Lam Rim – 1990-09-29 – KR

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 1990-09-29 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches impermanence, both subtle momentary disintegration and coarse impermanence in the form of death, and the uncertainty of when death will come. It explains that dwelling on ‘I won’t die today’ drives attachment and negative actions, and that mindfulness of death motivates practising ethics, generosity and patience. It ends with a short question session on karma, patience and vegetarianism.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-09-29

Duration: 1h 45m

UUID: d21b8b8b-6725-4af0-b080-bc199b691498

Words: 5,320

In order to, in order that I might be able to lead all sentient beings to a state of happiness divorced of all suffering, I must rid myself of all my various faults and bring the consummation to all excellent qualities. And in order to achieve that, I must, I’m going to employ the method of the practice of the essence of the great vehicle path to awakening. And therefore for the next five minutes we should seek to cultivate the motivation of the awakening heart to listen to the present teaching on the graduated path to awakening. In our last teaching we discussed the human life of leasures and fortunes. And today we’re going to take up the subject the impermanence in death.

So there are two ways to contemplate impermanence. There is the on the level of coarse impermanence and subtle impermanence. First, with respect to subtle impermanence, if we take the example of time, that at having when the time arrives at say 12:00, it doesn’t remain there even for a fraction of a second. That it almost immediately moves on. Likewise, with respect to ourselves, immediately upon taking birth, in the very next moment, the process of disintegration has begun.

So from the moment of our birth to the time of our death, we not for even a moment abide without change. That this process of moving toward our eventual disintegration is occurring moment by moment, whether whatever we might be doing, it’s sleeping, talking, whether we’re staying or going. That we’re constantly, this process of momentary disintegration is constantly taking place and we’re constantly moving toward the moment of our death. We can understand, this is the, this momentary disintegration is momentary, is subtle impermanence. These moments of disintegration add up to this process occurring, directing ourselves toward death, that the moments begin to add up to hours, one hour, two hours, three hours.

They compound into the passing of days. The days compound into two days, three days compound into months, and slowly the actual moment of the time of our death arrives. This moment of death is coarse impermanence. That is to say that the disintegration of our life force such that we are not able to carry on any longer is coarse impermanence. So this not only course impermanence not only applies to our life but it applies to the various things around us.

For example, we build a new house and but immediately that house is beginning to disintegrate. It’s beginning to fall apart. And the same is true for say a flower that it grows but immediately it is moving moment by moment toward its eventual death. And whatever articles that we might have, for example a dish, eventually it’s going to break, it’s going to disintegrate. Our clothes are always, are wearing out.

This process is constantly occurring with all things. So this is the quality of all functional things, that they are constantly undergoing a process of momentary disintegration until a time arrives when they come to an end. And this applies to all functional things. So this disintegrating process applies likewise to the life of ourselves as humans, that one day it’s going to finish. It’s going to our lifespan will be exhausted, and that we are not able to hold on for even one moment without this constant disintegrating process occurring.

One day we are going to die and this death is the abandonment of our present set of aggregates and the taking on the appropriating of new aggregates, which constitutes the course and permanence of death. So we as individuals are undergoing this process that each of us one day will die. That is to say, of us as individuals will arrive a day when this process of this life will be finished, exhausted, and we will have to abandon our present aggregates. What do we what are we always thinking about? Fact is that what is it that we want?

We want to be happy. We don’t want to suffer. We’re constantly occupied with this thinking. Thinking that we want happiness that we don’t want to suffer and beginning to think of this in terms of our impending death that you know when is this life going to finish? When are going to lose this opportunity to find happiness and eliminate our suffering?

Well you know we know that our life is going to finish, but we simply we cannot say when. We don’t know whether we’re going to live one more year, five more years, whether we’re going to live, whether we’re going to die this month. Maybe we don’t know whether we could die today. We really can’t say. So we know that our life is going to finish, but we simply don’t know when.

We don’t know if we’re going to live a short time or a long time. That when this moment of the impermanence death arrives we can understand that we’re going to experience a great deal of trouble. And we don’t know when this is going to occur. And we should begin to examine, you know, when am I going to die? And begin to develop a qualm with respect to that.

You know, could I die today or could I die tomorrow? And some sort of doubt, some questioning should arise in your mind because we know we’re going to die but we don’t know when. And the time of our death we’re going to experience a great deal of difficulty and suffering. On the one hand, if we can be mindful of this qualm that we create with respect to death, that is to say, being mindful of an impermanence in respect to our life, then this can be, this will be extremely beneficial. But on the other hand, if we are not able to be mindful of our impending death, then this is a great fault.

