1 h 38 min · 4,207 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk begins by explaining that generating a motivation of bodhicitta, even briefly, makes study and meditation a Mahayana practice, and that meditation includes subduing afflictions. It then teaches past and future lives using the continuum of consciousness, substantial cause and cooperative conditions, and the tomato example, which leads into the sevenfold generation of bodhicitta by recognising all beings as mothers. The recording ends with a question and answer session.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 39m
UUID: 41b89f09-724f-4d96-9a01-ede1f94c5cbe
Words: 4,203
So it is taught in the Lam Rim that the beginning of meditation is the motivation. And indeed, the motivation lies at the beginning of all the activities, either of listening, in other words, attending to teachings or teaching oneself. So I think one can say that when one generates a good motivation that qualifies as a meditation. Then when we say the beginning of meditation is the motivation, this means that when we generate or endeavor to generate a motivation at the level of bodhicitta, either a fully characterized bodhicitta, which would be ideal or a contrived bodhicitta, then in either case, it is insufficient merely to utter the words and say that one acts for the sake of others. Instead, from deep within oneself, one must wish to actualize the benefit of others, and then this qualifies as meditation.
So since the dharma we shall be listening to today is Mahāyāna dharma, then one must generate a motivation of bodhicitta, in our case of contrived bodhicitta. Then this should be done when one has the time. It is a bit strange for you to say that you never have the time, so the time can be found. Then in our own cases, we will not be able to generate stable motivation in a couple of minutes. If we meditate for only one or two minutes in, whatever motivation we generate is more akin to a prayer than to a stable motivation.
But if we have ten or fifteen minutes and we carefully generate the motivation, then we can hope to generate a weighty, stable motivation. So here, I am not referring to a fully characterized bodhicitta, which is an experience arisen from meditation, but just to the wish or the thought to benefit others. And if we meditate carefully, then we can generate this thought or this wish to benefit others, initially perhaps to benefit one person, then two persons, then more and more. And it is with such a motivation that we should go about our days trying to help others in the same way as, for instance, we eat or we drink water to benefit our body, our form aggregate. Then, we should also endeavor to study to benefit others.
Then to say that we wish to benefit countless sentient beings is somewhat of an empty statement. At present, we should focus on benefiting one, two, then an ever greater number of beings. And when we speak of sentient beings in general, in reality, it is far from clear that we can do anything for animals. So if we just focus on human beings already, that is a very great motivation. It is difficult to see ourselves helping all human beings.
So, then, when we study, studying the Mahāyāna does not become a Mahāyāna practice in and of itself. It is through a vast motivation that studying becomes a Mahāyāna practice. And as Rinpoche, Khensur Rinpoche said over and again, this is an extraordinarily beneficial motivation. We must therefore generate such a motivation. Then here we are speaking of a motivation to help others, not helping others in actuality.
For instance, if we take the example of drinking water, when we drink water, we drink water to benefit our body. And through our body, we can do things for others. As Atisha said in his Lamp of the Path to Enlightenment, until we have attained a fully characterized base, we cannot attain the supreme. The supreme here refers to liberation or full enlightenment. Now if fully characterized base is precisely this human rebirth with a leisure and endowments which we have attained at present.
There is no such, there is no rebirth superior to this precious human rebirth. As you know, when our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni attained full enlightenment, he remained for some forty days in silence without teaching because there was no benefit. And finally, he taught only five people because it was benefit. Then when we reflect on the path shared with the being of the small, of the middling, or of the great scope with such a powerful motivation, we accumulate huge amount of roots of virtue. We accumulate roots of virtue commensurate, in this case, to the number of human beings on this world, some 7,000,000,000 and some.
Then we may not be able at present to generate such a motivation continuously, but we can generate it for a minute or two. Then to say that we won’t generate it because we can’t generate it continuously, it’s nonsense. If we generate it for a minute or two, then there is vast benefit. So as we said, the beginning of meditation is the motivation, and therefore generating a powerful motivation is meditation. And as you remember last time, quoted the definition of meditation given in Lam Rim Cemo.
