Lam Rim – 20 Lamrim

1 h 40 min · 4,807 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 20 Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk covers motivation for receiving Lam Rim teachings, and the path shared with beings of small scope, including contentment with sensory objects, clothing, food and reputation as a way to reduce self-cherishing. It then turns to the three levels of ignorance that grasp at the self, and how the view of emptiness counters them. The second half is a question and answer session on these topics, including the Prasangika view and Aryadeva’s teaching on emptiness.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: 2ead5aa8-d592-4d0f-a5eb-3cbcadf8a465

Words: 4,803

So the weather’s getting colder. Right? Those who love cold weather are happy, and those who don’t love cold weather are unhappy. But I don’t like, you know, cold weather. But I lived in India long time ago.

In South India. The temperatures at Sera are really marvelous. Yeah. No no no too hot. No.

Too cold. You know? And the middle is there? The middle one. I think high fourth fourth is sometime, you know, 34 or five.

That’s a little harsh in during the during the the During the June January and February, I think, March, the time to to come down, you know, rain. So then it’s very helpful to think of these topics topics in terms of chapters. The first chapter would be motivation. The second chapter would be, for instance, the path shared with the being of the small scope. And the third chapter would be our topic, in this case, interdependence.

Then ideally, you ask questions later, you will fit your questions in these subdivisions. So these subdivisions or chapters, Geshe la does not mention explicitly, but they’re actually part of the outline of the teaching. So the first subdivision or topic is an easy one. It is that of meditation, and we all know what meditation is. There are both good and bad meditation.

There are good and bad meditations for receiving Lamrim teachings. Then there’s nothing particularly mysterious about motivation. The reason for which we left home today to come to attend the hall to receive these teachings, that is our motivation, then it’s not something which has to be identified suddenly on the spot. So our motivation for receiving these teaching is simply the thought, with which, we came here today with which we left home. Then the best motivation, is that motivation to wish to attain a higher rebirth as a human being or a god in the next life.

That’s what they say. So if we left home today with as motivation to attend these teachings, the idea, I will be going to these teachings to attend a higher rebirth in my next life, then that is superb. That is going for the sake of the motivation of the being of the small scope. If on the other hand, we left home today with the idea, well, I really wonder what Geshe-la could say today, then that is not a good motivation. It’s a neutral motivation.

So what happened? So I don’t know why we left home today to come to the temple. There’s not one of us who is unaware of this. That is our motivation. I think the ice is my problem.

But It’s called a feedback loop. Right? That’s what it’s called. Okay. So therefore, at the very least, at the minimum, the motivation we should have is, I am attending these teachings because I must attain in future lives the status of a human being all day.

And then, incrementally, if we say to ourselves, I will be going to attend these teachings for the sake of attaining liberation, that is going with the motivation of the being of the middling scope. And if we say to ourselves, I will be going for the sake of attaining full and utter enlightenment to benefit others, that is the motivation of the being of the great scope. In brief, these are the three motivations. So, for this, it is not sufficient, to pray, may I attain in a future life a higher rebirth? That would be too easy.

It is, the lazy man’s approach. Instead, we need, in addition, to accumulate the causes for this. We must engage the causes which give rise to this. And for this, we must reflect on the topics of meditation of the path shared to being of the small school. So now, Geshe-la will not expatiate on the path shared with the being of the small scope.

It has been taught many times at TBI whether you subdivide it into five, six, or seven, topics of meditation. What Geshe-la would like to point out is that it is insufficient, just to cover these topics. One needs, in addition, to engage in practice, and the example he would like to give is that of purchasing a car. So in addition to the motivation of buying a car, we realize that we need a car to go to work. Without a car, we can’t go to work.

And in addition to having the money to buy the car. We need also to engage in the activities to buy the car. Otherwise, if we have the motivation and we have the money and we don’t do anything about it, we will not get the car. So all of us understand this very well. It is not sufficient to wish to buy a car, and, it is not sufficient to have the money to buy a car.

We must also actually go to buy a car or physically buy a car. Now it is the same thing with our practice. It is not sufficient to wish to gain a higher rebirth, and it is not sufficient to understand how one goes about to gain a higher rebirth. One must also engage in the practice. And, therefore, either by, not understanding how to practice or by being unable to engage in practice, in other words, the procrastination or the laziness which keeps deferring to tomorrow, to next month, to next year, practice which we should be doing now, we do not attain our goal.

