1 h 34 min · 3,874 words · 13 August 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher explains that the Lam Rim is of real benefit for future lives, not just this life, and outlines the small-scope path beginning with death and impermanence, the lower realms, and refuge. He explains pure refuge as arising from fear of lower-realm suffering and conviction in the Three Jewels’ power to protect. The talk also covers the preliminary role of precious human rebirth and of reliance on the spiritual teacher, followed by questions from students.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 35m
UUID: 08612c98-7a92-4900-a9f1-372a011a261b
Date: 2014-08-13
Words: 3,870
It is critically important both for the propounder of dharma and the listeners of dharma to generate a pure motivation. If one has not generated a pure motivation, but one teaches or listens to the dharma under the influence of the afflictions, one’s mind will derive no benefit from this. So when I ask you to generate a motivation, this means to generate the appropriate motivation and to dispel inappropriate states of mind. While it is important to listen to Lamrim teachings, one must understand the purpose of the Lamrim. The Lamrim is not of benefit for this life.
The Lamrim is of benefit from the next life onwards. It is therefore for future lives, one should listen to the teachings. And therefore, there are two types of persons who attend Lamrim teachings. Those who mistakenly think that the Lamrim is of benefit for this life, and who attend teachings for that reason, and those who attend teachings trying to engage in the Lamrim for the benefit of future life after future life after future life. Then for those who mistakenly believe that the Lamrim is of benefit for this life, the main practice is meditation on death and impermanence.
Likewise, for those who upon contemplating the scale of the Lamrim practices are discouraged by their duration, meditation on death and impermanence is extraordinarily helpful. Then when the mind is beset by afflictions such as desire and anger, one can either meditate as was explained on the nine cycles of breathing meditation or alternatively, meditating on death and impermanence is extremely heavy literally to transform such a state of mind. Let us now please generate the motivation for a couple of minutes. When you reflect on the Lam Rim, you should start with reflections on the path of the being of the small scope. And here, is important to understand where the path of the being of the small scope begins.
The path of the being of the small scope begins with meditation on death and impermanence. And the reflections on the precious human rebirth, is subdivided into three, identifying a precious human rebirth, reflecting on its great meaningfulness, and reflecting on its rarity are preliminaries to the meditation on death and impermanence. So if one counts these three preliminaries as well as meditation on death and impermanence, the suffering of the lower realms, karma and causality and refuge, then there are seven cycles of meditation on the path of the being of the small scope. However, the actual topic, the foundational topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope are fourfold. They are first death and impermanence, then the sufferings of the lower realm, then refuge, and then karma and causality.
So death and impermanence and the suffering of the lower realms have been explained. We have at present reached a topic of refuge. Then in as much as the three cycles of meditation on the precious human rebirth, identifying the precious human rebirth, its great meaningfulness and its rarity are means or causes for giving rise to the path of the being of the small scope. They are or they can be included within the path of the being of the small scope. Then when we reflect on the precious human rebirth initially, as was explained, one identifies this human rebirth, which is endowed with the eight leisures and the ten endowments.
And in our case, probably one can say, we have a complete such human rebirth. Then one meditates on joy. After this, one reflects that as is explained, one can achieve all one’s contingent and all one’s ultimate goals in dependence on such a rebirth. Then regarding the third outline of the precious human rebirth, its rarity, when reflecting on it, a doubt could indeed arise within one’s mind. One might say after all, just how rare is such a human rebirth if there are 7,000,000,000 human beings on this earth.
When we refer to a human rebirth of leisure and endowment, we are not referring to an ordinary human rebirth or to a human base. We are referring to a human rebirth which has the eight leisures and the ten endowments. And such a rare basis in that of the eight leisures and the ten endowments enables us to accomplish whatever we wish to accomplish. Then one turns to meditating on the cycle of death and impermanence, which has been explained in greater detail. Meditating on death in impermanence has as a goal to turn us away from the vanities of this life.
Vanities in Tibetan means what is senseless, what is meaningless. And in this context, upon turning away from the vanities of this life, what does one focus upon? One focuses exclusively on future lives. Now through understanding, as was explained, that there are only two possible destinations in future lives, higher rebirths for which one needs vast stores of merit, and lower rebirths which are caused by non virtue, one tries to attain higher rebirths. And since if one does not apply the four antidotes as well as the practice of confession and of restraint carefully, non virtuous karma will inevitably mature and lead us into lower rebirths.
