26 min · 2,755 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A commentary on a mind training (lojong) text, teaching the practitioner to change aspirations toward bodhichitta and renunciation while keeping outward conduct unchanged and not seeking fame. It covers patience and avoiding anger, not blaming or belittling others, exchanging self and others, and steady, consistent practice rather than bursts of enthusiasm. The talk ends with a note on the text’s lineage and on how the Lam Rim commentary is structured.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 26 min
UUID: 80ad841f-a269-450f-97e7-d738cebbd3ff
Words: 2,751
Do not be patient with friends and impatient with enemies, or tolerant of humans while intolerant of spirits, and so forth. Change your aspirations, but preserve your old manner. Do not leave the old obstinate thoughts you have in your mind stream the way they are. Employ some remedy to improve them, a good deal. The best type of person sees improvement in a day.
The medium, in a month. So says a superior being should see improvement within a very day. The medium in a month. The most inferior in a year. You must see which of these you can manage.
If even this much is beyond you, then even though you have already received ordination and since become old, you will still have preserved the thoughts you had before you were ordained. Do not be like the rocks behind your house. Change your aspirations. They must be changed into bodhichitta, renunciation, realization of impermanence, and so on. Rocks behind our house remain the same all the time, don’t they?
Just rock, rock, rock without any change. This is what we don’t want to be like. Returning to the text, change your aspirations. They must be changed. Read this already.
But do not modify your external behavior at all. There are those who do not have even two hours worth of good qualities developed internally, yet pretend to be practicing and externally wear a holier-than-thou faraway look in their eyes and so on. You should only develop insights and improve your mind. Do not make any outward display nor should anyone know you have made any great progress. You should be like Śāntideva or Ārya.
It should be like Śāntideva or Kshudraka Panthaka, who had secretly abandoned delusion and developed realization. Even glorious Candrakīrti only seemed to be an unexceptional pundit, and no one paid him much attention. Yet inwardly, had achieved siddhis and was able to milk a drawing of a cow. Such beings do not make themselves conspicuous. And the past lamas of the Kadampa tradition also did not court fame by practicing in public, revealing their signs of accomplishment and so on.
Follow their example. You will meet meet with many hindrances if you advertise yourself. It is like boasting to others about your wish fulfilling gem. We are no different from worldly beings, and we step back into the things of this life. Yet if we even ever do even one dharma practice, we make sure everyone knows about it as if we had hoisted a flag on a mountaintop.
Don’t be like this. In the tradition of Atisha and the Kadampas, you must hide your good qualities like a butter lamp concealed inside a pot. Do not mention others withered limbs. That is, do not speak about others’ defects. Do not be obsessed with others.
That is, you should analyze your own thoughts and not look into the faults of others at all. Otherwise, you will only look for faults in your fellow practitioners, the members of your college, or the monks in your house at college. You will then naturally find fault even in Buddhas. Do not attribute faults to others. For if you do, you would only ignore people, belittle them, and so on all the more.
Purify the greatest delusion first. Purify whichever delusion in your mind stream is the largest. If your attachment is the largest, purify it by the application of antidotes, such as meditation on the ugly aspects of the body. Abandon all hopes of a result. When you do something virtuous, expect neither reward nor some favorable ripening of karma.
Abandon food with poison and do not cultivate any food of virtue that is mixed with the poison of self cherishing. Let’s deal with the rest without according to text further. Should you develop a delusion? Apply its antidote right away, and do not allow it to persist. Treat it unfairly.
The text talks about the four dharmas to be performed by practitioners of virtue. For instance, not to repay an evil action with an evil action. You are not a practitioner of virtue if you do not carry out these four. For you promised before your abbot and ordination master to practice them. If someone says to you, you mang your dog, do not retaliate with, you thief.
If someone hits you once, do not hit him twice in return. So these are the four characteristics of virtuous behavior we committed to ourselves to uphold. Do not bid your time waiting to avenge some wrong as if you had been waiting in ambush, but the road runs through a gorge to harm that person in return. Foolish, worldly minded people think it is best to smile, though secretly harboring harboring resentment. This merely shows that dharma and worldly activities are opposites.
If you know of some gross defect in another person, do not belittle them in front of many others or attack their weak spot. Do not bring up any of their faults. In the same way, do not recite wrathful mantras in order to destroy creatures and so forth. Geshe Potawa says this means, for instance, in front of many people saying, oh, this person I actually know has this and this defect. We should abstain from this.
