1 h 27 min · 3,758 words · 1 August 2018
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaching on the verse ‘I am my own Lord, who else could be my Lord’, presenting the mind as the only remedy for mental suffering, with anger as the true enemy and contentment as the first practice. It explains the Three Jewels, with the Dharma as the actual refuge, and then the view of selflessness, identifying the object of negation as a self that appears independent of body and mind. Students then discuss the mode of the self’s dependence on body and mind.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 28m
UUID: 00deb109-10f9-4571-8b8a-e747e78df19f
Date: 2018-08-01
Words: 3,754
A b c d e f g. The meaning of this verse is that we are our own masters, we make our own happiness. It is the meaning of the first verse and the second verse, who else could be my master? It means that there is no one who can protect us from the difficulties we face. There is no one who can dispel the hardship we experience.
We ourselves alone can do that. Now this has a very profound import when we say that I am my own master, I am my own lord, I am my own protector, no one else can be my protector. What is meant by this? As has been explained many times, we experience only two types of difficulties, physical and mental difficulties. And as far as mental difficulties are concerned, mental hardship is concerned, we are the only ones who are able to dispel this.
So this is self evident since the difficulties which are referred to here are mental difficulties which we and we alone can dispel. No one else can do it for us. Then obviously as to physical hardship, that can be dispelled by others when they give us food, drink and so forth, but that is not what is being talked about here. And as is said in the Lamrim and said this repeatedly to his students, generate the motivation and meditate. And here when we one of the first generating the motivation, it is obviously a good motivation which one should generate.
There is no need to generate a bad motivation. Such a bad motivation is naturally present within us. It is spontaneous. What we need is to generate a good motivation. So when one refers to generating the motivation in Tibetan, what is meant by this is not to allow one’s motivation to fall under the sway of the afflictions such as for instance anger or jealousy.
And therefore here one should not allow one’s motivation to fall under the sway of afflictions exemplified by anger or by jealousy. Because if one’s motivation does, in other words, if one’s mind does, then so will the person. In this context, there is not a big difference between the mind and the person. And then when we are told to meditate, generally in society at large, meditation is understood as adopting a posture and a set of mind which leads one to mental happiness. Then this is broadly speaking correct since what interferes with mental happiness are the afflictions.
These afflictions which are consciousnesses whose function is to generate inappropriate states of mind. These are consciousnesses which trouble the mind. Therefore our goal is to avoid falling under their sway. And you can see here that in terms of the meaning, the meaning is identical with the stanza of Buddha Śākyamūni, I am my own Lord, who else could be my Lord? Therefore the meaning of these two verses, I am my own Lord, who else could be my Lord, is that we should be the masters, the protectors of our own mind since it is we and we alone who should control our minds.
Here to meditate, in Tibetan means to focus the mind on one object of observation And when the mind is focused on one object of observation, then it does not fall under the sway of the afflictions because the mind falls under the sway of the afflictions by focusing on any which objects and being distracted outwards. So if the mind is focused on one object specifically, a virtuous object, then probably that mind itself is virtuous. Okay. So here, therefore, meditation means to gain control over one’s mind and to uphold one’s mind by means of recollection or mindfulness. Then if one does this, one’s mind does not wander wherever it wishes to want to wander.
Then in the society we live in, since people have little or no control over their mind due to the cult of freedom and independence, obviously as a result of this, we experience great complications. Then inappropriate mental freedom leads to great difficulties. This is not to say that we don’t need freedom but we need correct or appropriate mental freedom. Do you understand? Then if our mind wanders in a totally uncontrolled fashion, as a result of this, we experience numerous mental difficulties and whatever difficulties we experience mentally can only be eliminated by the mind itself.
They cannot be eliminated by other means. Then in society at large, we use nowadays drugs and so forth to try to control the wayward mind, but this cannot work. How could physical or material means work to control something which is immaterial? Mental suffering and mental hardship can only be addressed by mental means. They cannot be addressed by physical means.
