1 h 30 min · 4,005 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching links the grounds and paths with the Lam Rim through the Four Noble Truths, covering the path of accumulation, the path of preparation and the path of seeing, and the noble truth of cessation as emptiness. It then turns to karmic imprints, their receptacle according to the different tenet schools, and the Q&A that follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 30m
UUID: 0170ff8d-852f-48ba-8ac0-e7706d98d9be
Words: 4,001
Generally speaking, it is very helpful to be able to establish a relationship between Salam, Grounds and Paths, and Lamrim, the graduated stages of the Path. There is such a relationship, but what its mode of existence is, is what we should investigate. So, one sees numerous cases of practitioners who when they focus on the Lamrim, don’t think of Salam and when they focus on Salam, don’t think of Lamrim. But the two are intimately related. Do you understand what the relation is?
What’s the relation? Think by yourself. Think of it. Yeah. Rosie?
Why? Okay. So, broadly speaking it was pretty accurate. What is the actual link, if you wish, between Salam and Lamrim? It is the Four Noble Truths.
So it is the four noble truths, which are the link between salam and lamrim. Then frequently for ourselves, when we study the lamrim, we feel we are not studying Salam. And when we study Salam, we feel we are not studying the Lamrim. We see them as a bit different. So the first noble truth is the noble truth of suffering, and it is through reflecting on the force, the defects of the noble truth of suffering, in other words, of cyclic existence, that uncontrived definite emergence arises.
Now when uncontrived definite emergence has arisen, where is one from the standpoint of Lamrim? One is on the path of the being of the middling scope. Where is one now when one is on the path of the being of the middling scope, this naturally presupposes the preliminary training in the path of the being of the small scope. Where is one precisely from the standpoint of Salam of grounds and paths? There is some debate, and it calls for careful analysis.
But basically, one will have entered the path of accumulation. So, it is not difficult, it’s easy, all of us have studied. When we think in this way, we should understand. So no specific explanations were given regarding the three vehicles that of the solitary realizers, the hearers, sorry, the solitary realizers and the bodhisattvas. But we focused more on the five paths.
The path of accumulation, of preparation, seeing, meditation, and no more learning. Now once one has generated uncontrived definite emergence, then one has entered the path either of a hearer or of a solitary realizer. And when that is focused upon others, at that point, broadly speaking, one would have entered the Mahāyāna. So after reflecting, therefore, on the faults of the noble truth of suffering, in other words of psychic existence, one would have entered the path of accumulation. And it’s important here to link Salam with the Four Noble Truths.
Then one investigates what precisely are the causes of the Noble Truth of suffering. The ultimate cause of the Noble Truth of Suffering are the afflictions which are rooted in grasping at an I. One then investigates to find what is that state of mind whose mode of apprehension is opposite to the grasping at an I, and it is none other than the wisdom which realizes selflessness. And then at this point, one investigates carefully to find what is the powerful antidote which can counteract the ignorance grasping at an I. And this focus on a powerful antidote, which can counteract the ignorance grasping at an I, occurs for sure at the level of the middling path of accumulation.
What is this powerful antidote? It is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight which is focused on emptiness. At the level of the path of accumulation, definitely one will gain a realization of emptiness which starts to oppose ignorance grasping at a self. As was said previously, there are those who, before entering the path, have gained a realization of emptiness. And there are those who have not gained a realization of emptiness before entering the path and who will newly gain a realization of emptiness at the level of the middling path of accumulation.
But at the level of the middling path of accumulation, both will have a realization of emptiness. So this is the preliminary presentation of the grounds and paths in the light of the two first truths, the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. Now we have to broach the noble truth of cessation. I will only do so briefly because it’s a difficult topic. When we speak of the noble truth of cessation, we are referring to emptiness, but not just to any emptiness.
There are two types of emptiness. The emptiness or selflessness of persons, and the emptiness or selflessness of phenomena. Now, when we refer to the emptiness of persons, or the selflessness of persons, we’re referring to the selflessness of the I. In other words, the fact that the I is not established from its own side. And here, there is an intimate relationship between this I and the mind, since the mind, the subtle mind in particular, is the ultimate basis of imputation of this I.
So it is through understanding the emptiness thereof that eventually one will gain the direct realization of emptiness and proceed upwards. So here we will analyze quietly this topic, otherwise, you will get very confused. As you know, Svatāntrika Mādhyamika asserts that emptiness is the mere abandonment, which is an abandonment of the afflictions. It sounds very elegant, but when one investigates, it is quite awkward since for Svatavica Madiamica alone, the selflessness of persons is a conventional phenomenon. Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika on the other hand asserts that the selflessness of persons is just emptiness, and Chitamatra for that matter refers to emptiness as well.
