1 h 34 min · 3,829 words · 7 May 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the Lam Rim’s three scopes of the path (small, middling and great), how they are shared, and the Lam Rim’s kindness in presenting the path in order. It then teaches that the main object to abandon at the small-scope level is the belief in one’s own permanence, and that meditating on death and impermanence leads to contentment with little. A student’s question about subtle impermanence is briefly taken up.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 35m
UUID: 06b82de3-a681-47dd-a140-ac7a56f2ef20
Date: 2014-05-07
Words: 3,825
In my opinion, it is beneficial to think that even though there is some difficulty in studying, hearing and reflecting on the Lamrim, Nonetheless, through generating delight in the study of the Lamrim, these difficulties will eventually disappear. This is why Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen, the precious Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen said in his canticle of realizations, the concise stages of the path, the innermost essence of the teachings. What is meant here by essence? This might be understood as referring to the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, the greater, middling and shorter Prajñāpāramitā Sutras of the middle turning of the wheel of the law. The innermost essence of the greater, middling, and shorter perfection of wisdom sutras, the Prajñāpāramitā Sutras, was transmitted downwards from Ārya Maitreya for the stages of the vast path and from Aryamanjushri for the stages of the profound path.
From the standpoint of the textual lineages, the vast lineage descends from Maitreya’s treatise, the Abhisamayālamkāra, in which the details of the vast lineage are expounded. Whereas the profound lineage descends from Nāgārjuna, who manifests these instructions of Mañjuśrī. Well, these two lineages were transmitted separately, they eventually were fused inseparably by Atisha, Dipamkara, in his treatise, The Lamp of the Path, Mhmm. Then this is the actual way things were, and when one thinks about it, it creates mental delight. I would suspect that the actual actual term, term LAMRIM stages of the path must be sourced in the lamp for the path, the Bodhipathapradīpa.
And these instructions of the lamp for the path, the Bodhipathapradīpa were transmitted downwards from Atisha, first to the Kadampas of the Nyingma tradition, the old tradition, then to the Kadampas of the Sahma tradition, the new tradition, all the way up to Je Tsongkhapa who used explicitly the term Lamrim, stages of the path. When one understands that the Lamrim presents a complete path, which in addition is unmistaken in its sequence of realization. Then one will understand why its practice is referred to by Jetsongkhapa as the innermost essence of all treatises. It’s extremely important to understand that when a being realizes that to practice the path of the being of the great scope, he or she must practice previously the path of the being of the middling scope. And to practice the path of the being of the middling scope, he or she must practice previously the path of the being of the small scope.
This is due to the kindness of the Lamrim, of the stages of the path. Likewise, renunciation, bodhichitta and the correct view are terminology from the Lam Rim. If, and I say if, Lamrim, the stages of the path did not exist, then we would have to refer back to Atisha’s lamp for the path, and the lamp for the path is translated in English, you may have read it, it is only a couple of pages long. How would we able to extend this to the totality of the teachings? It is very difficult.
If we were to set Lamrim Chenmo, the great stages of the path aside and try to rely only on Atisha’s Bodhi Patta Pradipa, literally in Tibetan, we wouldn’t be able to bite into it. It is too difficult. Then if, and I say if, our tisha’s bodhipattaparipa, the lamp for the path did not exist, where would we have to begin our practice? We would have to begin it in Maitreyas, ornament of realization, the Abhisamayālamkāra, for the method aspect of the path and we would have to begin it in Nāgārjuna’s Mūlamadhyamakakārikā, the root verses on emptiness for the wisdom aspect. Then this will only be possible for someone of the sharpest acumen.
So the verse in the canticle of realization, the innermost essence of all scriptures refers to Atisha’s Then the Lamrim, the stages of the path presents not only the totality of the path in an unmistaken way, but it presents the sequence unmistakenly and presents all of the key points precisely as they are. And therefore, we should rejoice in recollecting the kindness of instructions such as the graduated stages of the path, which enable us to posit instances for beings of the small, the middling and the great scope, as well as for renunciation, bodhichitta and the correct view. Mahatu? In Mayank’s case, in February some, His Holiness the Dalai Lama imparted the interlinked teachings of the great stages of the path and the canticle of realization in Dharamsala. And even though I had completed my studies of Buddhist logic, Pramāna, Vinaya, Buddhist discipline and Abhidharma, Buddhist metaphysics, nonetheless, I was unable to posit clearly the principles within the three principles of the path.
