Lam Rim – 17 LR 1990 10 13

1 h 34 min · 4,770 words · 13 October 1990

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 17 LR 1990 10 13
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues the Lam Rim teaching on meditating on impermanence through death. The teacher presents the three roots (death is inevitable, its time is uncertain, only Dharma helps at death), each supported by three reasons, and explains why contemplating impermanence opens the door to Dharma by turning the mind away from concern for this life toward future lives.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 1990-10-13

Duration: 1h 34m

UUID: 6c6e339b-6e19-4411-9a3a-193510f6df90

Words: 4,766

Now we’re going to Rinpoche is going to explain them the the manner of meditating on impermanence. So the Buddha taught that amongst all the among amongst all the footprints of all the creatures, the greatest is that of the elephant. Amongst all of the various ways that we can bring about a crop in a field, the most useful is the plowing of the field. And amongst all of the recognitions that which is the supreme is the recognition of impermanence. So among the amongst all of the the types of footprints because the elephant’s footprint the elephant’s heaviest, its footprint is the greatest impression.

And the reason that plowing is the most beneficial means to bring about a crop is because by digging down deep in the earth, the deeper we go, the more nutritious the soil. And the various types of recognitions, by recognitions we mean discriminations. For example, saying this is this, this is this, this is white, this is red, this is a pillar, this is a pot. Amongst all of those types of recognitions, this is impermanent. This is supreme.

So why is the recognition of impermanence said to be the supreme of amongst all the various recognitions. If we remember impermanence, then this will be of an extremely great benefit because we will, in remembering impermanence, we will remember to create the causes of happiness in future lives through our practice of Dharma. So you should write this down. You shouldn’t allow it to be forgotten. What is the doorway into meditation?

That is how do we begin our meditation? It is the examination of the quality of the state of our mind and developing a healthy motivation. And what is the doorway into the paths? And this is this is the the beginning of the path is the we begin the path in relying upon the spiritual friend. And what what is the doorway into the graduated path to awakening?

This is the the initially, the listening to the teachings on Leisure and Fortunes. And where does the what is the doorway into the practice of Dharma? Where does it begin? It begins with with the practice of karma and the results. That is to say beginning to adopt skillful actions and rejecting unskillful actions.

And what is the doorway into the Dharma? It begins with impermanence. So we should try these are are extremely these advices are are extremely beneficial. They’re they’re really a wonderful quality, and you should try to hold them in your mind. So if when someone gives a teaching, the teaching should be in accordance with these precepts that we can understand if the individual knows what they’re teaching from the way in which they present it in terms of these precepts.

If they present it in terms of how are we to begin our meditation, how are we to begin our practice, how are we to begin entering into the path, how are we going to begin to graduated path to awaken? What is the way we can go about practicing the Dharma? And also with respect to our individual practice, if we don’t know these, then we really don’t know how to practice. So we said that the doorway into the Dharma is impermanence, and that’s what we’re going to explain now. So if the doorway into the Dharma is impermanence, how are we to begin?

So when, you know, when we meditate, there’s something that we have to think about, that we have to contemplate. So we should practice the Dharma in terms of the goal which is that mainly our practice of Dharma is in terms of present life, the happiness of present life and future life is mainly concerned with bringing about the happiness of future life. That is the the goal of our practice of Dharma. So motivation should be concerned with the happiness of future lives. In view of the fact that this present life is going to be lost quickly, that it’s not going to last, we cannot remain forever.

That in consideration of momentary impermanence and death. That it’s and upon our death we’re definitely going to have a future existence and what type of future existence are we going to experience in terms of happiness and suffering. And therefore beginning to concern our goal and our practice should be to concern ourselves with the implementation of the methods to bring about happiness in future lives. But, you know, if we were to think, we practice Dharma only for the benefit of future lives then well is there no benefit in the present life? In fact that’s not the case.

There will be benefit in our present life. So should we, in our practice of Dharma, be concerned only with the happiness of future lives and not even consider trying to be happy in this life? Not even consider the happiness of this life. Well then, this is not the case. If we do consider the goal, a practice as happiness in future lives, and we will experience indirectly, by the way, happiness in this life.

