1 h 46 min · 4,183 words · 15 December 2010
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues the Lam Rim teaching by moving from theory to practice, beginning with guru yoga, the seven limb prayer and mandala offering. It then covers training for the three scopes: precious human rebirth, impermanence and karma for the small scope; the four noble truths and three trainings for the middling scope; and equanimity, recollecting mothers’ kindness and tonglen of giving and taking for the great scope. It stresses that understanding must lead to practice and that harming others never brings benefit.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 46m
UUID: 6afe61db-39bf-401c-8005-12c7becdd408
Date: 2010-12-15
Words: 4,179
Uh-huh. So we will meditate for one or two minutes on generating the motivation to listen to these teachings. The supreme means to listen to Mahāyāna teachings, which is to generate a good motivation, a motivation which is impelled by love and by empathy to listen to these teachings and for these teachings to be, explained. This motivation is one where we wish from our side to eliminate all our thoughts and to, attain all qualities, actually, to lead all of our qualities to perfection and to lead all beings to this state. And with this as a motivation, we will, meditate for one or two minutes before listening to the teachings.
So Rinpoche has explained in detail the theoretical aspect of the teachings. And today, he would like to enter into how one should practice these teachings. So we will pass on to Page 16 of the commentary of Trijang Rinpoche on this text, the bottom third of the text. If one can, it is best to practice first an extensive Guru Yoga, either the extensive preliminary rites or the Lama Chöpa. Extensive preliminary rites here refers to the so called Jorchö practices which are engaged in the six preliminary practices of the Lam Rim.
Alternatively, one can also perform Lama Chöpa Guru Yoga. Or if such is not possible, after visualizing either on one’s crown or in the space in front, the guru deity with the field of merit. So here, Khensur Rinpoche says one can visualize one’s root teacher on one’s crown or directly in front of oneself, either in his own aspect or in the aspect of Buddha Śākyamūni, upon offering concisely or elaborately or concisely a seven limb prayer as appropriate offer mandala. So since from today on, we’ll be explaining how to practice, please listen carefully and retain this in your mind. Otherwise, from tomorrow onwards, when you try to practice, you will be unable to do so.
And then, as the commentary says, one should perform the seven limb prayer should one so choose. These include the limbs of prostration, of offering, of confession, of rejoicing, of requesting the turning of the wheel of the law, of requesting the teacher to abide for long, and of dedicating the merit thus accrued. One can do this in an elaborate or in a concise form. If you wish to do the seven limb prayer elaborately, you should do it in keeping with the royal prayer or the prayer of Samantabhādra, and you might want to look into it. There is tremendous benefit in the practice of the seven limb prayer in terms of purification of obstructions, accumulation of merit, and so forth.
After this, one should offer a mandala, offering mandala to request the blessings from the spiritual teacher to be able to realize the practices one is engaged in.
In as much as this teaching the wheel of sharp weapons is a Mahāyāna teaching, as a preliminary, one should train the mind in the practices of the being of small and middling scope. And then only upon this basis using them as a preliminary can one enter in the practices of the Mahāyāna. Otherwise, if one does not train the mind in the practices of the being of small and middling scope as Rinpoche previously explained, and one tries to enter directly in the practice of the being of great scope, then should one be a bodhisattva, one would be able to practice as a peacock in the garden of poisonous plants. But otherwise, one will be in the situation of the crow who dies from the poison. And the practice of the being of small scope starts with reflections on the difficulty in obtaining the precious human rebirth, which has the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments.
In other words, 18 main characteristics. This human birth, is so hard to obtain, must be meditated upon slightly. And then after this, one should reflect that one must practice dharma because this human rebirth is impermanent. In other words, we will die. And while the body itself is destroyed at death, the mind itself moves on eternally, and the mind, as a result of the karma which is accrued, can either move upwards to higher rebirth or downwards to lower rebirths.
It is difficult for us to accumulate positive karma, and probably because of the non virtuous karma already present in our mind stream, there is a great danger that we will be reborn in our next life in the lower bounds. So searching around for who can protect us from this, we can see that the triple gem, the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha are authentic protectors, authentic refuge. And then we generate both faith and veneration within our mind stream and request them to protect us from the lower realms. And after addressing these powerful imploring prayers, in other words, these powerful prayers to the Buddha, praying that we not be reborn in the lower realms, the Buddha himself will give us advice or teachings, and this advice is twofold, to practice virtue and to abstain from non virtue. This is nothing else but the teachings on karma and causality.
Now these are teachings we have to practice. We have to train in the 10 virtuous deeds, and we have to abandon the 10 non virtuous deeds. And as a result of this, we will not be reborn in the lower realms. And here, when we refer to practice, we refer to practice as the Buddha taught it. So we have to understand clearly what the Buddha taught, to train in the 10 virtuous deeds and to abandon the 10 non virtuous deeds.
