1 h 32 min · 4,336 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains how bodhicitta is generated through the seven-step training in equalization and interchange of self and others, distinguishing aspiring from engaging bodhicitta and the role of taking bodhisattva vows. It distinguishes great love from great compassion, noting that great compassion marks entry to the path of the being of the great scope. A question-and-answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 33m
UUID: 66f794ea-b1f3-4e21-8630-42d94f9bb7ae
Words: 4,332
As it is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhicharyavatara, even upon generating merely one instant of Bodhichitta, one will be counted among the scions of the conquerors. The meaning of this stanza is that just by generating Bodhisattva for one instant, one becomes a Bodhisattva. Here conventional Bodhichitta is synonymous with the mind generation of the great vehicle. And it is important to understand that the distinction between being a practitioner of the lesser vehicle, the Hīnayāna and a practitioner of the greater vehicle, the Mahāyāna is not made in terms of the view, but is made in terms of conduct. In other words, in terms of whether or not bodhichitta has been generated within the mind stream.
Likewise, the differentiation between being a great vehicle school of tenets or a lesser vehicle school of tenets is made in terms of whether or not emptiness is accepted within the context of being a Buddhist school of tenants. Greater vehicle schools of tenets accept emptiness, lesser schools of tenets do not. Likewise, once one has generated uncontrived bodhichitta within one’s mind stream, one has entered the Mahāyāna path. There is however a slight difference between having entered the Mahāyāna path and having entered the path of the being of the great scope. Since the criterion for having entered the path of the being of the great scope is having generated uncontrived great compassion within one’s mind stream.
And there is a difference between uncontrived great compassion and uncontrived bodhichitta. Great compassion is the uncommon cause of bodhichitta. So at present, one might wonder whether upon merely having generated love, one would have become a being of the great scope or not and this is something which is to be analyzed. One must therefore establish a difference between these various qualities such as between the great compassion generated in this context, immeasurable compassion, immeasurable love, immeasurable equanimity and immeasurable joy. And likewise, as far as love is concerned, the love which is generated in the context of the sevenfold causal process and love in general.
Then in addition, one must examine to see whether or not the love which arises in the context of the equalization and interchange of self and others is one and the same as a love which arises in the context of the sevenfold causal process or not. So we therefore have clearly pointed out that once one has generated great compassion, one has become a being of the great scope. The question is whether upon generating love, this has happened or not. And you have the opportunity to reflect on this by yourselves because when I explained this in Tibetan, there’s an empty moment and until the translator begins to translate. So here, one must reflect on the sequence which is adopted for the generation of bodhichitta when depending or relying on the equalization interchange of self and others.
First, one generates an impartial equanimity, then one reflects on the force of self cherishing, then the qualities of cherishing others, then the actual practice of interchange of self and others, then the practice of tonglen, giving and taking, with a generation of respectively love and compassion, and then the generation of the supreme resolve, followed by the generation of bodhichitta, seven steps in all. So, when one trains, in generating bodhichitta by the equalization interchange of self and others, one must distinguish the aspects of the objects of observation. In other words, the subdivisions of the practice. And this is something, this is something I would like to ask you. What are these subdivisions?
Quick, quick, please. What is the sequence? For For the interchange of The equalization interchange of self and others. Yes. Equanimity comes first.
Yes. Yes. So here what is the goal of this incremental process of training? It is to eventually give rise to bodhichitta. And what precisely is bodhichitta?
bodhichitta is the wish to place, the uncontrived wish to place all sentient beings numberless in amount in the state of full enlightenment. So the way one trains in this sequence is that initially one generates equanimity towards all sentient beings and in dependence on this equanimity, one reflects on the thoughts of self cherishing or egoism. At this point, the mind becomes more powerful. And then, in dependence on this one reflects on the qualities of altruism, the mind becomes more powerful again. And at this point, one gives rise to the actual interchange, the actual thought of the interchange of self and others.