This is a result of not having studied in-depth the Lamrim. Then in your case, probably every single one of you can, if asked, enumerate the three principles of the path renunciation, bodhichitta and the correct view. You can do this due to the extraordinary kindness of the teacher who taught Lamrim to you. This should be a source of great rejoicing for you. Then I can say this from my own experience, had become a Geishi and yet I was unable to present the three principles of the path, and this leads to a great energy in one’s wish to study these topics.
Then if you meditate on rejoicing and delight in this concept context, it’ll be very helpful. At present, we should generate the requisite motivation. The requisite motivation to attend these teachings is to benefit others. In other words, to generate a bodhichitta based on the Lamrim. Now here it is not sufficient to think, I will study the Lamrim, this will benefit others.
Your studying the Lamrim is totally irrelevant to others. It does not benefit them in the slightest. It is on the basis of your study of Lamrim, if you resolve to benefit others, that such benefit will accrue. If you can generate a powerful motivation, 100% of the motivation, then great courage will arise within your mind stream. Otherwise, if you generate this miserable motivation, there will be no courage and no power to your deeds.
Let us generate the motivation during a couple of minutes. As he said in the Canticle of Realizations, the concise Lamrim, therefore, who from within the scholars of India and Tibet is not mentally ravished, literally, mentally delighted at the thought of these stages of the path. This verse delighted in the stages of the path of the being beings of the three scopes is remarkably profound. It is very important for us to understand the levels of each of the scopes and the transition from the level of the being of the small scope to that of the being of the middling scope, from that of the being of the middling scope to that of the being of the great scope. An understanding of the levels of the Lamrim in Tibetan is extremely important.
And the outline of the Lamrim makes this remarkably clear. If you look at the outline, the practice of the being of the small scope is referred to as the stages of the path shared with the being of the small scope. That of the being of the middling scope is the stages of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. But that of the great scope does not include the participle shared, it’s the stages of the path of the being of the great scope. It is precisely because it is indispensable if one wishes to generate a fully characterized path of the being of the great scope, to have previously generated path of the being of the middling scope that this path of the being of the middling scope is said to be shared with the path of the being of the great scope.
Likewise, it is precisely because it is indispensable if one wishes to generate a path of the being of the middling scope which is fully characterized to have previously generated a path of the being of the small scope, that this path of the being of the small scope is said to be shared with the path of the being of the middling scope. Alternatively, since the two categories of beings, those who exclusively wish for the mere state of an Arhat of the lower vehicle, and those who strive for full enlightenment, both need as an indispensable preliminary to practice the path of the being of the small scope. This path of the being of the small scope is said to be shared. Likewise, since whether one is an Arhat, a being who aspires to be an Arhat of the lower vehicle striving for liberation from the sufferings of psychic existence, or one is a being who strives for the state of full enlightenment, a being of the great vehicle, in either case, since the path of the being of middling scope is an indispensable preliminary, it is said to be shared by these two beings. I have at present explained to you the meaning of the objective of the participle shared or common, it is not specifically explained in the Lamrim since it is considered self evident, but it is self evident only for those who reflect about it.
It is shared because the path of the being of the small scope is shared by those who engage in the practice of the being of the middling and great scope, and the path of the being of the middling scope is shared by those who engage with the path of the being of the middling and the great scope. Let me give you an example, let us take two people who have to fly from India. The first is flying from India to America, the second from India to Australia, both must transit through Singapore. These two people share a flight to Singapore. If one wishes to engage in a fully characterized path of the being of the great scope, one must identify the defects which are to be abandoned to engage in this, that which literally is to be countered.
That which is to be countered if one wishes to engage in a path of the being of the great scope is none other than self cherishing or the vanities, the figments if you prefer, of the being of the small scope, these are the defects to be abandoned. Then if one wishes to engage in a path of the being of the middling scope, which is fully characterized, what must be abandoned? What must be countered? What must be countered is saṃsāra. Then if one wishes to practice the cycle of meditations of the being of the small scope in a fully characterized fashion, what must be the object of abandonment?
What must one counter for this? This is something which you can answer since we are studying this topic at present. Then, what is the object of abandonment? What is to be countered to practice a fully characterized path of the being of the small scope? Can you answer this question or not?
