1 h 28 min · 3,391 words · 12 March 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teacher continues the Lam Rim teaching on the precious human rebirth, covering its contingent importance, its ultimate importance and the point that every instant matters. Earlier, the talk explains why few beings now attain enlightenment in one lifetime, linking this to sensory distraction, weak karmic imprints, the value of focused concentration and the wise use of time. The recording ends with questions on right view, the self and choosing meditation topics.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 29m
UUID: 104b4b53-72b4-41b4-b1fc-1ea2bf318cfb
Date: 2014-03-12
Words: 3,387
As usual, we shall generate the motivation initially. As I said in a stanza, the object of knowledge are infinite and a human life is short. Therefore, as the pelican learns to sift the milk from the water. The meaning of this stanza is that there is a well nigh infinite range of topics we can study and learn, but when we reflect on death and impermanence, we realize that most of these topics are meaningless. And therefore, like the pelican who is able to distinguish between milk and water, we should learn to differentiate between the essential and the non essential.
Then in this context, a doubt might arise in your minds. From the time of Buddha Śākyamūni to the great forerunners, Nāgārjuna and his disciple Āryadeva, Asaṇga and his half brother Vasubandhu, then the great scholars of ancient Indias, the great practitioners of the ancient and the new translation traditions, all the way down to Je Tsongkhapa and so forth. There have been numerous instances of great beings such as for instance, Milarepa, the noble Milarepa, the disciple of Marpa, who attained full enlightenment within one body and one life, through the efforts they undertook. Then, nowadays, there seem to be very few, if any, such beings. Generally speaking, attaining full enlightenment in one life and one body is possible.
But where are all the beings who attained it nowadays? Why is this the case? If we reflect on the situation at the period of Jetsün Milarepa or the noble beings of the past, there was no science and technology worth talking about, certainly nothing comparable to what we have nowadays. Then, in terms of sensory stimuli, there was very little visual sensory stimuli, few shapes and few colors to attract the mind outwards. Likewise, there was there were very few sounds and very little music one could listen to, and very few pleasant smells.
For that matter, food was very limited in its range of tastes, and tactile sensations as well were limited. As a result of this, the mind was naturally withdrawn inwards. And this meant that when one attended teachings, these teachings were listened to with extraordinary care, and implanted very powerful karmic imprints, karmic tendencies within the mind. The ripening of these karmic tendencies occurred swiftly, and as a result, the various stages of the grounds and of the paths were experienced swiftly as well. This is merely my own position on the topic.
And therefore, as I explained, since there were few objects of engagement of the five sense organs, the sensory consciousnesses were quite naturally and easily withdrawn inwards, and as a result of this, the activity of the mental consciousness was enhanced. Then I believe that when the sensory consciousnesses are not powerfully exerted, this strengthens the mental consciousness, doesn’t it? Nowadays however, due to the extraordinary proliferation of objects of sensory excitation, the sensory consciousnesses are constantly dispersed outwards and the mental consciousness follows them. As a result, irrespective of how much effort one puts in studying and attending teachings, the karmic imprints which are implanted on the mind are weak since the mind during study and attending teachings is constantly moved outwards by the sense consciousnesses, and as a result, the karmic imprints are strongly mixed with sensory karmic imprints. We well know that sensory karmic imprints are unstable, and the senses, the sense consciousnesses for that fact are unstable too.
For instance, when we fall asleep and enter deep sleep, there is no sensory consciousness whatsoever. So, we can see for ourselves that the karmic imprints of our attending teachings are very weak. For instance, I have noticed that one week after the teachings, nobody really remembers what was said during the teachings the previous week. Isn’t that true? And therefore, since nowadays, the visual sensory consciousness is constantly excited by attractive visual objects, the auditory sensory consciousness is constantly excited by beautiful music, the olfactory sense consciousness is constantly excited by stimulating smells and the gustatory sense consciousness is constantly excited by new and different varieties of food, while the tactile sense consciousness is constantly excited by the stimulation of new fabrics and textiles, our minds are overwhelmed by sensory consciousness and as a result, the sensory consciousnesses are far more powerful than the mental consciousness.
