1 h 32 min · 4,808 words · 2 August 2017
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains why meditation on death and impermanence is indispensable for practice on the paths of the small, middling and great scope, and how a higher rebirth remains within cyclic existence. It then turns to the twelve links and the five paths of the Sa Lam (grounds and paths), with a brief question and answer exchange on pervasive suffering and self-cherishing.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 32m
UUID: 17de93a8-948d-45cf-a84c-e0645a389639
Date: 2017-08-02
Words: 4,804
Mhmm. We frequently quote passages from the great beings of the past. And said in a verse, not only will we definitely die, but it is close. Then the first part of the verse, definitely we will die, refers to the first of these three roots in the meditation on death and impermanence. And probably, the second part of the verse, and it is close, refers to the fact that the time of death is uncertain.
And the second verse reads, if one does not train repeatedly, in the thought of death now if one does not train repeatedly in the thought of death means that it is profoundly meaningful to reflect on death. And therefore, it is profoundly meaningful to, recollect death. Why? Because at present, we have the possibility to do something about it. As was said last time, it is actually possible to abandon death, albeit this is very difficult for us at present.
But one thing is clear. If we do not think at all about death now, things are gonna get worse and worse. And at the time of death, it will not be possible to do anything about it. So the first two verses, therefore, read as follows. Death is certain and an addition is close.
If one does not train repeatedly in the thought of death, and the last two verses are then one will be unable to create a virtuous thought. And even should one do so, it will be overwhelmed by the perfections of this life. Now here, a virtuous thought refers to a virtuous motivation. And the final verse indicates that one will nonetheless be unable to have a pure motivation. And therefore, as is said, even should we should one be able to generate such a virtuous motivation, it will be overwhelmed by the pursuits of this life.
And we can see this very clearly. For instance, in cases of disease when one is sick and one tries to heal, then one is obsessed with the pursuits of this life. And for instance, Tibetans, let us say, offer long life pujas, engage in long life practices, long life initiations, and so forth, then probably this is totally, focused on this life. So, what therefore is necessary for our minds to focus or to engage, dharma? For our minds to focus or engage in dharma, it is indispensable to reflect on death.
For that matter, death is not merely indispensable to engage in the path shared with the being of the small scope, but it is indispensable to, engage in the path shared with the being of the middling and the great scope. Meditation on death is indispensable for all three. Then, we will take as a foundation or it will be a presupposition here that a majority of you believe in past and future lives. A majority of you believe in the existence of your own past and your own future lives. Then if you do not, it is very difficult to engage in any type of practice.
Geshe-la would be delighted to explain this in detail, but he suspects you won’t be interested. However, it is not sufficient to be convinced in the existence of past and future lives. This conviction must be based on reasoning, on logic. And then once such a conviction has arisen, definitely, there will be less fear at the time of death. And even now, one will try to focus one’s mind as much as possible on virtue.
To focus it totally on virtue is difficult, but as much as possible. And then at the time of death, death will be easier. Now, engaging in dharma, therefore, means studying as much as one can and putting this in practice. And as a result of this, one’s mind will become peaceful, and the afflictions will abate. This is what is meant by dharma.
It is not, however, sufficient to practice, let us say, the path shared with the being of the small scope and its various topics of meditation, one must practice purely. And to practice purely, one needs for every single of the topics of the past shared with the being of the small scope an awareness of death and impermanence. Without this awareness of one’s own death and impermanence, we just sit back in a state of sloth and laziness. And therefore, it is when one thinks every day, every week, every month, every year that one may be dying at any moment that one engages forcefully in practice. And engaging in practice is not like shifting a material object around the table.
It is a mental engagement. And here, it is extremely important to avoid mental distraction. In Geshe la’s own case, for instance, in the mornings, sometimes he tries to focus on a topic. But after ten minutes or so, the mind is distracted and it wanders off, let us say, for a minute. Once it wanders off, it is very difficult to bring it back on the topic.
For this reason, meditation on death and impermanence is very important. And when the mind is set single pointedly, actually, it engages single pointedly given topic whether by means of analytical meditation or concentration meditation, whatever, that may be the case, then, if the mind is not distracted, one’s progress will be quite rapid. If, however, the mind is scattered and, passes to the left, to the right, above, below, then finally, one achieves nothing and there is no difference. So it is this focus which enables us, for instance, to attain calm abiding even though that is quite difficult. Then for all of this, one needs time.
