Lam Rim – 2018-06-13 – Lamrim

1 h 34 min · 4,412 words · 13 June 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-06-13 - Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk stresses that Lam Rim teachings must be put into practice to subdue the afflictions, and that one should meditate on the Lam Rim before engaging in tantric practice. It then begins the Lam Rim explanation of the view, covering the coarse selflessness of persons as being empty of being permanent, one and independent, with reference to the Sankhya system. Students are told to study the 25 objects of knowledge in Sankhya and to ask questions.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 35m

UUID: aaa44922-803d-432f-9d77-ad867fbfd572

Date: 2018-06-13

Words: 4,408

Okay. Sorry. As said in a passage which Geshe la has quoted several times, to abandon the dharma despite having heard many teaching, to having heard often, is a sign of not taking it as an instruction. Then here, to hear refers to attend teachings, and to abandon the dharma refers to stop practicing, to stop practicing the dharma. This is a sign of, dissociating, hearing, thinking, and meditating.

It’s the same thing as attending teachings at a Buddhist center such as this one and then practicing some something completely unrelated, one has not received teachings upon. Now in mundane affairs, it would be like attending university to study medicine. And the goal, after all, of studying medicine is to earn a lot of money to become rich. And then after studying medicine for many years, when the time has come to earn money, instead of practicing medicine, to practice law. Then people would say to such a person, you are crazy.

You studied medicine, but now you’re practicing law with which you have no experience. So it is indeed very strange to first study medicine, and when the time has come to settle down to work and earn money, to put effort at finding ways to practice law. So this is the way things are in society. We find or try to find a job in whatever field we have trained in, not in a separate field. Then likewise, when one attend attends teachings, one should immediately put in practice and meditate upon what has been taught, not something else.

Then if one attends teachings on one topic, and then instead of practicing that, practices something completely unrelated, it is a clear sign of the dissociation of hearing, thinking, and meditating. Hearing, thinking, and meditating are separated. Then here, it is important that you not think that you should attend Lam Rim teachings. And when the time comes to practice, practice a tutelary deity, a Yidam, engage in Anuttara Yoga Tantra practice. Instead, the practice of Lam Rim is the foundation of engaging in, self generation and, practicing a sadhana.

Otherwise, it’s very, very strange if one sets Lam Rim practice aside and just stays in one’s corner reciting the mantras of one’s Yidam. Then, you have received many teachings on the Lam Rim, the graduated stages of the path. You understand it. If you have received highest yoga tantra initiations, you should first meditate on the Lam Rim to the best of your capacities. And then after that, on that basis, engage in tantric practice.

So, here, there is an aphorism. When tired of meditation, engage in recitation. When tired of recitation, interrupt the session. The recitation of mantra is not the focus of the practice. It is instead meditation, which is the focus of the practice.

Then when when is tired, one engages in recitation, dapa in Tibetan. But, that is not the essence of practice and it does not transform the mind. Do you understand? Then, Khensur Rinpoche, already said you should practice the Lam Rim. His advice was work on the Lam Rim.

Work on the Lam Rim means practice the Lam Rim. And this is the advice Geshe la within his capacities would like to give. His holiness the Dalai Lama, who is very famous, is very famous precisely because he teaches what he calls the preliminaries before the main practice. The preliminaries here refer to the Lam Rim. His Holiness teaches the Lam Rim extensively and then, for instance, gives or imparts the Kālacakra initiation, which is shorter.

And this is why says abandoning the dharma despite hearing much, arises out of not taking the treatises as instruction. Then, here, taking the treatises as instruction means that whatever one receives teachings upon, one must put in practice to subdue one’s own mind. If one does not do this, one does not take the treatises as instructions, and one will abandon the dharma. So here, this is a motivation with which one should listen to the Lam Rim. And within the three characteristics of the Lam Rim, the second characteristic of the Lam Rim is that with such a single motivation, it is straightforward to subdue the mind.

Therefore, this is the way we should listen to the Lam Rim. So, for instance, last year, Geshe la taught extensively on the aliyavijnana, the mind, basis of all. And this year, he is teaching on, Buddha lineage or gotra. Then, in the case of Buddha lineage, for instance, these teachings are intended to enable one to understand the way things are, the mode of abiding of things. There is no immediate relationship to practice.