After meditating on death and impermanence, one meditates on the sufferings of the lower realms, The sufferings of being reborn oneself as an animal, as a hungry ghost, and as a hell being. Then there is, therefore, an intimate connection between each of the cycles of meditation of the lamrim, of the graduated stages of the path. Meditation on the precious human rebirth leads to that on death and impermanence, which leads to that on the lower realms, and so forth. If you have any doubt about this, if you do not understand the connection, it will be very good to ask questions now because this is an important topic. It’s not sufficient just to be verbally or mentally aware of it.
One must understand the sequence of the cycles of meditation. Then after these meditations, one naturally searches for a refuge which can protect us from this suffering. And one must search for this refuge from the very depths of one’s being. Let us take an example. Let’s imagine we have fallen into a tumultuous river and are being borne along and desperately are trying to reach the other shore before we drown.
We need to find somebody who can help us. An animal will be unable to do so. We need a human being who understands the way to cross the river and reach dry land. He or she must accept to do this, must accept to help us. What would be such a refuge such a refuge would be the teacher of the dharma, Buddha, the dharma which he taught, and those who lead to that dharma, the Sangha.
Then once one has turned away or relinquished the vanities of this life, at which point will we be one be in a situation where one will no longer be reborn in the lower realms. This is said to happen at the level of forbearance of the path of preparation. However, one will have abandoned the causes for such a rebirth at the level of the path of seeing. And therefore, one searches for a protector, a refuge which can protect us from the sufferings of the lower realm. And one must generate 100% certainty, definiteness that the triple gem can do this.
And at present, we have reached the cycles of meditation focusing on refuge. Now these cycles of meditation focus on the generation of pure refuge after having meditated on one’s own suffering in the lower realms. Generally speaking, refuge should be explained before this. Why is it explained at this point? Because here, one is not focusing on mere refuge, which all of us probably have, but on the generation of pure refuge.
When all of us have some sort of refuge, but, we do not have careful refuge. We do not have pure refuge. As I said, it is independence on the two causes that pure refuge is generated and it is stable. In our case, where we may have some type of refuge, it is not stable. Why is this refuge referred to as pure refuge?
It is referred to as pure refuge because it arises from pure causes. Its two pure causes are, first, the fear of the specific and the general sufferings of cyclic existence. In other words, the fear of the lower realms, suffering of the lower realms, and the fear of the general sufferings of cyclic existence. And in addition to that, the conviction that the triple gem has the power to protect us from this. If these two causes are present in our mind stream, we will have pure refuge, otherwise not.
So these are the two causes of refuge, which lead us to taking refuge in the Buddha jewel, the Dharma jewel, and the Sangha jewel. Therefore, fear of one’s own suffering in the three lower realms and the conviction that the triple gem has the power to protect us are the causes for pure refuge. If one has refuge, this is a measure of being a Buddhist. Why is this the case? So one becomes a Buddhist.
Can you tell me why? Very, Richard. I think it’s because one believes that Buddha, his Dharma and the Sangha can take one to enlightenment for the benefit of others. The reason for being a Buddhist, Geshela is asking something different. Geshela is asking why refuge makes you a Buddhist.
Why taking refuge, makes you a Buddhist? It makes you a Buddhist because you’re not taking refuge in anything else in any other you’re not seeking protection from Christ or from any worldly things. You’re seeking protection from the Buddha and the Dharma. The reason that taking refuge makes you a Buddhist is that by fearing the suffering of the lower realms and cyclic existence, one makes that transition from the lower to the middling scope where one wishes to liberate oneself from cyclic existence and by liberating oneself from cyclic existence one has become a Buddhist. Really?
Upon seeing the suffering of saṃsāra and wishing to be free of it, one takes refuge in the cessation of that suffering and the path to that cessation and so in that way one becomes a Buddhist. You are answering the question of why taking refuge for a practitioner of the middling scope would lead to the attainments you mentioned, which in law indeed hinge on the wisdom realizing selflessness. That is not my question. My question is why taking refuge for a practitioner of the small scope turns that practitioner into a Buddhist? Taking refuge is the gateway to Buddhism.
It’s the start. It’s the yep. It’s how you enter on the path to enlightenment. It’s accepting the triple gem. It’s the gateway to Buddhism.
What is the reason? Because on this basis I’m sorry, I can’t hear you. On this basis, we can overcome our aggregates which bind us to saṃsāra and on this basis Please. On this basis, we can overcome our aggregates which bind us to saṃsāra and on this basis, we can close the door on saṃsāra. Overcome our aggregates?
