Lam Rim – Line in 0247

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - Line in 0247
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk continues a commentary on Bodhicitta vivarana, contrasting the Tirthika (non-Buddhist Hindu) view of a permanent, independent self, especially the Sankhya school, with the Buddhist view that the self is imputed on the five aggregates and is impermanent. It surveys the Buddhist tenet schools’ positions on what bears karma and transmigrates, and links this to the twelve links. Questions and answers follow, then announcements about upcoming events.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 2h 1m

UUID: 1020a6d9-061f-4d37-81bd-520c98325abf

Words: 3,809

So we will meditate for five minutes on generating the motivation to listen to these teachings. And this motivation should be a good motivation. What is meant here by a good motivation is a motivation which realizes that for we are only one, others are infinite in number. And they share with us a very self same wish for happiness and the very self same wish to be free from suffering and unhappiness. And seen in this light, others are more important than us.

So we should generate the motivation to place others in a state of infinite happiness in that with all qualities and free from all defects, the state of full enlightenment. With this as a motivation, we should listen to these teachings. Through listening to the teachings with this motivation, the karmic imprints within our mind stream will be profound. In dependence on these karmic imprints, we ourselves can hope in the future to attain the very state which Buddha Śākyamūni attained and to be of benefit to all beings. So with this as a motivation, let us listen to these teachings.

Page five, Mandala offering verse six. We recite the first and the last verse.

And as you remember to encapsulate what Rinpoche taught, over the last term, this text presents the twofold distinction between engaging between aspiring and engaging Bodhicitta. The presentation of aspiring Bodhicitta has been completed. And within the context of engaging, Bodhicitta, a summarized presentation was given of the first verses of the root text starting with this, verse of inherent being all entities are free. The, following six verses were first presented in a summarized way. They teach explicitly ultimate bodhicitta.

In other words, the wisdom which realizes emptiness without which liberation from cyclic existence is impossible. Then those self same verses from the root text were presented in a much more elaborate way, starting once again with the first verse on page three of inherent being, all entities are free and commenting elaborately the following six verses. The present the commentary was done in terms of the view of the Tīrthikas, the non Buddhist Hindu philosophers for whom all phenomena are actually not free from inherent being, but are instead established by their own characteristics and are inherently established. This is radically opposite to the Buddhist, especially the ultimate Buddhist view for which all phenomena are empty, of existence, of inherent existence. So the key assertion of the Tīrthikas, of the non Buddhist outsiders, is the assertion of a self, not merely a self which is an experience of happiness and suffering, which is also asserted by the Buddhists.

But that specific assertion which is a core of the Sankhya position and also of the Jain and some of the other Tīrthikas for whom the self is a permanent phenomenon. The Buddhist assertions on the other hands are assertions which rely on the core realization that, in as much as all composite phenomena are impermanent, there can be no such thing as a permanent self. So the position of the non Buddhist tirthikas regarding the self is that the self has three main characteristics. First, it is permanent. In other words, it does not disintegrate instant by instant.

Secondly, it is independent. In other words, it does not arise in dependence on causes and conditions and therefore cannot be said to be an other powered phenomenon. Thirdly, it does not depend on parts. This refers both to the parts of the object and the directional parts. And the Tīrthika vision of the self therefore is something akin to uncompounded space.

The Buddhist perspective is radically different and is rooted in the presentation of the four noble truths, which as you well know are the noble truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path leading to the cessation of some suffering. These four noble truths are qualified by the four characteristics of impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness. Impermanence here refers to the momentary nature of phenomena. The suffering nature refers to the fact that these phenomena arise from karma and affliction, and their emptiness actually is the position which radically refutes the assertions of the non Buddhist Tīrthikas for which the self is one object with the aggregates. And actually, the self, excuse me, is a different object from the aggregates, and actually is is of a different nature from the aggregates.

The core Buddhist position is that the self is of one nature with the aggregates. So if we try to understand the view of the non Buddhist Tertikas, we can see that they are keenly aware of the fact that the aggregates die, they disintegrate, and they they need to postulate something which passes from life to life and which carries karma and experiences its results. What is postulated is a self which is immortal and does not disintegrate. Such an immortal self is necessarily of a different nature from the aggregates. This is completely different different from the Buddhist viewpoint since for the Buddhists in as much as emptiness qualifies all four noble truths, the self therefore is not a different object from the aggregates.

Instead, the self is of one nature with the aggregates, and this refutes the Tīrthika viewpoint of the radical difference of self and aggregates.

