2 h 11 min · 4,831 words · 10 June 2023
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues a Lam Rim session on how to meditate. It distinguishes analytical meditation from placement (single-pointed) meditation, explaining that analysis of topics such as guru devotion, precious human rebirth, impermanence, karma and bodhicitta should be done forcefully and for long periods. It also covers why sleep is not meditation, the blacksmith analogy for refining the mind, and the need for calm abiding alongside analysis.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 12m
UUID: 307043da-bf1d-49a8-a7ca-2bf4bec9c42c
Date: 2023-06-10
Words: 4,829
So, like, because of this journey that it is obvious that an entire sentient being is interrelated. Therefore so they are not just related. The all the most the sentient beings are exactly the same as oneself wishing to achieve the ultimate happiness or wishing happiness and do not want to suffer. And they have the same wish to free or be separated from the sufferings. So therefore, since entire sentient beings are same as oneself, in in order to help or assist sentient beings to free them from the sufferings and tend take them assist them to achieve ultimate happiness, I shall sooner or later, if it didn’t happen, soon but definite that I shall attain Bodhicitta.
Number six verses one and three. So here we stopped, let’s say, second. The second which is the the last week, we talked about what to do during the meditation session and between the meditation session. And with further detail, we’ve gone through the the four sessions, how to lead the four sessions per in within twenty four hours, what in the morning, midmorning, afternoon, mid afternoon, evening. And then so and which was set forth such a practice should be applied to every practice since I practice from the technique, past.
In such technique or method should be applied to all of us. So, And then now here, the second which is what the reason why should the reason why one should continue each and every practice with which has been between meditation set, what to do in the meditation session and what to do between the meditation session. Buddha Maitreya in his Ornament sūtra, instead had stated or, yeah, stated that that man what man do the med prior to the meditation in terms of an con contemplation or the analytical meditation that one needs to hear the teachings. And after having heard the teaching, then one should analyze or contemplate recall upon the meanings of the teaching what one have what one have just heard. And after having done the contemplation or analytical, analyze the the hearings, then want to take up on and the placement meditation.
Yeah. So by doing so, and this is the process of how one achieves so called the the wisdom realizing selflessness. And it’s when one say meditation, it does not mean that meditation should be just done. All the meditation should be done just like doing a meditation doing like meditation on meditation. So and it’s not meditation on meditative stabilization, which is one single pointedly focused on one particular object and then remained.
Like like, with stable mind mind’s being stabilized on a particular object, but this is not this is not the case. Meditation can be done in many ways. So he and also the the Maitreya has stated in his text so called the Ornament of Clear Realization. And the method of the method to to to attain or achieve the realization of wisdom realism is that one first needs to contemplate or hear. So, receive or hear the meaning of whatever one is going to practice.
For example, like how important it is, how hard it is to achieve the precious rebirth, and how to rely on the spiritual teacher, and so forth. And after having heard all the teachings or method, then one contemplating it, analyze it, and by doing and by through thorough examining, then finally understand the true meaning or true gist of the teaching, understand the gist of the teaching. And by having felt that, then this is and by doing so, think that’s one that generates or generates the wisdom realizing and so forth. So the purpose of explaining this is because it is not just when when one say meditation, there there are a danger of people or the one thinking about just the meditative stabilization or single point meditation so called, it is not the case because even the even such practice, analytical meditation, is also done during the path of the the the meditation meditation path of the supreme beings so called, which is the path of preparation, of seeing, and there’s the part of med the meditation part or part of meditation. And the smaller less a smaller scope and the greater scope and then the superior scope.
So we call it the supreme being. So even people who are in the called the continuum of knowledge or precepts. And the purpose of saying that is to is to prove that the meditation should not be just a a single point of meditation. There are many types of meditation. Even the practices of Buddhist practice, practicing of generosity, which used as the analogy here, the body, for example, and the way of practicing the the giving one’s body in mentally that to to serve the entire sentient beings and the practices of generosity and giving possessions, which is the merit and so forth to yeah.
So giving one’s body, sacrificing one’s body to the entire sentient beings the practices of generosity and practicing of guarding the the body from committing negative activities, and and they also practices they also practice to in let engage the one’s body into the positive action, which is keeping it pure for yeah, pure. And the final focus also generating a wish to achieve more and more precious human rebirth in future in order to fulfill the purposes of others. So such a way of practice is also by practicing such a thought or such a way is also by meditation, but it is not a single point of meditation. So this is the proof that meditation should not be taken as only a single point of meditation. How they meditate is, like I said, an example, like the giving up one’s body and also their possessions, like every everything they have.