However, in the case of the Lam Rim, the Lam Rim is a means to subdue the mind. So for instance, when one studies tenets, it is critical to study the establishment of the view and the presentation of the ground, the path, and the result. Whereas, for instance, in the case of the Lam Rim, the Lam Rim is immediately relevant to subdue the mind. So here, when one refers to subduing the mind, what precisely do you understand by subduing or taming the mind? I suspect some of you are thinking of calm abiding or something of that nature.

But here, subduing the mind refers to subduing the afflictions. At present, we are under the sway of the afflictions. Then to put this in very simple terms, this means that we are overinvested in exterior phenomena, the exterior five sense objects. Magistra is in no way saying that we do not need the material world or the exterior five sense objects. They are necessary.

But when we are overinvested in them, when we consider that they can provide the totality of our satisfaction, then we set ourselves up for great suffering because they are unable to do this. Something we all understand. This is something all of us, understand. When we have great lust for, the five, set categories of sense objects, it creates tremendous suffering since they are unable to satisfy our craving. And therefore, what we must do to find peace

Is train in contentment. Then try it out for yourself. Check. Try it out for one week, one month, one year. And after one year, see whether contentment has given or imparted rewards or not, and you will find that you are much happier person.

You have to try. So here, therefore, it is contentment we should train in, and this is the main training of the path shared with the being of the small scope in which one endeavors to reduce one’s attachment to food, clothing, and to talk. Now talk here refers not just to talk, but to reputation, and this is not easy to counter. Now here, all of us are attached to our good repute, to our good name, and this is attachment to speech. This attachment to our good name, to our good reputation, which inflates us is something we have to try to counter.

And when we counter this, we are coming close to the past shared with the being of the middling scope. So this is something which is to be examined. Therefore, we must counter attachment or craving to food, vestments, and our reputation or our name. Do you understand? This is how one should practice on the path shared with the being of the small scope.

So, this craving or desire for a good repute, literally desire for a good talk about oneself manifests, for instance, when one thinks, well, I am a Geshe, not just a Geshe, but a Geshe Lharampa. And on this basis, then one becomes very inflated. Then on this basis alone, it is craving for good repute. PhD. So in society at launch, this is necessary, obviously.

Then, if one were to engage, for instance, in the Geshe studies to become a Geshe, so as as a to benefit others, then that would be okay. But that is not easy to do. So here, this desire for a good name, this desire for a repute is a desire actually for oneself. If it is a desire for oneself, a desire which desires oneself, then it is linked to the practice shared with the being of the middling scope. But this is something which needs to be examined.

Therefore, the path which we should follow is initially the path shared with the being of the small scope in which we reduce our attachment to the five exterior sensory objects and to food, clothing and good repute. So these realizations, the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small, the middling and the great scope necessarily follow each other in sequence or incrementally. It is not possible initially to train in the past shared with the being of the small scope and then as an afterthought to gain the realizations shared with the being of the middling and the great scope. As to the realization of emptiness, there is no definiteness. It is possible to have a realization of emptiness before practicing the path shared as a being of the small scope or after.

There’s no definiteness. Emptiness is the actual mode of existence of reality. And therefore, it is perfectly possible to gain a realization of emptiness without having trained in the past shared with the being of the small, the middling, or the great scope. Then in the context of the Lam Rim, the topic of emptiness is explained at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, mainly probably in Geshe-la’s opinion because it is a very vast topic, and it seemed appropriate to explain it in that context. Yes.

So for instance, if we take the four tenet systems, they are differentiated in terms of the establishment of the view. In terms of conduct, in other words, the practice of love, compassion, and so forth, they are absolutely identical. It is in terms of the view that the differentiation is made, then probably for the Lam Rim, it is a similar rationale. So there are not different tenet systems posited in terms of their presentation of bodhicitta or in terms of their presentation of compassion. Now focusing on our topic, emptiness.

