Lam Rim – Line in 0246

1 h 25 min · 2,588 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - Line in 0246
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching introduces the ninth-ish stage of the Lam Rim on the sixth perfection, wisdom, focusing on the view of Prasangika Madhyamaka. It explains the four key points for refuting an inherently existing self: identifying the object of negation, the necessary entailment that the self must be either one with or different from the aggregates, the refutation of both, and the conclusion that the self exists only as a nominal imputation. It notes that understanding this view supports karma and refuge, and that the session ends with a suggestion to hold questions over until next time because of Losar.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 25m

UUID: e693669d-6322-4a58-8c31-f85c093ca29b

Words: 2,584

So we will generate as usual the motivation to listen to these teachings, which is a wish to attain the, state of unalloyed and full enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. And with this as a motivation, we will listen these teachings on the essential nectar Lam Rim treaties. And at present, we will do the usual visualizations in the context of this teaching. We will invite Buddha Śākyamūni to settle upon our crown. And from the body of Buddha Śākyamūni, white light and nectar descend into our body, and we will perform the three purifications.

First, the downward voiding, where all of the faults of the body, which have been accumulated since beginningless time, leave our body through its lower orifices Then the upward voiding where all of our body is filled with light and nectar up to the mouth and the higher orifices of the body and departs from our body carrying all the faults accumulated through speech. And finally, a voiding in a heap at the heart where all of the mentally accumulated non virtuous karmic imprints are visualized at the heart, and the light and nectar enter our body, instantaneously dispersing these faults in the same way as one turns electricity on in a room and it instantaneously dispels the darkness. And we should reflect at this point that we have obtained whichever qualities we wish to obtain from this practice. And then we have two alternatives. We can either imagine that the Buddha Śākyamūni on our crown descends, into our heart and remains there in the shape of Buddha Śākyamūni, or alternatively, we can imagine him dissolving into our mind, whichever we prefer.

So returning to the outline of Lam Rim, which has been of the path divided into the path of the beings of three scopes, the being of the smaller, middling and greater scope. The presentation of the path of the being of great scope in turn is divided into presenting the advantages of generating bodhicitta and how bodhicitta is generated. And then in dependence on that, training in the six perfections. Of these six perfections, the five first perfections have been presented, and we are now covering the sixth perfection, the perfection of wisdom. So generally speaking, what do we mean when we speak of the Lam Rim or the graduated stages of the path?

Actually, all of the 108 volumes of the Kangyur, the Tripitaka, as well as the 220 and some volumes of the Tengyur, the shastras, which are commentaries on the Tripitaka, can be said to be Lam Rim in the full sense of the term. There is not a single word uttered in the Trippitaka, in the 108 volumes of the Kangyur, which is not ka in Tibetan, in other words, the honorific for speech. It is authentic and pure speech. Should there be a word which is not authentic and pure speech within the Tripitaka, we would have to say that pure speech does not exist. And therefore, all of the Tripitaka can be said to be the Lam Rim.

However, the texts called Lam Rim texts are succinct and, easily understood presentation of the Tripitaka, and they have three key features. They present the essence of the tribitaka. They are easy to understand by beings of the three capacities, the lesser, middling, and greater capacities. And these are works which are not created out of the arbitrary fancies of scholars, but instead are rooted profoundly in the Buddhist teachings. And the great Kadampa Geshe said that the totality of the Buddha’s teachings is subsumed in the treatises presenting the stages of the path.

In other words, the totality of the Vinaya or monastic discipline of the Abhidharma and of the Sūtra Pitaka are subsumed within the Lam Rim treatises. Hence, this Lam Rim these Lam Rim treatises are compared in the Kadampa tradition in keeping with Atisha’s instructions to a golden rosary. They are compared to a golden rosary because in the same way as a golden rosary is extremely precious because it’s made of gold. These Lam Rim treatises are very precious. And in the same way as a rosary enables one to repeat whichever mantra one chooses to repeat, other words to practice whatever one chooses to practice.