Meditation is protecting a mind focused repeatedly on a virtuous object of observation. So this understanding of meditation must be conjoined with the notion that motivation is the beginning of meditation. Then at present in our own condition, our minds under the sway of the afflictions And our minds basically follow the afflictions. Now we can see that when we give in to the afflictions, there is only difficulty, suffering and hardship. This is evident.
We can see this, for instance, in the recent terrorist attacks, in Manchester in England. It is not, so much the bomb which killed, the victims as the evil motivation of the perpetrator of this deed. Bombs are just matter. So we say casually when we speak that the bomb killed whatever number, 23, 24 people, but actually bombs really do not kill people. It is people who kill people.
It is the evil motivation in the mind, the afflictions in the mind of a person, which are actually the cause, the ultimate cause of the death of people. And therefore, we must try to subdue these afflictions, these afflictions such as anger, jealousy, envy, and so forth. And the way to do this is through meditation. As Śāntideva says in his Bodhisattva Charyavatara, once the wild elephant of the mind has been staked by the rope of vigilance to the stake of recollection and focused on a virtuous object, all fear is dispelled and all virtue is accrued. Then here, fear refers to the afflictions, and obviously, once the afflictions are eliminated, one accumulates vast amounts of virtue.
Then it should be evident to you that the afflictions are wrong. They are wrong consciousnesses. They are not right consciousnesses in any sense of the term. Therefore, let us, withdraw our minds inwards within ourselves. And, if our minds are at present, scattered, then let us bring them to a neutral and
In a virtuous state through mindfulness of breath, counting the exhalations and the inhalations until the mind is stabilized. And then we can meditate on the Lam Rim. Those who do this are pretty rare. Mhmm. Let us then meditate on the Lam Rim at present.
Then after engaging in these meditations, it is good in accordance with to dedicate the virtue one has accumulated. And this virtue, I think, we should accumulate to the victims of the terrorist attack in Manchester. In this way, both the method, in the form of meditation, and the dedication are similar. Then at present, we will, further on our study of the Lam Rim, the graduated stages of the path. And for yourselves, the Lam Rim is a bit of a difficult topic because the Lam Rims were produced in Tibet, and their trainees were Tibetan.
So the examples are given for Tibetans. Then there are tales and stories which could illustrate the Lam Rim from Western traditions, but I do not know them. It would be interesting to find this out. In your own cases, you seem to have made a good beginning with the Lam Rim. You attend the teachings very regularly even though I know that you have to work and many of of you come straight back from work.
So this is excellent. Then when we speak of dharma, really, we speak of motivation. That is critical. Then the Lam Rim includes the path shared with a being of the small, the middling, and the great scope. The, totality of the Lam Rim is predicated on a belief in reincarnation or past and future lives.
It was written for Buddhists in Tibet. If you are in a Buddhist country, the belief in past and future lives is a given. It’s a basis of society. Then if you ask people what exactly is a past life, they’re not quite clear about it. And what exactly is a future life, they’re also a little bit unclear about that.
But this core belief in past and future lives is foundation. So what therefore do we mean by past and future lives? Past and future lives refer to one’s own past lives and one’s own future lives. In other words, if you prefer to one’s own past and to one’s own future, and here, the notion of the continuum of consciousness or the substantial continuum is very helpful. So I’d like to ask you then for the past shared with the being of the small scope, and you can probably answer this question.
How does one think about past and future lives? Why is it important? To act out of virtue. Let’s just take it make it simple. Past lives.
I was gonna say to the small scope is to gain a higher rebirth in future life. Yes. Mhmm. Yes. That’s it.
That’s it. Yes. Uh-huh. The finger of the lower bounds. That’s that’s okay.
So in brief, future lives are the object of attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope, but this is not sufficient. This is something one must attend understand through reasons, in other words, through logic or reasoning. So now regarding the path shared with the being of the middling scope and its connection with past and future lives, This connection is the four noble truths, specifically the two first truths, the truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. And with the two latter truths, things are a little bit more complicated. And when the two first truths are expanded, one ends up with the 12 limbs of dependent origination, and this is nothing else but a presentation of cyclic existence.
