Lam Rim – 2011-09-21

2 h 7 min · 4,314 words · 21 September 2011

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2011-09-21
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. This session continues the Lam Rim teaching on the greatness of the Dharma, focusing on the second greatness: that all the scriptures can be taken as oral instructions to practise. It explains that study in the great monasteries should be applied directly to meditation and daily life rather than set aside. The teacher then reviews the previous session and ends with a brief question exchange.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 2h 7m

UUID: e2254bfb-63c9-4f28-b0de-b626365a42ff

Date: 2011-09-21

Words: 4,310

As Śāntideva says says, although they wish to abandon suffering, they do not know how. And although they wish to be happy, they also do not know how. The meaning of this quote is that sentient beings, although they wish to abandon suffering, do not understand what has to be eliminated for this. And although they wish to be happy, do not understand what the causes are for creating happiness. For eliminating suffering and creating happiness, nothing is superior to the teachings of the graduated path which teaches the practice of the beings of the three scopes.

Therefore, please listen to them. As the Pänchen Lama says in the second stanza of the Lam Rim prayer within the Lam Rim prayer, understanding that this rebirth of leisure and endowment is both rare and disintegrates swiftly. Bless me not to waste it on the meaningless affairs of this life, but instead to extract its meaning. Understanding therefore that the basis which we have which is a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is very difficult to find, we should try to extract its essence. It is most probable that its essence is not trying to accumulate money or wealth.

Then what exactly is it which makes this life meaningful and for which we ask for a blessing? And most probably within this room, there is not a single one of us who does not have a job and does not have to work for a living. Therefore, we come here after our work and we come here to study. Geshe la rejoices greatly in this and what we are studying is what is most meaningful, the graduated stages of the path of the beings of three scope. The minimum motivation we have to create for our human rebirth, our human life to be meaningful is to strive for the welfare of future lives.

And once we have generated powerfully this motivation which is striving for future lives, for the welfare of future lives, in other words, the practice of the being of small scope, we can then extend this and generate a motivation which wishes to be free from the suffering of all lives, which is training in the renunciation of the being of middling scope and extend this even more and generate a motivation which wishes to attain full enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So the path of the being of three scopes is summarized by the three principles of the path which are renunciation, bodhicitta and the correct view. Since Kyabje Rinpoche will be giving in the future the initiation of Yamāntaka at the center, these are indispensable specifically the authentic view. And ideally, upon meditating on the three principles of the path, they will arise in a fully characterized form within our mind stream. Even if they do not, some sense of the three principles the path is necessary to engage in practices of Anuttara Yoga Tantra, practices such as the generation or the completion stage which are difficult but not inaccessible.

And if we are unable to meditate, Vajradhāra himself prophesied, he who does not commit any downfall within less than 16 lives will full attainment full enlightenment attain. Therefore, even someone who never meditates, if he can keep the vows and pledges purely, will attain full enlightenment within sixteen lives or less. The supreme practitioner attains full enlightenment in this life while the middling practitioner attains it in the intermediate state, the Bardo.

Is. And one of the foremost disciples of Pänchen Lobsang Yeshe, whose name was Lobsang Namgyal, gave as advice to those of his students who were traveling far away from Tashilhunpo, they go to Drepung or Ganden, just far in Tibet, the following piece of advice. The very essence of practice is to preserve purely vows and pledges. And here vows and pledges refers to the three categories of vows and pledges starting with the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues, then the ethics of the bodhisattva vows and finally ethics of the mantra or tantric vows. One should examine one’s mind, see if one has been stained by downfalls.

If one has been stained by downfalls, one must immediately apply the antidotes and purify these stains. And therefore the last verse of the Pänchen Lama stanza in the Lam Rim prayer reads, bless me to make this life meaningful or to take the essence of this life. The meaning of that verse is that we should at least at the very minimum generate a motivation which is striving for future lives. And if we have generated that motivation wherever we go, whatever we do, we will always be mindful and think this behavior is inappropriate, it leads to non virtue, I will not engage in this. This behavior is inappropriate, it leads to non virtue, I will not engage in it.

And we will be in a state of great happiness. And, therefore, the minimum is to generate a mind striving for future lives. Then on that basis, independence on our capacities, we can give rise to renunciation or definite emergence to bodhicitta and to the mind which realizes emptiness. This is not easy. Geshe la himself entered the monastery in 1984, so he has been studying for more than twenty years.

He cannot say he has any of these minds, in his own mind stream, but he studied a lot and he thinks those of us with sharp capacities, if we put effort, eventually can come to realize this. When we do, we will progress very quickly with our practice. And therefore, having generated within our mind this mind which wishes for which aspires to future lives, then we should engage in the peerless practice for training the mind which is the Lam Rim or the graduated path. And within the Lam Rim, we have reached in the outline the section explaining the greatness of the dharma to generate faith. And within the outline of your English translation of the Lam Rim of Liberation in the palm of your hand, if you go to the back page 673, you have a detailed outline.