Now what are the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small scope? You all know what the abandonments are. You know what the object of meditation are. You know how to meditate. But what are the attainments?

And then we have to investigate the means to gain these attainments. Now as far as this life is concerned, what is the attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope? It is contentment, in Tibetan, literally knowing what is possible. Then there are two types of contentment. There is exterior and interior contentment.

Exterior contentment is contentment contentment focused on the, five sensory objects: forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations. In dependence on this, in turn, interior contentment arises.

Now what precisely is contentment focused on exterior objects? This is contentment focused on the five sensory objects. First, contentment focused on visual objects, in other words, colors and shapes. This is perhaps the hardest for us to practice. Then contentment focused on sounds, on smells, on taste, and on tactile sensations.

Do you agree? Then for a child, in other words, a child age, let’s say, ages three, four or five, the main sources of sensory craving are visual and auditory. And as one grows older, especially one grows into adulthood, as you all know, the main sources of craving are for tactile sensations and taste. Then, this is something which doesn’t have to be explained nor does it necessarily have to be considered as Then, as one grows older, the craving for tactile sensations becomes overpowering. Then here, tactile sensations refers to sexuality, the pleasure of copulation.

Then the pleasure of copulation or sexuality is necessary for society. Without copulation or sexuality, there are no children. Society ceases. However, it is also craving for sexuality, which is the source of the greatest suffering in our societies. And this is why if one can practice contentment and reduce one’s attachment to sexuality, there are great benefits.

Now, clearly, in society at large, these are the biggest problems. And, we can see that if we can increase our contentment, towards the source of great craving attach attachment, then we will increase our happiness. Then if we take the case of clothing, which we accumulate for the sake of our tactile sensation, we do not need more than four or five items of clothing and a couple of shoes. Then if instead of that, we have whole racks filled with fancy clothing, we will need the money to buy all this fancy clothing. Then we will have to work or someone will have to work for us to get that money.

Instead of that, if we can practice contentment and have few clothing and only a couple of shoes, then we can keep this money for ourselves. And as a result, we also will have time to study topics like So you have money. This is a rich country, Gishul. I can see you have money. But the question is, what do you use the money for?

You use it for something beneficial, or do you waste it? This is clear. Right? So at this point, one engages in practice. One practices contentment with respect to food and to bedding.

One practices contentment with respect to to these, and one becomes a superior being with respect to concentration. Then in your cases, Geshe la assumed that in this room, everyone is an adult. Probably everyone is over 30, maybe 40, 50, 60, even 70. But Not 70, I think. No.

Hey. Just all in. Then contentment with respect to exterior thing is probably more present within your mind streams, but what is lacking is contentment with respect to ourselves. For instance, contentment with respect to one’s body and one’s appearance. And this craving towards one’s five aggregates, in other words, what is included within one’s continuum, this is much more difficult to abandon.

Then probably if one has abandoned craving towards exterior objects and craving towards one’s own continuum, one’s body and so forth, then one will have a Then as one grows older, if one still looks good, one is not too fat, one is not too thin, one is just right, then one is proud of one’s appearance, and one is proud of one’s voice. You know? And in dependence on this, arrogance arises. True or not true? For sure you are like that.

Has it within himself. He assumes you do too. So this is, therefore, what is meant by contentment. Contentment with respect to exterior objects and also contentment with respect to what is included within one’s own continuum, one’s aggregates and so forth. In other words, contentment with respect to exterior objects, contentment with respect to what is included within one’s continuum, also contentment with respect to one’s name.

Now one’s name or one’s reputation is what is included within these three objects with respect to which one should have contentment, toktam sum in Tibetan, which are basically clothing, food and repute. And the most difficult of all is obviously repute. This is what is referred to in the verses of Tsongkhapa’s three principal aspects of the path in which he says. Leisure and endowment are rare and time is fleeting, reflecting on this turn away from the vanities of this life. So abandoning repute is the hardest thing of all.