To understand emptiness, one must understand the selflessness of persons. The selflessness of persons is subdivided into two, the coarse and the subtle selflessnesses of persons. As you remember, Geshe la taught that the coarse selflessness of persons is persons being empty of being permanent one and independent. So when one says that the person is empty of being permanent one and independent, what is being said is that the person is not a self which is established as permanent, one, and independent. In other words, that this self established as permanent, one, and independent does not exist.

However, other non Buddhist tenet systems teach that the self is permanent, one, and independent. What is their understanding? So be careful. It’s difficult. So these tenet systems, these non Buddhist Indian tenet systems teach that the person is a self which is permanent, one, and independent.

In other words, this self has three characteristics. It is permanent, it is one, and it is independent. So permanent naturally means permanent or the permanence of the person. Then do you understand these three terms? Permanent, one, and independent.

So permanent here refers to the permanence in of the person. In other words, the permanence the person does not depend on generation and destruction. Then one refers to the person being one in number. Previously, Geshe-la had explained one as being bound, and he doesn’t think that’s an appropriate explanation. So here, one refers to one as opposed to two or multiple.

Then if you want to understand the presentation of the person as permanent one and independent, Geshe-la would suggest that you study the presentation of the 25 objects of knowledge in Sankhya. I have a footnote on that in my translation of So to understand fully what is meant when the non Buddhist Indian philosophers speak of a self, which is permanent one and independent, there is an ātman, which is one and permanent and independent, one should study the presentation of the 25 objects of knowledge in Sankhya. Is asking whether any one of you have studied the 25 objects of knowledge in Sankhya. Then do study this in English.

So when the Sankhyas teach that the person is permanent, one, and independent, as far as one is concerned, what they mean is that what attains liberation or moksha is just the person, just the ātman, and not the afflictions, not the so called aggregates and so forth. So from the Buddhist standpoint, one reincarnates through the cycles of the 12 limbs impelled by beginningless ignorance and the afflictions. And one gains liberation through abandoning ignorance and the afflictions. For Sankhya, Purusha, the person reincarnates in cyclic existence due to lack of knowledge of Prakriti or what is known later on as Brahman. Then when Purusha understands what Brahman is, Purusha alone, the person alone, becomes liberated.

This is what is meant by one in the presentation of the person as permanent one and independent. Then, be that as it may, Geshe la would suggest when you have time to read over a couple times the presentation of the 25 objects of knowledge according to Sankhya, and then you will get a sense of what is meant by the their assertion that the person is permanent, one, and independent. Otherwise, it is just talk from our side. So this is for the meaning of one, which means not depending on parts. And as to the term independent in the presentation of the person as person one and independent, the meaning of independent is clear in the presentation of the 25 objects of knowledge in Sankhya when it is said that the person does not depend on nature, and nature in sankhya refers to the cause of the person nor does it depend on result.

So by this assertion, sankhya is saying that the person is independent. So, this presentation of the person as permanent one and independent is found in Sankhya and is only found in wrong systems of tenets. Geshe-la would assume that none of you subscribe to such a system of tenets. So here, as far as the person or the self is concerned, all schools of tenets accept the existence of the person or the self. The debates hinge on the mode of existence.

Now when the person or the self is said to be unrelated to body and mind or unrelated to the aggregates, excuse me, in the self same way as the owner of a house is separate from the house he or she owns, then one can see how a viewpoint which asserts that the person is permanent, one, and independent would arise. Keep in mind that all these schools of tenets such as Sankhya assert clearly the existence of reincarnation. So these schools of tenants assert that the person is permanent, one, and independent, which is not accepted by the Buddhists. But the question here is the actual mode of existence of reality. Then we can see that if we were to assert that the person was permanent, one, and independent, the person would be permanent.

Now clearly, the person arises in dependence on the aggregates, and the aggregates are generated and disintegrate. Just as the aggregates generate and are disintegrated, likewise, a person imputed on that base is generated and disintegrates. As a result, we cannot say that the person is permanent. So here, regarding the issue, Geshe-la brought up last time of the relationship between, on the one hand, the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent, and on the other hand, the apprehension of the person as permanent, there are three logical possibilities or three moves. In other words, whenever the person is apprehended as being permanent one and independent, it is necessarily being apprehended as permanent.

