Lam Rim – 2015-05-13 – KR

1 h 30 min · 4,214 words · 13 May 2015

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2015-05-13 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that the purpose of studying the Lamrim is to subdue the mind and free it from the sway of the afflictions, which brings lasting peace and happiness. It explains how anger and other afflictions cause suffering, outlines motivation by scope, and describes the sufferings of demigods and gods. A question and answer session follows on mantra recitation, rebirth as a god, reducing self-cherishing and realizing emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 30m

UUID: ee79b95c-5b08-4955-8639-35c286967572

Date: 2015-05-13

Words: 4,210

What is the purpose of listening and studying the Lamrim? It is to generate mental happiness. Then although we do everything to attain happiness, the happiness we focus upon is physical happiness. Whether we actually put any effort at trying to attain mental happiness, something we really ought to check. Then in our own cases, clearly, when we have breakfast in the morning, this is to foster physical happiness and not mental happiness.

And when we go to work after that to earn money, this is also to foster physical happiness and not mental happiness. Whether there is anything in our life to foster mental happiness is something we have to look into. Doubtless, it is true that there is a brief fleeting mental happiness which is related with obtaining physical happiness, which is a joy of obtaining physical happiness. But this is a mental happiness which arises independent of the condition of physical happiness. It does not arise by itself.

This is something we should gain direct experience of. Then the purpose of listening and studying the Lamrim will have been fulfilled if mental happiness arises in dependence on this. And by mental happiness, we mean a particular feeling of peace and of happiness. Otherwise, to merely understand the conceptions developed in Lamrim has no particular point. Then this study of Lamrim, does it induce such a sensation in your minds or not?

Really? That’s good. Very important. Thank you. Then this peace and happiness is a state which arises when our mind is no longer under the sway of the afflictions.

As the holy elder, the purpose of all of these scriptures and their commentaries is to subdue the mind. Subduing the mind here refers to freeing the mind from being under the sway of the afflictions. So we asked many times who the author of this passage was. Because Rinpoche said it was the work of a great Indian pundit. Then if we manage not to fall under the sway of the afflictions durably, we will have attained the state of an arhat.

This is something which is far removed from for us. But the preliminary to not falling under the sway of the afflictions is to understand the faults of the afflictions. Therefore, what is the purpose of the Lamrim? It is not to fall under the sway of the afflictions. When we are able not to fall under the sway of the afflictions, then mental peace and happiness will arise.

This is of tremendous benefit to us. It is therefore meaningless to say we don’t know what the purpose of the Lamrim is. Now, the afflictions in turn, when we fall under this sway, lead to mistaken deeds. The afflictions themselves are mistaken states of mind. Anger, for instance, is a mistaken state of mind.

It is a mistaken state of mind because it is mistaken with respect to its object. When we fall into this way of anger, we engage in turn in mistaken deeds. Then from mistaken minds, in turn mistaken deeds arise. This is the causal relationship of mind and deed. It is extremely important to understand that while the mind does fall under the sway of the afflictions, the afflictions are not in the nature of the mind, even though it might seem to be the case.

For instance, anger is not of the nature of the mind. This mind which is able to go from past lives to future lives and eventually to attain full enlightenment, cannot be of the nature of the afflictions. This is extremely important and must be understood. And therefore, when we observe this causal sequence in which we evolve, which causes us so much hardship and difficulty, we might wonder whether we ourselves are responsible for our sufferings. In reality, we analyze, we can see it is the afflictions which are responsible of our sufferings more than ourselves.

These afflictions are within the mental continuum, within the continuum of consciousness. They are not the continuum of consciousness. Then it is important to understand that it is the afflictions which cause this, and we should advise ourselves on this topic, give ourselves counsel. And when we behave in this way, then we can understand that when hardship arises and we can see people in this world who experience tremendous hardship, instead of saying, oh my goodness, it isn’t my fault. How could I do this?