There are very few people who are indifferent to what others say about them to the fact that others don’t like Then, obviously, the hardest of all is abandoning attachment to one’s name. And here, name does not refer to name in general, but what we call in English one’s good name, one’s good reputation. Then it is very difficult to abandon this. When one is able to do this, one probably has generated contentment both with respect to the exterior world and with respect to oneself. And, as a result of this, definitely, self cherishing would dwindle.

One would also have attained an abandonment of the eight worldly dharmas, and one would have attained the ten qualities of the Kadampa tradition. Okay. Then as Tsongkhapa says, once this uncontrived natural striving for this life, which is present within all of us, has progressively dwindled under repeated reflections of this nature, and we have actually replaced it. We have switched positions with a striving for high attainment in the next life and beyond. At that point, we have relinquished the vanities of this life.

We have the attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Do you understand? So the crux in this statement is the term uncontrived. It when we say an uncontrived striving for one’s welfare in future lives, this means it is present in the dream state naturally. And it also would mean that when we rise in the morning, it would arise spontaneously within our minds.

Then Geshe la assumes that everyone in this room, when they get up in the morning, thinks spontaneously of breakfast.

And then, obviously, if we all think when we get up in the morning, I’ve got to make breakfast, it seems difficult to generate that thought when we get up in the morning. I must strive for my welfare in future lives, or I must strive for the attainment of full and utter enlightenment. Then His Holiness the Dalai Lama says that when he wakes in the morning, he naturally spontaneously recites manis. And the thought, I am a disciple of Buddha Śākyamūni. I am a follower of Buddha Śākyamūni.

I am a bhikkhu monk arise naturally within his mind. Then if when we rose in the morning, the thought, I am going to study Lam Rim, I am a follower of the teacher, were to arise within in within our minds, that would be extraordinary. Does that sort arise? And, obviously, the happiness which we will gain is mental happiness, not physical happiness. That is a matter for the body.

And this mental happiness, in turn, will down the line foster physical happiness because mind and body are intertwined. So Geshe la has explained first topic, the motivation, and the second topic, the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Think about this. Now our third topic, which is interdependence. As you well know by now, the root of, suffering is the afflictions, and the root of the afflictions is the ignorance grasping at a self.

Now there are different levels of coarseness and subtlety of this ignorance. Broadly speaking, there are three. There is the ignorance which grasps the permanent the person as permanent, one, and independent, which is the coarsest level of ignorance. Then there is the ignorance which grasps the person as autonomous, as a substantially existent autonomous entity. This is a more subtle form of ignorance.

And there is ignorance which grasps the person as being established from its own side. So an example for the layers of ignorance would be that of certain seeds, which have multiple, sheaths around the grain. In the same self same way, you have several layers of ignorance. So regarding the first, this apprehension, which apprehends a person as permanent one and independent, or if you prefer the apprehension of the person as permanent, this is an ignorance which you identified very clearly last time. Then to counter it, we need to generate its exact opposite, its antidote.

In your opinion, what is the exact opposite of such a state of mind? So now while we are generating the motivation and engaging in the recitations, let us reflect on what type of mind exactly would be the precise opposite of this apprehension, apprehending the person as permanent, one, and independent, which is focused on its object of observation. Mhmm. Please open the playbook, page one. We recite one b, two, three, four.

Also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three. So here, if we are if we are unable to engage in practice, the best way to motivate ourselves is to meditate on death and impermanence, our own death and impermanence. Now it is self evident that we have past and future lives. And at the end of this life, we will transmigrate into a future life. But the question is when?

And for this reason, meditation on the uncertainty of the time of death is the foremost means to motivate us to practice. The example given in the is the following. Imagine someone who tells us early on, I will be visiting in June. And we know he will visit in June. But when precisely in six months will he be coming?

Our situation is simple. We know for sure that we will die. But when precisely are going to die? This way of thinking is very helpful for the

Then another example which is very helpful is imagine you are planning on going someplace for a very long period of time, let’s say one month. Then you will make preparations. You will make preparations for this, for a one month stay. But if you’re staying somewhere else on the road for a short period of time, you won’t. Now if you were to fly, for instance, from Australia to India, you pass via Singapore, and you spend only one hour in Singapore but a month in India.