One needs time to study. One needs time to meditate. And it is precisely to free time that, one becomes ordained. This is a goal of ordination. Then, those who are laypeople, obviously, have responsibilities towards family, towards children, and they should fulfill those responsibilities, but they should also make space, make time for their practice.
Geshe-la does not believe that there is anyone in this room who has no time whatsoever. It is possible to make time. Time is the most important thing there is. Time, once wasted, can never be retrieved. You cannot buy time.
Therefore, do not waste time.
And therefore, we should, use the time we have wisely. And for this, we need this meditation on death and impermanence. Now if we take the path shared with the being of the small scope, then the main element of this path is ethics, which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues. Once we engage in such an ethics, we have decided it’s already decided that we will be reborn in a higher realm. It’s a given.
So why is this the case? Because if one has continually protected one’s ethics, then at the time of one’s death, one will look back on one’s life and think, I have done well for myself in this life. I have behaved correctly. And one will then be able to die in a virtuous frame of mind. Now what is important, as Geshe la mentioned several times, is also to take care of one’s health so that whatever one’s maximum lifespan, if I say, comically, one would be able to live one hundred years, one lives that long.
And at the end of that life, one dies as if one were falling asleep peacefully. Then with such a death, one is able to die in a virtuous frame of mind. And then if one, is ill, one should take whatever medicine one is supposed to take and be mindful of one’s health. Eat and drink in moderation. Take care of one’s health.
Then if one practices correctly, the path shared with the being of the small scope and protects one’s ethics, it is a given one will obtain a higher rebirth. And here, a higher rebirth is to be understood as a human rebirth. There are other higher rebirths like deva rebirth, which we shall not talk about. But at this point, even though one has obtained a higher rebirth, nonetheless, one is still in cyclic existence. And it is important here to understand the transition between the past shared with the being of the small and the past shared with the being of the middling scope.
Tsongkhapa says, you will still be in cyclic existence. This should not satisfy you. And this is why, Tsongkhapa says in Lam Rim Chenmo, and we have Lam Rim Chenmo now in an excellent English translation that even though one attains a higher rebirth, nonetheless, there is no certainty. There is no definiteness. One may, again, be reborn in the lower realms as a result of nonvirtuous karma, and one must strive for liberation from this.
Now when we speak of a higher rebirth, it is actually what we have obtained now. So what we can hope for in the future is something like what we have obtained now, a rebirth in the human race. Then there are different colors of skin, different colors of hair. Some people are white, some are black, some have yellow hair, some have black hair. But at the end of the day, it’s one and the same.
It is a human rebirth. So it’s quite odd, isn’t it, that with all the racial variations, some people are black, some are white, and this is obviously a result of individual karma. At the end of the day, all of us have exactly the same afflictions, desire, anger, ignorance, doubt, pride, and the afflictive view. Then there are differences in our predispositions for the various afflictions such as desire, anger, and so forth. But are there any differences regarding grasping at an I?
Then this is a notion you are familiar with. Obviously, the greater the grasping at an I, the greater the afflictions which arise as a result of it. So at present, we have obtained higher rebirth. And to obtain a higher rebirth in the future, we must generate contaminated virtuous karma. So contaminated karma is karma which is induced or impelled by the ignorance grasping at a self, and it is subdivided into two, contaminated virtuous karma, which causes a rebirth in the higher realms, and contaminated non virtuous karma, which causes a rebirth in the lower realms.
So being such as ourselves accumulate contaminated impelling karma. But there is a passage in the Lam Rim in which is it is said that even though Ārya beings no longer accumulate impelling karma, nonetheless, Ārya beings can accumulate non virtuous karma. What this non virtuous karma is what this non virtuous karma is is to be examined. So as is said, Ārya beings do not accumulate impelling karma which impels cyclic existence because in keeping with the famous quote, one who has seen the truth is no longer impelled. Nonetheless, Ārya beings can accumulate non virtuous karma, which is not impelling karma.
Now what exactly this non virtuous karma and how it is accumulated, is something we must investigate. Do you understand? So what do you think about it? So we’re saying that Ārya beings can accumulate non virtuous karma. How?
It’s just a experiential observation, but sometimes you have the urge to do something generous in the moment when it’s appropriate at the time, and it feels very pure, and it’s nothing to do with you. But you have the means to do it, and so you you do it, and it kind of, has a certain feeling of of love. It’s spontaneous. Would that be how? Okay.
