Lam Rim – 2018-05-30 – 20180530Lamrim

1 h 33 min · 4,045 words · 30 May 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-05-30 - 20180530Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Explains the difference between taking refuge and taking lay vows, including the Sautrantika and Vaibhashika modes of accepting the five lay vows, and the relation of refuge and vows to the ten non-virtues. Then covers the three trainings in ethics, concentration and wisdom, and how the impermanence of the person, realised through its aggregates, relates to realising its emptiness. Ends with questions and answers on these points.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 33m

UUID: 5a8ab6e6-84ad-498a-87de-77439f81a1c4

Date: 2018-05-30

Words: 4,041

So initially, Geshe-la would like to give some explanations about lay vows, upasaka vows because there is some confusion, regarding, them and those of you who have taken them. So the term in Tibetan is means virtue, and means to become closer to. These are vows for someone who wishes to become closer to liberation. Geshe-la would imagine that a majority of you have lay vows, and one must know what is to be abandoned, what is to be protected against when one has lay vows. In other words, what one has accepted to do.

So there are, two modes, of, acceptance of, lay vows. According to the first, one accepts the totality of the lay vows. In other words, one accepts to abandon five, non virtues. The first is killing. The second is stealing.

The third is sexual misconduct. The fourth is lying. And the fifth is the consumption of beer. In other words, intoxicating beverages. So this is the approach in Sautrāntika.

If one takes lay vows, one must take the totality of the lay vows, all five lay vows, and there is a quote in Abidharma, which Geshe la will not quote tonight to corroborate this. And there is a second mode of accepting lay vows. One can accept just one lay vow, two lay vows, a majority of lay vows, most lay vows, or the collection of lay vows. All five lay vows, in other words. So this is the mode of acceptance of lay vows according to Vaibhāṣika.

And Jetsün’s commentary on Vinaya is written from the standpoint of Vaibhāṣika. So these are therefore the two modes of taking on lay vows. And therefore, if someone asks if someone has lay vows, does he or necessarily does he or she necessarily have taken all five lay vows? The answer is no. Such a person can have taken one vow, two vows, three vows, four vows, or five vows.

So this is for lay vows. Now within the, seven categories of pratimoksha vows, vows of individual liberation, lay vows are the vows of laypeople, male and female. Now among you, three students took refuge yesterday. These three three students took, therefore, refuge vows. And sometimes one is casually called, a refuge upasaka or a refuge lay vow holder.

This is a mere application of the name to someone who has taken refuge. Such a person is not a fully characterized upasaka or lay vow holder, but because having taken refuge, that person is moving closer to liberation. That person is a genyen, someone who is closer to liberation. So to resume, when one takes lay vows, one can take them in accordance with the Sautrandika system or with the Vaibhāṣika system. In accordance with Sautrāntika, when one takes lay vows, one must take all five vows.

If one does not take one of the five vows, one has not received lay vows. In accordance with Vaibhāṣika, and this is a system His Holiness seems to follow, when one takes lay vows, one can take one, two, three, four, or all five lay vows. Now what Geshele would like to emphasize is that those of you who took refuge yesterday have not taken lay vows. You just took refuge. Do you understand?

So, here, those of you who took refuge yesterday yesterday accepted to protect the refuge vows, but there is really no specific uncommon refuge vows. Principally, having taken refuge, one pledges to view Buddha Śākyamūni as the main protector against rebirth in the lower realms. And, Khensur Rinpoche, sometimes when he, there was no time, would confer refuge by, having the students recite three times in Sanskrit, Namo Gurubhya, Namo Buddhaya, Namo Dharmaya, Namo Sanghaya. And this was sufficient for them to have taken refuge. There is therefore no uncommon refuge vow associated with this.

Then some well, once upon a time, quite a time ago, someone, someone wanted to take refuge from Rinpoche, but was very busy and coming in and out. And one time when Rinpoche was going out, he ran into this person. And as this person wanted to take refuge, Rinpoche told to him to recite three times, these verses in Sanskrit, and that was sufficient to confer refuge on him. Then after a couple days, he stopped coming. So please don’t be like that.

So what does refuge mean? Refuge simply means that one pledges to become a follower of Buddha Śākyamūni, a pure follower of Buddha Śākyamūni. And then as a result of this, one, abides by the advice, the precepts Buddha Śākyamūni has given. And in a broader sense, one studies the Lam Rim. Then Geshe-la was somewhat ambiguous when he mentioned that having taken refuge, one must abstain from the 10 non virtuous deeds.

Abstaining from the 10 non virtuous deeds is a supreme limb of having taken refuge. It’s an excellent manifestation of having taken refuge. But, that is it. So we were all a bit confused in this respect. Don’t understand?

