1 h 39 min · 4,895 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the Four Noble Truths, focusing on the truth of suffering. It distinguishes three levels of suffering: suffering of misery, suffering of change, and pervasive conditioned suffering, which is the contaminated five aggregates. It shows how the true origins, karma and afflictive emotions rooted in self-grasping, can be abandoned through realizing selflessness, leading to true cessation and true paths. The aim is to generate a longing for liberation. A brief question session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 39m
UUID: 71f62316-2fff-474e-bba1-551736021ed1
Words: 4,891
So in their actual order of development or generation, the true sources of sufferings come first. But the Buddha taught the result first, first as a teaching device of practice. He first taught true sufferings and that we are to recognize these and then go on to look to what is the source of the suffering, true origins of suffering which are to be abandoned. So, you know, we are continually experiencing suffering, either mental or physical, every day of our lives. Again and again, various types of suffering are continually arising for ourselves.
Moreover, we simply don’t want to suffer, we don’t like suffering. And so we should question exactly, well, in terms of our suffering, can we get rid of it? Does it have a cause or does it come about by itself? We need to investigate what is the source of my suffering. If we think in this way, then we’ll be led to search out the roots of our suffering.
Where is it actually coming from? The fact is we don’t want to suffer it. And if we can trace it back to a cause, then we can begin to understand, we can begin to question, Well, since I don’t want to suffer and my suffering has a cause, if I get rid of that cause, then I won’t have this result of suffering any longer. Can I actually get rid of that cause? Is it possible to get rid of that cause or not?
So it is in this way that we are led from first an appreciation of our suffering, having recognized the truth of our suffering, to beginning to seek out its roots of suffering in terms of the origins of suffering. So this is the reason that the Buddha presented these two pairs in this manner. First, we recognize the actual nature of our experience in terms of suffering, then beginning to question and seeking now its causes, where is the root of our suffering. It seems as if Buddhism goes on a great deal about suffering, all of these teachings on suffering, but there is a purpose to these extensive discussions on suffering. They all are solely to help us to generate a longing, the longing which strives to be liberated.
We don’t like to hear about suffering. It doesn’t make us happy, but it is necessary to reflect upon our suffering if we are ever to develop a longing to be free from our suffering. If we have to understand the nature of suffering, the nature of cyclic existence, if we don’t we will never generate the longing which strives to be free from cyclic existence, which strives to be free completely from our suffering. So this is a very important point. So some some who do not understand the nature of suffering or the nature of cyclic existence would say that Buddhism is completely caught up in suffering, that all they do is talk about suffering.
In Buddhism there is nothing but suffering. This shows a lack of understanding of the nature of suffering and the nature of what Buddhism is trying to achieve. All phenomena which are contaminated, that is to say arise under the force of karma and affective emotions, yes, they are in the nature of suffering, but all phenomena are not contaminated. Buddhism places great emphasis on the fact of liberation and omniscience, where there is no suffering whatsoever. Is uncontaminated phenomena in the nature of non suffering, of bliss.
And this is emphasized a great deal in these teachings. So the emphasis is necessary to talk about the nature of contaminated phenomena, phenomena which arise under the force of karma and afflictive emotions in order to understand what the nature of uncontaminated phenomena are and thereby to develop a longing to experience them. So we don’t like to suffer. A very foundation, we don’t want to suffer. We have to strengthen that dislike for suffering and appreciate the nature of suffering If we are ever to develop a longing to be free completely from our suffering, we have to reflect upon the nature of suffering and out of that, that dislike for suffering in general, will develop a longing to be free from suffering, a longing to be liberated from our suffering.
We will implement the means to abandon that suffering. So everybody here, ordinary people in the world, they know what suffering is. We all experience suffering. We all can understand suffering. We all have headaches, toothaches, stomachaches.
Humans know suffering, but even animals are able to know suffering. If they’re out in the sun, they begin to experience the heat of the sun and they know enough to get out of the sun and get in the shade. So it’s no great accomplishment simply to know what suffering is. So even animals when they experience the pain of thirst, they know enough to drink water. When they experience the pain of hunger, they know enough to eat.
But so we most it’s not unusual for people to be able to understand the suffering of misery or the suffering of suffering. But there are two further levels of suffering which it is rare for individuals to understand. And these levels are called the suffering of change, but maybe the suffering of alternation. The second is usually translated as the suffering of pervasive compounded suffering. Maybe we could translate it as the suffering of universal conditionality.
