Lam Rim – 2014-06-11 – KR

1 h 42 min · 3,954 words · 11 June 2014

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2014-06-11 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk covers generating a virtuous motivation and the benefit of training in love, compassion and bodhichitta, and contrasts this with how much time is wasted each day. It then teaches the Lam Rim outline for the small-scope path, including the three roots and nine reasons for meditating on death from Pabongka’s text, and the links between small, middling and great scope paths. Questions about karma, causality and rebirth are answered at length.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 42m

UUID: 8d608398-8486-4ecc-b01a-8464a2b46971

Date: 2014-06-11

Words: 3,950

When we say that one should generate the motivation, this means that instead of allowing one’s mind to be subsumed by anger or by hatred, instead, one should orient, one should focus one’s mind towards the virtuous side of things. This is what is meant by generating a motivation. Then if your mind is always focused on virtue, you have no need to generate a particular motivation. When the mind is withdrawn from its usual wanderings and is focused on a virtuous object, therefore, one refers to generating a virtuous motivation specifically. When the mind is focused on great compassion, on empathy, on bodhichitta, then one can speak of generating a Mahāyāna motivation.

Then, if one is not only able to focus one’s mind for one hour or so on a given topic of the graduated stages of the path, but in addition, one’s mind is motivated by a virtuous motivation, then such a mind becomes very powerful and most courageous. It is said, and this is quite a profound account that the benefit accrued through meditating for one day on great love, not even bodhichitta but great love, is greater than that which was accumulated by the two arhats of the Hīnayāna, Maudgalyayāna and Shariputra, when they meditated for one eon on emptiness. Why would it be the case that meditating in our case for a mere hour on bodhichitta, love or compassion, would lead to accruing more merit than for these great arhats to meditate for a countless period of time on emptiness. This is the case because they meditated on emptiness for their own sake. Whereas, if one meditates on bodhichitta, but for that matter, emptiness for the sake of others, the merit merit accumulated is inconceivable.

As is said in Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, may I eliminate the suffering of all beings which are as vast in number as space is infinite in its expanse. Then when we refer to altruism, literally in Tibetan, shen pen, the mind wishing to benefit others, these others whom we wish to benefit are infinite in number. To train in such a mind is not something which occurs easily. It can only happen incrementally over a long period of time. It is visible.

It is something which can be grounded in experience that when one trains in altruism over time, the frequency of anger which arises in our mind decreases. Indeed, anger arises with respect to another sentient being. It is rare, if not unknown, for anger to arise without an object spontaneously in the mind. And when altruism has been trained in such an anger directed to other sentient beings dwindles. Then as one’s when trains in altruism, not only does anger decrease, but all afflictions and mental ideations.

And, after all, afflictions systematically seem to arise independent on other independence on other sentient beings, and they will dwindle as well. Our mind, however, must be focused. It is clear that if we were just to meditate once or twice on love, empathy, and compassion, our mind would rapidly get scattered again. It must be focused and brought again and again on these topics. Then we are not talking of generating such minds for one day, one week, one month or one year, although it is possible for this to happen, but very difficult, but just for one hour.

And it is for this reason that love and compassion are said to be highly beneficial in the beginning, the middle, and the end. In the end, especially because such roots of virtue lead to the attainment of utter and full enlightenment. When one’s mind is single pointedly focused on one’s topic of meditation, this is actually what is referred to as a retreat. What is this mysterious retreat people talk about which involves staying cross legged with one’s mind wandering all over? That is not retreat.

Retreat is merely focusing one’s mind on the topic. So when one refers to generating the motivation, it refers precisely to giving rise to, bodhichitta, love and to compassion. You have studied logic. Therefore, you understand what it means to transform the mind through love and compassion. And therefore, it has generated the motivation.

I would like to examine tonight your way of thinking to see whether our ways of thinking meet or not, literally whether we are on the same wavelength or not. And I would like to ask you, So just how important is it for you to be able to buy everything you want to buy, to sell everything you want to sell, to get everything you want to get? Do I understand? Yes. Really?

Good. Who? So there is something all of us have which cannot be sold and which cannot be bought, which cannot be built like a house or anything of this nature. Now what in your opinion is it? Inner happiness can be made, can’t it?

Yes. I think that can be constructed. By built Ah. By by the word built, does it mean caused Contentment can be produced, can be manufactured. Right?

Something which cannot be produced. So some said good in nature, some said mind. Ethics can be generated. Ethics is to be protected. Time.