Why would you put a lot of effort in preparing your stay in Singapore? You were there for only one hour. Then it’s the same thing in the relationship between this life and future lives. This life is short. It’s very powerful example which is given in the Lam Rim, this one, because we can see that we are in a constant state of flux, of becoming.

Then if you wish to prepare yourself for a good future rebirth, two broad conditions are required. The first is to accumulate virtue within one’s mind’s mind, but the second is to take care of your health. Because with a peaceful virtuous mind, if you have also taken care of your health, you will die as if you were falling asleep peacefully, and a good future rebirth is basically guaranteed. Has taught this many times. Yeah.

I taught, you know, many times. Then to transform one’s mental continuum completely into a virtuous stream of mind, that is very difficult. But, in the society we live in, if we can aim for maybe 60% of our thoughts as virtuous thoughts, then that is really exceptional. And then as far as virtue is concerned, we all know what virtue is. Virtue is the opposite of the 10 non virtuous deeds.

So this is something which Geshe la has explained many, many times. Alright? Okay. Oh, yeah. So Now Please, in brief, shortly, what is the mind which is the direct opposite of the apprehension, apprehending the person as permanent one and independent?

Precisely. Mhmm. The mind of wisdom realizing emptiness? Mhmm. Okay.

But if you do it this way, you give the subject simply, totally, it’ll be careful. Mhmm. The mind that sees oneself as changing or impermanent, as many, and as dependent. The mind of interdependence at the courses level, that is of causality and condition. It’s not that the is it’s it’s not that the self is many or and it’s not the opposite of permanent one and independent.

It’s the mind which realizes the emptiness of the self being permanent one and independent. So we have something to think about very carefully today, which is what precisely, is the opposite of that, ignorance apprehending the person as permanent one and independence. I’m thinking the wisdom that apprehends the person as impermanent. I don’t know whether it’s multiple and dependent. The apprehension apprehending yourself as and the other two would be implicit when you realize that.

Okay. And? Alright. Finished. Have we finished?

No? Okay. Yeah. So the wisdom, realizing the person as being impermanent, dependent, and I would say nondual as opposed to many. Nondual as opposed to many?

So, yeah, so so as opposed to one. Everybody else was saying people other people were saying one, and they were saying many in regard to one, but I would say nondual. So as opposed to one. Oh, Oh, sorry. No.

Are you ready? I’m a. It’s impermanent. It’s dependent. And it’s, I would say, not one.

Chris? Oh, you are very relaxed, actually. I’m trying to find it. I have to say the wisdom apprehending the self as being empty of being permanent one and independent. Your answers are very good because they all abut on the view.

It is the view which separates dharma from the view of the Tīrthikas. Then you must reflect on the words, the permanent, one, and independent. Most of you did. So when one refers to the person being permanent and one, in brief, this refers to the apprehension of the permanence of the person. So when one refers to the person being permanent one and independent, one gets a bit dizzy with the terms.

But in brief, this notion of permanence and oneness of the person refers to the apprehension of the permanence of the person. There’s no There is no difference between the apprehension of the permanence of the person and the apprehension of the permanence of the self as you pointed out. Then in brief, the direct opposite of the apprehension of the person as permanent is the apprehension of the person as impermanent. So this is obviously something you have put careful thought into and you understand. Then what with respect to the person being So can you comment on the status of the person, being apprehended as impermanent with respect to the person being apprehended as With respect to the apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent.

Because once one has realized the impermanence of the person, one has, it seems, realized the emptiness of the permanence of the person. So there’s a lot of food for thought here in the fact that it would seem that when one asserts that the person is impermanent, this apprehension of the impermanence of the person does not seem to counter the person which is other. So in other words, how precisely does this apprehension of the impermanence of the person counter this person which seemed to be separate from the aggregates, which is referred to as the person which is permanent one and independent, of which we talked about previously? How precise how precisely does this apprehension of the impermanence of the person counter this person which is separate from the aggregates of which we said that it was permanent one and independent?

So do think about this. In the systems of tenets from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards, the distinction between the person being empty of being permanent one and independent and the person being empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity are differences of subtlety. Mhmm. Now in Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka, and this is a school of tenets which Geshe la is presenting here, none of the scholars refers to the difference between the apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent and the apprehension of the person as a substantially existent autonomous entity as one of subtlety. So here, this explanation of the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent and the apprehension of the person as a substantial existence autonomous entity are beginning apprehensions.

