you cannot see anything in a completely dark room even though you may be surrounded by many things to see and despite having your eyes wide open. Similarly, you might have the eye of wisdom, but without the lamp of study, you will know nothing of points required for modifying your behavior.
If you light a lamp in the darkened room, you will be able to see all the things inside it vividly. Thus, with the lamp of study and the eye of wisdom, you can come to understand all phenomenon. Our Bodhisattva Bumi talks in some detail about these benefits and how one should listen to teachings with five attitudes. The first attitude is to regard the teaching as an eye by means of which we will develop more and more wisdom. Then we should regard the teaching as light by means of which as wisdom eyes sees relative and ultimate truth.
We should regard the teachings as something precious that occurs, but rarely in the world. We should regard the teaching as something most beneficial, and so that we will obtain the fruit enjoyed by great bodhisattvas. Lastly, we should regard the teachings as something completely unprohibited because it will enable us to achieve mental quiescence and special insight. Our studies are also the supreme possession that no one can take from us. Thieves can carry off our worldly goods, but they cannot possibly take from us the seven jewels of the Aryans, that is our studies, etcetera, nor the goods, qualities of scholarship, ethics, kind heartedness, etcetera.
Even at the best of times, our worldly goods give us many headaches. For example, when we go back to our birthplace, which of our possessions do we take along with us on the journey? Our studies are not like this. We can even take them with us when we die. So they say it is most important that we simple monks should not long for fancy trunks decorated with brass hoops or for copper pots and so on.
We should long for the seven jewels of the Aryans. So says this is very true. At the time of death, dharma is the only thing we can take with us. Returning to the text, study is like a weapon to overcome your enemy and your blindness. Through study, you will destroy all your delusions, your real enemy.
Study is also your best friend who will never give you wrong advice. Your former studies will advise you about any particular action, whether this is the right time to do it, how to do it if the time is right, how to prevent the action if the time is wrong, its benefits, draw backs, etcetera. My own precious guru told me, while Lama Yeshe was in prison, he became more and more determined. This was because of the advice he received from his companion, his former studies. Study is also a relative which will never forsake us.
In hard times, ordinary relatives pretend to be our friends when we are well off. When times are bad, they pretend not to recognize us. But study is the best of relatives, where ‘ll it be particularly helpful to us when times are bad, that we undergo suffering, illness, death, etcetera. The great became tutor to one of the Dalai Lama’s. However, there was a time when he was poor.
He met an uncle of his on the road who was going off to do some trading. Rinpoche said something to him, but the uncle spoke as if he did not recognize Nirinpoche. After Nirinpoche became the Dalai Lama’s tutor and occupied one of the highest positions of authority, the uncle went to see him and told Rinpoche that he was his uncle. Returning to the text, once there was a man who started out poor. Nobody claimed to be his relative.
Then he made a little money from trading, and many paid people later came and claimed the kinship with him. He summoned them to have lunch with him. He placed piles of money at the head of the table, then he recited the following verse where he prostrated himself before the money. A man who was not my uncle became my uncle. Oh, lovely piles of money.
I pay homage to you. In other words, you cannot trust even your ordinary relatives. So remember, he thinks this is really quite hilarious. So if we must seek out long lost relatives, why not seek out study, contemplation, and meditation? By the way, in the last line of the last line of the above verse reads, for my meal ticket, I pay homage to you.
But the version I gave is exactly how my own precious guru used to tell this story. Study is also a medicine for delusion and an army to dispatch against non virtue. It is also the best store of fame and glory, the best reward obtained from holy beings, the best way to gain the respect of scholars. The Jatakas also tell us, whoever has studied will develop faith. He will be steadfast and will delight in the excellent.
He will develop wisdom, have no ignorance. It is right even to sell one’s flesh to obtain it. In other words, study has infinite good qualities. You will develop faith in the good qualities of the three jewels through your study. You will then work hard at making offerings to the Buddhism and so forth.
Also, because of our belief in the fixed laws of karma, we will be happy to modify our behavior and so on. We will come to understand the faults of the first two of the four truths, suffering and the origin of suffering, and the qualities of the last of the two truths, cessation and the path. Thus, we’ll forever be working towards our final goal, Buddhahood. We are told it is right to cut off one’s own flesh and set for the sake of one’s studies. But now that we can study in comfort without having to mutilate our body, we ought to study as best we can.
