Lam Rim – 301116lamrim 2 – KR

1 h 45 min · 4,401 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 301116lamrim 2 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains the perfection of perseverance or enthusiasm, defined as delight in virtuous deeds and not being downcast, and the three forms of laziness (indolence, lack of self-confidence, and delight in evil deeds) with their antidotes. It notes that the first four perfections prepare for concentration and wisdom, and that meditation means mental reflection on bodhichitta, including the two aspirations. The talk closes with a few questions on posture, shared karma and the aspiration for others’ welfare.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 46m

UUID: de31b854-7c1d-4e16-89d9-6447e2c0781f

Words: 4,397

Mhmm. So today we will cover the explanation of the perfection of perseverance or enthusiasm. Then when I covered elaborately the presentation of great compassion and of bodhichitta, you may have wondered whether we would ever cover perseverance or enthusiasm when we did get there but we had to cover the preliminaries first. We need to have skill and means when we study and with skill and means, then we will never experience physical hardship when we study, instead we will experience delight. Enthusiasm is important.

That is true that I tell you that everything is important, but enthusiasm is important. Obviously it’s an experience we all have. When we study great compassion, this is the most important thing there is. Then when we study bodhichitta, what is more important than bodhichitta? Then when we’re studying definite emergence, nothing is more important than definite emergence.

It’s actually a very good way to look at things because with that outlook, one makes no distinction between the higher and the lower. And at present, regarding the perfection of enthusiasm or perseverance, Then the chapter on perfection of perseverance or enthusiasm in Bodhisattvacharyavatara is I believe the seventh chapter. And, it is striking that almost the totality of Bodhisattvacharyavatara is quoted in Lamrim Cemo. Then, a very good way to study these various topics is to look at these quotes of Bodhisattvacharyavatara within Then the nature or the definition of enthusiasm is a delight in virtuous deeds. You can also define it as an intention which delights in virtuous Then, right now, all of us have enthusiasm.

We delight in the prospect of studying. But as Gisela continues to teach and the hours pass on, then this enthusiasm will wane and we will lose this delight. And obviously, the problem is the body and specifically the five doors. Then as time passes, one experiences hardship. This really is laziness.

Honestly, our brains become full like a sponge is full of water, then it just overflows, right? The brain is very important. Frankly, when we speak of a precious human rebirth, what are we speaking about is not the human brain. It is certainly not the physical body we are referring to. We are referring to the brain and to its extensions, deep five sense organs.

Since precisely independence on our brain, we are able to master to understand whatever we train in. There are numerous verses in Bodhisattvacharyavatara about this one which says that the human rebirth is a locus of benefit. So, therefore, not only should we study these topics, but we should actually engage in them. We should live them. Then, clearly, all of us wish to be free from suffering, and all of us wish to be happy.

But this is not merely something we should study. It is something we should live, we should engage in. And within suffering, as was explained, we have physical and mental suffering. Then it is mental suffering which is our focus, and the root of mental suffering is the coarse afflictions. This is what we have to target and encounter.

So here, enthusiasm can be defined also as not being downcast at the prospect of engaging in virtue. Then this means basically not to allow this downcastness to arise within our minds. And here, there are three antithetical states to enthusiasm. These are these three forms of laziness. The first is indolence.

The second is a sense of incapacity. The third is the laziness which delights in wrong action. So, the first category or division of laziness, the laziness of indolence is something which is present in all our mind streams. It is that mindset which thinks, yes, I’m going to study the Lamrim, but tomorrow. Or actually, I’ll study the Lamrim this afternoon after lunch.

And when this afternoon comes, yes, I’ll study the Lamrim in a while, but first I’m going to have a little chat with my friends. And this is the laziness of indolence. So this is the laziness of indolence. All of us have. I have it within myself, and I recognize it.

It is that mindset which, even when you are studying, makes you stop after you have understood something, relax and think of something else. Then here, when we refer to enthusiasm, we refer to a delight in the accomplishment of virtuous deeds. And this is not the type of enthusiasm one encounters in worldly affairs. In worldly affairs, one would use a different Tibetan term, which literally means having a bone in the heart. It is toughnesses, if you wish.

