Lam Rim – 27092017Lamrim (Salam6 – KR

1 h 29 min · 4,029 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 27092017Lamrim (Salam6 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Explains going for refuge in the Triple Gem as a stable, reasoned conviction that protects from the lower realms, using the example of a doctor and medicine, and presents the Dharma within one’s own mind as the actual refuge. It then outlines the Mahayana paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing and meditation, and the ten grounds, distinguishing conceptual from non-conceptual realization of emptiness. The talk ends with student questions on bodhicitta and the afflicted mind.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 30m

UUID: c10b7708-4e13-46a6-8ca7-4df04b722ca0

Words: 4,025

Refuge is extremely important and generally speaking, there are three refuges. The refuge of the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope. This depends on the motivation. Geshela thought he would start by explaining the refuge of the being of the small scope. To go for refuge.

To go. To go for refuge. To go go for refuge. For refuge. Is asking me the difference between in Tibetan, say is refuge.

Means for or two, and is to go. So literally, instead of saying refuge, we should say to go for refuge. To go for refuge. To go for refuge. And Geshela points out that he he has heard many strange expressions here.

People say to take refuge. Then actually the term is to go for refuge. Then when hardship and difficulties arise, we go for refuge. We go for protection. Then our parents cannot give this refuge, this protection.

So we need something whose nature is to give protection, and we need to have conviction in its capacity to protect us. If when we we are beset with difficulties, we do not go in this way for refuge. We can become very very narrow minded, very small. Then, obviously, there are the cases of people who think they will be happy if they go to a different country, who think they’ll be happy if they move to different area or eat different food. And that is not what is being talked about here.

But when you start thinking, I’ll be happy if I have a different friend in my life, then you get closer. However, it is critical to have conviction, to be convicted or convinced, excuse me, in the potency of the object to which one goes for refuge. And here, one goes for refuge not for protection from the difficulties of this life, but for protection from the hardships from the future life onwards. Do you understand? Then if one studies dharma with the strong conviction that this is really going to be of benefit to my mind, then that is actual refuge.

That is true refuge. Dharma is said to be the actual refuge, and then one doesn’t need anything else. One doesn’t need any helpers. And otherwise, if one needs helpers, things get complicated. So here, when one speaks of going for refuge, one must distinguish going for refuge and the practice of going for refuge, and one should also distinguish the object to which one goes for refuge.

Geshela would like to ask you, when you practice going for refuge, what do you do? What does that mean for you? Big silence. The basics. Avoiding non virtue and practicing virtue.

In terms of actually practicing going for refuge, I would commence that with a motivation setting as my strong motivation through all the three scopes of the Lam Rim with the object of changing my mind towards virtue. I think about the preciousness of this human life. I think about death and impermanence. I think about suffering, my own and that of the lower realms. I think of the capacity of the triple gem to protect me from suffering in this life and in future lives.

And with that conviction, I then go for refuge in the triple gem. So I just think of it as taking a commitment when I go for refuge. I should have said having fear of the consequences of negative actions in terms of the lower realms and having confidence that the triple gem and especially the practice of restraint from non virtue will protect me based on the teachings. To put into practice the teachings of the dharma to my everyday life. Okay.

Good, very good. So going for refuge means placing your hope in something. And the meaning is explained clearly by the example of falling seriously ill. When one falls seriously ill, one seeks for protection from that disease. Then one seeks for someone who can protect one from that disease.

The actual protection from the disease is whatever medicine one takes. The protector who dispels the disease is a doctor who gives the medicine. So when one is seriously ill, one tries to find a mean to heal or eradicate this disease. Then one seeks for an experienced doctor who is knowledgeable. One asks around who who knows what to do in these cases, who is well known, and what medicine will heal me.

And then one must be convinced in the capacity of such a doctor, and of the medicine to heal one. Likewise, as far as refuge of the being shared with a small scope is concerned, what one is trying to gain protection from is the suffering of the lower realms. And one generates conviction in the capacity of Buddha Śākyamūni and his teachings to protect us from that. So generally speaking, people go for refuge in Buddha Śākyamūni and his teachings out of conviction. Then this is good, but the issue which arises is fine, Buddha Śākyamūni can protect us from the sufferings of the lower realms.

But how can he protect us? What is the mode of this protection? That is the critical point. Then to go for refuge out of faith in a temple like this with one’s hands folded, that is a very limited benefit. Then all of us recite the single-pointed entreaty of the Lama Chöpa.

You were the guru. You were the tutelary deity and so forth. But what precisely we mean when we recite that, that is open to the question. Many people come to temples like this one and with their hands folded, they go for refuge and make prayers. What exactly they pray for, one does not know.