So now let us take future lives. Then when we think about future lives, sometimes doubts arise because we think, well, okay, at the time of our death, we relinquish our body. Then what exactly is going on? What is this future life which is being talked about? And the easiest way to understand it is to take an example, which we all have direct experience of, the example of sleep.
So when we fall into deep sleep, we are completely unconscious. We are oblivious. Someone could cut us. They could kill us for that matter. We wouldn’t know.
Now before falling asleep, we awake. But after deep sleep, we wake up again, and that awakening can be compared. It’s an example of a future life. It’s easy. Right?
Yeah. Doesn’t allow you new crows are here, but I need to get the kid again. Then you could have
Just, you know Okay. We fall asleep, we’re not afraid, aren’t we? If we think about it, we just might die. But we do wake up tomorrow. Then we speak about what we will do tomorrow without any hesitation.
Don’t we? We say, I have breakfast. I have lunch. I have supper. There’s no doubt that we will wake up in our minds.
And future lives are the same way. Now what precisely goes on? Actually, it is the mental consciousness. Precisely, it is a subtle mind. But that is something which we will explain quietly.
Then in our own cases, as far as our body or our form aggregate is concerned, its substantial causes is the form aggregates of our parents. And this can be traced back millions and millions of years and lives. Then when we ask what we are, in other words, what is the I, what is the person, the person is imputed on the basis of the continuum of consciousness. It is not the continuum of consciousness. It is imputed on that basis.
And the continuum of consciousness is both beginningless and endless. Therefore, the person is also beginningless and endless. It extends for millions of lives in the past. And past lives are predicated on the basis of the mind, and this has to be understood in terms of substantial cause and cooperative conditions. I won’t give you too much material on this.
So let us take my own case. I am at present 52 years old. And if I were to die next year, then I would not be here with you on my 53rd birthday. Then what exactly would happen at that point? My 50 birthday, I would be reborn somewhere else.
In between, we would postulate the intermediate state, the Then, before that 53rd birthday, I would have died and been reborn. Then before that, in previous lives, where was I? I was everywhere. I was a human being. I was an animal.
I was in this country. I was in other countries. Then, Chris, you were born in Tibet. You were born as a man, as a woman, as a child, as an animal, and so forth. So it is when we think about it in this way that we understand this uninterrupted continuum of consciousness on the basis of which past and future lives are predicated.
Easy. I think easy, isn’t it? Sorry. No easy. If you don’t study, it won’t happen at once.
But if you study, it’s not terribly difficult. You have to analyze this in terms of substantial cause in cooperative condition. When we studied the Dura, the first volume of the text of collected topics, this issue of causality, substantial cause and cooperative condition was very important. I thought it was an unknown Tibetan word. So let us take the case of a tomato.
Then a tomato is the substantial cause Tomato. Tomato. Tomato. Sorry. Australian pronunciation.
But I’ll keep my American accent. A tomato is a substantial cause of another tomato. Mhmm. But a tomato alone is insufficient to give rise to a later tomato. You need also cooperative conditions, which are typically earth, heat and manure.
If earth, heat, and manure are present, and you have a tomato, you get a later tomato. Then if you do not have a tomato and you have only earth, heat, and manure, no tomato arises. Right? So in other words, for a tomato to give rise to a later tomato, you need both a substantial cause and cooperative conditions, both are necessary. The same is true for potatoes, for rice, for dal, in other words, for lentils and so forth.
Now this can be extended to all composite phenomena. All composite phenomena without exception necessarily need to give rise to a lateral composite phenomena, a substantial cause, and cooperative conditions. Then we ourselves are composite phenomena, which means we have both a substantial cause and cooperative conditions. Then let us start with the latter. What is our cooperative condition?