So there’s a way to proceed in these matters, a pure way. Please don’t think that because you took refuge vows, there is nothing in particular you should protect against. If you abstain from the 10 non virtues, there are only rewards for yourself and no loss. So, Geshe-la brought this up because, there was some confusion among yourselves regarding what someone who had taken refuge and someone who had taken lay vows were and what the distinction was and why someone who has taken refuge is somewhat sometimes called a lay vow holder who has taken refuge. So, Geshe-la hopes that you understand exactly the distinction at present.

Do you have special questions about this? Refuge is the foundation. It is the foundation for taking all vows. You can you can ask. Doesn’t so if you go for

Isn’t it like, the 10 non virtues, isn’t that more than the five? Because all all the five are in the 10 non virtues. Apart from not consuming alcohol or any intoxicants, yes. Correct.

But you can still take the second mode and still wouldn’t that constitute the same? This is a good doubt. However, to take lay vows, you have to actually rely on a teacher who gives you the vows and on a ritual to take the vows. So so when would that be offered? Yes.

It will be offered at TBI. There’s a big difference between just giving up killing on the one hand and taking the vow never to kill on the other hand. Completely. All of these rely on karma. Okay. So when you take refuge and if you don’t adhere to them accidentally, you can purify it.

Is that the difference? And if you take a vow, it’s more serious. So Geshe la will verify for the purification of refuge if it has degenerated. Then for vows of individual liberation, if they have degenerated, they can be reestablished. Okay.

The in a small scope, to achieve the precious human rebirth, you have to abstain from the 10 non-virtuous deeds, 10 non-virtuous deeds. And I was wondering, is it the same as if you take the five, you know, the five lay vows? Yes. But there is a difference in the power of these two. For instance, there is a difference between being reborn as a human being, just as a human being, and being reborn as a human being who is not an invalid or an infirm, but with all the his or her organs in perfect operation.

Don’t understand? Alright. So whether you have vows or not, you should try to abstain from the 10 non virtuous deeds. And if in addition, you can study the Lam Rim, then that is excellent. Then if you can take vows, all the better.

So in brief, vows refer to having accepted to do something, to having pledged to do something. And it is important once one has taken vows to put every effort to maintain them, not to take vows and then just relax and let things take their natural course. Just as in daily life, if you know someone who keeps promising to do things and never ever does what they promise, you would say this person is just a bum. They keep promising things. They never do what they say.

You know? No one respects them. Then in brief, this is what vows mean. Vows should not be a reason for becoming inflated and thinking I have high attainments because I have vows. All of us have vows of one sort or the other.

Is Geshe-la is not quite sure how you think about these things. And all of us have vows of various sorts. This is the beginning of a process of study and training, which we and we alone can do. Then to think, because I have vows, I am somewhere someone superior, this is wrong, wrong, wrong. Okay.

So at present, the vows of individual liberation are included within the first of the three trainings, the training in ethics. The goal of the training in ethics is to subdue inappropriate physical and verbal behavior. Independence on training in ethics, one is able then to progress to the training in concentration or Samādhi. And here, one endeavors to subdue the afflictions. The afflictions cannot easily be subdued through just controlling one’s physical and verbal behavior.

One needs concentration. Then through the training in concentration, and this refers specifically here to calm abiding or Samatha, one is able to cause the temporary absence or disappearance of the afflictions, one is not able to counter them permanently. To counter them permanently, one must address the actual source, the origin of the afflictions, which is the ignorance grasping at a self present within all our mind streams. And for this, one needs the training in wisdom. Through the training in wisdom, it’s able to sever the root of the afflictions from its very root.

And therefore, these three trainings are presented in terms of the order of difficulty. The easier the training in in ethics leads to the training in concentration, which is more difficult, which leads to the training in wisdom, which is the hardest. So this ignorance apprehending the self observes the self. The self is its object of observation. It observes the self, the I, or the person in a wrong fashion.

And, this is why one must counter it with wisdom realizing selflessness. Then that the I, which is the object of observation, in other words, what appears to the ignorance grasping at self exists is self-evident. From the moment we get up in the morning and have breakfast onwards, everything we do, whether we engage in virtuous deeds or non virtuous deeds is for ourselves. In other words, for the I. Why do we do it for ourselves?

In other words, the I exists. That’s a given. But the question arises, what is the mode of existence of the I? And that’s where the difficulties begin. I I I.

You know? In Tibet, how do you say? I I. You know?

So that the I exists, we have established and decided it is established based on our personal experience. The issue which arises is the mode of existence of this I. But the existence of the I is a given. It is something which you should maintain even if someone threatened to shoot you if you didn’t agree. This existence of the I must be established on reason or rationally.

And then when someone blathers away that the I doesn’t exist, we must know that this is just nonsense. This is what this person is saying. So that the I exists is therefore a given. However, the ignorance which apprehend the I, which is a consciousness, a mistaken consciousness, a wrong consciousness, apprehends this I as existing in a way in which it does not exist. So we have already established that the I exists independence on body and mind, the aggregates.

