Lam Rim – 2014-06-18 – KR

1 h 33 min · 3,263 words · 18 June 2014

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2014-06-18 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teaching contrasts dharma practice with mundane activity, arguing that mental happiness is infinite while physical happiness is finite, so contentment and lasting mental well-being are the real aims. It then explains how to meditate on death and impermanence using the nine-point cycle: death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, and only dharma benefits at death. A short question session follows, covering bodhichitta and the infinite nature of mental happiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 33m

UUID: e5063130-ef8c-4c96-b675-3ddcdae99b85

Date: 2014-06-18

Words: 3,259

Mhmm. Irrespective of whether one refers to dharma activities or mundane activities, and by dharma activities, one is to understand dharma practice. Their goal is actually similar. The goal of dharma in mundane activities is happiness as well as the elimination of suffering. In comparison to those whose sole focus is mundane happiness and the realization of mundane goals, we can say that the practice of a dharma practitioner is superior.

Otherwise, things would be rather odd. While we are not saying that the practice of a dharma practitioner is superior to the activities of a mundane person, clearly, the mind of a dharma practitioner is a mind which is more perfect, which in a certain sense is harder. Do you understand? Good. Whereas, whether one engages in dharma activities or mundane activities, the goal of happiness is the same.

Nonetheless, within these activities, there are great differences. From within the suffering which we wish to dispel and the happiness which we wish wish to realize, there are clearly two components, physical and mental suffering and physical and mental happiness. It is when we analyze how to dispel them and how to realize the ones we wish to realize that we will see there is important differences. We can understand clearly the necessity of generating mental happiness. When we see that irrespective of how good, how perfect, literally, our material situation is, irrespective of how good our house, our health and so forth are, there is there are still difficulties one encounters.

If it was possible for physical happiness to eliminate mental suffering, then once we obtained perfect food, garb, and facilities, we would expect it to totally eliminate mental suffering. This is clearly not the case. We can clearly see that whereas mental happiness is infinite and physical suffering is finite, since it is possible to reduce it to zero, the opposite is true as far as physical happiness and physical suffering are concerned. Do you understand finite? Good?

What do we mean when we say that physical happiness is finite or measurable? What’s the end? What’s the conclusion? And all of us have direct experience of the fact that physical happiness is finite. For instance, if we were hungry and were to eat a meal and ate an immeasurable infinite amount, this would create suffering.

We have to eat within measure. Likewise, if we were thirsty and were to drink an immeasurable amount, then this would lead to stomachache. We must drink within measure. When you have direct experience of this with reverse cycle air conditioners, when you are cold to counter the cold, you put the air conditioner, the reverse cycle air conditioner on its warm setting. Then if you keep it on its warm setting for an indefinite period of time, then suffering will definitely arise.

So we can say that as far as the physical component is concerned, physical pleasure, physical happiness is finite or measured, and physical suffering is immeasurable or infinite. On the other hand, mental happiness is immeasurable or infinite. For instance, it is said in Śāntideva’s bodhisattvacharyavatara, if one generates bodhichitta, one progresses from happiness to happiness. Indeed, if one gives rise to bodhichitta for even one day, then one can only progress from happiness to greater happiness. And therefore, mental happiness is immeasurable or infinite, whereas physical, excuse me, mental suffering is finite since when one applies the discordant factors, one can cause it to be reduced to zero.

Then the bodhichitta, the love, the compassion, which set us under the sway of others, give rise to a mental happiness, which is infinite in its scope. Then we should reflect why it is the case that having assembled all of the requisite conditions for dharma practice, nonetheless, we experience difficulties. And this is the direct result of discontentment with one’s own present happiness, discontentment with the food one can obtain, the clothing one can obtain, and one’s general wealth. This discontentment in turn gives rise to desire and to anger. And therefore, it is contentment with one’s own happiness, which is the foremost means to counter concurrent short term afflictions.

