57 min · 4,880 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This talk on the Lojong (mind training) teaching traces its lineage from Atisha through Geshe Chekawa and explains why it begins with bodhichitta before emptiness. It explains how self-cherishing is the root of suffering and how cherishing others, through recognising their kindness, is the basis for developing bodhichitta.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 57 min
UUID: 64399645-1288-4ab1-9e7c-721ac36cc76e
Words: 4,876
First, the greatness of the authors of his teaching. The lineage came from Buddha Śākyamūni down to the great Atisha. He passed it on to Dromtönpa. Under a seal of secrecy, Dromtanpa gave teachings to his disciples in public, but passed his mind training down Geshipotowa and others in secret. Geshipotowa passed it on to Langritampa and Geshe Sharawa.
So khid Zohanbati says Lamrim was taught in public gatherings. But this tradition of mind training was a secret lineage. Then the text, Geshe Sharawa gave his disciple, Geshe Chekawa, all the teachings on bodhichitta. These teachings were made public during Chakawa’s lifetime. Geshe Chekhawa was born into a family of great Nyingma practitioners and became very learned in the five sciences and so on.
But this did not satisfy him. He happened to see Langri Tampas mind training in eight verses, which says, give the gains and victories to others. Take the losses and defeats yourself. Geshe Chakawar then sought out the meaning of this, but Langretampa had passed on. He met Langretampa’s successor, Geshe Sharawa, requested instructions on mind training from him, and through his meditations to develop bodhichitta in his mind stream.
Geshe Chekawa gave this instruction to many lepers who cured themselves through this meditation. The teaching was even known as the leper’s dharma. Geshe Chekawa thought it was a great pity that this teaching was being kept so secret and taught it in public. He committed it to writing as a seven point mind training, dividing the teaching into seven sections. It has been called the essence of nectar instruction, because it’s the ultimate instruction on training the mind that would enable you to achieve the immortal state of Buddhahood.
So can somebody say it is precisely because his teaching is so beneficial that Geshe Chikawa put it down in writing. The greatness of this dharma can be seen by referring back to the section on the benefits of bodhichitta, how bodhichitta is like a diamond. It is similarly able to dispel the darkness of self cherishing just as even a fraction of the rays of the sun can dispel darkness. It can dispel the disease of self cherishing just as even a part of the medicine tree can dispel illness. In these times, when the five types of degeneration are commonplace and other dharma may not be effective, this mind training will help you, and you will not be bothered or disturbed by interferences.
This dharma has so many greatnesses. So can somebody says this Lojong lineage goes back to the guru. Returning to the text, it starts with homage to the great compassion. This homage is not being made to Ārya Avalokiteśvara. Just as Acharya Candrakīrti honored compassion in the opening of Madhyamakāvatāra, there’s a great compassion that is being honored here.
Now follow the sections of the main body of this mind training. So because you know, but they said this was an explanation of the greatness of the dharma. So, Kelsang Wangchuk, this is a passage in the text which says first engage in the preliminaries. This refers to the preliminaries to the creation of the body mind of bodhichitta. In other words, all the preceding stages of.
Secondly, teaching the preliminaries on which this dharma relies. This is me training yourself for the two types of bodhichitta, developing first ultimate bodhichitta and secondly, relative bodhichitta. Ultimate bodhichitta, the preserved teachings of the past say that the sharp witted Mahāyāna types should train their minds by developing ultimate bodhichitta first. So, Kunzang Wangchuk says, in past times, those who were sharp witted, who were intelligent, in other words, would first train by developing their understanding of emptiness, ultimate bodhichitta, and then develop conventional bodhichitta. And this was based on the thought that one had to have an understanding of emptiness before developing bodhichitta.
Between the text, however, the story of the Mahasiddha Khrastikopa could repeat itself if you first discuss training the mind to development of ultimate bodhichitta before you have taught the other part that deals with method. So I will not speak on the ultimate bodhichitta mind training first. This follows the practice of Togden Jampel Gyatso. I shall be dealing with it later for this included below in the section, the six perfections. So, this Mahasiddha Khrastikopa, whose name in Tibetan means ‘elephant skin’, engaged, engaged in all his meditations within the skin of an elephant, which had been slain.
So he gained realizations. He gained realization of emptiness through meditating, repeating within his elephant skin on the nature of cyclic existence, and he became very famous for the understanding of emptiness. And the king of the land requested him to come and teach him because he was so famous. And he taught the Prāsaṇgika view directly to the king based on the perfection of wisdom, the heart sūtra, And the king did not accept this, and he lopped his head off, thinking there is no such things as friends or enemies, good or bad. He developed powerful, no non virtuous views.