As was said in the stanza at the beginning, while this life is short, objects of knowledge are well nigh infinite. For instance, let us say we wish to memorize one page of this treatise, liberation in the palm of your hand. Let us assume it takes one hour for someone with good concentration to memorize one page. Clearly, if every five minutes we are distracted mentally and our mind travels far away for five minutes, then what would actually take one hour to memorize will take twice as long, will take two hours to memorize. And mental work, which would take two hours’ time, would actually take four hours’ time.
So because of distraction, we waste a tremendous amount of time. From what precisely does this distraction arise? This distraction arises from the powerful desires within our mind and these powerful desires are present because we lack contentment. As is said in the Śāntideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, should the wild elephant of the mind be fettered by recollection and vigilance to the stake of the object of observation, one will accomplish all virtue and abandon all that destroys. The meaning of this stanza is that should the, our turbulent mind be controlled by both recollection and vigilance and focused upon the object of observation, then even though perhaps for us the attainment of a state akin to calm abiding is difficult, nonetheless, such a powerful concentration will ensure that the coarse afflictions will no longer afflict us, coarse anger and coarse desire will no longer afflict us.
So, in my opinion, if one is able to concentrate, to focus one’s mind on one single text, Let us take for instance the case of Je Tsongkhapa’s Foundation of All Qualities, and to focus or concentrate one’s mind single pointedly on this text for fifteen or twenty minutes, and it takes at least fifteen or twenty minutes if one reflects on the meaning and not just merely on the transitory words, then this is a fully accomplished overview meditation, and is of extraordinary benefit. During these fifteen or twenty minutes, one’s mind would not be scattered or dispersed at all to the outside, but would remain focused on the text. The same thing would be to reflect on the at the end of the Guru Pooja, starting with the verse to the supreme field of merit, the holy Guru, all the way to the end of the prayer. If one’s mind can be focused in this way single pointedly, without necessarily talking of calm abiding, which is very difficult for us to attain, but if we have a high level of concentration, then this is of undeniable benefit for one’s own dharma practice, and for that matter, it is of great benefit in secular or mundane matters.
If our mind is focused in this way, then we shall understand clearly whatever is addressed to us and answer appropriately. On the other hand, if our mind is not focused in this way, but is troubled and scattered, our speech will be confused and meaningless. We will address before, which will be mentioned later, and we will address later, which should have been mentioned before. And this is why His Holiness the Dalai Lama, the supreme being said, for yourselves, you should put effort in study and meditation. I lack the leisure to do so.
It is true that if one meditates intensely for weeks, it is possible to generate renunciation or bodhichitta. Well, we ourselves have the same physical base as the Noble Milarepa or the Noble Je Tsongkhapa. The reason for which we have not attained any of the qualities which they attained is precisely due to this. So regarding Lilly’s question last week, whether Tibet or not would qualify as a central land since it lacked after all Bhiksunis, the lineage had been interrupted. Geshe-la would like to respond this time.
War indeed in Tibet, the lineage of Bhiksunis was severed. Nonetheless, it is said that there were female nuns, female practitioners, who practiced fully the mother individual liberation vows from within the twofold division of Prātimokṣa sutras into father and mother Prātimokṣa sutras, and this would qualify as a bhiksuni practice. Last time, I completed the presentation of the first outline of the precious human rebirth, which is identifying a precious human rebirth with the eight freedoms or the eight leisures and the 10 endowments. Today, we shall move on onwards with the second outline, which is understanding the profound meaningfulness or the profound importance of such a rebirth. This is subdivided into three, its contingent importance, its ultimate importance, and in brief, the fact that every instant is important.
Regarding the first subdivision, its contingent importance, this refers to the fact that through the practice of ethics, we are able to eliminate the causes for lower rebirth, whereas with the practice of generosity or for that matter forbearance, we are able to generate the causes for higher rebirths. Moreover, on such a physical basis, it is possible to obtain in future lives, not only a fully endowed human rebirth with the 18 characteristics of such a rebirth, but in addition, the eight full characteristics of a noble human rebirth. And it is said in this respect of Rahula Maitreyi, a very great practitioner, that he was praised by the, one of the Pancha-namas who said, Indeed, the elder has fully achieved the purpose of this life. When we speak of the first importance, the contingent importance of a precious human rebirth, contingent or short term here refers to the a human or a divine rebirth. Regarding the ultimate meaningfulness of a precious human rebirth, it is ultimately meaningful first because it is on such a base that one can attain liberation or full enlightenment, and to attain these, one needs preliminarily the training in ethics.
