1 h 31 min · 4,740 words · 28 October 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk examines what faith means in Buddhism, distinguishing faith from belief and holding that faith arises from investigating the Buddha’s qualities and from endeavour to develop them. It cites a verse from the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life on aspiration as the root of virtue, and touches on death and impermanence and avoiding harm to living beings. The session closes with questions on faith.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 31m
UUID: 610f5111-96c0-45a0-b4d2-1135f0af4688
Date: 2012-10-28
Words: 4,736
So we understand that we know that we all have belief or faith in the Buddhist dharma. We might all say that we believe in Buddhism or we have faith in Buddhism. But we really need to analyze this concept of faith or belief and understand exactly understand exactly what it is that it means. So when we say that we have faith in Buddhism, what exactly are we saying by that statement? What exactly does faith mean for us in terms of our understanding of Buddhism and our relationship to it?
That’s That’s So that’s a question that Geshela is posing to us, and he would like your like to hear what you have to say on that question of what is faith. So people have to answer. People have to say. Yeah. So faith, for me on the Buddhist path is seeing living examples of those who practice the dharma like his holiness, and thinking, I’m on the right path because of the good qualities he demonstrates.
And I wanted to say to Geshela that if we didn’t have those living examples, it would be quite difficult to maintain faith in the Dharma. To me, faith, is the ability through meditation and analysis to determine the Buddha’s teachings as correct and encompassing them in my life to stop all suffering, myself and others. Through this continual process and being hopefully fortunate enough to attain higher rebirth, will eventually attain enlightenment. A little similar to what was just said, but for me, it’s, incontrovertible, conviction that the dharma is valid and aligned with reality. And whilst, gurus and masters personify this truth, which gives me faith, it is only through my own observation, analysis, and experience that I actually realize this to be so.
Mhmm. Okay. My experience of faith is that as I continue to to study and attend teachings and to to practice, I can I can develop a faith that that comes from these things that I wasn’t wasn’t there before? Good. Maybe good.
So first, when we come to talk about faith, there’s a very good verse in the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. It is in chapter seven verse 40 and it says, the mighty one himself has said that aspiration is the root of every facet of virtue. Its root is constant acquaintance with the ripening effects of a of actions. So in this verse you see that the Buddha is referred to as the mighty one. In Tibetan the term that is used is which we generally can we get the sense of from reading that word that one who is capable.
So to be supremely capable is what is a literal translation of Tupa which in this verse they’ve used the expression mighty one. So one who is infinitely capable is probably a more literal translation of that. That aspiration is the root of every facet of virtue. And in that this verse, the word aspiration is used where other words could similarly have been used for that translation. The word is mönpa for people who are interested in Tibetan.
The other definitions that come along with that word are belief, which is the way that Geshela is using it in this example, but it also carries the connotations with it when we see that word in Tibetan of imagination, interest, intent, inclination, or disposition. Okay. So where you see that word aspiration in that verse, it should also bring along with it other meanings that perhaps aren’t necessarily clear from merely reading the text because imagination and belief and inclination are all part of that word. And so Geshela is saying this verse is a very important verse to read, to think about and to be mindful of where it says that all the good fruits that we wish to experience come about on the basis of being attached to virtue. So virtue is the root of all good results that we may experience.
So virtue is at the root. Where does virtue come from? How do we get this virtue? Geshela says this virtue comes about on the basis of belief. So in the text they use the word aspiration.
Geshela is using that word in context of belief. And where does this belief or this aspiration come from? Geshela uses the example of the living Buddha, Śākyamūni Buddha, where we’re able to analyse and see the qualities of the Buddha. And having seen the qualities of the Buddha, it inspires us. It inspires our imagination to attempt to achieve a similar state.
