Lam Rim – 1990-02-17 – KR

1 h 38 min · 4,914 words · 17 February 1990

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 1990-02-17 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that motivation determines the quality of any practice, and sets out three capacities of practitioners (small, middling and great), each with its own motivation. It then traces the origin of the Buddha’s teachings and the Lam Rim through Atisha’s Lamp on the Path to Enlightenment and Tsongkhapa’s commentaries, and says the graduated path summarises all the Buddhadharma.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-02-17

Duration: 1h 38m

UUID: 43bae18d-c4f6-4681-a76a-2f54fbf06566

Words: 4,910

So we’re going to take five minutes to adjust our motivation. Rinpoche will talk us through the generation of the proper motivation as we progress. So, how are we going to reflect and what way to develop our just proper motivation? First, begin by understanding that you want to be happy and you don’t want to suffer. Just like that, all sentient beings are exactly the same in wanting happiness and not wanting to suffer.

And then cultivate the thought that all of these sentient beings have benefited me greatly in the past and they are benefiting me greatly presently. May they be completely divorced from all their suffering and may they have complete happiness. And then cultivate the thought that I myself, I must establish all these sentient beings in a state of complete happiness where there is no suffering whatsoever. Then we should try to generate the aspiration of the awakening heart by thinking, do I have the ability to place all sentient beings in happiness, to eliminate their suffering? Seeing that we do not have the ability, asking, Well then who does?

Seeing that it is only a Buddha. And therefore seeing that it is only a Buddha who has this capacity, that in order to eliminate the suffering of all sentient beings and establish them in complete happiness, I myself must attain Buddhahood. We try to generate this thought. In order to actually bring that about, I am training my mind within the great vehicle and cultivating this attitude. So it is said that it is extremely important that if our practice is to be a spiritual practice initially if it is to be other than a worldly practice, but it is to be a Dharma practice, initially we must adjust our motivation in the beginning as a preliminary.

Once having adjusted our motivation, then we carry on the practice, and having carried on the practice, then in the end it must be followed by prayers and dedication. This is a complete method of practice. So our motivation is extremely important. It determines the quality of the action which follows upon that motivation whether it’s going to be a benefit or not. If we have adjusted our motivation such that we have a very positive motivation, then every activity which follows upon that will be of a positive nature and therefore beneficial.

If on the other hand we have a negative motivation, then no matter what types activities we may engage in, those which are propelled by this motivation will be negative and therefore of no benefit. On the other hand, if we simply engage in actions with a neutral or indifferent motivation, then the results of that activity are going to be neither positive nor negative. So the motivation is extremely important. If we set forth an analogy, the quality of a plant depends upon the roots from which it grows. If the roots are of a medicinal variety, then the leaves, the bark, the stems will all be of a medicinal nature, growing from those roots.

On the other hand, if the roots are of a poisonous variety, then everything which grows from that will be of the same nature, will also be poisonous. Likewise, with respect to the various activities that we engage in, the root is our motivation. Everything grows out of that root, that motivation, so it’s imperative that it be of a positive nature, so that the activity is of a positive nature. And with respect to the Lam Rim, the graduated path, it is said that within the practice of the graduated path, are three different capacities of practitioners. Those of small capacity, middling capacity, and great capacity.

And these varying degrees of capacity to practice are posited in accordance with the motivation of the practitioner, whether they have a lesser motivation, a middling motivation, or a great motivation. Therefore, practices the that they engage in, independence upon their varying degrees of motivation, is likewise in accordance. Accords the same way. Those who have great motivation carry on a great practice. Those who have middling motivation carry on a middling practice, and those of lesser motivation carry on a small practice.

So this term that we use in accordance with these three types of practitioners, sometimes it’s translated simply as scopes, but this isn’t a very good translation. What we mean is in Sanskrit, purisha, and Tibetan kebu. It has the idea of capacity or power, ability, and here especially in relationship to the graduated path. So what do we mean that someone has capacity? With respect to his ability to carry on a practice, that in fact whatever the practitioner has the ability, has the power to accomplish whatever qualities or whatever activities he is or she is setting out to gain or establish or achieve.

So it has this quality of capacity, power, ability. So, in this word, gains of varying capacity applies to all beings, but here we’re mainly talking about human beings. With respect to carrying on spiritual practice, we differentiate the types of beings into three categories. There’s a small capacity, middling capacity, and capacity. We’re talking about their style of thinking, the way their mind is operating.