So, we all have the experience of if we’re hot and thirsty and we drink some cool water, we experience a pleasure. Moreover, if we’re hungry and we eat some food, experience a pleasure. If we’re cold and we put on some more clothes, we experience the pleasure. So we’ve all experienced this and we all are aware of this pleasure that comes in this way. But in terms of the all of these pleasures which are being described are all examples of the suffering of alternation.
But we have to see whether these various pleasures that we experience in these ways really fully qualified pleasures. And when we eat some delicious food, initially we experience pleasure. But if we were to continue eating, eventually that pleasure would turn into pain. We would get a stomachache. So that pleasure quickly changes into pain.
It’s not fully qualified stable pleasure. Another example, you know, if we were extremely hot and we like being being burnt by the sun, we go into maybe an air conditioned room. And initially we experience a pleasure, but after some time it gets to be a bit chilly and a bit cold and becomes uncomfortable. Now, initially, when we were experiencing the suffering of heat, that next moment when we walked into the air conditioned room, what appeared to be pleasure was actually the first moment of the suffering of cold. So it’s just a matter of the fluctuation in the temperature When it’s balanced toward the heat side, one experiences the heat.
When the balance is shifted toward the cold side, one begins to experience comparatively the suffering. Comparatively it appears to be pleasure but one is actually beginning to initially experience the suffering of cold. So the same holds true, for example, if we go out walking and initially it feels pretty good to go out walking. But if we keep on walking and walking and we keep having to stand up, eventually it gets to be rather tiring and develops into an experience of suffering. And so we thought, well, I’ll sit down.
One is experiencing the suffering of standing and then one sits down, that cuts off the suffering of standing. That cutting away of the suffering of standing is comparatively experienced as pleasure. But what appears to be pleasure is in fact the beginning of the suffering of sitting. As we continue to sit there, your legs begin to hurt, your back begins to hurt, simply cannot continue to sit indefinitely because the suffering of sitting begins to become more and more apparent. Once, Oh, I can’t sit here anymore.
I’ve got to get up. My back’s hurting. So you get up, and the suffering of sitting has come to an end. And now the beginning of the suffering of standing has begun. So, the point is that these pleasures, these apparent pleasures, aren’t fully qualified pleasures.
They simply aren’t stable pleasures. We that though we think of them as very good, if we examine them, we can see that even in an instant they can change into their counterpart of some type of suffering. Then finally there is this third level of suffering which is termed conditionality or generally translated as the suffering of pervasive compounded suffering. And this is a type of suffering which is pervasive. It is universal.
Moreover, it is this suffering which is most important to be recognized. It is in terms of recognizing this level of suffering that we will actually develop a fully qualified longing which strives to find liberation, we will seek to free ourselves from cycle existence. Merely recognizing these former two levels of suffering, the suffering of misery and the suffering of alternation, is not sufficient in order to develop this fully qualified longing to be free from cycle existence. It is necessary to recognize this level of suffering. So in general, when we talk about true sufferings, we are talking about all of those compounded phenomena which arise under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions.
So anything which has as its cause karma and afflictive emotions, and here by karma, we mean actions, contaminated actions. Anything which has those as a cause is a true suffering. So this term that we usually translate these four truths, we usually say the four noble truths. In a way, it’s more correct to translate it as the four truths of the nobles or the four truths of superiors. A superior is, or let us say, an ārya.
A superior is someone who has directly realized emptiness. And so those who have directly realized emptiness see that any phenomena which has as its cause karma and afflictive emotions is in the nature of suffering. And this is the truth for them. So these are truths for superiors. So any phenomena which has arisen under the force of karma and afflictive emotions is a true suffering.
And this is true for a superior. So this is why it’s termed a true suffering for a superior or the first of the noble or superior’s truths, true sufferings. So there are great varieties of sufferings and a way of categorizing sufferings that we can subsume them into these three types: the suffering of misery, the suffering of alternation, and the suffering of universal conditionality. And we’ve explained these first two, and now it’s necessary to recognize this third level of suffering. So a line from Dharmakīrti’s Companion of Valid Cognition, he says that aggregates are the conditions for the suffering of cyclic existence, are the cooperative conditions for the suffering of cyclic existence.
In the course of this explanation, maybe some of you will get scared. But anyway, what do we mean by aggregates? They are termed the contaminated appropriate aggregates. We’re talking about your own aggregates. That is the aggregates we have taken, that we have appropriated.
