Lam Rim – 2016-05-04 – KR

1 h 31 min · 3,919 words · 4 May 2016

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2016-05-04 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching explains that bodhicitta sustains the Mahayana and, through the four noble truths, the Hinayana, and that great compassion, which is rooted in renunciation, is the basis of bodhicitta. It presents two methods for generating bodhicitta, the sevenfold causal instruction and equalizing and exchanging self and others, and describes how self-cherishing and afflictions block compassion. The recording ends with a question and answer session.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 31m

UUID: ddbd4167-973e-4ef8-9fe0-b733cd4cbbf6

Date: 2016-05-04

Words: 3,915

So as is said in very potent verses of these three principles of the path that which is not upheld by uncontrived definite emergence will not become a cause for liberation. These are very profound words indeed. Hence, the intelligent, those with a mind generate bodhichitta. In other words, without staying at the level of hearers or solitary realizers, those who are intelligent generate bodhichitta within their mind streams. In other words, once one has generated uncontrived definite emergence for so long as that uncontrived definite emergence is not upheld by a motivation of bodhichitta for so long, it will not become a cause for full enlightenment.

These are particularly meaningful words for us if we study the Lamrim and this is why the practice of the intelligent must be upheld by bodhichitta. There are numerous modes of generation of bodhichitta and motivations for generating it. One of which is to be unable to support the setting of the Mahāyāna. Now clearly if the Mahāyāna were to set, were to disappear, then likewise the vehicles of the hearers and the solitary realizers would disappear as well. So you might wonder how is it the case that should the Mahāyāna set as a result the vehicles of the hearers and the solitary realizers, in other words the Hīnayāna will set as well.

This is a case because the vehicles of the hearers and of the solitary realizers are taught by a supreme emanation body. So if the vehicle, the great vehicle or if the teachings of the Mahāyāna, this is synonymous, were to set, what would this mean? Well, the criterion for the existence or the non existence of the Mahāyāna within our mind stream is the presence or the absence of bodhichitta. This is the criterion. And the criterion for the existence or the non existence of the great vehicle in general is the presence or the absence of bodhichitta.

If bodhichitta is absent and the great vehicle has set. Now, what in your opinion would be the criterion for the existence or the non existence of the Hīnayāna or if you prefer the vehicle of the heroes and the solitary realizers, the two are synonymous. So therefore as mentioned, the existence or the non existence of the great vehicle is contingent on the existence or non existence of fully characterized bodhichitta. Now, what is the criterion for the existence or non existence of the Hīnayāna? If you have an answer, please give a quick answer.

No, obviously. So obviously, obviously the Hīnayāna is linked with definite emergence but the crux is the existence or non existence of the four noble truths. So uncontrived renunciation must exist for sure but that which is practiced is the four noble truth. So I think we can say the existence or the non existence of the four noble truth is a criterion for the existence or the non existence of the vehicle of the hearers and the solitary realizers. Therefore, for so long as bodhichitta has not degenerated, has not set, then for so long the teachings of the Hīnayāna on the Four Noble Truths will be present.

Since the cause of bodhichitta is great compassion and great compassion itself is rooted in uncontrived renunciation which is intimately linked with the four noble truths. For so long as bodhichitta is present, teachings of the four noble truths will be present as well. And therefore we have the presentation of the benefits of the generation of bodhichitta, one of which is that the state of full enlightenment becomes closer. Then clearly, if bodhichitta is something which is unable to be generated, then in turn there is a degeneration of the Hīnayāna. Now should bodhichitta no longer be able to be generated or there’d be no interest in this, then one would be restricted to the vehicles of the hearer and the solitary realizers and the attainment of the state of Arhathood.

And once the state of Ahad Hood is attained, it is very difficult to move away from it because of the extraordinary bliss associated with arhathood. One stays in this state for thousands and thousands of years. There is therefore a very great danger in this approach. Therefore as I said in the Lamrim, one should hold bodhichitta as one’s innermost jewel. Then here, how should one practice?

One should train in all of the components of the path. For instance, if initially one were to generate a motivation of bodhichitta and then in keeping with the Lamrim one were to meditate on the four noble truths focusing exclusively on the attainment of liberation, then one’s scope would dwindle dramatically and the result of this practice would probably be none other than liberation. For this reason, it is said in the Lamrim that it is important that one’s practice be upheld throughout by bodhichitta and upheld here means that it is under the sway of or under the power of bodhichitta. So when we speak of bodhichitta, what are we talking about? We are talking about a motivation which wishes to lead all sentient beings to full enlightenment.

