Lam Rim – T21 – Tape 21 – KR

1 h 33 min · 8,596 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - T21 - Tape 21 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues a Lam Rim teaching on the path of the medium-scope being, with renunciation as the main practice and bodhichitta as the foundation. It explains how delusions arise, their six root types (attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, doubt, wrong views), their causes and drawbacks, and how karma and delusion drive rebirth. It closes by describing how dying thoughts trigger the next rebirth.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 34m

UUID: 3256e8b4-d9ab-4a0e-88e4-3c82534cda31

Words: 8,592

Okay. It’s not counting. Yes. Yes. Then we just move it.

Okay. Yep. Okay. And now Please resume? No.

Oh, yeah. It stops. It stops. It stops at the So It’s moving. Think Does it say hold?

Yeah. I think it’s hold. It’s hold. So with the motivation of attaining full enlightenment for the sake of all the suffering mothers and human beings, One engages in the practice of these graded stages of the path. So with this motivation for being mindful of the kindness of the teachers.

All the teachers of the path, we endeavor to attain the Buddha ground. In particular, being mindful of the kindness of Anadhatisha and Je Tsongkhapa and all the great teachers who transmitted this text on these practices. As previously, will recite the outline we have covered in the last couple of days. Starting with how to rely on the spiritual guide, which is the foundation of the path, page seven thirty five of your text. But she is giving the general outlines of the divisions of the path and the beings of small, medium, and great scope.

Now within the context of the being of medium scope, in other words, the beings who are endeavoring to attain liberation from cyclic existence, We have covered most of these outlines yesterday. So it is continuing with the quote of Je Tsongkhapa we had covered yesterday. After such meditations, when you do not long for of for even a moment, when your thoughts day and night always yearn for liberation, you have developed renunciation. So the marvels of cyclic existence to which the text is alluding is all the various aspects of psychic existence which we have learned to classify into the category of suffering, aging, death, and so forth. So even though we are practicing at the level of the being of medium scope, the main focus of our practice is attainment of full enlightenment.

So we are only sharing the path of the being of medium scope. So the principle practice that even at this level remains the practice of bodhichitta. And for this, we must endeavor to generate the great compassion. So returning to the transmission of the text. For us to receive Buddhahood, we must have bodhichitta.

To have bodhichitta, we must first have compassion. To have this, we must first recognize that all sentient beings have been our mothers. We must develop renunciation by meditation meditating on our own samsaric suffering, and then develop compassion by meditating on other sufferings. So at this level of the path, it is through meditating on the sufferings of other and applying our thoughts of renunciation to them that we develop the various aspects of the path which are shared with the practitioner of the great vehicle. Returning to the text, this is certainly not the case that the great scope section has no meditation on renunciation.

So says that at the level of the practitioner of medium capacity, renunciation is the main practice. Whereas at the level of the of great capacity, it’s the development of bodhichitta, which is the main practice. And the other is merely a branch of it. Other practices that is developing the view which realizes emptiness and which is a means to meditate on the view, are practiced mainly at the prime level of the practitioner of great scope. So says, at the time of the practitioner of small scope, we must have a strong motivation.

At the time of a practitioner of middling scope, we must also have a strong motivation, and likewise at the time of the practitioner of great scope. But these motivates these motivations are somewhat different. At the time of the practitioner of being of small scope, our motivation must be the realization of the suffering of the lower realms and impermanence. Now the text says, we must this motivation, etcetera. The etcetera means that there are other factors apart from the ones we just mentioned regarding the motivation.

Now for instance, at the level of the practitioner’s middling capacity, we are relying on the practice and the understanding of the four noble truths. And the etcetera in that context means that there are other thoughts such as, for instance, the peerless motivation, which is actually characteristic of the great vehicle, which are also part of this motivation. So the time of the practitioner of small scope, bodhichitta is nonetheless present. Since we are traveling a path which is shared with the practitioner of small scope, but is not merely a path of the practitioner of small scope. And therefore, bodhichitta, the great compassion, must be conjoined with the practice of the being of small scope, and they are, as it were, branches of this practice.

So at the time of the practitioner of middling scope, what is the virtue we accumulated must be must be directed towards liberation from the cycle of existences. So even though we might enjoy the happiness of not being reborn in the realms, the practitioner at the level of the practitioner of middling scope realizes that wherever he is reborn is merely of the nature of psychic existence. So without the thought of renunciation, which is a rejection of psychic existence, then it is basically meaningless to talk of any practice since this is the foundation of all practice. Returning to the text, nevertheless, renunciation is a principal path in the medium scope section. When we have developed renunciation in our mind stream, any virtue we create will be a cause for liberation.

As long as we have not developed even a contrived, another without official form of renunciation, any virtue we create will usually only turn saṃsāra’s wheel. An exception to this is virtue created independence on the power of a merit field. If we do not take the three fundamentals of the path seriously, if we ignore them, any profound dharma we put into effort, meditation on the energy winds and their channels, meditation on the deities, recitation of the mantras, and so on, will not become even part of a path leading to liberation or omissions. So before we embark on anything with a claim to being profound, it is vital that we work as hard as we can on renunciation, bodhichitta, and the correct view. These are the three principles of the path, says Kunzang Vajra.

