Lam Rim – MLR 2 May – KR

1 h 25 min · 3,688 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - MLR 2 May - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues the Lam Rim teaching on the six recognitions a practitioner needs: seeing oneself as sick, the teacher as doctor, the teachings as medicine, and the need to practise earnestly. It then covers how to listen to teachings with the right motivation and how a teacher should explain the Dharma purely, without seeking fame or gain.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 25m

UUID: 70dbc930-c6ef-403d-82db-1d036a8a0ce0

Words: 3,684

So we will generate as usual the motivation for listening to these teachings, which is the motivation of bodhichitta, a wish to attain the state of full enlightenment for the sake of all suffering mother sentient beings. So we will perform as usual the invitation of Buddha Śākyamūni to dwell on our crown and perform the three purifications which we usually perform visualizing light and nectar emanating from the Buddha’s body and purifying our body, speech, mind the downward voiding, the voiding through the mouth, and purifying all the obstructions at the heart. And then in whichever way we ourselves feel comfortable with, we will visualize Buddha’s ceremony dissolving within us and abiding at the level of our heart. And at this point, we will imagine that we have received an uncommon blessing to generate the path of the bodhisattva within our mind streams. So we have finished, as you remember, the presentation of the four greatnesses of Lam Rim, and in turn have entered the presentation of how to listen to the teachings.

Geshela explained last time the three faults of the vase, and at present, we will be broaching the six recognitions of the six discriminations, which are on page 58 of your English translation of the greater. And these six recognitions are first to recognize oneself as a sick person. Secondly, to recognize the teachings of dharma as medicine. Thirdly to recognize the teacher of the teachings as a doctor. Fourthly to give rise to that definite awareness that since one is sick one must practice.

Fifthly to generate the awareness of the Tathagatas as holy beings and sixthly to generate the awareness which wishes to abide longly or durably within the context of dharma practice. So if we lack the first of the recognitions, which is a recognition of ourselves as sick or troubled, then we will not wish to practice dharma. Therefore, this is the foundation of the six recognitions and Geshela will explain them one by one. So it is not the case that there are there is a very high standard for the listeners to dharma teachings and just anybody can teach far from there. The listeners themselves must have a six recognitions, recognitions, but the teacher must have far greater qualities than this to be allowed to teach and quite frankly Geshela says a minimum for teaching Lamrim is the uncontrived spontaneous experience experience of both renunciation and bodhichitta.

If those two are not present, it is difficult, he feels, to teach Lamrim correctly. So you can refer to other texts to understand the qualifications of those who presume to teach. Teach. So the presentation of the first recognition called the first idea in your English translation is at the very bottom of page 56. Śāntideva’s engaging in the bodhisattva deed says, since you must follow a doctor’s advice even when stricken by ordinary illness.

So ordinary illness here, Geshela says, is actually a metaphor for the illness of the afflictions. What need is there to mention those who are constantly stricken with the illness of so many faults, attachments, and so forth. Ashantideva says, you have been sick for a long time with the illness of the afflictions, so this is a disease from which we have suffered for countless lives such as attachment, an illness that is intractable and causes strong suffering. Therefore, you must recognize this to be your situation. Kamapa Geshe says, was a great Kadampa Geshe, said that if we were not in fact sick, then meditating on a sick condition would be misguided.

So if in fact, we were not afflicted by the of mental afflictions, then it would be inappropriate to meditate. There would be no need to meditate. But since this is not the case, then we must meditate. And this is explanation of the first of the six recognitions. And the second outline on page 59 is to think of the spiritual teacher as a doctor.

For instance, when you’re stricken by a severe illness such as diseases of traditional Tibetan medicine, wind or bile disorder, you seek a skilled doctor. So the first step, Geshela says is to seek a teacher, a skilled doctor. And upon actually not consulting but meeting your doctor, you are greatly delighted and listen to whatever your doctor says, revering him or her respectfully. So at this point when one has found such a doctor, great joy arises within one’s mind and then one engages in activities of hearing and of thinking about what the doctor tells us to do, in this case, what the spiritual teacher tells us to do. And the third recognition or the third thought is on the bottom part of page 59 to think of the actually, not explanations, but it’s the teacher’s teachings of dharma as medicine.