There are always practices that, you know, giving generosity of their possessions to people who are starved on suffering of hunger, practicing generosity of food, and those who doesn’t the clothes, the material clothes, they just mentally give time to clothes for the people. And so this is how the practice of generosity through the possession or their belongings and then protecting and setting and they also protect that generosity or belonging not to engage in the falling into the negative action, tearing them from getting into the wrong direction or a bad action, and then keeping them, preserving them clean, and So this is how the practice in four category generosity, protecting or protection, pure or pure clean, and the increase. So which means is generosity is now the third one is the so first, we’ve got to go through the body possession, and third one is the merits or the virtuous actions there. So they give the entire virtuous action to entire sentient beings, and they protect this negative their virtues from getting destroyed by the negative action and maintain it pure by practicing or or increasing. Pure maintaining pure through practicing patience and yep.
Through practicing patience and then increase through yep. Sorry. I missed one part of the second one. And also to maintain pure, it practices So to summarize here then the each of the body possession or belongings and the merits, And this is how their practice is by performing those four methods which we have earlier stated. And so therefore and what so by doing so such a thought or meditation or a practice is also a meditation.
So thus, it comes down to the point that there are when one does meditation, there are two the the the two types of meditation, so called the the analytical meditation and the placement meditation, which is also called the single pointed meditation. And then Buddha Master Tukaka again continues in more detail about the meditation and the placement of meditation. And so it says that if one asks what path is the analytical meditation, and what meditation is the placement meditation. So here the answer is that the practices of generating a devotion or faith in spiritual teacher, meditating on spiritual through the faith or devotion in spiritual teacher, meditation on human rebirths, and how meditation on how hard it is to achieve precious human rebirth, meditation on impermanence, meditation on cause and effects, meditation on the disadvantages of the cyclic existence or saṃsāra, and meditation on the bodhichitta. So those of meditation or practice in those topics are mostly done through the analytical meditation.
So, yeah, it’s because the and by so one needs how one should do that analytical meditation, which we said on the meditation on devotion develop devotional faith and spiritual master, and how how hard it is to achieve precious human rebirth, recalling the the the advantages of precious human rebirth and impermanence and so forth because and one and how one should do this is because one should very forcefully or strongly give a thought or analyze through those topics, on those topics not just for a short period, continues one press for a longer period. And by doing this, then they will one will one it will help or it will make some changes in one’s mind, which means seeing the true benefits of all this. Because reason why is because if one does not do properly, perform the practice properly, and don’t take time or take it to the longer duration, then the problem comes is because instead of achieving all this one, we go through the opposite direction rather than generating a wisdom realizing impermanence once you generate the wisdom that agrees with or perceives the permanent nature of phenomena or things.
And in saying there’s no existence of cause and effect or karma, this is generating attachment towards the precious human rebirth rather than recalling how important it is to achieve so forth. So this is how it is important to analyze or recall the meaning and meditate on those topics in a long, strong, forcefully, and in a long and long duration. So how one should do is one should, again and again, oftenly, you know, analyze on those topics through so called the wisdom analyzing individual Yeah. Wisdom realizing or or analyze individual talk individuals. And by doing so, one will by performing such is the way how to do the analytical meditation, you know, by examining.
Yeah. So it is very important one to maintain Lojong analytical meditation and doing it properly or forcefully because, like, for example, like look. Example, as an object of appealing, which generates attachment. And by spending time on the particular object, the longer you spend all the time, then the more attachment, more likely it is or exaggerate the beauty of or quality of the particular object. And that will lead into the stronger attachment.
And for example, another analogy here is seeing that one’s enemy is very unappealing. And by spending more or focusing more on that unappealing state, then the more hatred one generates. So, likewise, if you use those things in opposite way to those qualities of the spiritual masters, the qualities of Buddhas, Buddhist subjects, and so forth. The longer you spend, the more gist you get and the better the practicing becomes. So what is said here is that what whatever one is meditating on it’s whether one may have, for example, a visualization, and one may have visualization very clear or vision vision clear or unclear, it doesn’t matter.