Maybe the reason is that by taking refuge one is able to start the practice of dharma which is lessening the afflictions? In taking refuge in the triple gem, one takes no other refuge, and one discards all other tenant systems. So my question is the following. We’re not talking, as some of you have mentioned, of the practices of the being of the middling or the great scope. They have their individual refuge.
We’re talking of refuge in the context of the path of the being of the small scope. And pure refuge in the path of the being of the small scope has two causes. These two causes are fear of one’s own suffering in the future in lower realms, and the conviction that the triple gem has the power to protect us from these sufferings. Independence on these two causes, one takes refuge. Now my question is, is this something which happens from one’s own side?
Does it happen from the side of the triple gem? What does it mean when we say that this turns us into a Buddhist? Good. The reason why, based on those two those two the fear and the conviction that taking refuge makes one a Buddhist. And this is something that happens within one’s own mind, is that one to one degree of force or another, one commits oneself to following the path that the Buddha took to freedom.
I guess we’re not even talking about freedom at this point. Taking taking committing oneself to following the path of the Buddha as explained in the teachings and as with the guidance of of the followers, the Sangha. It’s it’s by it’s by orienting one’s mind through commitment to those three, adherence to those three that one becomes One is convinced that the triple gem has the power to protect one from falling into the lower realms. The Buddha has the ability to protect one and so that’s why one has legitimate faith that Buddha has overcome death and fear and therefore has the capacity to teach us and to protect us. By taking pure refuge one creates stability in one’s mind and it’s this stability that is the cause that is sorry this is it’s this stability which gives one the pure refuge and that is veritably like being able to stably walk on the path.
To stably walk on the path. To stably, to walk on the path with stability. I think the reason is because one reaches this point having flirted with and considered all the quandaries of life and accepts that there is no way out except through taking refuge. So it’s a point of commitment rather than just an intellectual exercise on the vagaries of life. I think as we are getting another shot at this, I thought I’d have another shot at it too.
Is it we it happens from one’s own side and refuge is the commitment to be living for future lives, to be practicing for future lives. Another go. And That’s three. Can I have another go? Next.
Maybe later. This is a question which Atisha asked, and Atisha said that refuge was rare indeed. Then there are several answers, broadly speaking, I would say there are three answers. The first is that, as we shall see later, upon taking refuge, one accepts the refuge precepts. Then the refuge precepts really make one a Buddhist.
The second answer is that upon taking refuge, one becomes literally a follower of the Buddha. So one says in a sense, whoever you go, I will go to. In that sense, one becomes a Buddhist. The third reason is that while at present we have only spoken of the causal refuge, there are two types of causal of refuges, causal and effect refuge. Now the effect refuge entails generating within one’s own mind stream these three objects of refuge, the Buddha gem, the Dharma gem, and the Sangha gem.
In so doing, one becomes one’s own refuge. As Pänchen Rinpoche says, there are three types of refuges, the refuge of the being of small, middling, and great scope. The refuge of the being of small scope is to go for refuge for protection against one’s own suffering in the lower realms. The refuge of the being of middling scope is to go for refuge for protection against one’s own sufferings in cyclic existence. The refuge of the being of the great scope is to go for refuge out of being unable to withstand the sufferings of others in cyclic existence.
Then this is on refuge. I have asked you some questions. At turn, I will take a couple questions from you. Just a point of clarification. If precious human rebirth, the the three cycles of meditation on precious human rebirth are not included technically in the topics, the four topics being of the small scope.
Is that because this, the meditations on the precious human rebirth are dealt with in the introduction to the scopes as motivation for listening to your teachings on the Lam Rim at all? I wouldn’t say they are an introduction. They are a means to enter in the practice of the being of the small scope. It is said in the outline that it is through these meditations on the precious human rebirth that one takes the essence of a human rebirth. Mhmm.
That they incite one to take the essence of a human rebirth. Visually, I’m not sure why meditation on karma and causality would not come after the meditation on death and impermanence because it is the consequence of what happens after one dies that is related to an understanding of Karma that is that non virtue leads to rebirth in the lower realms. I mean, personally that link for me has always been helpful. Is there a reason why it’s not put at that point? I’ll answer next time.