No rush. So none of this can be engaged in at once or rapidly. Initially, one must study carefully the path shared with the being of the small scope, and then we must investigate the mode of accumulation of karma, and this is addressed at the level of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, specifically within the presentation of the 12 limbs. Twirlings, you know, very important. And this is why Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen will be teaching on the 12 limbs during the long October weekend this year.
Please come because when one understands the 12 limbs, one understands what psychic existence is and how it operates. Mhmm. Yeah. Very important. 12 links.
You know? So an Ārya being has found liberation. So they know Has what? An Ārya being has found liberation, so they have no longer developing the faults through ignorance grasping in itself, but they can develop, a calm non virtuous karma through self cherishing. You’re thinking about it the right way, but have not necessarily attained liberation.
So this is more part of Salam. The attainment of liberation occurs at the level of the path of no more learning. So for this discussion, we will take as a basis Hīnayāna Ārya beings who have not attained liberation, in other words. There. If I remember correctly, we have contact, and then we have feeling or sensation.
And then on that basis, desire arises. And from memory, I think it’s the difference between desire and appropriation. And so it’s if I remember, an REB can still experience desire, but it doesn’t it doesn’t what would be the right word? It doesn’t become appropriation, which would be the impelling aspect of the car. You’re talking with the 12 limbs, are you?
So Geshele is asking about the mode of accumulation of non virtuous karma in ārya beings. The Lam Rim says, even though Ārya beings can accumulate non virtuous karma, they do not accumulate nonvirtuous impelling karma, which causes a rebirth in other words. You understand? Right? Thought the impelling component might might relate specifically to the appropriation aspect.
No. No. Impelling means rebirth. So impelling karma is karma which causes a rebirth. Now impending karma is therefore karma which is a part of the 12 limbs.
That means it is karma which arises in dependence on the ignorance grasping at a self. Now because ārya beings have the direct realization of selflessness, they no longer, are able to or no longer accumulate karma in dependence on the ignorance
It’s grasping at the self. But the says they still accumulate non virtuous karma. As Vasubandhu says in Abhidharma Kosha, once one has seen truth, there is no impelling. So this is the foundation of that that position. What I was getting at with the appropriation was they may not continue to appropriate their own aggregate, but they still may have latent potencies of desire that may arise.
And so negative karma might be accumulated on the basis of that manifestation of the latent potencies of desire, but not necessarily on appropriation of their own aggregates since they realize that they are So one thing is clear that’s very good, that, ārya beings have virtuous and non virtuous karmic imprints in their mind streams. So if a Hīnayāna being on the path of seeing has direct realization of emptiness and they still have afflictions within their mind stream, then under those afflictions, they can accumulate negative karma. But no longer impelling karma. Just Okay. To understand the 12 limbs correctly, one must study Sa Lam grounds and paths.
Then we had already covered Sa Lam grounds and paths here at TBI. Geshe la taught it very extensively. You might want to cover the material again. It seems to be very fleeting. You seem to confuse Aryas and Arhats.
We have the three vehicles. Yeah. Yeah. Right? So the vehicle of hearer, of solitary realizers, and of bodhisattvas.
The two first vehicles are the Hīnayāna. The last vehicle is the Mahāyāna. Each of these three vehicles is divided in five paths. Right? So we have the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, and normal learning.
Right? So we have three vehicles in five paths. Within those three vehicles, any being who attains the path of seeing the third path is called an ārya being. But in none of those vehicles is a being on the path of seeing an arhat. In the two first vehicles, when the ārya being attains a fifth path, the path of no more learning, He has attained he or she has attained liberation, and he is called an.
It’s very beautiful, the presentation of Salam. Very beautiful. Very good. Very important. You know?
It’s both beautiful and important. Yeah. So the reason for which this is very important, the reason for which salam is very important is that when we meditate, we might suddenly wonder, well, have I attained the path of accumulation or not? And if we have studied salam, we know the answer. We can say yes or no.
And then we can analyze our attainments and say, yes, I have attained the path of accumulation. Yes, it seems that I have generated an uncontrived, mind of definite emergence. In other words, a continuous mind of definite emergence. We know where we are. Then, to enter the, Mahāyāna vehicle, we must generate, uncontrived bodhicitta.