To be more precise, we’re talking of a motivation which wishes to lead all beings which are capable of doing so to full enlightenment. In other words, to their own liberation. This is what is understood by bodhichitta. So when we say that bodhichitta is rooted in great compassion, what do we mean by great compassion? The wish for all sentient beings, all persons, all beings to be free from suffering.

Now for this wish to arise, we must be close to beings. If we are not close to them, how can such a wish arise? So this closeness is a mental closeness. And when we speak of a mental closeness, a closeness at the level of consciousness, this means that even if the person is far away, let’s say in America, we feel close to that person. Important, isn’t it?

Then on the other hand, it’s obvious that just being physically close to someone, for one’s body to be close to someone does not mean that we are close, does it? It’s important and it’s something you should study and think about. So for this mental closeness to beings to exist, what is needed? Great compassion. When we have great compassion, we are close to all sentient beings.

Then to give you an example, it is like a mother who has an only child. She doesn’t have many children, could be a father as well, but she or she the mother or the father has one child alone. Then such a mother is always thinking about her child, isn’t she? And this is just an example to give you a sense of what the generation of great compassion is. When we have great compassion, we are constantly preoccupied and close to sentient beings, to all sentient beings.

If you take our case in this temple, we are all huddled up close together in this temple, so we are physically very close. But we are not mentally close with each other, are we? Then what do we have to do to be mentally close with each other? It’s an easy question. I’m asking you what’s the reason for which we don’t have it?

What is the incompatible condition interfering with great compassion? Afflictions in other words. Anger, the jealousy, the envy which all arise out of self cherishing, out of egoism. So we are far removed from each other mentally due to the afflictions which arise out of the anger generated by egoism and by self cherishing. This is why we are completely unable to create or to generate great compassion.

So what this means is that once we are able to generate great compassion, then we will feel close, mentally close to all beings on this earth, all 7,000,000,000 human beings on this earth and whichever one of them we meet, we will naturally feel close to that person. And then once we have generated love, compassion and bodhichitta, then the afflictions under the sway of anger which arise out of self cherishing will no longer be able to dwell for long within our minds. And when they arise, they will subside rapidly. I am not saying that in dependence on bodhichitta we are able to abandon the afflictions. Then as a result of generating bodhichitta, great compassion and love within our mind streams, these bitter afflictions, jealousy, spite, competitiveness which have arisen from an anger rooted in self cherishing will no longer arise easily within our mind streams and instead of having twisted, uptight faces, we will have open, smiling, friendly faces, laughing at all times.

Then we can see a living example of this in His Holiness the Dalai Lama who at the ripe old age of 81, whenever he meets someone whether this is someone who is highly placed in society or a simple person from the streets always has the same smiling friendly mien. How different this is from us who have a smiling friendly mien when we meet our teachers and a twisted face otherwise. Then once we are able to generate these states of mind, love, compassion and bodhichitta, our minds will be at peace. And as a result of this mental peace, our health will be also stable and we can see this with great beings like Khensur Lobsang Paldhen and so forth. Khensur Lobsang Paldhen now is entering into his fifth day of tukdam after his death and his body remains intact and this is due to the steady practice of bodhichitta, emptiness and so forth.

So this is why we should generate within our mind streams love, compassion and bodhichitta and if we do this, there will be no place within our mind streams for indolence. On the other hand, if we are unable to satisfy our desire for worldly affairs, then since there is no end to worldly affairs, we will never experience this. There is therefore food for thought regarding bodhichitta and great compassion since they can counter the afflictions and as a result, we should endeavor to generate them. Egoism is a huge force within us, deep within us, isn’t it? Self cherishing and this is why the Kadampas of yore said, take revenge on only one.

Who is the one we take revenge on? The source of all our hardship and difficulties, egoism. And therefore it is critically important to apply the antidotes to the afflictions. Then, I and myself am ordained. So if we apply the antidotes to the afflictions, this is a benefit.

Otherwise, if we do not apply the antidotes to the afflictions, there is no point at all in being ordained. And I think about myself in the same way. It is silly to think that just through taking novice vows, our mind is going to change, our mind does not change as a result of receiving monastic vows. Our mind changes as a result of the application of the antidotes to the afflictions and therefore this is what we should do. Otherwise taking vows is pointless.

So very important you know. Then if on the base of being ordained, our outlook has not changed in the slightest, then this is absolutely pointless. Instead we have to elevate our outlook. So therefore what is the purpose of ordination? The purpose of ordination is to train in contentment regarding our lot, regarding whatever happiness we have.