So it doesn’t. Sorry. And when but more important is having a strong fault for not losing one’s focus within one’s mind and strong and strongly and for a longer term is very important. And very intense and perform teaching to perform the practice. The what basically it’s saying is directing one’s body, speech, and mind entirely on laying on on the side of the the positive actions.
So and the but because it is so hard to perform, so hard to do so for 27 full time, there may be a danger of wanting to feel disheartened. But this is not the case. One should not. These are the very performance. It’s very important to understand.
But once you also understand the the gist, the foundation, the one unique quality quality or aspect of the the Buddhist teaching is that one can become a attainment, an enlightenment. One because everyone has a willing nature. And therefore, having this thought and one if one should and prep engages in the the practices of listening and so forth. And those have become whether a become like an arrangement and one understands, knows what are the requirements to be attaining enlightenment and what things to be put into practice to achieve enlightenment. Knowing that is very important if one were to do so.
And whether one can perform it or not, that depends on individual’s capability, individual time management, how busy one it is, so forth. But at least one should also should know that by having known all these simple outlines and what are the qualities of the teachings by listening to the teachings and so forth, And at least make imprints or latencies with oneself, which will rapidly move in later part of life or in the next life. And also that if and also once you make the practice that, you know, wish that that one can attain life and within one life, with this life. But even if one fails to do so, just wish that you can do it next life. So this because the argument so our rebirths are endless until one attains the enlightenment.
So therefore, the practices of within is mainly formed through the mind or heart or mind. And so it is important that one should maintain, direct one’s mind towards positive, generate a kind mind or a positive mind and and reduce try to eliminate or reduce the the the the negative thought or negative mind, and by gradually increasing all this positive mind, and eventually, that one clears off the entire or completely abandoned or purified the negative mind, that’s when one attains enlightenment. And so this is the case, and this is very important one to have knowledge or know within oneself, and then keeping that in mind and practices on analytical meditation and developing compassion, love and compassion. And doing so, maybe with this life, if not, one one one whatever one have cultivated this life will become a foundation and will perform even better in the next life. So yeah.
And this is how I want to do the the the meditation analytical meditation. And the practices from relying upon the spiritual teacher up till and precious human rebirth and so forth until the until one achieves the altruistic intention are considered the the engaging meditation or I’m just trying to recall all the terms. It’s called the placement of meditation where one it’s called the single pointedly on one particular object. For example, when one do the meditation on calm abiding, And that calm abiding meditation is now the so called single pointed meditation or the placement meditation that so it has its own way of meditation rather than meditating on both the qi, for example, and breath and re work. So forth.
So calm abiding meditation is where, one, place the mind into a particular topic or meditation and then maintain the guide. Don’t analyze much because it distracts the mind from being from stabilizing it. So the practice is meditation will come about things called the So and he stayed the great masters of old has stated here that it is very important one to know the there are the two types of meditation, analytical meditation, placement meditation. And if one says, it’s been seems like some may have been understanding in past, in ancient Tibet, that the master’s wrong view says, if one says, those people who are scholarly, like, debate scholars and monastic monks and so forth are they do the analytical meditation with debates all the time. And then, those yogis or the hermits are only the only perform or do placement meditation.
If you wanna say so, say it like that, and which is a mistake. No. Because I’m sorry. Because both whoever the practitioner is, whether it’s a person who And it’s also saying that it is also a mistake to to think that through the so called the wisdom realizing individual topic, whatever one meditates upon. And if one say that the the wisdom realizing emptiness only requires during the analytical meditation is required is the one analytical meditation is the one which is actualized by the wisdom realized.
Individualism means which examine each and every objects or topics where one is meditating on. If one say that analytical meditation is only required during the time of hearing or contemplation, not during the practice in terms of through the meditation, then the hearing the teaching during the hearing time and the contemplation time, then which is mistaken, it would become similar to the particular view which perceives that all the conceptual thoughts are the very conceptual thought. So if one generates such a thought that it will become obstruction to achieve the enlightenment, because if one perceives that only the the placement of meditation or the the single part of meditation is required to attain the enlightenment, such a view is a very wrong view, and it will become similar to the one holds that all conceptions or thoughts are deluded thoughts or valid, yeah, valid thoughts. Because what it means is they are the thoughts or conceptual thoughts, which is that all conceptual thoughts are not valid because the the wisdom realizing emptiness is the the developed conceptual thought and the wisdom realizing the true existence of the phenomena or the true existence of individual phenomena, and that is not a valid cognition or it’s called rather called invalid cognition.