Do they pray for benefit for this life? Do they pray for benefit for future lives? That we do not know. But in any case, although it is said that Buddha Śākyamūni teaches the way to liberation, this temple alone actually is made of matter, or to be more specific of wood and stone. The statues behind us are also wood and stone.

Whether wood and stone can be of any benefit is open to question. Then one can consider that there are three objects of refuge, Buddha Shakyam or Buddha, his teachings and the Sangha, or one can just consider that there is one object of refuge. Buddha who encapsulates all three objects of refuge. In either case, at the end of the day, what matters is gaining oneself experience of this. It is the same thing as saying that food is delicious.

Then until one has actually tasted the food oneself, and one can vouch for the fact that it not only is tasty, but wholesome, there is no way to be sure of this. Likewise, if one has a headache, it is completely useless to talk about the virtues of the medicine. One must take the medicine. So here it is therefore very important to understand the mode of existence of Buddha Śākyamūni’s potency to offer refuge. This is what gives rise to stable refuge, as opposed to the wishy washy refuge, which we typically have, which is based on no reasons and is floating.

Buddha Śākyamūni said numerous times to his followers and disciples, faith in me alone will not be able to help you and will not be able to dispel your sufferings. You should study. You should analyze my teachings. Buddha also said, I do not transmit my realizations. I liberate through teaching suchness.

Now liberate from what? Liberate from the sufferings of the lower realms. So therefore, as Buddha Śākyamūni said, it is through teaching suchness that I liberate not through transmitting realizations. And here, suchness refers to the four noble truths. So whether the four noble truths are tasty, delicious, or not, that is something we will know when we actually experience them, when we try to practice.

Otherwise, it’s a little bit similar to someone who sets out a meal on a table and says this is delicious. He or she has actually no way of knowing this. It is a person who eats the meal who knows. Then when we speak of the mode of existence of the capacity of the triple gem to offer refuge, What we mean is in a nutshell, the capacity of the triple gem to offer refuge. Then apart from Buddha’s teachings, the Buddhist scriptures, there is nothing else.

The totality of the teachings of the Buddha are summarized in the three baskets, Tripitaka. And the three baskets themselves are summarized in the three trainings. The training in ethics, concentration and wisdom. Now these three trainings, if one summarizes them, can be summarized in the method and the wisdom aspect of the path. Now what the method and wisdom aspect of the path, what their relation is are, are they big, are they small, are they white, are they red, that we have to examine.

Then the totality of the method and wisdom aspect of the path is summarized in the Lamrim. When after studying the Lamrim, we are able to start to practice this, to integrate it within our mind, to change our mind in the light of the Lamrim, then the difficulties we experience in this life will dwindle. When these difficulties dwindle, we will understand the capacity of the triple gem to protect our mind. Then obviously, if they don’t dwindle, it’s been a waste of time. So once one has done this, then there is no longer any fear of the suffering of the lower realms.

One is protected from the suffering of the lower realms. And at this point, the dharma refuge is within one’s own mind. This is the actual refuge. Buddha Śākyamūni is said to be the teacher of the actual refuge, and the Sangha are said to be those who accompany one in one’s practice. But the actual refuge is this one.

Then if one is not able to create such an actual refuge, when difficulties arise in our life, then we turn to antidepressants to drugs and whatnot, you know. And then if one is unable to have such a stable, reliable helper, the dharma refuge within oneself, Then one turns to drugs, one turns to antidepressants, and however much these can pacify one. Geshela is not sure, but maybe a month, a week, a day, whatever. At the end of this, it all starts again. In the meantime, one will be stupefied.

Then the goal therefore is to become the master of our own minds. Do you understand? Transforming one’s own mind is a long drawn out process. It takes much time. One must invoke a lot of reasons, rely on the works of a lot of scholars.

It happens slowly. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said that when in dependence on a good motivation through study, eventually over time, once mental difficulties decrease and once mental happiness increases, at that point, that is dharma. Then this obviously does not refer to the occasional brief bursts of happiness we all experience for a variety of other reasons. Now moving onwards to grounds and paths, Generally speaking, within the fourfold subdivision of the Mahāyāna path of preparation, warmth, peak, forbearance, and supreme dharma, one is liberated from rebirth in the lower realms at the level of forbearance of the path of preparation. One can be reborn in the lower realms at the level of the path of accumulation, but one does not dwell there for long.

However, from the middling level of the path of accumulation, one is probably no longer reborn in the lower realms. If this is presented from the standpoint of grounds and paths. Now when one says the level of forbearance of the path of preparation, this refers to all three vehicles. So the path level of forbearance of the path of preparation of heroes, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas. So now, Geshela would like to ask you to give him the five Mahāyāna paths.