Those aggregates are the suffering of universal conditionality themselves. They are cyclic existence. So do you really dislike the suffering of universal conditionality or not once you’ve heard what it is? Do you really dislike it? So you know, in this discussion of the suffering of universal conditionality and we say it is equivalent to the contaminated five aggregates, we have to think of them in our terms.
We’re talking about each of our own aggregates. It’s not somebody else’s aggregates, but our own aggregates. In the Heart sūtra there’s the line that we recite where it says, Looking perfectly and correctly at the emptiness of inherent existence of the five aggregates. So that he wasn’t looking at somebody else’s aggregates, he was looking at his own aggregates, his own five aggregates. And so again, in this discussion, we are talking about each of our own five aggregates, not something else.
So the five aggregates. The first aggregate is the aggregate of forms. And what we mean most simply by this is the body, the physical body, the aggregate of forms. That’s the first aggregate. And the second aggregate is the aggregate of feelings.
And these are the various feelings that we experience, Pleasurable feelings, unpleasurable feelings, neutral feelings. These are aggregate of feelings. Then there’s the aggregate of perceptions. Sometimes it’s translated as recognition, sometimes as discrimination. The aggregate of perceptions is a type of thinking which, you know, is a human, looking around, this is a God, this is a table, this is a cup.
So that which does that type of thinking within our mind, that is called the aggregate of perceptions. Then there is the aggregate of consciousnesses, the states of the mind which is both positive and negative. And then Everything other than that in terms of our mind is called the aggregate of compositional factors. This is the various secondary mental factors, for example, you know, wisdom, faith, all of these emotional states. These are secondary mental, various secondary mental factors are all collected together in the aggregate of compositional factors.
So the five aggregates are what are taken. When we take rebirth, what we do is we take these five These are the base which is taken. That which is doing the taking is the I. The I is that which takes rebirth. It takes and the way it does this is by taking the five aggregates.
It’s like the room. A room is like the five aggregates and the person staying in the room is like the I residing within the five aggregates. So having taken the five aggregates of a human, then we are a person. We are like a person abiding within a room. So this holds true for all the possible types of aggregates that we could take, that we could assume.
If we take the five aggregates of an animal, it is the aggregates of an animal which are taken and it is the I which is doing the taking. This holds true for the aggregates of a dog or a cat or a horse, but also for the aggregates of a hell being, the aggregates of a hungry ghost, whatsoever. It is the being which is the taker of these five aggregates and that being as an I resides within these five aggregates which have been assumed. The I depends upon these five aggregates. Our experiences are related to the types of aggregates that we take.
We have all taken, our eye has taken human aggregates. Independence upon that, we experience the suffering of a human being. If to we take rebirth as an animal, that is say if we were to take an animal aggregate, then we would experience a corresponding suffering of animals. If we were to take the aggregates of a hell being, then that I, which is assuming or taking these aggregates, be, that I would be a hell being and would experience the sufferings of a hell being. Presently we don’t suffer, we don’t experience the suffering of an animal because we have not taken at present the aggregates of an animal.
Presently we aren’t experiencing the pleasures of a celestial being because we haven’t taken presently the aggregates of a celestial being. So one experiences, there is a corresponding experience of whatever types of aggregates that this eye assumes, takes on. So the eye the eye goes experiences, through experiences and corresponding to the aggregates which it has taken. So we have to look at what our aggregates are actually undergoing. And whatever those aggregates are undergoing, the I, which has taken those aggregates, will be experiencing.
So first we experience the sufferings of rebirth, the sufferings of taking birth. But then even having, but things don’t change, things don’t stand still. Things are constantly changing, things are impermanent. So we go through a process of aging and the process, the sufferings involved in the aging process. And then the aggregates undergo a variety of sicknesses.
There are many types of illnesses and diseases which the aggregates go through. Therefore, it is the I which goes through that suffering of these various sicknesses. And then eventually the power of these aggregates begins to fade. We find difficulty in getting up and sitting down. It becomes difficult to enjoy all the delicious types of food that we used to eat.
Our eyesight begins to fail, our hearing begins to fail. So all of these faults begin to we can’t sleep well. So we can begin to appreciate all of the various sufferings which our aggregates are going through, and therefore the eye experiences. The aggregates that we’re speaking of are the contaminated appropriated aggregates. They’re contaminated aggregates.