The foundation for the training in ethics is renunciation or definite emergence, and this can be attained in dependence on a precious human rebirth. In addition, from the standpoint of Tantric ethics, a precious human rebirth is profoundly meaningful, since it seems very difficult, if not impossible, to engage in any practice of tantra in a body which does not have the requisite elements and constituents which a precious human rebirth has. There is an account of a statue of Atisha in Tibet which was the object of great veneration. And as a result of this, its base became darkened through the offerings and the prostrations. But it is open to question whether such practices alone can protect one from rebirth in the lower realms.
If we reflect on the life of Jetsün Milarepa, clearly Jetsün Milarepa spent most of his life destitute, and he seldom had any tsampa, any barley flour to eat. Yet, as far as future lives are concerned, his condition is far superior to that of the king of Lu who was an extraordinarily wealthy individual. And therefore we should focus our attention on these teachings of the graduate stages of the path and try to spend whatever time we dedicate to them wisely. Time is of great importance in this matter because time which is lost cannot be retrieved. It’s not like a car which you can call back.
If we have wasted one hour, that hour will never come back. If we have wasted two hours, those two hours are lost for good. And therefore, however much time we have disposal, whether it be one or two hours, we should try to dedicate it to contemplation on the stages of the path because this is of extraordinary benefit for us. We shall stop here for tonight. Then if you have questions which are on topic, please ask them.
Over the week I’ve been thinking a lot about the teaching from last Wednesday night about the 10 endowments and the eight leisures and Geshe-la asked the question of us about why we felt or why wrong views were so important. And it occurred to me over the week as I was thinking about this topic that everyone in this room knows many, many people who have been born with the 10 endowments and most of the leasures but it’s the wrong views which stop them from being here and which stop them from being at other Buddhist centers and practicing dharma. Yes, indeed. The first obvious thought of wrong views is that if one has wrong views, one will not have fulfilled the eight endowments. Secondly, clearly, if one has the wrong views of not believing in past and future lives, or even though one believes in past and future lives, accepting karma and causality, this interferes greatly with one’s practice.
However, since wrong views are a composite phenomenon and are impermanent, they can be eradicated, and they can be eradicated swiftly if one attends teachings. In his thinking about how we are you know, how our situation is different than it was in days of yore, Could he could he contemplate also the following? In our society, our society runs on discontent. We are not supposed to be content. We are supposed to want.
We are in everything that is advertised to us, everything that we hear in music, everything that we see on television, everything that we see in store windows, everything that we see on the street is basically telling us that we need something else. We’re made to want. And this is like the air that we breathe, we will raise in it to the extent that we do not see it most of the time. Capitalism. Regarding contentment, one has to distinguish those domains to which contentment applies and those to which it doesn’t.
Contentment does not apply for instance to governments or let’s say to societies. It does apply to oneself as an individual. It is oneself who has to learn to restrain one’s desires and impulses. A little bit of a follow through from what Pamela said about distractions. We’re faced with so many distractions.
Can Geshela maybe give some advice on how we might deal with the distractions that we’re faced with on a daily basis through our meditation. I’ll take another question while I think about your question. Thank you, Elia Geshela. Geshela said tonight and he suggested we focus on one topic, one single text, single pointedly for fifteen minutes and on the meaning not just the words. So my question is in our fifteen minutes of single pointed meditation how do we discover the meaning when we only have our knowledge and what’s in our book in the liberation in the palm of your hand, when we don’t get to debate this like Geshela would in the monastery, how do we discover the meaning with our limited knowledge?
If we take the case of the Foundation of All Qualities, the two first verses of the Foundation of All Qualities can be put in close relationship with the related topic of liberation in the palm of your hand. Then you would go from the one to the other and back over and again until eventually you understood their meaning. Many of the teachings I’ve attended over the years both here and in the fall Concentrate a lot on the Lam Rim graduated path, but always the issue of right view is raised. Why is not right view taught as a prerequisite to the Lamrim when it’s so important to understand the whole context of the West Coast? What do you mean by Right View?