And here, just as a sick person has a high regard for the medicine prescribed by a doctor, so you too should view the instructions and explicit instructions that the instructor or the spiritual teacher gives as very important. Taking great pains to hold them in high esteem and not squandering them. Squandering them, Geshela says, means literally to be disrespectful towards the teachings and to act in any which way. Squandering them by lapses are just forgetting them. And then moving onwards to the fourth recognition.

On page the bottom of page 59 of your text, thinking of earnest practice as a way to cure your disease, sick persons know that their illness cannot be cured without taking the medicine which is prescribed by the doctor. They then take the medicine. Likewise, earnestly engage in practice after you have seen that you cannot vanquish the affliction such as attachment without putting into practice instruction given by the instructors. And then on page 60, the Middling Lamrim gives an example to illustrate this. Moreover, one or two doses of medicine will not do anything at all for lepers who have lost their hands and feet.

So someone who suffers from a grievous disease like leprosy will not be cured through taking medicine for a short period of time. Similarly, to put the meaning of the instructions into practice just once or twice is insufficient for us who from beginningless time have been stricken by the virulent illness of the afflictions. We have been suffering from the afflictions of non virtuous karma from beginningless time and it will not be eliminated rapidly. Therefore analyze with discerning wisdom the totality of every aspect of the path. So Geshela says it is not one or two aspects of the path which are to be analyzed.

It is the totality of the path which is to be analyzed again and again, and make effort that is like a river’s current. This is an example which is given for the continuity of the effort we have to provide. As a great master Śāntideva’s Praise of Confession says, our minds are and actually it’s not constantly, our minds have been confused for a very long time. We also have been ill for a very long time. What is achieved by the lepers who have lost their arms and legs and only occasionally take medicine?

So here again, the symbol of leprosy is given as an instance of the severity of our disease. Thus, the idea of ourselves as a sick person is extremely important for you. If you have this idea, the other ideas will follow. So Geshela says this is actually the fundamental of the six recognitions because from this recognition, all of the other recognitions naturally follow. However, if this idea is mere words, then you will not put the meaning of the instruction into practice in order to clear the afflictions.

It will merely have been listening to these instructions. So Geshela says here, if all we do is understand the mere words of the teaching, then this is a very little benefit if at all. And therefore this recognition of ourselves as a sick should in turn give rise to the wish to hear the teachings on this basis to the wish to think about the teachings, and on this basis to meditating upon the teaching. This is like a sick person who seeks out a doctor. If they apply themselves only to getting the medicine prescribed but not taking it, they will not be free from their disease.

And we have at present a famous quote from the Samādhi Araja sūtra, which I will let you read. And jumping onwards to page 61, there is a quote here which Geshela feels is extremely clear and cogent for our practice. I have explained this good teaching, yet if you having heard it, do not practice it correctly. Then just like a sick person holding onto a bag of medicine, your illness cannot be cured. And finally, Śāntideva says, physically put these instructions into practice.

What will be accomplished by mere thought, by mere talk, Will sick persons be kept by merely reading a medical treatise? And then moving onwards in the middling Lamrim. Therefore, if Geshela says in his commentary we do not put the teachings in practice there will be a great hardship at the time of death and as the middling Lamrim says otherwise if we do not establish these teachings then regret will arise specifically at the time of death. In the self same way as an actor performs merely for others or just as one who wishes to taste molasses were to chew on the bark of the sugarcane instead of chewing on the interior piece which is sweet, in the same way this is empty practice. Therefore motivated by a superior intent, I should take the resolve to practice thereby avoiding the regret and suffering at the time of death.

Otherwise, if I do not find from the depths of my heart what I am striving for, there will be great sufferings. Therefore, I should abstain from all of these thoughts. And this is followed by another quote which reads as follows. In the middling Lamrim, One who is trying to enjoy the flavor of of molasses will not enjoy that flavor if he stops at the wood of the bark or the wood of the tree alone. If he eats the bark, he will not enjoy the taste since the flavor he is searching for lies within.

In the self same way, that meaningful flavor which we are searching for is not to be talked about, but instead with constant vigilance to be striven for. So this is the presentation of the fourth discrimination and at present the fifth discrimination, which is on page 62 of your text is following. And the fifth outline on page 62 of your text reads, develop respect for the Tatagatas remembering the one who set forth the teaching. All the sixth outline is a wish for the teachings to abide for a long time. Thinking how wonderful it would be if independence upon hearing such teachings, the conqueror’s teachings could remain in this world for a long time?

