58 min · 2,950 words · 10 October 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The speaker presents a personal view that a meaningful human life depends on contentment with the happiness we have. He distinguishes physical happiness, which comes through the five sensory consciousnesses and is short-term, from mental happiness, and gives everyday examples of how over-use of phones, computers, alcohol and clothing harms long-term wellbeing. He ends with a short question and answer on managing young children’s distraction.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 58 min
UUID: 72afbd0f-a3c4-4178-8927-187855aa262d
Date: 2015-10-10
Words: 2,946
Okay. So our topic for today is a meaningful human life and how to lead such a life and I will explain this as I see things. Then this is my own viewpoint of things. It will not necessarily be related to Lam Rim or the graduated stages of the path before you to examine. This is my private outlook.
So all of us need and must lead a meaningful life. Any meaningful life is a life with meaning. I believe that contentment or satisfaction with the happiness we have is profoundly related to leading a meaningful human life. Now when we think of a meaningful human life, we almost immediately think of our body, but in reality, a meaningful human life hinges on happiness. And when we analyze, it is clear that there are only two forms of happiness, physical and mental happiness.
So when we speak of physical happiness, we are referring to happiness which is rooted in the five sensory consciousnesses. Now undeniably there is a relationship between the five sensory consciousnesses and our mind. So the Buddhist texts point out regarding physical consciousness that if we take the sensory consciousnesses, they are operational for so long as we do not enter into deep sleep. Once we enter the deep sleep, these sensory consciousnesses and their activities such as seeing visual objects, hearing sounds and so forth cease to operate. Now regarding mental consciousness, the manifestation of mental consciousness and happiness or suffering which is related to it becomes evident in the dream state.
When we experience dreams, whatever happiness or suffering we experience in the dream state is mental happiness or suffering. So when we speak of sensory consciousnesses, it is in dependence on the sensory consciousnesses that in turn desire and anger can arise. Specifically, it is in dependence on the five sensory consciousnesses that the sensation of desire and anger can arise. So when we reflect on the sensations which arise, dependence for instance on the visual consciousness, the happy and suffering sensations which arise in dependence on our visual consciousness, then we get a better understanding of what precisely is understood by physical happiness and suffering. Our goal here however is to describe the actual mode of existence of phenomena, in other words, reality and we can see that when a happy sensation arises, independence on the visual consciousness, it is a short term, a contingent form of happiness.
We are not aware of the long-term difficulties this will cause. This is self evident. If we take for instance the case of computers, then oddly enough many monks in the monasteries seem to have computers. What the purpose or the benefit of these computers is in that context, I am not quite sure. But for yourselves, for the education of your children and work, then it is meaningful but especially as far as children are concerned, one should give them advice regarding how to use computers wisely.
Otherwise, a tremendous amount of time is wasted and bad habits may be incurred. Therefore, there is indeed a positive aspect to computers. They are beneficial for study and so forth. But I would certainly not say it is a 100% positive. So for instance, the usage of computers in monasteries seems to me rather difficult to justify.
I don’t really see the benefit. Then if we take the case of young children using for instance, modern telephones which are basically handheld computers. Young children only understand the immediate benefit of something and are unable to understand the long-term consequences. We see now certainly from what I’ve seen in the West very young children ages two, three, five spending their time playing on computer on telephones. Then I think even at that very early age, because of this constant play on telephones in the internet, desire and anger must increase dramatically in their minds and as a result, when they become young adults around 19 or 20, they will have strong proclivities for desire and anger.
This will lead certainly to difficulties later on in life in their fifties and sixties, in addition to physical problems such as visual problems through focusing constantly on such a small screen. Then I am quite sure that most of you do not use your portable telephones for play but for work. But if this were the case nonetheless, please do be careful. Back in the old days when a couple of people were assembled, then they would enjoy the time spent together. They would drink tea, they would have meals, they would talk with each other and would interact as human beings.
Nowadays, this seems no longer to be the case. When people are assembled, everyone is typing away on his little portable telephone and it is striking that even when they eat, people are too busy to eat correctly and must type away on their little phone. Then obviously, if you complain about being lonely and having no human relations, how can you hope to create human relations if you don’t talk to each other? This is really true. So for the sake of short term happiness, we destroy our long-term happiness, don’t we?