Then the antidote to this first laziness, the laziness of indolence is reflecting on death and impermanence. And this is something we all understand, specifically its three subdivisions, and within that the uncertainty of the time of death. And for us Buddhists Buddha Śākyamūni is the most important figure. Yet Buddha Śākyamūni is dead. Then a very helpful way to think about this is to reflect on time.

Nothing is more valuable than time. Once you have wasted a minute of your time, you cannot buy it again. Then this leads onto reflection on death and impermanence because that minute of time wasted is a minute of time closer to one’s own death. And this reflection on meditation and death impels us to study and we should study these sections within the Lam Rim. The second form of laziness is the laziness of lack of self confidence.

And this occurs when one thinks there’s just no way I can do this. This is too difficult. It takes too long. And the way to counter this is to think of first the fact that Buddha Śākyamūni himself strived for a very long period of time. It is said to be three countless eons.

And then to reflect on the fact that even before we have attained full enlightenment, when we are able to generate uncontrived definite emergence or uncontrived bodhichitta, just how happy we will be. And the third form of laziness is the laziness which engages in evil deeds. And this occurs very easily. It would be difficult to explain this in detail based on the text. It would be too extensive.

But let us take the example of conversation. We meet someone and we say, how do you do? They say, how do you do? Then we say, what about your family and relatives? Then they answer.

Then it starts. And then we talk and talk and talk. And numerous thoughts are accumulated in the process. Then a huge amount of time is wasted and here it is critical to see the faults or the defects of this behavior that we would not engage in. And therefore, the nature of enthusiasm is not being downcast.

Now, in turn is subdivided into three. The first subdivision is armor like enthusiasm, which prevents any downcastness from arising. The second subdivision of enthusiasm is enthusiasm in the practice of virtue. And this means whatever virtuous deeds we engage in, we are never downcast. And the third subdivision is the enthusiasm in performing the welfare of sentient beings and this is, if you wish, virtuous deeds extended to others.

So, enthusiasm is a vast topic. Then after enthusiasm next year, we will study the two last perfections, the perfection of dhyana or concentration and of wisdom which are part of the insight section of Lam Rim So, here it is important to understand that these four perfections, the four first perfections, are a prelude or a preparation for concentration and wisdom. The first perfection, the perfection of generosity, is the main means to counter avarice or stinginess. In other words, to counter attachment, coarse attachment. The second perfection, the perfection of ethics, is the main way to train in an ethics which is an abandonment of non virtue.

Then at that point, one engages in the practice of the perfection of forbearance, which enables one to counter a particularly coarse affliction, anger. And once the afflictions have subdued somewhat, then there is more space for the activities which are virtuous in nature, and one engages in the perfection of And we have received many teachings. Then for yourselves, the situation is a bit awkward because I present the way I feel about things, and you don’t seem to have the time to attend many teachings. So how much of what I present resonates within you, I frankly don’t know. I hope it does.

And this is really my own private opinion. Sometimes I feel that I studied or listened perhaps too much because really, one has to put in practice. And as is said, it is only at the level of the third ground that one is satisfied with hearing or study. Then the goal of the perfections starting with the practice of generosity, ethics, forbearance, and so forth is to lead up to the perfection of wisdom. Likewise, all of the practices starting with definite emergence at the level of the being of the small and the middling scope, then bodhichitta have as a goal to lead to the generation of bodhichitta.

And then hand in hand, one has to train in the wisdom which realizes emptiness and bodhichitta. As Je Tsongkhapa says in the Three Principles of the Path, and this is really a foundational text, if one is bereft of the wisdom which realizes the mode of abiding, however much one trains in definite emergence in bodhichitta, one will not be able to sever the roots of existence. And indeed, one needs the wisdom realizing emptiness to sever the roots of existence. But in addition to the wisdom component of the path, one needs also the method component of the path which is definite emergence and bodhichitta and they operate in tandem. And therefore, the first five perfections ranging from the perfection of generosity all the way up to the perfection of concentration are preparations for the perfection of wisdom.

