Lam Rim – 2018-05-02 – Lamrim

1 h 37 min · 4,570 words · 2 May 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-05-02 - Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains why we study the Lam Rim: to subdue the mind within, not to gain intellectual novelty. It teaches recognising our own faults, reducing craving through contentment, and understanding the innate apprehension of the self as permanent, one and independent. Questions from students follow on coarse selflessness and emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 38m

UUID: 1800e9a1-137d-4b7a-8359-04926cdf304e

Date: 2018-05-02

Words: 4,566

Another. So what is the purpose of listening to the Lam Rim? The purpose of listening to the Lam Rim, to hearing the teachings, in other words, is to subdue one’s continuum. Now subduing one’s continuum here refers to subduing inappropriate or unsuitable states of mind. So therefore, the motivation for receiving Lam Rim teachings is to subdue unsuitable states of mind.

Such a motivation makes receiving teachings profoundly meaningful. Among us, there are some newcomers, but most have received numerous times over Lam Rim teachings. The goal of attending Lam Rim teachings is not to check to see if something new is being said today. That is not the purpose. The purpose is instead to subdue one’s mind stream.

So in this respect, the study of the Lam Rim or the graduated stages of the path is very different, from contemporary, mundane studies. So in contemporary mundane studies, the focus is on exterior objects. And one is fascinated by the latest and the newest and, discards whatever is outdated and old fashioned. Now this is not, at all the way one studies the Lam Rim. The goal of the Lam Rim is to subdue the mind within.

And then in this respect, the mode of studying the Lam Rim and the mode of studying contemporary mundane issues are different. So in this respect, there is a verse attributed to prince Chandra in which in the Jātaka, in which he says, may I see in the mirror of the dharma the shape of my evil deeds. So the meaning of this verse of the Jatakas in which prince Chandra says, may I see clearly in the mirror of dharma, the form of my evil deeds refers to independence on the study of texts, understanding clearly what non virtues of body and speech one has engaged in. Then in our own cases, and this is true for all of us, we tend to go about things in a very different way. As to thoughts of body and speech, we are extraordinarily mindful of the thoughts in others.

And, we say, yes, my goodness, poor him, poor her, what a mess, you know. But as to our own thoughts, we are completely oblivious to them. Our bodily behavior is good. Our verbal behavior is excellent. And as to our mind, we are suffused with qualities.

Then this obviously does not reflect reality. And that is, therefore, the meaning of the verse attributed to prince Chandra in the Jatakas. May I see clearly in the mirror of dharma, the form or the shape of my non-virtue, my evil deeds. The meaning is independence on the Lam Rim to engage in introspection and realize, my goodness, how how far I have fallen, how badly I have behaved, how at odds with the teaching. I must change my behavior.

I will change my behavior. So this account of prince Chandra is presented in a summarized fashion in Pabongka Rinpoche’s liberation in the palm of your hand. It’s very beautiful. The complete stanza reads as follows. If I were able to see clearly in the mirror of the dharma, the form of my evil deeds, my mind would be pacified and turned towards the dharma.

So to listen to the, therefore, we need the following discriminations. We must see ourselves as someone who is sick or diseased, not sick or diseased in the mundane sense, but in the spiritual sense. Then we should see the afflictions within our mind as the disease. We should see dharma as the medicine for that disease. And we should see the lineage of teachers from Buddha Śākyamūni all the way down downwards to Khensur Rinpoche as the doctors who can treat this disease.

So these discriminations are very profound, discriminating or recognizing oneself as someone who is sick or ill. Now this is not a recognition of oneself as sick or ill in the mundane sense. And then the Lam Rim acts as the antidote to this disease. So when you yourselves attend these teachings and when you listen to the Lam Rim, just what exactly are you thinking about? What motivates you?

Are you motivated by the wish to principally subdue your continuum? If that is so, it is said that one has gained the first realization of the Lam Rim. Then, there is a great risk for us who must only attend and receive the most famous and illustrious of teachings to be in the situation of someone who is sick, for whom only the most famous doctor will be good enough, for whom only the most expensive medic medicine is acceptable and who stashes it all away in a cupboard. Then it is very similar, as, a behavior to that of an ill person who stashes a medicine away in a cupboard and never ingested. Such a person can never be healed.