Probably at this point, both love and compassion will have been generated. After this, one engages in the practice of giving and taking, which leads to intensification of love and compassion. Through love, one gives happiness to others, through compassion, one takes suffering from others. At this point, one gives rise to the supreme resolve, which is a resolve to free others of their suffering and to give them lasting happiness. But such a general resolve is seen as insufficient and therefore to do this in actuality, one resolves to attain the state in which one can do this, which is a state of full enlightenment for the sake of others.
In addition, bodhichitta is subdivided between aspiring and engaging bodhichitta. At present, we have covered aspiring bodhichitta. This is the bodhichitta which wishes for the state of full enlightenment for the sake of others. It is akin to a prayer or a wish. After generating aspiring bodhichitta, one must engage in the physical and verbal behavior to benefit others.
And this point is a point at which one generates engaging bodhichitta and this is marked by taking the bodhisattva vows. So this is a very good way of presenting. Now in actuality, before receiving bodhisattva vows, let alone tantric vows, it is said that the being must already have generated aspiring bodhichitta within his mind stream. This is quite a quite a source for thought, isn’t it? Now regarding the process of taking Bodhisattva vows, and in this room probably everybody has already taken Bodhisattva vows.
We have the imparter of the Bodhisattva vows, who is the Acharya, who gives the Bodhisattva vows. We have the mode of imparting Bodhisattva vows, and we have the recipient of Bodhisattva vows. It is said that the imparter of Bodhisattva vows is one who must be in the lineage of those who have trained their minds in the equalization into change of self and others and gained experience in this. Then the imparter of the vows is the guru or the spiritual teacher who gives these vows. The receiver of the vows is the disciple, and such a disciple must before taking the vows, have trained his mind in these seven subdivisions, the seven steps of the equalization and interchange of self and others.
And even though he may not have generated a fully characterized bodhichitta, which is difficult for us, he or she must have some type of taste or experience. Then even though at present, we lack fully characterized bodhichitta, through repeated familiarization with these seven steps of training the mind of the equalization and interchange of self and others, and understanding, in English we would say an experience or taste will arise and on the basis of this experience, we will be able to take fully characterized bodhisattva vows. So this is a presentation of the spiritual teacher who imparts the vows and the disciple who receives the vows. Now regarding the mode of transmission or the mode of bestowal of the vows, this is explained in great detail and in a very clear fashion in Lamrim Chenmo. We shall not enter into such detail here.
You can read this in Lamrim Chenmo. In brief, one visualizes all of the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas in space in front of oneself, and then one is taking an oath or a pledge. One says, I myself, just as all the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas of the path of the past, who after training in the six perfections for the sake of mother sentient beings attained full enlightenment, will also train myself in the six perfections and attain full enlightenment for their sake. And at this point, one has taken an oath, this is the bodhisattva vows. Then one has taken an oath or a pledge.
This fundamental commitment is a commitment to ourselves to strive to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all other sentient beings without exception. Now here, at this point, one has generated engaging bodhichitta. It is called engaging because one engages in action or in behavior for the sake of others. Until then, until one had taken those vows, one had only generated aspiring bodhichitta, which was of the nature of a prayer or a wish. So to have generated conventional bodhichitta, one must have generated both aspiring bodhichitta and engaging bodhichitta.
In other words, one must first have generated an aspiring bodhichitta, which wishes or prays to attain the state of full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings without exception, but this is not sufficient. One must then engage in the physical and verbal behavior which leads one to attain this state. Both are necessary. So here, the seven steps leading up to the generation of aspiring bodhichitta by means of the equalization interchange of self and others. The steps leading to the generation of aspiring bodhichitta.
These steps are seven in number, but it is a different process than the seven for the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhichitta. Here we have the steps ranging from equanimity all the way up to the supreme resolve, which are causes. Aspiring bodhichitta is the result. Now generally speaking, this is something which we can understand and we can hope to generate within our mind stream unlike the topic of emptiness, which is a difficult topic. So it is at this point, once one has taken Bodhisattva vows and has generated engaging bodhichitta that one engages in the practice of the six perfections ranging from training in generosity, the perfection of generosity, all the way up to up to training in the perfection of wisdom.