And there is a very elaborate commentary in our text on these six first verses of inherent existence or phenomena are free and so forth in the root text of Bodhicitta vivarana since it’s very wordy. Rinpoche thinks we all get fairly dizzy in the process. So he’s going to explain the the core meaning here. And to do this, one must try to understand what precisely is the Tīrthika or Hindu non Buddhist understanding of a self. The foremost school here is the so called Sankhya school, which is said to have existed up to twenty thousand years ago.

It is the most ancient school of philosophy of ancient India, and its views were explained by Candrakīrti in his Madhyamakāvatāra most eloquently and clearly. Fundamentally, the Sankhya consider that the self, the Ātman, has five main characteristics. The first is that it is said to be an eater. This refers to the fact that it is an experience within cyclic existence of both happiness and suffering. The second characteristic of the Ātman is in as much as the Sankhyas and most of the Tīrthikas accept the existence of a liberation or a moksha, that this Ātman is a permanent phenomenon, and it is this permanent phenomenon which when it attains liberation ceases to experience any type of suffering, and abides in that state as a permanent one and independent phenomenon.

The third characteristic of the Ātman is that it is not the creator. It is not the ultimate subject. The Sankhyas consider that the foremost phenomenon, the foremost dharma is the creator of all. This creator of all is a cause which has an effect. In as much as for the Sankhyas, the self cannot have an effect, it cannot be this creator of all.

The fourth characteristic of the self according to the Sankhya school is that it is free of the gunas, the qualities of rajas, tamas, and sattva. This refers actually in terms of meaning to desire, ignorance, and hatred. And the fifth characteristic of their self is that it is partless. So generally speaking, Madhyamakāvatāra presents the tirthika views of various schools of philosophy, not only the Sankhya practitioners of Vaisheshika, the sectarians of Ishvara, and various other such schools. However, the foremost one is the Sankhya school.

And as Rinpoche explained, their core assertion is the assertion of the permanence of the Ātman. So the Sankhyas relying on the limited paranormal powers, paranormal perceptions of their gurus gave an account for the arrival of suffering and happiness in our world and explained the process of attaining liberation through the retraction of all sense powers within, which in turn enables the Ātman to attain liberation. And therefore, the principal difference between the non Buddhist Hindu schools and the Buddhist school lies in the nature of the self which is posited. The non Buddhist Hindu schools posit as a self which experiences happiness and suffering a permanent phenomenon, whereas the Buddhist schools posit as a self which experiences happiness and suffering an impermanent phenomenon. From the Buddhist standpoint, whatever is a permanent phenomenon cannot by that very fact experience happiness and suffering, nor cannot by that very fact accumulate karma.

Therefore, this self of the outsiders, of the non Buddhist Hindus, which is different from the aggregates is a non existent phenomenon. As you remember, within the fourfold characteristics of the four noble truths, the fourth was selflessness. That selflessness which is referred to here is a coarse selflessness. The subtle selflessness is that emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity, which is the very coarse selflessness of persons, which is accepted by all the Buddhist schools from the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka School downwards. It is not accepted by the Prāsaṇgika School.

And, therefore, the Samkhyas clearly assert the existence of a self which does not exist in dependence on the aggregates, which is a permanent phenomena and which experiences pleasure and happiness. And they do so because the Sankhya, like most of the non Buddhist Hindu schools, accept the existence of past and future lives and have to posit something which travels from life to life. Since they are keenly aware of the fact that the aggregate, specifically the body, is destroyed at death, something has to transmigrate. What they postulate as transmigrating is this self or the Ātman. Now, a such a permanent self does not exist from a Buddhist standpoint.

From a Buddhist standpoint, that self which experiences happiness and suffering is necessarily impermanent. Since the definition of a person in, Buddhist philosophy is that I which is imputed independence on any of the five aggregates. I here is the common sense of I we have. Any of the five aggregates is mentioned because all beings in the desire realm for instance have five aggregates. Beings in the formless realms do not have five aggregates.

They lack the form or material aggregate and have only four. Yet in either case, the self can be imputed. The five aggregates, as you remember, are the form aggregate, the feeling aggregate, the recognition aggregate, volition, and consciousness aggregate. And therefore, it is independence on these that the self is imputed. Without the aggregates, there is no person.

The aggregates, in other words, are the basis of imputation of the person or the self in the same way as its independence on the components of Rinpoche’s hand, his five fingers, his pawn, and so forth, that one can speak of a hand which is imputed on that basis. It is independence on the basis of imputation that the imputed phenomenon arises. So if we were to take the instance of the five aggregates of a dog, of a horse, or for that instance of a child, in every single case, dog, horse, and child is the imputed phenomenon, the person, which, is imputed on the basis of the basis of imputation, which are the aggregates thereof. And both the basis of imputation and the imputed phenomenon are of one nature. So all the Buddhist schools assert the existence of a self which arises as a result of virtuous and non virtuous karma, the non Buddhist outsiders, the non Buddhist Hindu philosophers, assert the existence of a self which exists independently of the aggregates as I explained it, which is a permanent phenomenon.