The world is against me. They are all conspiring against me. It is actually our own afflictions which have caused our own suffering. So it is precisely because we are unable to identify our foremost enemy that we view things in this way. Our mind actually continues indefinitely.

It is the afflictions under which our mind falls, which are responsible for our sufferings. The experiences we incur when our mind falls under the sway of the afflictions are clearly explained in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara. Under the sway of anger, we experience neither happiness nor joy. This is very clear. When we are angry, we cannot enjoy the taste of food nor even sleep.

This is a result of afflictions such as anger or let’s say jealousy. For instance, we Tibetans consider that nothing is more exquisite than momos. And yet, when you are angry, you can’t even taste the momos you are eating. It is critical to understand the thoughts of anger or of envy before they arise within our minds. Otherwise, once they have arisen within our minds, to try to understand their faults and to counter them is very difficult.

Therefore, before they understand, we should under they arise, we should understand their faults. And then when they approach our minds, then we should target them and counter them. And once anger has arised, then it is very difficult to counter it. It controls our mind and targets our mind wherever it wants to go. Then as is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara in the chapter on forbearance, anger is bereft of limbs.

Anger has neither arms nor legs. It is not out there in space. It is within our own minds and yet it controls us. Śāntideva continues and says, harming me, all seeming to be my enemy. And this is indeed how anger and jealousy function.

When we are under their sway, they seem to be able to help us, to protect us. We hold them in that very expressive way Geshe lah conveys. And this is why the bodhisattvas try to counter anger and envy when they arise within their mind stream, but this is not the crux of the matter. The crux, however, of the matter is to subdue the mind. This is the essence of dharma.

Even though scholars have written extensively on it, on this, this is the crux. As Jetsün Milarepa said, this old beggar controls his mind. Atisha says, the essential dharma to be held with the mind is not to fall under the sway of the afflictions. Once this happens, all is lost. And therefore, we should study the Lamrim with the intent to separate our mind from the afflictions and to keep them separated.

And Śāntideva adds, when the wise experience suffering, they maintain their mind untroubled. This is a very profound instruction. Suffering does occur. But the wise, in other words here, those who have studied the Lamrim, prevent it from affecting their minds. Then this advice of Acharya Śāntideva is not something we should just quote and look at in terms of scriptural passages.

It is something we should see in terms of experience, in terms of our own experience. So it is not a matter of saying, this and that passage are in Śāntideva’s bodhisattva Acharyavatara, but instead to instruct one’s own mind and see whether this fits with experience. Then regarding the generation of the motivation, we should meditate first on death and impermanence, and then understanding that the afflictions do arise within our mind stream, we should reflect on their thoughts and make sure that we do not fall under their sway when they appear. Then this type of motivation is an extremely powerful motivation. If we take the resolve, I shall not commit non virtue, I shall not commit symptom, there is afflictions within our mind stream.

If we take the resolve not to fall under the sway of the afflictions, this is something we can do. On the other hand, if we say, I will be virtuous, well, only from time to time are there traces of virtue within our mind stream. Then having taken the resolve that we will subdue the afflictions led by anger within our mind stream, what do we do in turn when someone else, another party gets angry with us and grabbing a stick hits us, for instance, on the head? Then we should reflect in keeping with Śāntideva. The stick itself obviously is not angry.

It would be silly to say that. Then thinking, after all, the staff, the stick cannot get angry, then why is it being wielded against me? It is being wielded against me by a person who is angry. We can extend this line of reasoning to that person and say, when we say that person is angry, really, that person themselves is being wielded by anger, is under the control of anger. And when we look at it this way, we say, ah, poor person.

My goodness. Then the stick is the servant of the person, and the person is a servant of their anger. This is how we get a blow on the hand. Then I don’t have to explain to you that anger is temporary and occasional. Nobody is angry all the time.

Because it is occasional, anger must arise dependent on causes and conditions. Then training in this way day after day is what is really important. Do you understand? This turns into authentic dharma, and this is how one can generate a true motivation. And therefore, the purpose of the Lamrim is for our minds to be at peace and happy, and this can only happen when our minds do not fall under the sway of the afflictions.