Attend to the text, when you do something wrong, do not deceitfully blame someone else. Also, do not be clever and blame others when things go wrong. Do not put the load of a dzo on an ox. So this is, for instance, unburdening oneself of heavy work on another person and saying, he should do it when he doesn’t have the capacities to do so. Returning to the text, the mind is trained in order to subdue self cherishing.
But if your meditations cause an increase in your self cherishing and you do not harm spirits, but because you want to gain fame, gifts, and so on, the spell has gone awry. Do not do this. Do not be in a hurry to get possession of something that is common property or try to get the best for yourself by being there first. That is, do not run a race. You see this is a lot of conservatism when there’s something of and people just rush thinking of themselves alone.
Particularly the text, do not let the god become a devil, means do not let your mind training act no longer as an antidote to self cherishing, but bolster it instead. Do not think, if only my enemy would die or suffer ruin, then I would be happy. This would be seeking happiness in unhappiness. These make up the 18 vows or the 18 commitments. Seventh, the 22 pieces of advice.
All yogas are practiced with the one. That is the practitioner, and you know, perform a variety of virtuous practices because they are all included within thoughts of interchanging self and others. When you eat, think I have already given my body to sentient beings, thus in order to work for their sakes, I shall keep it nourished. And do the same thing with all your daily routine. Do everything in this way, reciting knowledge mantras, performing the exorcisms, and the like.
If the medicine is not proving beneficial, the doctor may both bleed the purse the patient and perform moxibustion. The thought of interchanging self and others will likewise serve in hundreds of cases for it’s an antidote to all illness and delusion. Set your motivation before all virtuous deeds and follow them with a dedication. It is also most important to determine every morning what you will and will not be doing. You must not give up your mind training practice come what may, either happiness or sorrow.
Some people abandon the dharma when made happy by promotion or acquisition of wealth. Some give it up when they suffer from their enemies. But you must not give up your practice of mind training in either event. Safeguard the commitment of your mind training practice and those of your other practices in general, as you would value your very life. There are three ascetic practices that you should know and devote yourself to.
They are the asceticism of identifying delusions, that of applying antidotes, and that of breaking the continuity of the delusions. You should pray to be able to assemble the three main causes for practicing dharma: meeting with the right guru, being mentally fit, and having all the necessary conditions such as food and clothing. Do the three things that should not degenerate, holding the guru in awe and respect, rejoicing in mind training, and keeping these pieces of advice through remembrance and vigilance. Do not leave your body, speech, and mind idle. Occupy them with virtue.
The virtues of the body are not merely prostrating yourself or performing circumambulations and so on. You should even turn your posture into something virtuous by straightening your spine. Do not divide up the objects of your mind training into friends and enemies or into sentient beings and Buddhas. You must master this practice in the very depths of your heart to include all possible objects as Geshe Chakkawa did. In order to completely master it, emphasize meditating on enemies with whom you feel and find it difficult to be patient and so on, also reserve a special place for objects that that could prove karmically dangerous for you, as your guru, parents, and roommates.
Continue to meditate regardless of whether or not you have all the necessary conditions such as food and cloth clothes. Do not let this apply to you. Looking like a practitioner when your belly is full and the sun is shining and as an ordinary type as soon as things go wrong. From today, meditate on bodhichitta, which is hard to develop but most beneficial. You must do this in order to work for your own and other sakes and not for the things of this life.
You should work mainly towards your next life rather than this one, towards dharma rather than worldly things, and on your meditations on mind training rather than practice the other dharma as discussed. The text continues, don’t misunderstand. I shall discuss the rest without actually quoting the rest. There are six ways of misunderstanding. Wrong this is being tolerant of problems met while doing something worthy but having no courage to face the difficulties encountered in dharma practice.
Two, misunderstood taste. You have to taste the dharma through study, contemplation, meditation, etcetera. When you have the conception of dharma, but instead can understand the concepts of worldly conversation, business, military affairs, etcetera, and can analyze things, you have tasted the worldly. This is tasting the wrong thing. Wrong compassion.
This is not meditating on compassion for those who sin, but having compassion for those who undergo difficulties for the sake of the dharma. Misunderstood aspiration, not wishing to practice a pure dharma, but aspiring to worldly happiness, power, and wealth. Misunderstood yearning. This is encouraging people who could trust in you not to practice dharma which should benefit their future lives, but encouraging them instead to study business, the law, etcetera, which will prove very harmful for their future lives. Misunderstood rejoicing.