Getting heavy, isn’t it? So according to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the noble truth of cessation is emptiness. This is quite important. So the means to proceed to liberation exists within our mind stream. And it is the I which proceeds to liberation.
Now that is not to say that we are at present liberated. The afflictions are still present within our mind stream. But once one understands the noble truth of cessation, then understanding the fourth noble truth, the noble truth of the path, is fairly straightforward. So at present, it is helpful to try to understand the presentation of the noble truth of cessation from the standpoint of the three turnings of the wheel of the law. The first turning of the wheel of the law focuses mainly on the ascertainment of the four noble truths.
And from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the noble truth cessation within the first turning of the wheel of the law is presented from the standpoint of Prasanika Mādhyamika. Prasanika Mādhyamika also considers that the second turning of the wheel of the law is definitive. Specifically, that the 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sūtra, as well as the vast middling and lesser perfection of wisdom sutras and the heart sūtra are definitive. They consider that Samdhinirmochana sūtra in the third turning of the wheel of the law is not definitive. Now this is at odds with the position of Svatāntrika Mādhyamika, for which, for instance, within the second turning of the wheel of the law, sutras such as the heart sūtra is not definitive.
Now for Chitamatra, the second turning of the wheel of law is interpretative, and the third turning of the wheel of the law, specifically the Samdhinirmochana sūtra, is definitive. So the noble truth of cessation is therefore the object of attainment. What is the means to this object of attainment? It is the noble truth of the path, specifically, the direct realization of emptiness. Now, the realization of emptiness is twofold.
It can either occur nakedly without relying on a meaning generality or it can occur through relying on a meaning generality. So at that point at which one has generated an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight, focused on emptiness by means of a meaning generality, one will have entered the path of preparation. Jorlam in Tibetan, prayogamarga in Sanskrit. It is called or precisely because this preparation involves coming closer to the path of seeing. At the point where after training in the path of preparation, one has generated an inseparable union of calm abiding insight focused on emptiness, which realizes emptiness without a meaning generality, one will have entered the path of seeing.
And then, through repeated habituation with emptiness, one progresses on the path of meditation until one attains a path of no more learning. Now, the noble truth of the path includes the paths of preparation and the path of seeing. So this is how one presents grounds and paths from the standpoint of the four noble truths. So the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering are fully present within our mind stream at present. What is absent, are the noble truths of cessation and of the path.
However, that mind whose nature is such that it enables one to progress to the noble truth of cessation is present within our mind stream. And the noble truth of the path can be trained in. Most of what I explained explained to you, I explained in the light of the questions you ask. Then later on, we will move onwards to the paths of seeing and of meditation. So then I encourage you to reflect on these topics and ask questions in the light of your doubts.
I’m not saying that you have to ask questions for the sake of asking questions, but it is meaningless for myself to explain these topics and for you to just sit there in harmony with me. So you asked questions two times ago regarding karmic imprints, their base of implantation, and their mode of implantation. And since people do forget these topics, I would like to cover them again. As was mentioned, according to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the base of implantation of karmic imprints are the I or the mere I. According to Svatantika Mādhyamika, it is the mental consciousness.
According to Chitamatra, it is the mind basis of all. And for the schools of tenets beneath Chitamatra, it is the mental consciousness. Now the definition of the first limb, the limb of consciousness within the 12 limbs according to Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s treatise on the 12 limbs is a mental consciousness within one cycle of the 12 limbs which functions as a base for karmic imprints. And this definition is particularly informative, since there is not a single school of tenets which does not accept the existence of the 12 limbs of dependent origination. And the first limb of dependent origination, the dependent origination of consciousness is defined as that which is a receptacle for karmic imprints.
So the first limb, the limb of consciousness, which apprehends, has as function to act as receptacle for the karmic imprints, in keeping with Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen’s definition. This is, however, a contingent or short term receptacle for the comic imprints. Since, for instance, considers that the permanent long-term receptacle for comic imprints is a mind basis of all, and considers that the permanent or Lojong receptacle for comic imprints is the mere I. And therefore, as was said, the, first of the 12, limbs is a contingent or temporary, receptacle for imprints. It is not the permanent receptacle for karmic imprints according to Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika.
It is the mere I, which is the permanent receptacle for karmic imprints precisely because it is uninterrupted. The I is a permanent receptacle for karmic imprints, and this can best be understood in the light of an expression you have probably heard, persons in Buddhist philosophy are referred to as the, accumulators of karma and the experiences of the fruition of karma. Now, karma is accumulated at one point within the continuum of a being, but the fruition or the maturation of that karma is experienced at a different point in that continuum. What links to is a continuum of that being. So an example will make this clear, if one has studied well, let’s say in high school under a teacher, then later on when one is 50 or even 60 years old, when one is old, sorry, that’s how it’s said.