There’s great danger involved in this way of thinking. So probably most, the majority of us are aware of the fact that of our impending death that we all know that eventually we’re going to all have to die. So we all know that, don’t we? But additionally, probably most of us also think, Well, I’m not going to die today, and I’m I’m not going to die tomorrow. So, you know, most of us have the thought arising within our minds, I’m not going to die today nor am I going to die tomorrow.

And then tomorrow we think, Oh, I’m not going to die today nor am I going to die tomorrow. And then the day after tomorrow we will think, Oh, I’m not going to die today nor am I going to die tomorrow. That there is no end to these thinking, these todays and these tomorrows when we’re not going to die. And in this way months and years passed in thinking that, Today I’m not going to die today. Today I’m not going to die tomorrow.

And in actual we think we’re never going to die. And what is the implication of this way of thinking, in thinking that I’m not going today, I’m not going to die die tomorrow, and the continual process of this reoccurring thought is that we were constantly caught up in striving to acquire materialism or material possessions like food, clothing, etc. We’re constantly making preparations as if we’re going to remain forever. So, thinking in this way and putting effort into gaining the various materialistic things, materials in preparation for us remaining for such a long time that we develop desire for these various possessions, attachment, and under the influence of this attachment and desire we create unskillful actions. And then again, having brought together all of these various material possessions, then in seeking to gather together more material possessions, we generate anger whenever our aims are obstructed.

Whenever anything hinders our gaining material possessions, we gain anger. And having gained those material possessions, we develop a great deal of pride out of having them and jealousy. All the very subjective emotions arise in this way. And this is the way we pass our life. Leading our life in this way, there is something Leading our life in this way, we simply have no time for directing our attention toward liberation, qualities such as seeking liberation from cyclic existence or development of awakening heart.

Our life simply passes caught up in this materialism and finally our life finishes and the time of the death in terms of the impermanence of death arrives. And this life having come to an end and having led a type of life which is predominantly having created negative actions with very few skillful actions at the time of our death we have great difficulty. What type of difficulty will experience? And that having, if we were to have created a great deal of skillful actions at the time of our death we can be assured that we will experience a future existence of happiness. On the other hand having created much negativity during the course of our lives, then we can think that we will only be able to experience future sufferings.

So this fault of suffering in future existences bereft of the happiness that we wish, comes about through not being well mindful of death, not remembering death well. So it is the, this lack of mindfulness of death, the mind which thinks that today I’m not going to die nor tomorrow am I going to die. That is, it is our grasping at immortality which is the source of all faults. Je Tsongkhapa in his Graduated Paths to Awakening says that we must seek to put an end to this way of thinking, this negative attitude of mind which conceives that I am not going to die today nor am I going to die tomorrow. That such a way of thinking is the root of all faults.

It is the foundation of suffering and should be brought to an end. In order to do that, it is necessary to understand impermanence. How are we going to cease this grasping at immortality? That we know that we’re definitely going to die, but we don’t know when we’re going to die. And we have to think that, you know, I haven’t died today, but I could die tomorrow.

It’s not sure that I’m going to see tomorrow. You know, if we were to die today then there’s no question about when we’re going to die. But we have to see to what we have to understand, I didn’t die today, but I could die tomorrow, to begin to think in this way. To think in terms of that I could die today is a great benefit. It’s completely profitable.

There’s no disadvantages in thinking this way. And what is the profit to be gained in thinking in this way that I could die today? That one cease making preparations to remain a long time in this life, but will, on the other hand, begin to make preparations for future existences. For example, if one were to think, Well, tomorrow I’m going to go to India, one would begin to make preparations for that trip. One would not be one would not make preparations to remain a long time in the present situation.

In thinking in this way about making preparation for future lives, will not place so much emphasis on striving for the things of this life. But on the other hand, we will begin to think about what is necessary to benefit myself in future lives. What was going to actually benefit me in my future existence is that all my relatives will be of no benefit. My wealth and material possessions will be of no benefit. Not even the body of this life is going to benefit me in the future.

And we can understand that what is going to benefit in future lives is the Dharma and we become mindful of this fact. For example, in, you know, what would we need if we were going to travel to India? We would need money, rupees, Indian rupees. And if we were to have this as a preparation to have gathered together the money then we can have our travel will be easy. We can find the place to live quite easily.