So if we have developed renunciation in our mind stream, any virtue we generate becomes automatically a cause for nirvana. On the other hand, if we have developed a bodhichitta in our mind streams, then any virtue we generate becomes automatically a cause for full enlightenment. Secondly, ascertaining the nature of the path leading to liberation. Within blue text, there’s two sections thinking about the source of suffering, the stages forcing one into saṃsāra, and two, actually ascertaining the nature of the path leading to liberation. First, this is three subheadings.

How delusions are developed, how calm is accumulated, how one leaves one rebirth at death and is conceived in another. How delusions are developed. This has four sections. So, again, the number two is the main antidote to delusions is the wisdom which understands selflessness. This is the antidote we must apply foremost.

Now returning to the four sections. Four sections are the identification of delusions, the stages in their development, the cause of delusions, and drawbacks of delusions. There are two ways of fitting the heading, thinking about the source of suffering, the stages forcing one into saṃsāra, one way is to attach it to an earlier heading. The way used here follows the traditional discourse on the swift path and the easy path and puts a heading under ascertaining the nature of the path leading to liberation. So we will follow the second way of doing it at present.

Turning to the text, we should first think about the genuine specific drawbacks of saṃsāra, become moved to renounce it, and develop a wish to be liberated from it. But the says that the meditation on the drawbacks of cyclic existence is indispensable to create the requisite motivation. Returning to the text, you will then wonder, what is the cause of saṃsāra? After investigating the cause and becoming acquainted with it, you will then want to break its continuity. So it is indispensable to understand the causes and the defects of such existence.

So if we do not understand this, we will not develop the desire to cut the continuum of cyclic existence. Returning to the text, the origin of suffering has two parts, originating delusions and originating karma. So the root of suffering, the first truth, is the second truth, the truth of origination. The second truth has two parts, karma and delusion. So what is the root of the all-pervasive suffering we endure?

It is the four of the five afflicted aggregates. The cause of the four of the five aggregates is karma. The cause of karma is delusion. In other words, returning to the text, you must carry the burden of the afflicted aggregates, and karma is responsible. Karma developed because of delusions.

You’ve accumulated immeasurable karma in the past. But without the delusions of craving clinging as a maternity subsidiary cause, karma cannot on its own throw you into another rebirth. It would be like a seed without moisture. So can you know what this is? We must be very clear that without the afflictions, karma in and of itself will not be operational.

So delusions and afflictions are as it were the motor of psychic existence. They make these seeds, which are in our minds operational. Returning to the text. Yes. Even if you cannot accumulate a karma from the past, if you have delusions, you will immediately accumulate fresh karma because of these delusions and so receive a set of samsaric aggregates in your next rebirth.

Craving is unique among other aspects of karma, for these other karmas can’t precipitate rebirth being only attendant subsidiaries. But if one has craving, one receive more karma. The root, therefore, of being reborn into saṃsāra is delusion. By delusion, we mean something that through its own power and whenever we develop it has a function of immediately making our mind stream, our personal mental continuum, unpeaceful and unsubdued. Thus, we must identify the delusions.

For not doing so, it’d be like not identifying an enemy which shoots a poisonous arrow. We would not know what antidote to apply to the delusion. So this is really the So the identification of delusions, this has two parts, the root delusions and the secondary delusions. So the characteristic of delusions is that it they make the beings unhappy, miserable, and their minds unstable and tormented. The root delusions from Vassubandhu’s Abhidhamma Kosha, the six root delusions of samsaric existence are attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, wrong views, and doubt.

That is, there are six root delusions, attachment. So says that desire, hatred, ignorance, pride, doubt, and wrong views are these six root delusions. Returning to the text. When we see an attractive jewel, body, food, drink, or whatever, we develop thoughts such as not wanting to be separated from it. Other delusions are like dust on a piece of cloth, easy to remove.

Desire, on the other hand, which means clinging to or being fixated with something, is like oil that has soaked into a piece of cloth, difficult to remove. When, for example, one wants to look at an object, touch it, and so forth, a corner of one’s mind craves and clings to this object of one’s attachment. The attachment then spreads and is difficult to remove. So, Kunzang Vajra says the mind basically seizes the object. That’s very difficult then to separate the mind from the object of desire.

The lasso of craving attachment confines you to saṃsāra’s prison. In other words, attachment is the root that prevents us from being sufficiently moved to renounce saṃsāra and also one of the main things binding us to saṃsāra. So Kunzang Vajra says the antidote to desire is meditation on ugliness or filthiness. Through meditating on the aspects of the body and decomposition, on the open red flesh of the body, of a deceptive body, then it is very easy to block desire. To enter the text, one way to cultivate its antidote is to meditate on the ugly aspects of the body and so on.