And these particular types of aggregates act like the basis upon which this is the basis in which all of these events are occurring. The eye having taken these aggregates necessarily goes to a corresponding experience of various suffering. So it is this very basis, these aggregates, which are the conditionality, the suffering of universal conditionality, or pervasive compounded suffering. It is these aggregates themselves that they are in the nature of suffering. They are the root source of all suffering.
These aggregates are the mother of suffering. So if we begin to appreciate how all our suffering arises in dependence upon these aggregates, and that it is in the taking of these aggregates that ourselves as the I must go through the various experiences of suffering, correspond to the experiences of the aggregates, then there will rise the thought, I don’t want to take these types of aggregates. If I could be free of having to take these aggregates again, then I wouldn’t have to go through all of these experiences which the aggregates necessarily have to undergo. I would be free of all of those experiences. Having seen all the faults of such types of aggregates in terms of the suffering experiences, one develops a longing to not have to take these types of aggregates again, to be free of having to take these aggregates again.
So, in beginning to recognize that it is these aggregates which are the source of our suffering, then we will develop a longing to be free from aggregates. But what is the means by which we can free ourselves from the aggregates? How do we go about not taking rebirth into such types of aggregates? So it’s necessary that we first understand suffering, that we recognize the truth of suffering. This was what the Buddha taught first, in terms of the truth of suffering.
He pointed to his aggregates and he said, These are true sufferings. He meant by that that they are the suffering of universal conditionality, thereby they are the root of all suffering. And that if we want to eliminate our suffering, we have to find some means whereby not to take such types of again. So looking to the cause of taking such types of aggregates, what forces us to take such types of aggregates, if we go on to examine, we will see that it is the afflictive emotions and karma, and therefore we’re led to the second of these four truths, the true sources or true origins of suffering. We look to the causes of our suffering, and we are to abandon these causes of suffering.
The first truth is the truth of suffering, which we are to recognize. The second truth, which is we are to abandon. We don’t have much time to really go into the meaning of suffering, but if it were to be explained in the truth of suffering to be explained extensively, it would be explained how the Buddha Śākyamūni taught it. He said the truth of suffering had four characteristics: impermanence, suffering, emptiness, and selflessness. And this would be the method of beginning to recognize the nature of suffering.
So again, with regard to the cause of suffering are true sources. So again, if we were to go into true sources in detail, there are four characteristics of true sources of suffering. Is cause, origin, condition, and extremely forceful. So in terms of true sources of suffering, we are speaking mainly of the afflictive emotions and karma. And even between those two, karma arises out of afflictive emotions, so we are mainly speaking about afflictive emotions.
And what is the root of all afflictive emotions? It is the ignorance, which is self grasping. So this comes down to the root of all of our suffering, self grasping. Then we have to examine, can this self grasping, can it be abandoned or not? Well, we can abandon self grasping by coming to an understanding of selflessness And we can come to an understanding of selflessness through a process of reasoning.
For example, I as a subject, I do not inherently exist because I am neither inherently existently that one nor inherently existently many. Therefore, I do not inherently exist. So that is say we have to meditate on emptiness, we can apply many types of reasoning to come to an understanding of selflessness, and we can by realizing selflessness, abandon self grasping. So when we when we understand that grasping at the self of persons a distorted conception, it is a false conception, and therefore it can be eliminated. And that which eliminates it is the realization of emptiness, the realization of selflessness.
So this which is the root of our true sources of suffering, therefore our suffering, can be eliminated. One can come to a conclusion, I can eliminate the true sources of suffering. And out of that comes a desire to attain liberation, understanding that you can eliminate the true sources of suffering. You can be liberated from your suffering and with that desire to attain liberation. That state of liberation, which is the ceasing of our suffering, is the third of the noble truths, true cessation.
One thinks to oneself, I can achieve a true cessation, and one longs to achieve that. So through this sequence of understandings, arises a longing to be for a longing to achieve liberation. And there is a thought, I must achieve this. There’s nothing else which is more important. I have to achieve this goal.
Then along with that comes the thought, well, how do I in fact go about it? How do I achieve liberation? Again, if we went into detail in terms of true cessation, true cessation which are to be actualized, there are four characteristics of true cessation, the first of which is cessation. By cessation it means that there is a ceasing of suffering. Then there is the second characteristic of pacification, that the causes of suffering, true sources, have been pacified.
Then there’s that of high attainment. This is the quality of cessation in terms of an experience of bliss. And then there’s the fourth characteristic that of definite arising. One definitely arises from cyclic existence. One puts a stop to cyclic existence, puts a stop to rebirth within cyclic existence under the force of afflictive emotions.