For this, we have to understand what these virtuous deeds are and what the non virtuous deeds are. Otherwise, there is no practice. There is no practice in which we don’t train in the virtuous deeds and we run around engaging in non virtuous deeds. Then if we have trained correctly after death, things will go well for us. Otherwise, if we haven’t, we will fall in the lower realms, and after death, we will have had gained no benefit.
So this is a presentation of the path of the being of small scope, which includes reflecting on the precious human rebirth of leisure and opportunity, reflecting on death and impermanence, and reflecting on karma and causality. And the practice of the being of middling scope entails general reflections on the nature of samsaric existence. Psychic existence is pervaded by suffering. And for an understanding of this we must understand what suffering is and we must also understand the causes of suffering. Then, since we do not want to suffer, we want to abandon suffering, we must eliminate the causes for suffering.
Likewise, since we want to be happy, we must create the causes for happiness. To do this, we have to understand the four noble truths. Dependent on this, through understanding that saṃsāra is fundamentally bad, is fundamentally evil, we will train in the three trainings: the training of ethics, of concentration and of wisdom. The training of ethics is that training where body, speech and mind are restrained and subdued. The training of concentration is a training where the mind is in turn focused on a virtuous object, and the training of wisdom is the development of that wisdom which realizes the selflessness of persons and phenomena.
For this, it is necessary to understand what this selflessness is. Dependent on this, one can attain liberation from samsaric existence. So at present, these were the preliminaries for of the being of small and middling scope, which lead to the practice of the being of great scope. This practice of the being of great scope is mind training or lojong, which focuses on training in bodhicitta. And for this, it is indispensable to train in the preliminaries.
If one does not train in the preliminaries, it will be impossible to generate bodhicitta. In the self same way as if one does not train preliminaries in general, it’s impossible to accomplish one’s goal. On the other hand, if one trains carefully in the preliminaries, then most definitely it will be possible to generate bodhicitta. This is similar, Rinpoche says, to when we want to cook a really fine meal. We start by going shopping.
And if we shop for really good food, we we can hope to have a good meal. Otherwise, it is not possible.
So for the great vehicle, we must train in love and in compassion. However, as a preliminary for training in love and in compassion, we must generate equanimity, which is a mind which has neither desire nor hatred towards beings. This means that with such a mind we have neither attraction nor animosity to beings and while in general it is very difficult for us to place all beings themselves in a state where they are free from attraction and animosity, it is definitely possible for us from our own side not to allow attraction or animosity, desire or anger to arise within our mind stream towards sentient beings. This is called equanimity. In other words, all beings are seen as equal, as identical.
There is no desire whatsoever towards anyone, and there is no anger or hatred whatsoever towards anyone. If we are able to put an end to both desire and hatred, then this is an extraordinarily powerful practice. This is a source of great virtue. If on the other hand, we are unable to do this, then anything which is motivated by desire or hatred is necessarily nonvirtuous. And with a mind which is troubled by desire and hatred, it is impossible to generate genuine compassion.
And after generating equanimity, which is a state of mind which has neither attraction nor animosity towards being, since we are actually entering in the Mahāyāna, it is necessary to see all sentient beings as one’s mother. And to do this, one must reflect on the fact that in this life, we have a mother and in we have had beginning this beginningless lives in the past. There is no beginning point to our lives. We cannot point to one life and say this is where it started. Therefore, our lives themselves are numberless, are beginningless.
In this life we have a mother. In every single human life we have had in the past, we have had a mother. Therefore we have had countless mothers as well as countless lives. One can say that there is not a single sentient being which has not been our mother, whether we were in human form, in animal form, as a horse, and so forth. Therefore, we train to view all sentient beings as our mothers.
Then independence on this, one recollects the kindness of one’s mother. In this very life, our mother was in her womb for nine months undergoing tremendous physical discomfort in the process. She was never one moment without thinking of us, and whenever she ate, she only thought, will this help my little child or not? She was completely powerless. She lost her independence, And at the time of our birth, she undergo underwent tremendous suffering.
However, as soon as we were born, she took us in her arms and she smiled and laughed at us and looked at us and then placed placed us on her breasts and fed us with the very substance of her body. If we reflect on the fact, we can see that if she were to have abandoned us for just one hour, we would not have survived. And then we can subdivide thinking on the kindness of one’s mother in two parts, her kindness to us when we were in her womb and her kindness to us after we were born. So Rinpoche has covered her kindness to us while we were in her womb. After our birth, we can see that she not only fed her fed us with her own milk, she dressed us.