On the other hand, physical suffering or physical hardship, can be addressed by physical means. For instance, if we have a headache or the flu or whatever, then we should take the appropriate medication. This is of no benefit whatsoever for mental difficulties. So initially it is important to distinguish between physical and mental hardship. So, recently Geshela was, afflicted by the flu, and the flu is obviously due to a disorder of the interior and the exterior elements.
Then it can be healed by material means. He took the appropriate medicine and he is at present healed from the flu. However, when it comes to mental suffering, mental suffering can only be changed or eliminated by transforming the way we think. So prayer or taking refuge can in no way eliminate mental suffering. How could they?
Mental suffering can only be eliminated through study. Now if we look at mental suffering, what is the cause of mental suffering? The cause of mental suffering is the afflictions which trouble the mind such as anger. Now Geshe-la has heard some people say that anger is suffering. That is false.
It’s not anger which is suffering. Anger is the cause of suffering. And in turn, what is the root of the afflictions such as anger? It is discontentment, lack of contentment in other words. Lack of contentment is akin to desire.
So we should endeavor to reduce it. So therefore, it is the mind and the mind alone which can dispel mental suffering. And this is the meaning of the verse, I am my own Lord. That verse is very profound because when we try to identify what is referred to by I, what is referred to here is the mind. In other words, we must be the Lords of our own mind.
And then we must turn our mind progressively to virtue. Then you may have heard when one tries to identify what the triple gem is that the Buddha gem is said to be the teacher of the dharma And the dharma gem is said to be the actual refuge, whereas the Sangha gem are said to be the helpers in practice. Now why exactly does one say that the dharma gem or the dharma jewel is the actual refuge? What is it in the dharma jewel which makes it the actual refuge? So when it is said that the dharma jewel is the actual refuge, the actual protector, It is not said that the Buddha jewel is the actual protector.
Buddha the Buddha jewel is merely the teacher of the dharma nor is it said that the Sangha jewel is the actual protector. The Sangha jewel are merely the helpers in one’s practice. So why precisely is the actual refuge only the Dharma Jewel? Then this causes us to think very carefully on the meaning of things. Do you understand?
Is it busy? Is he busy too? So then we try to identify what or who precisely is the Buddha refuge. The Buddha refuge is our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni and who or what precisely would be the Sangha refuge? Well, obviously among us there are no Bodhisattvas at present apart from Geshela and if we say that Ārya Nāgārjuna or Ārya Asaṇga are the Sangha refuge then they left us some two thousand years ago.
So we should view each other as the Sangha refuge. We should view each other as helping each other in our practice. This is a very beneficial way of proceeding. Now at present, what exactly is the actual refuge? The actual refuge as Geshe-la said is the dharma.
So what are we to understand by dharma here? If our mind is oriented in a direction which promotes mental peace and happiness, then that is akin or amounts to the dharma. So when we say that the dharma jewel eliminates suffering, what suffering precisely does it eliminate? Do you believe that dharma eliminates physical suffering, that dharma eliminates the suffering of hunger, of thirst, headaches, sickness and so forth? When you experience physical suffering, if you’re thirsty, you should drink, if you’re hungry, you should eat, if you’re sick you should take medicine.
Suffering. Mental suffering is eliminated by mental means, by changing the way we think. And if as a result of changing the way we think, we eliminate or reduce mental suffering, then something akin to the dharma jewel is present within our minds. So you can see that the dharma jewel is present within our continuum. The dharma jewel is not up in the sky above us or in the space in front of us.
It is inside ourselves. This is the meaning of the stanza I am my own Lord, who else could be my Lord? Don’t therefore allow your minds to go just anywhere. If you do, you might lose them and not get them back. Instead, send your mind where you intend to send it, where you think to send it and if you proceed in this way you will become the master of your mind and as a result you will be a concentrated, a centered person.
And this stanza concludes with the two final verses. I am my own foe, who else could be my foe? And indeed, when our mind is beset with anger, anger is for instance, our true enemy. Anger is our true enemy because anger is a wrong, a mistaken consciousness. And as such, it thwarts everything we do and perceive.
And this is why in Buddhist scriptures the afflictions, the afflictions are referred to as the enemy. In Tibetan are called which means translated in English, foe destroyer. They destroy which foes, they destroy the foes of the enemy. Now in worldly parlance, we refer to exterior enemies, to people on the outside as our enemies. People are not our enemies.
