Lam Rim — 2011-10-02

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2011-10-02
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

[00:00:29] So my apologies for gathering everyone a bit early
[00:00:42] and for the disruption in the center,
[00:00:45] but since in many respects this one verse
[00:00:48] of Geshe Langri Tampa’s eight stances
[00:00:52] is perhaps the most important verse of all,
[00:00:57] it’s one which always is the most difficult
[00:00:59] for a Western audience to understand
[00:01:01] and to put in practice.
[00:01:03] I thought I would show you a very short presentation.
[00:01:07] it shouldn’t be more than 10 minutes, on the topic before we address your questions for today.
[00:01:14] And I will be drawing on material Geshe-la would not draw upon,
[00:01:19] which is sociological and statistical studies.
[00:01:23] So this image, the image of someone washing another person’s foot or feet,
[00:01:34] is a very powerful image in all cultures.
[00:01:38] It is a very powerful image in Christianity.
[00:01:41] It evokes the disciples anointing Christ’s feet.
[00:01:45] It also evokes Mary of Bethany and Mary Magdalene.
[00:01:50] Mary Magdalene was a prostitute, as you know.
[00:01:54] And the disciples, yes.
[00:01:57] Washing and anointing the feet of Christ with her hair.
[00:02:01] You find exactly the same practice for the development of humility
[00:02:08] in the 50 verses of Guru Devotion of Ashwa Gosha,
[00:02:12] in which the disciple is said or told that he should wash the feet of his master.
[00:02:21] So it is quite clear that these practices have a goal.
[00:02:24] Now, modernity considers that this is not psychologically beneficial.
[00:02:31] Much of the message we get, certainly from pop psychology, is exactly the opposite.
[00:02:37] It is a message of relentless self-affirmation,
[00:02:42] a message which says, in a nutshell, that taking care of number one,
[00:02:47] greed and even aggressivity, are necessary and even beneficial.
[00:02:53] And it draws on sociobiology to justify this.
[00:02:56] And the talk which he gave on sociobiology, I think I was able to show that sociobiology is in many senses a pseudoscience.
[00:03:05] There’s very little there which is solid.
[00:03:07] And we will see now with some of these statistics from recent studies on happiness just how wrong this viewpoint is.
[00:03:16] This is a study reported in the British Medical Journal a mere five years ago
[00:03:22] of happiness ratings in the various countries of the EU.
[00:03:29] And it ushered what is known as the Danish Paradox.
[00:03:33] Because you see quite astonishingly that from 1975 to 2005,
[00:03:39] the self-reported happiness asserted by the Danes skyrockets.
[00:03:45] and it is basically between 10 and sometimes even 20% higher
[00:03:52] than that of the next country,
[00:03:54] which also happens to be a northern European country,
[00:03:57] Netherlands and then Sweden and Finland.
[00:04:01] Strikingly, even though there is no major difference in living standard,
[00:04:05] at least at the period,
[00:04:07] Italy is at the very bottom of the countries
[00:04:11] as far as happiness is concerned.
[00:04:14] now this is quite puzzling
[00:04:16] why are the Danes so happy
[00:04:18] and why are the Italians
[00:04:22] absolutely miserable
[00:04:23] and the Portuguese even worse so
[00:04:26] this 5% of the Portuguese
[00:04:28] who are satisfied with their lot
[00:04:30] a very interesting article
[00:04:34] was written on this
[00:04:35] it caused a huge controversy in the EU
[00:04:37] and I can forward the article by email
[00:04:39] to those of you who are interested
[00:04:40] it reads sometimes like a comedy
[00:04:43] because the authors were trying to exclude
[00:04:45] all of the factors of unhappiness.
[00:04:48] And they said, well, the Danes,
[00:04:49] what can we say about the Danes?
[00:04:51] This is literally the article.
[00:04:52] They also say, well, the food is terrible,
[00:04:54] so it can’t be that they’re happy because of the food.
[00:04:57] Then they even addressed the issues
[00:04:59] of blonde people having more fun than dark people.
[00:05:03] They really did.
[00:05:05] And then they discarded this.
[00:05:08] Then they said, well, maybe it’s the social system.
[00:05:11] But then Sweden and Finland have also very generous benefit states,
[00:05:15] so it can’t be that.
[00:05:17] And they went through every single sociological component of Danish culture,
[00:05:22] which they could consider,
[00:05:23] and finally reached this astonishing conclusion.
[00:05:28] It has been argued that great expectations of favorable life circumstances in the future
[00:05:33] should be associated with life satisfaction.
[00:05:36] This is a commonly received thesis.