So another great scholar was invited by the king to teach him. He had a strong survival instinct and said, I think I’ll pass. Thank you. The king insisted. And because he was very scholarly, he taught the king about the various stages of the path, such as impermanence and the importance to develop compassion, but he very carefully left emptiness out of the picture.
And he taught the king the development of equanimity and then slowly built up to emptiness. So the king felt great repentance for having locked off plastic over his head. And Khastikova appeared to him in a dream and actually gave the king instructions. So the morality of the tale is before you start teaching people, it’s wise to be learned. Otherwise, you might find yourself on the receiving end of a lot of things.
So mind training is extraordinary in this respect. This is really central to our practice. Those who do not practice Lojong development, many difficulties and doubts. For instance, we have been teaching about the importance of relying on the spiritual teacher, and this is central to the teachings of Lam Rim. And these things are basically fundamental to build up to the level of the mind training practice we are at now.
Otherwise, we might be in the awkward position of being slain. Sir, therefore, this text says that because it’s dangerous to teach emptiness first and those ultimate bodhichitta first, one teaches in the tradition of traditional bodhichitta first or relative bodhichitta. Through the text, the source for this instruction is a story of Mitra Kanyaka. Mitra Kanyaka and other stories. He used to have a previous life of a compassionate teacher, but he was still in the path of training.
Although he had been born and held as a wrestler, forced to pull a car, he developed bodhichitta and so on. There are five subsections to this. So, Khensur Rinpoche says on the basis of developing a powerful understanding and realization of bodhichitta, then when one meditates on emptiness, wrong views will not arise. But in the text, meditation on and others are equal. This is preceded by the similar sections we had above, that is from equanimity up to the love that comes from the force of attraction.
Then you should contemplate as follows. So Guru Pooja says, there’s no difference between myself and others. We do not hold the smallest suffering, yet happiness never satisfies. Bless me to be glad at others’ joy. In other words, at present, we cherish and value the things we call the self but do not regard others in this way.
So the self and others are not equal. So Khensur Rinpoche says there are five divisions in this practice. The first is meditating on how self and others are equal, then contemplating the many thoughts resulting from self cherishing, contemplating the many good qualities resulting from cherishing others. And with these serving as a basis meditating on giving and taking. Text, it is not right to make such an enormous distinction between one’s self and others.
We ought to feel I and others are equal because we both want happiness and don’t want suffering. So can you see what he says? All sentient beings want happiness. Not one of them wants to suffer. So the one’s suffering, others are equal.
There is no difference between oneself and others. So we meditate on the fact that we are equal in that we all want happiness and all fear suffering. Returning the state to the text, at this initial stage, hardly another reasoning is used. There is no difference between the stage of that mind training and the understanding all sentient beings to be your mother, remembering their kindness and repaying their kindness parts of the above sevenfold cause and effect technique. So at present, unfortunately, conservatives, we do not cherish others in the slightest.
Returning to the text, this also holds true for the final section, altruism and bodhichitta. However, there are differences in the strength of your compassion and your love through the force of attraction. These two aspects receive special treatment here. The above section on remembering their kindness when we gave a method of recording the kindness engine being showed you when they were your mother. This new technique has a way of recording their kindness when they were not your mother.
Before moving on to the interchange of self and others, you must think that self cherishing is a fault. In an unfavorable condition, they’re cherishing others in a favorable condition and a good quantity. So commenting on what we just read, says, there isn’t the slightest difference between ourselves and others with respect to our fear of suffering and our desire for happiness. Moreover, there is no real difference in the in the result of the sevenfold meditation, which leads to the development of bodhichitta and the interchange of self and others. However, as the text says, there is a difference between the intensity of the mind developed through these two techniques.
And this arises from the fact that the former technique has no way of generating compassion towards beings who have not been our mothers should such beings exist. This present technique does not rest on that premise. Because the magistrates, it’s very difficult to interchange one side for another. So the Lama Chöpa, the guru puja says through understanding the faults of self cherishing. And says therefore, we’ll assume meditating on the faults of self cherishing that we must block it within our stream.
Secondly, contemplating the many forms resulting from self cherishing, the Lama Chöpa says, I see this chronic disease of self cherishing is a cause to produce unwanted suffering. In the Bodhisattva Acharya Avatar, it says, all worldly sufferings that have occurred stemmed from wanting happiness for oneself. Anything that befalls the worldly, any fear and suffering, all stemmed from self cherishing. Why should I have this great devil? So conservatory says it’s literally desire for oneself, liking oneself, which is the root of all worldly suffering.
