1 h 30 min · 3,539 words · 8 July 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the objects of abandonment for the path of the small scope (the ten non-virtues and the vanities of this life) and the middling scope (cyclic existence and the afflictions). It describes the five afflictions related to the view and the five unrelated to the view, and says that the 80/20 balance of preoccupation with future lives over this life marks realization of renunciation. A question-and-answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 31m
UUID: b9e3cf2d-67c1-4e11-9c58-fd465aac61c4
Date: 2015-07-08
Words: 3,535
So in this context, since the main topic we are studying is the path of the being of the middling scope, we should address the defects or the principal object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope. And the principal object of abandonment is cyclic existence or the afflictions. However, initially, I would like to address the path of the being of the small scope. Now the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope can be said to be either the 10 non virtues or the vanities of this life, which are numerous. And it is important for oneself to understand this.
So in as much as the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope are the 10 non virtues or the vanities of this life, and the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope is samsaric existence or the afflictions, there is an important difference in the qualities of realization and abandonment between the path of the being of the middling and of the small scope. So do you understand the difficulty in the importance of the abandonment, of the object of abandonment on the path of the being of the small scope? Do you understand? Do you understand, Usunima? This is important.
This is actually what study is. In short, not too much. In short, please. So the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope are the 10 non virtues. In other words, principally physical and verbal non virtues, which have an exterior material component.
Well, so the objects of abandonment of the being of the middling scope are mental. They are of the nature of consciousness, and they have little or no relation to exterior physical objects. For this reason, the objects of abandonment of the being of the middling scope are more difficult to abandon than the objects of abandonment of the being of the small scope. Now when one refers in the context of the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope to relinquishing the vanities of this life. This does not refer to abandoning one’s house or, for instance, turning one’s back on one’s relatives.
Instead, one has to assess what precisely the criterion is for having abandoned the vanities of this life. And in this respect, Lama Tsongkhapa’s great treatise on the stages of the path points out that because of beginningless habituation, we at present are heavily over invested in the affairs of this life. And this is the case for all of us in this room. We focus exclusively on the affairs of this life. But through repeated meditation and reflection on the Lamrim, eventually our outlook will change.
And the affairs of this life become subsidiary and the affairs of future lives become dominant or principal. This is a criterion for having gained the realizations of the path of the being of the small scope. Then if our preoccupations, the totality of our preoccupations is 80% of our preoccupations is focused on future lives and 20% on this life, we’re pretty much there. So this is the way Lamrim Chenmo explains things and this is really something which is extremely important for us to understand. Nobody in this room remembers when they get up in the morning to drink their cup of coffee or tea, right?
So that is the attitude we should have to future lives. Very important. As I said in these few principles of the past, when renunciation arises day and night uninterruptedly, then one realized renunciation. So probably none of us would forget to have breakfast when he or she woke up in the morning, but even if we did, we would have a very solid lunch to compensate for this. This is a simile or an example to enable us to understand what the realization of the path of the being of the small scope should be.
The line in Lamrim Chenmo which states that the affairs of this life should become subsidiary is critically important. The term subsidiary or ancillary indicates that we do not completely reject the affairs of this life. Indeed, it would be very difficult for our consciousness to dwell within these contaminated aggregates, this body of ours, in other words, if we took no care whatsoever of it. In other words, we do need to rely on exterior sense objects such as forms, sounds, smells, tastes and so forth. Likewise, if one has relatives or family members, then one must relate to these relatives or family members.
There’s a way of doing this. Now regarding the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope, it is said to be psychic existence. In the Pramānavārttika of Dharmakīrti’s samsaric existence is defined as the noble truth of suffering subsumed within a continuum. Now in this context, this refers to the contaminated aggregates. In other words, the form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factors and consciousness aggregate.