Okay. The View, in other words, with a capital Since the correct view, in other words, the view of emptiness is a particularly difficult topic, generally speaking, for ordinary practitioners of limited acumen, it is presented at the end of the graduated stages of the path, at the end of the Lamrim. Now, for practitioners of exceptionally sharp acumen, the correct view would actually proceed the generation of both renunciation and of bodhichitta. And this is a case because Lamrim leads up to the presentation of the two last perfections, the perfection of concentration and the perfection of wisdom, which are difficult topics and which are naturally presented at the end of the Lamrim. If there is no, this is a question from a student, if there is no autonomous permanent self, how does that calibrate with the concept of past lives or a continuous single eternal energy or consciousness that carries over the effect of previous lives.
From the standpoint of Buddhist treatises, it is precisely because the person is empty of being permanent and autonomous, excuse me, permanent one and independent, that it is actually an entity which is able to transmigrate and it is an entity which can be the receptacle of karma. Should there be a self, in other words an Ātman, which is actually permanent, one, and independent, such a self or such an Ātman would necessarily be permanent, and as a permanent entity would be inappropriate both for transmigration and as a receptacle of karma and causality. A permanent self, a permanent ātman is incompatible with transmigration. Sir, do want to talk to them? Whose question was this?
Was it your question? Whose question was this? Shaya. Good, good, good. It’s a very good question.
Buddhist scriptures refute the existence of a permanent self, a permanent Ātman, simply because the person is necessarily something which arises in dependence on causes and conditions, then clearly, a permanent ātman because it is permanent, cannot arise in dependence on causes and conditions. Thank you Geshela. I was looking at heading 104, a short discussion to convince you and it said you should substitute each meditation topic such as the one I shall now discuss under the above headings for the heading on how to pursue the main part of the meditation session. So then I went back and tried to figure out what heading were talking about, Pabongkha Rinpoche was talking about. And I think he was talking about the heading that is the main part of the session.
So anyway, then I went back and read the other bit and this leads to my actual question. I mustn’t have read it properly the first time. It says under heading 60, you should not pursue a a Lamrim topic arbitrarily doing whatever you please because you feel it’s dharma, nothing can go wrong. Could Geshela explain what’s meant by arbitrary? Because for me sometimes the notion of meditation on death and impermanence is quite conducive or my mind is quite conducive to that at one time and then another day I may feel that meditation on compassion is easier.
So could Geshela talk about what’s meant by arbitrarily choosing a meditation topic? No. The passage in Kyabje Pabongkha, which is liberation in the palm of your hand, referring to meditating arbitrarily, does not refer to this. It is perfectly appropriate, as you do, to meditate on death and impermanence, and when one does not feel in the mood to do that, to meditate on for instance renunciation or compassion or any other topic. That’s not the meaning of arbitrarily here.
Geshe-la, my understanding is that right now I’m engaged in hearing and that this is analytical meditation on the Lam Rim. Is this the case? Indeed, attending the teachings is engaging in the activity of hearing, and if you reflect over and again on the meaning of these teachings, then you will engage in analytical meditation. This coming Sunday, Day of Miracles, join us with Geshela for a special Puja this Sunday at 05:00. And then public talk, Mental Peace in Times of Crisis and uncertainty, Saturday March 22 between two and three.
And finally, we have been expecting Tenzin to return on the weekend, but unfortunately he has been his arrival has been delayed. So we’re not quite sure when he is arriving. So we’ll let you know as soon as we know. Thank you. Please join us for a
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- pratimoksha vows pratimokshasamvara (Skt); so thar gyi dompa (Tib)
- The various levels of individual liberation vows for lay and ordained, including the five lay vows, and the novice vows and full ordination that monks and nuns take. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If there is no autonomous permanent self, how can there be past lives or a continuous consciousness that carries the effects of previous lives?
It is precisely because the person is empty of being permanent, one and independent that the person can transmigrate and can be the receptacle of karma. A self or Ātman that was permanent, one and independent would necessarily be permanent, and as a permanent entity it would be unsuited to transmigration and to being the receptacle of karma and causality. A permanent Ātman is incompatible with transmigration. Buddhist scriptures refute a permanent self because the person arises in dependence on causes and conditions. A permanent Ātman, being permanent, cannot arise in dependence on causes and conditions.
Is attending Lam Rim teachings the same as doing analytical meditation on the Lam Rim, or is it only hearing?
Attending the teachings is engaging in the activity of hearing. It is not yet analytical meditation in itself. Analytical meditation comes when you reflect over and again on the meaning of the teachings you have heard. So hearing and analytical meditation are two distinct activities: the first is listening to the teachings, and the second is repeatedly reflecting on their meaning.