We are covering the section, which is outline number two, pages 60 onwards of your main text. The greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instruction in other words to generate faith. Might want to look simultaneously at page six seventy three and page 60. And this is subdivided into four. The first of these greatnesses is a greatness of allowing you to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction.

This was explained last time. Mhmm. The second is a greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions. The third is a greatness of allowing you to easily discover the true thinking of the victorious one. And the fourth is the greatness of protecting you from the worst misdeeds.

Today, Geshe la will explain the second of these. And we will therefore start covering the second of these greatnesses on page 63 of your English text. The greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions. Now generally speaking here, when one speaks of the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to you as instructions, this is a greatness of the of the graduated path. It is not a specific greatness of this treatise Liberation in the palm of your hand.

It is a greatness of their source. Their source is the Lam Rim Chenmo, Jetsongkapa’s great treatise on the stages of the path, and Atisha’s lamp for the path, the Bodhipathapradīpa, which actually are a synthesis of the totality of the teachings of the Buddha as they were developed by the two main trailblazers who were Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga. And as is explained, therefore, in this section on page 60 of your English text, there is no teacher. There is, in other words, no person, no being, which is superior to the Buddha in the capacity to explain the totality of the teachings in an unmistaken fashion and in a way which leads to that state of full enlightenment endowed with the four bodies. These teachings are presented in an unmistaken and unmixed way.

In other words, in the correct sequence in keeping with the analysis which was undertaken of the teachings using reasoning by both Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga. And this is due to the fact that originally when the Buddha taught, he taught for the specific need of individual disciples, custom tailoring his teachings to the need of the trainee. As these teachings were collected over time and through the decay, the degeneracy of the age, progressively an understanding of the precise meaning of the teachings was lost. It was for this reason that the two great trailblazers, Nāgārjuna and his disciples on the one hand and Asaṇga and his disciples on the other hand, manifested to make clear once again the meaning of the teachings of the Buddha, of the Kangyur, the Tripitaka. Now to this day, the Tripitaka is recited in the great Indian monasteries, in the great Tibetan monasteries in India.

And although it is recited quickly, nonetheless, some of the meaning can permeate the mind of the students. It is recited in the context of the long life prayers. And this is why it is said in our treatise, the Liberation in the Palm of your Hand, that it is a great fort to study in-depth the great treatises to familiarize with oneself with their meaning for many years. And then when the time comes for oneself to meditate, to abandon what one has studied, to go off to some so called great meditator who imparts one some sort of secret all instruction and to practice this discarding everything one has studied. This sort of behavior was condemned by Jetsongkapa quite strongly.

And in Tibet at the time of Pabonga Rinpoche, it was unfortunately quite common for geshes who studied a very large number of years, easily twenty, twenty five or thirty years of studies to then go off when they wanted to meditate and receive oral instructions from some Nyingma Lama who had done little or no studies. This behavior is strongly condemned by Pabongka Rinpoche who says that it leads to a degeneration of the teachings. And it is for this reason that the second outline of the greatness is a greatness

Of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to oneself as instructions. In other words, everything one studies becomes something to practice. And the precise meaning of all scriptures dawning to the mind as oral instructions will become explicit later on in the text. And this is why it is said in Jetsong Kapa’s great treatise in the stages of the path, the Lam Rim Chemo, that it is a joke to study the great treatises and then when the time comes to practice, to put them aside and to practice something else. So if one studies in the great seats, the great Tibetan monasteries in India, one will study the five treatises which are the Prajñāpāramitā treatises, the Madhyamaka treatises, the Vinaya, the Abhidharma, and Buddhist logic, Pramānavārttika.

And one must extract the essence of this and whatever one studies is that which one should be practicing at that moment. And therefore what is being said here is that for one is studying the shared or the common path of the Lam Rim, to for one is studying it when it comes to meditate, meditate on Anuttara Yoga Tantra is wrong. Instead, one should meditate on what one is studying at that point. And the example which is given for this is an example Geshe la says he thinks you Australians can relate to. In Tibet, Tibetans love horse races.

And before racing horses on the track, they would walk the horse around the track to show him the track and then would race on that track. So to walk the horse around one track and take him and race him on another track is completely meaningless. And this example should be applied to your own minds. Otherwise, just talking about the example is not very good. And therefore, even though the treatises, the five great treatises are studied very carefully in the great monasteries, one of the faults one encounters is that the practitioners do not understand how to apply what they study from the great treatises to their own meditation and their own minds.