She constantly kept an eye on us, making sure that no harm befell us and that we only had pleasant experiences. And if she had some money of her own, then she managed to take care of us. If she was poor and destitute, then she engaged in great non virtue to be able to get food for us, to get clothing for us, and so forth. And this continued for as long as we depended on her. And therefore, we should reflect that, as a matter of fact, our parents of this life, were our parents not once but many times, in past lives, and that there is not a single life in which we were not protected by mother sentient beings.
Reflecting in this way, we can see that our parents of this life were our parents in past lives not one time but many and many times over. And for that matter, that there is not a single being of whom we can say that he or she has not been our parent in past lives. They have therefore shown tremendous kindness to us, giving medicine, clothing, money whenever we required. We ourselves at present are unable to extend even a fraction of the kindness they show to us to other beings. Yet this is what we have to train in.
We have to train in giving food, in giving drink, in giving everything beings need to them. There is no such thing as Mahāyāna Dharma without the practice of repaying the kindness of father and mother sentient beings. And fundamentally, whatever sentient being one is dealing with, one should at least not harm them. A child who harms its parents is a vicious child. But in addition, one should try to help them.
Helping them is virtuous. Therefore, the best of practices is to help others, but at least one should not harm them.
And we train as follows. Initially, we recollect carefully the kindness of our mother in this life, how everything we have, we owe to her from the moment we are born to the fact we were dressed, the fact that we know language, the fact that we know how to function, we all owe this to our mother. And then reflecting that all sentient beings have been our mothers, we extend this sense of gratitude to, sentient beings through recollecting the fact that their kindness is similar to that of our mother. And at this point, we give rise to empathy and to love. Both can be generated quite easily, Rinpoche says, if one reflects carefully on these points.
So one sees that all these mother sentient beings suffer because they do not know how to practice virtue, and they do not have even one iota of happiness. And then reflecting upon this, one wishes out of empathy to free them from suffering and out of love to bestow happiness on them. It is at this point, natural to proceed upwards to the generation of bodhicitta which arises from empathy and from love. At this point, one visualizes all mother sentient beings in space in front of oneself, either in their natural appearance or in the appearance and the shape of our mother in this life. And reflecting on the fact that all of them suffer and are totally bereft from happiness, one then imagines that one inhales all of the sufferings within them and one takes them all into ourselves.
They enter into our nostril and they impact both the self cherishing and the conception apprehending the inherent existence of the self which dwell in our innermost innermost heart and completely destroy them. At this point, through this visualization, both mother sentient beings will have been benefited since one will have taken all their suffering upon ourselves. And we ourselves will have been benefited since we will have eliminated both self cherishing and the conception which apprehends itself as truly existing. And then having taken upon ourselves all of their sufferings, this is the first branch of is to give, and is to take. So this is to take.
Then one gives from one’s own side all of one’s happiness to mother sentient beings. And if we were to take the example of our mother in this life and imagine that she is afflicted with horrific pain and that wishing to help her, we cook a very fine meal for her. She will be unable to enjoy that meal because of the great pain she is in. Therefore, the first step is to give her medicine to clear the suffering, to clear the disease she is suffering from. And once she is hale and hearty, hearty, then we can give her a very fine meal and she would enjoy it.
Would be of help to her. Likewise here, the first step in the practice of Tonglen, of giving and taking, is to actually take the suffering of mother sentient beings. One could not give them initially happiness since they undergo such suffering at present that they would be unable to experience the happiness we gave them. Therefore, at first, one takes upon oneself their suffering, and one does this through imagining initially that beams of light akin to hooks emanate from one’s heart, and they hook the suffering of sentient beings, which is then then drawn back within us with our breath. And when it is drawn back within us, this suffering then impacts both the self cherishing and the conception apprehending true existence of the self at our heart as well as all our non-virtues and completely destroys them.
In so doing, we would have eliminated all the suffering from mother sentient beings and enacted their weal, and we would have also eliminated the causes of suffering at our heart and created the causes for eliminating our own suffering. Then having eliminated the suffering from the minds of being, we in turn can give them happiness. We therefore visualize love and compassion emanating from our heart, entering into the minds of all mother sentient beings and destroying all the self cherishing and the conception apprehending true existence of the self within their minds. At this point, we will have eliminated all the causes of their suffering and given them happiness. Having given them happiness, it is natural that we as their children should experience happiness.