And at present on page 62 of your text, the paragraph containing the sixth discrimination represents the last presentation of discriminations. And starting with furthermore Geshela says both Lamrim Chen and the greater Lamrim present Jetsün Rinpoche’s own advice on how to listen to the teachings. Furthermore, when you explain or hear the teachings, if your mind and the teachings remain separate, then whatever is explained will remain inconsequential. So the teachings must be fused with one’s mind. Hence, listen in such a way that you determine how these teachings apply to your mind.

For instance, when you want to find out whether there is a stain on your face, you look in a mirror and then remove whatever remove whatever is there. This is an example to enable us to understand how to practice the dharma. Similarly, when you listen to the teachings, your thoughts such as misconduct and attachment appear in the mirror of the teachings. So Geshela says, without hearing teachings, we do not even recognize what appears in our mind as false. So listening is the indispensable preliminary here.

With listening, there is recognition. Without listening, there is no recognition. At that time, you regret that your mind has become like this, and you then work to clear away those faults and establish good qualities. So there are two practices here. First, eliminating the thoughts and secondly, creating the qualities within the mind stream.

Hence, you must train in the teachings, and here we have a quote from the Jatakas. When I see the form of my misconduct clear in the mirror of the teachings, I develop a feeling of regret and turn my mind towards the teachings. This, Keshe la says, is just a summary of the previous development. And the example which is given is the following one. With this statement, Sudasa requested that prince Sutasoma bestow the teachings.

Sudasa, Geshela says, was we would call him nowadays a great criminal of ancient India, a mass murderer actually, who not only killed people, but actually was a cannibal, and he killed them to eat their flesh. He requested teachings from prince Sutasoma, who was a great Bodhisattva, and only upon recognizing the qualities of prince Sutasoma did prince Sutasoma from his own side accept to give Sudhasa the teachings. Thereupon, the Bodhisattva prince, knowing Sudasa’s state of mind, that is knowing that Sudasa had become suitable for hearing the teachings, gave him the teachings. In brief, develop the spirit of enlightenment thinking for the sake of all living beings. I will attain Buddhahood.

In order to attain this, I must train in its causes. For this, I must know those causes. For this, it is evident that I must hear the teachings. Therefore, will listen to the teachings. Therefore, remember the benefits of hearing, eliminates the fault faults of a vessel, and so forth, and listen with great delight.

This completes the explanation of how to listen to the teachings with the six discriminations. And then this is on page 63 of your text, how to explain teaching with which both the teachings and its author are great. Actually, Geshela says this outline goes a long way towards explaining the qualities of the spiritual teacher. There are four parts to this explanation. First, contemplating the benefits of explaining the teachings.

So it is only through understanding how the teachings help us in our practice that we will understand their benefits. And specifically here, this contemplation gives rise to veneration for the teachings. Veneration for the teachings is a foremost form of veneration since it is from respect and veneration for the teachings and respect and veneration for the teacher who utters the teachings arises and not the other way around. Secondly, developing reverence for the teacher and the teaching, as Geshela explained, this arises from the first point. And thirdly, with what sort of thoughts and behavior one should explain the teachings.

The thoughts here actually refer specifically to the motivation. If the motivation of the teacher is good, the teachings will be of benefit. Otherwise, if the motivation of the teacher is not good or mundane, there will not be the slightest benefit to the teachings and the behavior which is that of the teacher must be that of a bodhisattva. And finally, differentiating between those to whom one should and should not explain the teachings. Here Geshela says it is important for the teacher to see whether or not the students will benefit from the teachings.

If they will benefit from the teachings, he should teach. Otherwise, there is absolutely no point in teaching. So we will stop with this outline for today. And if you have questions, now is the time to ask them. Or one gone forth means Buddha.

Are there other questions? So if there are no questions, Geshela will continue a little bit. This is easy to understand, he says. And regarding the first outline, root text reads as follows. It is said in Vasubandhu’s Abhidharma Kosha.