[00:05:39] But if the expectations are unrealistically high,
[00:05:42] they could also be the basis for disappointment and low life satisfaction.
[00:05:47] The Eurobarometer data on expectations show that while Danes are very satisfied,
[00:05:52] their expectations for the coming year are rather low, ranking among the bottom half.
[00:05:59] In contrast, Italy and Greece, which rank lowest on life satisfaction,
[00:06:03] satisfaction, rank high on expectations for the year to come, together with Swedes and the Finns
[00:06:09] they rank at the top. This is massive evidence that it is actually unsatisfied expectations,
[00:06:18] as we said yesterday in the context of depression, which causes happiness and suffering.
[00:06:25] And they point out, a much extraordinary sentence, the headlines in Denmark after the study ran,
[00:06:32] where are the happiest ligonu?
[00:06:34] The phrase ligonu in Danish,
[00:06:36] which can be translated literally as just now,
[00:06:39] is a quintessentially Danish expression.
[00:06:43] Reeking of the sentiment,
[00:06:44] for the time being, but probably not for long,
[00:06:46] and don’t have any expectations, it will last.
[00:06:50] Right?
[00:06:51] This is quite extraordinary.
[00:06:54] So it seems that the Danes are natural Buddhists.
[00:06:58] Right?
[00:06:59] But then happiness studies have taken off in the last decade.
[00:07:04] If we look at a map of happiness,
[00:07:07] the assessments of happiness are varied.
[00:07:10] It’s subjective well-being.
[00:07:11] We see what we broadly expect,
[00:07:13] which is a broad correlation between happiness and material welfare.
[00:07:18] North of the USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Brunei,
[00:07:24] some of the northern European countries
[00:07:26] rank very highly on the happiness scale.
[00:07:29] But we have a real paradox,
[00:07:32] which is that we have countries
[00:07:35] throughout Eastern Europe,
[00:07:37] ranging from the Ukraine all the way up
[00:07:39] through the Baltic Republics,
[00:07:41] which basically, in terms of happiness,
[00:07:46] consider their lives as unhappy
[00:07:47] as people in Somalia, the Sudan, Egypt,
[00:07:51] Chad, and so forth.
[00:07:53] Now, how can you compare the living standards?
[00:07:56] I traveled through most of Eastern Europe, both 20 years ago and much more recently.
[00:08:03] Most definitely, the living standard has nothing to do with that of sub-Saharan Africa.
[00:08:09] And yet, it affects massively the citizens’ perception of their own happiness.
[00:08:16] And this leads us to an extremely intriguing chart, one of the most interesting I know,
[00:08:23] in which happiness and the so-called human development index are correlated.
[00:08:30] The human development index is the broadest measure of human development we have at present.
[00:08:37] It includes not just wealth, in other words, GDP, but social development, benefits, as you would say in Australia,
[00:08:45] health standard, life expectancy, and so forth.
[00:08:49] So you have on the bottom line, and at CISO we used to say when I was young,
[00:08:55] the human development index from zero to one.
[00:08:58] Zero are the least developed countries in terms of human development.
[00:09:02] One the most.
[00:09:03] And the vertical scale, the ordinata, we have the self-assessment of happiness.
[00:09:10] Now, unsurprisingly, a large number of Western countries are in this section here,
[00:09:17] ranging from Finland, all with the same high level of human development index,
[00:09:23] all the way up to Iceland.
[00:09:26] Now, what is not clearly understood is why countries with all the same level of human development
[00:09:33] have such different self-assessments of happiness.
[00:09:39] But what is even more puzzling is that the two countries,
[00:09:43] which are the happiest in the chart, Tanzania and Nigeria,
[00:09:47] are at the very bottom of human development.
[00:09:52] In all senses of the term,
[00:09:53] they are the places where living should be the most awful.
[00:09:58] And we have a bevy of countries here,
[00:10:02] almost overwhelmingly Eastern European countries,
[00:10:06] the Ukraine, Russia, Albania,
[00:10:09] Latvia, Estonia, Slovakia, Lithuania, Hungary,
[00:10:12] which have actually very high human development indices
[00:10:15] and in which people are absolutely miserable.
[00:10:20] So what this chart shows very clearly, this is a recent chart,
[00:10:24] the studies were made between 1999 and 2005 approximately,
[00:10:28] is that there is not an automatic correlation
[00:10:32] between material welfare, in the broadest sense of the term,
[00:10:35] not just money, and happiness.
[00:10:39] And there are major exceptions.
[00:10:42] It is of these exceptions that Buddhism talks.
[00:10:46] The Buddhist teachings are that happiness occurs
[00:10:48] within the minds of the person
[00:10:51] and that the mind filters the exterior experience.
