47 min · 5,224 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching on the medium scope. It briefly covers death, the bardo and rebirth, then explains the twelve interdependent links as a cycle of karma, delusion and suffering. It closes by turning to renunciation and the three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom as the path to liberation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 48 min
UUID: 80d8389a-2140-4474-8683-c79309a70688
Words: 5,220
Going. But, clearly, if we familiarize our mind with virtue, Such thoughts will spontaneously arrive at the time of death. And then our practice and the blessings of our practice will arise at the time of death. For instance, those who have practiced tantra correctly can then engage in very advanced practices in the state. Or they can meditate on the supreme view.
For that matter, they can meditate on bodhichitta. And thus transform the mind of death. Otherwise, if one does not transform the mind of death, then there is no doubt suffering will arise. So through thinking about the benefit for future lives, we must endeavor to accumulate virtue at present. Through hoping not to go to a lower rebirth, but going to a good rebirth, to having a good teacher, a good condition.
All of these are effects which have causes, and we must accumulate the causes at present. They will arise through familiarity. Without familiarity, without meditation, then it will be very difficult. So if we do not think about these things now, then when when will we think about them? You could be a dharma practitioner who continually creates virtue, but if you get angry when you are dying, act with non virtuous dying thoughts and go to the lower realms or into the ripening effect of past non virtues.
And the same principles would apply to a sinner who continually sins. So those who generate anger within their mind stream, unfortunately, at the time of death are almost certainly bound to the lower realms. Returning to the text at this point, one will be going to either the upper or the lower realms. If one is going to the upper realms, one’s body heat dissipates from the lower parts of the body and collects into the heart. If one is going to the lower realms, the opposite happens.
Heat dissipates from the upper reaches of the body and collects in the lower. Also, you can know which of these two will happen by such times as a degree of discomfort the person experiences during his fatal illness. Discomfort during the illness refers to when a major part of the body fails. Kensur Rinpoche says, when the heat dissipates from the top of the body to the feet, it is a sign of rebirth in the lower realms. So Kensur Rinpoche says, at the time of death, some people have extraordinarily difficult and painful deaths.
This is generally a very poor sign. Time for tea. Some people hallucinate when they die. For instance, they may imagine being squashed under bricks of tea or by people. Kyabje Pabongka Rinpoche told Harjor Lhasa he saw a steward of the central government die.
He had stolen tea. When he died, he had hallucinations and thought he was being squashed under boxes of tea. When an official of Tang province died, he said, I am being crushed by many people, and he left that light life in a state of terror and so on. This also happens to people who have performed virtuous deeds. Once a beggar who lived by the side of the road had visions of a palace in white light rays when he died, also told how an old woman in Chusang who had recited Om Mani Padme Hum a lot had virtuous visions when she died.
Such signs are but a prelude to death. So, Kensur Rinpoche says, after dying, we enter the bardo, the intermediate state. Returning to the text, like the swinging of the arms over a balance, your present incarnation and simultaneously with your adoption of the physical form of the preliminary incarnation, the subsequent incarnation. This refers to the phantom, the being that resembles the aggregates of your next rebirth, the next rebirth of incarnation. Wherever it may be is preceded by this being.
Some peoples claim that the dead live at the bardo with the appearances and costumes they had when they were alive, and there are ways of sending messages to them. This is a fallacy. It is possible there have been one or two such sightings, but they are not the dead person. They are be said to be some creature taking the form of the dead person done to deceive ordinary worldly beings. So, again, remember Jesus, we must be very clear that the being actually at the time he is born in the body, he appears in the body, takes on the form he will have in the next rebirth, not the form he had in the one which he has just departed from.
Returning to the text, Kyabje Pabongka is referring here to the story from Jetsün Milarepa’s biography about the death of a Bampo layman’s father. Bardo beings have all their faculties. They are clairvoyant, and can perform paranormal acts. Nothing except for sacred reliquaries or their birth sites bear bars their way. The bardo beings who are to be reborn in hell are the color of burnt logs, beings to be reborn as hungry ghosts are of a watery color.