So that is the way that this verse explains the value of faith. So the answers that we’ve been or the feelings that we’ve expressed in terms of our discussion on faith have been very similar to what is in fact the intended meaning of the word faith. So having discussed these having started the discussion about faith, it’s good to have very short and precise kind of, definition of what it or understanding of what faith really means to us. So we have faith in the Buddha and the reason and having faith in the Buddha comes about on the basis of us thinking about the Buddha and seeing the Buddha’s qualities using our reasoning to investigate the qualities that the Buddha possesses. Now when we talk about the faith that arises in people who are born into a culture whereby Buddhism has been the dominant religion for generation after generation and generation.
Being born into such a culture, one arises and grows up to have a faith in Buddhism on the basis of the historical presence of Buddhism within their culture. And that kind of faith faith. There is no way of saying it is not faith, faith, but it is not the most reliable kind of faith. But a more reliable faith that can arise is the faith that arises on the basis of making an investigation into the qualities of a Buddha. Having heard about the Buddha, investigated the Buddha and come to some degree of respect and aspiration for the Buddha’s qualities that the Buddha has been able to obtain.
So when it comes we all we all we all feel faith in Buddhism, and we all have reasons we all have faith in Buddhism for the reason that we see qualities in the Buddha that we wish to aspire towards. Now when we look at the Buddha, when we see the image of the Buddha, we see that the Buddha is a person who the Buddha is a living being who operates under the power of great compassion, of loving kindness and great compassion. It is through whose entire mind operates through the power of that virtue of those qualities. Now seeing a living being be able to possess such an extraordinary level of loving kindness and compassion and to be driven to exist purely to as an expression of loving kindness and compassion. It is quite an exceptional an exceptional reality for us to see, to imagine.
And it is something that we can understand has come about on the basis of study and practice and training that the Buddha has attained these qualities on the basis of things that we can see and understand that is study and training. And so when we think about the potential that exists when it comes to the expression of loving kindness and compassion, we can see its ultimate expression through the example of the Buddha. And when we feel inspired that such an extreme or when we when we see that ultimate expression of loving kindness and great compassion embodied in a living being, it inspires us with the drive, with the wish, with the excitement to similarly seek to attain a similar state of being. And that feeling that feeling is the feeling that we can call faith. That is belief.
You know? So, you notice that the words faith and belief are sometimes used interchangeably. So what the word that Geshela has been using is the word that does translate as faith. Okay. Now sometimes it comes with the connotation of belief.
So I ask Geshela then to make the distinction between what faith and belief is. And Geshela said that in order to have faith you require belief. So you need to something to be able to have faith in it. But to believe something doesn’t necessarily imply that you have faith in it. Does that make sense?
So you can believe something but not engender a sense of faith But to have faith requires that belief is a pre existing element within your mind. Geshela uses the example of where we have our relationship with a child or a partner or significant person in our lives that we will have a belief in that person, a belief that connotes trust, but we don’t have faith in that person. Now when I when Geshela when earlier when Geshela I discussed this with Geshela, I did give the example that we in the way we use English, we would say we have faith in our in our child or a child would say they had faith in their parents. But in terms of the way but when if you were to say those same things in Tibetan it really wouldn’t make sense. So even though it makes sense when you say it in English that you have faith in your child or as a child you have faith in your parents it sounds very strange if you were to say it in Tibetan.
So that’s as close as I can get to translating how it means other than to say they’re the same words but the connotation is very different. And so faith really will not arise in a person who doesn’t have some agreement or commitment with Buddhism. So Geshela is saying that that happens with all belief systems that once you make an investigation into its system, its belief system, and you agree to it and then you can say that you have faith in it. And what you can’t say that you have faith in Buddhism or any other belief system if you don’t essentially agree to the components that make up that belief system. That acceptance of the system of belief is what gives rise to faith.
Is that clean? Yeah. No. Yes. This one?
Yeah. So understanding and recognizing our faith is something that is very beneficial to do each morning when we wake up. So when we when we under what is meant by the Buddha and Buddhism, we understand as key features of that to be renunciation, great compassion, and the profound view. The profound view or philosophical position of Buddhism. Now these, very deep meanings that we can inquire into and investigate through our study and our practice.