Chris? Hello? Then your answers are very good. They are the answers of people who have studied and who think about things. Good.

Good. Good. Good. Thank you. Time.

Time. I think time. So if you think about time and here we refer to a human life, this is something which is not for sale. It cannot be bought. It is not something which can be produced.

Otherwise, there will be no death in this world. But the answer is Buddha nature or for that matter, love and empathy are also correct. Since they are present within our constitution. Constitution. There’s a very powerful connection between this question and the path of the being of the small scope.

Since the foremost meditation and the path of the being of small the small scope is that on death and impermanence. And death precisely means that one does not dwell. So death is linked to time. Since this is something which we have, the question is to what usage should we put it? Then in one day of twenty four hours, Geshela assumes you work a full ten hours a day.

Forgive my smile. And then on top of this, you would sleep eight hours a day, which makes eighteen hours. Then probably after eight hours, you would wake up, wouldn’t you? Eight hours of sleep. Who’s gonna sleep nine hours a night?

Well, maybe there’s not great difficulty in doing that. I don’t know. I think these eighteen hours are obviously eighteen hours which are necessary since our bodies need both food and clothing. After all, they’re made of flesh. Then six hours are left.

Of these six hours, I just say two hours are spent eating, washing, taking care of one’s body, and so forth. Then an an extra four hours are left. One should examine what precisely one is doing with those four hours which are left every day. Those four hours might very well go to waste. Then in seven days, how many hours would be wasted?

Oh my god. Twenty eight hours. In one week, you will have wasted more than one day. And then if in one day you have wasted in this way lost one full day, then how much will you have lost in one year? Probably more than two months.

Exactly. Then when it is only four hours in one day, it doesn’t feel that important. When you start looking at the amount of time lost in lost in a month, it becomes much more important. And when you look at the amount of time wasted over the years, then it is very important. Then think for yourself in these four hours you have every day, what precisely are you doing?

Is it meaningful or not? Then it is a strange habit of ours that precisely because time is something we neither buy nor sell, we do not value it. And as a result, we do not value these four hours we waste every day. But imagine that, let’s say, in Australia, you were given something very valuable, let us say a spanking new computer, and then you lost that computer. What regret you would experience?

Because after all, you know how much effort it took to make a computer. And reflecting in this way and the fact that time is being wasted, we should turn time into a commodity, into a thing. And for this reason, it is critically important to prepare one’s mind beforehand not to succumb to anger, to envy, or to competitiveness towards one’s relatives, one’s friends, and those one knows. Otherwise, if one has not prepared one’s mind beforehand, then it is extremely difficult to subdue the mind once the afflictions have arisen and probably one will lose control of oneself. Very impotent.

Very impotent. So it is before these, coarse afflictions arise that one must reflect and prepare the mind because difficulties and problems do arise in families and in human relationships. It’s a given. Then to try to prevent oneself from succumbing to anger, to envy, to competitiveness when these difficulties have arisen is very difficult. Instead, one should prepare oneself beforehand, and then one is able to subdue one’s mind, and one does not utter hurtful words or harmful words where difficulties arise.

It is a tremendous benefit when one rises in the morning to reflect on these, points over and again, in keeping with the injunction given in Śāntideva’s bodhisattva Acharya Vattara in which it is said, all suffering and all harm as well as all happiness and all virtue arise from the mind. In the context of the question which I asked you last time regarding the uncommon or specific relationship between the path of the being of the middling and the path of the being of the small scope, many answered causality, karma and causality. It is important to understand that there are two different presentations of causality, that which is specific to the being of the medianscope, which is rooted in the four noble truths in keeping with the verses in Jetsün Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path, in which Jetsün Tsongkhapa says, reflecting over and again on the incontrovertibility or causality, turn away from all future existences. And in addition, in the context of the path of the being of the middling scope, those reflections on karma and causality linked to the 12 links of dependent origination. On the other hand, there is an alternate presentation of causality within the path of the being of the small scope, where one reflects on the fact that through engaging in non virtues of body, speech, mind, one can be reborn in a an evil realm in future lives.

Therefore, many of you did indeed respond that karma and causality were the uncommon link to the path of the being of the small scope. This must be qualified since, as I said, there are two presentations of karma and causality, One specific to the being of the small scope and one specific to the being of the middling scope rooted in the four noble truths and the 12 links. Now in the context of the question I ask you where we took someone and such people do exist who, by nature, views cyclic existence as essenceless, as meaningless, what precisely would be the benefit for such a person of the practice of the being of the small scope? And the answer here is impermanence. Then such a being would understand that one has no control over the timing of one’s death and the conditions of death.