It is very helpful to present things in this way. Generally speaking, there are delicate points in the equalization and interchange of self and others which must be clarified. And if one does not present things in a sequential fashion, one risks becoming very confused. Then, when one has generated such a state of mind, even though there may be a little bit of physical hardship, there is great inner mental happiness. And such a being is someone who, from the time he or she rises in the morning, will be solely preoccupied with actualizing the welfare of others.
What can I do to help others? How can I help? How can I be of benefit? Actually, such a being reflects on this day and night, continuously, spontaneously. These are very beautiful lines of thought.
And when you face difficulties in your lives and all of you, you are married, you have children, you suffer from your marriage and you suffer from your children. Then if you reflect on the Lamrim and you reflect on these lines of reasoning, it will help you. Just joking. Please. I don’t know if I have to translate this or not.
It’s on a sensitive topic. So basically, once one has generated bodhichitta, then, one is mentally happy. Whatever happens and even if there is there are physical problems, one remains mentally happy. Then to speak of physical problems in a country like this one is difficult. In Australia, you don’t really have physical problems.
Even if you are sick or ill, you stretch out the hand and money falls from the government in the sky. Sorry. Then, this is a very good country. It’s difficult to find conditions better than these, we have in Australia. So one can’t really speak here of physical problems, but problems people have in this country are mental.
It’s in their minds. And then if you want to address mental problems, what is more powerful than training in love, compassion and bodhichitta? Then in reality, as you remember, understanding that one has a profoundly meaningful basis of leisure and endowment is the foundation of the path of the beings of all three scopes, the small, the middling and the great scope. And if this present body of ours in Australia is not an almost perfect basis for practice, then I don’t really know what is. Think of countries in which people face tremendous hardship, live in violence, war, and don’t even have an eye blink to practice, then we have all the time in the world.
We were born in a country in which the main activity day after day was slaughtering each other and all we knew how to do was to kill. Now how exactly would we practice? Then when we speak of a meaningful base of leisure leisure and endowment, this is a good example. How much better than this does it get? Then why exactly do we turn around like hamsters in a cage?
Simply because of our obsession with money. Our five senses are totally focused on getting money at any cost. This is the only thing we think about. Then what is money if not a means to gain physical happiness? In other words, we do not understand the importance of mental happiness.
And his holiness has pointed this out many times. Then once we have mental peace, what difference does physical suffering make? It is mental peace which matters. And, what is superior to generate mental peace than the Lamrim? It is the Lamrim which severs mental suffering.
As said many times, when we speak of eliminating mental suffering, this sounds easy. And when we speak of realizing mental happiness, it sounds difficult. But the meaning is exactly the same. Eliminating mental suffering and realizing mental happiness are one and the same. And there is no other means for this than the lamrim because Lamrim is precisely the stages of the path.
Then I do not know, but I hope that you recite the Lama Chöpa and pointed repeatedly out that the what is called in English, the Lamrim prayer at the end of the Lam Rim is extraordinarily profound. If you have the possibility, you should recite it in English for reflecting on the meaning. You can build your entire Lamrim practice on this. Now, when one studies, one must delineate the boundaries or the limits of concepts. What is the boundary of conventional bodhichitta or the mind of the Mahāyāna?
It is from the entry in the Mahāyāna path all the way up to the attainment of full enlightenment. During that whole period, the uncontrived mind of bodhichitta is present. Then love and compassion are present from before the beginning of the path up to full enlightenment. Now, regarding the relationship between love and great compassion. Actually Lamrim Chemo refers to great love as the counterpart of great compassion.
And what is the sequence of generation of great love and great compassion? Generally speaking, great love precedes the generation of great compassion. Then this may be a little bit new for you. So great love precedes a generation of great compassion, and the greater the love one experiences, in turn the greater the compassion. An example will make this easier to understand.