We can see that the Buddha himself is an embodiment of the perfection of these qualities and ultimate expression of these qualities of renunciation and great compassion and profound view. Now on the basis of that, we can see that within ourselves faith arises and we seek to understand within ourselves the potential we have for loving kindness and compassion. And we and we strive to be able to have these qualities become part of our own mind. Now this introduces another key element to our equation on what faith means and implies and is the expression that, Geshela is using that means to strive or to seek to to seek, to strive to produce or great endeavor. So on the basis of seeing the embodiment of these qualities within a Buddha and understanding that these qualities come about on the basis of practical steps such as study and training, meditational training, then we what arises with our mind is this strong determination to or this strong sense of endeavor that compels us to seek to train and study in these things in order to obtain what we have seen embodied in the Buddha.
So this becomes another element within our, when this becomes another element in our expression of faith that it implies or connotes endeavor and a strong endeavor to obtain the qualities that you see embodied by the Buddha. So and therefore to clarify the, definitions of this, the word that Geshela is using now that is also, implies faith or necessitates faith. To be clear that these words seek, to seek, to strive, to have willpower, intent, desire, and aspiration to achieve the things that you are seeing embodied in the Buddha. So these qualities are also implied when we say that we have faith in Buddhism. So now if we look into this expression of striving and endeavor, this determination to to this determination to seek or this aspiration to obtain these qualities, we might use an example death and impermanence.
So we understand that when we listen to Buddhism invariably we will hear hear something mentioned about death and impermanence. And we will have this interest and this, we will have an interest in this idea and we will then apply this striving, this endeavour to understand exactly what it means in its most profound sense. So we will engage in the study of what it means and listen and study and then we will engage in the practices that that are associated with the topic of death and impermanence. And so eventually if we are able to maintain this strong sense of endeavour, this determination to strive to obtain results, eventually over a great deal of time, perhaps many years of application of our practice, then we begin to feel a greater power within our mind to truly understand what death and impermanence means. Now death and impermanence, we tend to understand that we, are going to die at some stage, but we really don’t live as if we have encoded that knowledge into the way that we operate in the course of our daily life.
So on the basis of practice we begin to really investigate into the nature of death and impermanence. We begin to see that on the basis of this idea that we will exist into the future, that we have some certainty that we will exist into the future, We base a great deal of our thoughts and behaviours on this presumption of longevity. We say that we need to make sure that we have adequate housing, resources of wealth, of sustenance, of comforts, and we put an enormous amount of our daily lives, the work of our daily life into creating the basis upon which our we act out our longevity. Okay. Now as we begin to study and practice and with this great endeavor, we begin to understand that all these behaviors are coming about on the basis of self grasping and that this feeling of eternal existence is perhaps a false one.
And we begin to truly feel within our mind an understanding of what death and impermanence truly means. And so it has come about over many years of practice sustained by this what we are calling this endeavour or this determination to strive and obtain the qualities that we are seeing expressed through the teachings of Buddhism? Now of course in our situations where we have a very practical responsibilities towards our family and our dependents that when it comes to, engaging in this training of death and impermanence it’s very it is difficult for us to turn our back on the responsibilities that we have to others in terms of providing comfort security for people who rely on us. However, it is valuable to us even though we know that we must sustain the way that we live in order to provide for the people who depend on us. There is great value to be had for imagining and engaging in the thought of this concept of death and impermanence.
And so one part that I should add to that is we were covering what it means to do this investigation into death and impermanence and suddenly develop, an internal awareness of the reality of death and impermanence, we seek to, we therefore the state of mind that we arrive at is where we understand the value of what we have and we cease to strive endlessly for things that we imagine that we will need in the future. And so this what comes with this is a state of satisfaction, in the contentment to be satisfied with what one has, to be content with what one has and not to be continually striving to obtain something that you imagine you may need in this potential future. Okay. So that was you can click and paste that back one paragraph. Makes better sense.