So appreciating these four characteristics of true cessation and that it is possible to actually achieve this, one develops a longing to be liberated. And one goes on to question in terms of the fundamental cause of this process of cyclic existence is the grasping of a self, a person. Therefore, in order to achieve this cessation, one must overcome this fundamental root, is the grasping at the self of persons. One goes on to look to true paths. True paths are most true path most essentially is the direct realization of wisdom.
The wisdom which directly realizes emptiness. The wisdom which directly realizes selflessness. It is this wisdom which directly realizes selflessness which can rid our minds of the ignorance of self grasping. One achieves liberation so true paths are to be cultivated. So it is through one develops this longing to be liberated through seeing these first two truths, that is to say, sees the nature of cyclic existence as suffering and understands the origins of cyclic existence and the origin, the cause of our suffering, and then going on to which we are to abandon, and then going on to seek the methods for its abandonment, and understanding that true cessation, that these can be eliminated, and that the true paths which are able to eliminate the pair which are to be practiced.
So these four noble truths have 16 characteristics in all. It is by meditating on these 16 characteristics that one develops a longing a longing which strives for liberation. So we’re going to stop there for today, if you have some questions we’ll spend some time with those. Yes? Feel the suffering of or feel the suffering for?
Seeing a bird suffer, we recognize the fact that just like ourselves, that bird doesn’t want to experience that suffering. And so there arises a compassion wishing that bird was free from that suffering and this arouses an uncomfortable mental state in our mind, the state of wishing that something be free of suffering and there’s an uncomfortable feeling mentally arises for that bird. So experience mental discomfort out of your compassion. So out the condition of seeing the bird, one experiences mental discomfort in one’s own mind, but one has not accumulated the karma for the suffering of the bird. Karma is from the side of the bird, but due to that condition of seeing the bird, one experiences mental discomfort in one’s own mind.
Our mental suffering arises through and there’s a particular word in Tibetan which can be translated in various ways. It’s hard to find the right word for it, but some ways of translating are preconceptions or sometimes it’s even translated as superstitions, but maybe that’s not such a good translation. The various conceptions that we have in our mind are the cause of our mental suffering. Our karma are the causes of our physical suffering. We think in the ways of our thinking are the causes of our mental suffering.
So out of attachment to your aggregates. Maybe your aggregates are more handsome. So by the force of your attachment to your anger. Yes? The third kind of suffering.
So the compassion which merely wishes that, for example in this case of the bird, that bird to be free from that pain is not what we mean by fully qualified compassion. This is what we generally call what is termed compassion in the world. But it is when you desire that bird to be free from the suffering of universal conditionality, and that be it would free from all suffering whatsoever. That would be fully qualified compassion. Do we have a question here?
We The taker of the aggregates is the eye? What is the nature of that eye? So it is the I that we are continually referring to. We don’t examine the nature of the I, we say, I’m going, or I’m sick. So it is the mere I.
What’s your name? Your name? Astrid. So in your particular case, sometime after your birth, there were these aggregates and someone said, Let’s call those aggregates and you became known by that. And we came into existence by labeling this name upon those aggregates.
And likewise, the I is merely labeled onto aggregates. And then one subsequently comes to the thought arises, I am Astrid. Six realms? Okay. So there’s no form in formless realms?
That’s why it’s called formless realm? So we talked about there are six types of migrators. Overall there are three realms, desire realm, form realm, and formless realm. The form and formless realms are the beings that are termed celestial beings or gods. But within the desire realm there are the levels of the hell realms and hell beings, the hungry ghosts, the animals, the human beings, and the anti gods.
So there are those five. The other types of celestial beings either occupy this top level of the desire realm or one of the form or formless realms. There are no animals within the formless realm or there are no hell beings within the formless realm. There are no human beings within the formless realm. Is that clear?
We don’t usually say the six realms. We say the six types of migratory beings. Depends on which context you’re talking in. Overall there’s three realms. So have followed in order to achieve the realm of the formless beings.
They have traveled a path in which they concentrate on all the various faults of form. So they free themselves from attachment to form, but they haven’t abandoned attachment. They are temporary free of attachment to form and this is what provides a condition for them to take rebirth in a formless realm, but it’s only temporary. Did you have a question? So if you meditate well you can realize them.
Not necessary. Begin by offering a mandala.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.