Those who think in a very narrow fashion will engage in very small types of action activities, very limited types of activities. Those who have a middling perspective, way of thinking We’re engaged in those types of, middling types of activities. Those who have a very broad perspective correspondently engage in great activities. We’re talking about in terms of spiritual practice. All these ways of thinking, these styles, are dependent upon the motivation, the varying degrees of motivation that these individuals have.

As was previously explained with respect to beings in general, we can say that let’s use the term positive and negative types of beings. This arises, the type of being arises in dependence upon the power of the positive and negative motivations behind the person. And amongst those types of positive beings, we could say, I think I use proficient or excellent. We can differentiate them into three, those types of excellent beings which have a small capacity, middling capacity, and great capacity. So if we just present these various types of beings in general, not necessarily from the point of view of the graduated path, that depending upon the degree of positivity of the mind of these beings and the negativity of these beings, Those positive types of beings, I’ll think of a better word maybe, have, due to the force of their small, there are three types even within these positive types of beings, people say.

But those of the lesser degree will, by the force of this positive quality, will take rebirth as humans and gods within the desired realm. Those of the middling quality will take rebirth as deities within the form realm and those of the greatest will take rebirth as a deity within the formless realm. On the other hand, those of negative types of beings, those of the slightest types of negativity take rebirth as animal, those in middling as hungry ghosts, and those of greatest as hell beings. Over and above this, is the, in terms of the spiritual practice, of the three capacities. Those of the smallest capacity realize that they are aware of impermanence and their impending death.

They understand that if they involve themselves in unskillful actions, then this will lead to rebirth in hell. They develop a dread of the possibility of being reborn in hell and therefore they take a direction, they go for refuge as a method to alleviate this fear. They go for refuge to the three jewels and they begin to adopt various types of positive practices and to reject various types of negative activities as a means for such a type of way of thinking we term a being of small capacity. By the power of this motivation, the practitioner engages in various practices, and these practices would be taking refuge in the three jewels, carrying on a practice of adopting skillful activities, rejecting unskillful activities, adopting, abandoning negativities, cultivating positive actions. On the basis of this practice, he or she would not be born in a bad migration in the future, but in fact would be born in a happy migration as either a human or a god, a deity or a god.

So this is the motivation of the being of small capacity. But we pass on to the motivation of the being of middling capacity. And he has trained in the common path of the being of small capacity. So he has no dread of taking rebirth in the bad migrations. He’s assured, he feels assured that he’s going to take rebirth as either a god or a human, but still this isn’t enough for him because he sees that even as a human or a god, this still involves a great deal of physical and mental suffering.

That no matter where he might take rebirth and cyclic existence, that he sees it as an unbearably painful experience. And therefore, he develops the motivation to be liberated from cyclic existence altogether. And he looks for a method, a practice whereby to be liberated from cyclic existence. And he adopts the three higher trainings. The higher training in ethics, higher training in meditative and stabilization, and the higher training in the wisdom, understanding, selflessness.

This means he develops the determination to be free or to be free, that is the renunciation, and this is his method of practice. We passed on to the motivation of the being of great capacity And having trained in the common path of the small and middling capacities, he has an aspiration to be free from cyclic existence. But he sees that this in itself is not sufficient. That how can he leave all his mothers and fathers in this situation of suffering? That to simply seek solitary peace for oneself alone is actually very shameful, and that he cannot accept this.

Therefore, he sees that it is necessary to free all sentient beings from their suffering and to place all sentient beings in complete happiness. Therefore, his motivation is the awakening heart to establish all, to achieve Buddhahood for the sake of all sentient beings. This is the reason that we’re continually cultivating this motivation of the awakening heart. This is the motivation of being of great capacity. So with such a type of motivation, the motivation of the waking heart, matter what activity we might engage into, whether it’s listening, meditating, it all falls within the aspiration of the great vehicle.

It all acts as a method, as a cause for achieving Buddhahood. So whatever Dharma that we may practice, if it is to be a great vehicle practice, it is dependent upon our motivation, and therefore it’s necessary to adjust our motivation. So we must adjust our motivation in accordance with the varying levels of capacity moving through these three levels. Being of small capacity seeking to attain a human rebirth in the future. The being of middling capacity seeking to the bliss of liberation from cyclic existence, but highest most, the being of greatest capacity seeking future Buddhahood.