And if one can say all thoughts are one, then there is a danger of combining those two. So if one thinks that the analytical meditation is or performing analytical meditation becomes the obstruction to to achieve the meditative stabilization, that is wrong because analytical meditation is very important. But later down down the part later part of the teaching will come through how one achieve the calm abiding through meditation on wisdom, realizing emptiness and so forth. But prior to doing that, it is important to to to to practice on the meditative stabilization. So meditation.
Sorry. So yeah. And the the analogy, for example, of smelting gold as a blacksmith. And to concise the meaning here, what the analogy or example here is that, like, what how I want to practice and and in engaging the practice and generates or develop every now the realization is like a blacksmith which prior to converting all the gold into whatever ornament it’s going to be, first they to to to validate or to to make yeah. The gold, test the gold by boiling it or melting it, I should say, under the fire and then make it clear of entire other substance or yeah.
Substance rather than maybe show it’s only the gold there and through this and by heating or putting it through the fire and make it flexible or very pliable. Mhmm. And it’s very, very flexible and agile so one that the blacksmith can convert that gold in any, like, earrings or any other ornaments, whatever whatever the shape or design the blacksmith want wants to. Likewise. The the the through through the wisdom realizing individual or the analytical meditation that one analyzes the actions of one’s mind and and making sure that the disadvantages of developing disturbing emotions or a negative action and by eliminating them or abandoning them and then increase the positive action or engaging one’s body actions into the positive action, then through this meditation or through this analytical meditation one generates.
So develops the realization or wisdom. So this is the best methods method the best method to to to generate or or, yep, the development of achievement and to actualize the highest attainments through through first, through practicing on the analytical meditation because and, for example, in order to develop bodhichitta, it is important the first one spend time yeah. One one should perform analytical meditation of the qualities of the the bodhichitta and the benefits of the qualities and advantages of practicing more generative bodhichitta and so forth. And after having done so, then one do perform the analytical. So the meditative stabilization or the calm abiding or special insight meditation on the bodhichitta.
And but through by doing this, then one will easily, without any hardship can develop the bodhichitta very quickly or very easily. So therefore, it is the proof that the analytical meditation is very important prior to the the the And then similar analogy or explain example also been stated by the great master Ārya Asaṇga. And the analogy of the the blacksmith, how the blacksmith or the the great blacksmith damped gold and through cutting, burning or melting, and then washing it with water, and finally, making converting making it flexible to gold by the blacksmith’s line, the the recalling the faults. The the the faults of covetousness or the bad negative thoughts or negative mind in the attachment. And so for the recording and not generating that is the analogy.
And then secondly, the generation doing the analytical meditation. Sorry. Analytical meditation and then and so forth. And by doing so, and later meditation doing a meditation on calm abiding, special insight, which is the meditative stabilization or the placement meditation, the reason why the the sleep is not good during the meditation is because the in terms of meditation, there are two meditations. So analytical meditation and the placement meditation.
And so when one is in the meditation and I’m full sleep, then that one is not one neither in the med analytical meditation nor in the placement meditation because that soul, the sleep consciousness, it prevails or overtakes the entire consciousness. And that that’s mean that and then whatever what what what one was meditating has been overpowered by the the consciousness of awakening the sleep sorry, sleep consciousness. So what happens is that so this that that is the that is why one should not sleep during the meditation because that it won’t become any it won’t become a meditation because it won’t become either, you know, the yeah. So either the analytical or the calm placement meditation and but they don’t do the same meditation. And what happens is one one fall into the sleep.
So one Buddhist have to meditate on bodhichitta. And through their practices and in and because their mind is focused on the bodhichitta and sleep, While they’re going to sleep, the sleep is not considered as a meditation. But hold their sleep or become a very effective and very powerful and become a positive cause to the meditation or cause to become attaining enlightenment because they because we call it the so called the sleep consciousness or sleep mind is considered as a very easy to influence on. So if it’s been influenced by a negative thought, all the sleep will become a negative. If the sleeps are influenced by the positive thought, the entire sleep becomes positive.
But so the Bodhisattvas, when they sleep, the the sleep all goes onto the bodhichitta, but they are not on a meditation. But the moment they awake, the the meditation on the bodhichitta resumes. Makes sense? Bodhisattvas of the first bhūmi. But some of the Bodhisattvas with a higher realization or attainments are exceptional and who and they have the control over their sleep.