And these conditions of death are intrinsically related to one’s being constituted of contaminated aggregates. This links such a person to the practice of the being of the middling scope and an understanding of the 12 links of or 12 limbs of dependent origination. Having posited, as you remember, a an uncommon relationship between the path of the being of the great scope and the path of the being of the middling scope, it would be very inappropriate if we were unable to posit an uncommon relationship between the path of the being of the middling scope and that of the being of the small scope. Now these teachings are rooted in the experience of the great pandits of ancient India who themselves practiced this and progressed through these paths. It is not a good way of training one’s mind to say, oh, well, the practice of the being of the small scope is meditating on death and impermanence.

Meditate on that, and then figure, oh, well, the practice of the being of the middling of the middling scope is meditating on interdependence and the 12 links and meditate on that with no particular relationship between the two. At present, within the context of, Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, as you remember, we have covered the six advantages of meditating on death and impermanence within the second outline and and the disadvantages of not meditating on death and impermanence, and have reached the third outline, the actual mode of recollecting death. The first, subdivision within this is recollecting death through reflecting on the three roots and the nine reasons. These are three roots for each of which three reasons are given. So in retreat, this is how would one one would proceed, focusing on one or two topics for every couple cycles of 24, every full day and days and night, in other words.

But before doing this, it would be indispensable to read the topic and to generate certainty regarding the topic. And for the three roots, in the three root and the nine reason meditation is first that death is certain, then that the time of death is uncertain, and then at the time of death, apart from dharma, nothing is of benefit. The first root that death is certain is subdivided into three, And the first reason for the fact that death is certain is that no condition whatsoever is able to counter death. This is something of which we have direct knowledge. We can see that Buddha Śākyamūni departed, his 12 followers departed, and all the great beings up to Jetsongkopal themselves left this world when their time had come.

Then the second reason is that nothing is ever being added to our life. Time is only being subtracted from our life. This is something which is very powerful when we reflect on it. When we are in our thirties, it is clear and obvious that we will live to be 70 or 80. But when we are 70 or 80, it is self evident we will live to be 100.

And when we are 100, 120 seems highly probable. This is a clear manifestation of the grasping at our own permanence. This is what is meant by grasping at one’s own permanence. This is not something which is very subtle. It is a very coarse state of mind.

This is the belief, I will live for a very long time. And the way to counter this belief that I’ll be around for a very long time is meditation on death and impermanence. Then if we were to take a member of our family who is somewhat elderly and say to that person, within ten years, for sure, you will be dead, Then this person is going to think about it. Ten years after all is is quite a bit of time, and it is very possible that this relative of ours will be unable to fall asleep through thinking about it. Now this is how one starts reflecting on death and impermanence.

So this is in brief the meaning of the second reason that nothing is being added to one’s life and time is only being subtracted. And the third reason within the first root is that while alive. we will lack the leisure to meditate on dharma. Then this is closely linked to a statement by Gungthang Rinpoche who said, those who have lived 60 years of age for the first twenty years have no clue about how to practice dharma. For the following twenty years say, I must I must practice dharma.

And for the last twenty years say, I should have I should have practiced dharma. But who is guilty of this, grasping at one’s permanence? And as Potowa Rinpoche said, it is akin to the situation of a farmer who hears that a huge flood is coming. Ideally, he is able to salvage all his crops and flocks. Otherwise, he tries at least to salvage some.

Likewise for us, ideally, we will have practiced the paths of the being of beings of all three scopes. But if that is not possible, we will try to practice those of the being of the small and the middle scope. And if that is not possible, at least that of the being of the small scope. Therefore, at present, if you have questions, Geshe-la will be very happy to answer them. When, the Bardo being has just seen the mother and father and that consciousness is about to come in, is it simply is it completely karma that choose the gender of that being is chosen when they come in and how does the gender what I guess my question is, what exactly and precisely are the conditions that cause you to come in as one gender or another as a human being?