If you cannot, we will meditate for a couple of minutes on it. Geshela said to answer concisely. Attachment to this life. Death and impermanence, death and impermanence and to a lesser extent, and causality. I can’t understand, excuse me.
Death and impermanence and to a lesser extent, karma and causality. What are the thoughts? What is to be abandoned If one wishes to practice and you know. Death and impermanence is common causalities, what you’re supposed to practice. If you say you’re supposed to abandon them, then it’s exactly the opposite, right?
No problem at all. Good, good, good, good. And you? Low lower rebirths? Abandon the attachment of this life.
Really don’t have To abandon the attachments of this life. Could you repeat, excuse me. Abandoning the attachments of this life. He’s just asking what you want to abandon, right? What are the faults?
The defects you want to abandon. Self cherishing and pride. Self cherishing is counted by bodhichitta. Permanence. Permanence.
What’s the thought of permanence? Probably. I would say that the fault of permanence is that it doesn’t it’s unchanging, therefore there is no cause and effect. To abandon the ignorance, desire and hatred, the three poisons. Just one, you know.
No second answer. Atishan said give up this life. Give up this life. I think it’s the eight worldly concerns. Lily, do you understand?
Viewing this life as a as a pleasure grove? It’s very important to answer sincerely as you have done and not to be afraid of giving the wrong answer because this is how one learns something. Then perhaps some of you are worried that if they give the wrong answer, things won’t go well. This is a small way of looking at things, isn’t it? Another?
To elaborate on my first answer, sinful deeds that lead to lower rebirths. Simple deeds? Sinful, the sinful actions, the 10 or sinful deeds or whatever they Diana, do you understand? Attachment is the same as few other people who’ve been saying attachment. Attachment to this knife.
Just to elaborate on my earlier response as well, grasping at the permanence of things is more what I meant. Grasping at the permanence of things? That’s very good. Most of you were close to the answer or dead on. You expressed it in different ways, but what is really helpful is to reflect by yourself over and again and find your own answers.
So the possible answers, which are merely different instances of the object of abandonment, whose meaning is the same would be the apprehension of one’s permanence, the eight worldly dharma’s attachment to this life, and one which I find particularly beautiful, which is the idea that one will be here for a long time. You will find that someone who is 92, 93 years old is still 100% certain to be around tomorrow and for that matter to reach the age of 100. And the outline makes this quite clear. In the outline, this section is called countering the view that one will be in this world for a long time. This says it all, being in this world for a long time refers to the apprehension of one’s own permanence.
And this is how Jetsong Kapha explains the topic in the great stages of the path. And this is actually the topic of a question which Geshe Potowa addressed to Geshe Dromtonpa. Potowa asked Dromtonpa, what is the precise boundary between this life and dharma? And Dromtonpa answered, what acts as a counter to the afflictions that is dharma? What does not act as a counter to the afflictions that is of this life?
Then, in the context of the path of the being of the small scope, if one asks, What is the specific dharma of this path? The specific dharma of this path is whatever acts as a counter to the main affliction we struggle against on this path, which is the apprehension of our permanence. Whatever acts as a counter to this is of the practice of the being of the middling scope, whereas the abandonment of the grasping at a self or self cherishing are related to the path of the middling and the great scope. Then clearly when the apprehension of our permanence leads us to believe that let alone being still in existence tomorrow, we will still be in existence next week, we will still be in existence next month, we will still be alive next year, we will still be alive ten years from now, when we know for a fact that this is a mistaken view, then such a mistaken view, when we subscribe to it totally, can only lead to mistaken behavior. Therefore, as I explained, the main topic of meditation for the being of the small scope is death and impermanence, and the more one can meditate on it, the greater the benefit.
What is the result of such meditation on death and impermanence? We will become like someone who is sentenced to die within the next hour or two. If such a person were to be offered whatever amount of wealth or material happiness, he or she would develop no desire whatsoever for it. Then meditating in this way, the vanities of this life, the figments of this life become akin to an illusion. This is the beginning of the practice of contentment with little happiness.
Then once contentment with little happiness has arisen on this basis, one attains excellent happiness in this life and then on this basis, eventually happiness in future lives. Then if you think about this, you will understand that once being satisfied with little happiness has been generated within this life, then fear, anxiety will dwindle. Then even those who do not accept the existence of reincarnation of past and future lives are nonetheless able to reflect on death and impermanence, and in so doing, they are able to enhance their contentment. Then to actually engage in the practice of the being of the small scope, this is not sufficient. One must also be intimately convinced, profoundly convinced that future lives exist.