At that point, we have entered the path of accumulation. That does not mean that we have gained a realization of emptiness. Those who have gained a realization of emptiness at that point are on the path of preparation. And then one progresses upwards during the remaining four paths. Then just in the last month, his holiness Dalai Lama in Ladakh declared his own attainments.
He said he had generated bodhicitta, which means, you understand that he’s on the path of accumulation, and that he had realized emptiness, but that he still had to focus on training, in calm abiding. And when he did, then he would attain the path of preparation. Then, in our cases, what is missing is obviously meditation. So we must meditate, and then we must link our meditation with what what we study and rely on our teachers. Then, obviously, if we don’t, there is a risk of attaining all sorts of attainments no one has ever had before.
So it is extremely important for us as, Rinpoche, Khensur Rinpoche said, relying on Pabongka Rinpoche’s liberation in the palm of your hand to first generate understanding and gain experience and for the two to be linked. So we must, therefore, generate minds arisen from hearing, from thinking, and from meditation. Initially, we must generate a mind arisen from hearing through listening and studying. And then we must generate minds arisen from thinking which are valid cognizers focused on what we have understood. At this point, we have to blend, to mix that understanding with our minds.
This is the wisdom arisen from meditation. So based on what his holiness said, once, he has trained in calm abiding, he will attain the path of preparation. Now at that point, he will have induced a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. This is an extremely stable mind. And as a result, it is difficult to see how the afflictions could arise.
Therefore, one would no longer give rise probably to, impelling karma, for the lower rebirth. Then once one has attained the path of preparation, obviously, one moves onwards to the path of seeing, and there are clear scriptural passages corroborating that at the level of the path of seeing, there are no afflictions. Specifically, those who have seen truth no longer are impelled. Then that would be marvelous for us since those states of mind would be present even in sleep. So this is really quite marvelous.
We should be delighted when we think about this sort of attainment. And then we should try to attain them based on reasoning. Mhmm. Be attained. Right?
And there’s not a lot of hope if you sleep. Now, one moves at present upwards to the path of the being of the middling scope. And during the path of the being of the middling scope, one focuses on defects. Which defects? Specifically, those defective aspects of the four noble truths, I e, first and foremost, the truth of suffering.
Then you may have received teachings on the noble truth of suffering. The truth of suffering is subdivided into three. Three, We have the suffering of suffering. We have, the suffering of change and or pervasive suffering. So within these three sufferings, the suffering of suffering is self evident.
It doesn’t call for any commentary. Animals can identify it clearly. As to the suffering of change, a good example would be if someone stares at us and says, you are really obese. Then at this point, we have a clear understanding of what the suffering of change is. Now this is specifically the suffering the mental suffering of change.
For instance, in cases when, in reality, we are not that fat, and after all, no one likes to be fat either. All of us like soft and sweet words. Then when we encounter harsh words, immediately, we feel uncomfortable. Why? Why?
Unkind words, after all, don’t affect our body. It’s not like a thief who’s stealing our possessions or someone who beats us up. So why exactly do they make us so upset? There’s this literature called transactional analysis, and I think it’s really insightful because it has this idea that when we’re a small child, we try to make sense of reality. And after we’ve had a lot of suffering, we believe that we’re not okay.
And we but we believe that other people are. And this is normal unless you’re a psychopathic child and then you believe you’re okay and nobody else is. But this this belief that you’re not okay is persistent because that’s how we make sense of us suffering at a tiny age. And I think that idea of not being okay persists, and that’s why we’re in pain when that idea is confirmed back to us.
Mhmm. So here, when we are speaking of, the mental suffering of change, we’re referring to mental suffering. And mental suffering ex inflicts tremendous hardship as much as it can, doesn’t it? Mhmm. And it’s forced to examine as best we can how it arises.
So, obviously, our hand is not being pierced. It is not being cut. We’re not being struck. So why exactly is mental suffering so in supportable? So, obviously, here, the root to self cherishing, we have tremendous self cherishing egoism, if you wish.
And then even if everyone, a 100% of the people surrounding us told us we were wrong, we were in the wrong, then this self cherishing means that we cling to our own situation. As self cherishing is reduced, these difficulties disappear. Obviously, ideally, we would abandon it, but then we would be enlightened. So I think we all understand this, that this links to self cherishing is evident to all of us. Do you understand?