However, this ignorance apprehending the I apprehends the I as not existing in dependence on body and mind or the aggregates. So therefore, as was said, so the I exists in dependence on the aggregates, in dependence on body and mind. The ignorance apprehends the I as not existing in dependence on body and mind. It apprehends it as autonomous. In other words, it apprehends the I as being permanent one and independent.

Then as Geshe la explained last time, what actually does this entail? This entails an apprehension of the I as permanent. What is the main antidote to this apprehension of the eye as permanent? It is the realization of the impermanence of the eye. So then what at present is the mode of apprehending the I or the person as impermanent?

Could you answer quickly? Yeah. Apprehending the person impermanent on the basis of the person being imputed on the aggregates which are Mhmm. Mhmm. Okay.

Art and next. Why is the person impermanent? What is the mode of realization of the impermanence of the person? What’s the mode of ascertainment of the impermanent real impermanence of the person? The fact that the aggregates change, thus the person changes.

Can have you can you ask him? That the person and the mind and the body are all dependent originations. The I cannot be found in the five aggregates. Alright. So the answer in brief is that it is because the ground of imputation or the base of imputation of the person, which is body and mind or the five aggregates, is impermanent that one can infer that the imputed phenomenon, the person, is also impermanent.

However, the doubt which arises at this point is you did correctly all say that it is because the aggregates are impermanent that the person is impermanent. Is it necessarily the case that if one understands that the aggregates are impermanent, one has understood that the person imputed on that base is impermanent or not? So Geshe la would like to give you an example. Let us imagine, which will not be the case, that, he does not encounter Chris for one year. Then after not meeting Chris for one year, when Chris meets Geshe la, Chris would say to Geshe la, my goodness, you have aged so much.

Then this is something we say in society, but on what basis would Chris say that? The only basis he can say that upon is Geshe la’s aggregates. There’s nothing else Chris has access to. This is what one should think about. So therefore, it is based on the transformation of the aggregates that we infer the transformation of that which is imputed on the base of the aggregates, which is the person.

Then Geshe la explained in a different context how this process of imputation occurs. When, for instance, looking at Chris writing, we say, is writing. Actually, we impute Chris is writing upon the activity of writing of a part of Chris’s form aggregate, the hand. It is not the totality of Chris which is writing. So let us, at present, before engaging in the recitations, generate the appropriate motivation.

We should, with the motivation of being free from cyclic existence, generate the wish to train in the three trainings and so forth. Please open the preview page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, mandala offering, verse one and then three.

So to understand the impermanence To understand the impermanence of the person to understand the impermanence of the person, one must understand the impermanence of its base of imputation, the aggregates. And there is a passage in Gomde Rapsel clarifying the intent of Tsongkhapa’s treatise in which he says, upon ascertaining the instant by instant disintegration of sentient beings, the mind which considers that sentient beings are permanent one and independent is countered. So, therefore, to refute the permanence of the person, one must establish the impermanence of the person. And to do so, one must understand the existence of a link or a relationship between the person and the aggregates, which are its base of imputation. Once one has done so and one has established the impermanence of the person, one has also generated the mind realizing the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent.

So this is something which is difficult to understand if one doesn’t think about it carefully. So once one has realized that the person is impermanent, one has also realized that the person is empty of being permanent one and independent. And once one has realized that the person is empty of being permanent one and independent, one has realized that the person is impermanent. However, once one has realized that the person or once one apprehends a person as permanent, that does not mean that necessarily one apprehends a person as permanent one and independent. The converse, however, if one apprehends a person as permanent one and independent, one necessarily apprehends a person as permanent.

So if one realizes the impermanence of the person, then necessarily one understands the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent. Likewise, if one understands the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent, one understands the impermanence of the person. So if one apprehends the permanence of the So if one apprehends the permanence of the person, one does not necessarily apprehend the persons being permanent one and independent. Then if one apprehends a person as permanent one and independent, one necessarily apprehends a person as permanent. So in other words, if one apprehends the person as permanent, one does not necessarily apprehend the person as permanent one and independent.

Whereas if one apprehends a person as permanent one and independent, one necessarily apprehends a person as one does not necessarily apprehend one necessarily apprehends a person as permanent. Then one has to analyze whether there are three or four moves here. So this is something we will examine carefully. In your opinion, how many moves or how many logical possibilities are there here? Sorry.

What was that? I couldn’t hear. How many logical possibilities are three or four? Three, you say? Which one?

You cannot see or ascertain the person as being permanent one and independent without also seeing them as permanent? Give them correctly. Give them most correctly. Precisely. Okay.