All the sufferings of psychic existence down to the hell realms. They all arise from self cherishing. So when we talk of self, we’re talking of the savages perceived as truly existent. Returning to the text, our root text says, put the blame on one thing alone. That is all your unwanted sufferings come from yourself cherishing, coming to grief through weapons, poison, gods, and nagas, being reborn in hell as hungry ghosts, animals, etcetera.
These are due to having killed other beings in the hope of some gain for your own happiness, of being miserly and treating others with contempt. When we talk of the world, Khensur Rinpoche, says we’re talking of gods, human beings, this life, the future life, in other words, everything we encounter as ordinary being. Returning to the text, the hope of some gain for your own happiness, of being miserly and treating others with contempt. Likewise, succumbing to the diseases of the humors: wind, bile, phlegm, etcetera, fearing enemies, getting the calls of fame prosecution by the authorities. All these are due solely to our lack of self control, to gorging ourselves on food, to being obsessed with food, fashion, and fame.
So all of the undesired things which happen to us concerning us come from self cherishing. So instead of putting oneself first, we should put others first, make them the main object of our concern. Returning to the text. When at the top of the ladder, kings, ministers, and whole countries fight. But when on the bottom rung, their subjects, families, etcetera, argue, or even when monks squabble.
Self cherishing is at fault. Don’t have self cherishing. You should have an attitude of, I don’t care. You do what you like. And none of these problems will occur.
You get this a lot in monasteries concerning what Jesus Returning to the text, your self cherishing created all your troubles with thieves, bandits, and even with mice making holes in your bags of tsampa. So this is a very powerful way of handling these things. You just say to these troublemakers, I don’t care what you do. You do what you want. So because the fisher says, you all know that mice have this fondness for digging holes in tsampa bags.
Return of the text, when you die from poison or from undigested food, you do not really die from poison because you’re self cherishing. Because of your self cherishing, you ate far too much. Your self cherishing killed you. When you’re innocent, they get accused of being a thief, the direct result of having harmed others due to self cherishing. So for instance, to take another example, disease is a karmic result of having killed or harmed others.
Self cherishing, returning to the text, is a butcher who kills your chances of rebirth or liberation. He’s like the burglar who carries a swag full of the three poisons on his back and steals your crop of virtue. It is like the sower who sows the seed of evil karma in the field of ignorance, thus reaping the harvest of saṃsāra. Like the glory seeker who braves the arrows, spears, and swords in the thick of battle in hope of some personal gain. Like a reckless never do well who will desert even his guru, abbot, or mother in a crisis.
With the empty handed wretch who right from the beginning never achieved any good qualities. It makes you have hopes or fears for things you shouldn’t. It makes you jealous of those above you, compete with your equals, and snub those below you. It makes you arrogant when praised and angry when criticized. It brings everything second rate in the world.
There’s a root of all known virtue, the thing that brings you suffering. An old owl faced ill omened one. It is. The Tibet is a specific type of torma offered to demons, which lies buried in the center of your heart. So Khensur Rinpoche says, if you have to throw at somebody, then throw them at self cherishing.
In times long past, a Geshe once made tormas and then stuck them to his breast as a symbol that he offered them to the demon of self cherishing. Don’t do that with your tormas, however. Returning the text, if you must threaten something and throw it ritual cakes, you should throw to propitiate this demon. When we throw out tormas, we do it to sentient beings, our former mothers, all saying, this is for anyone who is my enemy. Let us think of the fact that these are old mothers, are mothers of yore.
This is really quite terrible. Returning to the text, what a mistake this is. This is the point brought out by the quotation, self cherishing is a blue headed bird of ill omen. Mind training is the bribe to make this nuisance go away. So because of this is this blue headed bird of an omen is our own self cherishing which values ourselves and rejects others.
Formerly, a true practitioner took over a place where a spirit lived. This spirit then used its magic to live on there. One day, the man’s two sponsors fell into a call. The man went to heal the dispute, and one of them took up a weapon and killed him. I heard this story from my precious guru.
The ultimate root of such violent death is nothing nothing but self cherishing. So because I’m a choose this too is dangerous business, really. The police of Acharya Vatara says when your thoughts only wish to benefit yourself, all your mighty labels. Performed over count as sions would only bring you suffering. So says this quote from shows clearly how our present situation, our misery, is purely the product of our mind.
We are responsible of our suffering. That is, the thing that has brought us suffering since beginning this time in saṃsāra is our own self cherishing. Self cherishing and grasping at the self are two quite distinct things, but they are discussed in this mind training as if they were the same, for there are some resemblances. Kins and Amache says they’re basically friends. The one helps the other.