Those about to become animals are gray. Those about to become humans or gods of the desire realm are the color of fine gold. Those about to become formed realm gods are of a white color in the bardo. There is no bardo for beings taking rebirth in the formless realm. The bardo intermediate state appears as black to the non virtuous.
To the virtuous, the state appears as if punctuated by the white strips of cloth or lit by moonbeams. Many claims have been made about the lifespan of bardo beings. Usually said to be seven days, days of the same duration as those in the previous life. After these seven days, Bardo beings undergo a small death, and they can have up to seven such small deaths before they find a rebirth. Thirdly, the way one is conceived and reborn.
Take the case of being born from a womb. Conception occurs within the sperm and blood of the parents. The bardo being sees the father and mother sleeping together. Its anger and attachment activated, and it sees only the sex organs of the parents. Its anger kills it, and it is conceived into its next incarnation.
Sir, a little bit of anger is enough to terminate the life of the bardo being. This completes the heading thinking about the source of suffering the stages forcing one into saṃsāra following Je Tsongkhapa’s medium stage of the path, the Swift Path and the Easy Path. I shall now discuss this heading according to the 12 interdependent links that were also discussed in the great stages of the path. The swift path and the easy path lamrims are not clear on this topic. I shall teach this according to a treatment in Mañjuśrī’s own words, giving little more than its headings.
The above brief version of the way to think about the stages of being forced into saṃsāra that is a source of suffering is sufficient. However, people who, for instance, have studied the classical debate text should think about this by means of the 12 links. This is the best thing for certain exceptional people. Once told how the king of Magadha and the advice of the Buddha explained the process of taking rebirth to the foreign king Uttarayana by using a drawing of the wheel of life. Uttarayana developed the awareness of saṃsāra, and Rinpoche also told us how Geshe Puchama made a study of the 12 links and taught the small and medium scope according to these links.
So you should think further about the drawbacks of the origin of suffering and the drawbacks of saṃsāra by means of the 12 links. In order to strengthen your weariness of saṃsāra and so forth. The Buddha did discuss these links when he taught the Rice Seedling Sūtra. As was it said this exists, that will occur. Because this has arisen, that will arise.
Similarly, ignorance serves as a subsidiary cause for the compositional factors. In other words, there are 12 links as follows. Ignorance. This is the root of our revolving on the wheel of saṃsāra. We are ignorant of how to apprehend selflessness with our wisdom.
Our grasping is directed towards our person and phenomena, and we hold that they have a self or that they can be established by their nature. Ignorance is a perverse manner of apprehension that contradicts primary wisdom. This is like being blind. There are two forms of ignorance, ignorance of cause and effect and of suchness. So, because, you said this ignorance is like a form of darkness.
It is a very root of psychic existence. It’s a root of all suffering. It’s a root of old existence. So this can be eliminated probably from the level of the being of middling capacity and perhaps from the level of the being of small capacity. So this is a very root as saṃsāra’s producer.
Secondly, compositional factors. Ignorance motivates a compositional factors as if this were its job. The aggregates manifest in our reincarnation the same function of the composition of factors. Thus, we are motivated by the ignorance of being blind to the law of cause and effect, so creating unmeritorious karma. Or we are motivated by the ignorance of being blind to the mode of existence of things, and we create a meritorious or immutable karma.
All three types of karma are compositional factors. Thirdly, consciousness. This refers to two consciousnesses, a consciousness at the time of the cause and then at the time of the result. The first type is a consciousness immediately, and your text is wrong. It’s not after.
It’s at the instant, at the time of the instinct or latency of the compositional factor. That is the karma that has been imprinted. The second type is a consciousness immediately before conception into the next incarnation. An illustration. Suppose if motivated by ignorance, you take a life.