So it would be difficult to achieve a result without having one of these three types of motivation. That if we are seeking to achieve rebirth in the future as a human being, then we have to adjust our motivation that we at least have capacity the of motivation. If we are seeking the result of liberation from cyclic existence, then we must adjust our motivation such that being of middling capacity. And if we are seeking to bring about the welfare of both ourselves and others, then we have to adjust our motivation to that of the great being of greatest capacity. So having discussed the motivation, then we can discuss the actual practice and that is the Dharma.

And we question, well, does the Dharma come from? Specifically, where does the buddha Dharma come from? And the root, the source of the Buddha Dharma is the Buddha himself, having taught a considerable time ago his teachings. Just as in the case of, if we ask where does the ocean come from, it has its original source in the snow, maybe on the mountains. If we trace back, it comes from the snow.

Likewise, if we trace back the Buddha Dharma, we can trace it back to the teachings of the Buddha himself. Initially, the Buddha gave the various teachings which we term the Dharma. Subsequent to his original teachings, then the various scholars, yogis, they examined his teachings. They, using various types of reasoning to see if there was any fault, they settled the various meanings of his teachings. And then subsequent to that, then they put these, the great practitioners, the superiors, put these teachings into practice and gain realization.

So what we have by way of Dharma is we can be assured that these teachings are unerring, that there’s no mistakes, that we cannot go off on some kind of tangent, that there’s no danger involved in following these teachings. Now, as to whether we actually gain the realizations, the results of these teachings quickly or not, depends upon our practice. But the final goal of the practice is there, definitely. We need to have no doubt about that. So we can have a great deal of confidence that there are no faults, there are no errors within the teachings of the Buddha.

How can we begin to recognize this fact of the unerring nature of the Buddha’s teachings? If speak from the point of view of an intelligent, the most intelligent type of practitioner, such a type of practitioner would first make use of the teachings in generating love, compassion. Having generated love and compassion, go on to cultivate the correct view and understanding of emptiness. Having done that, go on to develop the awakening heart. These two, correct view and the awakening heart, are like legs which take us to the goal.

They are called wisdom and method, these two feet. Having done this, generate these two, then go on to the actual practices of the bodhisattvas such as six perfections, generosity, ethics, patience, effort, meditative stabilization, and wisdom. In addition, teaching others which included within the four means of cultivating the disciples of students, the minds of students. In this way, eliminating all our various faults, developing all the excellent qualities and thereby achieving the goal. The word Buddha is a Sanskrit word.

In Tibetan, it has been translated sangge, two syllables. If we look at the etymology of this word sangge, sang, sang, Sang, means to clear away, to clear, to eliminate, to make non existent, and what has been cleared away is all faults. Gue, G Y E, means to expand, to evolve, and what the evolution which is taking place is the development of the ability to know all phenomena, all knowables whatsoever. The culmative of all excellent qualities. All excellent qualities have been completely evolved.

This is what we mean by a Buddha. So a Buddha has completely rid him or herself of all errors, of all mistaken ways of knowing, of all unknowing altogether. That he or she understands in an undistorted fashion reality. The Buddha taught what he understood and he taught it out of a sense of love. It is said that the Buddha loves us hundreds of more times than a parent loves their child.

This is the type of quality of love that a Buddha has for us. Out of this sense of love, he taught what he understood unerringly without any mistakes. If we take as an analogy an educated parent, and because of their love for their child, then whatever knowledge they may have, they quite willingly try to train their child in that same understanding, that same knowledge. They will make use of whatever method they can, try to make sure there’s no mistakes in passing on their various understandings, their various knowledge to their child. Due to the force of their love, their caring for their child, likewise, the Buddha’s love is said to be hundreds of times greater than that of a parent for their child, and they too are seeking to pass on their knowledge to us in an unerring, unmistaken fashion.

All of the accomplishments that the Buddha attained were for us. He generated the awakening heart for us. He collected the various accumulations for us. His ultimate achievement of Buddhahood was for us, and having achieved this for us, we can have no doubt that there’s any distortion in his quality of his motivation and he teaches unerringly. But not only that, that the Buddha sought to impart his knowledge as a parent would to his child, but his knowledge, his teachings have passed through extensive examination, analysis, investigation by the great pandits, the great masters of India, for example, Maitreya, Mañjuśrī, Asaṇga, Vasubandhu, Nāgārjuna.