Likewise, these Lam Rim treatises are

Appropriate for all to practice. And, even though they are actually rooted in the mainly in the core treatises of Atisha, the, lamp on the path, the Bodhipathapradīpa, nonetheless, they can be said to be rooted more broadly in the totality of the Buddhist teachings. And Atisha came specifically to train the disciples he would have in Tibet. And while he was specifically a teacher for the Tibetans, his heart son or his closest disciple was the glorious Dromtonpa, who is said to be an emanation of Avalokiteśvara. And it is on those teachings that the Lam Rim are based.

And for generally speaking, emptiness is explained in an extremely elaborate and detailed way in Tsongkhapa’s Lam Rim Chenmo. There are more succinct presentations in the other Lam Rim treatises, And the various reasonings which are presented for understanding, emptiness and generating the realization of emptiness are to be understood by us. But the foremost of these reasonings and the easiest to understand is the reasoning of nonestablishment as inherently one and inherently many. This is a reasoning which will be presented here in the light of the so called four key points. And the first of these key points is the key point of ascertaining the object of negation.

It is critical in the reasonings on both the selflessness of persons and the selflessness of phenomena to clearly identify that which does not truly exist. In general, truth does exist. So the question is, what does not truly exist? What is not truly established? To do this, one must identify the object of negation.

And therefore, one first checks the mode in which the person, in other words, the self, appears to us and sees whether the self does indeed exist in the way it appears or not. If it does not exist in the way it appears, what are the reasonings which can harm this fallacious mode of appearance? And what are the reasonings which actually establish the authentic mode of existence? And therefore, even though phenomena do appear as existing from their own side to our minds, in actuality, they do not exist in that way. In other words, phenomena do not appear as they exist, and it is capital for us to try to understand how exactly they exist.

Now the view which is presented in Lam Rim is the view of the Prasanika school, the Prasanika Madhyamaka school. In other words, the view of non true existence or non inherent existence. As you know, the various schools of Buddhist philosophy from the Vaibhāṣika school, which is the lowest school all the way up to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school are differentiated exclusively in terms of how they present the view. These different views of the surfaces of persons in a phenomena are presented for the sake of the various trainees. Because it is said that should the ultimate view, the view of the lack of true existence in the light of Prāsaṇgika be presented to trainees of the lower school, they would generate great fear.

And this might lead to tremendous problems in their practice. So the view which is presented here is the ultimate view in the very self same way as when scientists investigate reality, their understanding of the ultimate nature of reality from the standpoint of science tends to be particular. In the same way here, we analyze to find whether or not phenomena are truly existing or not. And this analysis which leads to the view of selflessness is the most important part of our practice. So the first, key point here, therefore, is identifying the object of negation.

In other words, identifying identifying what is to be refuted. And, from within the two alternatives of the self being completely nonexistent or the self being inherently existing, it is actually the middle way which is to be preferred. So the self is not in here completely nonexistent, But the question then is, what is its actual mode of existence? And the best way to understand this in Geshe la’s opinion is to check how the process of apprehension of the self occurs. We will notice that that self which is being refuted is similar to the lord or to the ruler of body and mind, which is placed or imputed on top of them.

And we notice the appearance of the self when powerful emotions such as fear arises in our mind. When fear arises within our mind, a very powerful sense of I which is going to be harmed arises. And this powerful sense of I seems to be independent and not to depend on the body, on the mind, on the collection of body and mind. It is not the case that there is no no I in general. What is, however, the case is that there is no inherently existing I which exists or exists like a king imputed on the basis of the aggregates.

The eye which does exist is a mere imputed I which accumulates, comma, and of which we can say he goes or he comes. So therefore, the I can be said to be non truly established, and it is this which we have to try to identify. We see likewise that when, emotions such as desire arise within our mind, or anger, not only ourselves, but the object towards which we feel desire or anger seems to become an inherently existing independent, non dependent phenomenon existing from its own side. And this is how the inherent or the apprehension of the inherent existence of the I gives rise in turn to all of the delusions such as anger and hatred. And therefore, we are impelled in the cycle of lives through the innate ignorance, which spontaneously apprehends phenomena as truly or inherently existing.

