1 h 18 min · 2,536 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A talk on how to relax the mind and meditate, beginning with mindfulness of breathing before a virtuous object is chosen. The main part explains coarse and subtle impermanence of the self, body and aggregates, and why meditating on one’s own impermanence counters attachment to this life, citing Tsongkhapa’s Three Principles of the Path. The recording ends with a few questions on the meditation object, sand mandalas and past-life memory.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 19m
UUID: 7c93adb9-7c26-4923-8225-c05c2a127133
Words: 2,532
Let me meditate a bit. So what do we mean when we say we should meditate? How do we meditate? The first step is to have a relaxed or an easy mind. You know, as a relaxed or an easy mind, it is possible to meditate.
Then we come to TBI with numerous experiences which we carry with us from the day. Some have to work, they may be working in trade and so forth and they find it difficult to leave their professional experiences and what happened during the day behind when they come to TBI. Others, even though they don’t have to work for a living, have to take care of their children or family members. When they come to the center, they bring these worries and preoccupations with them. Others finally do come with a mind which is focused on virtue, a mind which is open to the Lamrim.
In every single case, one must loosen, relax the mind to be able to meditate. As is said in a text, do not think about the past, not worry about the future, focus on the present. Then here thinking about what we did today is actually thinking about the past and worrying about what we will do tomorrow is worrying about the future. It is the present which should be the object of our preoccupation. Then meditation is a means to keep the mind single pointedly on its object.
And if the mind is too scattered, too distracted by whatever topic, it is very helpful to focus the mind through mindfulness of breathing and count one’s complete breaths, inhalation and expiration as one, two, three, four, and then when the mind is pacified, one engages in meditation. And then once the mind is pacified, one can focus it on a virtuous object, one can focus it on the Lamrim and there are numerous topics. One can focus on definite emergence, you know what the sort of definite emergence is, One can focus on compassion, can focus on bodhichitta, or can focus on impermanence. Do you understand? Then here, if one is for instance meditating on Guru Yoga, one can invite one spiritual teacher, one’s lama and visualize him in space in front of oneself, visualizing either Avalokiteśvara or Ārya Tārā or Mañjuśrī at his heart.
And then there are numerous practices, are numerous forms of meditation. And at present, let us therefore engage in meditation for as long as we are able to do so, ideally a minute or so. Three key points as far as the posture is concerned is the crossed legs, joined hands with the right palm on the left, and straight back and neck. So you do understand that this is a means to withdraw one’s mind inwards and at this point, to focus it on a virtuous topic such as, for instance, the. Okay.
And let us stop here. Yeah. No, ma. Not yet. Whatever you meditate about, that is good.
What did you meditate about? Problem with the Vaibashika? With the Vaibashika having those four parts for the instant? Another? Okay.
So for instance, if you are meditating on definite emergence, then it is very helpful to reflect in detail on your own suffering and pain. Whereas if for instance, you are meditating on great compassion or bodhichitta, then it is very helpful to reflect on the fact that just as others, just as yourself are afflicted by the affliction under the sway of anger, so are others. So for instance, if you meditate on impermanence and someone says you should meditate on impermanence, it is obviously your own impermanence you should meditate upon. Then the impermanence of the table is broadly speaking irrelevant to us. The table is impermanent, so what?
Then continuing with the example of the table, when we say the table is impermanent, what we mean by this is that the table is momentary. In other words, moment by moment, instant by instant, the table changes actually moment by moment it disintegrates. Now what we actually mean by this is difficult to understand. It is not easy to express clearly what subtle impermanence is. Then there’s an awful lot to say about impermanence.
Then even though there are a large number of lines of reasoning which establish that this table is impermanent, this is of no particular benefit to ourselves. Then we ourselves are impermanent, is self evident, I don’t have to explain it. But when we say that we should meditate on our own impermanence, how do we proceed? So when one tries to meditate on one’s own impermanence, the issue of oneself arises. What exactly is that which is impermanent?