Then one should train in contentment with respect to food, with respect to clothing, to one’s general wealth, even to one’s status. Then if one is able to do this, one eliminates all problems. Otherwise, with discontentment, only problems will arise. Then this is something one has to think about. There are not there are very few who do not really understand this.

What is the source of such contentment, such satisfaction with one’s present lot, with one’s happiness? It is recollection of death and impermanence. And not merely recollection of death and impermanence, but an understanding of death and impermanence. The totality of the cycles of meditation of the practitioner, the being of the small scope are linked or encounter with the meditation on death and impermanence. So through meditating on this, one does actually train in the path of the being of the small scope.

At present, we should meditate on this, and through this, the motivation will arise. If one is able to cover these topics of meditation, then thereby one will have generated the motivation of the being of the small scope. And if one attends Lamrim teachings with this motivation, one will be attending them with the motivation of a being of the small scope. Then let us generate the motivation. We are at present covering the path of the being of the small scope, and one must identify what the path of the being of the small scope is, how it is practiced, and for this one needs an example, an instance.

Then Do not please open Lamrim Chenmo, the greater stages of the path to find an example of the being of the small scope. That isn’t okay. What example would you give of a being of the small scope? So what example would you give of the path of the being of the small scope? So I would not like an example of a person but of the path.

No person. The path is shared with Buddhadharma path is shared with Christian Islam and other traditions because it’s, the path is considering or practiced from the next life onwards. I was asking for an example. Would it be meditation on death and impermanence? Putting into practice the right view, right intention, right speech, right everything.

I was thinking of I can’t think in terms of avoiding lower rebirths. The five precepts? Five precepts?

Yeah. Lay vows. Sorry? Lay vows. Yes.

You can just say the five precepts or lay vows. No need to mention practice. Language. A future student. Is it the conscious abandonment of the 10 non virtues and the cultivation of their opposites conjoined with patience and something else that I’ve forgotten conjoined with patience?

Then generally speaking, a path must be a consciousness. So some of you proposed persons, a path must be a consciousness, and the path of the being of the small scope would be the realization of the verse in Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path. Through reflecting repeatedly on the fact that this life is short, turn away from the vanities of this life. Then since the path of the being of the small scope is necessarily a consciousness, the examples you could give would be the concentration focused on death and impermanence within the mental continuum of a being who has renounced the vanities of this life, or the wisdom focused on death and impermanence within the mental continuum of a being who has renounced the vanities of this life, or the ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non virtues within the mental continuum of a being who has renounced the vanities of this life. Otherwise, it is very odd because you can’t really answer the question, is such a path present or not within our mind stream?

Then merely stating, turning away from the vanities of this life would probably be appropriate and then the ethics of the abandonment of the ten non-virtues within the mental continuum of such a being would be an instance of the path of the being of the small scope. Or for instance, generosity, ethics, forbearance, enthusiasm, concentration and wisdom within the mental continuum of a being who has turned away from the vanities of this life. And therefore, the foremost source of contentment with one’s lot, with one’s happiness is recollection of death and impermanence. Kyabje Pabongkha Rinpoche repeatedly instructed his disciples to meditate. Meditate, he would say.

Meditate. Now meditation does not mean only focusing single pointedly on an object. There are numerous forms of meditation. We have analytical meditation, we have concentration meditation and so forth. Then when you are instructed to meditate on death and impermanence, to meditate on death, just how do you meditate on death?

Explain how you meditate analytically. And that to So setting aside the advantages of meditating on death and the disadvantages of not meditating on death, which have already been presented, the actual meditation on death, which is the third outline, is subdivided into two, reflecting on the nine cycle death meditation and meditating on the aspects of death. The first is subdivided into three, reflecting on the fact that death is certain, reflecting on the fact that the time of death is uncertain, and reflecting on the fact that at the time of death, apart from dharma, nothing whatsoever is of benefit. One is said to have a natural experience, a spontaneous experience of death when one constantly thinks, what will happen to me when I die? What will happen to me when I die today, if I die tomorrow, and so forth?