And this arises from not understanding that the Lam Rim, graduated stages of the path is the center or the crux of these five great treatises. And therefore, it is seven page 64 of your English text. Ngawang Chokden once occupied the Ganden throne at the bottom of the page. Noah Trollin was one of the was the first reincarnation of the lineage which became known as the Ling lineage of which the great scholar Trijang Rinpoche was the second reincarnation. After he completed his monastic training, he received many instructions from Jamyang Shepa, the great practitioner from Amdo.

For instance, Jethongkapa’s three fundamentals of the path. He was introduced to the way to meditate on the thoughts contained in the entire body of the Buddha’s words, the sutras and tantras as a coherent whole. And it is said that when Trichen, in other words, he became the head of the Geluk tradition, Trichen Ngawang Chokden was very elderly. He was presenting to some of his students the 8,000 verse perfection of wisdom sūtra, as well as the more elaborate, more extensive perfection of wisdom sutras which are huge texts. And as he was reading them, he said to his students repeatedly, if I wasn’t so old, there are key points here I should practice.

This is a clear sign that he had realized that all the teachings are to dawn as oral instructions. If we take now, for instance, these studies in the great monasteries, we can see how they are all connected to the Lam Rim. For instance, in the first section of Parqin, Parqin Kundun Damo, one studies the Four Noble Truths which are connected with the path of the being of middling scope and one studies later on within the ancillary topics the 12 links of dependent origination which are also connected with the practice of the being of middling scope. Within the first volume of Parqin, one studies generating the mind which is generating bodhisattva, the practice of the being of the great scope and the practice of the being of small scope is partially addressed within the presentation of the four noble truths in which impermanence is presented. And if we reflect on how the studies are undertaken in the great monasteries such as Serhaje, Geshe-la’s root monastery, Then every morning, one receives teachings, peti.

It is called guidance in texts. Then all afternoon, one studies. And the whole class, which is studying the topic, which may be 150 or 200 monks, studies only the same topic together. And then the evening, they debate for hours only on this topic and on nothing else. Then if one has been able to defend one’s own position well in debate against the attacks of other scholars, at night and the next day one feels very happy.

On the other hand, if one has lost one’s good position to the attacks of other scholars, then one’s mind is troubled. Perhaps these emotional reactions are a sign that one has not taken the totality of the teachings as oral instructions. Did you go to Sera? Robin? So Anilah has been to Serraje and Shaya will be going to Serraje.

And those who have been there and those who will be there, Geshe would like you to recollect or to look when you go there at how the Serraje monks study. And when Geshiva started, the classes were very large. There were up to 300 monks at a time studying altogether simultaneously the same topics. As an anecdote from Tibet, it seems to come from Ganden Monastery in Tibet. As you know, when Buddhist monks debate, there is one debater, and he claps his hand when he casts the debate, and there is one respondent who answers the debate.

These two monks were debating on the nature of phenomena, whether they were impermanent or not, and they were using the example of a vase called bumpa in Tibetan. The term is never used in ordinary Tibetan for a vase. They were debating on and on, and finally, one of them asked the other, what is this vase we’re talking about?

And a sign of having realized all of the teachings as oral instructions is that one has limitless veneration for the teachings in any form even in the form of tsa-tsas. In other words, small clay or plaster statues of the Buddhas which are kept in a tsa-tsa house in company with old texts which are ready to be burned. So one has respect even for these old and frayed texts. And in this context, the seventh Dalai Lama said, giving an example here of the behavior to be avoided, it is akin to a bumblebee which is fluttering from rhododendron to rhododendron, never staying for long with any flower. This is a sign of lack of stability both in friendship and in practice.

What is this greatness of seeing all of the instructions of the conquerors, in other words of the Buddha appearing as oral instructions? It is understanding that every single element of the teachings of the Buddha from the individual letters of the teachings upwards is exclusively intended to benefit the mind of beings. And Je Tsongkhapa himself asked from a great Tibetan master the meaning of the term kadampa. As you remember, Geshe la spoke of the kadampa’s. And the term kadampa in Tibetan has two syllables, ka, which means speech or teaching, and dam or dampa, which means instruction.

And this great Tibetan master told him, a kadampa is one who takes every single letter, even the letter nah within the Buddha’s sutras as an oral instruction to practice. When Je Rinpoche Jetsongkapa left this master’s room, he said, I received today a great teaching from this master. Then through understanding that every single letter, every single word of the sutras was taught by Buddhas and Bodhisattvas for the benefit of beings, the realization of the greatness of the scriptures arises and with this arises faith. And this is why it is set on page 66 of your English text. As one yogi, of a famous yogi actually said, we are not told we will find instructions for gaining definite enlightenment in some poem sized anthology of spells of mantras.