Here, if we were to say that abandoning psychic existence means to abandon one’s form aggregate, the conclusion to be quite awkward and delicate discourse for analysis. So this form aggregate, this contaminated form aggregate of ours is the basis of sufferings such as the suffering of heat and cold, the sufferings of desire and anger and so forth. Yet, should we say that to relinquish, to abandon these sufferings, we have to abandon this body, this form aggregate of ours, that would be quite awkward and a bit odd. So if we wish to abandon this contaminated form aggregate, then we must address the issue of the method of abandonment of the form aggregate. And to use a simile, should an area of the country be afflicted by floods, the first step is to identify the origin or the source of these floods, to put an end to the flooding at the source and not at the end of the line.
This is a procedure we should adopt. So if we analyze what the source of our body, our form aggregate is, we find it is the spermatozoa and the ovum of one’s parents. Technically in Tibetan, semen the and the blood of one’s parents. Then is it possible for us to abandon this? Well, obviously not.
We have no relation at all at present to those substances. If we view as the object of abandonment of the being of the small scope, the remaining four aggregates which are subsumed within our continuum, in other words, the aggregates of sensation, discrimination, composition of factors and consciousness, then clearly these aggregates include numerous afflictions which have fallen under the sway of anger and we can see the nature of these afflictions. Within our mental aggregates, we have anger, which is related to the sensation aggregate. We have anger related to the aggregate of discrimination, anger related to the aggregate of compositional factors, and we do have anger related to the aggregate of consciousness, albeit not subsumed within the aggregate of consciousness. And this is the case for all three poisons.
So when afflictions under the sway of anger arise within our mind stream, what is their impact on the mind? They trouble the mind. The same is true for afflictions which are related to envy, to jealousy, to competitiveness, and so forth. Even though they are not present now within our mind stream, nonetheless, they are potentially present. And therefore, it is when afflictions such as anger are not present within our mind stream, that we should try to become aware of their thoughts.
It is when they are not manifest that we should try to do this, not when they have become manifest. Ārya Asaṇga defined the afflictions as mental factors whose function is to cause unsuitability within one’s continuum. When we understand the faults, defects of anger, does the desire to be free from this anger arise or not? Clearly, the desire to be free from this anger does arise. But when we speak of being free from anger, we do not refer to expelling anger from the mind somehow.
We refer instead to understanding the source or the origin of anger. When the mind which wishes to be free from anger arises, then clearly the mind which wishes to be free from psychic existence may be said to have arisen. At this point, one can say that the mind which wishes for liberation from psychic existence has arisen. Now in this context when we analyze psychic existence in terms of the four truths, once the wish to be freed from the first noble truth, the truth of suffering has arisen, Can we say that the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation has arisen or not? If we can say this, then clearly in terms of the sequence of practice, the third noble truth would not be third, but second.
It would arise after the first noble truth, noble truth of suffering. Whereas the second noble truth is the noble truth of the origin of suffering and not the noble truth of cessation. So this doubt does arise. Then the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope is cyclic existence or the afflictions. In other words, when we understand the nature of an affliction such as anger and we generate within our mind stream the resolve, I shall not fall under the sway of anger, or for that matter, I shall not fall under the sway of any of the three poisons, anger, desire, and benightedness, then this is really something quite extraordinary.
And once we have this resolve, then we have to search for the means not to fall under the sway of the afflictions. Now what means apart from the study of the graduated stages of the path might there be? And therefore, let us at present generate the motivation to receive these teachings. The answer Chris gave to my question regarding the relative difficulty in abandoning the respective objects of abandonment of the paths of the being of the small and of the middling scope was also correct. There are numerous possible answers to this question, the one Chris gave, or the fact that it is more difficult to abandon inner states of mind than exterior physical objects.
So when we speak of controlling our mind and not falling under the sway of these three poisons, it is a process of mental imputation where we assert, I shall not fall under the sway of these three poisons, and we identify them. Then when we take the resolve not to fall under the sway of these three afflictions, these three afflictions are not necessarily manifest within our mind stream, but their potency is present. And we target them and focus on them and resolve not to fall under their sway when they manifest. This creates tremendous waves of merit. There are countless afflictions subsumed within the three poisons within our mind stream.