They all took these teachings and they examined them using various reasoning, various methods of investigation to see if there was any fault, if they could harm them in any way. Then having done this, then numberless great meditators of the past, great accomplished siddhas actually made use of them in meditation and gained their realizations. Initially we have the teachings that are set forth by the Buddha, having passed through this investigation analysis by the great scholars such as Mañjuśrī, Maitreya, Asaṇga, Vasubandhu, Nargajuna, analyzing and investigating, having been cultivated in meditation by the great powerful attainers, the great siddhas of the past, and gained various realizations. This all came together, realizations and the actual scriptures, the text in the form of Atisha who came to Tibet, one of the greatest masters. Having been invited to Tibet, he was asked to compose the text setting out the practices of the Buddha.

In answer to this request, he composed what has become known as the graduated specifically the text called Lamp on the Path to Enlightenment, Puripatipatiptha. These practices were there. This graduated system of passing through the path to enlightenment had always been there from the very beginning. It’s not that Atisha made up something new, but he did create a classification of these practices into the three capacities of being, small capacity, middling capacity, and great capacity as this way of classifying, this way of designating and clarifying the practices and how they’re systematized. Atisha, the composer, forerunner of the genre of text which later became the graduated path, remained in Tibet for seventeen years.

He was one of the greatest Buddhist masters both with respect to sūtra and tantra. He was continually in contact with Tārā, and he was emphasizing this quality that he was one of the greatest masters called Pandita. Also the genre of teachings known as mind training or thought transformation stems from Atisha. Atisha, in order to attain the teachings on development of the awakening heart set out on an ocean voyage which lasted thirteen months from India and went to what is now called Indonesia where he received the teachings from his master, Serlingpa, on the method of cultivating the awakening heart by means of exchange of self with others and the seven cause and effect precepts. He remained there, received the teachings, meditated on them, gained the realizations, and then returned to India.

So it was his great master Atisha who developed the prototype of what later became known as graduated path, having composed the lamp on the path to enlightenment while he was residing in Tibet. All of the various traditions, which all have their various types of lam rims or graduated paths, all were developed based upon this prototype composed by Atisha, whether it’s the Kargyu, Sakya, and Nyingma, the three graduated paths composed by Tsongkhapa, the abbreviated middling and extensive graduated paths, all are based upon this prototype of the lamp composed by Atisha. The root of all texts within this genre called Lamrim or Graduated Path is within this text composed by Atisha called The Lamp on the Path to Enlightenment. In particular, the teachings that we’re following, those of The Graduated Path set forth by Tsongkhapa. He composed three texts as commentaries to the lamp.

There’s an extremely detailed and extensive graduated path, and then there was a middling one, and then there was an abbreviated one. He also composed one which is called Songs of Experience, he set forth his realizations in verse with respect to the graduated path. We’re going to make use of the abbreviated graduated path, but because we can’t go through the large ones, we’ll supplement this abbreviated one with passages from the more extensive graduated path. If we begin with the actual lamp written by Atisha, the name of the text in Sanskrit is Bodhipathapradīpa. Bodhi means awaken enlightenment.

Patha means path, and pradipa means lamp. The lamp on the path to awakening or enlightenment. So this is set forth initially in this text to show the source. Where does this text come from? All of the Dharma which existed in Tibet has as its source the Dharma of India, that it was not made up, the Dharma of Tibet was not made up in Tibet and therefore this is showing that it has its source in India by showing the Sanskrit name from where this text is being drawn from.

In the translator, that is to say originally the text, the lamp was composed in Sanskrit and later on it was translated into Tibetan. The translator who went from Sanskrit into Tibetan now pays homage to Mañjuśrī, the bodhisattva Mañjuśrī. And then there follows the homage to the three jewels and this is the practice to differentiate from non Buddhist. Initially, the determination of the Buddhist and non Buddhist is going for refuge to the three jewels of the Buddha’s Dharma and Sangha or spiritual community. So why does the translator pay homage to the three jewels here?

As a means to generate positive potential or meritorious power. It is by the force of one’s positive potential that all activities can be brought to completion. Whatever spiritual activity we may be initiating, it’s important that in the beginning that we go for refuge, make requests, pay homage to, make various prayers to our particular deity which is central to our practice. The reason that we have to do this is in doing this we create a great deal of positive potential. Whether or not we are able to accomplish our activity, whether we’re able to bring it to completion, is dependent upon the amount of positive potential that we possess.

Therefore, in order to create the positive potential to ensure that we’re able to accomplish and complete the activity that we’re involved in, we go through this process of making requests, going for refuge, paying homage to our particular personal deity as a means to accomplish and to remove any obstacles. The Buddha said that for someone who has positive potential, then he can accomplish whatever he intends. Whether or not we’re able to accomplish the activity that we engage in, whether we’re able to bring it to completion, is dependent upon the personal power that we possess, the positive potential. If we possess it, then we can accomplish it easily with little effort. On the other hand, if we don’t have positive potential, then no matter how much difficulty or hardship we may put forth, we will not accomplish our end.

