1 h 36 min · 4,270 words · 23 May 2018
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher explains that Lam Rim study must lead to inner transformation: hearing alone does not change the mind, so one must think and meditate on topics such as impermanence. He contrasts mental suffering, which Lam Rim counters, with physical suffering, and explains the antidote to the apprehension of a permanent, independent self through the realization of impermanence. Students then ask and answer questions on these points.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 36m
UUID: fcebb4c4-9889-4914-ac03-86c67945bcc4
Date: 2018-05-23
Words: 4,266
So as says in the prayer, after engaging the topic motivated by empathy, one should enact the will of others. So here, the topic, refers to whichever topic of Lam Rim one is studying, and enacting it refers to gaining realization of this topic. At this point, motivated by empathy, one endeavors to help the minds of others. So here, when one refers to the experience, in other words, the realizations of Lam Rim. This actually refers to countering the afflictions of which anger is an instance which are present within our mind stream.
So from your side, please listen carefully because if you don’t so, don’t do so. You will, drift away and fall asleep. Then if you drift away and fall asleep, Geshe la would unfortunately be limited in his enthusiasm for teaching. And if his own limit enthusiasm is limited, then he would be distracted and probably would not remember everything he might remember otherwise. On the other hand, if you are awake and enjoy the teachings, then he is quite sure that his memory would be strong.
This does happen. Then this really does happen. If from your side, you are focused and you understand what Geshe la explains, then he himself will greatly enjoy teaching and will delight in teaching. If on the other hand, you don’t understand that you are not focused, then Geshe la will wonder how do I present this? If I present this in easy terms, they don’t get it.
But if I present it in difficult terms, they don’t get it either. So how do I proceed? Interdependent. You know? Interdependent.
So here, one must practice hearing, thinking, and thinking hearing, thinking, and meditating inseparably. This is the crux of the instructions transmitted from Geshe-la, from Atisha, to his disciple, Dromtönpa, all the way down to Je Tsongkhapa, then to Gyaltsab and the Dalai Lama and our teacher, Then if you think, oh, this was explained last time and something else is being explained this time, it is clear that hearing, thinking, and meditation are not inseparably present in your mind. They are divergent or different. So please be mindful of the fact that mundane studies studies in society at large are different from the study of the Lam Rim. The focus of the study of the Lam Rim is the elimination of mental suffering.
The focus of mundane studies is the elimination of physical suffering. The two are fairly unrelated. They’re completely different. What do we mean by, inseparable hearing, thinking, and meditating? We mean that first one hears or one studies the topic which one wishes to, meditate upon.
Then one reads everything one can find and thinks carefully about this topic. And in this process, endeavors to generate a valid cognizer. And finally, one engages in meditation on this topic. Now if we were to take the case of impermanence as an instance, one would first read everything one could find on impermanence and listen to all the teachings on impermanence. There are numerous books written on impermanence.
Then one would analyze over and over again the lines of reasoning establishing impermanence to try to generate ascertainment by a valid cognizer. And at this point, one would meditate on what one had studied and thought about. So irrespective of whether it is the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, or the great scope, if one teaches one of these topics based on one’s own experience, this is uncommonly powerful. And this is why, said in the passage quoted earlier, engaging the topic, taught by means of numerous skillful means with empathy transform the mind. So if one proceeds in this fashion, then for instance, when a powerful affliction such as anger arises within our mind stream, we will understand, as we all do, the thoughts of anger, and we will understand how to counter it.
This is what anger is. This is how I counter it. And this is why says the key points of the topics being taught. So, here in our own cases, we have received many teachings, on the Lam Rim. For instance, many teachings of the past shared with the being of the small scope.
And Geshe la would like to give an example for this. Okay. I ask you to repeat the meaning of the example, which I did not understand. Uh-huh. Another.
Just put for example, you know, sport. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly.
So hearing alone does not transform our mind. Now let’s take the case of sport, for instance, cricket. If we watch a cricket match match, however much we might enjoy watching others playing cricket, that in no way enables us to play cricket better. So hearing alone does not benefit the mind. It does not transform the mind.
Now if in your own cases, your minds have been transformed, all the better. But if you feel that you have been attending all these teachings and you have still not experienced mental happiness or peace, this is a sign that you have only engaged in listening. And as a result, the mind has not been transformed. It is a sign the teachings are not placed within your mind. So now if in addition to, listening to teachings on a topic, let us say, such as impermanence, we analyze carefully and think by ourselves using our own reasons about impermanence, trying to generate an ascertainment
By a valid cognizer. This can transform the mind, and this is akin to someone who actually knows how to play cricket, who understands how cricket is played, watching others play cricket, then there is benefit for his own play. So if instead of being a mere spectator at a cricket match, we actually know how cricket is played. We played. We are knowledgeable about how to play cricket.