So says, an arhat does not have the mind which apprehends the self as existing truly. However, there both types of arhats, arhats who have self cherishing and arhats who don’t. Therefore, there is a difference between apprehending the self as existing inherently and self cherishing. To be brief, returning to the text, both are at the root of all problems. One of them operates by taking the I, your feeling of I to be established as true.
So we say I I I, Kinshoka Chasers, we’re seeing that that I is truly established. However, self cherishing is that attachment, not only to oneself, but to one’s own things and objects and so forth. So consumer chooses Not touching. Self cherishing puts the self first. That apprehension which says I I I is an assertion of the self as being truly existence.
Returning to the text. One of them operates by taking the I, your feeling of I to be established as true. The other operates by not giving up the idea of I and then cherishing these ideas. To sum up, all problems come from the deep seated thought. I want some happiness.
But if you cannot subdue the self cherishing, you will have no happiness. You have never before checked to see what is at the root to blame for so your sufferings, but it is self cherishing. From now on, check what is to blame and look on your self cherishing as an enemy. Practice the techniques to abandon it. So Vincent was saying that we do not understand what is the root of suffering that is the combination of the apprehending the self as truly existence and cherishing oneself above others.
So the fact that we systematically privilege our friends, try to harm our enemies, All of this is rooted in these two minds, the mind which apprehends itself as truly existent and the man which cherishes oneself. So says the abandonment of the very seeds of the apprehension of the surface truly existence is very difficult, but we must endeavor to do this at the same time as we try to abandon self cherishing. Through practice and through practice alone, can we hope to eliminate these two? So these two are like the root of the distinction we make between enemies and friends. So if we were to practice just one dharma to see where are our friends, where is suffering, you know, what is the root of all of this, then really lojong is what we should practice.
And this is a very root of lojong. So like, through purifying our minds quietly, quietly, gradually, gradually, then we can attain non contaminated appearances. Into making this present minds less and less contaminated, and we can attain enlightenment. These westerners, they tend to believe that it’s easy to attain enlightenment and it can be attained within one life. It’s extremely difficult.
We must progress on all of the grounds and paths, on and on. In the so as it is said, one needs three countless kalpas, three kalpas. Now it is true that with the practice of tantra, we can go faster. But without bodhichitta, is no power to tantra. So to practice tantra, we must rely on the three principles of the path: renunciation, bodhichitta, and the correct view.
To eliminate the attachment to the self, we must cultivate the correct view. And to eliminate self cherishing, we must cultivate bodhichitta. We must see that these are our enemies. We must treat them as our enemies. And then with that mind, we must strike them and obliterate them.
Frankly, without meditating on this, it is very difficult. So we must then keep in our mind the thought, how can we care for others? The following outline, contemplating the many good qualities resulting from cherishing others, Śāntideva said, all worldly happiness to be found comes from wishing others happiness. And the says, I see that cherishing these, my mothers, is a thought that leads to happiness is a door leading to infinite qualities. Says, it is the door to the infinite qualities of both sūtra and tantra.
Apart from this, there is no great vehicle. Returning to our text, our text on mind training says, meditate on the greater kindness of all. What is this? It is the great kindness of sentient beings. Śāntideva says, quoting from that we owe our full enlightenment to both sentient beings and to Buddhas.
Therefore, the kindness of sentient beings is infinite. And yet, why do we give respect to the Buddhas and pay no homage to sentient beings? Buddhas exist in dependence on certain beings. Which of these is more important? They’re one and the same.
If Buddhas depend on certain beings, how can we say the Buddha is the most important? While there is vast kindness in the Buddha spiritual teacher, he exists in dependence on sentient beings. Return to the text. In other words, having the body and wealth of a high rebirth or having magnificent surroundings resulted from cherishing others, Virtue from abandoning killing because you cherish the life of others will ripen into a resultant rebirth in the upper realms, long life and so on. The practice of generosity and the abandonment of miserliness from cherishing others will result in great wealth.
In short, Ashantideva said, let more needs be said. Look at the difference between those who work for their own needs and the muni who benefited others. One doesn’t really have to explain a lot here. What is the difference between sentient beings and Buddhas? Look at it.
Then look at how they behave. Look at the result. One has freed himself from all sufferings. The other has not. And the Lama Chöpa says, in short, the infantile work in saṃsāra.
Keep in mind, because I’m Jesus at the beginning, Buddha was just like us, mired in cyclic existence. There was no difference. This is really the way it was. There was a period where we had the same sufferings. Returning to the text, but at some time in the past, the Muni began to cherish others and progress to fulfill both his own and others’ aims by eradicating his faults and gaining the consummation of all good qualities.