If you understand them well, later on, things will become easier. So these are difficult topics. You will not be able to formulate easily or, soon a distinction between, in Madhyamaka, the, emptiness of a person being permanent, one and independent, and the emptiness of persons being substantially existent autonomous entities. Then to point this out, Geshe la would like to say that in the monasteries, this topic, Madhyamaka, was studied for four full years from morning till evening, every day, every week of the year with debates and analysis. And at the end of the four years of study, the monks had an idea of the distinction between the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent, the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity, and the emptiness of persons being established from their own side.

So Geshe la knows that some of you seem to feel that in a couple of weeks, after working all day and coming from time to time to the center for teachings, you’re gonna get it like this. This doesn’t happen. It will take time. You lack mental strength. You lack mental fortitude.

As a result, everything must be quick. In the monasteries, Geshe-la was saying, there are monks who rise at six to start studying in the morning, six in the morning, and they debate until one or even two in the morning. Such monks do exist. Not all, but some do. So we should proceed slowly, slowly.

Our goal is to find the or to target the afflictions which are the source of our So what Geshe la would therefore like to ask you to think about in the coming week is if the apprehension of the impermanence of the person is the direct opposite to the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent, and this person perceived as permanent one and independent is somehow apart from the aggregates, how can the apprehension of the impermanence of the person counter it? There’s a lot of food for thought here. Then Geshe la will give you a clue. The, emptiness of the persons being permanent, one, and independent is what is known as a nonimplicative negation. Most of you know what nonimplicative negations are.

Now we will be talking later of negations. It’s a central topic in the study of emptiness. Mhmm. In Tibetan. Mhmm.

One or two questions. Nonimplicative negation. Implicative. Nonimplicative negation. Okay.

Just now, what should I say about the permanent and in and the independent And, also, the the other level is the existing upon its own side. You know the subtle mind? What’s your question? I want to ask whether it’s related to different schools of tenets and also related to the level of affliction that you counteract with it. What is related?

The the independent You’re talking of the apprehension of the permanent person as permanent one and independent. Right? And also the autonomous itself and the other one is the last one exist from its own side. Uh-huh. Those three.

Three three Around there. Uh-huh. So Yes. I was asking is whether they are related to different school of tenant and also related to the affliction. You know, like, the the cost affliction, you use the So regarding your first question, there is, only an assertion of these three in that form in Prasanika Madhyamaka.

Prasanika Madhyamaka asserts the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent, the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity and the emptiness of the person being established from its own side. However, the lower schools of tenets do not assert the existence of an emptiness of persons being established from their own side. And regarding your second question, do these counter various levels of subtlety of the afflictions? Yes. They do.

Okay. Next next question. I’m not sure if I misheard, earlier just after that presentation was given on the three degrees of subtlety of ignorance. Did Geshe la say there are seven layers of ignorance or several? Several.

Several. Not seven. Okay. Next question. Okay.

On the grounds and paths within the presentation from the point of view, at what point does one abandon the apprehension of the self being one permanent and independent? Because as I understood it, the first instance of the path of seeing abandons the acquired view of the self, and I understand that to be the self being one permanent and independent. Yes. You can posit the abandonment of the persons being apprehended as permanent one and independent at the level of the path of seeing. Mhmm.

I was just gonna say the object of meditation at that point is emptiness and not impermanence. Okay. So there is a quote in Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand from Ārya Deva’s 400, the Chatuhshataka in his section on emptiness. You can probably find it. I’ll translate it for you.

It is said in the chatur sattaka, initially, counter the absence of merit. In the middle, counter the self. Finally, counter all views. Counter all views. He who understands this is wise.

So this is how Geshe la would explain the view. So Geshe la will explain the view in terms of this passage in liberation in the palm of your hand, and therefore, your translations. It will be in the chapter, the three modes of training in the chapter on insight which is of the nature of wisdom. Maybe maybe six pages after the beginning of that chapter. Then look at it.

And after all, this is only one stanza, so do try to memorize it. Mhmm. Okay. Thank you. Prebook page nine.

Eight b, Mandaloffering.

Key terms in this teaching

grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top