Likewise, if one attends Lam Rim teachings for intellectual satisfaction, just listens to them and never applies them, then there is no benefit. What is similar to someone who keeps discussing the taste of various meals saying this is delicious and that is marvelous, but has actually never tried anything. Then in our own cases, we must experience the taste of the teachings. They don’t even know what we’re talking about. So Italian food is world famous.

We have pizza and pasta and whatnot. And what would we say at a mundane level of someone who spends a lot of money for the best Italian meal and doesn’t touch a bite of it. We would say he is really an imbecile. As said, all of the utterances of the Buddha in all of the shastras, the treatises pronounced for the sake of subduing the mind. If that does not happen, they are all wasted.

Then we should reflect on the meaning of the stanza when we think of the numberless beings who are striving endlessly life after life for liberation or enlightenment and never attain anything.

Now it is insufficient to say that one must subdue one’s mind. One has to answer the question, what is the mode of subduing this mind? How does one subdue this mind? How specifically does one subdue inappropriate physical and verbal behavior? So Kinturinpoche always said, and you must have heard this yourselves, generate realizations, give rise to realizations.

Then we have to ask ourselves, how does one give rise to realizations? In realizations, he referred to the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small, of the middling and of the great scope. These must be developed in sequence or incrementally. It is not possible to generate the realizations of the being of the great scope without having initially generated those of the being of the small and of the middling scope. So how precisely do we proceed?

So we must generate realizations. These realizations, if we take the case of the path shared as a being of the small scope, do not refer to be able able to list the topics of meditation of this path nor nor do they refer to being able to explain their meaning. It is something else. And these realizations are our reward. Animals and human beings are similar in this respect.

Whatever we do, we do for a reward. There’s a goal. So one must therefore give rise to realizations, in other words, to experiences. In this case, experiences of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Now if we take, for instance, the 10 non virtuous deeds, which are the main topic of abandonment of this path, in our own cases, those with which we are the most familiar are the four non virtuous deeds of speech.

So we must abandon these. Otherwise, what precisely are we doing? If we take two of the most widespread non virtues of speech in society, which are divisive speech and harsh words or insults, then these are things which we engage in ourselves. We know we do. And if we examine what the faults, let’s say, of divisive speech are on the one hand and what the advantages of ceasing from engaging in divisive speech are, then we can abandon it.

Likewise, if we examine what the faults of harsh words are and the advantages of no longer uttering harsh words, we can abandon them. Who is there who cannot abandon these? And if we take two close acquaintances and we examine their speech, we will find that it is overwhelmingly constituted of divisive speech and harsh words or insults. Then, if we examine what would happen if they stopped uttering these, then perhaps they would just sit back and say nothing. So we can see here if we examine carefully what the rewards of not engaging in such verbal speech are and what the faults of engaging it in it are.

Then even in society at large, no one praises divisive speech and no one praises insults or harsh words. Their defects are evident. So this is how we can transform ourselves progressively. And then, obviously, contentment. Contentment acts as a direct antidote to the two first of the three mental non virtues.

And all of our unhappiness arises independence on our lack of contentment. Independence on contentment, craving is reduced. Through contentment, the lust for visual objects is reduced. Through contentment, the lust for sounds are reduced. Through contentment, the lust for smells, the lust for tastes, the lust for tactile sensations is reduced.

As a result, through contentment, the lust for exterior objects is reduced. So let us take an example. Let’s take the case of shoes. So, basically, one or two pair of shoes is sufficient for every normal person. But we see an extra pair of shoes and we crave it, so we buy that extra pair of shoes.

And then we buy another pair of shoes and then another pair of shoes. Then we need money for all these fancy shoes. Then we crave money. Then the problem start. So if we limit ourselves to one or two pairs of shoes, then we reduce the difficulties in our life.

So shoes here are just an example of how we should practice contentment. In our own cases, the greatest object of craving is tactile sensation, sexuality, in other words. Then one must try to reduce one’s craving for tactile sensations. So likewise, for food, we need food to live. But if we eat too much, we become heavily overweight.

And if we eat too little, then we are skeletal. So if we eat moderately, we will be in between. And as a result, our health will benefit. As is said in Vinaya, one should eat with measure and divide the day in three portions. Okay.