And the meditation on the nine cycle, meditation of death hinges first on meditating on the three roots. Each of these three roots is subdivided in turn into three reasons. So the first root that death is certain is subdivided into three reasons, which are that the Lord of Death will definitely come and that no condition whatsoever can hinder his coming. Secondly, that nothing is being added to one’s life and time is only being subtracted from one’s life. And the third reason is that, while alive, one even at that time is unable to find the leisure to practice dharma.

Do not be afraid of meditation on death. The goal is not to inflict hardship upon yourselves, but instead, before death comes, to prepare yourselves so that you will experience happiness. Then regarding the first root that death is definite, the first reason which is advanced is that let alone leading a long life, there is no way to eliminate death. This is self evident and we can formulate this as a syllogism. It follows that my death is definite or is certain because there is no way to prevent it.

There is no way to eliminate the conditions which give rise to my death. Regarding the second reason, it is self evident that time is not being added to our lifespan, but that time is uninterruptedly being subtracted from our lifespan. One could say, to put things bluntly, that at the very instant of birth, we have already decided to die and started to die. Then this can be formulated also as a syllogism. It follows that my death is certain because no time is being added to my life, and time is uninterruptedly being subtracted from it.

Then reflecting on this over and again, one generates a sense of the definiteness of one’s death. This is something we all know but do not think about, and we do not think about it because of the apprehension of our own permanence, the sense, I will be around, I will be alive for a long time. And the third reason within the first root is that even when alive, we lack the leisure to practice dharma. Then, in this context, we should recollect the anecdote attributed to Geshe Potowa, who said, most of us like this man who for the first twenty years of his life was unable to practice dharma, for the following twenty years kept saying, I will practice it, I will practice it, and for the last twenty years said, I should have, I should have. Let us therefore reflect a couple minutes on the two main lines of reasoning establishing that death is certain.

The first, the predicate, death or my death is certain because of the reason there are numerous causes contributing to my death. And the second reason, my death is certain, which is a predicate because of the reason no time whatsoever is being added to my life lifespan, and time is uninterruptedly being subtracted from my lifespan. So we shall engage in analytical meditation on this, in other words, think about this for a couple of minutes. And therefore, after meditating on the three reasons of the first root, we should generate a powerful sense that our own death is certain, is definite. At this point, we meditate on the second root that the time of our death is uncertain, and three reasons as well are advanced for this.

The first is that in Jambudvipa and specifically during the age of degeneration, lifespan is uncertain. The second is that there are numerous causes for death and few causes for life, and the third is that one’s body is extraordinarily weak. Now regarding the second reason that there are numerous causes for death and few causes for life, this is evident. In addition, we can say that most of the causes for life, such as food and drink, can also turn into causes for an untimely death. So the causes for death are far more numerous than the causes for life.

Regarding the third reason that one’s body is extraordinarily weak, this is also self evident if we reflect upon it. Our body is said in a sūtra to be akin to a butter lamp flickering in a strong wind. It is astonishing that it lasts at all. Reflecting on these strong reasons, these three reasons, we give rise to a strong sense that the time of one’s death is completely uncertain. And therefore, we shall at present meditate for a couple seconds on the second route that the time of death is uncertain through analyzing the three reasons for this route.

So when we refer to the fact that the time of death is uncertain, we mean that there is no certainty that the parents will die before their children. There is no certainty that the young will die long after the elders. Then if you reflect carefully on these two main roots, that the time of that death is certain, and that the time of death is uncertain, eventually an experience will arise. And with this experience, the sort of death will never be far removed from you. If we gain such an experience of death and impermanence, then we will naturally turn away from the vanities of this life.

This is the result of this experience of death and impermanence. For instance, if someone is on the point of being executed, of being shot for instance, and a large number of people out of compassion for him say, you are going to be facing great difficulty, great torment, Allow us to make you presents and give him a large number of very expensive gifts. Probably no desire at all will arise in his mind. So this is a criterion of having had an experience of death and impermanence. Then what should we do?

