Lam Rim – 2016-04-26 – KR

1 h 11 min · 3,448 words · 26 April 2016

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2016-04-26 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Explains how one enters the path of accumulation, defined as a sapience upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, and how one progresses through its small, middling and great levels. The progression depends on the Four Noble Truths, on realizing emptiness through analysis, and on combining calm abiding with insight into emptiness. The talk ends with questions and small-group discussion.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 12m

UUID: f80a4d1e-e55a-490d-abad-84f7155035ce

Date: 2016-04-26

Words: 3,444

So the mind of bodhichitta is the gateway to the Mahāyāna. The reason for which it is the gateway to the Mahāyāna is that its presence within one’s mind stream is a criterion for one having entered the Mahāyāna. Then I suspect you know what the gateway to liberation is. The question arises when one enters the path liberation, what qualities must one generate within one’s mind stream? What is precisely generated within one’s mind stream?

Do you have an answer to this question? Angel? Yes. The sort of definite emergence. So you answered precisely.

There is however a difference between definite emergence and the thought of definite emergence. Definite emergence precisely is the noble truth of cessation. The thought of definite emergence is a motivation. So here it is the uncontrived thought of definite emergence which must be generated as Je Tsongkhapa said, once this sort of definite emergence is generated, etc. Then broadly speaking, one can say that when an uncontrived thought of definite emergence has been generated, one has entered the path leading to liberation.

However, if we analyze carefully, things become somewhat more complicated. As you remember, the definition of a path is a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Why the distinction between that definition and mere uncontrived definite emergence? What is added by upheld by a thought of uncontrived or an uncontrived thought of definite emergence? What is added is a distinction which arises when a being aims to enter the Mahāyāna path.

Such a being would indeed generate uncontrived definite emergence but immediately thereafter will generate great compassion and the great intent which give rise to the mind of the Mahāyāna and cause him to enter into the Mahāyāna path. So broadly speaking, it is appropriate to say that once one has generated uncontrived or a uncontrived sort of definite emergence, one will have entered the path leading to liberation. But for those who study and it is important to study and to analyze carefully, things become more delicate. The question arises regarding a being who enters directly the Mahāyāna. Now, such a being to enter directly the Mahāyāna must generate bodhichitta.

To generate bodhichitta, he or she must previously have generated great compassion. And to generate great compassion, he or she must have generated the preliminary to great compassion, which is uncontrived definite emergence, an uncontrived sort of definite emergence. So let us take the case of a hearer. The goal of a hearer is the attainment of liberation for his own sake. This is the object of attainment.

And the motivation is uncontrived definite emergence. Now, when uncontrived definite emergence has been generated within the mind of a person aspiring to be a hearer, has that person at that point entered the path or not? The path is defined as a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. So what precisely would be this sapience upheld by such a thought? It would be for instance, reflection or meditation on the four noble truths within the mind of a person aspiring to be a hearer once such an uncontrived thought of definite emergence has been generated.

Then such a being would have entered the path of a hearer. Then it’s really very very pleasant to think about things in these terms. Now I am aware that this is quite difficult for you. Obviously, many of our students are lay people who must work, must take care of family, relatives, children and for those who are ordained the situation is very different. The totality of one’s time should be dedicated to study and to meditation.

And obviously, we have received many teachings. However, the problem is after having received many teachings, one must change, one must transform the mind and this is not easy, this calls for repeated reflection. It is said that one cannot attain the first ground without the wisdom arisen from hearing. Now I am not saying that it is impossible for you to attain the first ground, but I am saying that it is difficult. So you should try to generate courage.

I’m fully aware of the fact that you must take care of children, relatives, that you must work. But you should put effort in your studies and generate joy at the thought that you are able to study. Then myself and the two anagarikas are ordained. So this is something we should do all the time nonstop. Then way back forty or some years ago when I was a child, conditions were very harsh and after we finished work by day, I think it was the Chinese, there was no light of any type, there were no normal lights of any type and there was constant streams of Chinese conversation being broadcast.