This is a motivation of the being of the middling scope. The being of the great scope wishes for the minds of others not to fall under the sway of the afflictions. And for the sake of protecting the minds of others from falling under the sway of the afflictions, oneself must initially not allow one’s own mind to fall under the sway of the afflictions. For this reason, one practices a path of the being of the middling scope. As Śāntideva says, if even in a dream we cannot help others, how could we hope to help them in reality?

Clearly, if we are unable to even get rid of our own afflictions, what pretense is there in getting others rid of their afflictions? So by ensuring that our mind it does not fall under the sway of the afflictions, we in turn must ensure that it does not fall under the sway of self grasping or the grasping at an I. By doing this, the afflictions will not arise. If the afflictions do not arise, in turn inappropriate physical and verbal deeds will not be committed. Our body and speech will be subdued.

This clearly connects directly the path of the being of the middling scope to that of the being of the small scope, which is the training in the 10 virtues. As it is said, do not allow the mind to fall under the sway of the afflictions. The nature of the mind is clear light. The meaning of this passage is that the mind is not naturally contaminated. It is therefore suitable to be led to liberation or to full enlightenment.

Tibetan language. Initial language, It is therefore important at present to generate a motivation which says, I will not allow my mind to fall under the sway of the afflictions. If that motivation is generated, then a motivation of the being of the middling scope will have been generated. Let’s generate this motivation. To understand the faults of the afflictions, it is very helpful to recollect previous instances in which the afflictions such as anger, desire and so forth had arisen within our own minds and to recollect the consequences of our succumbing to the afflictions and the shame we felt after succumbing to the afflictions and yelling and screaming and so forth.

And then looking back upon this, we can clearly see the faults of the afflictions. As to looking for afflictions in the minds of others, why would we do this? So we should recollect the afflictions which were present within our own mind streams and how do we know which afflictions are present in the minds of others? Then when we recollect our spiritual teacher, the triple gem, a powerful, virtuous, and peaceful, happy state of mind arises. What greater counter is there to the afflictions in this?

In this case, virtue has arisen, which gives rise to mental happiness and peace. Then the exact opposite, is incompatible with this is a state of anger, which for instance troubles the mind. We can clearly see the difference between a virtuous and a non virtuous state of mind. When coarse anger and desire, excuse me, anger and envy arises, sometimes the person actually shakes under the power of the affliction. Then we ourselves have fallen under the sway of our mind, and our mind has fallen under the sway of the afflictions.

As a result, as it’s said in Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra, we wander through cyclic existence. Then within the presentation of the path shared with the being of the small scope, we have finished the general presentation of the sufferings of samsaric existence. And within the specific sufferings of psychic existence, we have presented the six sufferings of psychic existence or the six faults as well as the suffering specific to human beings. What is left to be presented are those of the demigods and the gods. There definitely do exist both demigods and gods.

However, these states, however exalted, are still psychic existence and only cyclic existence. Now regarding the demigods, the foremost affliction the demigods suffer from is envy and and jealousy. It is said that the maidens of the demigods are extraordinarily beautiful and are an object of lust for the gods who capture them and take them back to the god realms, which causes tremendous suffering for the demigods. The foremost suffering is mental suffering and not physical suffering since the demigods experience miraculous birth and therefore do not need like us to strive for food, for drink, and so forth. As for the gods, probably the foremost suffering they experience is suffering at the point of death.

Since the gods have paranormal powers and can therefore see their previous lives, and they can also see the non virtue they have committed and can see what rebirth they are going towards. At the time of their death, their body becomes odorous and the garlands of flowers they wear with, and none of their friends, relatives, mistresses and so forth wishes to be with them. This gives rise to tremendous suffering. Then this is neither here nor there. The sufferings of the gods are the sufferings of psychic existence.

What matters is that one understands clearly the thoughts of the afflictions which are present within our own mind stream and how to counter them. All right. I can stop tonight. Thank you. Right.