Likewise I’ve been wondering about reliance on the spiritual teacher coming before the precious human rebirth, because my understanding with the precious human rebirth is that you wouldn’t think of relying on a spiritual teacher or even seeking a spiritual teacher unless you had a precious human rebirth in the first place and had some understanding that having a spiritual teacher was of some importance. The reason for this is that to attain either the higher rebirth or liberation from cyclic existence, one must rely on the unmistaken instructions of somebody. And this person whose unmistaken instructions we rely upon are the is a spiritual teacher. Therefore, reliance on the spiritual teacher is presented before the topic of the precious human rebirth. My question actually comes from the discussion we had before we were asked to set a motivation and that was Geshela suggested that those who mistakenly think that the Lamrim benefits this life are mistaken.
My humble reading of the Lamrim suggests that the benefits are instantaneous for this life and for all future lives. So could Geshela explain where I’ve gone wrong? You’re quite right. If you start thinking about future lives, you will be benefited in this life. It’s the excellent culmination of recognition of this..
I was telling Geshela, I have had direct experience of this and I would mention it to you with his permission. When I was in Dharamshala, a Danish doctor who specialized in the treatment of the victims of torture came to see me because Delek Hospital has a special section for the Tibetan refugees who’ve escaped or been liberated from the Chinese jails after torture. And this Danish doctor was not a Buddhist, but he told me he had worked with victims of torture in Argentina and Chile, and there were systematically major mental problems as a result of torture, which lasted for years off in the life of the patient, and he did not see this in the subjects of Delek Hospital. And he asked me why this was the case, why the Tibetans. There was huge physical damage, but there was no mental damage.
And I told him to come to see me at Sera Je Monastery and spend some time there. Then he came down and he spent a month, and after a month we met again, and he said to me, I now understand that he can never become a Buddhist. It is their their method of mental training, which prevents the torture from damaging the mind. And he actually wrote it up for a scientific paper. He told me he would send me a copy.
He never did, but I believe it’s published. So, of clarification. If the reliance on the guru and precious human rebirth lie outside the presentation of beings of small scope, middle scope, and great scope, how should they be characterized? I view them as preliminaries to the practice of the being of the small scope. Reliance on the spiritual teacher and the cycle of meditations on the precious human rebirth are not included in the practice of the being of the small scope.
Keshe la, with reference to the sequence of meditation, is it okay to meditate on any particular topic at any given time? Everything depends on the amount of time at your disposal. If you have little time, meditate on whatever you can. If you have time, it will be of great benefit to you to meditate in sequence incrementally. I just thought of a question.
I’m not familiar with refuge, but is the act of refuge, is the act of taking refuge the thing, or is applying the teachings of the three jewels? Applying Is the teachings or the act of taking refuge that you meant first in the lower realms? This is a good question. There is much more to taking refuge than just going to refuge. We will be talking about the refuge precepts, the prescriptive precepts, in other words, which must be practiced, and the proscriptive precepts, in other words, what must be abandoned.
I I want to ask a question about the sudden death. Like the MH17, people die in the crash. Do they when is sudden death like that, people like a There is no certainty about the rebirth in the case of sudden death. Yours is a very good question. I’m going to think about it, and I’d like to answer next week.
Geshele, you said that once having turned away from the vanities of life, one is assured of a higher rebirth, and then you mentioned briefly the path of preparation and seeing, but I lost the connection. So roll from the level of forbearance of the from level of forbearance of the path of preparation, one will no longer be reborn in the lower realms. It is only at the level of the path of seeing that one has the inner certainty that one will not be reborn in the lower realms. Then regarding Susan’s question, it is very important precisely because we have no control over what may happen to us when we’re in a car or in a plane or going someplace, that as we go through life, we go through life in a virtuous frame of mind. Then if something untoward happens, we die in a virtuous frame of mind and have a higher rebirth.
Just before we break up, there’s an important announcement. There will not be a teaching next Wednesday night. That’s because Ilya is going to become an Aussie. So he has a special lesson in citizenship. He’s got to drink billy tea and eat lamingtons.
No, only joking. So there will be a pooja here as usual at five and then if people want to gather to have an informal discussion about any of the teachings then the center will be open. We will be sending an email out but just so that you know. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- causal refuge
- The objects of refuge - the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha - existing in the mental continua of others, as opposed to resultant refuge. Only by relying upon these external refuge objects can we achieve our own internal resultant refuge. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is it acceptable to meditate on any single topic at any time, or should the sequence of meditation be followed?
It depends on how much time you have. If you have little time, you can meditate on whatever topic you are able to. If you have time available, it is of great benefit to meditate in sequence, going step by step, building up incrementally through the topics in order.