So therefore one should train in contentment or satisfaction with the happiness one has. Then if it’s meaningful to engage in some activity such as for instance using a portable telephone or mobile, then why not? If it is not meaningful, then we are sacrificing our long-term happiness for the sake of short term happiness and we will lose our eyesight in the process. So this covers satisfaction with regards to the visual consciousness. Then as far as the auditory consciousness as hearing is concerned, we should try only to listen to meaningful conversation and not waste our time listening to meaningless talk which will just trouble our mind.
So, as for the olfactory consciousness, I think I can say that in the past there was no particular suffering experienced in relation to the olfactory consciousness. Nowadays, however, it is very widespread. If you think for instance of the usage of marijuana, probably the short term pleasure experienced through using marijuana is a pleasure experienced by means of the olfactory consciousness. But there are major long-term consequences such as psychosis and so forth which cause great suffering. Now regarding the pleasures experienced through the gustatory consciousness, these obviously refer to the pleasures of taste.
Then this first refers to the pleasures experienced when one eats meals and obviously the risk of becoming overweight and so forth. And obviously the usage of alcohol. So if one drinks beer or whiskey, then obviously the pleasure of alcohol is experienced first by the gustatory consciousness and we all know the consequences it leads to. So short term, there is some pleasure and long-term one destroys one’s happiness. Then I am mentioning all of these obstacles to contentment today but I assume none of you has to experience any of this.
I’m just presenting today hypothetical cases to show how the method of illustrating these matters, you yourselves are probably not concerned by these cases. In a committee, it doesn’t matter. Then if you have children, friends or relatives and you are able to give them good advice like this, then this is of great benefit. If we can benefit one person that is a great thing. So alcohol is a great obstacle.
Then obviously a small amount of alcohol doesn’t seem to cause any problems, but everything is contingent on measure and if one drinks alcohol in without measure, if one succumbs to inebriation, then one experiences all of the problems due to a shortened lifespan, intoxication and so forth. Now in this matter, the Buddhist position is almost identical to that of the law. Legally, you have the right to drink, but past a certain limit of alcohol consumption, you will have to face legal consequences if you drive, let us say. And obviously when we experience pleasant tastes as a result of the gustatory consciousness, at that moment there is no measurable harmful impact but the food has to go into our stomach and we never think of the consequences for our stomach. For instance, gastric or intestinal diseases or simply becoming overweight.
And finally, the pleasures from the tactile sensation obviously beset us with considerable difficulties. We sacrifice much Lojong benefit to very short term pleasures which arise from tactile sensations. For instance, we accumulate huge hoards of clothing to satisfy our craving for tactile sensations and these clothing are never worn, never used, yet great expense is incurred in the process. Then for myself who is ordained the situation is very simple and very pleasant. I have one shamtap, the lower garment, one zen, the upper garment and one tonka, the inner vest.
Then obviously Be careful, you know. Then obviously for lay people the situation is radically different and I should mention that women seem to buy a gigantic amount of clothing. Please be careful. Reducing the difficulties in this life to a minimum is to try to reduce the amount of desire and anger which arises in dependence on the five sensory consciousnesses in my opinion. Now moving onwards to mental suffering and happiness and the experience of mental contentment.
As we said, suffering and happiness can be subdivided into two, physical and mental suffering and happiness. Physical suffering and happiness are contingent on the five sensory consciousnesses. Mental suffering and happiness, on the other hand, is quite different. The mode of thinking is different from that of the functioning of the five sensory consciousnesses. Mind for instance is beginningless and therefore it relates to the five sensory consciousnesses in a radically different way.
So whereas the five sensory consciousnesses are bound to their object, an exterior physical object, a mind even though it may have arisen from them, can travel anywhere it wants and focus on anything. In this matter, there is a fundamental difference between sensory consciousnesses and mind. That when mind abides on the sensory consciousnesses, it is very relaxed and loose. So let us take an example. If we look at animals, whether they are herbivores or carnivores, then how do animals proceed?
The herbivores eat their fill of grass, the carnivores eat flesh, but in both cases, once their bellies are full, then they are very relaxed and there is no particular interior mental activity. In other words, it is not that they don’t have a mind, but the mind is intimately bound with the sensory consciousnesses. This is not our case. You know, in the case of animals, they face other difficulties obviously. The first naturally is that they eat each other.
The carnivores particularly eat the herbivorous animals and naturally the animal realm is subject to violence and power. This we would say is the state of nature. So I’m not saying we should be like animals, actually I’m saying we should be different from animals but there is food for thought in the fact that animals whose basic needs such as the need for grass, for herbivores or for flesh, for carnivores are satisfied remain at ease and at peace. Then in this country, it is exceptionally rare to be on the receiving end of the violence of another party. This is a country of freedom and of peace.