So what is the you know, someone who plants a field and, you know, their their goal is not the planting itself. That that they that their goal is ultimately to to reap the harvest. And for that purpose, they plant they they sow the seeds in the field. So they plant, they sow the field in order to have the harvest. Their goal is to harvest.

Intermediately, they don’t have to even concern themselves with the with the growing of the roots, the stem, and the leaves. These come as if by themselves. So the same holds true in seeking as a goal, the happiness of future lives. Intermediately, we will achieve happiness in this life without having to directly consider it. So between the two of the happiness of this life and the happiness of future lives we are to emphasize, place greater emphasis on the happiness of future lives.

And how are we to actually bring this about, this emphasis? It is through the recognition of impermanence that if we don’t consider impermanence, we’re not going to be concerned with the happiness of future lives, and therefore we’re not going to practice Dharma. It is by being concerned with the happiness of future lives that we will if we aren’t concerned with the happiness of future if we don’t recognize impermanence, are not going to be concerned about the happiness of future lives, and we’re not going to practice Dharma. Is by means of concerning ourselves with the happiness of future lives. If we don’t consider the happiness of future lives, we’re not going to practice the Dharma.

We’re not going to practice the Dharma. We’re not going to enter into the doorway of Dharma. So previously, I explained that in in the terms of our discussion of impermanence with respect to death, that without without the recognition of death and its remembrance, then we are going to, we will naturally have a tendency to conceive that we will, are going to remain for many, many years. And in view of this conception, then we will spend all of our energy and time bringing about possessions, food, clothing, and in this way there is no practice of Dharma. So how what is the manner of the meditation on impermanence?

And this is in accordance with the the teaching by in which there there are said to be three roots, nine reasons, and three conclusions. So the the three roots in the contemplation of impermanence are firstly, that death is in inevitable. That is to say that it’s definite that we’re going to die. The second is the time of death is uncertain. That it’s definite that we’re going to die but we don’t know when we’re going to die.

It’s indefinite. And the third is, at the time of death only the dharma can help. That is to say that when the time of death actually does arrive there’s nothing else other than the the dharma which is going to be of any benefit to us. So the first of these roots is that the death is inevitable. That is to say that it’s definite that we’re going to die.

Whatever is born under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions, whosoever that sentient being might be who takes birth in this manner, definitely must die. And what reasons can we give for this, supporting this? So in our meditation we must always be applying what is being contemplated in terms of ourselves. We are not thinking of death in the terms of others. We should apply death, its inevitability, etcetera, to ourselves, to oneself.

Meditation is to be done in terms of seeking to eliminate the faults within our own minds to develop excellent qualities in our own mind. So all of these have to be applied within the context of our own minds. This is the most beneficial. We’re not applying these things to others And this and one applies all these to oneself as an individual, and out of this will come individual experiences. So, we must apply this meditation procedure to oneself as an individual, taking oneself as the subject of meditation that I inevitably will die.

I am definitely going to die. And what are the reasons supporting that? And there are three reasons and we should contemplate these in their order of presentation. The first of these is in understanding that I am inevitably definitely going to die is that generally it’s definite that I’m going to die because when the Lord of death comes for me there’s no condition what whatsoever by means of which I can turn him away. So, you know, we must begin to use this means of contemplation.

This is what we mean by meditation. As I I mentioned previously there are the two types of meditation. There’s analytic meditation and stabilizing meditation. And in the analytic aspect of meditation we are making use of intellectual analysis or reasoned analysis. And having come to a conclusion through applying reasoned analysis, we stabilize upon that conclusion single pointedly, and this is the the most powerful way to carry out meditation.