Let us imagine the love a mother has for her little child. Let us say maybe three or four years old, her only child. And if one has an only child in that age which is so sweet, then the slightest suffering that child experiences, one wants immediately to free that child from that suffering. In other words, out of the love one has for the child, compassion arises. And this is why love is generated before compassion.
Then as far as the four immeasurables are concerned, immeasurable love, compassion, equanimity and joy. There is no particular sequence of generation to the difference of great love and great compassion. Then previously, we had said that immeasurable love and immeasurable compassion were one and the same basically as great love and great compassion. They are not. My apologies.
It is one of those mistakes which arises in the course of conversation. Now after training in equanimity, one reflects as was said on the force of self cherishing and then on the qualities of cherishing others or altruism. At this point, I would suspect, although nothing in particular is said in the equalization and interchange of self and others, generation of bodhichitta regarding love and compassion, that at the point of reflecting on the qualities of cherishing others, probably great love will have been generated. Then we said that once great compassion has been generated, one has entered the path of the being of the great scope. At this point, it is a bit odd to assert that once one has generated great love, one has not entered the path of the being of the great scope.
So think about this one carefully. In the context of generating the motivation at present, let us think as follows. Ideally, when we rise in the morning, we should spontaneously generate a motivation to be of benefit to others and to be of benefit not just mentally, but also physically. Then if we are unable to do this, we should at the very least generate the motivation not to harm others, not to harm them either mentally or physically. The reason for this is that even though we might derive some short term satisfaction and benefit from harming another person physically or mentally, since phenomena are dependent originations and are linked, we ourselves will experience physical or mental harm as a result.
Then looking at things in that way, we should resolve not to harm others. And therefore, let us meditate on the purpose and the benefits of bodhichitta, great compassion and great love. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one, two, three, four, and also page five. Number six month offering.
First one and three. So at present regarding the generation of great love and great compassion and bodhichitta, obviously at present, we do not have fully characterized great love, great compassion or bodhichitta within our mind streams. However, we do have the foundations for both love and compassion within our mind stream, which one of us does not feel love and compassion for those who are close to us, whoever they might be, let us say, our children for instance. Then it is a case or a matter of ameliorating or improving these pre existing foundations in our mind. For instance, all of us wish to benefit those who are close to us.
A mother, for instance, wishes to benefit her child. She will do anything she can to help her child, to help him improve his lot in life. Then this is a foundation on which bodhichitta can be built. What precisely prevents us from generating great love, great compassion, bodhichitta, egoism, or self cherishing? We have nothing left to add.
Then obviously topics such as emptiness, coarser forms of emptiness, the subtle presentations of the four noble truths are very difficult to understand. But this topic is easy to understand. There’s nothing here which is difficult to understand. It’s a very different issue altogether to generate these states of mind stream within ourselves, but understanding them is easy. Okay.
Then I will take questions at present, one question per person, and please short concise questions, not long speeches. Okay. Thank you. What sorts of experiences? So when you spoke about how you go through the stages of aspiration and then I think then you take the vows, and then you said there’s an experience.
What’s that? So what is meant here is that when one trains the mind incrementally in these seven steps of mental training of the equalization interchange of self and others, then at the end, before one reaches the point where one takes bodhisattva vows, one must have some sort of feeling of what bodhichitta is. Not a physical. In the mind, mental sensation. So it’s not a an unfabricated experience of bodhichitta.
It’s a fabricated experience based on thinking of the course, thinking about the causes of bodhichitta. What is it about the vows that make the practice of bodhichitta so much more powerful? Once one has taken bodhisattva vows, then one’s physical and verbal activities become activities in the context of bodhichitta. I’ve got a question from last week. Geshela taught that the superior resolve induces bodhichitta within the interchange of self and others, is that supreme resolve equivalent to the seventh cause of special intention within the sevenfold cause and effect method?
