Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-12-02

Buddha House Adelaide

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-12-02
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Kopan 2001 12 02 Tape 66 Side 1.MP3

UUID: bee8867f-7d8e-49a2-a8d3-c0fdda3f3668

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2001-12-02

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 44 min

Words: 4,968

But because they’ve had the experience of emptiness in meditation, they don’t grasp at those appearances the way we do as being real. Everything appears to them like a movie show, whereas we see it as real, completely solid. For bodhisattva, it’s like something like maybe walking in a dream, being completely aware that it’s a dream created by one’s own mind. But for us, we think it’s all completely real. So, this term emptiness is used a great deal.

So, some things that this emptiness does not mean what emptiness does not mean there are many ways emptiness can be used. So emptiness can mean the absence of obstruction. The absence of obstruction is like space is empty, we say space is empty because it’s an absence of obstruction. But that is not yeah, okay? Yeah, but the emptiness of phenomena does not mean that.

It doesn’t mean that when you realize the emptiness of the glass that it’s actually space. It doesn’t mean like that. Even though there is what is called the space like emptiness, but it doesn’t mean space. Also, emptiness can be used. Something is empty meaning simply the absence of form, which is very similar to the absence of obstruction.

Emptiness, the emptiness of phenomena, the ultimate truth, doesn’t mean that. And then we can also say that this room is empty of an elephant. Right? This room is empty of an elephant. There is no elephant in this room.

It is empty of having an elephant. So empty also doesn’t mean that. Being empty doesn’t mean that. The lack of something that could there could be an elephant in this room sometimes. We could bring an elephant in here, but presently there’s not an elephant in here.

Emptiness is not that. Because, when we talk about the emptiness of existing phenomena, we’re talking about the lack of something that has never existed. The absence of something that has never ever existed and never will exist. It’s not like when one realizes emptiness, one creates something that has never existed before and now exists. This situation has never existed and never can exist.

This true existence. Emptiness is the absence of true existence or inherent existence or independent existence. It’s an absence of something that has never ever existed even for a in a small way for a fraction of a moment. And even though it has never existed, it appears to our mind. It has always appeared to our mind, this thing which has never existed.

Just like in the case of the snake and the rope, the snake has never existed even for a moment. Not one scale of the snake has come into existence for a moment. Alright. Never, it was never ever there in reality. Yeah.

Even conventionally, even conventionally not there, only there as a hallucination. Okay, so this is what we’re trying to realize that what we are experiencing about ourselves, me and everything, it’s not there, the way we believe. There is something there, but not the way we think, not the way we experience it. And it’s not completely different, of course. This pillar, believe it or not, it’s hard to believe, but the Buddha said that the pillar here that we are experiencing is not there at all.

It is simply not there. It’s just created by our ignorant mind. But there is a pillar there, exactly where we see it. Exactly where we see a pillar that doesn’t exist, is a pillar that does exist. So, the thing that is existing there is not something like when one realizes emptiness, it’s like some glowing crystal thing like that, that actually it’s a crystal diamond pillar.

It doesn’t mean that the world turns into something like that, like some science fiction movie or some hallucinogenic experience. It’s not like that. There is a pillar made of concrete there, actually. We see a concrete pillar there, but the concrete pillar we see is not there, and the concrete pillar that is there, we don’t see. You paid all this money for a whole month to learn this.

But this is what the Buddha taught. That’s why we leave it till the end because if we say at the beginning, everyone would leave. So, this is difficult to understand and it seems like it’s not even worth understanding. It seems ridiculously stupid, but it’s very subtle. Because, on the one hand, the pillar that we experience although a pillar is not a very good example but because we experience this pillar in a particular way, it acts as the basis of all suffering.

And when one experiences the pillar as it is, there’s no way we can experience any kind of suffering whatsoever, but there is bliss in the mind. So, it’s kind of worthwhile to understand this very subtle difference because there is suffering and there is a cause of suffering. The Buddha said there is only one cause from everything from a toothache to mass murders. There is one cause for a toothache and the lowest hell, and that is seeing this pillar in the wrong way. This is either very stupid or very, very, very profound.

His Holiness spent years and years trying to understand this point, studying this point. Because, again, if we go back to the example of the rope and the snake, we have had this experience. A snake appears, you know, a tree stump definitely, I’ve looked in the countryside and seen tree stumps that look like people. Or even down the street, it looks like your friend, it’s not your friend. Could have sworn it was your friend.

So, what appears to the mind is not there at all, is not there at all, and what is actually there, a stranger, a tree stump, a rope, one doesn’t see. What is actually there, we don’t see at all, at all. What is not there, we see. We see a pillar, it is not there at all. What is actually there, the pillar, we don’t see.

There is a pillar there, there is a rope there, on the basis of that, our ignorance puts something that is not there. It creates with the mind something that is not there at all. And then we believe it, that that’s it. And that is the source of suffering. There is a person here which exists in a very insubstantial way, like a rainbow appearing in the sky, totally existing but totally ungraspable, existing purely because of many, many factors arising so momentarily, and then there’s this appearance.

It’s there, but it’s not something existing from its own side that can stay there. It is there, a rainbow is not an hallucination. It’s like one, it’s like an illusion, but it’s not an illusion. So we and everything exists like that, but our mind grasps like a small child that it’s really there, that Bugs Bunny is really inside the television set, running around. That’s what we think.