Then this is really something which induces great indolence. Then we were exposed by the elders to relentless streams of Maoist propaganda and the great deeds of Mao Tse Tung were explained to us. So the focus, the topic of the path of the being shared with the being of the building scope is definite emergence And the object of attainment of the path of the being of the building scope is, or excuse me, the object of the path of the being of the building scope is the four noble truths which are that which the mind of definite emergence focuses upon. The topic of the path of the being of the great scope is bodhichitta. Now at that level, there is less of a focus on the four noble truths and the object of attainment is full enlightenment.

At the level however of the path of the being of the small scope, the main topic is an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues and the object of attainment is a higher rebirth. The problem which arises is obviously that there is no definiteness in this matter. There is no definiteness in the attainment of such an object of attainment at the level of the path of the being of the small scope. And in this respect, there is food for thought with the difference of the practice of the being of the middling and of the great scope. Now once one has entered the path, in other words, once one has generated a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, one will enter the path at the level of the path of accumulation.

The path of accumulation is subdivided into three. The small, middling and greater path of accumulation and one enters at the level of the small path of accumulation. So such a being will be a being of the small path of accumulation. And the mind or the consciousness of such a being will be the small path of accumulation which is focused on the four noble truths in the order of appropriation and rejection. So at present, how does one progress from the small level of the path of accumulation to the middling level of the path of accumulation?

It may help you to remember what was taught during the long Easter weekend on the 37 facets of enlightenment. As you remember, the four recollections or the four close placements of recollection are present from the level of the small path of accumulation upwards. Whereas the four thorough abandonments are only present from the middling level of the path of accumulation upwards. So as was said, therefore within the seven fold subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment, the first, the close placement of recollection is present at the level of the small path of accumulation. And the second, the four thorough abandonments are present from the second level of the path of accumulation, in other words, the middling level of the path of accumulation upwards.

Now, the four several abandonments in brief are nothing else than an abandonment of non virtue and a training in virtue. But here, when we speak of an abandonment of virtue and a training in virtue, the focus remains on the four noble truths. Since beings which have entered the path are exclusively focused upon attaining their attainment. And this attainment can be attained through training in the Four Noble Truths. And therefore, they focus on the first Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of suffering, in other words, in brief psychic existence, its causes, which are the afflictions such as one’s mind being under the sway of anger, and the actual root of the afflictions, which is the ignorance grasping at a self, as well as the antidote to this ignorance, which is the noble truth of the path, or the wisdom realizing emptiness.

This leads ultimately to the noble truth of cessation. Now at the level of the second subdivision of the path of accumulation, the middling level, this level is if you wish suffused or pervaded with meditation on emptiness. Now, as soon as let us say a hearer has attained the middling level of the path of accumulation, that hearer will no longer pass to another path. In other words, he or she would no longer pass to the Mahāyāna. What this means is that the middling level of the path of accumulation involves an extremely stable commitment to the attainment, in this case of the enlightenment of a hearer.

As you remember, numerous metaphors are given for bodhichitta such as bodhichitta being like earth, like gold and so forth. This is a partial reflection of such level of commitment. Now, once one has attained the middling level of the path of accumulation, even though this is not explicitly asserted in Buddhist texts through reasoning, one can understand that this level is pervaded or is suffused with meditation on emptiness. So, since this understanding of emptiness is so central even though it’s not explicitly explained in Salam, we will cover it together one day carefully. Now, it is actually the realizations of emptiness which cause one to progress upwards once one has entered one of the paths.

It is not an increase in definite emergence or bodhichitta. This is quite an important point. So this is why we should repeatedly over and again think on emptiness. Emptiness is a difficult topic. What is particularly difficult is identifying the object of negation.

Now, I am in no way saying that I have a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer. I have some sort of a feeling of what emptiness ought to be like. So how at present does one progress from the middling level of the path of accumulation to the great level of the path of accumulation? This progression occurs through a repeated focus of a mind of calm abiding upon emptiness. Now, at the level of the greater path of accumulation, one must necessarily have attained calm abiding.