Cause and effect. Cause and effect. Cause and effect. And so within the text that our teachings are based on, Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun, there’s a reference within that text that we may have read as we’ve gone through it in our own time. In regard to whatever it is that we seek to, practice in when we when it comes to the Buddhist training, whether we are working on death and impermanence or renunciation or whatever it may be that we have chosen as something to focus on or to train in or to cultivate an understanding of, Whatever it is that we do within our training, there is a very important thing that we must always remember and that is to at no stage in any way exist live our lives in a way that intentionally causes harm to other living beings.
We know through everything that we have covered through the text, the dependence, the reliance that we have on on other living beings. This has been expressed throughout the text of, the Mind Training Like the Rays of the Sun text. This has been expressed throughout it. So it is very important that we know that no matter what it is that we are seeking to, direct our specific attention towards, it is of vital importance that at no stage in any way do we intentionally seek to harm other living beings. Now if we have made our investigation into the nature of reality, we come to an understanding of causes and effects.
So we know from our own side causing harm to others in the in terms within the context of what we understand of cause and effect is detrimental both to ourselves and to others. So it is another important part that we must sustain within our minds no matter whatever else it is that we might be studying or training in, that it is vital importance that we intentionally cause no harm to other living beings. So we may use the example for people who eat meat and for people who enjoy eating meat. We know that when we every time that we eat meat that we that it has necessitated there being a loss of life. For us to be able to sit and eat the meat it means someone has a living being has lost their life.
So when we sit to eat meat it is important that we remain mindful of the fact that or it is important that we imagine that we think something about what kind of suffering has been involved in the production of the food that we are eating. And so to think about the suffering that may have the suffering that was experienced and the loss of life before we engage in eating of the meat. Then it avoids the situation whereby merely simply eating the meat without any thought of the origins of that meat and the processes that had to take place for that meat to arrive on your table. You’re not paying attention to the process of how that meat arrived at your table, you’re in fact distancing your mind from an understanding of what cause and effect means. So it becomes a behaviour that reinforces this blindness to cause and effect.
So if we want, as we know, we want to intimately be aware of the processes of cause and effect. So when it comes to eating meat it is important that we remind ourselves of what suffering and loss of life happened in order for that meat to arrive at our table. Thereby we are able to sustain our understanding of what cause and effect means within our lives. So there are people amongst us who probably don’t eat any meat and that is a very good thing. And that is a very of course, as people who seek to practice Buddhism to not eat meat, it’s it’s naturally a very good thing because you are being mindful of the harm and suffering and cause and effect.
But for others who eat meat because perhaps it’s a part of their diet that they need or have to rely on, it’s still important to do it in such a way as that it gives you an opportunity to reinforce understanding of cause and effect and not turn a blind eye to the nature of cause and effect. But undoubtedly for the people who are able to maintain a diet that doesn’t include meat is of great benefit to yourself and it is a very good thing to do. Geshela was just trying to remember the people who he remembers saying that they don’t eat meat and the people who do. And while he was just going through the faces and trying to see who it was that did or didn’t eat meat he mentioned that of course he himself eats meat. So now we can use the next couple of moments, couple of minutes to to set our motivation within our minds that when it comes to practising and engaging in the teachings that we have heard that we are able to apply this concept of endeavor of striving to obtain and having this this determination or endeavor within ourselves to obtain the qualities that we have seen demonstrated through the teachings of Buddhism.
So let’s use, the next couple of minutes to set our motivation and with this under with this understanding of what we’ve been discussing about Endeavour. Australia? Different meat. So I guess I was saying that many years ago when he was back in Tibet, when he was growing up in Tibet, there wasn’t much to eat other than barley flour and butter, which is tsampa and butter which is how they mix mixing butter, tea and flour together. So there wasn’t much to eat other than that.