And then for entering into practice of the being of the middenscope, it is very difficult to do so if one does not accept the existence of past and future lives. Because one must reflect on the 12 limbs of dependent origination. Really? Good. Good, good, good idea.
Then for a practice of the path of the being of the small scope, an understanding of future lives is indispensable. And for the practice of the being of the middling scope, an understanding of past lives is indispensable, since it relies on an understanding of the 12 limbs of the dependent origination. Without an understanding of past lives, is very difficult to understand emptiness. Since it hinges on interdependence. Therefore, what is the main object of abandonment?
What is the main view which must be countered during the practice of the being of the small scope? It is the idea that we will be in this life for a long time. When we counter this, we get the sense that we will live for a very short period of time, and then when one is convinced one will be around for a short time, this is of tremendous benefit to dharma practice. Then it is not sufficient to practice Dharma, one must practice pure Dharma. How does one practice pure Dharma?
One practices pure Dharma by relinquishing this life. One relinquishes this life through understanding that the vanities of this life are short lived. This is the meaning of the first of the four reliances of the ten jewels of the Kadampa masters of yore. The first of the four reliances or the four focuses is focus the mind on the dharma. This first of the ten jewels of the Kadampa tradition is difficult for all of us.
However, in a community such as this one, it is possible to progressively relinquish one’s body and focus one’s mind on the dharma. If one thinks about this as much as one can, it will definitely benefit one’s mind. The first of the four focuses is therefore focus the mind on the dharma. The second focus is having focused the mind upon the dharma, focus dharma upon beggarhood or homelessness. This means that even if one loses everything one has and one is a homeless beggar on the street, one will nonetheless not be depressed, but will be satisfied because of one’s inner riches.
The meaning here is that even if one were a beggar in reality, one would be rich in dharma. Then in Tibet, we had practitioners who were physically destitute, but rich in the teachings. We had those practitioners who had both and those who had neither. In this country, the dharma is progressively spreading, whether it is spreading within your minds or not that I do not know, But on the outside it is spreading, so there is good hope you will become rich in the dharma. The third focus is focus beggarhood upon death.
Indeed, when one beggars oneself for the practice, one might be afraid that one will actually die of hunger. We should remember in this context that Buddha Śākyamūni, when he was a universal ruler, a Chakravartin, dedicated huge amounts of merit to the continuance of the teachings and the welfare of the practitioners. Then Geshe Ben Gungyal, the Kadampa Geshe, who must have been a wealthy landowner before becoming ordained, said that before he entered the monastery, as he had large tracts of land, if it snowed in the morning and at noon, he was extremely worried for his crops. But after entering the monastery, his mind was at peace.
The fourth reliance is to focus death on death alone without any friends in a desolate area. This actually is an impossibility for a pure practitioner, but should something like this happen, we might worry if I die having practiced like this, there will be no pallbearers, no friends for me and we should embrace this and rejoice in the prospect of our body decaying all by itself in a house with people finding about it many years later. This was the outlook of This is what is meant by relinquishing or abandoning one’s body. This is not easy to do. It is difficult for us since we need food, we need clothing and so forth, but the more we can reflect upon this, the greater the benefit for our minds.
Alright. I will take one question at present. Yes. One question, please. I said to Yogeshala, you have no questions about giving up this life.
Gisela earlier we had a discussion group and during that discussion we were discussing impermanence and I understand coarse impermanence but I have difficulty understanding subtle impermanence. Can you help me understand it? Very good, very good, good idea. Yours is an excellent question. I have not yet had time to find a satisfactory way to answer Lily’s question regarding the equalization and the interchange of self and others.
And I would like to think how to present subtle impermanence in a way which is of help to you and which is not complicated. Otherwise, is no point. Just a couple of quick announcements. The Foundation Day, which has been moved this year to the eighteenth, Sunday May 18, we’ll be having shared lunch. So bring something for sharing half past eleven for 12:00 start.
And then the special commemoration for Rinpoche, Tenzin will be bringing relics, etcetera. And that’s Saturday, the thirty first at 02:00, two to five. And then an advance, I’ll say advance warning, advance notice of His Holiness birthday celebration. We’re just working on that. And so stay tuned.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- Nyingma
- The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.