Shall stop here for tonight. If you have questions, please ask them. Michel, I would like that your questions be clear and short. And you are entitled to ask one question per person, and after everyone has asked their question, then second questions can be asked. Geshela mentioned about keeping the mind and the afflictions separate.

Does that mean that not to get involved in the afflictions and then eventually work on them so that they are removed altogether? I explained this completely. As Je Tsongkhapa said in his Song of Realizations. If one does not understand the faults of the truth of suffering, how is it possible to put effort in being free from the afflictions? One must initially understand the thoughts of the afflictions and independence on this one will separate them from the mind.

Then more generally, the totality of the paths of the being of the small, middling, and great scope are none other than means to free the mind from the afflictions. So as we train on these paths, our minds will be freed from the afflictions. This was something that came up in the study group earlier on today whether it is possible. Is it possible through reciting mantra or the names of the Buddhas constantly in one’s life, is that in any way possible that that would lead to liberation or full enlightenment as opposed to liberation or full enlightenment? This is very difficult through mere recitation of Mani’s, let’s say, to attain liberation of full enlightenment.

One obviously would attain a huge accumulation of the collection of merit. But the basic question is through reciting Manis, would yourself grasping dwindle? But Then in the case of the six-syllable mantra, it has both a meaning from the standpoint of method and wisdom. If these two are recollected simultaneously while reciting them, it could be possible for it to be a cause for liberation or for the enlightenment. But in reality, if we only recited them, the risk obviously is a falling sound asleep.

Geshela has taught that the purpose of studying the is to subdue one’s mind. And my question is, what is the difference between subduing one’s mind and this experience of sort of comforting or anesthetizing somehow one’s mind, like English version vegging out somehow using the dharma improperly. There’s a huge difference. If you, as you say, veg out, in other words, if you just sink in torpor, your mind is not freed of the afflictions. The goal is for the mind not to be under the sway of the afflictions.

When Jill was talking about asking that reciting the mantra or the Buddha names before, is that a great way to counter the affliction? Basically, your mind will be preoccupied on this such a mantra or Buddha name, so you don’t have time or even energy to focus on affliction. But if you have a compassionate mind or compassionate wish while you chant the mantra of Buddha’s name wishing to liberate all the beings in the cycle of existence, is that a way to sort of achieve full enlightenment as well? It’s difficult. It is true that when you recite, let us say, the name of Amitābha, while praying to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, because you are thinking of all sentient beings, the afflictions will become non manifest.

But that does not mean that the afflictions at their seeds will be eradicated. We have to distinguish between manifest and non manifest afflictions on the one hand and eradicating the or extirpating the afflictions. This is our goal. Another question. My question is about the gods and the demigods that, particularly the gods at the point of death experience great suffering that see the And life of the gods And if that’s true, why do they always have a lower rebirth?

No, it is not the case that it is certain that gods will be reborn in the lower realms after the end of their life as gods. Actually, if we compare the human and the divine base, the divine base of the god rebirth is superior. It is a better base. This is a delicate topic. It is said in Buddhist scriptures that even though the gods have indeed a good rebirth, a good base, nonetheless it is difficult for them at the time of death to generate virtuous mindsets.

And therefore, the human rebirth is the best of all. When we experience happiness in this world, we understand the causes of happiness. When we experience suffering, we understand the causes of suffering. Should there be prayers, may I be reborn as a god? I mean, gods are part of psychic existence.

Such prayers are the sign of a superficial study of the Lamrim. A deep study of the Lamrim would lead us to target the afflictions since that is of benefit for this life and for future lives, and not to wish for rebirth as a God. There is a passage in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara which says, the supreme is to attain full enlightenment in this life, alternatively one attains liberation, but at the least from happiness to happiness. Can Geshela please explain the different causes for rebirth as a demigod and rebirth as a god? That’s a good one.