And it was only very occasionally that there was the opportunity to eat meat from yaks or oxen or pigs. But when you come to Australia, is meat comes from an incredible array of sources. There are so many different kinds of meat products in Australia. So just remember that at the beginning of the teaching, we read the quote from the guide to the Bodhisattva’s way of life where we and again, if you have, depending on the edition you have of that, where it said the mighty one himself has said that aspiration is the root of every facet of virtue. So when, we having elaborated on today’s teachings, if you go back and read that word aspiration, hopefully you will be able to carry the meaning of what was expressed in today’s explanation by Geshela into that specific word aspiration because that is what Geshela has been talking about in terms of our understanding of what an important element of faith is this determination to achieve or this endeavour.
And as it’s written in the verse of the Guide to Bodhisattva’s Way of Life aspiration. So just to remind ourselves of that verse now having heard Geshela make the explanation of what endeavour means in the context of faith, we might go back to that verse reread it and have a greater sense of what that verse actually is implying or saying. So we understand then that when we engage in study and practice, we do it with a goal that we are striving to obtain. And that goal that we are striving to obtain, that ultimate ambition that we have is not merely for happiness in this life. It is not merely for happiness in a future life.
It is to obtain the state of Buddhahood in order to embody the qualities that enable you to bring absolute, the qualities that enable you to bring benefit to every living being, to countless living beings, being all beings without exception. That you are able to obtain the qualities that enable you to truly benefit every living being and this is the aim that we are hoping to achieve through our study and our practice. If anyone has any more questions on faith. So if anyone has any more questions they can answer in regards to faith, you can ask Geshela now if you have any questions. It seems that, faith is only really understood when it’s tested and I guess that’s what Geshela is implying by studying, but it’s only when the pressure is on that we can really know what we think we might have had.
We think we might have faith, but then we perhaps discover that it’s a bit thin. That’s my experience. So in terms of reliable faith and trying to cultivate the most reliable and definite faith really comes about, on the basis of having a thorough investigation into, the Buddha and the Buddha’s the Buddha’s qualities whereby the Buddha is a manifest a pure manifestation of loving kindness and compassion. And the most reliable faith comes about on the basis of having a good reason. And the reason that we have is that we see the qualities that the Buddha himself has been a that a Buddha possesses.
And so that is when we, when it comes to talking about a reliable faith, a faith that is strong, it will always come back to relying on having a good reason as its basis. With the quote, Geshela, that the mighty one himself has said that aspiration is the root of every facet of virtue, is this the same as the quote, and I apologise, I don’t know where its source is, that says that everything rides on the tip of the wish. Is wish the same as aspiration? Wish. Do you know what’s on the wish?
Do you know where that’s from that quote? What it is? I’m sorry, no, I don’t. Maybe from the Lam Rim, but I’m not sure. Yes.
So in that sense, that wish, that wishing is you can say yes is similar to having aspiration. Wish in the sense of how you read the word wish in a Buddhist. In the smaller or middle scopes, is it is an aversion for suffering reason enough to develop faith? So yes, to practise for a practitioner of this, if you are to divide practitioners between the smaller, the middling and the great scope To be a practitioner of what we call the practitioner of small scope still that requires faith and it requires an understanding of cause and effect. So yes, that of the small scope has faith requires faith.
Nice. Maybe just to, maybe elaborate on that. I guess the ultimate goal of the great scope is to be a maximum benefit to all beings I guess for me, I’m trying to break that goal down into whilst that’s my ultimate aspiration, I’m trying to break it down to the point where I don’t cause my own suffering anymore or cause pain to others. I guess that’s the context in which that question was asked. If that is a sufficient reason to develop a strong enough faith.
So, faith is required. Faith is at the root of practise. So therefore any level of practise you might be talking about in terms of your aspirations for hoping to achieve something, faith is at the as faith is at the very root then it’s applicable to every single step of the way. I think you said, all right. Can I stop today?
Thank you so very much. At 12:00.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.