And specifically, for the insight focused on emptiness or the inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused upon emptiness. Now, you can see in the progression from perfection to perfection that as one progresses from the lower perfections upwards, the focus on exterior deeds dwindles. And as a focus on exterior deeds dwindles, a focus on interiority increases. Next year, our focus will be on emptiness and specifically on emptiness in accordance with the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka view. Then this is a difficult topic, it is not easy to understand and therefore I would like to encourage you to study before we start the year this topic by yourselves.

The more you study, the easier it will become. Then as far as bodhichitta and definite emergence are concerned, I believe all of you understand what bodhichitta is, and I think it is possible to generate uncontrived definite emergence and bodhichitta eventually. Next year, I would like to think you will be able to at least understand what emptiness is. Then to generate a valid cognizer realizing emptiness, that is not easy. Eventually one is able to conjoin bodhichitta and the view.

So, therefore, one initially generates a definite emergence at the level of the path of the being of the middling scope. And then understanding that all others are beset by the afflictions like ourselves, one extends this to others generating great compassion. Then, independence on great compassion, one gives rise to bodhichitta. At this point, one trains in the perfections, the perfection of generosity, ethics, forbearance, and so forth. Then you inquired last time the antidote, excuse me, the perfection of generosity acts as antidote to stinginess or avarice, and the perfection of forbearance acts as antidote to anger.

But how is it possible for stinginess and anger to be present in the mind stream after definite emergence has been generated? Well, clearly some or a little bit is left, but yours is a very good question. Then, it’s independence on your question that I started wondering, yes it is true, after all uncontrived definite emergence in bodhichitta have been generated and yet it would seem the coarse afflictions have not subsided. How is this possible? Then you are uncommon trainees which gives rise to such doubts in the mind of your teacher.

Exactly. You know, So here, once uncontrived bodhichitta has been generated, I would like to think that jealousy and envy cannot arise. However, regarding anger, it is another affair. Anger can and does arise Simply because otherwise there would be no rationale for the explanation of the perfection of forbearance and training in it. And the example which makes this clear would be that of the relation to a child in a family.

We get angry with a child in a family setting, but this anger is actually for the sake of the child. So this anger is not an anger for our own sake, it is an anger for the sake of the child. Then this is found for instance in higher bodhisattvas, let’s say in relation to lower bodhisattvas. When the bodhisattva, the higher bodhisattva thinks this lower bodhisattva is not doing what he pledged to do. Then, clearly, the anger of such beings, bodhisattvas, is not the same as the anger of ordinary beings like ourselves.

Then today, really, we should meditate a bit. And obviously, you know, when I say you should meditate on bodhichitta or you should meditate on the definite emergence or for that matter, on emptiness or impermanence, I would like to think you don’t adopt a glorious posture and put your mind in a state of blankness. Instead, you should actually think. You should reflect. So meditation does not mean to adopt a particular posture, crossing one’s legs and folding one’s arms.

This is exterior behavior. This is subsidiary. It’s a subsidiary branch. Meditation is mental training. And then we have fixative and analytical meditation.

Now when you meditate that’s in a topic like bodhichitta, you must meditate on the totality of the topic as we explained the two aspirations within bodhichitta. And you can meditate from the topic itself downwards or from the foundation of the path upwards. Both are possible. Then you can meditate in the sequence you wish and you are most accustomed to. But if we take a topic like bodhichitta, you should meditate on the two aspirations.

The aspiration for the sake of others and the aspiration for full and utter enlightenment. Now, the aspiration for full and utter enlightenment induces an aspiration for the sake of others, which is great compassion. But this great compassion can only arise, and here we start moving downwards, if one is aware of one’s own suffering. If one is not aware of one’s own suffering, how can one feel compassion for that of others? And regarding one’s own suffering, as was explained, there are two types of suffering, physical and mental suffering, and our main focus is on mental suffering.

So this is how one proceeds. And then after you have meditated in this way, when doubts arise, you can ask them during the question session. And therefore, we should put effort in this way reflecting on bodhichitta. Now it is a given that if we become habituated to thinking of bodhichitta and study it eventually, we will be able to generate uncontrived fully characterized bodhichitta. Not being able to do so is a sign of laziness.