It is at this point that the third root comes into play. At the time of death, nothing is of benefit apart from dharma. And there is a stanza in the 37 practices of a bodhisattva by Togme Sangpo referring to the fact that at the time of death, nothing whatsoever is of benefit, whether awake or asleep, we will still die. And specifically, the three reasons given are that wealth is of no benefit, relatives are of no benefit, and one’s own body is useless. Then when one reflects on this over and again, there will be definite benefit.

While there may not be benefit in the physical component of the death process, there will be great benefit in the mental component, and this will lead to a great increase in contentment with one’s own lot. And after all, it is the mental component which is the most important. Then when it is said that you should meditate, it is in death and impermanence that you should meditate, and you should meditate on it with analytical meditation, going over the topics of meditation over and again. Then if you do this, it is certain that you will experience no hardship at the time of death. Are you going to meditate on death and impermanence?

Really? 100%? Very important, you know? Then it is all explained in liberation in the palm of your hand. Since we don’t have the time to enter the enter the detail of the text, which is very extensive, just read it by yourselves.

It is very clear. So the main topic today was the actual manner of meditating on death and impermanence, which is subdivided, as you remember, into two. The first topic is the nine fold cycle of meditation on death and impermanence. This is not difficult. There’s only nine outlines, three routes, three reasons for each route.

Try to meditate on it. I will take one or two questions. With meditating on death and impermanence, I find I have a more intellectual understanding. How does one go beyond that intellectual understanding I have explained how to do it. Now you have to go into practice.

If you reflect over and again on these topics, over and again on the presentation, the text, then you will gain experience. Mhmm. Geshe-la said the bodhichitta love and compassion which settles under the sway of others gives rise to a mental happiness which is infinite in its scope. Is this mental happiness infinite because the objects of bodhichitta, love and compassion being sentient beings are infinite or is there another reason? The reason for which this happiness is immeasurable is simply because such a type of happiness cannot be measured.

And just as the object of observation of such a love and such as such an empathy are sentient beings or living beings, which are immeasurable in number, then as a result of the fact that the object of observation is immeasurable, likewise, the love and the empathy become immeasurable or infinite. The second reason for which such happiness is measureless is because once one gives rise to a love, a bodhichitta, or a compassion, which causes one to fall under the sway of others, then one’s envy, one’s jealousy, one’s competitiveness towards others progressively dwindles, and this creates measureless happiness. Is there another question? Okay. This Sunday at five there’s a puja and His Holiness’s birthday, 70th birthday celebration on Sunday the sixth from 11:30 until approximately 02:30.

Lunch will be provided by TBI if you would like to make a donation you’re welcome. But if you could register that would just help with the catering, and you can either ring, leave a message or send an email to the office. Thank you. Cut down. Okay.

If you like, it’s in the kitchen. Is it written there? I’m not sure exactly.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
five lay vows panchashila (Skt); ge nyen gi dompa nga (Tib)
The precepts taken by lay Buddhist practitioners for life: to abstain from killing, stealing, lying, sexual misconduct and taking intoxicants. LYWA
Jambudvipa Rose-apple Land; dzam bu ling (Tib)
Of the four continents surrounding Mount Meru in Buddhist cosmology, this is the southern continent where human beings live. The other three continents are Godaniya in the west; Kuru in the north and Videha in the east. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is the mental happiness of bodhichitta, love and compassion infinite because sentient beings are infinite, or is there another reason?

Such happiness is immeasurable simply because it cannot be measured. There are also two reasons. First, the objects of observation of this love and empathy are sentient beings, who are immeasurable in number. Because the object is immeasurable, the love and empathy become immeasurable or infinite too. Second, once one gives rise to love, bodhichitta or compassion, which causes one to fall under the sway of others, one's envy, jealousy and competitiveness towards others progressively dwindle. This creates measureless happiness.

Scroll to Top