We will have all the food that we need. We will have no problems having made this preparation. Likewise, what do we need as a future preparation, as a preparation for the future of the Dharma that having made this preparation that we will have no problems at the time of our when death arrives and in the future we will have made preparations for the future. So what is the consequence of being mindful of the fact of having to make these preparations in terms of Dharma so that we will have no problems in the future? That one will understand that I haven’t died today and that necessary for me to continue making preparations in my practice.

And what do we mean by the practice of Dharma? For example, the abandonment of actions such as killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, speaking harsh words, etc. These all constitute the practice of Dharma, that is to say ethics. If we abandon these unskillful types of actions, then in a future life we will again achieve a human life, but even a life which a type of embodiment which is better than the embodiment we presently have. Again, with respect to preparations that we should practice generosity.

In dependence upon the practice of generosity that in the future we will have material necessities such as food, clothing, etc. And again, with respect to the preparations for the practice, the cultivation of patience, that is, the tolerance in respect to whatever harm is brought to us, forbearance. And in dependence upon the cultivation of patience, then in the future we will have harmonious a companions and friends around us. So these practices of ethics, generosity, and patience — it’s not that we cannot practice them, is it? We can practice these.

We can practice the abandonment of these various unskillful actions. Know, we can abandon, for example, killing, stealing. We can cease sexual misconduct. Can cease lying, speaking harsh words, divisive words, cease idle gossip. We can cease covetousness of other things.

We can cease harmful intentions, wrong views such as with respect to, for example, the law of cause and effect, future lives, the three jewels. If we do this, then it’s definite that we’re going to achieve a human life in the future. And we can all practice in this way. There’s no reason why we cannot make these abandonments. And with respect to ethi generosity, it’s not that we cannot practice generosity.

We can. All the various types of generosity, materials, the generosity of Dharma, the generosity of love, the generosity of fearlessness, freedom from fear. That, for example, we can There are the objects of the high objects as which we can offer generosity to such as the three jewels. You know we’re making offerings of flowers, incense, food, drink, etc. And then there are the lower objects which are sentient beings or those who are poor, troubled by giving them food, clothing, material possessions.

It is not so much the substance which determines generosity, but simply the intention of generosity. Again, respect to practice of patience, that is the forbearance in not returning harm for harm which is caused to ourselves. That we can do this. We can practice this. And all of these various practices, independence upon, for example, ethics, will achieve a human life.

Independence upon generosity, we will have complete necessities and material possessions. In dependence upon patience, we will have a complete type of human life that we get for a full full of meaning and happiness. And for example, we’re listening to the Dharma and dependent upon listening to the Dharma we can develop a wisdom and simply listening to the Dharma in this way we implant latencies so that in the future when we listen to the Dharma again wisdom will arise. So, we should think, know, today I haven’t died. That’s really wonderful.

Know, it’s a great, great profit to be made today that I can practice Dharma, that I can benefit in some small way my future life. And then when tomorrow arrives, Ah! Today I haven’t, I haven’t died. You know, there’s a great deal of profit to be made today. I can make some, I can practice in order to benefit my future lives.

Each day in this way, practicing a little each day, and there’s a tremendous amount of profit to be gained in this way and that I can practice. This is the way that we can carry on our practice of Dharma. So in order to think in this way, that is to say that remembering, being aware that one has not died today, have to be mindful of death. We have to remember death. This is the remembrance of impermanence.

And it is as if this mindfulness of death is a great kindness to ourselves. That in dependence upon this mindfulness of death, we will practice the Dharma and we will cease to create negativities that we will all of the benefit which comes out of the practice of death and all of that the benefit to be derived from ceasing negativities arrives out of the mindfulness of death. And this way, having led our life in this way, at the moment of our death we can die happily remembering that we have practiced the Dharma and we have ceased to create negativities during the course of our lives. And this is the benefit of the mindfulness of death. So that there are the two benefits to be derived from mindfulness of death that we will understand that what will be a benefit to ourselves in future lives.

And this is the Dharma. And we will practice the Dharma. And what type of experience do I want to undergo and what will determine the experience of my future lives is determined in dependence upon the creation of positive actions and the ceasing of negative actions. So we will practice the Dharma as a way to benefit ourselves in future lives. And in consequence, we’ll practice negative, we’ll abandon negative actions and practice positive actions.

Understanding that the experience of future lives is dependent upon the negative and positive karma that we are creating, we will then acknowledge our negativities that we have created as a way of eliminating them. That is to say, we will confess our negative actions to eliminate them, and we will cultivate positive actions. If we were to question well, you know, if in order to, out of this mindfulness of death, should I just give up my work? Give it all up. We don’t have to do that.