When you commit this karmic action or composition of factor, its instinct or latency is imprinted as soon as the karmic process has been completed. This is a consciousness at the time of the cause. By virtue of this karma, you were conceived into an incarnation as a hell being. Immediately after this conception, the situation of your consciousness constitutes the consciousness at the time of the result. The consciousness at the time of the result.
Each known virtuous karmic action is capable of throwing one into many rebirths in the lower realms. Apply the same principle to meritorious karma and so forth. The instincts of these karmic actions enter the consciousness as oil soaks into sand or the ink of an official seal soaks into paper. Craving and clinging are able to activate these latencies, which then become potent enough to effect rebirth. So this is a process whereby the karmic imprints are imprinted in the mind.
Fourthly, ly, name and form. In the case of rebirth from a womb, the name link is the four aggregates of feeling, recognition, composition, factor, and consciousness. The form link is the blood and semen in the first stage of development, etcetera, into which the consciousness has been placed. Such links, where they apply, are called the link of name and form. Fifthly, the six senses.
Once the sixth sense faculties, the eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, mind have formed, this link only applies as long as one will not discriminate between objects whenever a certain object, a faculty, and the sensory consciousness are present. The physical and mental faculties are said to exist from the period of initial fetal development, with the development, the example of a transformational rebirth into two inspirational realms, the desire and form realms, the name and form link and the link of the six senses occur simultaneously. In the formless realm, there are only the name link and the link of the mental sense. There are no links of form or of the five physical senses. Sixth link contact.
Once a previous link has been formed, the object, the faculty, and the sense consciousness are present and touch as well. One can then discriminate between pleasant, unpleasant, and neutral object. This is a contact link. Seventh feeling. This contact link serves as a condition of one of the three types of feeling, happiness, suffering, or equanimity.
For instance, we develop a happy feeling on meeting with a present object. Eight, craving. Craving is wanting not to be separated from happy feelings. It is also wanting to be separated from suffering and clinging to the separation. We can also crave that our equanimity does not decline.
Feelings are said to serve as a condition for the development of craving. This should be understood to mean that ignorance is present and that contact then serves as a contributory factor. It’s only the feeling that occurs then that produces craving. So when we do not have ignorance, we may still have feelings that craving will not develop. Grasping, the ninth of the 12 links.
Our craving increases, so we desire the object and become attached to it. There are four types of grasping. Grasping at sense pleasures is being attached to the object of the senses. Grasping at views is being attached to all evil views except the view that equates itself with the perishable. Grasping at ethics and modes of behavior is being attached to inferior ethics and modes of behavior linked to evil views, grasping at assertions of self.
It’s a fondness for notions of true existence. It is fundamentally a fondness for the view of equating the self with the perishable aggregates. Tense becoming in the passive composition of factor link implanted the instinct of some karmic action to the consciousness. Craving and grasping activate this instinct, which then becomes potent enough to throw into a body of which a rebirth. 11, rebirth.
This link extends from just after this activation when the potent karma, which will be responsible for reincarnation so this is basis for being conceived in one of the four types of rebirth, and we’re just after our conception in this rebirth. 12, aging and death. We received where applicable the links of aging and death in order. Aging is a maturing of the aggregates, a gradual changing of their condition. Death is what we call the destruction of the aggregates.
They’re ceasing to function. Once you have been introduced to these 12 links and can distinguish between them, you must know how to group them properly into limbs. Therefore, these limbs, the precipitating limb, the limb, the resultant precipitating limb, and the resultant manifested limb. Ignorance is like a sower of the seed. The karmic action, the composition of factor motivated by ignorance is like the seed.
And like the earth into which a seed is planted, the consciousness at the time of the cause has the instinct of the accumulated karma put into it. So the precipitating limb is the first two and a half links, ignorance, compositional factor, and the consciousness at the time of the cause, not the other division of the consciousness link that is at the time of the result. Just as a seed is nurtured by water, manure, heat, and moisture, so craving and grasping activate common into being able to produce a result. Like a seed being made potent enough by water, manure, heat, and moisture to develop into a sprout, karma that has been activated by craving and grasping is made certain to precipitate the aggregates of one’s next incarnation by the link of becoming. Thus craving, grasping, and becoming are the establishing limbs.