[00:10:56] And this leads us to the chart I was talking about to Aaron.
[00:10:59] Many of you have seen it already.
[00:11:01] I plotted two charts,
[00:11:03] so I put two charts on the same graph.
[00:11:06] One is a chart showing in Australia
[00:11:10] mean happiness
[00:11:11] as assessed by Australians from 1945 to 2010.
[00:11:15] you can see that in the last 65 years, Australians have come to feel more and more unhappy.
[00:11:24] It’s a very clear pattern.
[00:11:26] At the bottom of the chart charts the changes in GDP in Australia
[00:11:31] based on the Australian Treasury Department reports.
[00:11:35] Now you can see basically the GDP is pretty much all over the place.
[00:11:39] But there is no correlation we can see between changes in GDP,
[00:11:44] let’s say between 1975 and 2000, it has risen steadily,
[00:11:48] and happiness, there’s actually an inverse correlation.
[00:11:54] So even within this country, it is quite clear
[00:11:57] that people feel more and more unhappy,
[00:12:01] even though in the last 35 years,
[00:12:04] living standard has been increasing steadily.
[00:12:08] And the final chart I wanted to show you,
[00:12:11] I apologize, some of you have seen it already,
[00:12:13] but I think quite a few have not,
[00:12:15] is a very puzzling chart.
[00:12:18] It plots male suicide rate changes
[00:12:20] over the 20th century in Australia.
[00:12:24] Now, what is quite striking is,
[00:12:25] for the general suicide rate is dropping,
[00:12:29] it actually would be converging,
[00:12:31] if you look at the chart carefully.
[00:12:33] If you break it down by age,
[00:12:35] you have a very puzzling phenomenon.
[00:12:39] Suicide rate among the very elderly, above 85,
[00:12:43] has been dropping.
[00:12:44] This is in red here.
[00:12:46] And suicide in age group 65 to 84 in mauve is also basically dropping.
[00:12:55] However, the suicide rate in teenagers aged 15 to 24, which is in black here,
[00:13:03] which was nominal in 1907, that’s six deaths per 100,000 by suicide, explodes.
[00:13:09] It basically increases in one century to 20 deaths per 100,000.
[00:13:16] And actually a friend of mine who spoke with an Australian statistician
[00:13:21] said that this figure under-represents the suicide rate in the 15 to 24 age group in Australia.
[00:13:29] He said many of the so-called car accidents in that age group are actually disguised suicides.
[00:13:36] So this raises a major question.
[00:13:39] Nobody would deny that the living standard in Australia in 1907
[00:13:43] was far inferior to the living standard in 2000.
[00:13:48] Then why is it that we have this explosion of suicide,
[00:13:52] the ultimate act of despair,
[00:13:54] from people who have everything in front of them?
[00:13:58] It’s quite understandable that suicide among the elderly should decrease.
[00:14:03] Health care has increased dramatically.
[00:14:05] Living standards have increased.
[00:14:07] There’s better care for the elderly.
[00:14:09] So the decline in the suicide of the elderly makes a lot of sense.
[00:14:13] But when a suicide rate increases by four times, according to the figures,
[00:14:19] according to this statistician, it might be five or six times in one century,
[00:14:22] among people who have everything in their life, what is going on?
[00:14:27] It is quite striking that this is a figure which is extremely embarrassing
[00:14:30] and doesn’t seem to be really addressed in public debate.
[00:14:35] So these were the charts I wanted to show you.
[00:14:37] and I wanted to show them
[00:14:42] to show the benefits of low expectations
[00:14:44] so I think the Danish study makes it very clear
[00:14:48] that if we lower our expectations
[00:14:51] we can be much happier
[00:14:54] in a given set of circumstances than otherwise
[00:14:57] but what is even more striking
[00:15:00] with the chart plotting
[00:15:03] the human development index against happiness
[00:15:05] is that it seems to show that it is possible to have literally nothing
[00:15:11] and to be extraordinarily happy.
[00:15:15] And it is also possible to have a lot, as in Russia or the Ukraine,
[00:15:21] and to be positively miserable.
[00:15:24] And it is this argument which is the argument of mind training.
[00:15:30] The main argument of mind training is that our experience of happiness or suffering
[00:15:34] does not depend on exterior events,
[00:15:38] money, partners, health, jobs, whatever,
[00:15:42] but depends on how the mind reacts to this.
[00:15:44] And this is empirically proven by these charts.
[00:15:48] So that’s what I wanted to show you for today.