And then one progresses upwards through the nine levels of calm abiding, the nine mental abiding up to attaining a calm abiding which is focused upon emptiness. To give you an example, this is akin to the progression of the days in the Tibetan lunar month from the first upwards. So there is therefore no definiteness regarding having attained emptiness at the level of the small path of accumulation. One can as well as one cannot. However, at the level of the middling path of accumulation, since beings who have entered the path of accumulation of a hero for instance, have generated a very powerful uncontrived thought of definite emergence, which is single pointedly focused on the attainment of liberation.

Such beings will relentlessly focus on the four noble truths. In other words, they will relentlessly focus on the noble truth of suffering, the contaminated nature of the aggregates, in turn, noble truth of the origin of suffering, which is the afflictions which can be traced back to an ignorance grasping at a self, and in turn the noble truth of the path, which is the wisdom, realizing emptiness, acts as an antidote to this ignorance leading to the noble truth of cessation. This constant relentless focus on the four noble truths entails a relentless focus on emptiness. And it is for this reason that we can say based on reasoning that the middling level of the path of accumulation is suffused with the realization of emptiness. The realization of emptiness That one must necessarily have realized emptiness at the level of the middling path of accumulation.

Now through the mere realization of emptiness, there will be no transformation of the mind. Since the realization of emptiness at this level is a wisdom which has arisen from thinking. Whereas what is required for a profound transformation of the mind is a wisdom which has arisen from meditation. Not any meditation, but an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. Calm abiding alone is insufficient and insight alone is insufficient.

So you have a translation of the three principles of the path in English and at the end of the three principles of the path it is said. And once you have realized these key points, child dwell in solitude and practice enthusiastically. Now, the key points here do not refer in my opinion to definite emergence in bodhichitta, which would not call for a lot of meditation, but refers specifically to that realization of emptiness which severs the nets of doubt. It is once one has a realization of emptiness that one must dwell in solitude and meditate. And there is another passage to the same effect which says, once one has generated mental fortitude, sever the nets of doubt and meditate this also refers to meditating forcefully on emptiness.

Now there are numerous points here. While it is true that there are beings who have not entered the path, who have a realization of emptiness. It is also true that beings who are on the middling level of the path of accumulation necessarily have a realization of emptiness. Now, how does one effect the transition from the middling level the path of accumulation to the great level of the path of accumulation? As you remember, in the seven fold division of the 37 facets of enlightenment, the first is the close placement of recollection, which is present from the small level of the path of accumulation upwards.

The second is the four thorough abandonments, which are present from the middling level of the path of accumulation upwards. And the third is the four limbs of magical emanation, which are present from the great level of the path of accumulation upwards. Now the four limbs of magical emanation within the seven fold subdivision of the 37 facets of enlightenment refers to calm abiding. This is therefore a clear indication that a calm abiding focused upon emptiness is what occurs at the boundary between the middling and the great level of the path of accumulation. Then once one has generated an insight, which is focused on emptiness, one will pass from the great level of the path of accumulation to the path of preparation.

But clearly, a calm abiding focused upon emptiness must precede an insight focused upon emptiness. So please reflect on this for a couple of minutes in the context of generating the motivation. After this, we will recite the prayers and then you can ask whatever questions you have. Thank you, Lily. And please open the prayer book, page one.

We recite one b two three four, page five, number six, number three, verse one and three. So if you have questions, you can ask them now. Short questions, one or two questions. Actually, I wasn’t able to be here last week, and but I’ve read through the in the form. What I didn’t find was the answer to this question, which is in terms of the path of accumulation, what is being accumulated?