And some practices, even within sleep, because they have control of their sleep, they know they are in sleep, and within the sleep, then they convert into a sleep yoga. There was an experiment with three groups: one group played the piano, the other group did nothing, and the third group just imagined And and the what we were saying earlier is because that we’re mainly talking about the two types of meditation, the analytical meditation and the placement meditation, and what how the analytical meditation is done is like Bodhisattvas. The practice of Bodhisattvas of visualizing the generosities and their possession of the bodies and then not being protecting them from being getting stained or by the negative actions and so forth. And those practices would establish the analytical and placement meditation. And when you’re doing this, it’s like making is to maintain the so called increase the knowledge or the realization or the attainment.
And likewise, the internal piano, you we know, could we could imagine a sage, as I said, that can it converted into how they’re meant to function or they probably just for playing and listening, they join the sounds of those could be placement meditation, just focusing once more just on music. But if making it into the analytical meditation, they’ll probably analyze the music itself. Is it the phantom of the opera or something else or not? And they’re just analyzing, so you convert it into analytic. Does that make sense to you?
Change in the movement and the brain function because we are those meditation point of view here is to train the mind to so forth that we don’t talk the brain because the the mind is formless, but it mounts on the wind. It’s called the travel, connects the nerve systems, which at the end connects up on the top or the other on the brain. But and it could be related, but you have just said. But in terms of the mind, we call training mind, we don’t compare the mind to the brain. So one is different because like, it’s not made public or announced public or worldwide yet because I think it was last year, actually, I said that the actual scientists examined Ganden throne holders, the Ganden Tripa, the head of the Gelugpa tradition.
So not the current one. The previous one, the ex one, passed away. And he remained it was last year, I think, sometime, the question is that, and remained something like in we call it the the meditation in Tibetan word called thukdam, which is the person stayed still in the meditation even though it’s classified as dead outside the sun, difficultly. So and then who was in a meditation of something like twenty something days. And his owners has given the permission giving them not to disturb the meditation.
And that time, it was one of the best opportunities that scientists scientists had. Had. And they were quite amazed with how the body temperature is maintained. Action now is not breathing. And the Western medicine has been classified as dead, but in Buddhist view, it’s not.
The person is still in the meditation. But scientists were examining how the brain functions and so forth. They can’t really see any movements in the brain and so forth. The person, but still in the meditation, there’s no deformation of the body, features, and so forth. Still perfectly preserved up until the meditation is over.
So they were quite amazed, but they’re hoping to get one more chance to the second, you know, So I I personally haven’t had any chance or interaction with the scientists, but there are many in our listening have been studying together with the scientists. It is very important that Yeah. Is there a short sort of analytical, meditation or analytical process that you can do to help you to be able to sit down and do analytical meditations? It is it’s it’s actually quite hard to do a long meditation when you’re a beginner. It’s better than a short meditation.
And, yes, you can do a short kind of meditation. For example, like the you know, when when one’s meditating, I mean, with limitation on meditating on compassion and then just recalling, you know, the kindness of the motherly sentient beings. And by recalling all the kindness of the motherly sentient beings, then the benefit of doing so, one generate the the the the wish to free them from sufferings sufferings or or free free them them from from the, the, yeah, yeah, some saṃsāra. Sorrows. So that that is the the result of, you know, recalling the consciousness and so forth.
And by doing analytical meditation on that compassion, compassion, like like how how to cultivate this, what percentage it means, means then, then but after a while, you can one can easily, you know, generate the compassion or wish to free them from saṃsāra. Yes. This is the most powerful type of meditation for us. I have to buy asked a question about the Kadampa. Yeah.
The
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bhumi sa (Tib, Wyl)
- Ground, or level, as in the ten bodhisattva levels. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Gelug
- The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is there a short analytical meditation a beginner can do to get used to sitting down for analytical meditation?
A long meditation is quite hard for a beginner, so a short one is better. One example is meditating on compassion by recalling the kindness of the motherly sentient beings. Recalling all their kindness leads one to generate the wish to free them from suffering and from saṃsāra. Doing analytical meditation on compassion, considering how to cultivate it, makes it easy after a while to generate the wish to free them from saṃsāra. This is described as the most powerful type of meditation for us.