Our enemies are within our own minds. So how do we abandon the afflictions within our mind stream? As I said, the foe of the afflictions is destroyed through the light of wisdom. And therefore the preliminary, let us generate a good motivation as was explained and focus our mind on stably on an object of observation of our own choice. Please open the prayer book, page one.
We recite one b, two, three, and four. Also page five, number six, mandala offering, verse one and three. Page nine. Page five. It’s very helpful to view the triple gem in the following way.
The Buddha jewel should be seen as the doctor who prescribes the medicine one should take. The Dharma jewel should be seen as the actual medicine one takes, and the Sangha jewel should be seen as the nurses who help one when one is ill. Then the actual treatment is the medicine. The doctor diagnoses it and says you suffer from this or that and you should take this or that medicine. Without the medicine there is no cure.
Then just as someone who goes to the doctor is prescribed medicine, buys the medicine and puts it in his drawer and locks it up and never takes it, will never be healed. Likewise, if we do not put in practice the teachings of Buddha Śākyamūni, we have no hope to be healed. Buddha Śākyamūni was a being like us, beset by suffering like us. He identified the four noble truths and taught them. If after studying his advice and understanding his advice, we do not practice it, we cannot be healed from the afflictions.
Then in society at large, the most important thing is to practice contentment. Contentment with a lot, contentment with the happiness we have and therefore if you ask what should I practice, what should I do, the first practice is to practice contentment and then one builds on that basis. Then if we investigate further what the actual cause of the afflictions is, we will find that this cause of the afflictions is the ignorance apprehending a self and the antidote to this ignorance is the wisdom realizing selflessness. At present, the wisdom realizing selflessness is not present within our continuum, but both the ignorance grasping at a self and self cherishing are present. If we endeavor to generate the wisdom which counters them, it can be done.
So please listen carefully at present Geshela will continue explaining the view. Alright. Are you ready? Okay, then we have to go. How to say?
Just joking. So this ignorance apprehending a self, ignorance apprehending an I has an antidote which is wisdom realizing selflessness. Now here when we speak of selflessness, we must identify what the self is. The self here or the identification of the self is the identification of the object of negation or the identification or of the topic being negated. So here, when we say that the person is not established as a self or that the person is selfless, we must identify what this self which is being negated is.
We must identify the object of negation. And to give an example, which is given in the Lamrim, When we say that a man, someone is not present here, we must know who that man is to be able to say that he is not present. For instance, if we say Chris is not in the temple tonight and he is there every Wednesdays normally, we must know who Chris is to be able to say Chris is not present. So therefore, just as when we say Chris is not present in the temple tonight and he is usually there every Wednesdays, for this statement to be meaningful, we must have previously identified who Chris is. We must know who Chris is.
Likewise, when we say the person is not established as a self, which is something we repeat all the time, to be able for this or for this to have meaning, we must first have identified the object of negation which is the self. What is this self? So now as far as the presentation of the lower schools of tenets is concerned, when we endeavor to identify this person established as an autonomous self or this person established as a self, we do realize that there is an innate mind within ourselves to which the person appears as such. Don’t we? So as was explained previously, when we endeavor to identify this self or this I, we find that it appears as if it existed deep within ourselves as the master of both body and mind.
Sometimes when this sense of I is very powerful and we investigate, we can see that it seems to exist without depending on its base of imputation, without depending on body and mind, as master of body and mind. This is the self which is the object of refutation when we say that a person is not established as a self. So such a person, such an I, which would exist without depending on its base of imputation, body and mind, does not exist. We have established previously that the person, the I is intimately related or linked to body and mind. Therefore, an I or a person which does not depend on body and mind does not exist.
Easy peasy peasy. Complicated or easy peasy. So here, we have established previously clearly that in our own cases, we as persons or human beings depend on body and mind. Yet to this mind, we appear as if we existed without depending on body and mind. This is obviously false.
Now examples will make this clearer. The examples which Geshe-la gave previously were the examples of a general and his army. A general appears as if he existed independently of his army. This is obviously not the case. The general is a part of the army.