So we begin by understanding, by contemplating the fact that when the Lord of death arrives, there’s nothing that we can do to turn him away. But this is in order to overcome our habitual thinking that I am not going to die, that I have a healthy body and therefore I’m not going to die. So this is, you know, thinking that we have to, cease this reasoning that because we have a healthy body that we can turn away the Lord of death because it’s simply not the case. I mean even the Buddhas, the Bodhisattvas, the hearers, they all had these wonderful bodies, but still they were susceptible to the impermanence of death. So so we should we cease thinking that when the Lord of Death comes that we should consider the fact that a healthy body is not going to stop the Lord of Death.

But additionally, we might think, well, I can always run away from the Lord of Death. Like if there’s some kind of revolution in India, well I’ll I run away to Australia. And then if the problems arise in Australia, I can run away to China. That is some place I can always run to to be safe, but this is not this is not the case. So there’s simply nowhere that we can run from the Lord of Death.

Other types of enemies, there may be a place that we can find where we can be safe for them but not in the case of the Lord of Death no matter where we may go. If we go up in space when the time of our death arrives we still die. If we go beneath the ocean when the time of our death arrives we will still die. And if we try to hide away in a cave when the time of our death comes, we will still die. So there’s nowhere that we can run from death.

So that there’s no place that we can run from death. But we might think, well I mean there must be some method that will prevent death from coming. There’s some power that I have some ability to prevent death, that I can turn it away. But in fact there’s nothing that we can do to stop death once it arrives. We can’t give the Lord of Death gifts to bribe him.

Money won’t work, wealth won’t work, medicine when the Lord of Death has finally arrived isn’t going to be of benefit, using the mantras etcetera is not going to turn him away. So, you know, we might think that, well, medicine is a benefit, isn’t it, when we’re at such a time. But medicine can only be a benefit, alleviate the situation temporarily. It does not alleviate the situation from its very root. Contemporary medicine is very powerful, but we have never heard of or seen anyone who, though they took the best of medicines, was able not to die.

So there’s there’s no way that we can there’s nothing by means of which we can turn away death. The Buddha in advising a king used an analogy that it is as if there were great mountains approaching from the south, the north, east, and the west, and they are unstoppable. There is nothing, as they approach together, no force which can turn them aside. So this is an analogy: of these great mountains approaching, we come to an understanding that all of these various methods that we may think will work for us at the time of death — medicines, mantras, etcetera — cannot turn away death, just as we cannot turn away the approaching of these huge mountains from the various directions. So this is just — though this may in fact not happen — this is just, what would you say?

A simile. So in explaining this analogy, there would be these four great harms which would be coming toward one in the form of these four large mountains which you cannot turn away. And to explain the meaning in terms of the context, then we would also understand that these harms were coming toward one. And again, though we could use wealth, medicines, mantra, and a healthy body. These could not turn them away.

So the so in this situation of these four great mountains when there would arise these four fears with respect to the approach of these mountains and not being able to turn them away. And in this analogy explaining the meaning in the context is that again we would generate the four fears. And these four fears are the fear of disease, illness, pain, fear of old age, of decrepitude, and death. So, the first of these fears is the fear of the pain of illness. And presently we’re able to enjoy the happiness of health, that is the lack of illness.

But what is it that’s able to destroy this happiness of being well? That is to say say sickness. So there will arise a sickness which will destroy our present happiness of being well, and this sickness will bring about the pain of illness. So it not only we experience the pain of the illness but it destroys the happiness of being well and there’s a fear with respect to this. So we all can understand this that when we’re very young, we have little illness and we’re able to have the happiness of being well, the lack of illness, but as we grow old the occasions for illness become more and more and we’re not able to enjoy the happiness of health as much.

And then finally getting older, then there are times when we will be almost always sick in some way and our happiness of being well is destroyed. So the second of these fears was old age, and this is moment of our birth from our mother, old age begins. Aging begins. So this process of aging begins at the moment of birth and there is a gradual deterioration in our body as we grow older. Finally we get to the place where it becomes more and more difficult for us just to get up or just to be able to sit down, that we can’t hear well, we can’t see well, we aren’t able to eat all the foods that we previously were able to eat, that we had many it’s difficult for us to move around, we have many troubles with our body.