[00:15:52] And then, if you have any questions
[00:15:54] about Geshe-ra’s talk today or about this material,
[00:15:58] I’ll do my best to address them as well.
[00:16:28] No.
[00:16:33] To be honest with you, what’s very surprising is
[00:16:35] these studies are very controversial.
[00:16:38] I had to work very hard to get the data for Australia.
[00:16:41] For the states, we have very good data,
[00:16:43] which goes back more than one century.
[00:16:46] For Australia, the data is very hard to get.
[00:16:49] Generally speaking, these studies are a big embarrassment
[00:16:51] for the countries involved.
[00:16:54] and it is just this sort of study
[00:16:57] which led the Bhutanese government
[00:16:59] to introduce a new measure of development
[00:17:04] which they call the Human Happiness Index
[00:17:07] now the Bhutanese government has said
[00:17:10] it’s a very interesting notion
[00:17:12] which has attracted a lot of attention in the UK
[00:17:14] that GDP is not a good indicator
[00:17:17] of a society’s development
[00:17:19] we see here societies with high GDP
[00:17:22] in which self-reported happiness is very low,
[00:17:25] and that one needs a more all-encompassing index.
[00:17:29] Now, if one starts using such an index,
[00:17:32] many developed societies can be seen as failing, relatively.
[00:17:42] Are there any other questions? Yes.
[00:17:43] The latest figures in that chart date back to 205.
[00:17:59] Then there was a dip in the suicide rate in 205.
[00:18:02] I have no more recent data.
[00:18:08] Are there other questions?
[00:18:12] Yes?
[00:18:20] I don’t think so.
[00:18:22] I think happiness depends on two things.
[00:18:25] It depends on one’s individual expectations
[00:18:27] and on the socially shared expectations.
[00:18:34] If you are raised in a country
[00:18:35] in which your individual expectations are very low
[00:18:37] and the socially shared expectations are also very low,
[00:18:41] you can be happy with very little.
[00:18:43] If you are raised in a country like this one, or the United States, in which the socially
[00:18:49] expected level is extremely high, and the individually expected level is extremely high,
[00:18:57] then you have the recipe for all the mental ailments we have nowadays, where people
[00:19:03] do not succeed in gaining this arbitrarily high level of achievement, and then succumb
[00:19:11] to a form of self-hatred, which is completely unwarranted.
[00:19:17] Yes? No. No, no, no, that’s completely incorrect.
[00:19:37] If there’s one characteristic of this country, it is that you are all, broadly speaking,
[00:19:41] equal compared to a third world country. Anyone who’s traveled
[00:19:45] to a country like India, let alone Africa, knows that the
[00:19:49] difference in wealth between the poor, let’s say in India, and the rich,
[00:19:53] the richest in India are richer than any Australian. They’re richer than almost
[00:19:57] all Americans, the founder of Reliance,
[00:19:59] the two Ambani brothers, are multi-billionaires
[00:20:01] in dollars.
[00:20:03] They’re worth 30, 40 billion each.
[00:20:06] Then the difference
[00:20:07] between someone of that standard
[00:20:09] and an Indian Dalit, like the ones I saw
[00:20:11] in Delhi cleaning the sewers,
[00:20:13] is stratospheric.
[00:20:14] So it’s not…
[00:20:16] You see, these studies put us on the spot
[00:20:18] because, I don’t know if you’ve noticed,
[00:20:21] we’ve started to try to explain them away.
[00:20:23] Because it’s extremely embarrassing.
[00:20:25] If this is true,
[00:20:26] much of our social policy is wrong.
[00:20:29] What these studies show
[00:20:30] is that happiness is not something
[00:20:32] which can be found or addressed
[00:20:34] by material means.
[00:20:37] That the material means
[00:20:38] contribute, there’s no debate
[00:20:40] about that, but it is possibly
[00:20:42] to be blissfully happy with nothing
[00:20:44] and totally miserable with
[00:20:46] everything.
[00:20:48] Then, we in the West, we have followed one
[00:20:50] route of development, and we have been
[00:20:52] superb in this. We have
[00:20:54] decided to privilege externals, material development. But what is very striking is
[00:21:00] because there’s no inner development, we have extraordinarily rich, wealthy,
[00:21:08] healthy, successful people who are miserable. Having lived in India, the one
[00:21:15] thing which I find very striking is a degree of mental misery in Western
[00:21:19] countries, then one forgets it over time.
[00:21:22] So this is
[00:21:23] the justification
[00:21:25] for Lo Chung.
[00:21:27] Because this, especially
[00:21:29] the chart plotting the Human
[00:21:30] Development Index against
[00:21:33] happiness
[00:21:34] shows that it is possible
[00:21:37] to be happy with nothing.