Or for instance, the example of a factory and the director of the factory. The director of the factory seems to exist independently of the factory of which he is a director, yet he is a part of that factory. See which example works best for your mind. So what do we make of this object of refutation, the self of which it is said that the person is not established as a self? It’s only in this way that one can understand the presentation of the view in the lower schools of tenets and the establishment of the view.
Otherwise, it is not possible to present the Buddhist view. So when we say the person is selfless, the person has no self, how do you understand the self which is this object of negation? I don’t necessarily need to recall an analogy but either of those two analogies work for me. The self appears to me as the I within my thoughts. It’s up to you.
I mean, you’re speaking. Okay, Annie. And other one. Yeah, quick please. Well, it, the self appears to exist, independently but it’s just totally impossible for that to be the case.
I understand the object of negation is being a self which appears to be separate from the aggregates and is somehow controlling or the owner of the aggregates? So generally speaking, one should speak based on one’s own experience. Then so far from what Geshela can hear, all of you are very bookish in your references. You refer to what you have read in texts. Then this may be true, but it is not stable.
What Geshela means by it’s not being stable is that it is not linked to one’s experience. So one must link what one has studied in the texts with one’s experience. This is what makes it stable. So generally, in Buddhist text, one refers to this object of negation as the self which is the object of negation as appearing to be autonomous. Here autonomous and independent have broadly speaking the same meaning.
Autonomous and independent means that the self appears not to exist independence on anything else. Okay. Yeah. Do you have question? No.
I was sort of gonna answer what I thought the eye was. I think of the eye as not being stable because one minute the eye can hate something and the next minute the eye can love the same thing. So then I need to question who is the what is the eye? So here, since the Lamrim presents the Prāsaṇgika madhyamika view, when you ask where the eye is, the I is unfindable under investigation. In other words, when one asks the question where is the eye and one investigates, there is no eye to be found.
It is said to be a mere nominal and conceptual imputation. So here, this self or this I appears as not dependent in the slightest on body and mind, even though in reality it is established and it exists dependent on body and mind. Then what precisely is the mode of dependence of the eye on body and mind? Can you hear some? I’m wondering whether it’s just the result of cause and conditions.
Excuse me. Indeed, the eye arises in dependence and causes and conditions. But what Geshela is asking is what is its relationship with body and mind? What is the nature of that relationship? Is it busy?
No. Is it busy or complicated? The nature of the relationship is of one nature but different isolates. And the mode of dependence of the eye on body and mind is that the eye is imputed on the basis of the body and mind. When I look for how the eyes dependent on body and mind, I see that in my thinking it’s blended with a thought or it’s mixed with a thought or it’s mixed in with a feeling or even with a feeling of grasping itself.
It’s just blended in there and if I look to see if it is within those thoughts, within those feelings, then I can see that it is there’s no actual self there. There’s just kind of a mixing of this idea or imputation of self within thought and feeling. Geshela is asking one question and you’re answering something else. Geshela is saying that we have established that the I depends on body and mind. It is related with body and mind.
What is the mode of this dependence? What is the mode or the manner of this relationship? How is it related? This was already explained. It’s not difficult.
We or persons, we are impermanent. We disintegrate instant by instant. What is the mode of this disintegration? We are impermanent, we disintegrate instant by instant. How do we disintegrate?
What is this mode of the momentary disintegration? Disintegration? So the mode of disintegration is aging as a result of birth and then the aging leads to death. So let us analyze this. When we say that a human being eats for instance, let us say hero eats, then why do we say hero eats?
It is because when we look at hero, we can see that hero’s hand and mouth are going through the motions of eating. Do you understand? So what’s the relation here? That we are imputing hero on the basis of a portion of his form aggregate. Exactly.
Yeah. 99%. So we are basically imputing the activity of hero on the activity of one part of the base of imputation hero’s hand and mouth. So let us think about this and stop here for tonight. Thank you.
Sorry, everybody. Could I just make an announcement? On this Sunday, we’re now having Deity practice after Geshe-la’s teachings in English led by Venerable Lama and that will take place every Sunday
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.