Kasanamaji said he relied on a spiritual teacher and put an end to his faults. Return of the text, we heard it from beginning this time in in saṃsāra have cherished only ourselves. We have toiled and toiled with our own happiness in mind, but gained nothing in return. All we have been able to accomplish has acted solely as a means for our going to the lower realms, and even now all we have is suffering. If the opposite can happen, then at some time in the past we had acted as our compassionate teacher, all our suffering would have been eradicated by now.
Undoubtedly, we would have had the supreme happiness and been able to fulfill the needs of others magnificently. This is not what happened, however, we are in our present predicament. Once during a protector ritual at a certain monastery, a Geshe of Dakhpo inserted into the ceremony some of the curses found in the wheel of sharp weapons. An instance, that is how it is. I know my enemy.
I lay in ambush and court you, you sneak thief, hypocrite. You have fooled me with your lies. Or self grasping, I have no doubt this is how you are. This caused the scandal, but the point was made, Recognize your true enemy. So, Kunzang Wangchuk said the time of offering the tormas, this Geshe understood what tormas had to be offered to.
Return to the text, once displayed his power and killed many thieves. The first Dalai Lama, the son of, prayed that the might cast a spell on the Dalai Lama’s own self. But he had no self cherishing, and the Tantrika’s magic was unable to harm him. So, Khensur Rinpoche says, this Tantrika was throwing tormas to destroy evil beings, but there was nothing in the Dalai Lama to destroy. Returning to the text, Drukpa Kunle once made tormas while performing a ritual for his younger brother Chögyal.
The time had not yet come for the tormas to be thrown outside, and Kunle had an idea. Why not throw the cakes at self cherishing? So he threw them on his brother’s lap. Our compassionate teacher also cherished others in his former lives. When he took rebirth once he took rebirth as King Padmaka, he died of the plague and was reborn as a Rohita fish whose flesh cured many beings struck down with the plague.
When he was reborn as a tortoise, he rescued 500 merchants who had fallen into the sea, then he gave his body to 80,000 flies. He gave away half his body when he was king Shri Senna. When he was Maharatna Chudha, he had a jewel on the crown of his head. He actually cut out of his flesh to give it to another. As king Prakriti, he gave his body to a hungry tigress who was just about to eat her own cub.
As Chandraprabha, he gave his head. So these are the peerless acts of generosity of the great Bodhisattvas. So these were the deeds of our great teacher, Śākyamūni, the deeds we should endeavor to imitate. For the power of his prayers, he derived great benefit. Returning to the text.
These were the deeds of a compassionate teacher. We only ever think of ourselves. Yet although these things are difficult to do, we should prepare ourselves for them now by at least making prayers. Cherishing others is the right thing to do since we depend on sentient beings for our daily food and drink. They’re like a field that grows magnificent crops like wish granting gems.
Not only have all sentient beings shown us great kindness when they were our mothers, but also even when they were not our mothers. We say they’re alive only through their kindness. For instance, a single bag of barley flour is a result of much hard work. Some single beings had to plow the field, others watered it, others threshed the grain, and so on. The building we are in is a result of the kindness of others.
Many animals and people had to carry earth, build the walls, do the carpentry, fetch water, and so forth. A zen, the upper robe of a monk, is not ready to wear. But a large number of sheep had first to produce the wool, then some beings wove the cloth and others sewed it. It is through the kindness of sentient beings that we temporarily have this optimum human rebirth, and ultimately, through their kindness, we shall develop bodhichitta, train in the bodhisattva tasks, and even gain buddhahood. We gain all these things with their kindness because sentient beings are the object of our compassion, of our development of bodhichitta, and of our generosity.
They are the basis of our ethics and the object of our patience. From the Bodhisattvacharyavatara, the victorious ones and sentient beings are both necessary for your practice of the dharma. While you are the victors, how could you not pay homage to sentient beings as well? In other words, you will achieve Buddhahood half through the kindness of your guru and half through that of sentient beings. Langri Thangpa said, by contemplating how I should achieve supreme benefit due to all sentient beings, more than I could achieve from any wish fulfilling gem, may I cherish them greatly.
That is sentient beings will achieve all your ends for you, both temporarily and ultimately. Thus, they are like the wish fulfilling gem, and that is why it is only right to cherish. So we stop here for today.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- five sciences
- Within Tibetan Buddhist education, they are: grammar, logic, medicine, arts and crafts, and religious philosophy. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- Nyingma
- The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- torma balimta (Skt)
- An offering cake used in tantric rituals. In Tibet, tormas were usually made of tsampa, but other edibles such as biscuits and so forth will suffice. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.