[00:21:38] Not just happy.
[00:21:40] The happiest countries in the world. Vietnam is included
[00:21:43] in that category. In the chart at least.
[00:21:47] Tanzania and Nigeria.
[00:21:50] Do we have any other questions?
[00:21:54] Yes.
[00:21:59] The research has just started.
[00:22:01] I mean, the biggest problem right now is how to measure happiness.
[00:22:04] So it’s measured by a self-report.
[00:22:06] Then, in a country like this, where the expectations are very high,
[00:22:11] people who actually aren’t unhappy might report themselves as quite unhappy.
[00:22:16] So this research is very loaded research,
[00:22:19] because this research has a direct impact on government policy.
[00:22:25] And you can see why it’s very problematic.
[00:22:27] I don’t know if there’s adequate funding for this sort of research.
[00:23:21] So the question which underlies your question is a very simple one.
[00:23:26] Who am I?
[00:23:29] That is a question which is asked by the scale of the three beings,
[00:23:33] the being of small, middling, and great scope.
[00:23:35] We study these, but we have to apply them to ourselves.
[00:23:39] So there’s actually four categories of beings.
[00:23:41] There are worldly beings who are not on the scale,
[00:23:44] beings of small scope, middling scope, and great scope.
[00:23:47] Probably in this room, most of us are worldly beings.
[00:23:51] In other words, we work for this life.
[00:23:54] Then if that is our goal,
[00:23:57] there is one type of behavior.
[00:23:59] If we are working for future lives,
[00:24:01] there’s a completely different type of behavior.
[00:24:03] So before even answering your question,
[00:24:06] I think we have to ask ourselves, who am I?
[00:24:08] Am I a worldly being?
[00:24:10] Am I a being of the small scope?
[00:24:12] Am I of the middling scope?
[00:24:13] Am I of the great scope?
[00:24:15] If I am a worldly being,
[00:24:17] then one defends oneself as best one can.
[00:24:19] That’s what His Holiness said.
[00:24:23] One has no other goal but this life.
[00:24:25] That’s all one believes in.
[00:24:26] Nothing before, nothing after.
[00:24:28] One tries not to do too much damage.
[00:24:30] And if one is a being of the small scope, one is an intelligent egotist.
[00:24:36] An intelligent egotist is someone who figures he or she wants long-term happiness.
[00:24:41] A worldly intelligent egotist is someone who plans for his old age.
[00:24:47] of us in this room are worldly intelligent egotists putting money in our supers. An intelligent
[00:24:54] egotist of a smaller scope puts money in his future life super. He’s planning for the
[00:24:59] next lives. Then such a person will never do help at any cost because he or she knows
[00:25:05] he will pay for it. There’s no doubt. He has no doubt. Then the next type of practitioner
[00:25:12] wants to escape from it all,
[00:25:15] then such a being is not satisfied
[00:25:17] with not doing harm and doing good.
[00:25:20] He or she wants to cut the root to cyclic existence.
[00:25:23] And the being of great scope
[00:25:25] is a being who is happy to suffer for others.
[00:25:32] If the situation calls for it,
[00:25:33] as Gishara explained this morning,
[00:25:35] such a being sacrifices his or her future life,
[00:25:38] sacrifices his life for others without hesitation.
[00:25:41] But the question we have to answer
[00:25:43] when we attend teachings like this, is
[00:25:45] I, who am I?
[00:25:48] If I’m a being
[00:25:49] who is a worldly being,
[00:25:51] I’m not even, in other words, a Buddhist practitioner,
[00:25:53] a worldly being is not a Buddhist.
[00:25:55] He or she may call himself a Buddhist,
[00:25:57] but there is nothing there, there’s no refuge.
[00:26:00] If I am a worldly being,
[00:26:02] then do I want to become a Buddhist?
[00:26:03] Do I want to enter at least
[00:26:05] in the practice of the being of small scope, or not?
[00:26:08] If we don’t want,
[00:26:09] nobody forces us.
[00:26:11] Sri can come, stay away.
[00:26:14] Then if we do want, we have to think, what is the advantage for me?
[00:26:17] We have to really believe in it.
[00:26:19] So most of us, I think, are very verbal in our relation to the teaching.
[00:26:24] And it’s a matter of trying to live this.
[00:26:28] Then I am really sorry.
[00:26:29] We basically have a little bit more than five minutes to clear all this before Geshima comes.
[00:26:34] If you have any more questions, please ask them from Geshima.
[00:26:37] I thought the charts were interesting and worth showing.
[00:26:40] Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
guru devotion
After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top