So we, you know, as a consequence of our mindfulness of death, we are intent on practicing Dharma. So we want to give up for all our work. And doing that, then we’re not going to have enough money to buy all our necessities of life. And we’re just going to things are going to be tough for us. You don’t have to worry about that.

So, we practice the Dharma all day long. During the course of a day might be two parts to our day. Those when we practice the Dharma and those when we don’t. Times when we don’t. So, we can fix these two areas, parts of our day in which when we’ve set aside this part where we’re going to specifically contemplate the Dharma, and here we contemplate, for example, impermanence, etc.

And then there are those in which parts of the day in which we’re not contemplating the Dharma, we have to get on with our livelihood. So, this is quite acceptable to have not been able to practice. So we cannot practice the Dharma all day long. We can have times when we do and there’s times when we don’t. So we have to have those times for it to earn our livelihood.

But at those times when we do practice the Dharma, then we should contemplate well, for example, develop the mindfulness of death, and we should, at those times, carry on a pure practice of Dharma. So, you know, we have been discussing the benefits of the mindfulness of death and we should seek to renew this mindfulness each day. And, you know, we can establish part of our day, say half the day in seeking to, you know, earn our livelihood, etc. And half the day is devoted to our practice of Dharma. And during this practice of Dharma we should seek to this portion of the day we should seek to practice well, remembering death, for example, making various prayers.

And in this way that our life, our practice will go well and we will make good preparations for our future life. So, in remembering death, you know, we if we were to think, Well, I’m going to die. And I’m going to lose all my relatives, my friends, all my house, my possessions. And out of this arises This is not the way to remember death. So, fear, the anxiety, which is to be cultivated with respect to death is that in terms of the negativities, negative and positive karma, what that one has created, that I’ve created a great deal of negativity in this life.

And I must purify that negativity. And additionally, I have to practice the Dharma in order to create positive actions. If I don’t do that, then I’m going to have a great deal of difficulty in the future. And thinking about the troubles that will arise and having anxiety about those troubles is the anxiety which is to be cultivated with in respect to mindfulness of death. So, the benefit to be derived in thinking out in this way is that one will abandon negative actions and cultivate positive ones.

This is the way that we remember death. But it’s necessary that we meditate on the impermanence of death. And how are we going to do that? So, we begin by cultivating the understanding of the definiteness of death. Understanding that all sentient beings whatsoever are under the control of karma and afflictive emotions.

And due to the force of these, they have no control over their ability to remain. It’s not by choice that they all have to die no matter who they might be. Even the Buddha with his unimaginable qualities could not remain. But additionally, those who are extremely brave, those who are extremely wealthy, they too cannot remain by their choice. They too must die.

Thinking that, in general, everyone must die. Particular must die. So, making this determination that my own death is inevitable. But when am I going to die? It’s definite that I am going to die, but when?

We simply can’t say that I could die today, die after a few days, next month, after one year, five years. But we don’t know that the time of our death is indefinite. When death were to come to us today, there is simply no way that we can stop it. If death were to arrive and we were to seek to turn it away with, for example, offering death our valuables, our wealth, that will not turn it away. On the other hand, maybe our companions and ourselves could talk death out of coming today, but we can’t.

That won’t work either. So when death arrives, our companions, our relatives, our parents will be of no benefit. And even this body which we hold so precious that we give it food and clothing that we don’t want even the slightest of flick, even the flick of a finger harm that we hold so dear even it will be of no benefit at that time of the arrival of death. Hold All of these things which have benefited in the course of this life that our possessions, companions and our body will not be able to benefit us at the time when death arrives. And at the time of, at the moment of our actual death that none of these things will be of benefit and we will have to move directly into into a future existence.

What can be a benefit to us at such a time? Our body is not going to continue on to a future existence. It is our mind which continues on to a future life. So, we were talking about these practices of, for example, ethics, generosity, and patience. Just our practice of Dharma in general, how is that going to benefit ourselves in a future existence?

These factors implant predispositions upon the mind and the mind continues onward to a future life. Therefore, due to the nature of this relationship between these practices and our mind, these can be a benefit in our future life. But this, in turn, is true for various negative actions that we create killing, stealing, etc. They, too, implant latencies predispositions on the mind. And again, they will and the mind continues with these latencies implanted upon itself to a future existence.

