1 h 40 min · 4,103 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the two verses recited at the end of puja and the definition of bodhichitta as a special mind with twin aspirations: for the sake of others, grounded in great compassion, and aiming at full enlightenment. It then covers the order of the six perfections and why generosity depends on motivation. Much of the session is taken up with students’ questions about generosity and motivation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 40m
UUID: 58d7b4fd-584b-43d9-bf80-98a2647dd4ee
Words: 4,099
Then at the end of Puja, it is the tradition to recite two verses, precious supreme bodhichitta upon having generated you, may you increase ever more. These are very profound verses which really encapsulate the totality of the Lamrim. And there is a tradition, I cannot say whether it is true or not, that they were composed by Atisha Jowo himself. Then, this very beautiful stanza encapsulates the totality of the Lamrim. The first verse, Precious Supreme bodhichitta, refers to conventional bodhichitta, which is the very essence of the Lamrim.
And then the first part of the second verse, Should it not be created, may it be created, refers to the paths of the being, of the small and the middling scope whose goal is the creation of bodhichitta. And the final part of the second verse, may it increase evermore, refers to the path of the being of the great scope and to the means to cause the increase of bodhichitta whose object of observation is full and utter enlightenment and these means are none other than the practice of the perfections. Then these two verses were verses which we all have to memorize and at the end of Petri, in other words, the classes in Buddhist philosophy at the great monasteries, we would recite these verses and as they encapsulate the totality of the of the Lamrim, they were extremely profound.
And therefore, the paths shared with the being of the small and the middling scope referred to in the first verse, the means to give rise to bodhichitta and once bodhichitta has been generated then one prays that not only should it not degenerate but may it increase ever more and the means for this increase ever more are the six perfections. This is, these are my own thoughts on the topic. This is not something which is found in, the text. But, frankly, we have received many teachings about, bodhichitta and what matters is upon understanding the meaning, the essence, the nature, the definition to actually try to generate it.
What’s the meaning of bodhichitta? You understand? It says that a special mind endowed with two aspirations or twin aspirations is the definition of bodhichitta. So this is how one should proceed, one should reflect on this topic such as bodhichitta which is endowed with twin aspirations over and again. And eventually one can generate a contrived experience of bodhichitta, another contrived one is difficult.
So when we say that bodhichitta is a special mind endowed with twin aspirations, these twin aspirations include the first aspiration which is for the sake of others which refers to the means to generate bodhichitta and this alludes to great compassion. So, within the prayer, which is recited at the end of Puja, which was mentioned, this is what one generates. And the second verse of the prayer recited at the end of Puja, once it has been created may it not degenerate but increase ever more refers to the second aspiration within the definition of bodhichitta, which is the aspiration whose object of observation is full and utter enlightenment. Then the aspiration for the sake of others, the first aspiration refers to great compassion. And great compassion here has as its cause uncontrived definite emergence.
It is not a phenomenon which arises without causes and conditions. So these are the means to generate bodhichitta. I think Geshe-la says we should turn the heat off. Could have become I you are all little bit worried. Oh, yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. I So since we are all beginners, obviously, we are heavily dependent on our bodies. It’d be difficult for beginners like ourselves not to be dependent on our bodies. And as a result, when it’s nice and comfortable, we tend to droze away.
Now instead, we must generate enthusiasm and joy. In other words, a pliancy. This is what we talk about when referring to pliancy. And clearly with the heater on, you’re going to doze off because you’re bored, Geshe-la’s going to doze off and we’d all fall asleep. In our own cases, we rely very heavily on our bodies and as a result, we are heavily dependent on the happiness induced by sensory consciousnesses and excessively dependent on extra exterior physical objects.
So his holiness when he teaches bodhichitta emphasizes heavily this definition, a special mind endowed with the twin aspirations. And therefore it is obviously a profound definition. Then as was mentioned previously, it is insufficient for either of these two aspirations to be present alone. For the mind in question to be bodhichitta, both must necessarily be present and as was said, the first aspiration, the aspiration to enact the welfare of others or for the sake of others, can be traced backwards from great compassion all the way to uncontrived definite emergence which is its cause. So the doubt which could arise and has been mentioned is whether a great compassion is present or not within the mind stream of hearers and Pratyekabuddhas.
And I have addressed this in the past, but in brief, there is no real rationale for which it should be present. This is not to say that compassion is not present, but as is said in Pramānavārttika, benevolence So as I said in the second chapter of Pramānavārttika, benevolence does not arise causelessly or without conditions. It arises in dependence on compassion. Now in as much as there is no reason for hearers and Pratyekabuddhas to generate this, it will not be present within their mind streams. This is not to say that they do not have compassion for the six or 7,000,000,000 human beings on this earth, they do.