There is a slight difference between the supreme resolve in the context of the equalization interchange of self and others, and the supreme resolve in the context of the seven fold causal regeneration of bodhichitta. It’s a difference of power or strength. A single person or people don’t have children? And how do they cultivate great the compassion? You know, like like, you love your child, you can set put try everything for your child.
But if you have you are married, but you are single, you don’t have a So at that point, you generate great compassion through the equalization and the interchange of self and others. I’m joking. There’s a lot of food for thought in the equalization and interchange of self and others. So here when one speaks of generating great compassion, the example of a mother’s love for her child is given just because it’s the most famous example of such love. But that doesn’t mean that one can’t generate great compassion if one doesn’t have children.
Every one of us has very powerful experiences of love for another person. It doesn’t have to be a child And on that basis, we can generate great compassion. Yeah. Who? Amanda.
Amanda inside. Yeah. I just wanted to ask whether Geshela will be covering the six perfections or has he already done that? And the second part of my question is, do we are the six perfections practiced for the benefit of people in this life or in future lives? So Geshela will be explaining the training in the six perfections, and the training in the six perfections is a benefit both to beings in this life and a benefit to beings in future lives.
Through the practice of interchange and exchange with self and others, we reduce our self cherishing. As we reduce the self cherishing, does it make it easier to realize emptiness? Perhaps because in the Lamrim, is clearly explained that self and other are mutually dependent. Self is not autonomous. It is dependent on other and this then abuts or links to dependent origination.
Also, it is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhicharyavatara that this should be the practice of the equalization and interchange of self and others should be kept as a secret practice. And the reason for keeping it secret and not public is because it is connected with the identification of the object of negation, therefore emptiness. Okay. Chris. Great love is said to be sorry, great compassion is said to be the cause, the primary cause for bodhichitta.
Would it be fair to say that great love and great compassion, if they are one nature separate isolates, that great love would also be part of that cause for development of bodhichitta because you couldn’t really have great compassion without great love. Please be careful. I said that love and compassion were of one nature but different isolates. I never said that great love and great compassion were of one nature in different isolates. They are not and cannot be because great love precedes great compassion.
They’re in a temporal sequence. So points out that love and compassion are of one nature but different isolate because love in general is the thought may all sentient beings have happiness. And compassion is in general the thought, may all sentient beings be bereft of suffering, and there is no major difference between these two. Hence, are said to be of one nature but different isolates. Great compassion is quite different in this respect.
It is that excuse me, great love is quite different in this respect. It is that thought of affectionate love for others. Yeah. Nick. In terms of the power and strength of engaging bodhichitta and aspiring bodhichitta, I roughly recall Khensur Rinpoche saying that there’s a difference.
Can I guess you can give the reason why there is such a difference? Like engaging body chitter was said to be a lot stronger in terms of the merit created? The difference is one of commitment. Aspiring bodhichitta is just a wish. May all sentient may I attain full enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings.
Engaging bodhichitta is a commitment or a vow to do so, and there is the power of the commitment which is present. Okay. Hello? This Saturday sorry. I have to put my glasses on.
Okay. Two to 04:30, Elias’s seminar on three principal aspects of the path. I think some of you came last time and how, you know, enjoyable that. And please make sure you to yourself to come and to bring your friends. And there’s two to 04:30 on this Saturday, three principal aspects of the path.
And, course, we have this great opportunity. And, you know, Geshela is very kindly giving, you know, refuge ceremony and four-armed Chenrezig empowerment to you to able to practice in a in a fully with the permission. So that’s fantastic that, you know, we should be grateful that, you know, Geshela is very kindly giving this precious refuge ceremony and four-armed Chenrezig. And that’s in our twenty fourth, one thirty starts. And if you haven’t taken a refuge,
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is the supreme resolve the same as the seventh cause, special intention, in the sevenfold cause and effect method of generating bodhichitta?
They are not quite the same. There is a slight difference between the supreme resolve in the equalizing and exchanging of self and others and the supreme resolve in the sevenfold causal method of generating bodhichitta. The difference lies in power or strength. The passage does not say which is stronger or give further detail on how they differ.