So, this is, as far as the realizations of the past shared with the being of the small scope are concerned and the realization of contentment is concerned. So therefore, in brief, at the level of the paths shared with the being of the small and of the middling scope, one’s focus should be on reduce or on the afflictions within one’s own mind stream, which are an obstacle to one’s own happiness. And at this level, it is inappropriate to focus on other people’s physical and verbal, behavior since this is irrelevant to us and in no way affects our own mind stream. Then once this has happened at the level of the path of the being of the great scope, one then can focus on the behavior of others motivated by this and for their sake. Then as said, one should focus on one’s own faults and not like a child on those of others.

Then in our own case, is this what we do or not? Do you examine your own thoughts? You should. Then as Togme Sangpo says, therefore, one should look at one’s own faults. If one does not, one is akin to a child.

Then in our own cases, Geshe-la thinks that we do not look at our own faults. And he would strongly suggest that we try it out for a month and see whether there is some reward for us as a result or not. So engage in this self examination, therefore, for a month or so and see whether you as a person have improved, if there is a reward. And if there is, then proceed onwards. And if there isn’t, just give it up.

After all, the goal is not to deceive you. Now if one wishes to abandon ultimately the afflictions, then one must

Abandon their root cause, which is the ignorance grasping at a self. Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen says, the root of all the afflictions, whatever they might be, is ignorance. So here, if the root of the afflictions is ignorance, what ignorance is this? It’s an ignorance apprehending itself, and one must oppose its direct antidote, which is the wisdom realizing emptiness. So here, therefore, one must oppose to this ignorance grasping at a self,, the wisdom realizing emptiness or the wisdom realizing interdependence.

Now not the wisdom realizing the emptiness or the interdependence of just anything, not that realizing the emptiness or the interdependence of a house, a building and so forth. It is true that they are empty and interdependent, but, realizing their emptiness or their interdependence is not terribly helpful to us. What matters is realizing the emptiness or the interdependence of the I or the self. Now the I or the self exists, but the question which arises is what precisely its mode of existence is. So, here, the existence of the I is a given.

It is settled. Everything we do from the moment we wake up in the morning until we go to bed at night is for the sake of the I. We get up for the sake of the I. We drink some water for the sake of the I. We go to the toilet for the sake of the I.

We have breakfast for the sake of the I. In a cycle of twenty four hours, check for yourselves if there is anything you do which is not for the sake of the I. So the I is fundamental, isn’t it? In the Tibetan, you how do you say? I is.

You know? In English, I. From animals upwards, apart from terminological differences, differences in terms of the expressions, the sense of the I exists among all. In Tibetan. One says in Tibet in English, excuse me, one says I. Or mine.

So it is a reality we deal with. Now the reason for which grasping at the I is problematic is precisely for that reason. So as Geshe la has explained many times, the mode of existence of the I, he will not enter in great detail. As was explained, the I exists in dependence on the five aggregates. It exists in dependence on body and mind.

It exists therefore not only in dependence on the aggregates, it exists in relation to the aggregates. It exists depending on the aggregates. So Geshe la previously explained the two main modes in which the I is perceived. In one case, to use an example, the relationship between the I and its ground of imputation, the body and mind, is seen as similar as that between the owner of a house and the house whom that owner owns. The owner of the house is separate from the house which he owns.

Likewise, in this mode of perception of the I, the I is separate from the aggregates. There is a second mode of perception of the I in which the I is seen as deep within the aggregates. It is subsumed within the aggregates. So please listen carefully because the topic is profound. And if you don’t pay attention, you will be rather stunned after.

So this is really important because the establishment of the Buddhist view hinges on this. So now within the first perception of the I, as you remember, the example given was that of the relationship between the owner of a house and the household which he owns. Now the owner of a house is different from the house which he owns. In this first perception of the I, the I is perceived as different from its ground of imputation, the aggregates, or the body and mind. This is obviously mistaken.

Now this mode of apprehension is mistaken. Not everything which appears to us is correct or authentic. There are mistaken appearances. Why is it the case that the perception of the I as different from its basis of imputation is mistaken simply because the I has a relationship with its basis of imputation, the aggregates. So there is, therefore, an innate mind within us which apprehends, which conceives, or to which the I appears as different from body and mind, as different from its base of imputation, the aggregates.