And it is before they become manifest that we must take the resolve not to fall under their sway. Otherwise, once they have become manifest, it will be very difficult to pacify the mind since these afflictions are mistaken states of mind. And once they have arisen, we ourselves are mistaken. And, therefore, one must become aware of the nature of afflictions such as anger and so forth. Once one is aware of their thoughts, it is quite straightforward to generate a mind wishing to be free from them.
To do this, one must initially identify the afflictions. One must identify their mode of abiding. One must identify their nature, their personality, if you wish. To do this, one must study in detail the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. So in Lamrim Chenmo, there are four outlines regarding the second noble truth, the identification of the noble truth of the origin of suffering.
The first is the identification of the afflictions. The second is their mode or their sequence of generation. The third is their cause. And the fourth is their faults. So the nature of the afflictions, I have already explained.
Afflictions are mental factors whose function is to perturb our continuum. Then in turn, there are afflictions which are related to the view and afflictions which are unrelated to the view. The afflictions related to the view are the view of the transitory collection. The the view of permanence, the view of nihilism, wrong view, and grasping mistaken conduct as supreme. The four afflictions unrelated the five afflictions unrelated to the view are desire, anger, ignorance, doubt and pride.
Then these 10 afflictions are present within our mind stream. We should investigate or check our mind stream to see whether yes or no, these five afflictions related to the view and the five afflictions unrelated to the view are present within our mind streams or not. Then we should reflect on the nature of these five afflictions related to the view and the five unrelated to the view and see whether they are present or not. Then after doing this, we should ask ourselves, are they or not present within my mind stream? And if they are, what is their function?
Is their function a suitable or an unsuitable function? So what are the natures of the five afflictions unrelated to the view? The first desire is a mental factor which imputes unwarranted attractiveness to an attractive entity. The second anger is a mental factor which wishes to harm that which is unpleasant. The third, pride, is that state of mind which reflects on whatever qualities we might have.
Everyone has some qualities and thinks no one is like me in this respect. This wrong view is pride. The fourth, ignorance, is that mental factor which is obscured with respect to an object we wish to know. Whichever object we wish to know, if we are obscured with respect to that object, we suffer of ignorance with respect to that object. Now affliction in these texts refers to afflicted affliction.
Excuse me. Doubt in these texts refers to afflicted doubt. Doubt or afflicted doubt is doubt with respect to the existence or nonexistence, veracity or nonveracity of the four noble truths, of causality of the existence of past and future lives. These are the five afflictions unrelated to the view. Now the afflictions related to the view include first view of the transitory composite.
This is that mind which observes the person and views it as having a self. Then the following affliction related to the view is the view of permanence. This is the view which on the basis of the disintegrating base, we are ascribed permanence. This is followed by the view of nihilism. This is a view which to the contrary considers that after our death, the destruction of our physical aggregate, there is no future life.
Wrong view. The following affliction related to the view includes, according to Buddhist texts, the view that the four noble truths are not correct, that causality does not exist or that past and future lives do not exist. The following affliction related to the view is holding the view as supreme. This means that whatever of the previous wrong views one might have, in other words, the view of the transitory composite, the view of permanence or the view of nihilism, these are seen as supreme. The last of the afflictions related to the view is holding wrong ethics or conduct as supreme.
This in Buddhist text refers to believing that through physical asceticism and mortification, such as sitting in the midst of the five fires or burying oneself, one will be able to attain liberation. Are these five afflictions related to the view and the five unrelated to the view present or not within our continuum? Most Then I shall stop here. Please ask your questions. Could you speak in Tibetan?
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. [Tibetan]. Most definitely, the eight worldly concerns are included within the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the small scope.
Specifically, they are included within the vanities of this life. They are also included within the 10 non virtues since they are included within the three mental non virtues. And So it is difficult to explain the eight worldly truths on their own terms, but when we understand that they are intimately connected to this life, we can see how they are connected to the vanities or the appearances of this life. Yeah. And another?