Here, you develop the attitude that the body is ugly, that as a corpse it has a bloody aspect, a decomposing aspect, a swelling aspect, and that it will eventually be a skeleton. When you’re attached to someone, for instance, consider how that person is just a sack full of six kinds of filthy substances. When you are attached to eating meat, think how the main ingredient is filthy and how it was prepared by taking a life. Your attachment and craving will then diminish. So says meditate on how the human body is filled with feces, with urine, with grease, with blood, with pus, with fat.

Think how your stomach is an open sewer. It’s like a vase which is filled with feces. All the garbage of the body is there. So when we think that the body is beautiful, think how you basically have a sewer, which is called the intestines, which leads feces and garbage out of the body all day. Whenever you would think that the body of a person is beautiful beautiful or feel desire about that, Meditate on this likewise.

Think of how fluid comes from the nose, saliva from the mouth, and everything in this body is basically dripping and oozing all the time. So this is how we destroy and kill desire. We collect all of the filthy and disgusting substances which constitute the human body. Secondly, anger. Anger is the highly disturbed aspect of the mind that arises when we see something unpleasant, enemies, so forth.

The objects of anger could be sentient beings or inanimate objects. When we involve ourselves with them, they completely disturb and torment our mind, and we wish to harm them. Anger does a great anger damage. It does things like destroying your root merits as if they had been burnt in a fire. Anger is responsible for people taking lives, stabbing or beating others, and so forth.

Nowadays, some people apply sweet sounding names to anger. Her lama is crossed, they say. So says that anger is the greatest of nonvirtues with the exception of wrong views. In one instant, it destroys our root merits. It’s a tremendously powerful non virtue.

That’s why it is said that there is no non virtue like anger. Returning to the text, these people may not reckon that anger is damaging, but as it is said, there is no sin like hostility. There is no austerity like patience, or anger is the weapon to murder your high rebirths. In other words, of all the delusions, anger has the greatest strength to destroy root virtues and is the thing that throws you into the lower realms, and therefore does great damage. There are different ways in which root virtues can be destroyed, and these ways depend on the object.

You must apply the antidotes to anger, being patient, etcetera. I will talk further about anger in the section of the six perfections below. It is permissible, however, to beat your pupils if you do it solely with their benefit in mind and not out of anger. So consideration is let’s be very cautious. It’s only if the mind is totally dedicated to the welfare of the students that one can use these forceful means.

Otherwise, there is only harm. Thirdly, pride. Pride is your inflated opinion of yourself and can manifest in relation to some good or bad object. Your power, wealth, good qualities, family, wisdom, your pure ethics, even your pleasant voice of physical prowess. When you look down from a high mountain, everyone below seems to have shrunk in size.

When you hold yourself to be superior to others and have an inflated opinion of yourself, you take on a superior aspect. It requires only a trivial object to serve as a cause for your developing pride. As the of old says, does much vapor steam off the snow on mountain tops in springtime? See if any comes from the snow in the ravines below. They also said that the mountaintop of pride won’t get flooded with the water of good qualities.

In other words, it is difficult to develop any good qualities at all when one is arrogant. Also, a guru may teach dharma to a person who has pride, but will do no good. The antidote to pride is to think of some list you don’t understand, especially the full classification of the sense elements, which comes from Abhidharma. Occasionally, you should think over every individual internal and external thing that exists from the crown of your head down to your feet. You will not know very many of these, and it ought to destroy your pride.

Fourthly, ignorance. Generally, ignorance, in Tibetan, is the opposite of the word to know, with a negative particle added. Like the verbs to see and not to see or to know and not to know, ignorance is not knowing, not seeing, not understanding, being unclear, and so forth. But it’s like not seeing fire, for instance, because one’s eyes are shut or not seeing objects in total darkness. Ignorance is like blindness, not seeing the nature or mode of existence of something.

The four truths, cause and effect, the three jewels alike. Ignorance is the root of all delusions. So Kunzang Vajra says ignorance is the root of all delusions. So this not seeing seeing the nature of reality or delusions of us. Return to the text, There is one system that asserts that ignorance is similar to the view of the perishable.

Another system asserts that ignorance and this view are separate. For instance, suppose the mistake of taking a rope is a snake is like the view that equates itself with the aggregates. Ignorance would then be like the cause for this mistake, that the coiled rope lies in darkness and that this darkness is responsible for one’s lack of clarity about the mode existence of the rope. The first system was asserted by the former Candrakīrti and Dharmakīrti and others, the second by Asaṇga, and there’s a mistake in the English, and Vasubandhu, his brother. So a conservatory is being requested to make a special offering of the apple juice offered by Genyen Wangchen.

He was wondering whether tea had been offered. First, it hasn’t. Fifthly, doubt. This directed towards the four truths, the three jewels, cause and effect, and so on. One wonders whether they exist or not, whether they are true or not.