The converse is not true. Now, in this case, it is also very helpful to examine how the person actually exists. And it is quite striking that whereas when we don’t think too much about the person, it is obvious how we exist. The moment we start examining, we can’t really find this person. So let us, therefore, at present present reflect on the fact that everything we do from the moment we rise in the morning, whether it is having breakfast, brushing our teeth, watching a movie, and whatnot, is all for the sake of the I or the self.

And yet the moment we investigate to try to find this I, we are bemused and puzzled because it is unfindable. And let us also, meditate on the fact that there are three moves or three logical possibilities between the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent and the apprehension of the person as permanent. Okay. Then let us generate the motivation. Please open the prayerbook, page one.

We recite one way, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandal Offering, verse one and three.

Page five. Then, it will be good when you get up in the morning if you’re interested in the view to think what precisely the I or the self which engages in daily activities, sleeps, and so forth is and examine it. This is the first topic which Je Tsongkhapa presents in his five treatises on the view. It indicates its importance. So Geshe-la suspects that you have a fairly good understanding at present of what is meant by the coarse selflessness of persons, the person being empty, of being permanent, one and independent.

Now as you know, in the lowest schools of tenets, the surfaces of persons is subdivided into two, the core surfaces of persons and the subtle selflessness of persons. The core surfaces of persons is a persons being empty of being permanent one and independent, And the subtle selflessness of persons, Geshe-la will explain from next week onwards, is a person being empty of being a substantially existent self-sufficient entity. Now, we will go quietly into these topics. Geshe-la would like to ask you not to rush. There is no hurry.

If you rush, you will just get confused. You know, for four years. At the monasteries, Madhyamaka is studied for four full years from dawn till midnight every day. So it is not easy. One must attend the classes.

One must memorize the root text. One must memorize the commentaries. One must debate. It’s not easy. It is in Tibetan.

You know? You know? It’s strange. You know? So in Tibetan, I is said na.

Then in English, I, obviously. But what is strange is that the thinking processes which say I occur in the brain up here. But when we say I, we always point at the chest, don’t we? I definitely don’t agree. And when you say to someone, you’re not thinking about it, you point at your noggin, don’t you?

So thinking is obviously related to the sensory consciousnesses, Then Geshe la will enter in detail in these topics later on. So these mental activities which, cause us to, think, based on the sensory consciousnesses, they occur from morning till evening, don’t they? So, therefore, there are three moves, not four moves, between the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent and the apprehension of the person as permanent. Please give the three moves quickly. So within the four possible moves, which one is missing?

So the three moves are both, in other words, both the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent and the apprehension of the person as permanent. Secondly, the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent without the apprehension of the person as permanent. And thirdly, neither the apprehension of the person as permanent one independent nor the apprehension of the person as Then as an instance of both, we can give just the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent itself. Mhmm. So what instance can you give of the apprehension of the person as permanent without it being the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent?

Really? Yeah. Possibly the innate misconception when you’re in the grip of powerful emotion. Okay. And So the which we are asking for is the apprehension of the person as permanent without the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent.

In the Sankhya Yoga Shastra, Kapila was talking about Purusha and Prakriti. Prakriti. Now the Prakriti, the vessel is Prakruti. The house is Prakruti. Would that be right?

The vessel is what? Prakruti. And the house is? The house is Prakruti. Uh-huh.

The Purusha is the the the seeing part. Prakriti is unseen. Okay. So, here, we should check for ourselves whether, we are afflicted by grasping at our own permanence or not. Then if we examine, we will all find that we are afflicted by our own permanence.

For instance, Geshe-la himself is at present 52 years old. But if he doesn’t think carefully about it, he plans on staying around another fifty years. Then the moment one examines, obviously, this is no longer true. But what is meant here is that this apprehension of one’s own one’s own permanence is innate because unless one examines and reflects on one’s own permanence, it is naturally there. Then for instance, if Geshe la examines his own continuum, the, apprehension of his own permanence is innately present.