Not only will we feel delight through watching the game, but in addition, our own playing style will improve. How is for example? Then the example of the meal will maybe be easier to understand for you. If all you do is look at food which is set out and say, my goodness, this is beautifully set out food, then, you don’t experience the pleasure of eating the food, the pleasure of the taste of the food. That is listening alone.
It is only when you actually engage in eating the food that you will experience the delight of eating the food. That is experience arisen from thinking. You understand? The Lam Rim has numerous examples of this, such as the example of sacred dances and so forth. So we have to gain experience by ourselves.
Then both the expounder of the Lam Rim and the listener of teachings on the Lam Rim should engage in this activity motivated by the desire to subdue the afflictions within their continuum. Geshe-la from his own side does this as much as he can. He in no way is saying that his afflictions are subdued. If they were, that would mean that he had at least gained a direct realization of emptiness, gained a realization of emptiness, nakedly, which is very difficult to do and which he has not gained. And in our own cases, we should listen to the teachings with the same motivation.
Do you understand? So the Lam Rim is like a mirror. Why exactly do we look at our faces in the mirror? Why do we look at our faces in the mirror in the morning? So, therefore, we look at our faces in the morning.
And if there are any faults or defects, then we tidy them up quickly. Then the Lam Rim is the place in which we check our minds for faults. We study the Lam rim, and then we check our minds, and the Lam Rim indicates that we have this defect and that defect and this defect and that defect, and then explains how to counter them, how to eliminate them. Then that we all have defect is something we know. Then this is the experience transmitted from Buddha Śākyamūni downwards through the great teachers until our own days.
It is important to keep in mind that Buddha Śākyamūni was not a Buddha from the beginning. He was a sentient being at the beginning. He had defects like us. He was like us, but he purified these defects and eventually became a fully enlightened being. Then whatever experience we have gained in the process of meditating on the Lam Rim, if, having gained this experience, we wish to help others based on this experience, such a practice has truly become a Mahāyāna practice.
And this is how one generates motivation. So to help others initially, we must subdue our own mental continuum. And the foundation for subduing one’s own mental continuum is first, the path shared as a being of the small scope. So what is, therefore, the motivation of the path shared with the being of the small scope. This it is the uncontrived wish for higher rebirth.
And what is the attainment of this path? It is the attainment of that wish. So what is at present the special realization of the path shared with the being of the middling scope? It is the unconstrained striving for liberation. What is the attainment of this path?
It is liberation. Likewise, what is the uncontrived realization of the path shared with the being of the great scope? It is striving for full enlightenment. What is the attainment of this path? It is full and utter enlightenment.
So now what, in other words, is the attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope? It is the attainment of a higher rebirth. In other words, the attainment of a worthy base, a higher rebirth. What is the foremost means for attaining this? It is an ethics which abandons killing.
So, therefore, the foremost means for attaining a higher rebirth in a human rebirth in a future life is abandoning murder. Now, in this room, probably no one, thinks of engaging in murder, but this does not mean that we should not be mindful of the importance of not engaging in murder or killing another human being. Then if one engages in this, the result is rebirth in a lower realm. So it is important for us to keep in mind that, our own future lives exist, and it is our mental continuum which will be reborn in these future lives. Then once we are mindful of this, we wonder what precisely will happen then.
How should I proceed to prepare for this? Do you understand? This is important. This is something we should think about. There are great rewards for this.
So if we have from deep within ourselves abandoned murder, killing of another human being, then that is a virtuous karma. That is what is known as merit that leads to a higher rebirth. Then if in addition to this, we can abandon violence and killing of all sentient beings from the smallest of ants upwards, then this is all the more meaningful. And we should then reflect how we ourselves would benefit as a result of this. So there are numerous forms of violence.
And as you know, VESAC is coming up, I think, Tuesday. And, on Vesak, we try to abandon, all forms of bloody deeds, all forms of violence
Towards others, enabling animals to lead as longer life as possible. So then it may be difficult for us to abandon all deeds of violence, all bloody deeds towards others, but we should try to reduce them as much as possible. And in the case of eating meat, it is clear that eating meat has a link with violence towards others. We should reflect on how we ourselves would feel if we were treated in the way animals are treated. And therefore, we should try to eat as little meat as is possible, as little as is possible for our health.
And if we do so, our health will benefit, and the natural violence within us will be reduced. Do you do you agree? Okay. As much as possible. Then within this temple, there are probably people who eat meat, maybe people who eat chicken.
Then think for yourselves during one month how many living beings this would amount to. Okay. But this is Geshe-la’s private view. He explained it to you then. You do what you what you want.
Then even for your own health, if you can reduce your ingestion of meat, then it is beneficial. So here, therefore, if one can abstain from inflicting violence on other beings and from robbing them of their life, then, this is the abandonment of killing. It is a virtuous deed. It is what is known as merit. And the way to do this is to think how would I feel if this was done to me?