Doubt in the three jewels contributes towards preventing us from developing realizations. As a first Dalai Lama, Gendron Roop said, save me from doubt, that terrible ghost, that cruel one who flies in the sky of utter blindness, who harms my yearning for conviction, who murders my liberation. When you doubt the law of cause and effect, it prevents you from attaining high rebirth. Doubt the four truths, and you cannot gain liberation. Doubt, in fact, does a great deal of damage.

As such, it is assumed to be one of the five nonviews that is the first five root delusions. Sixthly, deluded views. There are five deluded views. The view that equates the self with the perishable. This is a deluded view directed towards the aggregates, which have the property of being perishable and which regard them to be the self and to belong to the self, that is I and mine.

An illustration, when people hurt or harm you, the thought, why did they do this to me? Presents itself most vividly to your mind. You grasp at this as if it existed in this way. This is a root of misdeeds. Even ants hold this view, equating the self with the perishable.

If you poke an ant on the nose, the blade of grass, it will immediately sink. What are they doing to me? Hunch up and play dead. Later, it will turn round and run away. The view of equating the self with the perishable caused it to do this.

Secondly, extreme views. These views are directed towards anything grasped by the above-named view of equating the self with the perishable. Extreme views take such things to be permanent, stable, independent, established as being true, and so forth. Viewing views such as regarding the continuity of the I as being discontinued at death are also extreme views. Although it is mainly non Buddhist who hold these views, we may also wrongly regard things as being established as true or regard things in other equally silly ways.

The view of holding the aggregates to be supreme, this is a deluded view deriving from any of the above mentioned wrong views. Those equating the self with the perishable or those holding things to be permanent or nonexistent, this delusion is directed towards the aggregates of the holder of these views, and it takes these aggregates to be supreme. Four, holding an ethic or mode of behavior to be supreme. This view is taking, for instance, the cultivation of the five fires, jumping over tridents, the ethic of standing on one leg, and so on to be paths to liberation. It could also be holding some mode of behavior to be supreme, such as sitting on an animal hide.

Some people perceive by subtle clairvoyance that they were a dog in their previous life, and this blinds them. They want to receive a human body in their next life. So mistaking being a dog as the cause, they emanate many canine actions, bark and so forth. They take this to be supreme, and so make their body and speech perform these evils. People pursue these evil ethics because, for instance, they hold that such things are the main cause of liberation.

Wrong views. These many comprise a view that the four truths, three jewels, cause and effect, and so forth do not exist. Two things should be considered here, exaggeration or imputation, where something nonexistent is supposed to exist, and denial, where something existent is supposed not to exist, but when holds a view that the things do not exist at all. Some non Buddhist claim that the world was created by Vishnu, who incarnated 10 times into the world. The Samkhyas divide all knowables into 25 categories and hold that, generally speaking, these 25 principles created the world.

Others assert that the world was created by Ishvara and so on. These people claim that something was created when it was not. So these are exaggerations. Wrong views, however, are denials. Count these five types of wrong view as one, add them to the five non-views.

The resulting six make up the six root delusions. Delusions. If you are an ordinary being, you should apply your antidotes. Still, as the Chattushattaka says, just like the sense faculties in the body, ignorance resides in them all. In other words, ignorance pervades and acts as cause for all the other delusions.

However, ignorance is difficult to identify, so I will discuss it below. Secondly, the stages of the development of the delusions. So at this level, we will explain the mode of generation of the delusions. The six with delusions, returning to the text, in fact, all delusions derive fundamentally from grasping at the self and the view equating the self with perishable. All suffering, all karma, and all delusion therefore derive from this view.

According to the Prāsaṇgika madhyamika system, the view of equating the self with the perishable is the root. There are intellectual and instinctive views, and here this view is of the later kind. There are two types of instinctive views, grasping at I and grasping at mine. The view of equating the self with the perishable is a grasping at mine. When someone compliments you or whatever, you think, how very nice of him to say that of me.

This I and me are very vivid and very deep seated within the mind. Because we have these thoughts, we take them to be the self, and the notion that this self is a user arises. Because of this, we cling to the I, grow attached to those who help us, angry at people who harm us, and have ignorance towards strangers. So this view of the person, consumer, what gives rise to the sense of I and mine. We feel desire towards those who help us and hatred towards those who harm us.

Returning to the text the Pramanavartika, you know people as others because you’re supposed to have a self. You grasp at the perishaph in others and become hostile. These are all related. All misdeeds derived from them. From Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra, may my mind perceive that every faulty delusion derives from views that equate the self with the aggregates.

At first I clung to the self, the I, and develop attachment to things to them. Although the root of the six subtle and extensive root delusions is ignorance, one develops attachment, hostility, doubt, and so forth, in dependence on the view of equating the self with the perishable. And in dependence on attachment, creates karma and in dependence on this karma, one turns on the wheel. The roots of saṃsāra: ignorance, the instinctive grasping at the I, the view that the self is a perishable set of aggregates. To abandon delusion for good, one must work hard at applying the antidote to ignorance and to grasping at the self.