Now comes in the text, the promise to compose that, so in order to create positive potential, there was homage made, and then there is a promise to compose the text. Previously, Atisha met with the Tibetan king, Jangchub who requested that he compose a text setting up a path, and as a response to this, he promised to set out and compose what later became known as the lamp. Talking about this king, Jangchub, who invited Atisha to come to Tibet and spread the teachings of Buddha. We can talk a lot about this. There’s a great deal of history involved in this, but we just tell a little story in connection with this.

Previous to the coming of Atisha, the teachings had degenerated. It was as if they were almost nonexistent. They wanted to invite a master to re establish the teachings in Tibet, and they collected gold in order to, as an offering, to invite the teacher to come to Tibet. There was a relative of the king, Jangchub, whose name was Yeshe O, who was going to invite go to India, to invite Atisha, but there was also an evil king who was against religion, the Buddhist religion, and he thought if Tisha came to Tibet, then Buddhadharma would spread throughout Tibet, and he wanted to stop this. So, he imprisoned the king’s relative, Yeshe O, but king requested this evil king, King Jangchub requested the evil king to free Yeshe O, and he refused.

He said, I will only free him if you give me as ransom gold equal to the weight of his body, and then I will free him. The king set about collecting enough gold to ransom his relative, and it came to the point where he went to the evil king and says, to free him, says, I have collected enough gold equal to the weight except for his head, but I will continue. Yeshe O heard about this and he said, Don’t give that evil king even a gram of gold. I want to give over my body to the Dharma. Therefore, take all of the gold that you’ve collected up to now and use it to invite Atisha to come to Tibet.

So the Lam Rim was born out of a great deal of difficulty or this graduated path, this genre of teaching. We shouldn’t think that the graduated path is so extremely important, it’s extremely precious, and we shouldn’t think that it’s just something for new students, those who don’t know much about Buddhism, that this is kind of an introduction for them. This would be a great mistake to think in this way. All of the Buddhadharma, whether it’s Tantra, whether it’s Sūtra, great vehicle, lesser vehicle, is abbreviated within the graduated path. We cannot make any progress in the path unless we follow the graduated path.

The graduated path is like the body, It’s like our body if we’re going to go somewhere, and all of these other facets of the Dharma such as the awakening heart, wisdom understanding emptiness, secret mantra, mind training, These are all parts of that body like arms and legs, but the body itself, that which is going to take us to liberation in Buddhism, is the graduated path. So this is to emphasize the great importance of these teachings on the graduate path and we’ll stop there for today, but we’ll take five minutes to answer questions. Many great masters. There many great masters. Previously there were times when we would have these gatherings to exchange views on spiritual practices on the Dharma, and many great masters and scholars would come from Varanasi, and that the three seats of learning of Sera, Ganden, and Drepung all have many great masters.

There are other great masters even in other spiritual traditions. Other spiritual traditions. Okay. There are many great Panditas, great masters, but amongst these there are different levels. Are the masters of the masters and the masters of them.

There are different varieties even amongst these great masters. What is your problem? Concept of it. So you want to know if they really exist? So We can see from our own reasoning and experience that according to the various negativities, negative actions, activities, and positive activities that we experience negative and positive results as a consequence.

There’s some concordance, agreement between the degree of positive action and positive results, or the negative action and negative results. Even as human beings we can see this, the cause and effect relationship. What happens if there are types of actions which go beyond the negativity and positivity of these actions are such that the results cannot be experienced in this human realm. That have to, that their experience, the results can only be experienced in another type of embodiment, another in type of realm, and therefore according to the various positivity and negativity, we may have to experience the results in a different type of embodiment. With respect to negativity, if it’s beyond the capacity of the human realm for us to be able to experience that result, then it’s definite that the place of result in the case of small negativities will be as in the animal realm.

Middling negativity will be a hungry ghost, and those with greatest negativity, the resultant realm where we are able to realize that result will be as a hell realm. So, even within the human realm there’s a correspondence between our actions, the degree of negativity and positivity and the result, but if we just simply extrapolate and carry that further, we can begin to extend this into the possibilities of other types of realm. So using analogy the actions which would result in the heat and the fires of hell.

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
Nyingma
The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
pandita khäpa (Tib)
Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top