Definitely our parents, specifically spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. These are our cooperative conditions without which we would not exist. Are they, however, our substantial cause? Obviously not. If they were our substantial cause, then that would mean that our father’s body and our mother’s body have become ourselves, which they obviously have not since they still exist.
Then we do need a substantial cause in addition to the cooperative conditions. What is our substantial cause? Our continuum of consciousness. So actually, I explained this already, so I’ll ask you, why aren’t father and mother are substantial cause? Because they don’t turn into us.
Exactly. Because otherwise, they would disappear, and many of us have parents who are still with us. And this is self evident since many of us have supper with our parents, so they are still there when we are there. For a substantial cause to be the substantial cause of something, it must turn into that something and disappear when that something occurs. So for instance, a tomato is a substantial cause of a later tomato of similar type.
It has disappeared when that later tomato of similar type arises. So it should be quite evident at present that our parents are cooperative condition and our mental continuum is our substantial cause. Now how precisely does this happen in my own case, Geshe-la’s case? Geshe-la is 52 years old, which means that fifty three, fifty four years ago, well, fifty three years ago, he was born. Fifty four years ago, he was someplace else in this world.
Some someone else was his parents. And you can understand through that that Hiro was Geshe-la’s parent many times in the past, and all of you were Geshe-la’s parents many times in the past too. Then please explain to me why I can say that Hiro was my was born as my parent once. I explained to you how to think about it. You can pass it.
Just pass. He himself does not want to answer that question, obviously. Because we needed a body, needed parents to have a body, and the continuum is eternal. Therefore, everybody has been our mother or father many times. I’m asking you about Hiro.
I’m asking. You know? Hiro Why how is Hiro my parent? How was Hiro how did Hiro experience being born as my parents? Because his continuum is also eternal.
And And so every combination has been possible, which would therefore include Hiro as having been Geshe la’s mother and Geshe la having been Hiro’s mother at some stage. Jet.
Mine is more of a question. Is it possible that Hiro was never my mother? So if you’re saying for this life, then obviously, Hiro is not your mother and never never was. Mhmm. If you put it in those terms, yes.
That’s not what I’m saying. So when I say that Hiro experienced being born as my father, that does not mean that Hiro now is my father. But as Chris put it so rightly, that means that in a previous life, Hiro was Geshe-la’s father. Do you understand? Yeah.
No? Correct. It’s still complicit. Maybe I’m thinking more about the laws of probability. I think I find that hard to understand.
I can imagine that everybody has been somebody’s mother, but not always directly. Why? Why? What do you cut? Maybe I changed my mind.
Maybe I did. Oh, that’s fast. So our past lives are infinite in the past. They’re countless. Then there is a countless number of years in the past and countless numbers of beings we had relations with.
This is something which can be established through logic. It is not contradictory with logic. So what do you think of the idea that because Hiro’s mental continuum is infinite in the past, hero experienced being my father. Yeah. If you prefer, you can say independence on my mental continuum.
He will experience being my father. Think about it. If you can answer? Yeah. As an answer.
Similarly, was thinking about it probabilistically. If a composite phenomenon must give rise to another composite phenomenon, then every composite phenomenon is necessarily a cooperative condition for another composite phenomenon. And as was said, if there are infinitely many past lives, then there have been infinitely many combinations. And so, yeah, it mathematically follows that that combination has been possible. Which combination is impossible?
That Hiro has been Geshe la’s father. He’s impossible? No. It is mathematically possible. Because we are all familiar with love and well, love, it follows that this universal feeling has been felt before.
This is so familiar with it. Mhmm. Yes. So so it’s Keep going. It’s also it’s habituation.
Type thing. Yes? It’s habituation. Yes. And?
That’s my answer. That’s okay. Another? I’m thinking that it it’s what gives keeps giving rise to cyclic existence. What keeps giving rise to cyclic existence?
Do you need Like, the subcentral force and the propagation Okay. So if we analyze and take Gesheera’s case, and Geshe-la is 52. So fifty four years ago, Geshe la was born or had been born somewhere else. He could have been born in Australia for that matter. He must have been born at some point in Australia.