That is the wisdom that understands selflessness. The wisdom that understands selflessness is like a medicine, Therefore, that can destroy hundreds of evils. Kunzang Vajra says that ignorance apprehends the self as inherently existing. The wisdom of selflessness is a direct antidote to this in that it apprehends the self as not inherently existing. From the Chattushattaka, So in a nutshell, ignorance is the root of all delusions.

When the ignorance increases, and naturally, all delusions increase with it. Returning to the 400 verses of that is why all delusions are conquered when ignorance is conquered from the sūtra in the Ten Stages. In this world, all misdeeds ever committed came from manifest clinging to a self. Without manifest clinging to a self, these would not happen. Or the same until one understands selflessness, one must employ some means to suppress delusions in order to be temporarily rid of them.

One must prevent their cause, and so Thirdly, the causes of delusions. Why is it important to understand the causes of delusions? Remember what Kunzang Vajra says? Because if we can eliminate the cause, the the effect will not arise. Therefore, all we have to do is eliminate the cause of delusions and the effect, the delusions themselves, will not arise.

The first cause of delusion is their foundation or the base. The base consists of seeds or latencies. Just as when one is unable to uproot the seeds of illness, even the smallest piece of food would provoke illness. So So this example is very clear. If we cannot eliminate the very root cause of a physical illness, then we may eat good food to be beneficial, and it will be of no use to us.

It’ll just make us feel sick. Returning to the text. So when one meets with a certain condition, one will readily develop delusion in one’s mind stream because one has the seeds of delusions. These seeds, Kunzang Vajra says, are the karmic imprints, the vasanas. As soon as the conditions arise, these karmic imprints give rise to delusions.

So this is why these karmic imprints are called seeds. If we do not destroy them, then the moment the conditions are ripe, these karmic seeds ripen. So these karmic imprints are the root of delusions. Secondly, their object. This could be something pleasant, unpleasant, or whatever.

When we meet with these things because we have not abandoned the seeds of delusions, as Vasubandhu’s Abhidhamma Kosha says, not abandoning delusions, both subtle and extensive. So this by saying that if we do not meet the cause of something pleasant, then anger spontaneously arises in our mind. Returning to quote from the Vinayasūtra, not abandoning delusion, but some and extensive remaining in proximity of the objects and carrying our unrealistic thinking, these are the full set of causes for delusion. So we want to prevent these from arising. Second, Kunzang Vajra says for us, especially who are beginners, it’s important not to meet the object which gives rise to desire or anger.

We just close our eyes when an object of anger, an object of desire appears, then neither anger nor desire will appear because the object is absent. This is for beginners such as ourselves a simple and effective way of blocking the arrival of delusions. So it’s extremely important, Kunzang Vajra says, not to encounter the object which generates delusions. Returning to the text, in other words, we must distance ourselves from the object of delusions and we’ll otherwise develop delusions.

Ordained people should avoid them by living in monasteries, hermitage, and so forth. It is beneficial for us beginners that we will not develop delusions if we do not see these subjects of delusions for a while. We should therefore avoid them as much as we can in some mind training texts we find. He who still applies antidotes should chiefly abandon these evil objects. So, Conserva Jay says, just controlling the eye sense organ and not seeing the objects of delusion is an extremely simple and effective way of progressively taming our minds.

But if we don’t apply the antidotes, then, unfortunately, the delusions will naturally arise. And as Sangha said, abandon evil objects and delusions will gradually be veiled because you have no distractions. Virtuous practices gradually increase because your mind is cleansed. You will gain conviction in the dharma. Cultivating solitude is a task of a child of the victorious ones.

So we should endeavor to purify our mind stream. It is on this basis to purifying the mind that we will progressively eliminate delusions. In other words, it is vital to abandon the objects that develop delusions and to stay in some secluded place for this. The third cause is society or gatherings. So conservatory says a lot of desire, hatred arises when we meet people and socialize.

So it is very beneficial for us to dramatically reduce our socializing. Returning to the text, you should abandon the preoccupations of bad company. However, everyone involved in this life is bad company since their conversations about things that cause delusions, alcohol, games, and so on. You should not heed such people or be influenced by them. If you don’t do this and fall under their influence, they will increase your delusions, and you will participate in unbecoming actions.

An illustration, there were once two people from the kingdom of Pembo. One drank alcohol and the other did not. The drinker went to Rathryn. The nondrinker to Lhasa. The one in Rathri met the Kadampa Geshes.

The one who went to Lhasa fell in with bad company. The two men later met. And because of the influence of good and bad company, the man who used to drink had now given it up, and the former nondrinker now drank alcohol. We call miserliness swift and anger being cross, being rash, and so forth. So this is very common nowadays, this habit of applying euphemisms all over the place.

We give them these sweet sounding names, but they still do great damage. When pupils depend on a stingy teacher who is tight fisted with all his possessions, the miserliness of the pupils increases. We can all see this in the monasteries, can’t we? And the same the same goes for bad tempered teachers. It’s all too easy to understand the activities of bad company, so we must abandon such company.

