49 min · 2,866 words · 10 February 1990
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that rebirth after death is not chosen but shaped by karma, and that skillful or unskillful actions in this life determine the fortunate or bad migrations one takes. It describes three degrees of negative and positive karma and the sufferings or happiness of each realm. It then introduces the Dharma as that which holds back from falling, and the graduated path (Lam Rim) for beings of lesser, middling and greatest capacity. A short question on whether a cow can create positive karma closes the recording.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 50 min
UUID: 8814be88-add5-49df-873f-1ba892615a51
Date: 1990-02-10
Words: 2,862
So we are again and again taking rebirth. Again and again taking a new embodiment. In the case of humans, for example, upon the aggregation of the sperm and ovum, then the life, consciousness aggregates and takes a new embodiment in this way. In general, not in general, there are four types rebirths that we can take, four methods of taking rebirth. There is rebirth by womb, womb rebirth.
For example, humans, in which the offspring matures in the womb and then it’s born. There is rebirth by what is called warmth and moisture, for example some types of insects. There is rebirth by egg, for example birds. Then there is spontaneous rebirth. This would be, for example, hell beings and gods take spontaneous rebirth.
So the fact that we’re going to die and then we’re going to take rebirth. Do we have any freedom in our rebirth, and what type of rebirth that we’re going to take? Do we have any choice? We can’t we don’t. We can’t it’s not we we cannot decide.
I want to take rebirth here, I don’t want to take rebirth there. What influences, what determines rebirth is our karma, action. The type of whether we have skillful or unskillful karma determine what type of rebirth we will take. You know, sometimes people don’t, this is sometimes referred to as black and white karma, but people don’t like to hear about black and white because they it refers to, when we talk about black and white people, these different races, they don’t don’t don’t like to speak in these terms. So rather than talking about black and white karma, we talk about skillful or unskillful construct karma or constructive or destructive karma.
So the degree of freedom that we as was mentioned, we don’t have any freedom in what type of rebirth we take once we die. But during the course of this life, then there is freedom of what type of rebirth we will take. In the case of someone who practices the Dharma under the influence of the positive karma created in this practice, then this individual will take rebirth in a fortunate migration. On the other hand, someone who creates a great deal of negativity, under the influence of this negative karma, this individual will take rebirth in a bad migration. The person who has practiced Dharma has exercised the freedom of avoiding bad migrations and will take rebirth in a positive, fortunate migration.
It is during this life that we’re able to determine what type of rebirth it would take. Once we die, then we have no power. So these in determining what type of rebirth that we will eventually take with respect to the negative actions that we create, there are three degrees of negativity with respect to these negative actions. There’s those of lesser negativity, middling, and greatest negativity. Those of the least negative types of negative action will bring about rebirth as an animal.
Those who are middling will throw us into rebirth as a hungry ghost or a clutching ghost. Those who have the greatest negativity will throw us into rebirth as a hell be. So each of these these negative these negative rebirths that are taken under the influence of negative karma differ in the degrees of suffering that there is a mild type of suffering within the animal realm. It’s worse within in the hungry ghost and it’s most worse. Let’s see.
It’s worst. It’s most worse. It’s the most extreme suffering in the hell realm. Then on the other hand, the types of skillful karma that we create is going to help us to take a fortune type of migration. Again, there are three degrees of skillfulness in these types of actions.
Lesser, middling, and greatest. The lesser skillful karma will bring about rebirth as a human being. The middling will bring about rebirth as a god of the desire realm. The gods of the form realm experience a great deal of happiness and very beautiful. The most skillful, what shall I say?
Skillful karma will lead to rebirth as a god of the formless realm where they experience a tremendous amount of bliss. With respect to the the lesser skillfulness of karma which brings about rebirth as humans, that having created this type of karma and taking rebirth as a human, still we cannot say definitely. Have no We there’s no we have no choice in where we definitely will take rebirth. That we could take rebirth as in Australia, in India, Tibet, China, even America. We could even, you know, we may, as an Australian person, we may create some lesser type of skillful karma which would cause us to take rebirth as human, but it’s it’s not certain that we’re going to take that rebirth in Australia again.
We could die as an Australian and take rebirth as an Indian or as a Russian. There’s no definite. Even amongst taking rebirth as humans, from human to human rebirth, it’s all mixed up. There’s a variety of possibilities. So this is the case of taking human human rebirth.