Good question. As I said, there is no cause for a higher rebirth supreme or greater than the ethic which abandons the 10 non-virtues. So the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues would have to be the foundation conjoined with specific prayers for such a rebirth. So from what Geshela said before, avoid such a rebirth, we don’t pray to be we talk about being having a higher rebirth, so that means that we should aspire from the lower scope point of view for a better human rebirth, but certainly not for a rebirth in the god realm because we cannot practice dharma. Is that correct?

So one should dedicate one’s roots of virtue combined with prayer to obtaining such a the attention of such a base. Yeah. The training in subduing the course afflictions that we suffer and that we’re going through in this life, if attained, does that carry over to the next life or do you sort of have to start all over again? If you have just subdued the coarse afflictions in this life, but have not eradicated their seeds and in the next life they will arise again because their seeds are present. And this is why the uncommon Buddhist means taught in the Buddhist teachings for eradicating the afflictions with their seeds is the realization of selflessness.

Without this, it is not possible. Andy? We have very fortunate rebirths, but I’m just wondering what the ideal rebirth is that the being of the lowest scope is seeking. Shall I rephrase that question? Ideal rebirth is our rebirth in this world.

What you have is the ideal. All of us. Yeah. Don’t sleep. As Je Rinpoche Tsongkhapa says, even the great bodhisattvas practicing the exchange of self and others nonetheless repeatedly make prayers to obtain just the base we have.

Then obviously such great beings can be reborn under the power of karma. Then our base, our rebirth, in other words, is greatly praised in this world. You can do everything on its basis. You can go up, but you can go down as well. And the second question.

Geshela, can you give me some technical advice? I’m looking to expand the space in time between the mind and falling prey to the afflictions. Is it focusing on understanding self cherishing and self grasping, or is it more working on the afflictions themselves? I’m looking for a bigger time to catch it. Yes, precisely.

Once one sees the faults of the afflictions and sees these faults as faults, then one sets out to find a means to prevent the afflictions from arising. And one finds that the afflictions are rooted in both self cherishing and self grasping. Then trying to counter these is the way to eliminate the afflictions. Then what could be superior to causing self cherishing and self grasping to dwindle? Frankly, if you are able to cause self cherishing and self grasping to dwindle, what other purposeful Lamrim do you need?

After all, the goal of the is the attainment of full enlightenment, and all of the numerous teachings of the Lamrim lead to that. But once you have countered self cherishing, once you have countered self grasping, you are on the path to full enlightenment. What else do you need? Then once we have it is actually difficult to eliminate completely self cherishing and self grasping, but once we are able to cause them to dwindle, then we are on the path to full enlightenment. Yeah, just one question.

Have you? Here. Śāntideva was constantly talking about directly realizing emptiness to be able to eradicate all the afflictions. So which are the ways to see emptiness?

I know, theoretically, we understand. Okay. Should I use the table as an example, different parts and the collection of the parts? Theoretically, I understand that. Is there a way to actually see or directly perceive the evidence and then we’ll know ourselves, we exist or we exist under the power of karma?

What is necessary to gain direct realization of emptiness is first to understand what emptiness or selflessness is. One must identify them correctly. Then direct realization of emptiness means to see emptiness nakedly, in the same way as we see this table when we look at it. This is something which is difficult.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Can constantly reciting mantras or the names of the Buddhas throughout one's life lead to liberation or full enlightenment?

Attaining liberation or full enlightenment through mere recitation of mantras such as mani is very difficult. Recitation does bring a huge accumulation of merit. But the basic question is whether the recitation would make one's self-grasping dwindle. The six-syllable mantra has a meaning from the standpoint of both method and wisdom. If these two are recollected simultaneously while reciting, it could become a cause for liberation or enlightenment. If one only recites the words, the obvious risk is falling sound asleep.

What is the difference between subduing the mind and simply comforting or numbing it?

There is a huge difference. If you just "veg out" and sink into torpor, your mind is not freed of the afflictions. Numbing or dulling the mind does not subdue it. The goal of subduing the mind is for it to no longer be under the sway of the afflictions.

Scroll to Top