That though we have presently a youthful body, you may have it and that because you’re a small age, still there is this unremitting deterioration to of the body in the in the sense of age, which is approaching this state. So the third of these fears was I think I I said decrepitude, but maybe just degeneration would be better. Initially we may have wealth, we may have a complete well-being but that these conditions are not going to remain static, that they will gradually diminish and finally they reach a point where they’re exhausted, that all our very supportive conditions which go to bring about our well-being will lessen in the case when one could be rich and then one could gradually degenerate to the state of poverty, that qualities will deteriorate. So and all the various conducive conditions, supportive conditions will lessen. So there’s this gradual movement toward degeneration.

And the fourth fear is the fear of the approaching of death. And this was no matter what the lifespan may be, whether it’s sixty, seventy, eighty, one hundred years, that gradually we are always approaching the moment of our death. If we were going to live eighty years, after thirty years we only have fifty years to go, after fifty we have thirty, and slowly, no matter how long our lifespan may have been, it’s definitely going to reach the point when this life is finished, it’s over. So by way of analogy that when we woke up this morning that there may have been twelve hours a day which were present for us. This did not remain static, this twelve hours a day afforded to us.

Throughout the day, minute by minute, hour by hour, it was slowly being exhausted until they reached the point where we only had one minute of day left and then that was over. Likewise with our life. No matter what our lifespan might be, what time is afforded to us, it is moving inexorably toward its that moment of its exhaustion. And that is to say, we’re moving always moving to the point of our death. So these four great harms of which we have four fears of, there there is no method that we can make use of to stop them, that they are irreversible, and there is nothing that we can do to to turn them away.

So the first reason is that there is nothing which is able to turn away death, that I will die. Whatever I make use of cannot prevent it. So this is the first reason among of the of the inevitability of death. That the second reason supporting the inevitability of death is that I do not remain I cannot remain in this life, that I cannot remain even for a day. Each day, as my life passes, my life that each day of each day that passes, my my life is being exhausted.

So analogy would be that we had a hundred dollars in our wallet or our purse or whatever we keep our money in, and there would be no addition to this amount of money that we had. And we have to support ourselves. For example, we have to eat food every day and make use of this. And slowly, since there was no addition coming, there would definitely reach a time when all of our money would be finished. It would be exhausted.

So our lifespan is determined by the skillful karma that we have created. in dependence upon the quality of the skillful karma would determine our lifespan. Whether this is in dependence upon the skillful karma, our lifespan may be only ten years, maybe twenty years, thirty, fifty, sixty, seventy, one hundred years. But it is determined and dependent upon the skillful karma, this lifespan. And there’s no, there’s, it’s solely determined by that.

There’s no addition forthcoming. So in each day that passes, our lifespan is lessening with no addition. So it’s definite that we will reach a point when this will be our lifespan will be finished and then we die. Australia affords a good example in this way. Many people’s supply of drinking water comes from storage tanks. And so these storage tanks they get built up over the through the rains to a certain amount of water.

And if it doesn’t rain the next year then as we drink the water it becomes less and less. And then finally, it’s finished, completely exhausted. So if we in the course of of drinking the water day by day, if there’s no addition forthcoming then there will definitely arrive a time when our water supply will end, it will be finished. The same holds true of our lifespan which is determined by our skillful karma that we’ve created. Is no addition forthcoming and there is a definite end.

And what constitutes death is the disruption between the connection between the body and mind, and this is karmically determined, coupling, this connection between the body and mind. When the karma to sustain this connection is exhausted, then the body is simply slipped off and this constitutes death. So there’s no addition forthcoming to our lifespan, and each day it is passing. That it passes, it’s coming nearer to its final exhaustion, that we are definitely going to die. Because there is no addition forthcoming to our lives, it definitely be exhausted and I will die.