It is the I not in Tibetan, just as you would be Kiran yourself. Then when one meditates carefully on this, one gets a sense that the I actually isn’t there. Then the I as experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensation of happiness and suffering is something we all understand. Then the person can be posited on the basis of any of the aggregates. If we were to posit the person on the basis of the form aggregate, then how would we meditate on the impermanence of the person?
We would begin by observing the coarse impermanence of the form aggregate and independence on this we would realize the subtle impermanence which through incremental change leads to coarse impermanence. It is not easy to get a sense of subtle impermanence. And this is why, for instance, the Vaibhāṣika School is unable to posit subtle impermanence. So coarse impermanence is the end of a process of change, the foundation of which is subtle impermanence. But subtle impermanence is very difficult for us to understand. I am now, you know, 51 years old, you know.
Then I’ll take myself as an example, I am at present 51 years of age, then for those fifty one years to have passed, one year must have passed. This is how we get an understanding of coarse impermanence. So for one year to have passed, one month must have passed. For one month to have passed, a full cycle of twenty four hours must have passed. For a full cycle of twenty four hours to have passed, one hour must have passed.
For twenty four hours to have passed, to have changed, one hour must have passed or changed. For one hour, what must have changed? So for one minute to have passed, what must have passed? What does it depend upon? So one minute, therefore for one minute to pass, that passing of one minute must depend on seconds.
Then can we posit the snapping of fingers as subtle impermanence or not? It’s not possible. How do you in turn identify the subtle most impermanence? Yes. It’s a traditional answer.
Is it the most subtle? So if we take the case of my voice, when I say hello on the telephone to Sarah, that hello, that sound is transmitted, it seems instantaneously to Sarah, yet that process is still constituted of instants. So we can see that subtle impermanence is extremely difficult to understand. Know, for instance, is said in pretty much the time it takes to snap my fingers. And yet, it’s a composite phenomenon.
It’s composed of many parts, isn’t it? So we can see that we are unable to explain coarse impermanence. Then becoming depends on subtle impermanence. Coarse becoming hinges on subtle becoming, which becomes ever ever finer and more delicate. So in our own case, when did we originate?
Our bodies appear at the instant at which the spermatozoa of the father fuses with the ovum of the mother. So this is the boundary of the establishment of our body. And from that point onwards, every instant of generation of our body is an instant of destruction. Then even though it might be difficult to assert that that instant, initial instant of generation of the form aggregate is also an instant of generation of the four remaining aggregates, sensation, discrimination, composition of factors and consciousness, Nonetheless, we can say that from that point onwards, every single instant of establishment of our aggregates is an instant of generation and of destruction at the same time. Then in the case of our bodies, the establishment of our bodies can be traced back to that instant where the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother unite.
But if we move further back, then just how far back in the sequence of bodies can we go? There seems to be no beginning. The same could be said about other aggregates. So we can see then moving onwards from year to year, we reached the end of our continuum. And this is a very difficult topic because we can see that if we apply the four characteristics of the first Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of suffering to ourselves, that these four characteristics as you remember are suffering impermanence, selflessness and emptiness, that impermanence and emptiness are linked.
So what exactly is the purpose of these teachings on impermanence and especially on subtle impermanence? Their purpose is to counter the vanities of this life, counter to attachment to this life. As Jetsün Tsongkhapa says in the three principles of the path, in as much as leisure and endowment are rare and do not last for long, turn away from the vanities of this life. Then in our own cases, probably everyone in this room is convinced that we will live to the age of 100, a full 100 years of age. And with this in mind, we put great effort to accumulate the money, the food and everything we need for this.
Then there is no guarantee whatsoever. Some of us will die at 50, some at 60, some at 70. So this In my case, I think maybe I’ll live fifty years. So this way of looking at things counters apprehending one’s permanence in Tibetan. This idea that we are going to be around for a very, very long time and therefore need to accumulate all the favorable conditions to live in this way.