But in the case of, for example, example, the the gods, they can a god upon their death, they could take rebirth as a human. They could take rebirth as an animal, for example, a cow. A cow could, upon its death, take rebirth as a god. That that that one could take rebirth down, up, it is not definite. There’s always this continually circling through these different possible embodiments.
Example, were to involve ourselves in all types of negative ways of acting, behavior, then the next year perhaps we die. We may have have horns on our heads next year. We don’t know. What type of rebirth that we’re going to take is we don’t have any freedom upon our death. It is completely under the influence of karma, our actions.
But we do have a freedom in the way we create our karma, the types of karma we create. But not exercising that freedom, perhaps we take rebirth as a goat, as a sheep, or whatever we may be, or even just kinds of insects. But these types of beings, they only create negativity. They have no opportunity to practice the Dharma. So we have to think about, you reflect upon our actual conduct during the course of our life, in the course of each day.
Now what types of karma are we creating? Even, you know, we’ve taken many, many re births and we created endless karma in those past rebirths. But if we just, amongst these types of karma, are a tremendous different variety of karmas. But even if we look at this life, what we do in this life, during the course of one day, One day is composed of twenty four hours. Perhaps four of those hours we involve ourselves in some kind of a positive practice, some kind of positive conduct.
But the rest of it, what do we do for the rest of those twenty hours of that of that single day? We’re probably mostly involved in negativities, the negative such negative, emotions such as anger, attachment, jealousy, all of these creating types of negative karmas. This and we think about in the course of one day all the negativity that create. And we do this every day, each day, day in, day out, again and again and again. And thinking about all of the negativity that we’ve created.
And negativity, this negative karma leads to suffering and we create negative karma through body, speech, and mind. And that comparing the little constructive actions that we do in comparison to the great amount of destructive actions that we create, we can, there’s a great deal of danger that we will, take an embodiment in a type of migration involving great suffering. You know, we should reflect upon the fact of where we’re going, where we’re going to end up. If we look at our life and see how little constructive actions that we’ve created in the course of our life and the great amount of destructive actions that we’ve created and think about them well, and think about the possible suffering which can evolve from these destructive actions, then we should experience some kind of real sense of anxiety or dread. Such a type that we wouldn’t be able to, rest, that we wouldn’t, we couldn’t even eat our food, that it wouldn’t have any taste for us.
We wouldn’t even be able to sleep thinking about the possibilities of future existences in this way. Itself is of really no benefit to us. But we we should think, you know, how can I eliminate this dread, this anxiety that I feel? What what methods? What what will protect me from these future possible sufferings?
You know, what direction can I take? What can I do? In reflecting in this way that understanding that that now now is the time to really consider the possibilities of the future. When death comes, then there’s no possibility I’ve lost my chance, my opportunity. Coming to some sort of conclusion, some definite determination, there’s no need to to really fear if if I do something, if I act.
If I Mhmm. If I if if I engage in some method, then there’s no real need to fear. You’re looking for some sort of method to work our problems out. And coming to the conclusion that aside from spiritual practice, the Dharma, there’s no there’s no other method than this. That we there’s no need to experience suffering rebirths.
That we can cease suffering types of rebirths. That we can do this. And having ceased suffering types of rebirths, that we can abide in happy rebirths. And how do we cease these suffering types of rebirths is by making use of the method of the Dharma, that nothing else aside from spiritual practice has this ability, this capacity. So it is the Dharma which has the if we ask the question, how does the Dharma have the ability to cease suffering types of rebirth?
It’s important that we understand how operates, how it actually brings about a cessation of those types of rebirths which are experienced as suffering. The word Dharma, Dharma is a Sanskrit word. We often recite the verses, Namo Buddhaya, Namo Dharmaya, Namo Sanghaya. Among st these is the Dharma. Translated in Tibetan, we say chö.
It’s Tibetan. It literally means to hold or prevent. To hold back. Yes. This word Dharma, in Tibetan, it has a two distinctive meanings, two two ways that the word is generally used.
One is more of a technical use. We we it’s often translated as phenomena since it applies to all things. Phenomena. What we mean, we say, using this etymology of hold, we say that things are able to maintain or hold identity. Anything which is able to maintain its entity, call phenomena.