And the degree, the quality of our future existence is dependent upon the degree of skillfulness and unskillfulness actions which have been implanted upon the mind. How does, how are these latencies, negative and positive latencies, held within the mind, implanted? To. Stamp. Stamp.

Stamp. So the implementation of these negative and positive skillful actions upon the mind is analogous to the stamping seal. The stamping of a piece of paper in which the you know, that this like if you go to the post office they cancel a letter, a stamp, and it’s printed on the paper, and this stamp remains on the paper. It’s printed on the paper, stamp printing itself on the paper. Likewise, the negative and positive skillful actions are printed upon the mind.

So and having printed the stamp upon the paper, wherever the paper goes, that stamp will, this imprinted stamp will go right along with it. It’s not somehow left behind. So, our mind will not cease at our death. It continues onward and therefore all the various negative and positive karmic impressions will also continue on after our death. Are going to leave, on the other hand, we’re going to leave this body behind.

This body which has arisen from the combination of sperm and ovum of our parents. It is simply form and it will be left behind at the time of our death. And all of those things which relate to this form of body, you know, the food, clothing, possessions, they all of them will be left behind. So, you know, we’ve discussed the benefits of remembering impermanence and death and the method of meditating on the development of this mindfulness of death in which we understand that death is inevitable, that it is definite, but we don’t know when it’s going to happen, that the time of our death is uncertain. And the various things about us, possessions, companions, and our own body will be of no benefit at the time of death.

This way, thinking in this way, can begin to make preparations for future lives, but additionally we will begin to loosen our attachment for the things of this life. So if you have some questions we will take five minutes. So, the results of the practice of ethics is rebirth in high status in the future life as either a celestial being or a human being, and the non rebirth in a bad migration. The results of the practice of generosity is that having achieved a human life in the future, independence upon that, material things such as food, clothing, shelter will be obtained. The results of patience is that in a future life that we will have handsome, beautiful bodies, that we will have harm, we will have harmonious, stable, healthy relationships with others.

These are really wonderful results, aren’t they? So, the various deities such as Chenrezig, Tārā and Mañjuśrī, do they have beautiful bodies or not? So, if you practice through your practice, you will achieve these types of bodies. So, upon practicing patience we will be good looking and that people will like to look at us. So, as a result of our practice of patience in this life, enjoy being around us.

And then as a result of that, it is in the nature that this is going to continue and increase such that people will enjoy being around us even more in the future life because we’ll be that much more beautiful to be around. And if, on the other hand, those who people who are not patient, not tolerant, who are very angersome, they have a very displeasing appearance. You know, they always have a scowl on their face and people don’t like to look at them. And this would this nature of a situation is that this will carry on as a result and they will even be that much more unpleasant in appearance in future lives. Example, in the case of snakes that this is a result of a great deal of anger in previous lives and now in this life in having taken the form of a snake, it’s a very displeasing thing that people don’t like snakes.

They immediately become afraid when they see a snake. This is a result of being very angry in a past life. Could you please? I haven’t died today. I may die tomorrow.

And then how does that connect Tomorrow? So, from your side, you make such prayers, and from my side, I’ll make such prayers. Which which restaurant to go to? Okay. So, if you could be vegetarian, that would be very good.

You know, would be better. If it would not affect your health, it wouldn’t cause you any sickness, then it’s better to be a vegetarian. But on the other hand, if you know this our body is the basis of our practice of Dharma, it’s very precious, and therefore if this would in any way impair your health not to eat meat then there’s no fault in eating a little meat. Additionally, the Buddha said that if we were to The Buddha said that if we were to recite particular mantra and to make prayer that may this sentient being be reborn in a happy migration, then this can be a benefit to that being. In it’s in our book.

Is it? It’s in this blue blue FPMT manual. And so, remember to give it to you if you want it. Let’s see. And what was the what was the final point?

You know? The chugi nam’s limbo. Sometimes. So it’s it’s a it’s of no benefit to explain Dharma to people if they get angry. That’s the people that it is to be explained to.

There has to be it has to be appropriate. There has to be some need and some type of faith on the other person who has some type of faith in the Dharma before explanation will be of benefit. So this is the importance of having friends within the spiritual community. Because because they have faith in the Dharma, the members of the spiritual community, the Sangha. In Tibetan the word Sangha or spirit which translated spiritual community is Gendun and Ge literally means skillful action, but here it’s it refers to liberation.

And, Dun means to be intent upon. Those who are intent upon liberation is one’s spiritual community.

Key terms in this teaching

cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top