As Geshe la explained, this innate mind is mistaken. Then Geshe la asked you last time what the name of this innate mind was. Which I asked you two one or two weeks ago? Name does one give to this mistaken mind? Thoughts.

Ah. Thoughts? Thoughts. Okay. In Buddhist text, in Buddhist scriptures.

Truly established, inherently existing. The mind of permanence? Attachment? Chakpa? I would say, substantially existent.

The mind that sees the I as being substantially existent. The ignorance that grasps it as so. The dualistic mind. Chris second. No.

That’s why he doesn’t know. Just I need just one more time. Self sufficient sufficient and substantial. Mhmm. It could be the mistaken view of the transitory collection or seeing the I as permanent one in an independent.

Ignorance that perceives the self as a substantially existing autonomous entity. So it went pretty well. Some of you came close. And some were dead on, and a couple were close. So it’s reasonably good.

Was going to say I was going to say a conceptual consciousness which mistakenly apprehends its object of observation as inherently existent. And other? So the purpose of this approach is for things to stay stably in your mind. If Geshe la just explains you what this is called, you won’t retain it. If you come up with your own answers, then when Geshele explains things, it’ll stick.

Any other? Mhmm. Rayfying view of the disintegrating aggregates. The ignorance that grasps itself specifically as being permanent, one, and independent. Are you ready?

Just ignore this. Okay. Things went very well. So one of you gave the answer indeed. It is the apprehension which apprehends the self as permanent one and independent.

So the answer was indeed the

Apprehension which apprehends the self or the person as permanent, one, and independent. Most of you gave pretty much 90% of the answer, and one of you gave a 100%. If one can get an understanding that the person or the I is not permanent one and independent, that is an extraordinary achievement, something which couldn’t be bought for millions and millions of dollars. So does the apprehension of ourselves as permanent one and independent exist within ourselves or not? Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So you do understand the meaning of an innate mind apprehending the person or the I as permanent, one, and independent.

Now in the schools of Buddhist tenets beneath Sautrāntika Madhyamaka, this is known as the coarse selflessness of persons. There’s a coarse and a subtle selflessness of persons. Geshe la would enter into these topics later. So at present, let us meditate and generate the following motivation. Just try to understand this topic, of the person appearing to be permanent, one, and independent for the sake of explaining it to others.

In other words, for the benefit of others. And let us think about this both during the meditation and after where we recite the prayers. Please open the prayer book page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, mandala offering, verse one and three. So, therefore, you understand at present what this apprehension, apprehending the person or the I as permanent, one, and independent is.

Now this is a wrong consciousness. As it is a wrong consciousness, we have to understand why it is a wrong consciousness. And once we have understood that, we can apply its direct antidote, its opposite. So you understand that present what the apprehension, apprehending the person or the I as permanent one and independent is, then this is a mistaken mind. It is a wrong consciousness.

The way it apprehends its object is wrong. Why? Short answers with reasons, please. It’s wrong because it believes that its apprehension corresponds with reality, and it doesn’t. It’s wrong because the I or person is impermanent, dependent, and probably not one as well.

Is the I is in a relationship with the aggregates? It’s not independent of As it is a consciousness apprehending something about the aggregates, as a consciousness, by definition, it is one of the aggregates. It is consciousness. That’s my yeah. That was it.

Any other? It’s not permanent one and independent because it functions. It can be a causal agent, and no causal agent can be independent nor can it be permanent because if it was permanent, nothing would ever change. So because the I functions, it cannot be permanent one and independent. Because if we try to find this I, we cannot find it.

Because the I has a has a dependent origination. So we can therefore see that the apprehension of the I or the person as permanent one and independent is mistaken. Then it would be countered by a mind or a consciousness which has a mode of apprehension of its object directly opposite to that of this mistaken consciousness. And this is something Geshe-la will talk about later. Then Geshe-la will take your questions at at present.

Please concise questions. Geshe-la, I thought grasping at the self that was permanent one and independent was not innate, that that was learned through acquired through philosophy, and that it was grasping at this substantially truly existent autonomous self that was innate. Could you explain, please?