Return. Mahāyāna path of accumulation, Mahāyāna path of preparation, Mahāyāna path of seeing, Mahāyāna path of meditation, and the path of no more learning. Meditation. Minor path of This is how the teachers interrogate the students at the monastery. First you get examinations, then you are individually debated with and so forth.

Then one is asked to give definition, one is asked to give instances or examples. Obviously, is for the lower classes and later on in the higher classes, we’ll focus mainly on the meaning of the texts on the studying. So what are the differences between the Mahāyāna path of accumulation and the Mahāyāna path of preparation? The Mahāyāna path of preparation and insight focused on emptiness has been generated. This is not the case for a Mahāyāna path of accumulation.

And that insight is actually a conceptual insight which is contrived, relies on a line of reasoning. So just simply, you can say the distinction between these two paths is that between having attained and not attained an insight focused on emptiness. What is the difference between the Mahāyāna path of preparation and of seeing? Madam? On the Mahāyāna path of seeing you’ve generated a non conceptual awareness of emptiness whereas on the path of preparation you’ve only achieved a realized a conceptual realization of emptiness.

Can you hear some? I keep going. I’m gonna retire in no time. Preparation is a distinction. Right?

Preparation. Yes. Definitely. What is the difference between an ordinary being and an Aryabh? An Ārya being has had a direct realization of emptiness.

And? Ordinary being? An ordinary thing So what’s the difference between a normal being and an ārya being? You studied all this. You should be able to do this easily.

You obviously are saying, you mean non-conceptual. Geshela hopes. So ordinary beings have a realization of emptiness which is linked with conceptuality. What is the difference between a Mahāyāna path of seeing and a Mahāyāna path of meditation? The Yana path of meditation is a subsequent generation of a direct insight into emptiness which is entered into with the motivation appropriate to the level of abandonment of that particular meditation. Whereas a Mahāyāna path of seeing is the first direct perception of emptiness.

Another. Chris? Really? It is a bit more difficult because both beings on a Mahāyāna path of seeing and of meditation are Ārya beings. Both have direct realization of emptiness, then one must be able to pause at the difference one occurs after the other.

So the way to understand the distinction between a Mahāyāna path of seeing and of meditation is to understand the mode of passage from a Mahāyāna path of seeing to a Mahāyāna path of meditation. Just as the way to understand the distinction between a Mahāyāna path of preparation and of seeing is to understand the mode of passage between these two paths. I think the ārya being can, in the path of seeing, has to generate the direct realization of emptiness whereas on the path of meditation it is having come off the cushion. There is no need to generate the direct naked experience of emptiness. The question is important.

So you should reflect carefully on the mode of transition between the path of preparation and seeing, and the path of seeing and of meditation. Now here, these practitioners have tremendous familiarity with emptiness, and it is this familiarity which gives rise to a non conceptual realization of emptiness. Whether the on the path of seeing, for instance, realization is always non conceptual is another question Geshela does not think so. Initially one must have a preliminary conceptual realization of emptiness before the non conceptual realization arises. Because of the great habituation, initially one thinks about emptiness conceptually, and then there is a transition to a non conceptual realization of emptiness.

Then when exactly is bodhichitta present in his mind? Are bodhichitta present and great compassion continually present uninterruptedly? He does have to think about having lunch, doesn’t Then if one is able to think about all of this at the same time in one mind, then probably one is enlightened. So it is important to reflect on the following topics. Is or are bodhichitta in great compassion continually present in the mind of a bodhisattva or not?

Likewise, on a Mahāyāna path of seeing, is the consciousness realizing emptiness continually present or not? Is the insight focused on emptiness continually present or not? So what precisely is the mode of transition between a Mahāyāna path of seeing and a Mahāyāna path of meditation? On a Mahāyāna path of seeing, one has generated for the first time a direct perception of emptiness. That does not mean that it is continually uninterruptedly present.

Then once one has stopped or cut that session, in keeping with the definition of a Mahāyāna path of meditation as a subsequent manifest realization. When one gains again a direct perception of emptiness, one is on a Mahāyāna path of meditation. So previously, one had generated a direct perception of emptiness on a Mahāyāna path of seeing. Then that is interrupted. And the difference between a Mahāyāna path of meditation and a Mahāyāna path of seeing, is that the Mahāyāna path of meditation occurs after that interruption.

Now, the path of meditation must be explained in terms of the 10 grounds. And if each of the grounds were explained individually, we would lose a lot of time. But in brief, during these 10 grounds, one abandons the obstructions to omniscience, and one abandons them incrementally from the greater of the great obstructions of the omniscience to the middling of the middling obstructions of omniscience to the smallest of the small by applying antidotes which are also progressively greater and greater. So during the path of meditation, therefore, one abandons progressively the innate ignorance which grasps at a self. And one does so through focusing on emptiness with ever more subtle and more powerful mind.