So the path of accumulation which is the first of the five paths is called the path of accumulation because, let us say, once a hearer has entered the path with the goal to attain liberation, the accumulations begin to be accumulated on that path. So the accumulations which are accumulated or the collections which are accumulated are the accumulations of merit and of wisdom. The accumulation of merit includes the practices of ethics, of generosity, of forbearance, of enthusiasm, of concentration and the practice of wisdom is training in wisdom such as meditation and emptiness. And mother? There is a connection with the six perfections, not the exact six perfections on the path of hearers.

There is also a practice of generosity of ethics, of forbearance, of concentration and of enthusiasm within beings who have not entered the path. Another? I’ve questioned another. What is the criteria of generating uncontrived renunciation apart from having that thought in days and night every moment in a dream? Is there another criteria?

So it’s an important point. Once the uncontrived thought of definite emergence has been generated within one’s mind stream, one just doesn’t sit back and relax. Instead, such beings are then driven to the attainment of liberation and put great effort in training in whatever is necessary to attain liberation. Then here the talk is obviously of emptiness. Geshela said that in order to enter the Mahāyāna path of accumulation or the Mahāyāna path, yes, of accumulation as opposed to the hearer path of accumulation, having generated an uncontrived thought of definite emergence, it’s necessary also to have generated great compassion.

Is this an uncontrived thought of great compassion rather than great compassion itself? And in relation and perhaps I can ask a similar question with regard to the entry in regard to the middling scope of the path of accumulation where Geshela said that there is no transformation of the mind as it arises from thinking not from meditation. This emptiness, this realizing, wisdom realizing emptiness arises from thinking and not from meditation. Is that therefore equivalent to the un uncontrived thought of wisdom realizing emptiness as a whole or emptiness as opposed to what is going to be derived at the great level. I’ll take your first question.

The second is unclear to me, so I’ll ask you to repeat it after Geshe answers the first question. One doesn’t use the terminology uncontrived for great compassion. The term uncontrived thought of definite emergence is used to contrast that with a contrived thought of definite emergence. It is not used for great compassion. The difference between wisdom realizing emptiness at the middling level of the path of accumulation and that at the great level of the path of accumulation is that the first arises from thinking and not from meditation, whereas the second arises from calm abiding focused on wisdom realizing emptiness as I understand it.

Does that mean if it arises from thinking, might this be said to be an uncontrived thinking, an uncontrived thought regarding wisdom in relation to emptiness? Again here the term uncontrived is not used in the context of the wisdom arisen from thinking. The wisdom arisen from thinking is a wisdom which severs doubts regarding its object through the power of analysis. So I think you have understood the small level of the path of accumulation. Now the transition to the middling level of the path of accumulation occurs once one understands that one is able to attain one’s object of attainment, liberation.

And at this point, one puts effort in trying to attain it focusing upon the four noble truths. Now the transition from the middling to the great level of the path of accumulation occurs upon realizing that one must eliminate the ignorance grasping at a self to in turn eliminate the afflictions, and that the elimination of the ignorance grasping at a self cannot be done through the mere realization of emptiness. It can only be done by means of a definite ascertainment of emptiness. Such a definite ascertainment calls for the generation of insight, a prerequisite of which is calm abiding. Realizing this, one trains in a calm abiding focused on emptiness and this leads to the transition to the great level of the path of accumulation.

So at present we will have the discussion and debate on the topics by groups of two or three maximum. What I’d like you to discuss about is the distinction between the small, the middling and the great path of accumulation, number one. And number two, if you want, the meaning of the definition of a path, a sapience which is upheld by an uncontrived thought of definite emergence. Please.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

On the path of accumulation, what is actually being accumulated?

The path of accumulation is the first of the five paths. It is called this because once a hearer has entered the path with the goal of attaining liberation, the accumulations begin to be accumulated on it. The accumulations, or collections, are those of merit and of wisdom. The accumulation of merit includes the practices of ethics, generosity, forbearance, enthusiasm and concentration. The accumulation of wisdom is training in wisdom, such as meditation on emptiness. There is a connection with the six perfections, though not the exact six perfections on the path of hearers.

Scroll to Top