There’s not rejoicing in your own or other’s virtues or in other’s happiness. Not to do this is nonvirtuous. Also, misunderstood rejoicing is to re rejoice when your enemies suffer. An illustration, once a monk rejoiced when his rival broke a major vow, actually broke a root vow. Geshe Potawa heard of this and said, the one who did the rejoicing committed a grievous greater sin than the one who broke the vow.
So this rejoicing in someone else’s breaking a root vow of ordination was a tremendously nonvirtuous deed. But in the text, when we do things like studying under a lama, we may develop a superficial renunciation, literally short haired renunciation, and for a few days frantically practice virtue. After a while, we get fed up and give up virtue. So do not be intermittent in your practice. As Geshe Khamlungpa said, Look far ahead.
Develop a vast mind. Be relaxed. So what is meant by having a vast mind or being farsighted? Being farsighted refers to seeing all the aspects of the path from relying on the spiritual guide to attaining full enlightenment. So we are going to the state of Buddha Vajradhāra, and the road is long.
This is what is meant by being by looking far ahead. So it is not good, consequently, to practice in this very enthusiastic and an intense way. Because we only practice for a couple days, and then we give it all up. Instead, slowly, slowly. As they say in English, slowly, slowly.
This will lead to results. Just jumping all over the place like a flea, that’s absolutely meaningless. This is going quietly like a little mouse. It’s going up a wall. The mouse gets places.
In other words, turn to the text when you practice virtue, you should always maintain the right pitch, neither too intense nor too relaxed. After you have finished the yoga of getting up each morning, you should practice the right amount. Later, increase this, and you will cover a wide range. So one can say, at the beginning, when we practice, we should be kind to ourselves. We should stop quietly.
And then quietly, we increase the pressure. We spend more time. Because all of this takes a lot of time. If one goes quietly, quietly, then there’s no doubt it will be a benefit. The people who will quickly when they were on the road, the people who would leave quickly for Lhasa.
They were the ones who never got there. This is like the story of the louse and the flea. The text says, do not train intermittently. One interpretation of this is, devote your mind fully to this training. When a doctor lets blood, he simultaneously cuts through blood vessels in skin.
In the same way, your mind training should wear down your mind stream as a rock will wear down a bone. Train yourself thoroughly through analytic meditation and mind training by means of both conceptualization and analysis. Apply the antidote to whichever delusion you deem to be greatest. Working for the sake of sentient beings is only right and something you have already promised to do. So do not make a big deal of it to anyone.
Supposing someone belittles you in front of others, do not get angry and so on. That is, do not be spiteful. Do not be as changeable as spring weather changing from happiness to sadness for the slightest reason. Do not offer your help in the hope of receiving praise and so forth. This completes the advice.
We have already accepted to generate bodhichitta. We have taken the bodhisattva vows. So this is our obligation. There’s no point in making a big fuss about it. So, Kancho, what she says, let us not be very changeable.
There are people whose minds are shifted by the slightest things. One day, they’re happy. The next day, they’re crying. Let us not be like that. Returning to the text.
If you follow it, you will be able to convert unfavorable circumstances into the path to enlightenment despite the fact that the five degenerations, the degeneration of lifespan and so forth are common place. The lineage of this instruction comes from Suvarnadwipa. It delighted Chekawa who said he could now die with no regrets. Except for the part covering the view, this completes a teaching. It’s okay.
Had extraordinary experiences from this and could die happy. The text, there are many commentaries on this text of you is dealt with according to the early dissemination of the teachings, and so is not made clear. Mind training according to the rays of the sun follows the system when it discusses a view, and your contemplation should be along lines. Suvarnadwipa originally followed the Cittamātra version of the view, but later changed through the Mādhyamika system. When giving an informal discourse on Lam Rim tradition, one does not repeat three or four times the material following this section on the development of bodhichitta.
Second, Geshe Potawa says, normally, these experiential commentaries on the Lam Rim are given three times, but in the case of this particular section, it is not. So we have done well today. We will stop here.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- five degenerations
- The degenerations that occur as human beings evolve over the eon of existence; they are: the degeneration of disturbing thoughts, of lifespan, of time, of view and of sentient beings. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.