1 h 27 min · 3,471 words · 15 April 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the Lam Rim presentation of three scopes of the path, arguing that one must first train in the small-scope aim of a higher rebirth before the middling-scope aim of liberation. It describes liberation as severing the continuum of karma and affliction through wisdom realizing selflessness, and introduces the eightfold presentation of suffering. It ends with a brief question and answer exchange.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 28m
UUID: ff8870ad-d3d2-42d0-91c3-db9102b506a6
Date: 2015-04-15
Words: 3,467
As Chetsun Shenpen said in his Garland of Realizations, who among the scholars of India and Tibet was not delighted by the stages of the path. And indeed, who of sharp acumen could not be delighted by the presentation of the stages of the path in an incremental fashion, their nature, their topic, their subdivisions and so forth. How should one train in the stages of the path of the beings of the three scopes? It is not the case that these stages of the beings of the three scopes are independent and that therefore there is one training of the being of the small scope, another of the being of the middling scope, and yet another for the being of the great scope. Instead, these three stages of the path are the totality of the training, one being intent on attaining full enlightenment must train in incrementally.
So this is an instruction which the teachers give to their disciples in Lamrim Chenmo since it is a doubt which can arise. Why precisely since the trainee of Lamrim Chenmo and of the Lamrim in general is a trainee of the great vehicle, is there a presentation, for instance, of the path of the being of the small and of the middling scope? The path of the being of the small scope, for instance, is very far removed from that of the being of the great scope. And it is precisely to dispel this doubt that this is clarified. Since otherwise, one might think that one could at once start with the highest training, training one’s mind in bodhichitta without any preliminary preparation.
And obviously, if one were to proceed like this, it would be very difficult to gain any realizations. Therefore, it is necessary to initially train in the path of the being of the small scope, and this is what the Lamrim teaches. What is the rationale or the origin of this teaching? It is to be found in a stanza of Ārya Nāgārjuna in which Nāgārjuna says, initially attain higher rebirth, thereafter strive for definite excellence. In other words, one must initially try to gain realizations, for instance, in the path of the being of the small scope before progressing upwards to the path of the being of the middling scope.
Likewise, I believe it is Āryadeva who said to attain finally full enlightenment, one must scale the stairs leading to it. The stages of the path are akin to stairs. As the Kadampa Geshes said, cast your gaze in the distance, hasten not but persevere. Cast your gaze in the distance refers to focusing on the distant goal of full enlightenment, which is far removed from us. Hasten not refers to avoiding becoming harried and nervous at the prospect of such a goal.
Persevere refers to practicing uninterruptedly. And this is great advice since the Kadampa Geshes of yore were practitioners of tremendous experience. Cast your gaze afar, hasten not and persevere. When one drinks tea, for instance, to enjoy one’s tea, one has to drink it a little sip at a time. And when one wants to overcome one’s enemies in war, one kills them one at a time.
And when one wants to scale a mountain pass, one scales it one step at a time. There are numerous examples like this. When one drinks one’s tea, for instance, one drinks it a little sip at a time. Otherwise, if it is very hot, one will just burn one’s tongue. It is therefore extremely important to study continually and regularly.
As Geshe Dromtönpa said, one should persevere like the flow of a river. In other words, uninterruptedly. Then for a being who is striving for full enlightenment for the sake of others, in other words, a practitioner of the great vehicle, It is indispensable to have first trained in the practice of the being of the middling vehicle. The reasons for this we will leave aside at presence since the topic we are focusing upon is the actual practice of the being of the middling scope. For a practitioner to engage in the practice of the being of the middling scope, it is indispensable to have had initially pure realizations, fully qualified realizations of the practice of the being of the small scope.
So it does not mean this is not the case, that it is indispensable to have for a person to have fully characterized realizations of the being of of the small scope before engaging and gaining fully characterized realizations in the practice of the being of the middling scope and likewise to have fully characterized realizations of the being of the middling scope before engaging in the practice of the being of the great scope. Since there are beings who enter directly in the practice of the being of the middling scope and become. Nonetheless, the general presentation of the beings wishing to train in the stages of the path is that they should progress from the path of the being of the small to the middling to the great scope. So we must understand through careful study the reason for which it is indispensable to have fully characterized realizations of the being of the small scope before training in the path of the being of the middling scope and so forth. This is akin to studying carefully a sport such as horse riding or football and understanding how to ride or how to play football before engaging in the sport.
If one does this, one will know the rules. Then you probably know the reason for which to obtain fully characterized realizations of the being of the small scope, it is necessary to obtain fully characterized realizations of the being of the middling scope, it is necessary to have first had fully characterized realizations of the being of the small scope. If you do know the answer, please give your answer in few words and clearly. It’s a question I’m asking you. Why do you need to have fully realizations of the being of the small scope to give rise to fully characterized realizations of the being of the middling scope?
So you should put it clearly. This life is the object of abandonment of the being of the small scope and cyclic existence is the object of abandonment of the being of the middling scope. It is not possible to see the faults of cyclic existence without seeing the faults of this life and then turning away from the vanities of this life. So it is important to understand the necessity for the preliminary generation of the realizations of the being of the small scope before generating the realizations of the being of the middling scope. And this can be understood as follows.