It’s a Dharma. Flowers, books, people, they’re all able to maintain, to hold together their identity or their entity or nature, we we call them dharmas. So there was a technical other usage is in the sense of practice, spiritual practice. As Rinpoche was pointing out, it has the idea, taking as an example, holding a bell in one hand, if the other hand takes hold of the bell and prevents it from falling, it holds the bell. If it did not hold it, then the bell would fall.
So this is also of the word Dharma, that which prevents from falling, that which holds back. Religions, spiritual practices in the world, many different varieties. And the the one that we’re seeking to put into practice is the is the Buddha Dharma, and especially amongst the varieties of Buddha Dharma, the the practice of the great vehicle. Now Exactly what do we mean? What type of Dharma are we seeking to practice?
What qualities should it have? It is first the foundation. The Dharma as foundation which we are seeking to practice was that which was taught by the Buddha previously. Taking those teachings of the Buddha, the past great Indian masters investigated them, examined them using various methods, using coming to an ultimate examination of of their validity. Then the great siddhas, the great accomplished masters, put the meaning of which they derive from examination, from investigation into practice, for example, meditation, and gain complete realization within their minds themselves as a means of achieving liberation.
They settled the meaning of what the Buddha taught, put it into practice, and gained the result. This is the type of Dharma that we should practice, one which has been taught unerringly and which has been examined, which has been which the meaning has been researched and meditated upon and from which a definite complete result arises. Therefore, it is sure that by practicing such a type of Dharma the result that we’re seeking will come about. You know, if someone if someone says, well, you know, explains this particular spiritual path, there’s no way that we can be sure that it’s going to bring about the results that he or she said. There’s no way that we can gain conviction.
It may gain some result, it may not. But it becomes important that our Dharma practice follow an unerring, unmistaken path, a method which will definitely give rise to the results that we’re seeking, one which has been tested in the past. If we follow this unerring, unmistakable unmistakable path, then we can have conviction in it that we are going to gain what we are looking for. We’re talking about what we mean by Dharma and what we mean by practice in Dharma. We said in connection with the meaning of the word Dharma, is to hold or to lift, to bring out, to prevent from falling.
With respect to the graduated path, the Lam Rim, which constitutes the collective teachings of the Buddha representing the method for achieving the ends of these, but the ends of three types of capacities of beings. As we mentioned, the Lam Rim, the graduated path is set out according to different capacities. Each of these beings is being held back is being lifted up to a specific state. What is each of them being held back from? In the case of the person at a lesser capacity, sometimes this is called lesser scope, a lesser capacity.
This being is seeking to be held back from from falling into bad migrations. Being it’s held from held back from falling into bad migrations and is assisted toward freedom of being rebirthed in a fortunate migration. Those of middling capacity are being held back from the sufferings of cyclic existence in general and is gaining the freedom from cyclic existence. On the other hand, the being of the greatest capacity is gaining the full culmination of the human potential in being free from not only cyclic existence and the sufferings of bad migrations, but fulfills the welfare of both oneself and others in being established in Buddhahood. So the the teachings on the graduated path, Lam Rim, are actual practices brought together.
They’re extremely precious teachings of paramount importance in our practice. They are the methods whereby we can develop an excellent mind, a kind heart. Initially, we’re developing this kind heart. It has the methods for initially generating a kind heart. Then it has the means for having developed a kind heart, for actually increasing our kind heart, our excellent mind, and finally, the methods for bringing it to culmination, to fulfillment.
So we’ll stop there for today, but we’ll we’ll take five minutes for if you have any question. If if beings in the three lower realms can only create negative karma, how then can a cow be reborn as a cow? If it can only create negative karma, how can a cow then make the positive karma creating? How is that possible?? I don’t understand that at all. So the cow would take rebirth as a god through the force of previously created karma that that there was a the the cow had taken infinite number of rebirths previously to that and had has latencies of all types, sometime in the past having created constructive action.
When there’s negative action, when there’s negative karma being taken rebirth as a cow is exhausted, then through if the conditions are such and this latency of taking rebirth as a god, the latency of that karma will be activated and it will take rebirth as a god. So previous karma. Different time. Doesn’t mean that the cow will then be the So within amongst cows there would be, what do you say, good minded cows and bad minded cows. For example, having practiced Dharma in the past due to familiarization with the Dharma in the past and a cow will have a good mind and others don’t have this familiarization will have a bad mind.
But this also applies to people, to horses, to dogs. They all have different familiarizations, habituations from the past.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.