Just as the seed grows into a sprout, so the link of rebirth that is being conceived into one’s incarnation is one component of the resultant manifested limb. Five and a half links make up the result precipitated limb. The consciousness at the time of the result, which I have already described, name and form where applicable, the senses contact and feeling. Aging and death, where they apply, are another component of the resultant manifested limb. So the resultant manifested limb is made up of the link of rebirth, percent of aging, death.
Let’s take the example of rebirth as a god. To through the power of our ignorance and as being blind to suchness, the instinct of some karma we accumulated, Karma which will throw us into rebirth as a god is placed in our consciousness. Then we feel hired, welcome rebirth as a god. And aspired to this in our prayers and so on, this is craving. Then we put even more effort into this aspiration.
This is grasping at this. These last two make up the starting to throw us into this rebirth that is becoming. So three components of the precipitating limb and the three of the establishing limb, six in all are complete in this life. Then we are reborn as a god. The other six links are complete in this next rebirth as a god.
Four of them, name and form, the senses, contact, feeling, are the resultant precipitating limb into birth plus aging and death, are the result manifested limb. This is how one set of 12 links is completed in two lifetimes. Take the example of rebirth in the lower realms. The same principle apply. Because of a blindness to the law of cause and effect, we accumulate non virtuous karma, which is activated by craving and grasping, etcetera.
It is impossible for one set of links to be completed within the one lifetime under the power of one karmic action. The fastest we can complete a set of links is definitely within two lives. It takes longer when we have been unable to activate some karma through craving and grasping. Then the three components of the precipitating limb will be completed in one life. The three of the establishing limb in another life, and the four of the resultant precipitating limb as well as the two of the resultant manifested limbs will be completed in yet another life.
An illustration? We accumulate evil karma to be reborn in the lower realms, and the instinct is implanted. However, at death, the guru and others induce virtuous thoughts in us. This activates karma for a human rebirth, and we are next reborn as a human being. When we die, we activate the previous evil karma through craving and grasping, and are then reborn in the lower realms.
In our example, there could be many intervening rebirths between the precipitating and establishing limbs, but they are lives that belong to other sets of links and so do not count. So to summarize, the fastest we can complete a set of 12 links is in two lives and the slowest in three. There’s not possible to do it any faster or more slowly. Each link gives rise to the link that follows it, so all suffering, rebirth, aging, death, and so on is experienced as a cycle. While we follow the links that resulted from a single karmic action, we may develop various other sets of links in their cause phase.
Aging and death derive from rebirth, a compositional factors derive from ignorance, and so on. So one link follows another, and ignorance is therefore fundamental in causing the wheel of saṃsāra to turn. Said, two of them derive from the three, seven of them derive from the two, and then the three occur again. This is a wheel of life, and so it turns and turns. In other words, the three delusion links give rise to the two karma links, and from these come the seven links of suffering.
And from these seven links come the three delusion links, and so on. The cycle is repeated, and the wheel of life turns without interruption. This is a revolving of the wheel of suffering. The 12 links can be dealt with in another order. If we practice a path that is able to put a stop to them, we impede the composition of factor link by preventing the ignorance link from occurring.
This would put an end to all the suffering of aging and death. To summarize, The 12 interdependent links can be brought under the three types of links, the karma links, the delusion links, and the links of suffering. So, Kensur Rinpoche says, let us think about this, for instance, in terms of the various sensations. We can put an end to the link of ignorance through the direct perception of emptiness. If we do not have the direct perception of it of emptiness, then it will not be possible to put an end to the link of ignorance.
The wisdom which understands emptiness and the ignorance which happen against phenomena is inherently existent are mutually incompatible. Therefore, they cannot coexist within one mind stream. Returning to the text. Ignorance, craving, and grasping are the three delusion links. The two karma links are composition of factors in becoming.