The being of the middling scope wishes to relinquish his inner contaminations. These inner contaminations are the contaminations of the aggregates. The aggregate of form, sensation, discrimination, composition of factors and consciousness which are subsumed within his person. To be able to relinquish or turn away from these inner contaminations, one must turn away from outer objects of attachment first, such as clothing, food, gob and so forth. Why is this the case?
This is the case because those elements such as the aggregates which are included within our continuum, within ourselves, count much more for us than exterior objects. And because what is included within our continuum counts much more for us, there is much greater craving and attachment to it than towards exterior objects. This is something which I think is difficult for you to understand. And you can see that it is extremely difficult to counter the afflictions which are within ourselves without initially having countered the exterior objects, such as food, clothing, garb, and so forth, to which we are attached. Simply because however hard we try to counter the afflictions within ourselves, if we have not countered these exterior objects first, the afflictions are constantly turned outwards.
So to turn the mind inwards, we must first counter these exterior objects. It is important to understand here that at present, it is difficult for us to abandon completely clothing, food, garb, and so forth. What is being referred by countering these is not to dedicate oneself to focus a 100% on these. This is clearly explained in the great stages of the path. This is something which I explained previously.
At present, focused on our happiness, we identify our happiness with physical happiness and consider that physical happiness arises independence on the five sense objects. Now it is clear that however sated we may be with the five sense objects, it will be impossible for this alone to make us permanently happy. We also need mental happiness. And understanding this, we turn inwards. If we look at it in this way, it’s a very helpful way of seeing things.
So we can see for ourselves that from the moment we rise in the morning, all our thoughts are focused exclusively on exterior happiness, So we can see for ourselves that it is only when we are able to turn our way our mind away from the five coarse objects of the senses, that it becomes possible as a result of this to turn the mind inwards. For so long as the mind is focused on the five coarse sense objects, it is distracted and we call this agitation. When it is focused inwards, then that state is probably akin to that of the being of the middling scope. That is why it is indispensable to initially train in the path of the being of the small scope before training in the path of the being of the middling scope. This is the reason for which the preliminary realizations are necessary to give rise to the latter realizations when one progresses in the path of the being of the small and the middling scope.
And this is the reason for which the latter realizations arise in dependence on the preliminary ones. It is extremely important to understand the necessary relationship between the path of the being of the small and the middling scope. Now the object of realization of the path of the being of the middling scope is liberation or complete freedom. Now we can utter these words, liberation, complete freedom, the attainment of the state of an Arhat. I believe we can utter them, but it’s a very different matter to know their meaning.
It’s therefore their meaning which has to be explained. So what is liberation, tharpa, in Tibetan? Liberation is nothing else but being free after one had initially been bound. So what do we mean when we say we are bound? At present, under the force of karma and of klesha, of affliction.
We accumulate the causes which are requisite for the fact that at the end of this life, instead of our life being or continuum being interrupted, we will actually enter into another set of contaminated aggregates. This is the bound state we are in at present. To sever, to cut that continuum, and to no longer have to do this, that is liberation. So will it be the case that this boundary between the continuum of the present contaminated aggregates and the next set of contaminated aggregates will be severed naturally and by itself. No, this will not be the case.
It can only be severed through the application of the requisite antidotes. For ordinary beings such as ourselves, the present continuum is linked to contaminated continuums through the power of afflictions. And for that matter, even if one attains the state of an arya being, one still does have karma and afflictions within one’s mind stream. And for so long as one has not attained the state of an arhat they can continue to cause such rebirths. Here, when we refer to the antidote, we are referring to wisdom.
In other words, to the wisdom which realizes selflessness or emptiness. This must go back to the root of the afflictions which is none other than ignorance. And in as much as the mode of apprehension of ignorance and the mode of apprehension of the wisdom realizing selflessness are directly opposite As the wisdom realizing selflessness increases in strength, ignorance automatically decreases in power until it completely disappears. Then when, through the power of such a wisdom realizing selflessness, ignorance has totally disappeared, one is said to have attained the state of an and is no longer under the sway of karma and afflictions. Then you might wonder at this point, after all, when one becomes an arhat, certainly at the beginning, one has the same body as before and this is a contaminated body.
So what has happened? Indeed, the body is the same, it is still a contaminated body. What has been eliminated is not physical suffering. What has been eliminated is mental suffering. Physical suffering is still present, but physical suffering is nothing.
You can eliminate it with an injection or something like that. It’s not the case where we have attained the state of an Arhat that suddenly our body becomes very powerful and very handsome. There is no relationship whatsoever. The body doesn’t change. What changes is the mind.
And at that point, there is no mental suffering of any type. It is totally eliminated. So at this point, we shall generate for couple of seconds the requisite motivation to receive these teachings, which should be to reflect on the meaning of liberation and on the possibility of attaining it. The topic which is explained clearly both in Je Tsongkhapa’s Great Stages of the Path and Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand is a not very long sections, so we could read them as well. And therefore, let us think after reflecting on the qualities of liberation, I shall generate a mind striving for liberation.