We should consider using these various examples and come to some conclusion about the inevitability of your death. So the third reason is that though it’s definite that we’re going to die, that we find very little time to practice the Dharma. So if we give an example that if someone were to have a lifespan of sixty years and the first fifteen or twenty years it’s very difficult then to think in terms of the Dharma. So in the amount of time which remains to us, that we spend maybe a third of our time sleeping, maybe a third of our time working, and then the rest of the time is pretty much caught up in going here and there talking, eating, etcetera, there’s almost no time for the practice of Dharma. And we pass our life without having had time to practice, and then we die.

So we should contemplate the the root of the inevitability of death in terms of these three reasons. And the first being that there is nothing whatsoever which we can use to turn away death when it arrives. The second being that our life is continually decreasing and no addition is forthcoming. And the third reason is that we have little time. We we pass our life with little time in in the pursuit of practicing the Dharma, and then we die.

So we should contemplate the root, that is the inevitability of death, in terms of these three reasons, supported by these three reasons, we actually arrive at some conclusion that I’m definitely going to die. And having made this firm decision, this is the final end product and this is the conclusion. The first part of meditation is constituted of the root, supported by three reasons coming to a definite conclusion. So death is inevitable is the root supported by three reasons, and then we come to a a definite decision or conclusion concerning that. And then the same holds true for the time of our death is uncertain — that’s the root, supported by three reasons coming to one definite conclusion.

And the same holds true for that contemplation of the time of death, only the Dharma can be a benefit. That this is taken as the root, supported by three reasons coming to a one conclusion. So, therefore, the contemplation of the manner of meditating on on death is in terms of the three roots supported by nine reasons coming to three conclusions. So I think that in this process of the recollection of death that amongst all of these, that which is of the greatest benefit, the most powerful is the second of these two of these three, that is the time of death is uncertain. So I’ve never though I’ve never seen this written in any in any text, but but this is my own thinking.

I think that this this second root, that of the time of death is uncertain, supported by three reasons, and coming to the conclusion is of the most beneficial of these three. So we’ve completed an explanation of impermanence in terms of death, this manner of meditation, the first of the three divisions. That is, in terms of the root, the inevitability of death supported by three reasons coming to a single definite conclusion. And the future will continue with the second and third divisions of this manner of meditation on death. We have to actually put this into contemplation that we have to actually meditate on it.

We have to think that I will die and if we are going to really practice the Dharma and how are we to meditate on this? What is the manner in terms of just as has been explained, the taking as the root, the inevitability of death? And why am I going to die? What are the reasons that I can come to this conclusion of the inevitability of my death in terms of the three supporting reasons? But also making use of quotations from the Buddha, etc, contemplating these.

And this combination of quotations, reasoning, it’s a very powerful method to establish for ourselves what is to be proven. In terms of having proven the thesis that I am definitely going to die, we come to a conclusion. This is a very powerful way to arrive at this definite conclusion using both quotations and reasoning. He said that in talking about this, he thought that there were two main enemies that we had, and these were hope and fear. And this is to say that those who have hopes for this life, this is an enemy for the Dharma practitioner in respect to those who have hopes for this life.

And it is the contemplation of impermanence which is able to bring about an end to this hope for this life. So the great meditators of Tibet would initially meditate on impermanence. Then secondly, they would meditate in accordance with whatever their particular practice was, whether it was in terms of they wish to meditate on emptiness or the awakening heart. They had various practices which they would follow, but they all initially meditated on impermanence. So it is contemplation of impermanence which opens the door to the Dharma.

As we said, the doorway into the Dharma is the recollection of impermanence. And this is by means of the entrance way into the dharma that through the contemplation of impermanence we will begin to deemphasize directing ourselves toward the happiness of this life and begin to direct it toward benefiting our future lives. If we do not do this, if our practice is carried out, is carried on seeking results in this life, then it would be difficult for us to carry on a pure practice. So in Tsongkhapa’s Three Principal Aspects of the Path, it says that this life of leisures and fortunes is not going to remain forever — that is to say, it’s impermanent.

And in thinking in terms of its impermanence, this will cause one to cease emphasizing striving for this life only. So we’ll stop there, we won’t have any questions. So during this intervening one week until the next teaching, see how you meditate on this and see how it goes.

Key terms in this teaching

graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top