I don’t know. One is said to have studied when one was young. Then that means that there is a clear connection, a continuum. This understanding of karmic imprints as a habituation is one we owe to Ārya Asaṇga in one of his treatises. There is an alternate presentation of karmic imprints as potency.
And we can clearly see how this would unfold if we take the example once again of someone who studied, let us say, someone who studied medicine for instance, when he was young, then later on, in later years at age 50 or 60, that person is still the person who uses the studies which were made when he or she was young. There’s a clear continuum. So Ārya Asaṇga asserts in one of his treatises that the mental consciousness is occasionally interrupted, for instance, during deep sleep, or when one faints, or sinks in a coma. This poses no particular problems for Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, which asserts that the receptacle of the karmic imprints is the I or the mere I. But could be problematical for Svatantika Mādhyamika, for which the receptacle of the karmic imprints is indeed the mental consciousness.
It is to be examined, whether Prāsaṇgika and Svatāntrika accept this treatise of Asaṇga as definitive or not. And therefore let us reflect on the relationship between the paths and the four noble truths, and between grounds and paths and the four noble truths. And generate the requisite motivation to receive these teachings. Page one. Then if you have questions, I’ll take a couple of questions.
Sorry, with the Chitimatra view, the mind basis of all what? Like is it the mind basis of all karmic imprints or afflictions or everything or other things? So in Tibetan kun, in Sanskrit alaya, or in English, is a plural. It refers to the fact that this mind is the basis of all karmic imprints, virtuous and non virtuous. And basis refers to the function of this mind to be a receptacle.
Krishna mentioned realizing emptiness nakedly without relying on a meaning generality. What was an example? When we refer to a direct cognizer, we refer for instance to something such as a visual consciousness, which when it perceives a form, in other words, a color and a shape, perceives them nakedly without relying on any meaning generality. Likewise, a direct valid cognizer which perceives emptiness without relying on a meaning generality, perceives emptiness in the same way. So this calls for great habituation since initially, one will have to give rise to an inferentially valid cognizer perceiving emptiness.
This is a mind arisen from thinking. And through repeated habituation, eventually, this will give rise to a mind arisen from meditation, which thanks to further habituation, will give rise to a yogic direct perceiver realizing emptiness. I’m just rereading through notes from about three weeks ago today. I was reading through about karmic imprints and that they are physical or they arise through physical or verbal behavior. But I’m not sure I don’t remember seeing that they arise through mental behavior and I was just wondering or through the mental consciousness.
And I wouldn’t be able to understand that karmic imprints could not arise from the mental consciousness. So could Geshela please explain that? Yes, it’s the same thing. When one refers to karmic imprints, which are accrued to physical and verbal behavior, one refers among others to those accrued to the seven categories of physical and verbal deeds which are to be abandoned. But the same thing can be said for mental activities.
Geshela my question or doubt really is about the basis of implantation of karmic imprints. So I believe in Prāsaṇgika the basis is the mere I which during this slide you said is the five aggregates and after death the subtle mind. So I, given that Prāsaṇgika believes in a continuum of mind from one life to the next, I don’t really understand that distinction. Why don’t they say they’re just on the basis of implantation is the continuum of mind? So, what was explained was that precisely because the mental consciousness is, absent or interrupted during deep sleep and during the state of coma when one faints, then such a support would be inappropriate for the karmic imprints, which risk to be lost in the process.
And therefore, the only appropriate support would be the mere I. So I’ll dedicate further thought to it since all of this rests on a passage from Asaṇga’s Śrāvakabhūmi in which he asserts that, during deep sleep and, the state of coma, come excuse me, the mental consciousness is interrupted. Now everything hinges on whether Svatāntrika Mādhyamika and Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika accept this passage of Śrāvakabhūmi as literal or not. If they accept it as literal, they must posit another receptacle for the karmic imprint. If they do not, however, they, would not have to.
So this is something we’re to investigate quietly. And it’s not good to just decide this by yourself. We will think about it, discuss about it with others, and study. You have remarkable favorable conditions here in the existence of the discussion group, during which you can discuss these topics and try to gain an understanding. And another?
Could Geshela please explain why there’s an increasing nature with karmic imprints? Increasing nature with karmic imprints? So this is just my own opinion on the topic and we will develop it further later on. The first instant after the performance of a deed, a karmic imprint is implanted. Now unless this karmic imprint is purified by the four opponent forces immediately, it is in its nature to increase.