Therefore, we ourselves will also experience happiness. It is the key of Mahāyāna practice that our own happiness is automatically and powerlessly created through enacting the happiness of others. As Buddha Śākyamūni said, just as the cause you have created, likewise will be the effect. In other words, one who harms others will himself reap harm, whereas one who helps others will himself reap happiness. And, therefore, the the core practitioners of the Mahāyāna are Buddhas and Bodhisattva
These are the ones who practice the Mahāyāna, and what they practice is this practice of taking upon themselves the suffering of others and of giving to others their happiness. Therefore, they engage in this practice of of giving and taking. And how they do this is since others do not understand in the slightest how to eliminate suffering, they explain to them individually for each, event of suffering what the cause of the suffering is. Since they do not understand in the slightest how to create the causes for happiness, they explain to them for each instant of happiness what the actual causes of happiness are. Engaging in this way in the practice of taking upon oneself the suffering of others and giving them one’s own happiness is how the Buddha’s and the Bodhisattvas practice.
At the very instant when within the mind of a practitioner, the thought arises, I want to be free of my own suffering and I want to be happy myself. At that very instant, this practitioner has fallen from the Mahāyāna into the Hīnayāna. He ceases to be a Mahāyāna being. This is the sole thought of Hīnayāna practitioners to be happy themselves alone and to eliminate their solitary suffering. They have no thought whatsoever for others.
Buddhas and bodhisattvas, on the other hand, do not think at all about how to eliminate their own suffering nor do they think at all about how to create their own happiness. They only think about how to eliminate the suffering of others and how to create the happiness of others. Oddly enough, Rinpoche says, as a result of eliminating the suffering of others, they themselves experience tremendous happiness. It is strange, isn’t it? So if we were to take the example of farmers, for instance, the foundation for the wealth or the prosperity of farmers are their fields.
It’s independence on the fields of farmers and the quality of their crops that they will do well in a year or not, and in turn be able to buy clothing for themselves and, so forth. Now sentient beings are the field of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas. It is independence on sentient beings that Bodhisattvas accumulate merit. And therefore, Bodhisattvas strive to eliminate the suffering of sentient beings because in so doing, they eliminate their own suffering. And they strive to enact or to generate happiness within sentient beings because in so doing, they enhance their own happiness.
This is how Buddhas and Bodhisattvas practice. There is no such thing as a practice which harms others. When one harms others, let alone not being able to attain the state of full enlightenment or becoming a bodhisattva, one will never be able to become for that matter an arhat or a Hīnayāna practitioner. If we were to take another example, Rinpoche says, we might take the example of a child which is offering food to his mother. Now when the child offers food to his mother which has been well obtained, the mother is happy and satisfied.
But otherwise, if the child has engaged in criminal activities and dependent on this, tries to please his mother through through making her gifts of meals and so forth, the mother will not be happy because she wants the welfare of the child, and she knows very clearly that these gifts were badly acquired. In the same same way, there is no such thing as offerings to the Buddhas or the Bodhisattvas, which are acquired through harming beings. For instance, through killing, through stealing, through dishonesty, and so forth. This cannot satisfy the Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas in the same way as ill earned money cannot satisfy a mother. The term for worship in Sanskrit is puja.
Puja means to please, to satisfy. As Nāgārjuna says, the cause of both worldly virtue and happiness and worldly nonvirtue and misery is none other than helping or harming sentient beings. In other words, generally speaking, we understand that there are two possible destinations, the higher and the lower realms, and the cause for reaching the higher realms is none other than benefiting beings, whereas the cause for being reborn in the lower realms is none other than harming sentient beings. Therefore, Rinpoche says, the cause of higher or lower rebirth is none other but other sentient beings. Did you understand?
Okay. We’ll take one question today. So generally speaking, what is translated in English as idle talk in Tibetan is which is degenerate talk or debased talk. It refers to meaningless talk, talk about politics, the Tibetan say about the kings and so forth. But more fundamentally, the term because it refers to degeneration here, refers to talk which leads to a degeneration of ethics.
And this is, for instance, gossip or idle talk, which actually leads to the harming of another person’s ethics or even to the abandonment of their ethics. This is the meaning of of. And therefore, in general, ethics refers to the threefold restraint of the body, of the speech, and of the mind. Restraint of the body or taming the body, restraint of the speech, or taming the speech, and restraint of the mind. Now in the context of idle talk, idle talk is the opposite of restrained or tamed speech.
It is meaningless speech which leads to a degeneration of verbal ethics of the ethics of speech. So this is why gossip is such a fault.
Said, the purpose of hearing is understanding, and the purpose of understanding is practicing. So we have attended many teachings and heard many dharma teachings. And dependent on this, we hopefully have understood some of the teachings. However, the purpose of this understanding is not mere understanding, mere information. It is practice.
Therefore, dependent on this, one must first understand what virtue and non virtue are, and then one must practice virtue and abandon non virtue. If one, understands what virtue and nonvirtue are, but does not practice virtue and abandon nonvirtue, this is said to be much worse than someone who does not understand and as a result of this is not able to practice at all. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- jorchö
- The six preparatory practices that prepare the mind for lamrim meditation. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.