Then once one is able to do this, one is acting in accordance with the first verse of Āryadeva’s stanza, which Geshe-la quoted several weeks ago, initially abandon initially counter demerit. So, this first stanza teaches causal interdependence. So this is, as you remember, the first stanza or the first verse of the stanza of which Geshe la quoted initially counter demerit, and it refers to causal interdependency abandonment of non virtue or nonmeritorious deeds. This is called causal dependent origination because if one engages in non virtue towards others, then oneself would experience suffering. And once if one engages in virtuous deeds towards others, oneself would experience happiness.
Now the second verse of Āryadeva’s stanzas reads, in the middle, counter the self. Here, the self refers to that basis of imputation of the person which Geshe-la identified as the aggregates previously. So the source of all our unhappiness and suffering is discontentment, lack of contentment. And the source of discontentment is desire. The source of desire is ignorance, and the way to counter this ignorance is the, wisdom which realizes the selflessness of persons.
Now there are two presentations of the selflessness of persons, that in keeping with the lower schools of tenets and that in keeping with Here, Gesheera will explain that in keeping with So as you remember, previously, Geshe-la had explained causal interdependence, giving the example of the relationship between the basis of imputation of the person, which is the body and mind, or if you prefer the five aggregates, and the person which is imputed on this basis. So at present, let us generate a an appropriate motivation at the very least, at the minimum, a motivation striving for a higher rebirth. For the sake of others. Thinking, I will wish to attain a higher rebirth in my future lives, a worthy base, so that I can engage in effort for the sake of others. Mhmm.
Okay. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, number offering, first one, and it’s three. Page five. Then countries such as this one are the countries in which Lam Rim, should be taught and studied, largely because in countries such as this one, you have very little physical suffering, if any.
And the main suffering is mental. Lam Rim is a means to counter counter mental suffering. Then in appallingly poor countries where people don’t have enough clothing to
Clothe themselves, enough food to eat, then there is no time to focus on mental suffering. One must focus on trying to eradicate the overwhelming physical suffering one experiences. And this is a very clean, very pure country in many senses. And if one wishes to help others, then once one has oneself gained experience of the topics of the Lam Rim, one can then instruct others and say, I myself experienced this, and you must be experiencing the same thing. This is how one counters it.
Then if oneself has no experience at all, then merely verbal about expressions, babbling away about things is of no benefit whatsoever. Well, check for yourselves today in your own lives what is the predominant form of suffering you experience. Is it physical or mental suffering? And Geshe la thinks you will find that you experience, unless you are ill, frankly, little or no physical suffering at all. Everyone eats to their hunger.
Everyone has enough to drink. Everyone has clothing to wear. Everyone has some type of house or dwelling to live in. So people overwhelmingly experience bitter mental suffering. And mental suffering cannot be countered by taking drugs or an injection.
To counter mental suffering, you need dharma. Mhmm. Yeah. Exactly. No.
So in brief, it is out of discontentment, dissatisfaction, lack of contentment that mental suffering arises. Geshe-la explained this many times. What we need is contentment. Okay. Okay.
We need a contentment. We need a strong We need stable contentment, not ephemeral contentment. And if we have stable contentment, then the difficulties will not arise. So here, contentment is virtue, and discontentment is nonvirtue. Now what is the root of discontentment?
It is ignorance, apprehending a self. And Geshe la explained that there are two broad subdivisions of this ignorance that in keeping with the lowest schools of tenets and that in keeping with Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka. That in keeping with the lowest schools of tenets has been explained. It is the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent and the apprehension of the per person as a a substantially existent autonomous entity. So, Geshe-la, would not enter into the details of whether the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent is imputed or innate.
We will set that aside. The issue is that it is present within our mind stream, and we have at present to identify the antidote to this apprehension. So what would this antidote be? So therefore, what would the antidote be to this apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent? And you can broach the topic, some of you, last time.
When we apprehend the person as permanent, one, and independent, we actually apprehend the person as permanent. So this refers to apprehending one’s own permanence. Now what is the antidote to this? Then the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent amounts to apprehending the person as permanent. So please answer as one what the antidote will be.
Could you repeat precisely? The apprehension which apprehends the person as impermanent. Or the awareness apprehending the person as impermanent permanent or the wisdom apprehending the person as impermanent. You do understand that the, apprehension of oneself as permanent has as its direct opposite the apprehension of oneself as impermanent. So how exactly does the, apprehension of the person as being impermanent act as an antidote to the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent?
So in which way does the apprehension of the person as impermanent, act as an antidote to the apprehension of the person being permanent, one, and independent? Well, if the person is impermanent, it has arisen on on causes and conditions. So it’s clearly not one, and it’s not independent. It acts I’m sorry. Apprehending a person as impermanent acts as countering the person’s permanent because they have the same object of observation, which is the permanent which is the person, and they’re directly opposite to each other in their apprehension.