If it is purified by the four opponent forces, it will no longer increase. Its increase is several. So in this respect, it is different, let’s say, from money. Unfortunately, if we fall asleep and there’s money on the table, when we wake up, it will not have increased. So, I don’t remember this exactly.
It is a second characteristic, second general characteristic of karma. And another. What is the mechanism for that amplification? So I’d give first an example to give you a sense of what’s happening. If we have, let’s say, one and we don’t do anything with it, then it is not going to increase.
It will remain the same. On the other hand, if we have a dollar wherever we invest it, it will increase over time. It’s a bit the same thing with comic imprints. Then why this is the case? I think it is linked to the fact that through habit, we develop more and more of a proclivity to do things.
What I’m trying to understand, have we been talking about that the mind’s interrupted during big sleep and coma, and therefore that’s why karmic imprints don’t exist in the mind. Like so what I’m trying to grapple with is understanding, like, in those states, we actually I’m assuming we don’t create any karma or we can create karma? In deep sleep, and here we must be very clear, deep sleep is the sleep in which there are no dreams or mental activity of any type. Then, I believe, we cannot accumulate karma. In deep sleep, technically, the mental consciousness is non manifest.
It exists, but it is non manifest. Therefore, if it exists but is not manifest, surely the karmic imprints could be stored there. Yes. If the it does exist, then we could posit it as a receptacle for comic imprints. So obviously, the debate here is if someone is in deep sleep, he is sleeping.
Sleep is a mental factor. If there is a mental factor, then the main mind of which it is a mental factor must exist. Do you understand? Not the soliton, they are aware of soliton. So it’s good to think about that a little bit.
Just following on from Steve’s question, also the person in deep sleep or in a coma or who’s fainted will be the accumulator or the, sorry, the experience of karma depending on the circumstances surrounding those states and the individual. At that point, he such a person is not the actual accumulator of karma, even though in general, such a person is both the accumulator of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma. Definitely the the experience of the accumulation of karma, of the fruition of karma. Ken, could you pass Mone. I guess, can we just try and clarify terms?
This mental consciousness that might not exist in deep sleep and a coma, are we talking about the same mental consciousness that the lower schools say, well from Svatrenfied downwards, say is the person? Yes. Setting aside the Chitamatrans, who are the subschool which asserts eight collections of consciousness, the mental consciousness is the instance of the person for those schools. So if, at that point in deep sleep, sleep is a mental factor, then its corresponding main mind exists, and that corresponding corresponding main mind would have to be a mental consciousness. And Ralph, have you got questions?
Not too much. Few questions. Few words. Few words? I would like to return to Molly’s initial question which is whether the Prasangikas believe that is the subtle mind that is the store of karma, karmic imprints or the tainted contaminated five aggregates.
Because upon death, it cannot be the five aggregates other than the subtle mind. So why don’t we just simply call it quits and just say it stays with the subtle mind to begin with and stays there? Exactly. I don’t think it was I I got the impression it wasn’t fully answered and like to return to it. And you say So, no, the fundamental mind cannot be the receptacle of karmic imprints for Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, simply because some of the karmic imprints are contaminated, the non virtuous karmic imprints.
And there must be a compatibility between the karmic imprints and the receptacle of the karmic imprints. So if the karmic imprints are contaminated, then the fundamental mind, which is the receptacle of the karmic imprints, would have to be contaminated too. And the fundamental mind, obviously, cannot be said to be contaminated. That would be very odd. So you can understand with the example of my little table.
Everything which I put on my little table must be a course form precisely because my little table is a course form itself. Compatibility is required between what rests on my little table and the support. So what is the contaminated mere I which is the receptacle for the karmic imprints between lives? Yes. Why not?
I mean, the contaminated mere I between lives would be contaminated. But, yeah, just need to please. So I would like to point something out. We are presenting this topic from the standpoint of the Pāramitāyāna, not from the standpoint of Tantrayāna. In Paramithayana, is no such thing as a fundamental mind.
It is not accepted at all. There is some very, very slight reference to tantric concepts in Pāramitāyāna, but very slight indeed. And the reason for this is that in Paramithayana, form, in other words matter and consciousness, are totally contradictory. Now this is not the case in tantra. In tantra, the subtle mind rides on a wind which is form in nature.
Now ultimately, obviously, we rely on Anuttara Yoga tantra. Now what is it? You actually just answered my question with what you said. Good. Thank you.
Stop here tonight. Thank you so very much. Just to remind people that the symposium is coming up very quickly in a couple of weeks time. Saturday the sixth, empathy and altruism with Vasilis Dalivo, Pamela Lyon, and Ilia. So I’m gonna start thinking about registering.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.