Let us now meditate today for eight, nine minutes. Don’t sleep. Yeah. Don’t sleep, please. Okay.

Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one, two, three, and four. Also page five. Number six, mandala offering. Verse one and three.

So, one needs time to meditate. Then study is somewhat different. You can pick up a topic and study as much as you want. But meditation means actually to reflect on the meaning of what one has studied and I suppose we are all the same in that our mind at first does not engage the topic. It’s almost refuses to engage the topic.

Then it takes time. This will not occur in a short period of time. You need twenty minutes to half an hour to meditate, especially because we are beginners. And once one is a skilled and experienced meditator, it happens fast. And we should do retreats.

Really, it is when one does retreat, whether it is for three months, two months, for one month, maybe less a week, that there is a transformation. Because during the retreat, there is behavior one must engage in and behavior one must abstain in, and one must focus on practice. And, clearly, when you engage in a retreat, you must make this unambiguous distinction between what you should engage in and what you should abstain from. Then if your behavior and mindset doesn’t change, why don’t you bother to start the retreat? Then most of us when we think of retreats tend to think of tantric retreats and counting retreats, but actually it is a Lamrim retreats which matter.

Then frankly so many say they don’t have time. Then what one say? Then when you engage in retreat, the time must be used purely. So within the twenty four hours of a day, you set aside, let’s say six or seven hours for sleep, then whatever, one hour for food, and then obviously you don’t talk, there’s no conversation, right? So the rest of the time one focuses on practice.

Then some have very vivid dreams when they do retreats, Geshela does, some don’t. It depends on the person. Then Australia is a very quiet country so there’s nothing to interfere with your concentration, your meditation. It’s a peaceful country. Most of you have your own houses.

Then you have excellent material conditions. What more than that is required? Then as he said, even though it is like that, nonetheless, then what can you do in that case? But said that at the end of the three principles of the past, one should go forth into a solitary retreat in a hermitage in the mountains. Then really what more is there to say, we do have the opportunity and then if one engages in this practice, there will be benefit for one’s mind, it’s a given.

Then I rejoice in the fact that so many of you came this year and put effort. Next year, we will be covering emptiness and dependent arising. Then it is a rare opportunity to have such a translator who has experience. And therefore, I would enjoin you not to waste your time, but to put effort next year. And there are many expressions in the monasteries for this.

Then you yourselves, you should think about yourselves, you should think about your own benefit. If you start thinking about others, then there will be trouble. Then this center was created for you, Geshe-la, Tenzin, the volunteers, myself, we work for you. But you, you have to think about yourselves. Then for myself, I can say that there has been a great benefit in teaching these topics.

I have certainly understood something I had not understood at the monastery during my studies, which is that upon generating an insight, a reason for meditation and emptiness, the afflictions do subside. And I have also understood something which I found difficult to understand, which is that one must counter the appearance of objects. Then this has been of great benefit to me. Then we are mutually dependent, you and I. I stayed at the monastery for many years uninterruptedly and studied and I would like to make this available.

I probably, I suspect most of you don’t think you’re coming here to benefit me. It’s my way of looking at things. Then from my own side, I can truly say that I endeavor to generate a good motivation to teach, to explain these topics so that you understand them, so that you can dispel your mental suffering and the main source of mental suffering are the afflictions. So we have to find a means to dispel the afflictions. Then once this is done, our goal is our own happiness and that of this entire world we live in.

In that respect, we are the same. Then, for mental peace and happiness, we need this practice. This practice is useless for physical happiness and health. Tenzin fell quite ill with the flu a couple days ago. Then the only way to handle that sort of problem is to stay quietly at home and take whatever medicine one has to take.

That’s how one heals. Then please take good care of your health since at the end of the day as beginners our minds are completely at the mercy of our bodies and exercise within moderation, try to go on walks and so forth. In Australia, we have exceptional conditions. Then it is entirely in your hands whether you do something with these conditions or you waste your life. In my case for instance, as a little child, I never experienced tasting anything sweet, it was unknown.