Then wall in Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, nothing is said about a difference in subtlety of the emptinesses. There is a big difference of subtlety in the minds concerned in Tsongkhapa’s opinion. So at present, we will generate bodhichitta in conjunction with a good motivation, and then do the recitations. Recite page one and page also five. One b, refuge and bodhichitta.

Page five number six, Bodhichitta. Then it is ideal when one gets up in the morning, and we all have to get up in the morning to generate a good motivation, in other words, to generate bodhichitta. And then to proceed through one’s day with bodhichitta. bodhichitta is nothing else but altruism. The wish to benefit or to help others.

Then as a result of generating bodhichitta at the beginning of our day, our whole day will proceed well and we will experience no suffering because we will be countering self cherishing, which is the root of suffering. Then, if one proceeds in this way, one will be happy and it is up to us to make or to generate our own happiness. So it is really important to think of others. Now whether this thinking of others can turn into actually helping others, that’s another question. It happens later on, but we should try not to fall under the sway of egoism or self cherishing.

Then it is as one progresses on the grounds and paths, especially the grounds that it becomes possible to differentiate self cherishing and grasping at a self. At present for us, they are almost completely inseparable. So Geshela would like to point out here that it is very helpful to analyze this in terms of the presentation of the afflicted mind, is done on Tuesdays here. As you remember, the afflicted mind is said to be present throughout cyclic existence except at certain critical moments during equipoise, for instance, on emptiness. And at these moments, what remains present is the nature of clarity and cognitiveness of the afflicted mind, but not the additional four mental factors which I explained in the Tuesday class on Chitamatra.

Now precisely this line of reasoning is what enables one to understand differentiation between self cherishing and self grasping in the mind stream for instance of an Okay, have your question? I’d like to clarify something from last week when we were talking about, let’s see, as in desire and hatred, friendships and enmities arise in dependence on the visual consciousness and the auditory consciousness, and then this is the part I’m curious about, the visual consciousness is the controlling condition and the auditory consciousness is the immediately preceding condition. If I’m not understanding the definitions of the meanings of the controlling condition and the immediately preceding condition. Geshela will definitely explain the distinction between controlling conditions and immediately preceding conditions at some point. Right now, we will waste a lot of time.

The definition of a path is a sapience upheld by definite emergence. To enter the path of the Mahāyāna path of accumulation, one needs to be a Bodhisattva. But definite emergence is a substantial cause of great compassion. So at that point it becomes great compassion. Great compassion is the cause of bodhichitta.

So how can definite emergence be present in the mind of a being on the Mahāyāna path of accumulation? It’s a very good question, a meaningful question. Indeed, at the level of a Mahāyāna path of accumulation, great compassion has been generated. Definite emergence is a substantial cause of a great compassion, so it could no longer exist as such. Then Geshela will enter into this later.

Your questions are pure questions. It was on topic if you wish in English. Pure questions. Just, I know Geshela wasn’t going into detail about the 10 grounds on the Mahāyāna path of meditation, but does covering those 10 grounds, does that take place in one meditation session or is it a much more protracted process? You have to meditate to become familiarized a lot.

It’s a huge amount of time. Buddha Śākyamūni spent three countless eons attaining full and utter enlightenment. The first countless eon was spent on the paths of accumulation and preparation. The second countless eon was spent on the path of seeing and the first seven grounds of the path of meditation. The third countless eon was spent on the so called three pure grounds, the last three grounds, the eighth, ninth and tenth grounds of the path of meditation.

But in their minds, because bodhichitta and the realization of emptiness had been generated, there was tremendous bliss and happiness. Keshe la when you were referring to a stable, reliable refuge, is that were you referring to the middling path of the path of accumulation? Because refuge exists in the minds of being who have not entered the path. So what would Geshe define as stable and reliable? So stable refuge occurs when after studying and reflecting carefully on the method and wisdom aspect of the path, one is able to transform one’s mind in terms of this, and as a result of that transformation, profound faith in the triple gem occurs.

That is stable Okay. I think stop here tonight. Yep. Geshela, during Sunday morning teaching, you said that the substantial cause for taking refuge in the Triple Gem was belief in the Triple Gem. However, how can this be if belief is still present once one has taken refuge?

If what is present? Belief in the Triple Gem is still present if one has taken refuge. How can belief be a substantial cause of taking refuge? So what Geshela said was that it is through the conviction that the Triple Gem is able to protect us from the suffering of the lower realms that one goes for refuge, and this amounts to a pledge, to a commitment. What matters for us is to be able to generate a stable refuge in the teacher, Buddha Śākyamūni, which is based on reasoning and on logic.

There are numerous causes of refuge which I explained, this is the best one.

Key terms in this teaching

grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top