So now, as far as definite emergence is concerned, basically we all know the hardship which arises as a result of affliction such as anger and so forth. Now when it comes to physical hardship, clearly physical hardship and suffering can be eliminated through taking medicine, injections and so forth. But in Australia, are excellent and physical hardship is rare. So then what precisely is a form of hardship which is widespread here? It is mental suffering.
What does mental suffering arise from? It arises from the afflictions. So one must here understand clearly what definite emergence is. Some students in the past have misunderstood definite emergence and liberation. Definite emergence is the mind which strives for liberation.
It arises once one understands the thoughts within one’s own mind stream. In other words, the afflictions which are a cause of suffering and wishes to be freed from them. So here, the important thing is to understand the suffering of one’s own afflictions, the sufferings induced by one’s own afflictions. You do understand the sufferings induced by your own afflictions, don’t you? You do understand your own suffering.
Then once one has understood this, we will set aside animals because we don’t really understand the animal condition. But let us just take other human beings. We will think for instance among the human beings in this temple. Each one of them their mind is troubled, they experience anger, they experience jealousy just like me and so forth. Then, if we think in this way, this is how compassion arises.
We see the suffering in our own mind and we see the suffering due to the affliction such as anger and jealousy in another’s mind and we say, my goodness, their situation is like mine. And then independence on this compassion increases. Then you might think that monks and nuns do not experience coarse afflictions. This is not true. Monks and nuns experience coarse afflictions like everyone else, but they train themselves to see these afflictions as faults.
So far from it being the case that because one is ordained one does not have coarse afflictions, it is a case that because one has coarse afflictions one has become ordained. Then regarding animals, basically, one must have compassion for animals but animals are unable to engage in the studies leading to mental happiness. This is a human specificity. Australia, people have many pets, dogs, cats and so forth. And they feed them, they take them for walks, they put them for rest on cushions and so forth.
Certainly, as far as physical happiness is concerned, they lack nothing. Then the means for mental happiness are absent in animals. Animals are unable to train their minds in mental happiness. So when we speak of the means of generating compassion, broadly speaking, there are two means. The first is the sevenfold cause and instruction.
The second is the equalization and exchange of self and others, by which one counters self-cherishing. Then you all understand what self cherishing is. Through this one develops compassion for the suffering due to the afflictions in others. So once one has reflecting on the sufferings which have arisen from the afflictions generated compassion for others, then at that point one will become close to others, one will feel close to others And this closeness is not a partial closeness, it is an impartial closeness. Once this impartial closeness has arisen, then probably the coarse afflictions have ceased.
So once one has generated uncontrived great compassion and uncontrived bodhichitta, at that point, probably the coarse afflictions will cease to manifest. And as you said, one progresses from happiness to happiness without any indolence of any type. So this is for the first aspiration, the aspiration for or to enact the wheel of others, the benefit of others, which is linked to great compassion. And the second aspiration is an aspiration striving for great compassion. This is perhaps the core aspiration of bodhichitta which is a main mind.
So, once this special mind endowed with the twin aspirations has independence on the first aspiration, great compassion, generated a striving which is a second aspiration, striving for full and utter enlightenment, then the definition of bodhichitta is fully satisfied. So once one has generated this uncontrived experience of bodhichitta, then in keeping with Śāntideva’s injunction, one should train in the six perfections and you probably do know the sequence of the six perfections. So, the six perfections are presented in terms of the difficulty in their training. If you actually know the difference, please present it. If you don’t, then don’t say anything.
No. Geshe-la assumes you know the sequence of the six perfection. Why are they presented in that sequence? I’m asking you why ethics comes after generosity and why forbearance comes after ethics and so forth. What is the reason for the sequence?
Yes. Generosity is easier to practice than ethics. Ethics is easier to practice than forbearance. Forbearance is easier to practice than enthusiasm. But why are the former ones easier and the latter ones more difficult?
Your fingers are touching your noses. And another to understand. It’s helpful to look at the Lamrim for this. So why is generosity easier than ethics? It is because generosity is practiced occasionally at times.
Then ethics is a commitment. Once one has taken the commitment to protect one’s ethics, one must practice it continually, not occasionally. So let’s see now. Geshela says, today we’re going to give you work. So then do you understand why ethics is easier than forbearance or patience?
Another? This is how one should proceed. One should ask oneself, in which way is a practice of forbearance harder than the practice of ethics and one should check for oneself and then after this one should check in texts and see whether or not one’s opinion is in accordance with the Buddhist text. Whether it is or not, one’s understanding will be more stable. It seems that with each perfection we’re getting closer and closer to the sense of inherent self or self cherishing and so what I meant by habituation is that as we move through each of the perfections we’re more and more habituated with a certain level of self which gets triggered by factors such as anger.