Then I have nothing left to add. And for myself I can say there has been great benefit and I sincerely hope you have benefited a bit from these teachings. My mind certainly was transformed by having to teach these topics. So I’ll take tonight only two questions. It seemed to me that bearing the, guess I spoke earlier on about over time the body experiences hardship which is laziness and it seems to be the enthusiasm required to overcome that laziness seems related to the third category of forbearance accepting hardship for the dharma.

Is that third category of forbearance accepting hardship for the dharma could that be a cause or a condition to contribute towards the perfection of perseverance? Yes, they are quite similar. The latter two divisions of ethics, the latter two divisions of generosity, the latter two divisions of forbearance, and all three divisions of enthusiasm are linked. So next Wednesday, I’m gonna try to teach in English. And you better come because it’s gonna be fun.

And then, after that next year, I’ll rely on the kindness of the translator. I have to rely on the kindness of the translator, but from my own side, I really want to practice my That’s the problem of having two languages. I understand most of what you say, obviously not the technical terms, but if people speak slowly like the translator, I understand well, then you start speaking quickly and skipping, then it’s hopeless. And if you break from time to time when you speak, then it makes it easy. And if it’s uninterrupted like a flow of water, it’s hopeless.

What happened? Just one question, second question. So no problem, we’ll make an exception, you can have a third question. Geshela, just a small point about teaching meditation and the posture. I thought the posture was quite important when it came to the channels, sitting correctly so that the wind channels are unimpeded.

Can Geshele say something about that? Yes, definitely. If we adopt an erect posture then the winds can enter and flow with greater ease in the channels and the mind follows the winds. But what I am saying is that meditation is not posture, what matters is a mental transformation. Geshela cited the circumstances of a higher bodhisattva being angry or expressing anger towards a lower bodhisattva.

For the sake of the lower bodhisattva apparently not pulling his or her weight, What sort of circumstances might there be where a body sufferer was not pulling their weight? I I find that inconceivable, but what what was So setting Bodhisattvas aside, we can see this in teachers when one thinks of one’s teacher and one thinks he is such a remarkable person, so exceptional, then the same thing happens with Bodhisattvas. Right? It happens with Bodhisattvas of the lesser and middling path of accumulation. So, then obviously the anger in a bodhisattva’s mind is not like in our minds an anger which differentiates between closeness and distance.

And I ask Geshela’s permission to give you the case of his son, Mr. Dalai Lama, who said when I was attending a teaching, that he had gotten angry with his translator whom, as you know, is quite difficult. Then, obviously, it is for the sake of the translator. Something we can see. You can’t say that there are no afflictions whatsoever in the continuum of Bodhisattva.

Have a question? Within the twin aspirations of bodhichitta, the aspiration to enact the welfare of others, is that the wish to bring all beings to the state of full and utter enlightenment rather than yeah. Is the aspiration to enact the welfare of others the wish to bring them to the state of enlightenment? No. The aspiration for the sake of others is compassion.

It’s a mere wish to free others from suffering. So, it’s best when one reflects on the wish to enact the wheel of others in the mind of a Bodhisattva to think of great compassion. I read in the Internet or somebody also told me about shared karma. The definition, is there such a term same karma? It’s like if like the 10 non virtuous deed, if a person have this idea to like killing for example and the other person, friends or agree with the same idea to kill another person and What is the effect you know the effect you know the the the karmic effect later on Is that these two person have the same karma?

If two people associate and they plan to murder a third party and within the two, one of them commits murder, when the third party dies, both have accumulated the non virtuous deed of killing a human being completely. It is a very difficult point. Yeah. But does that mean that two persons, accumulate this karma, the next life, do they get killed by this the person who who who got killed by them? It happens.

It does happen. Because of the interdependent relation between the deeds. Yeah, yeah, stop there, next. Please. Thank you.

Please open the prayer book, page nine. This is the end of the teaching this year. So we’re gonna do the show slowly, one offering.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
dhyana samten (Tib)
An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top