Basically, you said, they have the same object, but their modes of apprehension are mutually exclusive. Mhmm. That one? So you all agree, same object, contradictory, or opposite modes of apprehension? Okay.
Quick plea please. I don’t think that the apprehension of impermanence fully counters the person being permanent one and independent. The reason I’m sorry. And the reason is because you can have two things which are separate but both impermanent. So the aggregates and the person could theoretically be impermanent but separate.
I don’t understand. You’d have to repeat. Could have two things, two objects, which are both impermanent. Uh-huh. And just because they’re impermanent doesn’t mean they’re not separate.
So the reason for which the apprehension of the person as impermanent is antidote to the apprehension of the person as permanent is what many of you said, which is that the object of observation is the same, but the mode of observation is directly contradictory. So you explained exactly how the apprehension of the person as impermanent counters the apprehension of the perfect person as permanent. So what exactly is the mode of apprehension of the person as impermanent? How is the person apprehended as impermanent by a valid cognizer? What happened?
I think through even analyzing one component of the aggregates, say the mind, we can see how that is changing moment by moment, minute by minute, second by second so that that understanding of impermanence can be determined through our own experience of our aggregates. So we all understand that the person is apprehended as impermanent, But it is not sufficient to say that the person, is momentary for the realization of the person’s impermanence to arise. How do we generate the valid cognizer? What reasons do we use to establish the person’s being impermanent? Okay.
The person doesn’t exist on its own side. Same with the aggregates. They are not exist on their own side. Okay. Okay.
And the other? Everything arises through causes and conditions, including the body and the mind. What’s the relation with the person here? So Geshe-la is asking why the person is impermanent. If we understand the reasons for the person being impermanent correctly, we will be able to generate a valid cognizer understanding that the person is impermanent.
We can begin by, well, we have direct experience in a sense because we see ourselves changing and aging and and see others die around us. I would say that it’s on the basis of the discrimination of an aggregate that we impute person. And because person and the aggregates of the person of the same nature but different isolates, and because the aggregates change, we can infer that then the person must change. That’s it. Okay.
And the same. No. Mine was different. I was gonna say meditation on death and interdependence helps me realize understand. Focus on one’s own impermanence and death and impermanence.
The table is impermanent. Right? Why? Because its basis of imputation is impermanent. Sorry?
Because its basis of imputation is impermanent. Okay. So just as we say that the table is impermanent because table is imputed on its basis of imputation, and its basis of imputation is impermanent. Likewise, the same is true for the person. The person is impermanent because it is imputed on its basis of imputation, body and mind.
Body and mind are both impermanent. So let us reflect on this carefully. Please reflect on this by yourselves. The basis of imputation of the person, the foundation of imputation is body and mind, and it is from the imputation on this impermanent body and mind that we infer the impermanence of the person. So this is the second dependent arising which is being studied here.
The first dependent arising is causal dependent arising. The second dependent arising is dependent arising between imputed phenomenon and basis of imputation. Mhmm. Okay. Do you have questions?
Two or three? I think two. What you say is true indeed. War, there are two, broadly speaking, rebirth, human and divine higher rebirth. Here, we are focusing on a human rebirth.
I think it has to be done with VR, you know. And say again? Who is that? Thank you, Geshe la. Today, you talked about the benefits of vegetarianism, and one might think that you are a vegetarian because you didn’t mention that you’re that you eat meat.
So with respect, why do you not practice what you’ve preached? And what so in other words, why do you preach vegetarianism but are not a vegetarian yourself? Yes. Yes. I say, you know.
Yes. Sometimes, you know. So this is exactly what Gesheera said. You should try to eat less. So for health, you know, for health and for dharma, you know.
I can understand how the apprehension of a person being impermanent counters the apprehension of the person as permanent. But how does the apprehension of the impermanence of the person counter the apprehensions of a person also being one and independent? A very good question. Geshe la will enter into that one quietly next time. If one doesn’t do it carefully, it gets very confusing.
Is the accumulation of merit that you spoke of tonight synonymous with the developing lineage, related to the developing lineage, or not related at all to the developing lineage? Yes. There can be a relation. Depends on the tenet system. In Madhyamaka, the collection of merit is the developing lineage, but in Cittamātra, it is not.
Okay. Final. If the apprehension exists that we are permanent and exist in our mind and the innate mind apprehends the coarse self of persons, how many minds are there actually? Is there a main mind and then lesser minds? How many minds?
Yes. In general, there are two main minds in this situation, but they are not simultaneous. When there is a powerful main mind focusing on the person’s impermanence, The main mind focusing on the person’s permanence is absent. Okay. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you very much. Very good. Very good. Okay.
Slowly. Slowly. You know? Page nine.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.