Andrew. Ethics is turning away from the afflictions and forbearance is accepting the afflictions and I think it’s more difficult to accept the afflictions. Ethics is restraining actions which are the result of the afflictions which is their cause and forbearance is restraining the actual affliction itself. Your answers are all very similar. Basically, ethics involves countering one’s own wrong behavior.
Whereas forbearance involves countering the wrong behavior of others. Now, as far as countering one’s own wrong behavior is concerned, we have control. As far as countering the wrong behavior of others is controlled, is involved, we have very little control, very little power. So this is how we should think about it. So as was explained last time, generosity is a mind of giving which is bereft of avarice or attachment and whereby one gives to another possessions, teachings, roots of virtue and so forth.
If this mind is bereft of avarice, of stinginess, then it is counted as the practice of generosity. If in addition, it is upheld by the wish to attain full and utter enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, it becomes the perfection of generosity. But it is not the perfection of generosity as such, it is merely the practice of the perfection of generosity. So regarding the perfection of generosity as was explained last time, it has three subdivisions which I shall not re explain, but the first subdivision, the perfection of generosity of giving material objects, is detailed in Lamrim Cemo and in Pabongka Rinpoche’s liberation in the palm of your hand. You really should read these passages.
Now, Lama Tsongkhapa points out that when training in the perfection of generosity, one must examine very carefully the object given, the recipient of this object, the time at which giving occurs and so forth. To see for instance, whether this giving causes hardship or not to the recipient and so forth. So for instance, if an enemy or a competitor were to ask someone who has bodhisattva vows to give them something. It could be possessions, money, whatever. Then the person who has Bodhisattva vows has as a first very commitment to give wealth, but he or she must examine carefully what usage the person who is asking for this is going to make of it.
So for instance, for someone who has Bodhisattva vows, if another party were to ask that person for help and that person refused with a strong sense, I cannot and will not help this person, probably the root Bodhisattva vow would be destroyed. If in addition that person had generated Bodhichitta, then they would have relinquished Bodhichitta. However, since definite emergence has been generated before this, then definite emergence would remain. So ethics is an intention to protect and it covers the restraint from the non virtuous deeds of body and speech as well as non virtuous intention. Moreover, ethics is subdivided into three.
So, us reflect at present on the nature and the examples of bodhichitta. During a couple of minutes. Open the prayer book, page one. One B, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandalu three, verse one and three. Thank you.
So we would explain ethics in detail next week And at present, if you have questions, ask your questions. One question per person. And after everyone has asked questions, you can have seconds. Well sorry, is there a big meant to be a big difference in difficulty between the first four? Because to me it seems that there’s not a big difference in difficulty and that it can depend on your personal circumstance and the time in your life.
So that at times generosity could be more difficult for you than ethics. The last two to me seem very difficult So because of that we will stop there. So to start with I would say you have to think of the totality of the perfection. For instance, you take the perfection of giving. It has three subdivisions, not only giving money or wealth but giving dharma and giving fearlessness.
That can be very, very hard. That’s what I mean. Times Why? Which of the three is the hardest in the perfection of generosity? So there’s not only the perfection of giving material objects, but that of giving teachings or dharma and that of giving fearlessness.
Then, the perfection of giving material objects does not refer to giving necessarily vast offerings. I explained last time giving a little piece of chocolate is sufficient, isn’t it? Yeah. Yeah. My point was it When you say giving time what do you mean?
Giving being generous with your time not doing things for yourself, doing things for other people. So what are you saying that that is a practice of generosity? So you see ethics must be protected at all times Whether you are sleeping or awake. But that’s not the case with the practice of generosity. Generosity is practiced occasionally.
Think about it. Yeah. Which was, I think. Geshe-la, I wonder if generosity being the first of the six perfections is because we need to create a tremendous amount of merit to progress along the path and especially to obtain the form body of a Buddha. So to practice generosity would be critical to create the merit to progress along the path.
It’s not a question, is it? Okay. So I was asking for questions. Do you have other questions? Yes, Geshe-la.
It was mentioned tonight that we have to be very careful about when we give something to somebody else because we have to be careful that it might cause them hardship. That can be a very difficult thing to actually assess when you are going to give somebody something because you don’t necessarily know how two different people might accept the same type of gift. For one it might be a question of having hardship from that and for another person it could be an amazing opportunity for them. So could Geshela help us what sort of what do we need to know to be able to assess whether gifts that we’re giving are going to cause others hardship? Hello.
So what is being said is that before engaging in the training of the perfection of generosity, we should first see if we have the possibility to give whatever wealth objects is to be given, then we should see if the recipient of this gift has usage of this and we’re making good usage of it as opposed to making a bad usage of it. Gamma? I’m not satisfied with that answer, sorry. Because I was thinking of an example a true story of a beggar in Sydney who was on the street and a man came over and gave him $50 and instead of going and spending it on food, So that is definitely an extremely beneficial deed. Then the key here is to have a very good motivation before one engages in deeds of generosity.