And they assert this through a re keen realization that the aggregate specifically the body die, and that something must continue after death. This they posit as the permanent self, which accumulates virtue and non virtue, and in which the karmic imprints are deposited. From a Buddhist standpoint, the various schools of Buddhist tenants have various positions in the matter. The lowest school, the Vaibhāṣika school considers that the self is actually the five aggregates. This is the coarsest position of all.

The Sautranticas have two possible positions. Many Sautraticas consider that it is the continuum or the collection of the aggregates which is the self, while a second group of Sautraticas consider consider that it is actually consciousness which has to be posited as the self. As for the Chitamatras, generally speaking, they consider that it is the mind basis of all the Alaya Vijñāna, which is the self. All the Svatāntrika Madhyamikas, most Svatāntrika madiamicas, positing mental consciousness as the self. And it is only the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamikas which assert a self which is a mere imputation on the basis of the aggregates.

This is the subtle most view of all. So there are many different methods of positing a self in the various Buddhist schools. As to what bears the karmic imprints, in other words, what bears karma, For the five aggregate for the Vaibhāṣikas, Rinpoche says, it is probably just the five aggregates. For the Sautrantikas, it will be the mental consciousness. For the Chitamatra is the mind basis of all.

For the Svatantrikas, once again the mental consciousness. Since, in keeping with a quote most probably from Bodhicaryāvatāra, which says that which takes birth, that is the self. The Svatāntrika Madhyamikas school asserts the mental consciousness as that which transmigrates from life to life, which goes through the death process in the Bardo and is therefore the self. So these are the various possible assertions of the self. Fundamentally, if we look at the process from the standpoint of the 12 links of dependent origination, that very first link which is ignorance, the sense of an I, an inherently existing I, is a link whereby karma is accumulated.

If the motivation is virtuous, then to engaging in practices such as prostration, making offerings and so forth, virtuous karma is accumulated. If the motivation is non virtuous, then engaging in deeds such as stealing and so forth non virtuous karma is accumulated. And then, thereby, this sense of self cherishing, is very powerful within us, which has led us to accumulate karma, deposits karmic imprints within the mind stream, which can be compared to the seeds which are planted by a farmer in a field. For those seeds to germinate conditions such as water are required. In the same way, if we consider the seeds to be a metaphor for karma, the water with which the seeds have to be water watered would be a metaphor for craving, which Rinpoche says is none other than desire.

It is independence on this watering that a sprout germinates, which corresponds to the future life which arises. So today, Rinpoche says, we would have a longer period for questions. So if you have any doubts, this is the time to ask them. Yes.

There’s an apparent contradiction there, but it’s probably not. Just. So the the self is, of different nature. The self is of one nature. With the aggregates, it is imputed on the basis of the aggregates.

So it’s of different isolates from the aggregates. Things can be of one nature without being one. For instance, composite phenomena and impermanent phenomena are of one nature, but they are not one. So as Rinpoche says, actually, Vaibhashika position is that it’s a continuum of the five aggregates, which is posited as itself. Technically, he doesn’t think one could say it’s just the five aggregates.

Yes. Oh, Pamela. Yes. If I heard correctly, Rinpoche said that the samkyas accept past and future lives and therefore required a vehicle for karma to travel from life to life since the body dies. And and the five characteristics that the Sankhas ascribed to Ātman are are fall out of that logical need.

I’m presuming that’s a logical need. How is it that they came to accept past and future lives if if they didn’t already have a notion of what the nature of the mind was like? So one of the Sankhya teachers had direct experience of past and future lives. And then something had to transmigrate Since, obviously, he felt an impermanent self could not transmigrate, he posited the existence of a permanent self. And this self, this ātman which he posited was a permanent phenomenon.

It is because the Sankhya school Sankhya means enumerators, in in Tibetan. It is because the Sankhya school enumerates all phenomena of cyclic existence within a 25-fold category that they call the enumerators or the Sankhya. Okay. As Rinpoche said, it is the mental consciousness that goes to the death process and it goes to the Bardo. Is it that same thing that returns into the drops at birth?

Is it that same entity self that comes back in into the womb at birth that is carried with the new aggregates that enters into the drops at birth? Is it the same entity or self or mental consciousness that has actually gone through the Bardo? And the second section to that question is what is it that actually remembers or has direct experience of the previous life? Is that that is it imbued in that mental consciousness? Is it carried with that consciousness, or is it something different?