So, yes, there is a small connection with karma. However, what mainly occurs is that when the battle being is ready to take rebirth, he or she well, the Bardo being sees the two parents in sexual union, and at this point, it is contingent on whether the Bardo being experiences hatred for the father and lust for the mother or hatred for the mother and lust for the father that he is or she is reborn as a male or female child. If the Bardo being experiences hatred for the mother and lust for the father, it will be reborn as a female. If it experiences lust for the mother and hatred for the father, it will be reborn as a male. This is what is explained in Buddhist texts.

Thank you Geshe-la. I wanted to clarify some of my notes which are notoriously unreliable. Quite some time ago, about two months ago, have written down that we need to understand the reason that the medium scope relies on the small scope is through understanding the intimate connection or uncommon relationship between key elements of the small and the medium scope. And in that time, in that teaching Geshela asked us what is this intimate connection and said that it was karma and causality. I also have written down here that there are four preliminaries to the medium scope, one is death and impermanence, one is suffering, one is karma and causality and one is refuge.

These preliminaries to the medium scope, if I have written them down correctly, are they all uncommon relationships between the small and the medium scope? So death and impermanence, suffering, karma and refuge. Yes, that is indeed the case. However, in my opinion, it is not indispensable to engage in all of these preliminary practices before entering the path of the being of the middling scope. In my opinion, death and impermanence is the uncommon connection, the specific connection, if you wish.

Just further to my previous question and the answer, tonight, does the Bardo being feel hatred or lust first in their mind stream? Does one of those emotions come first and then thus makes it the distinguishing factor for the choice of gender? Well, as is said, if one is to be reborn as a male, one feels desire for one’s mother. And if one is to be reborn as a female, one feels desire for one’s father. Therefore, probably desire comes first.

There has to be probably some type of uncommon karmic connection between the twins. Some specific karmic connection between the twins. So if we analyze the mechanism of conception, if the Bardo beings were material, clearly, they could not penetrate the womb of the mother at the time of conception. They are immaterial, and therefore, one could assume that two or even three Bardo beings could simultaneously penetrate in the womb of the mother. Thank you.

I’m not asking this question to try and find flaws in Geshela’s teaching but to try and understand his meaning. I feel quite sure and a couple of other people sort of agreed as well that last week Geshela’s answer to the uncommon connection between the small and the middle scopes was death and impermanence but I also remember him saying the uncommon relationship or connection between the small and the medium is calmer and causality I remember him using the word uncommon in both But then in answer to my question just then, he said the specific one is death and impermanence. So now I’m really confused. I’ll answer your question later. It’s a very good way to handle these ones.

So I will think about it by myself quietly, and you can reflect on it as well. It seems the best way to approach these difficult topics. Regarding karma and causality, as I mentioned, there are two presentations of karma and causality. One specific to that of the being of the small scope and one specific to that of the being of the middling scope. And we must differentiate between them to see which might be an uncommon specific relationship.

Then one has to reflect on these things, and it is very good that one does so, and one will obtain different results in function of one’s reflections. So there’s a question from a Lamrim study group, is it necessary to be a being of the small scope before being a being of the middling scope? If so, why? So the answer is, indeed, it is indispensable to have been a being of the small scope before being a being of the middling scope. Why?

Because it is necessary to have first meditated on death and impermanence. It is specifically mentioned in the outline that the topic which is being studied or presented is the path shared with the being of the small scope. Now this implies that that path shared with the being of the small scope must be traveled upon before one engages in the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Then a couple days ago, really, you said that the uncommon relationship between the path of the being of the small and the being of the middling scope was karma and causality. Then you seem to have changed your opinion since then and are referring to death and impermanence.

So I say to you, you have lost your crude assertion. The way we think about it is that what impels us to practice forcefully and swiftly on this basis of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is precisely death and impermanence. As Geshe was saying, Saga Dawa, the most important holiday of the year, a day to remember Buddha Śākyamūni. That’s a Puja at 06:00, a very auspicious day. And then on Saturday, Ilya will be presenting how to develop bodhichitta, the two methods on Saturday at 02:00.

Sorry, yes 02:00. Thank you and enjoy some chai.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What exactly are the conditions that cause a being to be born as one gender or another as a human?

There is a small connection with karma, but mainly it depends on what happens when the bardo being is ready to take rebirth. The bardo being sees the two parents in sexual union, and whether it is reborn male or female depends on the feelings it experiences at that point. If the bardo being feels hatred for the mother and lust for the father, it will be reborn as a female. If it feels lust for the mother and hatred for the father, it will be reborn as a male. This is what is explained in Buddhist texts.

Scroll to Top