Studying impermanence counters this, and it is through study that in turn one generates enthusiasm to engage in retreats, to practice and so forth. And this is why there is a famous piece of advice or oral instruction. Tomorrow you will die thinking like that. Today has a taste of a corpse. Therefore, put effort at study.
And obviously, for the sake of others, for the benefit of others, one must take care of one’s offspring and so forth. Then it is evident that apprehending one’s own permanence is a major obstacle to both study and meditation. What is less clear is how the ignorance grasping at a self is a major obstacle to dharma in general. So here it should be evident that apprehending one’s own permanence is a major obstacle to any type of study or meditation. And then through extending this to others, we are able to give rise to compassion.
So it should be clear that others suffer from apprehending their permanence just as we do, and this is a ground for generating compassion for them. In our own case, when we say that we will live a hundred years or a very long time, obviously it is our self grasping at permanence or apprehending at permanence which is talking. Since we ourselves are completely unable to say this, not a single of once, one of us could sign on a dotted line saying, I will live to 100. It is beyond our control. Then take good care of your health, eat well, sleep as much as is possible, keep your minds at peace, and there is good hope you’ll be around for a long time.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. If do you need long life, you know, then you must So so they care for your health.
And keep your mind at peace and obviously this is a marvelous country. The environment is clean. There are no problems at the border. There are no bombs, maybe one or two from time to time. Then it’s evident that if we lose control of our minds, think about everything and nothing, become agitated or unable to sleep, then there will be physical consequences.
This is obvious, we all know this. Then the ideal is to dedicate one’s body, speech and mind to the welfare and happiness of others. But if this is not possible, at the very least, one should not harm others with one’s body and speech, nor should one harm them with one’s mind. And here, obviously, the mind is immaterial. It is very difficult to block or to control, so it tends to go where it wants.
But we should try to restrain this. Now in the context of generating the motivation, let us meditate on the harm, which apprehending our own permanence causes to ourselves and causes to others, let us resolve to dispel it. It’s placed into the playbook, page one. We recite versus one b, two three four, and then the Mandala offering on page five versus one and three. Then I’ll take a present a couple of questions.
Yep. One, two, or three. In the process of meditation when one focuses on that moment between the in breath and the out breath and focuses more and more closely into the moment and in that process loses consciousness of the outside environment and sense of bodily sensations and eventually one’s thoughts and is left with just that single point of consciousness. My question is in coming to that point of consciousness, does one find it or does one create When we meditate, we need an object of observation. It’s not possible to meditate without an object of observation.
Okay. Another question? Okay. Is the sand mandala considered as a good example of subtle impermanence? It’s difficult to give a good example of subtle impermanence.
I’m just wondering if the sand mandala is a reasonably good example of subtle impermanence, that each grain of sand is like a moment and that as soon as it starts to be constructed, we know it’s going to be destroyed. It’s difficult for us to give examples of subtle impermanence. If you take the celestial mansion, which is constituted of colored grains of sand, it is true that one constructs it with these grains of sand. It’s not an example of When one reflects on certain impermanence, one must understand the process of momentary destruction or disintegration of phenomena. Yes, Juan.
One question. Okay. So, it’s said that Buddha Śākyamūni remembered his past lives and Professor Stevenson’s research suggests that people remember their past lives. That would imply then those memories are permanent. So how is that concorded with the message or the idea of impermanence?
Because memories are impermanent, it is precisely because memories change, we are able to get stable memories. Permanent memories will be nonexistent memories. Stop here. Thank you.. Thank you. This weekend, a day of miracle on Sunday.
Probably you got the email this morning, and
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- guru yoga lama nel jor (Tib)
- A practice in which one views the guru as inseparable from a deity or the Buddha, in order to amass the two collections of merit and wisdom and to purify negativities and obscurations. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.