Very good question. And Geshe-la is delighted that you’re not sticking just to the words, then it’s a topic he’ll cover in detail later. So Geshe-la enjoys very much your questions since he can formulate answers in dependence on your questions and all of us improve as a result. It’s inappropriate to teach, if you wish, ex cathedra where Geshe la teaches and you take notes in your notebooks and close your notebooks and forget everything. Okay.

I had the same question as Molly, and the reason I had that question is because I thought the answer possibly could be that it was the self that sees the the view that sees the self as permanent one and independent. Because at the end of last teaching, Geshe la mentioned about coarse consciousnesses that disappear when the brain decays, and I thought that he was referring to, consciousnesses which have been learnt by tenants such as permanent one independent. So was that what you were talking about with the brain decaying? No. Not all coarse consciousnesses are consciousnesses which apprehend the person as permanent one and independent when we refer to the distribution of the 25 consciousnesses.

This includes sensory consciousnesses and so forth. Okay. Next question. Yeah. Yeah.

Wait. Sorry. Yeshua, in the verse that you gave us a couple of weeks ago about from Nāgārjuna, The Tathāgata is not endowed with aggregates. Who is the Tathāgata at this? I thought that the Buddha does have aggregates.

So I don’t quite understand unless it is saying that the, you know, there there is no self as such, no inherent self. But I just want to understand the meaning of No problem, Geshe-la will give you a commentary on this later. So these two stances which were given to you, the stanzas from Nāgārjuna and the stanza from the Ratnavalli. Nāgārjuna’s Ratnavalli are actually stanzas on the basis of which His Holiness, the Dalai Lama said, he realized the selflessness of persons according to the lower vehicles.

So for that reason, Geshe la will comment. Okay. Next question. Geshe-la, why would a teacher instruct a student to meditate on the wisdom realizing emptiness rather than on developing the uncontrived thought of definite emergence? Why?

Simply because it is not necessary for a realization of emptiness to have the realization of uncontrived definite emergence. They are not mutually dependent. Okay. Is that clear? Alright.

I understand that, but I had understood in a previous class that Geshe la was saying that there’s more worldview transformation from the uncontrived thought of definite emergence. So if that’s the case, why would we spend our time contemplating wisdom realizing emptiness when the superior thought, if you like, What Geshe-la was saying is that indeed, when one gains a realization and one generates uncontrived definite emergence that is extraordinarily beneficial and one’s outlook changes dramatically. Whereas a mere realization of emptiness does not lead to that change of outlook. However, that realization of emptiness acts as a prelude to the attainment of a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. That is extraordinarily beneficial.

Okay. And? No. No. No.

You are second. I need. Okay. I don’t know where I got the idea from that you were teaching from the Prāsaṇgika viewpoint, but I I did have that idea. But Prāsaṇgika.

Prāsaṇgika viewpoint. But I was a bit confused because if I remember correctly, the coarse selflessness of persons for Prāsaṇgika is a substantially existing autonomous entity. They don’t really look at the permanent one and independent thing. So I was just wondering what perspective this teaching is being given from. No.

That is incorrect. It is not that in Prāsaṇgika, no reference is made to the person being empty of being permanent one and independent. There is a an ongoing debate about whether there is a difference of coarseness and subtlety in Prāsaṇgika between the person being permanent one, being empty of being permanent one and independent and the person being empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity. That’s a different topic. Then Geshe la would like to explain these topics incrementally because if he explains at once the ultimate Prāsaṇgika view, you will not understand it and there will be no benefit for you, whereas he thinks that you have understood the view of the person being empty of being permanent, one, and independent.

Okay. Geshe-la is absolutely delighted. You were able to identify within yourselves the apprehension of the person or the I as permanent one and independent. This is very far reaching. Geshe-la was very happy with your questions, especially those who pointed out that this apprehension is an imputed apprehension or an artificial apprehension and not an innate one.

There are indeed numerous texts which talk about this. But when you check within your mind, you do find an innate apprehension like this. That this is what we should be looking into. And then he would explain these topics step by step. Otherwise, no one will understand anything.

Okay. Please open the prayer book, page nine.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
tathagata de zhin sheg pa (Tib)
Epithet for a buddha; literally, “one who has gone to suchness.” LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top