And then on the basis of this contentment, we can put great effort in our studies. In so doing, we increase the wisdom acquired through hearing but this is insufficient. We should also train in the wisdom acquired through thinking and through meditation. This is the goal of ordination, its purpose. Then at present I can see most of us are not beset by coarse afflictions because as I don’t have to teach in English, can observe people’s faces and I see that your faces are not all twisted.

Then if all of us could put the amount of effort which Tenzin Lhamo and Tenzin Drolkar are putting, that will be remarkable. Effort in what? Effort at targeting the afflictions which are the true enemy. We always seem to think that our enemies are exterior to us but our true enemies are interior enemies and this is why Arhat in Tibetan is the foe destroyer. Then one who is ordained is someone who has generated an ethics, a renunciation from definite emergence and as a result of this sadness at the thought of psychic existence is and is aiming for the attainment of liberation.

If that is not our goal and if one’s way of thinking is completely unchanged, why become ordained? So what is the reason therefore for which we are unable to generate bodhichitta within our mind streams because we are unable to generate its cause, great compassion. Why are we unable to generate its cause? Because of the afflictions. Why in turn are we unable to generate, or why are we unable to counter the afflictions?

We are unable to counter them because we lack altruism. We lack cherishing others. And we lack altruism because of our own egoism, our own self cherishing. So how do we generate bodhichitta in this case through the interchange of self and others? And therefore, let us at present to generate the motivation, meditate on the benefits of bodhichitta, and during this period of meditation, let us dedicate the merits from the meditation to first Khensur Lobsang Paldhen who has left us for five days, as well as to the mother of your translator who departed six days ago.

Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b two three four and also page five number six, mandala offering, verse one and three. So now regarding the mode of generation of uncontrived or fully characterized bodhichitta, there are two famous modes of generation. The first is the sevenfold causal instruction and the second is the instruction of the interchange of self, excuse me, the instruction of the equalization and the interchange of self and others. So the sevenfold causal instruction is one which can be traced back Buddha Śākyamūni himself.

It was transmitted to Candrakīrti, to Acharya Chandragomin and down to us. Whereas the instruction of the equalization and the interchange of self and others was transmitted downwards from Buddha Śākyamūni through Ārya Nāgārjuna and Śāntideva to us. These instructions were both transmitted by Suvarnadvipi to Atisha and downwards from Atisha to Geshe Potowa, Geshe Charawa and Geshe Chekawa. And during this period the sevenfold cause and instruction was the public one. It is at the time of Geshe Chekhawa that the oral instruction of the equalization in the interchange of self and others was for the first time made public.

Until then it had been secret and the main reason seems to have been the widespread suffering due to leprosy at the period of Geshe Chekawa. It was thought this instruction would help to cure that. And as a result, numerous works of mind training were composed of the equalization and the interchange of self and others such as the sevenfold verses of mind training and so forth. Leprosy was extremely widespread at the period in Tibet and caused tremendous suffering as you can well imagine. And it was thought that through disseminating the instruction on the equalization and the interchange of self and others, practitioners could take upon themselves the suffering of lepers and give their happiness to them.

And since leprosy as a disease is the karmic maturation of previous non virtues, then the lepers who trained in this way would purify their previous non virtuous karma and this would help in the healing process. So the practice of the equalization and the interchange of self and others is subdivided into five outlines. The first is a practice of equanimity. The second is reflecting through numerous ways on the thoughts of egoism or self cherishing. The third is reflecting in numerous ways on the qualities of altruism or cherishing others.

The fourth is the actual thought of interchanging self and others. And the fifth is the way in dependence on that to train in giving and taking or Tonglen. So the first outline equanimity is actually something which Valens asked a question about. What is meant here by equanimity? It is quite straightforward.

All of us without one single exception are equal, in other words there’s no difference between us in wishing for happiness and in not wishing for suffering. Nobody wishes for suffering, even though suffering can arise within our mind streams. Then you have the famous stanza in the prayer of the Lamrim, of the Lama Chöpa, the first verses read, No one wishes even the slightest suffering and everyone is insatiable in their pursuit of happiness. Bless me to understand that myself and others are equal. So this is a presentation of equanimity.

We will stop here tonight and if you have questions, please ask your questions. One question per person. What happens is that such practitioners have during their life a very stable and powerful intent and practice and then when the coarse minds dissolve and they enter in the subtle states of consciousness, then that intent remains in the subtle consciousness. And that is what maintains them in that state. There is nothing else.

Then there is no way someone like myself could say, I intend for Rinpoche to stay in that state. That would be impossible. Great, you understand? Really? Not entirely, so does the body just No, there is no smell and no decay.