We should look instead upon all scripture as instruction. And says that the sign of all of the teachings of the Buddha dawning as oral instructions is when every single point of practice which is taught whether it be in the extensive Lam Rim, the great treatise on the stages of the path, the concise Lam Rim also by Jitsongkapa or other treatises of Lam Rim ranging from relying on the spiritual teacher all the way up to the practices of single pointed concentration and Vipassana or insight as well as a union. Every single one of these therefore is practiced by ourselves in our daily lives. And how should one practice this? It means that if one is engaged in the great studies, specifically in the monasteries, when one is studying the generation of bodhicitta within the first section of of the paramita studies, Then one fuses this with the teachings in the Lam Rim Chenmo on Bodhicitta in the final section of Lam Rim Chenmo.

Then when one is studying the four noble truths within again Parqin Kundun Damo, the first volume of Parqin in the monasteries, one actually connects this with the teachings on the four noble truths within the great treatise on the stages of the path. And likewise when one is studying on studying impermanence and so forth. So to give an example, it’s exactly as when you are cooking a really good meal. You have a recipe which lists the ingredients. You can’t make a meal of meat alone or of spices alone.

You need rice, meat, spices, oil in certain amounts. If the amounts are wrong, the food is damaged. Then you mix them in the right amounts and you get a delicious meal. In the same way, to practice correctly, we have to take the various topics we are studying and then fuse them into one whole practice, one recipe. So it’s the same thing as for instance if we have people with different vocations in life.

For instance, people who are ordained and people who are lay people. Nonetheless, they meet in their daily activities. This would be another example. And therefore, we have presented the two has presented the two first greatnesses of the Lam Rim that all of the teachings one realizes all of the teachings as non contradictory and one also sees all of the teachings without exception as oral instructions, then the doubt which might arise is, is there any necessary entailment between these two? And in this matter, says, if one has realized all of the teachings as non contradictory, one has not necessarily realized that all of the teachings can dawn as oral instructions.

If on the other hand, one has realized that all of the teachings dawn as oral instructions, then one has necessarily realized that all of the teachings are non contradictory. In the Lam Rim Chenmo, Lam Rim Chenmo it is said that the first of these greatnesses of Lam Rim, the realization that all of the teachings are non contradictory is actually the cause of the second of these greatnesses which is the understanding that all teachings without exception dawn as oral instructions which is its effect. So they are in a cause and effect relationship. To use an example, Geshe-la says one could compare this with canals or irrigation channels in India by the field. The first realization that all of the teachings are non contradictory is like building the irrigation channel by the field.

The second realization is what happens when water actually flows through the channel irrigating the field. Therefore the realizations ranging for instance from the generation of compassion on the path of the being of great scope all the way up to the attainment of the state of full enlightenment endowed with the four bodies would represent or would be included within the first greatness understanding that all of the teachings are non contradictory. Whereas engaging in that practice oneself would be grouped within the second realization where all of the teachings dawn as oral instructions. So we will stop here for today on page 67 of your English text. And we have covered today the presentation of the second greatness of Lam Rim that all of the teachings dawn as oral instructions.

Now Geshe la will be asking you questions and his questions will cover the topic covered last time, which is the presentation of all of the teachings as non contradictory, the first greatness of the Lam Rim. And what Geshe la would like to ask you is what is this this first greatness of the Lam Rim and what examples are given to illustrate it?

And then think about this carefully. And if we can’t cover everything today, we will cover it next time. What is the example? Yes. Very good.

So for each of the outlines, Geshe la will ask questions from you. Therefore, you have to cover them carefully. And now regarding your questions, if you have questions only on the topic covered today which is all of the teachings dawning as oral instructions, please feel free to ask them. Do you have questions? Yeah.

A common one. What do you Alright. Common with that. So that is absolutely wrong. It is out of the question to put aside one’s whatever tantric practices one is engaging with within usually where one is attending Lam Rim teachings instead one must draw one’s Lam Rim teachings or practice into these and one must practice them even more intensely.

And therefore we have covered over the last two weeks these two weighty topics of the greatness of the Lam Rim. The first that all of the teachings dawn as non contradictory. The second that all of the teachings dawn as oral instructions to be practiced. Geshe-la would like to ask you to reflect on both of these and although it is not easy to put effort in them. Understand that all of you have jobs and work and that you may not be able to meditate formally.

That is not important. You can meditate whenever you have time or even tonight when you go to sleep. Before going to sleep, reflect on what was taught today and then the six, seven, eight hours of sleep you are taking all turn into a virtuous activity. This is his hope. A small comment, please.

We are very lucky at TBI to have a Geshe who is trying to teach us the way we are taught at Serraje monastery which is very interactive but this demands something from the students. This means that you have to prepare the class and the questions you ask are not questions on any which topic, it has to be on the topic covered during the previous class or this class. If you have time, having your own discussion groups is a very good way to go about it. Otherwise, if we have something very passive, then there’s no point. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

bumpa
A ritual vase with a spout used in ceremonies and initiations. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top