This really is a question regarding just terminology with Asaṇga’s definition of the afflictions as mental factors whose function is to cause unsuitability within one’s continuum. With that term unsuitability, unsuitable for what? To put it simply, suitable means something which is good, which has a part of existence, if you wish. And unsuitable means contaminated, what harms the mind. Wait.
Who is this? I will first read your question in English because nobody knows what you’re asking. Ladies’ question in summary is about the order of the outline in Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand versus the order of the outline in Je Tsongkhapa’s, Lamrim Chemo. So in Je Tsongkhapa’s Lamrim Chenmo, the sufferings are explained first in terms of the eightfold, then the sixfold and the threefold subdivision, then the human sufferings. Pabongka Rinpoche explains the six sufferings first, then the human, then the eight.
And Lily’s doubt is whether this is because for Pabongka Rinpoche, the six sufferings occur over more than one life whereas all present all eight are present in one human life. And Geshela says he will check himself and see. Please hold the microphone to your team. Further to Jill’s question on the issue of unsuitability, could the meaning of unsuitability relate to unsuitability to attain the goals that one sets for oneself either for higher rebirth, for for liberation from cyclic existence, or for attaining enlightenment. It’s unsuitable for gain, to for accomplishing any of those goals.
Okay. Yes. I think so. In as much as unsuitable, probably has a meaning of to block, to counter. You encounter both forms.
Sometimes sometimes. Its meaning is the same. Another? Oh, yeah. I’m in that.
I was just wondering about that 80%, 20% breakdown that Geshela gave before. I think I understand the 20% being the worldly concerns. But in terms of actions that we do in our everyday lives, what would be the makeup of the 80%? So what I meant when I spoke of 20% dedicated to this life and 80% of future lives is that one’s thinking should be dedicated 20% of the time to this life and 80% of the time to future lives. So for instance, within one hour, let us say, once you dedicate 48 minutes to future lives and twenty minutes to this life.
So in one day, all of us engage in actions and deeds, then what this means is if we look at our actions of body, speech, mind, they can either be virtuous or non virtuous. Then, to work for future lives means to focus on the virtuous deeds and to abandon the non virtuous deeds to engage in correct practice and abandonment. About the competitiveness and pride, I would like to ask a question. You know, like, at this age with the science and progress, you need to you know, when you have to study hard and compete to get into a progress, you know, in the modern age. So is that good or bad?
The the that’s what my question. The competitiveness and pride for that reason. So in a class, for instance, when one is studying, if one views one’s classmates as foes, as opponents, then this is clearly a competitiveness which is an affliction. If, on the other hand, one has the mindset, I don’t want anyone to be better than me, then that’s a bit different. When you want to motivate the children to study hard to get a better future, but to do that, you have to tell them that you have to earn, you know, certain thing to you know, like, if you see people like that, they the model, they have they bought a good car or something like that, and you motivate them to study hard to get into that stage?
Yes. It’s okay. I mean, certainly, they will study on that basis. That’s okay. That’s a good.
It’s okay. I wondered if there’s any relationship whatsoever between afflicted doubt and the doubt of the within LORIG of the doubting consciousness within LORIG. Yes. I mean, the afflicted emotion, the afflicted doubt is doubt as it is explained in LORIG. However, not all doubt is afflicted.
Sorry. Could Geshe-la explain the criteria for doubt that is not afflicted? That would be the motivation. Independence on a good or a bad motivation, doubt regarding the four noble truths is virtuous or non virtuous. Yes.
We shall stop here for today.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
In everyday actions, what makes up the 80% of our time and thinking that is dedicated to future lives?
The 20% for this life and 80% for future lives refers to how one's thinking is divided: about 20% of the time on this life and 80% of the time on future lives. Within an hour, for example, most of the time would go to future lives and the smaller part to this life. In a day, everyone engages in actions of body, speech and mind, which are either virtuous or non-virtuous. Working for future lives means focusing on virtuous deeds and abandoning non-virtuous ones, that is, engaging in correct practice and abandonment.