The remaining links are the seven links of suffering. As Nāgārjuna said, the first eight and ninth are delusion. The second and tenth are karma. The remaining seven are suffering. The first line of the verses discusses the three links of motivation.
The second line, the two karmic links, karma, actions of body and speech, that is the composition of factors. And becoming. The third line, the links that one will experience. You have developed renunciation when as a result of your meditation on the general suffering of saṃsāra and the 12 interdependent links, you yearn to be liberated from saṃsāra as a prisoner yearns to be freed from prison. You will then want to train in a path leading to freedom.
So this is what we should endeavor to put an end to consumer purchases. Secondly, ascertaining the nature of the path leading to liberation. Independence on the motivation which desires liberation from psychic existence, we now endeavor to establish what the means are, which leads to this liberation. This is two sections between the text, a sort of rebirth that will stop saṃsāra, and secondly, the sort of path that will stop saṃsāra, the sort of physical rebirth that will stop saṃsāra. So says, the first point we have to ascertain is the basis.
It’s a better transition than rebirth, which is required. And then the path, the basis that will stop saṃsāra. You have thought about the drawbacks of saṃsāra. The nature of saṃsāra is that its environment isn’t permanent and perishable, because the image of the moon on water whose surface is being blown by the wind does not stay still even for a moment. Samsaric happiness and wealth harbor as great a danger as a shadow of a hooded cobra.
You can see that any of the five kinds of rebirths are an uninterrupted torment of suffering. Just as people in prison or in a burning house do not wish to remain there and want to be freed from it, you will develop unforced thoughts of wanting to be liberated from saṃsāra. You will investigate the causes of saṃsāra. There are two causes, karma and delusion. When you know this, you will want to work hard at some means to defeat these two.
So Kensur Rinpoche says, in the same way that a prisoner from the very moment he is thrown in jail only dreams of being free, we likewise must aspire to freedom from suffering. So says cyclic existence is basically described as an ocean of suffering. So an ocean is basically a huge expanse of water. And in the same way, cyclic existence is a huge expanse of suffering. So the all pervasive suffering, the third of the three sufferings, is the very ocean of suffering we are referring to.
Because it’s all pervasive and huge, it is then described as an ocean, the ocean of suffering. This is nothing else but the contaminated aggregates. So the very root of such existence is karma and delusion. If we investigate further, it’s delusion, and the very root of delusion is ignorance. So we must find means to defeat this enemy, the delusions.
Returning to the text, the rebirth, the base used to have is the optimum human rebirth. And now we have gained such an optimum human rebirth in which can we can follow the three higher trainings and other wholesome endeavors. We must turn away from saṃsāra. When you wandered so much in the past, saṃsāra did not stop by itself, nor will it stop by itself. You must stop it.
And the time to stop it is now that you have gained the optimum human rebirth. In other words, there was no better rebirth than this one. So Kensur Rinpoche says, saṃsāra does not stop by itself. However much you would like it to. It’s on the basis we have at present, which is the precious human rebirth, that we ourselves can put an end to the wheel.
Secondly, the path that would put an end to cyclic existence, we should sever the root of saṃsāra. The root is ignorance of being blind to suchness. The instinctive form of grasping at the I, the root that must be cut because when we do not sever this and cultivate other antidotes instead, it merely dulls a few delusions a little, but does not destroy them forever. Other virtues cannot affect this instinctive grasping at the I. Only thoughts of a quite opposite kind can stop this grasping.
Likewise, Kensur Rinpoche says, if we destroy the root of a tree, then we have eo ipso destroy the leaves. The wisdom, returning to the text that understands selflessness, realizes that the I does not exist by way of its nature. This wisdom is therefore directly opposite to the thought and manner of grasping that takes the I to be established by its nature. You therefore need the wisdom that understands selflessness in order to eradicate the instinctive grasping at the self. When you do not have this wisdom and work hard at other virtues, it will only bolster your grasping at a self.