And with this in mind, I shall study the stages of the path. In addition, at this juncture, one should point out that there are different objects of attainment for each of the paths of the beings of the three scopes. The object of attainment for the path of the being of the small scope is obtaining a higher rebirth in the next life. The object of attainment for the path of the being of the middling scope is liberation. The object of attainment from the, of the path of the being of the great scope is full enlightenment.
Since there are three different objects of attainment, there are also three different means for these beings to attain their object of attainment. To identify the path of the being of the middling scope, it is necessary initially to identify psychic existence. And to identify psychic existence, it is necessary to identify the truth of suffering. In other words, our contaminated aggregates. So within the context of the presentation of the outline in Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path.
The first subdivision has already been covered. And the second subdivision includes identifying liberation and the means to attain this. Identifying liberation has broadly speaking been covered and the means to attain this involves identifying the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering as well as a presentation of the 12 links. Now within the second outline in keeping with Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, we have two sub outlines. The first is reflecting on the general truths of the general sufferings of cyclic existence and the second is reflecting on the specific sufferings of psychic existence.
The first outline is subdivided into an identification of the six faults of psychic existence. Now at present, the reason for which the general sufferings of psychic existence are explained can best be understood through an example. Let us imagine that an alcoholic goes to his doctor to be told by his doctor that if he continues to be intemperate in his drinking habits, he will die rapidly of some disease or other. At this point, the alcoholic to avoid a premature death will modify dramatically his way of living. Likewise for ourselves, once we understand the faults of our contaminated aggregates, we wish to be liberated from them.
Then there is an eightfold, a sixfold and a threefold presentation of suffering in Lamrim, which you can read. We won’t present them in detail here. But if we take the eightfold subdivision of suffering, it begins with the suffering of birth. And after birth, as time passes, the afflictions such as desire and when desire is inhibited or prevented from attaining its object, anger arise in the child. Likewise, the suffering of death includes, for instance, the suffering of the great wish not to die, which all experience.
Then we shall stop here for today. If you have questions, I’ll take your questions. I would like your questions to be concise and clear. Mhmm. Yeah?
Perhaps you should ask that person between drinking less alcohol and dying, what do you prefer? When there are people whom we cannot do anything for, they are not able to restrain themselves, then there’s nothing you can do for them. The only answer is they have to stop drinking and to stop using drugs. Apart from that, what is one supposed to do? Initially, one must have a relation with these people.
So if has one has some type of relation, there’s a beginning to be able to help them. If one has no relation, they won’t let you in the door. Another point.. So this is very clear in Je Tsongkhapa’s Great Stages of the Path. The outline for the practice of the being of the small scopes includes training in thoughts and engaging in the practice.
And then the criteria for having attained the realizations of the being of the small scope. The criteria for having attained the realizations of the being of a small scope is that one focuses between this life and future lives, mainly on future lives. Now at present, we only do this verbally. But when this is one’s focus and one’s behavior is in keeping with this, then one is a being of the small scope. Obviously, when you engage in work like this, the question is, are you doing it of your own free will or are you under the power of someone else?
If you’re under the power of someone else, it’s a slightly different matter, but I will think about it. So here, uninterruptedly in the gloss of that quote refers to practicing like a great river. In other words, practicing without ever severing the continuum. Some rivers will, for instance, when there is no rain, run dry. This is not how one should practice.
One should practice continually. Instance, when one studies intensively, if one is not accustomed, which is our case as beginners, one can fall ill. Then for a month or longer, one studies are interrupted. So one of the meanings of uninterruptedly is to take care of one’s health. In addition, not only should one take care of one’s physical health, but of one’s mental health as well.
One should not allow as a result of one’s studies, one one’s mind to become very up tight, very narrow. Then when it is the time to go to sleep, one should go to sleep and however long one has chosen to sleep, let us say one or two hours per night, then one should rise. And at this point study with renewed enthusiasm. There’s no benefit in studying when it’s time for sleeping. Then I know of one case of someone who was preparing his final Geshe exam, the Geluk examinations.
On Semenandrel, on Buddhist logic and who studied all night for the exam. As a result, when he had to stand the debate in the exam in the morning, he had forgotten everything as a result of lack of sleep. So this is a commentary for you on those verses. So this is a clear answer to your question about enthusiasm and practicing uninterruptedly. Therefore, one must not only take care of one’s physical health, but also one should take care of one’s mental health and this is intimately related with the practice of contentment.
If you have one question left, I’ll take one question. If one is striving to attain the state of for one’s sake alone, then this is incompatible with the practice of the Bodhisattva Yana. However, in the context of the Lamrim, these teachings on the path of the being of the middling scope are stages leading to the path of the being of the great scope. Yong de, we shall stop tonight. Thank you.
Alright.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- yana
- Literally, vehicle; a spiritual path that leads to an awakened state. The vehicle and spiritual journey depends on the attitude of the practitioner. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.