All the same, although the people who yearn for the things of this life are usually nothing but bad company, we cannot forsake everyone. So it is vital that we treat such people with caution. So, unfortunately, most of the people we will meet are bad friends, so we must be very cautious Returning to the text. We should not associate with them too much. There was once a country where everyone drank the water of madness and became insane.

Only the king was left sane, but the others said, the king is mad. Similarly, these days, dharma practitioners do not conform with the common herd, but this does no damage, for they wish to reach out to pursue and to succeed in their practices. When bad friends advise you, do not contradict them. Be like a stubborn old yak and practice the most prized possession of the kadampas. First, Vajra obstinacy.

Then bolster yourself with Vajra primal wisdom and find a common Vajra recklessness. It will be better to translate this as Vajra shamelessness. The fourth course, delusion discussions. This involves reading books which give instructions that seem plausible but still generate delusions. When you read these evil works, such as the folktale exploits of Gessar of Ling, treatises on love, anthologies of tantric spells or sex positions, and so forth, they make your attachment, hostility, and benighted ignorance increase.

But you think over the deeds and life stories of the saints, this can implant the seeds of liberation in you. You should therefore read such stories. When people get together in groups, they talk about many things that increase attachment or hostility, like the king, the army, women, lawsuits, and so on. This is also a cause to develop delusions. The fifth cause, familiarity.

Said, you are as if wrapped in instincts from your familiarity with evil thoughts. In other words, owing to your great familiarity, With delusions, you develop attachment hostility and so on as a matter of course even when distracted. In other words, we are basically almost powerless to prevent the arising of these delusions because of our great familiarity with them since the beginningless time. But in the text, we have great or small delusions according to our greatest more familiarity with them in past lives. Some people develop.

So, Kunzang Vajra says, we see this with people who have a very short fuse. It takes the slightest pretext for them to blow up. So it is as if we have developed great familiarity with the various delusions in past lives, and then in this life, the these delusions become very powerful because of our familiarity with them. And if we keep developing familiarity with them, then they will keep on increasing in power. So if we do not apply the antidotes, there will be no end to these delusions.

Then the text, some people develop great attachment, hostility, whatever at the slightest pretext. So, whenever a delusion arises, then we should immediately ascertain what delusion this is and apply immediately the antidote. For instance, if great heat arises, to eliminate the heat, we apply code. However, if it is extremely cold, to eliminate the cold, we must apply heat. Likewise, through analysis, we must ascertain which of the delusions is dominant and immediately apply the antidote, the requisite antidote, to eliminate it.

For instance, returning to the text, people familiar with anger can’t even tolerate a dirty look and so forth. There is nothing for such people but to apply some antidote and do what they can to prevent these delusions continuing. The sixth cause, the English translation is a bit unfortunate. We should translate it as wrong recollection. Recollection involves the constant exaggeration of remembering that makes one one that one makes concerning the object of one’s attachment, hostility, and so forth.

Regarding the object of one’s attachment, clothing, for instance, one thinks that they have fine colors, a beautiful cut, a lovely belt, and so on. Regarding the object of one’s hostility, one thinks they did to me this and this harm, and afterwards this, that, and that to me. One thinks over and over again about these pleasant or unpleasant objects. A person may be a dharma practitioner, but he will still suffer or experience problems, and so may doubt the law of cause and effect. He will develop delusions if the above causes arise, so he must do what he can to prevent them.

If he does not apply the antidotes, his delusions will increase. They will be overshadowed if he applies the antidotes, so work hard at this. So council member says we should not despair through the application of the antidotes. The delusions will steadily decrease, and it will become ever easier for us. If we don’t apply the antidotes, however, they will steadily increase, and it will become steadily more difficult for us.

Fourthly, the disadvantages of the delusions, the drawbacks of the delusions from the sūtra Nāgārjuna. Delusions destroy you, destroy sentient beings, destroy your ethics. You hold your equals as inferior. Guardians and teachers criticize you, and you will you don’t heed opponents. You will be born in unconducive states.

Your acquisitions and non acquisitions will decline, and you’ll have great suffering. In other words, delusions have many drawbacks. When a delusion arises in your mind stream, it becomes nonvirtuous. So says, all of these non virtues, which include among others the view of the perishable and ignorance, they are obviously non virtuous because they disturb our mind stream. Our mind becomes of one nature with a non virtuous phenomenon.

Returning to the text, your mind stream becomes a non virtuous entity. You then act perversely towards the objects of the delusions. This makes the latent seeds of the delusions take hold. So we will continually develop the same sort of delusions that is attachment, clinging to whatever, and into states forbidden by the holy beings. The unfortunate karmic actions will increase because of these last two drawbacks.

We stray away from both liberation and omniscience, becoming distance from them. Delusion causes your virtuous actions to decline. In other words, it makes you wrong yourself and wrong others. It makes your ethics decline. You will be given fewer gifts and be paid less service.