They will be unable to harm it. To develop this wisdom properly in your mind stream, you need the following. Says the three trainings. Returning to the text. Kensur Rinpoche adds out of the three trainings, the actual antidote, the real antidote, is the wisdom which understands the selflessness of all phenomena.
Returning to the text, you will not develop it without the high training of single pointed concentration. For instance, you need two things when you chop a tree trunk. A sharp axe and a steady arm. If your axe isn’t sharp, it cannot cut it to the tree trunk. So, Kensur Rinpoche says, not only must your axe be sharp, but your arm must be powerful and stable.
Likewise, for meditation on the selflessness of the aggregates. Returning to the text, if your arm is on three, the axe will not fall in the same place on the trunk. Kensur Rinpoche says if the axe falls all over the tree, it have absolutely no hope to cut it. It must fall time and over again in the same place. Or to see, returning to the text, to see a mural at night, you must have a bright butter lamp that is protected from the wind.
The wisdom that understands is like the sharp axe. Grasping at true existence is a trunks to cut. Properly seeing the mode of existence is like the steady arm wielding the axe or the butter lamp shedding light on how things are. In order to develop in your mind stream stable single-pointed concentration that is free of internal mental distractions like the butter lamp not flickering in the wind, you must free your mind of gross external mental distractions. That is, you must first take up the higher training of ethics.
Kensur Rinpoche says in the same way as one needs a sharp axe, which is the higher training of wisdom to cut a tree, one also needs to strike the tree again and again in the same place. This is the perfection of meditative concentration, the second of the trainings. Not only that, one needs a powerful body, a strong-arm. This is a higher training of ethics. Without the higher training of ethics, the mind will not be stable and has no hope.
So one needs a strong stable body, the higher training in ethics. This is the foundation of the three practices, the three trainings. To summarize, the sūtra requested by Brahma as quoted in as Śrāvakabhūmi tells us, the things to have, a very stable root, rejoicing in a pace of pacified mind and the ārya view, things not to have to views of the sinful. So says his view of the arias is a direct understanding of emptiness, direct perception of emptiness. So to perceive the emptiness directly, we need the perfection of concentration.
Returning to the text, this is in order to develop the antidote grasping at true existence, especially insight that possesses the ārya view, understanding the true mode of existence, emptiness, you must first achieve mental quiescence. And if you do not follow the high training of ethics, you will not have all the requisite causes for mental quiescence. From Nāgārjuna’s letter, if your hair are closed, you suddenly catch fire. Give up putting them out. Strive instead to stop reincarnation.
There can be no other aim as great. Do not backslide on the quest for peaceful, subdued, stainless nirvana. For pure ethics and and wisdom, achieve it. nirvana is without earth, water, fire, wind, sun, and moon. The main things to be practiced in the medium scope are the three high trainings, so I would have to discuss them at this point if I were not going to teach the great scope meditation topics.
However, this is only a teaching on the medium scope and the shared part of the path, not on the actual medium scope. So I will discuss two of the high trainings, single point of concentration and wisdom in the mental quiescence and special insight sections of the great scope. That leaves only the high training of ethics to be discussed as the traditional way of teaching. So can you this is not a teaching on the actual path of the being of middling scope. It is a teaching on the practice of bodhisattvas who are traveling on the path of the being of meddling scope.
In other words, they share part of the path with the beings of meddling scope, but this is not their actual path. As it says in Nāgārjuna’s letter, as both animate and inanimate are supported by the earth, so ethics was said to be the foundation of all good qualities. In other words, ethics are vital because they’re the basis of all good qualities. They’re the Buddha’s fundamental teaching. Ethics are more beneficial if we keep them, but there are enormous drawbacks if they are not kept.
The benefit lies in keeping them. Thank you so much. He says this applies to all forms of practice all the way up to an Uttara Yoga tantra. .
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- four types of grasping
- They are: grasping at sense pleasures, grasping at the wrong view of denying what exists, grasping at the wrong view of holding our own beliefs as superior and grasping at the wrong view of the sense of a self-existent I. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.