And then when such a motivation underlies things, one would examine very carefully and independence on this, it is certain the deed will be beneficial. Again, I would really like some clarification on the issue of generosity and how it is practiced. It would seem to me that TBI, for example, runs on volunteer labor to a certain to a large extent. Does that mean that everyone who gives their labor to TBI is not donating their labor and their time, or being generous with their labor or their time.
The other example I would like to look at is what a mother does for her children. She’s making food. She’s providing food. She’s getting clothing. She’s washing them.
She’s wiping their bottoms when they’re when they’re dirty. And she’s looking after them for a great deal of their life. Does that mean that all of this action by a mother does not count in any way as generosity? That generosity is only the giving of money or precious objects. You could, regarding your first question, you could include activities such as volunteering for TBI to do things like cleaning and so forth within the generosity of giving material objects.
So it would be difficult for you, the second question, to include the care a mother extends to her child within the perfection of generosity or within the activity of generosity since it is actually motivated by desire. When giving material objects, does it matter how much benefit the recipient makes of the donation? For example, with the $50 donation that Natalie talked about, the guy completely changed his life whereas he could have gone and bought like a $50 meal. So does one’s own merit increase in correlation to the benefit that the recipient makes of the donation? No, it doesn’t depend.
The merit accrued through practicing generosity does not depend on what the other party does with what one has given them. It depends on one’s own motivation in giving. If one gives us a motivation of bodhichitta, then the result of this giving will be very vast. Is it possible to have one perfection within another so that the ethics of generosity or the generosity of ethics? No, there’s no common locus between ethics and generosity.
Geshela said that bodhichitta was a main mind. It was composed of two aspirations and I understood aspiration to be a mental factor and an effort and enthusiasm to be another. So Geshela could explain that. So bodhichitta is a main mind. As Je Tsongkhapa points out in the Golden Garland of Eloquence, there was one scholar in ancient India who asserted that bodhichitta was mental factor.
But if we look at the stanza in Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, generating the mind is for the sake of others aspiring for full and utter enlightenment. Here, aspiring does not refer to the mental factor of aspiration. Patience number three, following on from what Pamela was saying and also Molly, I was thinking that forbearance by a parent who has a child who’s suffering from autism, for example, wouldn’t that also fit in with generosity in helping those who are mentally challenged? No, there’d be no relation with the perfection of generosity. To qualify as a perfection, the motivation of benefiting others must be present.
So, was telling Geshela that you seem to believe, I think the root of the misunderstanding is that one considers taking care of one’s child as an altruistic deed, Whereas, it is a form of desire. Following on from that, if you didn’t care for your child, wouldn’t that be an unethical act? You be engaging in non ethics, non virtue? If you didn’t take care of your child, it would be similar to a non virtue. So you don’t seem to take any account of motivation in your comments.
When you take care of I’m sorry. Far from it. I am taking account of motivation. Yeah, I’m sorry, but to be suggested no, I’m sorry. The suggestion that I’m not that the question is not on the basis that there is a motivation that is a motivation that is a sympathetic motivation, an altruistic motivation.
It’s just I don’t understand that. So, I was will translate what Geshela was saying which was basically, if the motivation of taking care of the child is bodhichitta, then the deed of taking care of the child becomes practice leading to full and utter enlightenment. Okay. Amanda? Just you?
I just had a question like, is it when you’re talking about desire this desire with the children, do you mean because they’re your own children? Like if you were taking care of autistic foster children or in a childcare center for instance, and you didn’t have that parental desire or your own motivation in that way, Is that what Geshela means? Because you’ve got that parental desire to take care of your own children? Like if you’re impartial towards the children, would it make it different? If you have an unmistaken motivation, yes.
Otherwise, without the motivation, it wouldn’t be appropriate. Okay. So it’s all about motivation, but just a thought I just had was, by basically giving birth to a child, you have given that being the priceless opportunity to be to achieve enlightenment and to then have the opportunity to to have that aspiration of bodhichitta and that’s that’s a pretty good thing to do I would think. I have only one question to you, when you conceive the child what’s your motivation? Okay.
Thank you. So we’ll stop here for tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What do we need to know to assess whether the gifts we give will cause others hardship?
Before engaging in the training of the perfection of generosity, we should first check two things. First, we should see whether we are actually able to give whatever wealth or object is to be given. Second, we should see whether the recipient of the gift can make use of it, and whether they will make good use of it as opposed to bad use of it. Considering both the giver's capacity and the recipient's likely usage helps us judge whether a gift is appropriate before we give it.
Does the merit of giving increase according to how much benefit the recipient gets from the donation?
No, it does not depend on that. The merit accrued through practicing generosity does not depend on what the other party does with what one has given them. It depends on one's own motivation in giving. If one gives with a motivation of bodhichitta, then the result of this giving will be very vast.