So You can ascertain the person as both being permanent as well as permanent one and independent. Mhmm. You can ascertain the person as being permanent one and independent and So give this do you give the instance of both? Apprehending the person as permanent and apprehending the person as permanent one and independent? An instance would be I don’t know.

Ignorance grasping at the self. So which is absent? You say this. The one that’s absent is the one where you can see the person as being permanent one independent, but not see them as permanent. So there is, therefore, a logical possibility or a move for the person being apprehended as permanent, but not being apprehended as permanent one and independent.

Yes. Jure. Mhmm. Give it. Give it.

I would say you’d say a child that perceives a person but doesn’t understand the relationship between the aggregates and the person. So they wouldn’t necessarily see the person as independent, but they would still see the aggregates as permanent. So indeed, there are three modes or three logical possibilities between the apprehension of the person as permanent and the apprehension of person as permanent one and independent. And, Geshe-la would like you to think about this during the remainder of the week. The key to understanding this problem is that the apprehension of the person as permanent one and and independent only exists in the mind stream of people contaminated by wrong tenets.

Okay. And if you have questions, Geshe-la will take your questions at present. Just regarding that last section about guess you’re saying the apprehension of a person being permanent one and independent only exists in the minds of people contaminated by wrong tenets. But in an earlier teaching, he was saying we were discussing how that’s very sort of an it’s an innate feeling that we’re permanent one and independent. That that’s how we feel on a on a very, you know, gut level that it isn’t dependent on tenets to fuel that.

That is true, Gesheera. Geshe-la didn’t say that previously, but he will explain in detail why later on. When we see the person as separate from the aggregates, then we naturally see the person as permanent one and independent. So the way to understand this, because I explained this very slowly, otherwise, we will not get it, is that there is no difference between the emptiness of the person being permanent, the emptiness of the person being independent on the one hand, and the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent on the other. However, there is a difference between the apprehension of the person as permanent and the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent.

So what Geshe-la would suggest is that we check for We check for ourselves whether this apprehension of the person within ourselves as permanent one and independent exists within our mental continuum or not. It is not easy to do so. Okay. Next question. It is, sometimes problematic in in the view of many religions who believe, that there is such a thing like a

Whole. So, basically, that soul is almost like an independent set if they continue once the aggregate stopped to be around. Yes. So and that’s, of course, a view which is very difficult to agree to, but many seem to believe and follow that. And I think this is problematic.

And it should Because like the the the like, almost like the soul would be a permanent independent being almost like an I that continues to exist. Indeed, it when one asserts the existence of a truly established self, an I as with a soul, then it becomes very difficult not to assert it as permanent. If you would were to assert such an entity as impermanent, it’s difficult to see how it could be truly established. Okay. Question?

Geshe-la, what are the obstacles that prevent a person from progressing from the wisdom realizing emptiness based on thinking to the wisdom realizing emptiness based on meditation? So the main obstacle to the transition from a mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness to one arisen from meditation arisen from emptiness is as follows. To have a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, one must have a continuous recollection of emptiness through repeated familiarity. And the main obstacle to that would be mental agitation. The opposite, if you wish, of memory or recollection is agitation, the absence of memory.

Okay. And? Kishalah, is the ascertainment of the persons being impermanent, does that in any way get at the realization or the ascertainment of the person’s being empty of being a substantially existing autonomous entity or it doesn’t touch that? Yes. Yes.

Definitely. So is the ascertainment of the persons being empty of being inherently established, is that inferred directly from the ascertainment of the persons being impermanent or is there a complete change of the object of observation? There is no induction of understanding of the person being empty of being inherently existent on the basis of the realization of the person being impermanent. Because for that to be the case, realization of the impermanence of the person would have to induce the The reason I ask that is because in order to ascertain the impermanence of the person, we must understand thoroughly the relationship between the person and its aggregates and that the person is established in dependence upon its aggregates. And so it would seem to follow that one could deduce or induce from that initial ascertainment of impermanence the noninherent existence of the person?

Yes. Indeed. Independence on that gradually, one would gain an understanding of the. Gradually. Okay.

Thank you. Thank you. Over to page nine, the mandala offering.

Key terms in this teaching

five lay vows panchashila (Skt); ge nyen gi dompa nga (Tib)
The precepts taken by lay Buddhist practitioners for life: to abstain from killing, stealing, lying, sexual misconduct and taking intoxicants. LYWA
individual liberation
The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
upasaka genyen (Tib)
A male lay follower of Buddhism. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What obstacles prevent progress from the wisdom realizing emptiness that arises from thinking to the wisdom realizing emptiness that arises from meditation?

The main obstacle to moving from a mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness to a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness is mental agitation. To have a mind arisen from meditation on emptiness, one must have a continuous recollection of emptiness through repeated familiarity. Agitation works against this, because it is the opposite of memory or recollection: it is the absence of memory.

Scroll to Top