He was born at some point in Australia. He was also born at some point in other countries. Chris as well was at some point born in other countries. He and Geshe-la were at some point born in the same village. The same is true for Chris’s father.
And therefore, we can see that every sentient being has been a mother sentient being in the past. There is not a single sentient being who was not our mother, our father, and so forth forth in the past. And the kindness of our parents in this life is extraordinarily great. And reflecting on their kindness in this life, then we think of the kindness of the sentient beings who are our parents in the past. And in this way, we can start training our minds in the sevenfold causal process of generation of bodhicitta, recognizing all sentient beings as mother sentient beings, recollecting their kindness and repaying their kindness, these are the three first steps.
Let let us at present meditate during a couple of minutes on generating bodhicitta in this way, reflecting on mother sentient beings and their kindness to us. Good morning. Please open the prayer book. Page one, 1b. Page five.
[inaudible]. First one. And the three.
So regarding the sevenfold cause and effect generation of bodhicitta, the first subdivision or topic is recognizing sentient beings as one’s mothers, and this topic I have just explained. Geshe-la went through a lot of effort too. So, Geshe-la would like to thank, the translator who made it possible to give this explanation in terms of substantial cause and cooperative conditions. Then if you have questions, Geshe-la will take only one or two questions tonight. Yep.
What is the cooperative condition of a formless being or a dream consciousness? Dream. Right? Dream consciousness. You’re asking about either a a formless spirit, a real being, or a dream or both.
You don’t know. Which formless being which specific form is being? Yeah. I’m working off the three subdivisions that were explained from Tuesdays, but I wasn’t The cooperative condition. Right?
Then I’ll think about it and let you know later. Geshe la, the substantial cause of consciousness is the mental continuum, and our mental continuum is beginningless. So how do you explain the analogy of the tomato whose substantial cause is a previous tomato which has ceased once the next tomato has grown? So here to be precise, when we’re speaking of the substantial cause of consciousness that is a previous consciousness. It’s not the mental continuum in general.
So it says, if you take my present consciousness, then its substantial cause would be yesterday’s consciousness. Okay. Just one more thing. Okay. So when we generate bodhicitta, through generating bodhicitta, we accumulate vast amounts of virtue.
Now when we wish to benefit all the human beings in this world, as a result of that, we accumulate what is known as roots of virtue, which are very vast in number. Gilles? If all continuums of consciousness are beginningless and endless and need the cooperative conditions of other beings to become embodied, then surely there must be a finite number of continuums of consciousness because by themselves they cannot, you know, they cannot multiply. Mhmm. Mhmm.
Could you repeat? So the first part I got, the beginningless and endless. Yes. If all continuums of consciousness are beginningless and endless, and they need the cooperative conditions of other beings to become embodied I’ll translate that. Yes.
Then there must be a finite number of continuums of consciousness. Continuums of consciousness are numberless You don’t have continuums of consciousness of sentient beings here. Woah. What are you talking about? Continuums of consciousness So when we’re speaking of sentient beings, obviously, we’re not talking of human beings alone, but we’re talking also animals, etcetera, etcetera.
Right? Then they are numberless. When we speak of sentient beings, it’s only not only human beings, but animals, etcetera. Right? Okay.
Thank you, sir. Such a yeah. Turn that. Thank you. Mortgage engineers.
I want to tell you something. If you are interested in the mathematical theorem, which goes a long way to establishing the possibility of all sentient beings being mother sentient beings, check what is known as Cantor’s demonstration of the denumerability of rational numbers. Say that again? Because you mentioned mathematics. Cantor, c a n t o r.
Demonstration of the denumerability, d e n u m e r a b i l i t y, of rational numbers. I expect you why it demonstrates
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Collected Topics dura (Tib)
- A preliminary subject in the Tibetan Gelug tradition that serves as an introduction to syllogistic reasoning and systematizes and defines basic Buddhist concepts and terms. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.