So the consciousness of, the past life and the consciousness of the present life are different. It’s not the same consciousness. It is as a river Rinpoche says, the river flows from life to life. So what we’re speaking of is the continuum of mental consciousness, the flow of mental consciousness. That is what passes from life to life.

As for memories, Rinpoche says, memories dwell within the space of consciousness. That is the the location of memories. So you see, if the mental consciousness of the past life and the mental consciousness of this life were one and the same, then mental consciousness would be a permanent phenomenon. It would not be an impermanent phenomenon. Yes.

Yes. See, the man who came yesterday is not the same as that man today. It’s a different man. Even though the man today may remember what he was yesterday did. How did we all come to fall under the trap of ignorance?

Like, everyone’s starting to believe in a separate self. Was it was ignorance always there, or did it arise from the past? Or Ignorance has no beginning. It is beginningless. In the same way as beings have no beginning, in cyclic existence has no beginning, ignorance itself has no start.

Excuse my ignorant question. Yeah. Oh, yeah. So based on Rinpoche’s presentation, can a Sankha reach Nirvāṇa? Can a what?

A Sankhya. Sankhya. Yep. Sankhya reach Nirvāṇa or any further steps on the path? And the second part of the question is someone like Gandhiji who was, clearly drawing from the Hindu tradition appeared to reach some one of the levels of the Bodhisattva levels.

So how does that fit into the Hindu philosophy? So regarding the first of your questions, what is asserted in the non Buddhist Hindu philosophical systems that liberation or moksha is possible through resolving all of the emanations of the self. This is asserted within their system, but they cannot attain that liberation or moksha they speak about. As for your second questions, Gandhiji was most probably a a bodhisattva. When Khensur Rinpoche was in the refugee camp of Buksa, which used to be a concentration camp the British used to hold Indian political prisoners such as Nehru and Gandhi.

He heard accounts of the period when Gandhi was in jail and people saw Gandhi out of the jail. So it was most probably an emanation of Gandhi. Then from Rinpoche’s standpoint, perhaps Gandhi was a Buddhist. And this is based on the fact that he could manifest emanation. So we don’t know whether he was a Buddhist or not, but thinks possibly and probably a bodhisattva.

You. You. Happy of the questions you asked today. Thank you.

Take care. Take care, buddy. Can you give me one a few minutes? This is a miracle month, you know, that the long prayer ceremony starts very soon within a few days in the monastery, all the Tibetan monasteries in India and Tibet. So, you know, if you do recite one mantra, it multiplies millions.

So there is a I give you a chance here. February 27, 09:30AM to 04:30PM. If you like to learn more about the meditation, karma body, Anila, Venerable Chamdinsu, we’re leading. So that please come along and bring your plate with something. And, yeah, there’s a flies out there, and I think it’s a great opportune ’27.

Actually, ’28 is the one the biggest day. It’s a miracle day, you know, the fifteenth, the full moon day. Okay? And so there is more about the what the miracle is. You know, there’s a fly over there or you can Google.

And then, of course, you know, you can put down your diary on the March 13, Buddhism in the forthcoming dark ages by, you know, our most, you know, funded translator and assistant teacher here. So that make sure put in your diary and also, bring your friends. You know, there’ll be a great benefits. And there’s also a fly there as well. And if you’re thinking of doing a retreat, on a Easter retreat, so there’s a great opportunity.

And Rinpoche is very kindly he’s going to give one of the highest yoga tantra initiation, Heruka. And so if you haven’t taken the highest yoga tantra, there is really opportunity in the South Australia, in the Southern Hemisphere. And of course, there is prerequisites on that. If you haven’t listened a Lam Rim or best in my understanding, realization on the three principal aspects of the path. If you don’t have realization on three principal aspects of path, at least read and understand having a great conviction and faith towards these three, then Rinpoche will probably say, yes, you can come.

Alright? And, if you haven’t done, there is a bit of time. You can do it. And, of course, you know, the I just, like to give this is a great opportunity. As a community, we can, help for the environment and help for the TBI to just collect your own refundable bottles.

Even the, you know, that cotton, you know, those small juice, if you look at it underneath, there is a it’s a refundable. Alright? And, not the recycle, the refundable one. Sorry. Make sure.

That’s it. Thank you very much. And, wish you a happy New Year. And there’s a Chai, and, TVI provide it tonight, Kapse, which is, there’s a very special offer for New Year. So that please make sure before you go, take one each.

Alright?

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
tirthika mu teg pa (Tib)
An outer being, a proponent of a non-Buddhist system of beliefs with tenets that assert either eternalism or nihilism, views which bind them to samsara. Also known as an outsider, one who adheres to an outsider doctrine. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top