Teach purely relying on sūtra and give the dharma without being afflicted by the delusions. Now this quote indicates clearly Geshela says that the mind teaching the dharma or the mind of one who teaches the dharma should not be afflicted by the delusions such as a wish for fame or a good reputation, but instead that the dharma should be taught purely. And it is said in the auto commentary to the Abhidharma Kosha. Therefore, those explanations which are of the dharma which are given in a mistaken way or with a mind obstructed by the afflictions without respect or out of a wish for fame and good repute will merely lead to the degeneration of one’s own great merit. Hence, Jetsün Rinpoche says, the motivation for teaching the dharma is extremely important.

And in addition, Geshe Gompawa, the Kadampa Geshe of which we talked before, said that it is important before explaining the dharma to meditate briefly during one short session on impermanence so as to generate a good motivation. And then moving onwards in the middling Lamrim, it is said the merit which is accrued through the giving of dharma purely without the aspiration for material gifts or donations, and motivated by a superior mindset is said to have 20 different benefits. These are not listed in the middling Lamrim, but they are listed in the Lamrim Chenmo on pages sixty three and sixty four from a text known as the exhortation to wholehearted resolve. And as is said, one who a lay person who gives boundless donations accumulates less merit than one who is ordained and who gives merely one verse of dharma. Moreover, as is said in the Prajñāpāramitā sutras and this refers now to the second outline.

The Buddha himself when receiving teachings out of respect for the teachers set out a seat for them and so forth. And this should lead us to behave in the same way, Geshela says, through appreciating the qualities of the teacher and through generating respect for his kindness. And then moving onwards to the third outline with what sort of thought and behavior one should explain the teaching. With regard to thoughts, develop the five ideas set forth in the on page 64 in the questions of Sagaramati sūtra. Think of yourself as a doctor, of the teachings as medicine, of those listening to the teachings as sick persons, of the Tathagatas as excellent beings and wish that the teachings remain for a long time.

Cultivate love for those who have gathered to listen. Give up jealousy that fears the superiority of others, the laziness of procrastination, the dispiritedness of explaining something again and again. So this means Geshela says that even if the students do not understand, one should again and again explain the teachings. Praising yourself and listing the faults of others, stinginess with regards to explain the teachings, and concern for material things such as food and clothing. A true dharma practitioner is not preoccupied with money or with food.

If it comes, so much better. And if it does not, he accepts the situation. Then think, just this merit from teaching the dharma in order that others and myself attain Buddhahood is a favorable condition for my happiness. And this is therefore the presentation of the first subdivision of the third outline, which is a motivation to be generated to listen to the teachings. The second subdivision, which is how to behave when it listens to teaching, is listed from the bottom of page 64.

With regard to one’s behavior, wash and make yourself clean, then after putting on unsoiled clothing, sit upon a teaching seat and cushion in a place that is clean and attractive. This is a symbol of the inner purification, Geshela says which one should perform since many obstructions arise when teachings are given, and one can choose to perform additional purifications by reciting, for instance, the heart sūtra. On page 65, it is said in the questions of Sagaramati sūtra that if you recite the mantra for overcoming demons, then demons and deities of the demon class within a radius of 100 leagues will not come. So this is a practice which has been transmitted directly from the Buddha to us. It is therefore something we should engage in.

Even if they come, they will be unable to cause difficulties. Therefore, recite that mantra. Then with the radiant face, teach using examples, reasons, and scriptural citations, and other accessories for ascertaining the meaning. So Geshela says, one should teach with a laughing expression just as his or whenever they teach are smiling and giggle a lot. Unfortunately for him, he’s very serious.

Monasteries. And in the great monasteries, one has to tame quite a lot of young monks. And therefore, one has a very serious manner even though Geshela says in his own mind, there is very little anger. He has always been quite sober with his students to control them. And then he is not accustomed to smiling, so he must practice a bit.

So it is very important for the dharma teacher, he says, therefore, to smile. And the fourth outline on page 65 of your text begins with a famous quote from the Vinaya Sutras. If it is not requested, do not give it. In other words, teachings can never be given if they are not requested. This however is qualified later on with the following passage.

Even when requested, it is necessary to investigate whether or not the potential student is suitable to request to receive the teachings. And even when not requested, it is appropriate to explain the teachings to someone only if you know them to be a suitable recipient on page 65, and we will stop here for today. And there’s time for one question, you should assess. I mean, that is the foremost mantra for overcoming obstructions, isn’t it?

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top