Now moving onwards to the third subdivision of suffering all pervasive suffering. This is a topic Geshe-la has not explained previously, but he will explain a bit at present. All pervasive suffering is in Tibetan. And here, it is at the level of the attainment of the state of an of that one abandons or pervasive suffering. Once one has abandoned or pervasive suffering, one has attained the state of an.
How do you identify all pervasive suffering? What do you think it is? What is meant by pervasive here? Yep. Okay.
Okay. Okay. So as is said in Buddhist text, all pervasive suffering is the suffering which causes one under the power of karma and the afflictions to take rebirth in cyclic existence over and over again. This is the meaning of pervasive. So there are numerous commentaries on and the range involved.
So here, it is through understanding the thoughts of all pervasive sufferings that suffering that in turn one understands the thoughts of its origin, which is karma and afflictions. And through understanding the thoughts of karma and affliction, one then gives rise to the mind which wishes to abandon their root, which is the ignorance grasping at a self, in dependence on which one accumulates both virtuous and non virtuous karma causing rebirth in cyclic existence, as Ārya Nāgārjuna said. So if you say that these aggregates are all pervasive suffering, it’s obviously wrong because at death, they are incinerated. So, obviously, our body intersects with the contaminated aggregates, which act as a substantial cause, but it does not include them. This body of ours arises in dependence on the spermatozoa of our fathers of our father and the ovum of our mother.
Then for so long as we have not abandoned, all pervasive suffering for so long will we continue to transmigrate in cyclic existence. So the 12 limbs have begun, haven’t they? One must be able to identify the 12 limbs. So it is extremely important, therefore, for us to study the 12 limbs. And if we do so, that’ll be quite extraordinary.
Let us therefore generate at present during a couple of minutes a motivation to benefit others, and then we will recite the prayers. Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b, two, three, and four. Also page five, number six, number seven, offering verse one and three. So in brief, once one has attained an Ārya path, in other words, once one is an Ārya, although one still is reborn in cyclic existence under the power of karma and affliction, nonetheless, one is no longer reborn in cyclic existence under the power of impelling karma.
Being reborn in cyclic existence under the power of karma and affliction ceases when one attains a state of an because at that point, one has definitely eliminated the limb of craving.
So once one has attained the state of an, then one continues to be reborn under the power of karma and affliction simply because one has accumulated karmic imprints from when one was an ordinary being, and these can and will mature. However, one will never be reborn in the lower realms. One will only be reborn in higher realms. One abandons being reborn under the power of karma and affliction upon the attainment of the state of an arhat because at that point, one has abandoned the root of craving. It would be good one day, to focus again on Salam on grounds and paths because it is indispensable to understand the 12 limbs.
Then without focusing on salam, there is no point in Geshe la’s talking of the path of seeing and of meditation since, you would all get confused. But unless you understand salam, you will not be able to understand the distinction. But before we do this, it would be very helpful if you could become familiar with the basics of Sa Lam, the existence of the five paths, the path of accumulation, of preparation, of seeing, of meditation, of normal learning, the fact that an ārya being has attained the third path, the path of seeing that an arhat is a being who is on the path of no more learning, and what the boundaries, the junctions are between the various paths. Just one question, please. So think from your own side about how one accumulates karma and how one transmigrates in psychic existence, and you can ask your questions later.
Mhmm. But now just one question. So yeah. Was saying about all pervasive suffering is suffering which causes one under the power of karma and afflictions to take rebirth in psychic existence over and over again. By that definition, it seems to be the same thing as the ignorance grasping at a self.
There is a difference. All pervasive suffering is that process of taking over and again, rebirth in cyclic existence, but its root is ignorance grasping at itself. So in our own cases, we have taken rebirth many times in the past in cyclic existence. And unless we abandon the ignorance grasping at itself, we will continue to take rebirth in cyclic existence. This is the pervasive component of all pervasive suffering.
So, you could also say cyclic existence since there is no substantial difference between cyclic existence and all pervasive suffering. Have you question? I’m referring to the links between just now, you say somebody is talking harshly to you, and then you got the self cherishing arising. And the I had got the self cherishing. Is it the same?
Would an Arhat also have self cherishing. That self cherishing is not the same or is not similar to the one in the mind of someone to whom harsh words are addressed and whom as a result of that has a troubled or disturbed mind. If you were to address such harsh words to an arhat, his mind would not be disturbed. Okay. Thank you.
Yes. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.