But that apprehension of his own permanence is not the apprehension of his self as permanent one and independent because, it does not analyze. Then in your own cases, do you really think that grasping at your own permanence isn’t present in your own continuums? Geshe la asks, why do you take such extreme care about what you eat, only organic and biological food, such extreme care about what you drink if it is not because you want to lead a very long life? Grasping at one’s own permanence is very easy to elicitate. Do you understand?

So, therefore, the instance which we can give of the apprehension of one’s own permanence, which is not the apprehension of the person being permanent, one and independent is easy. It is the apprehension of permanence within the continuum of a being unaffected by wrong tenets. What example would you give of illogical possibility which is neither?

The apprehension of a person who has, the wisdom realizing emptiness or a direct realization of the emptiness of a person being permanent one and independent. These are easy. Right? The table is Table is okay. Right?

So the table, for instance, is neither the apprehension of the person as permanent nor the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent. So how is all of this going down with you? You have understood? You have figured it out? Or, Geshe la, should we explain this next week?

So with the example that I gave of neither being the apprehension of a person with a wisdom realizing emptiness, is that incorrect? Yes. Yes. You got money. That’s okay.

Yeah. Just got a bit confused with the move. I thought a few weeks ago, we said that the of the full move, the one that wasn’t possible was being not permanent, not one, not independent, but being necessarily impermanent. That didn’t follow. I being yeah.

That one. Tonight, we seem to be saying that permanent, saying somebody is permanent, and they can also be not permanent, not one and independent, but be permanent. Could you repeat your dad, please? Trying to I’m getting the doubt was I think Mark thinks such too that before there was if something doubt was permanent, it was necessarily permanent one and independent. If it was impermanent, it was necessarily, not permanent, not one independent.

And if it was We’re speaking of two very different things. Couple of weeks ago, Geshe la talked of the moves between permanent phenomena or objects and phenomena which are permanent one and independent. Now, Geshe la is talking of the moves between the apprehension of permanent phenomena as permanent and the apprehension of phenomenal persons as permanent one and independent. Apprehensions of minds. So what is most important at present is for you to understand the mode of apprehension of the person as permanent and independent and what these three characteristics, permanent one and independent, mean.

Then this will become clear if you study the 25 objects of knowledge in Sankhya. For instance, the apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent does not exist in Geshe la’s mind. Please continue. But the apprehension of the person as permanent does exist in his mind. The innate apprehension.

Do you understand the mode of apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent? So, please read up on the 25 objects of knowledge. It’s not an easy topic. It’s covered in the monasteries, And ask questions next week. Yeah.

Have your question? Uh-huh. Oh, yeah. Okay. It’s a It really say you are afraid.

Really? Likes it when you ask thought out questions because it enables him to deepen his own reflection. And if you don’t ask questions, you don’t ask questions. So is Strange worried about your reputation? Why?

And you must ask questions because if you ask questions, you can dispel the benightedness. Otherwise, it’s not possible. Okay. Now in the team. So for to read up on Sankhya, the 25 objects of knowledge, you have Jeffrey Hopkins’s translation of Jangya Rolpai Dorje, Maps of the Profound.

And Kensur Rinpoche in his teachings on Bodhichittavivarana, TBI published the books, talked of the 25 objects of knowledge and the three correct with the three gunas, and I have a footnote on that. That’s number two. Number three, in English, the best reference is Larsen, L-A-R-S-E-N. It’s a great scholar who wrote on Sankhya. So it is very important, therefore, to understand these tenet systems such as Sankhya to be able to understand Buddhist tenets.

Otherwise, if we don’t understand Sankhya, how can we understand the Buddhist position which counters it? Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

Please open the prayerbook, page nine. Eight b Mandala offering. Mhmm.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
self generation dagkye (Tib)
The practice in Vajrayana where the meditator visualizes him- or herself as the deity. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
yidam ishtadevata (Skt)
Literally, "mind-bound." One's own personal, main - or, as Lama Yeshe used to say, favorite - deity for tantric practice. The deity with which a practitioner has the strongest connection. LYWA
Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top