Even the Buddhas and dharma protectors will criticize you, other beings as well, as you will suffer because your delusion makes other people want to kill you, and so on. In this life, you develop a worse reputation if because of becoming embroiled in lawsuits, arguments, and so forth. And in future lives, you will be reborn in remote lands or in the lower realms. To summarize, there are an infinite number of drawbacks, and they are all said to be produced by delusions. So when you develop these delusions, you must immediately recognize them clearly as your enemies and employ some means of putting a stop to them from the bodhisattva.

So consider Burchase says first enemy is the delusions. We foolish people, we actually do not know who our enemy is. We think that others are our enemies. Others can do us no harm. They are our parents.

Our enemy, our true enemy, is our own mind. Laughable when we say others are enemies. Our enemy is straight within ourselves. From the bodhisattva, all the gods and demigods were to become your enemies, even they would be unable to lead you to the fires of the Avici hell. So, Kunzang Vajra says the most powerful beings in the cosmos, will be unable to push us into the lower realms.

We ourselves, however, are very capable of doing this. Delusions are the strongest foe because whenever you meet with them, they may in but a moment cast you there till not even rubble from Mount Meru remains. So Kunzang Vajra says when we talk of Arhat, which in Tibetan is translated as, destroyer of the enemy, the term refers to the delusions, which are what the have destroyed. So Kunzang Vajra says, what do we mean by an evil mind? We mean by an evil mind, a mind whose cause is delusions.

What do we mean by a mind which is not evil, which could be a neutral or virtuous mind? We mean by such a mind a mind whose cause is not the delusions. Returning to the text, in other words, there is no more powerful enemy than these. When you accommodate your foe, it may pacify his anger, and he will not harm you in return. The Tibetan reads actually when you praise your opponent.

It may pacify his anger, and he will not harm you in return. So says, if we praise our ordinary opponents, if we develop love or compassion for them, then they will not harm us. They will turn around. This is not the case of delusions. They are relentless.

To the text, all the myriad sufferings you had when you were burned by the fires of the hell without respite were created by delusion. Henceforth, delusions was forced to have listened to some sirens, so they are more powerful than all your enemies in the three realms. The Qadambas have all said, train to stand at the attack against delusions, but to extend your hand to sentient beings and benefit them. Geshe Ben Gungyel said, I guard the entrance to the Fortress of my mind with a spear, the antidotes. At no time am I not doing this.

When delusions are at the ready, so am I. But they relax, so do I. In other words, you must see delusions as your worst enemy and apply their antidotes right away. So Kunzang Vajra says, we must be absolutely ruthless with delusions, and we must be extraordinarily compassionate with sentient beings. Secondly, how these are accumulated.

So we by this, what are the causes? What sort of karma gives rise to this? Returning to the text, are two types of karma, mental karma and intentional karma. Mental karma, Asaṇga’s Abhidhamma Samuchaya says, what is mental karma? It is a karmic deed of the compositional factors aggregate that makes a thought manifest.

Its function is to engage the mind in the virtuous and nonvirtuous or the neutral. In other words, a mental karmic deed is, for instance, a primary mind. So conservatory says at Agloss that when we talk of the intention, this intention is fluctuating, and the direction of the intention determines the nature of the deed. This has nothing to do with our body, what our hands do, for instance. It is totally dependent on the motivation we set.

In other words, between the text, a mental karmic action is, for instance, a primary mind that provokes us to feel we should speak insulting words. What’s a karmic action of the secondary mind that provokes or encourages us while we are stressing these insulting words? Secondly, intentional karma. This consists of the actions of body and speech motivated by mental karma. As the Abhidharma Kosha says, karma, it is mental or created by the mind.

Mental karma is mental action. It gives rise to the karmic actions of body and speech. Delusion gives rise to its three types of karma, unmeritorious, meritorious, immutable, to take them in order. Unmeritorious karma is karma accumulated for yearning for the things of this life and then acting upon this by killing, etcetera. This type of karma makes one take rebirth in the lower realms.

Meritorious karma is karma accumulated from yearning for sensual happiness in a future life. This karma makes one take rebirth as a desire realm god. Immutable karma is as follows. One repudiates sensual pleasures in future lives, indulges in the happy feeling that comes from single pointed concentration and is thus reborn as a god in the first three jnani concentration states. Or one could even repudiate a happy feeling that develops from single pointed concentration and so yearning for feelings of equanimity, accumulate karma that acts as a cause to be reborn in the fourth dhyana concentration state or higher.

Both meritorious and unmeritorious karma throw one into a rebirth in the desire realm, and the results are variable. For instance, one may have already achieved the bardo state of a being on its way to the hell realms. But through the power of one’s guru, of rituals, of the secret tantras, and so on, one’s Bardo state can be changed so that one is able to receive birth in the upper rounds. Said that if all the people of were to hold their property in common, it will be particularly helpful in the creation of root merits after one of their deaths. In other words, because these lay people would all have the same property, root merits would be especially beneficial to any of their dead colleagues in the bardo.