The above verse was given to the bodhisattva, Chandraprabha Kumara, one of Śākyamūni’s former lives, after he had hammered 1,000 nails into his own body for each line in the verse. The depth of our studies determines how many times we have to contemplate. This number determines how soon we will develop insight through our meditations and, in turn, how we will come to have wisdom. Young people ought to study the five standard debate subjects when they enter one of the great monasteries. There is a huge difference between those who have studied and those who have not, even in the things they recognize to be the three jewels.
So this passage says, that we should really study carefully, the texts we study in the great monasteries. Returning to the text, you may have some children to look after. If you yourselves have read a little, you should not bring them up to be the same as you. Make them study. And in your next life, you too will develop as much wisdom as they would in this life.
The old, the dull witted, and so on may want to study the great classics, but death will come and interrupt their studies before they have rid themselves of their misconceptions. Such people are therefore incapable of completing a great amount of study. But if they study something like the Lambrim, they gain some understanding of the whole path. Je Tsongkhapa once told the Pänchen Lama of Sangye Gyatso in a dream. In order to benefit yourself and others, never be satisfied with your studies.
Observe Bodhisattvas on the third bhūmi. They are dissatisfied with their amount of study. We should do as he says. Points out. He’s giving the quote on this passage on the Triple Gem that people who have not studied actually don’t understand what the Triple Gem is.
It’s only through careful study that one understands what is actually the object of refuge. Returning to the text, no matter on how lower level people think, surely they have some time they could devote to studying, a concise text on the Lamrim, for instance. How could they possibly not know how to carry out such a study? How could they live a life that has such a small share of dharma? How could they claim we are not bookish types?
Why, even horses, cars, and sheep know how to get their fair share all by themselves. You must study at your own intellectual level. But whatever you study, be it a brief text or an elaborate one, it must contain the whole range of meditation topics starting with depending on your spiritual guide and ending at the unification of the no-more-learner. So Rinpoche says, if our learning in minds are vast, then we should study the great treatises. But otherwise, we should study whatever is at our level.
It is a great shame to say, I can’t do anything. Returning to the text, if a text is incomplete, it will not have the full range of meditation topics. Even its having great detail on some of these topics will not compensate for this lack. It will be like having a 100 carpets in your room, but no clothes to wear, like having a 100 things to wear and no carpets. If the text is complete, it will lead you along the path regardless of the amount of detail it has to offer in the same way that both a huge room of minister of state and amongst each serves its own purpose.
They have oodles of stuff in their rooms or house, but the one thing they don’t have are texts to study. So the one thing which is really important in our practice is the development of the great compassion, and everything else is really quite secondary. This is what we should focus upon. So says those who engage in extensive study and extensive hearing will indeed meet will indeed need strong karmic imprints. If these imprints are not present in this life, then we should prepare them for future lives.
So the people who cannot make any progress in their study of the great classics of the Tibetan language in this life are people with weak imprints. These karmic imprints must be strengthened. They must plant them in this life for future lives. So now we are at the outline. How to show respect for the Dharma and its teachers?
The sūtra of Akhiti Gama says, listen to the dharma with faith and respect. Do not mock or disparage its teachers. Make offerings to teachers of the dharma. Develop the attitude that they are Buddha’s equal. We must pay the same respect to the teachers of the dharma when we listen to their teachings as we would to our teacher Buddha himself.
Asaṇga’s Bodhisattva Bhumi say that when we listen quite free of delusions, the mind are distracted by the five things explained below. We should also be free of pride. There’s further mention of six things that we should be should be present where we listen. The right time, deference, respect, a lack of anger, the fact that we relate to put the teachings into practice, and not picking fault in the teachings. Let us take the first of these the right time.
The guru must give if he feels happy to do so, if he has no other chores to perform. So we would not request to listen to his teaching whenever it suits us as this would be most presumptuous and selfish. Geshe Potawa was once staying in Kadang Monastery in the uplands of the central province, editing many scriptural texts and was very frustrated. A man came to him and requested teachings. Geshe Potawa stood up and adopting a rather wrathful manner drove the man away.
The man beat a hasty retreat, which only goes to show that we should be skilled in our timing. So Rinpoche says that in this respect, time is of the very essence, so it’s a sign of respect for the teacher. One shows deference through prostration.
Key terms in this teaching
- bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
- Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
- dhyana samten (Tib)
- An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Kadam
- The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Atisha, Dromtönpa and their followers, the "Kadampa geshes"; the forerunner of the Gelug School. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
- The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.