From within the threefold division of virtuous, non virtuous, and neutral states of mind, this innate ignorance is a neutral

State of mind. It is neutral because it can give rise to either virtue or non virtue since it is the actual motor of all of cyclic existence, both the fortunate happy states and the unfortunate unhappy states. So for instance, the gods of the form and formless realms do not experience, anger, and their minds are suffused with virtue. Nonetheless, they are afflicted by the innate ignorance which afflicts all beings, within cyclic existence. So we have finished the presentation of the first key point, which is the key point of ascertaining the object of negation.

And you have now understood conceptually at least what is that self which is being negated. And the second key point is the key point of ascertaining the pervasion or the necessary entailment. If such a self, which is like a king or a master of the person exists, then it is either one or different with the body and mind, which are the divisions of the person or the fivefold aggregates, which are the alternate divisions of the person. And the key point of ascertaining the necessary entailment is to realize that there is no third alternative for this falsely existing self which appears to exist as a king. It can only be either one with its constituents or separate from them.

And then the third key point is the key point of being free from being truly one. We have now established or identified the object of negation. And if this object of negation is actually truly one with the five aggregates, then there are only two possibilities. Either the five aggregates become one unique entity since they are truly one with a self which is one, or alternatively, the self itself becomes fivefold because it is one with the five aggregates. There is no other possibility.

Now this is obviously absurd. And should one on the other hand say that the self is truly different, or truly other from the, constituents on which it is imputed, the five aggregates, then the obvious rejoinder to this is where is this self you are talking about? And this is the fourth, ascertainment. If there were such a thing as a self which was truly other from the aggregates, then we would set the aggregates here and we would have to find some sort of self elsewhere. Well, Geshe la says, where precisely is the self we would be talking about in that case?

So we have established that if such a self exist, it is necessarily either inherently one or inherently different from the aggregate. It is not inherently one. It is not inherently different. Then where is it? So this is in no way a refutation, or a confutation of the conventional self.

This is a mere refutation of that inherently existing self, which seems to exist as the ruler of the aggregates. This is actually the way the self appears to us, especially when powerful emotions are involved. And this can only be refuted through first identifying clearly the object of negation, then understanding that if such a self exists, it can only be one, one with the aggregates or truly different from the aggregates, and that since it is neither such a thing exists in no way. So in the same way as being a king is a position which is conferred upon one, one is appointed, one is enthroned into kingship, and one is not a king until intronization has occurred. Likewise, the self does exist as an imputation or as a nominal designation on the basis of the aggregates.

But until that nominal designation has occurred in the same way as a king is not a king until enthronization, that self has no existence from its own side or independently. So this is the actual mode of existence of the self as a mere nominal imputation. And for this reason, the Prāsaṇgika School asserts unambiguously the nominal imputed existence of all phenomena. As Nāgārjuna himself says, I do not disagree or quarrel with any of the worldly viewpoints. I do not accept their true existence, however.

Therefore, the nominal designation of all phenomena is asserted, the true existence of all phenomena is refuted. And it is said that when this view is understood authentically, it leads to a particular deepening of one’s understanding of karma and causality and of refuge. However, those who do not understand this view correctly face the risk of a complete collapse of both refuge and their understanding of karma and causality. And this is the reason for which the lower schools from the Chitamatra school downwards assert the true existence of phenomena out of a fear of the collapse of karma and causality should the non true existence of phenomena be asserted. So the Prāsaṇgika school is able to postulate a distinction between existence on the one hand and true existence on the other hand, between nonexistence on the one hand and nontrue existence on the other hand.

This is a distinction the lower schools cannot postulate. So we will stop here for today. But today, because it’s Losar, Geshe la will suggest that we don’t have questions. Put them aside for next time. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top