Therefore, we would have all the reasons to be mentally at peace. Now is or are contentment and satisfaction necessary, indispensable for happiness? The answer is there is no necessary entailment, there’s no simple answer. For instance, if we take the topic of studies, let’s say for instance, dharma studies, then that is a field in which we should have no contentment since the more one studies, the more one understands and therefore one should be driven onwards by great perseverance. It is very important, know, very important.
I think And therefore, you can see that the more you study and specifically the more you study topics such as interior development and dharma, the more you can carry this with you wherever you go. So in this field, one should have no contentment. Whereas obviously if you take material objects such as houses and cars, then these are things you cannot take with you if you have to leave suddenly and therefore these are things to which one should not be attached. So this is my own outlook on how to train in contentment as far as the five sensory consciousnesses are concerned and how to train in contentment as far as the mental consciousness is concerned or the mind. So you might think that basically this is the talk of someone who is a monk and it doesn’t really concern us who are lay people.
I would put it to you that this is very much the wrong outlook. We are all identical in that all of us want to be happy and all of us want to be free from suffering. I as well as you want to be physically happy and to be free of physical suffering, as well as to be mentally happy and to be free of mental suffering. Then the remedies are identical for both yourselves and for myself. The only difference is that those of us who are ordained give rise to happiness, in dependence on ethics or discipline.
That is the only difference. Otherwise, we are strictly identical. So, I will stop here for today. We have some nine minutes left and therefore if you have questions, I’ll take a couple of questions at present. I have young children at the moment, and I can see they have a monkey mind or a very roaming mind lots of attachment to especially things that I don’t think are good, violence and jumping on things and destroying things without having to always tell them off or I don’t I can’t find the the way to, cultivate sort of, how can I put this, less distraction in their minds and try to calm that desire that they have?
How are there any suggestions? No no no, very easy. What do you say? It is very, yeah, very easy, you know. Very typical in the rest than the typical young kids.
Why? Why? Because they see it all the time. Okay. Okay.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, it all depends on the environment, so Geshela’s answer is keep them indoors, right?
They won’t see anything, will they? They will not get excited, will they? Usually ask me what I thought. My sister had young children, they’ve grown up very nicely that, eighteen nineteen and the way she handled this one was that there was no television, there was no internet in the house. Then once sensory stimuli is down, then the children they calm down.
Then obviously if there’s television internet, you have no control. They watch what they want as violence, as pornography, you know. And then later on, she had a system where she had a code or something on the television, then she would choose what they could watch and that was it. As a result, they’ve done very well in their studies. So that’s a very good idea because basically in that way, one prevents the children from succumbing to bad influences and one should explain to them.
And obviously, if one has no televisions, no machines like that in the house, no apparatuses, the opportunity to watch does not arise. Then over and again, one should say to the children, if you were to watch television, play on computers in this way, there’s a lot of time which will be wasted, time which could be spent doing something else and you will be harmed in the future. The most important is to think to oneself, if we use this frequently, then we will harm ourselves in this life. Most important obviously in those who suffer the most are the very young children ages two, three, four and five and really, while they are teenagers as well, when they become young adults then they understand the way things are and they have more self control. Okay.
I want to ask is the opposite. It’s some children, they have boredom, and it lead to affliction that they will do crimes and other thing. So how do you counteract If one uses these apparatuses, these machines a lot, computers and so forth, then clearly time is wasted and great difficulties are eventually experienced. The more one thinks about this, the less one would want to do this. So we will stop here today.
Then from your side, obviously you have none of these obstacles so this was very pleasant. So this explanation was a waste of time. Thank you very much Gesheera for giving us some further reminders about how to live a meaningful life. I’m sure we’ll be going away and continue to think about this. Thank you, Ilya, for translating.
And thank you, everybody, for coming. You’re welcome to stay for a cup of tea cup of tea and have a biscuit, but of course without being attached to it. And you’re welcome, as I said before, to come on Wednesday night to see the dissolution of the mandala after an authentic Buddhist teaching with Geshela. And check out the website for our program. If you would like to leave us your email, then we can send you updates to the program as we proceed.
So perhaps if you would like to join me in thanking Geshela in the traditional Western manner. If you would like to stand up while Geshe-la leaves.
Key terms in this teaching
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.