What happens is that the heat withdraws from the extremities upwards to the heart. Then once the smell of decay rises then we’re all the same. But in Tokdam, is no smell, no decay. Really? Yeah, exactly.

How could there be a smell of decay in tukdam? Sorry. Could I clarify the question I asked yesterday? I think what I really would like to know is today you also mentioned again, delusions are the true enemy. External objects are not a true enemy.

Where is this realization generated? Is it generated at a level of the second noble truth, which is the origin of suffering? So as is said, how could the striving for liberation occur without putting effort at understanding the noble truth of suffering? It is once one understands the suffering of the contaminated aggregates that the striving for liberation occurs. So to answer to your question in brief, it is this realization of the noble truth of suffering which generates this.

Then we can see that exterior enemies are not real enemies because however fierce our exterior enemies might be, if we are kind with them and we court them, then over time they will soften and will become our friends after all they’re not crazy, right? Then with our interior enemies such as anger or let’s say jealousy, the more we befriend them and court them, the fiercer they become. They do not attenuate, they become worse. So these are our true enemies and this is what Śāntideva says in Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara and we all have direct experience of this. The true enemy is that one.

Yep. It’s Jamie. You were talking about being close to beings for this to arise, which is compassion, and you’re talking this closest is a mental closeness. I’m just wondering if you can sort of elaborate more on that concept of mental closeness to even to people. So what is meant by that is that however far removed we are from that person, we feel, we experience with them if you wish.

We feel close to them mentally. Could I just get clarification please on the term Mahāyāna sets? If Mahāyāna was to set, was to stop, does it mean decline? And are we referring to the Mahāyāna mind or the Mahāyāna teachings? Like Mahayanists or the Mahāyāna teachings?

So when we speak of the setting, it’s like the setting of the sun. The setting of the Mahāyāna, it means the degeneration of the Mahāyāna. So when we speak of Mahāyāna and the Mahāyāna mind, they are different. Mahāyānist specifically refers to a person. The Mahāyāna mind is bodhichitta.

A person and a mind are different. Another. Mckenzie. Amanda. I have a bit of an anecdotal sort of question.

I think it’s a question. I thought I after Geshela taught on the topic of closeness a few weeks ago, I tried to experience this and bring that practice into my own life. And that there there’s a person in my life who we sort of have gone in different directions mainly because of different ethics. And I thought that I would try and apply it to that relationship. And what it what it resulted in really was a whole bunch of afflictions arising on both of our parts, which were absent certainly for me before.

Yeah. So that I just I guess the question I yeah. What does Geshe think about that? When Geshe talked about what? I didn’t understand the word you said.

Geshe taught about? What what does he think about that? That situation that all of these afflictions arise as a result of trying to achieve this mental closeness? So these discordances of view, discordances of outlook, they arise from strong self cherishing, from strong egoism Where one side says, well I think like this and the other side says, well I think like this and the first side says, well you are wrong and the other side says, well no, you are wrong. And then as a result, great quarrels arise.

So the key here is on both sides to reduce egoism and self cherishing and then happiness is a long time coming. Then it is difficult to meet someone who has exactly the same viewpoint as you, who has exactly the same outlook as you. So if you’re looking for happiness over one human life, then when difficulties arise in one given day, keep quiet and then the difficulties they will fade and the other party will also look at it the same way. Kappa, microphone. Does Tonglen equal compassion?

Tonglen Yes. Equal compassion? Compassion is a part of It has two components, the training in compassion and the training in love. So when we wish for all the suffering of sentient beings to ripen on us and free them, that is compassion. When we wish to give them all our happiness and all our roots of virtue, that is love.

Kesha, when you talk about mental closeness, does that account for how when we’re close to someone we can know they’re dying or sick or in trouble even though they’re at the other side of the world? Or is that something totally different? What is true is that as a result of mental closeness, we experience different feelings which arise from that mental closeness. It’s a condition of mental closeness. So however here what you are talking about is biased mental closeness.

The mental closeness we feel for mothers, for children, for relatives. However, in the context of the generation of great compassion, when we speak of mental closeness to all beings, we are referring to an unbiased mental closeness which is not an innate mental closeness, but which arises through effort and through study.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
tukdam
A state of meditation in which a great spiritual master with deep insight into emptiness remains absorbed in clear light after their death. The meditative absorption may last for days, weeks or months. Read more about tukdam here. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is Tonglen the same as compassion?

Not exactly. Compassion is a part of Tonglen, which has two components: the training in compassion and the training in love. The compassion part is wishing that all the suffering of sentient beings would ripen on us, so that they are freed from it. The love part is wishing to give them all our happiness and all our roots of virtue.

Scroll to Top