He was a lay practitioner, and therefore, felt that this collective ownership would be of great benefit to all lay practitioners. So, she says otherwise, any karma accumulated with relation to private properties is only of benefit to oneself and not to others. Returning to the the throwing kamma to be reborn into the higher realms is as follows. Suppose one has already accumulated kamma to be born in the first jnani concentration state.

The kamma will not change instead into kamma to be born in the second jnani concentration state or whatever. This is why such karma is called immutable. From the Abhidhamma Kosha, virtuous karma is karma to be born in the desire realm. So Kunzang Vajra says, in a nutshell, whatever karma we accumulate at this level is the cause of cyclic existence. Returning to the quote: the karma to be born higher is immutable.

This karma is immutable because it will ripen only in these higher levels. Any karma not accumulated in conjunction with one of the three fundamentals of the path, that is renunciation, bodhichitta, and the correct view of emptiness, will only be the cause for saṃsāra. And karma created when you are moved to renounce the three realms of saṃsāra could only become a cause for your liberation. When you give up this life with the thought that you will practice dharma, but do not do this in conjunction with renunciation and so on, you may stay and meditate in some mountain hermitage. But even if you are lucky, you will only receive cause to be reborn in the formless realms or the form realm jnani concentration states.

This is why if you want to practice dharma, it is vital to seek some totally unmistaken instruction. Thirdly, how you leave one rebirth at death and are reconceived in another. This has three sections. What happens at death? Your lifespan may run out.

Your merit may run out. You have not rid yourself of danger. The sūtra and the factors contributing to death mentions nine such factors for death. These and others can kill you. Your dying thoughts activate the karma that will throw you into the next rebirth after that death.

Second, which is there are many such causes which trigger death, unfortunately. What is critical at this juncture at the time of death is the state of the mind. This mind at the time of death will activate whichever impelling karma controls our next rebirth. Returning to the text. Your dying thoughts activate the karma that will throw you to the next rebirth after that death.

The activators of this karma are craving and clinging, and this is what happens. You might feel I’m going to be separated from this body and cling to your present body. So says whatever clinging is present in our mind will then activate with the respective karma. If we have virtuous desires in our mind, virtuous thoughts, then we will be reborn in the higher balance, but this will activate virtuous seeds. The same thing for non virtuous deeds.

Written to the text, craving includes things like desiring heat when you are to be reborn in the hot hells. I mean, So, karma is like a seed. And clinging and thirst, craving, are like the humidity which will lead to the maturation of the seed. Return to the text. The object of this triggering process is your most powerful karma, be it black or white.

If your black and white karma are equal, then the triggering object is whichever of these two types is the most familiar. If the two types are still equal, then whichever type of karma was first will be triggered. So says, if we are at the point of dying, and we feel cold, and we figure, oh my goodness. I’m freezing. And within our mind arises a craving for heat.

That craving for heat activates whichever karma we have to be reborn in the hot hells. And the result of that is rebirth in the hot hells. On the other hand, if at the time of this, we say, good god, I’m just boiling. If only I could be cold, then that craving for cold, that very craving activates whichever karma we have to be reborn in the cold hells. So says, let us not delude ourselves.

We have many such karmic imprints in our minds. We turn into the text. The time when this triggering takes place is while the mind is still active and still has a coarse form of recognition and either virtuous or non virtuous phenomenon. So says, a glossy in earlier part of the text, that if the two karmic imprints in the principal mind are of equal strength, it’s the earliest one which will match mature first. The text.

That is faith, compassion, attachment, anger, etcetera, and you can still be coarse with things by yourself or can be reminded of them by other people. When coarse recognition ceases and while your dying thoughts are subtle, your thoughts are neutral, and you are unable to remember any virtue or known virtue. So says this impending process only occurs more the dying man the course dying mind is present. The subtle mind of death is neutral. So, Kunzang Vajra says, we must endeavor to do our best for our coarse mind at the time of death to be filled with virtuous thoughts.

This is extremely important To recollect one’s teacher, how to generate faith within one’s mind, because this will really be of great benefit. It will activate whichever virtuous imprints we have in our minds. However, if anger arises in our mind, then we are bound to the lower realms. And even if we are monk, we will just be a monk heading straight down. So returning to the text.

When coarse recognition arises, if your dying thoughts are of faith and so on, your virtue will be activated. Is therefore vital to activate virtuous thoughts when your dying thoughts are on the point of participating in this impelling process. You could be a dharma practitioner who continually creates virtue, but if you get angry when you are dying, you activate nonvirtuous dying thoughts and go to the lower realms or into the ripening effect of past nonvirtues. And the same principles would apply to a sinner who continually sins. At this point

Key terms in this teaching

Avici narme (Tib)
The lowest level of hell. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
root delusions mulaklesha (Skt); tsa wä nyonmong (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these are the afflicted or nonvirtuous minds that subsequently lead to the secondary delusions. There are six: attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, afflicted doubt and afflicted view. LYWA
secondary delusions upaklesha (Skt); nye wä nyon mong (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these are the afflicted or nonvirtuous minds that arise in dependence on the root delusions such as attachment, anger and so forth. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top