This is not easy to understand. To say the words is relatively easy. To actually understand what the words are leading to takes a lot of time. We have to have a purified mind, a lot of merit, the blessings of the Guru, and we have to study the teachings again and again, and not just think, Oh, you read a few words and I’ve understood that. But, like, for example, when we say something is true, what do we mean by that, this is true?

When we say that, we seem to be implying that it’s an independent fact that everyone will agree with, because from its own side it’s like that. The truth of the fact is, the truth of the situation is this: When the accident happens, the truth of the accident is, it happened like that. But when one checks, this driver says that, the other driver says that, this onlooker over there says that, and the other person there says that, and another person said, I didn’t even see an accident. So, what is the truth? Very difficult to find, an independently existing truth.

So, when we talk about truly existing, that’s what we’re implying, that there is something, that everything has this facticity, this reality that is unquestionable and it’s there from its own side, that everyone can know and experience. But it’s not alright, it’s not like that. What we are experiencing is not like that. Emptiness is something everyone with a valid, clear mind can experience. That can be discovered, that empty nature of things.

But the true existence of things can’t be found at all. Everything can only exist depending on causes and conditions, parts and the labeling mind. But this phenomena, as we experience it now, does not appear like that at all. So, we’ll try and investigate this some more after the break. Thank you very much.

So, a fundamental view of the Mādhyamika school is that if something exists in accordance with its concrete appearance, if it exists the way it actually seems to appear, one has to be able to find that object. It appears to exist sorry if it’s really the way it appears to our mind, then we should be able to find it. If we look at either it has to be the same as its parts or it has to be something different from them. So, in the teachings yeah So, if there’s this truly existing phenomena, this truly existing phenomena, then we have to we should be able to find it. If it really exists as a truly truly existing phenomena, existing from its own side.

So, there is the traditional presentation which I will now attempt to do. Again, probably many of you have seen this many, many times. I have also done it and seen it many, many times and at one level one can just dismiss it as a party trick but that’s because we really don’t understand how profound this is. I’m sorry, maybe that’s like a cover up but it is actually a very profound thing to try to understand and maybe at least what we can understand from it is that we do grasp at true existence because here is a flower. So, in actual fact, one can do this in meditation, I’m just doing it crudely but one can do this with anything.

Come on, please. This is serious, important, right? It is. But one can do it with anything and one does it mentally, but here I’m just going to do it physically. But here is a flower, right?

And that flower, to us, whether we understand it or not, is appearing as being a truly existing flower. This is the words that are used to try to capture the actual experience we’re having right now, that it appears as a truly existing flower from its own side, from its own side. So if such a flower does exist, if it exists truly from its own side, it would be an independent phenomena, an independent phenomena, and we should find it if we look for it, if we look for this truly existing flower. So, we look, okay, there is a flower here Buddhism says, the Dharma says, the Buddha says, there’s no question that there is a flower here. But there is not a truly existing flower here.

So, what we’re now this is important to understand, is that what we’re looking for now is not a flower which is a dependent arising because that does exist here and can be found. Here it is. This flower is actually arising depending on many factors. That flower can be found and here it is. But now, what we’re going to look for is the truly existing flower.

Yeah, the truly existing flower, from its own side, independent, which would mean it’s independent of anything. Okay? So here’s the flower, so where is it really, this real flower? Is this the flower? No, this is not the truly existing flower, it is part of a flower.

Part of a flower is not a flower, it’s part of a flower. So that’s not the flower. So is this the flower? Because I’m looking at the flower and I’m trying to find the real flower, the truly existing flower, so I look, but that’s, Oh, I’m looking at the flower, but all I that’s just part of a flower. Okay?

But still this the flower here, so this must be it. Wherever but no, oops, it’s just part of a flower. It’s a petal. Is a petal a flower? No, it is not a flower.

It’s not a truly existing flower or a dependently arising flower, it’s just part of a flower. If you gave that to your girlfriend, you’d be in trouble. So is this the flower? We keep looking, you know, looking. Here’s the flower.

I can see this real flower is here, so I look. Where is it? Where is it? Is this it? No.

It’s a part. Is this it? No. It’s a part. Is this it?

No, it’s a part. Is this it? No, it’s a part. Is this it? No, it’s two parts.

And one can keep doing this, and wherever one looks at the flower, you can’t find it. All you can find is part of a flower, but you cannot, wherever you look, you can’t find the whole flower. A flower, you know, this is part of a flower, it’s a stem, but it’s not a flower. Then you look here, there’s the flower, the whole flower, the truly existing flower, but when you look at it, woah, you see, it just falls apart, you can’t find it anywhere. All you can find are parts.

And then, if you look at this, here’s part of a flower. So this is a petal which is part of a flower, so is that the petal? No, it’s part of the petal. Is that the petal? No, it’s just part of the petal.

Is this bit the petal? No, it’s one side of the petal. So is that the petal? No, it’s the other side of the petal. Is that the petal?

That’s the very thin side of the petal. It’s not the petal. When you look, even at a petal, you can’t find the petal. All you can ever find is part of a petal. And when you look at part of a petal, you can’t even find part of a petal, because everywhere you look, you find a part of a part of a petal.

Wherever you look. So then, one could say, so here’s the truly existing flower back again, right? Because we keep grasping, you know, we say, oh this is just a game, you know, sure there’s parts but look, there it really is, parts because actually all the parts, if you put all the parts together, if you would stop tearing this nice flower apart and leave the parts together, there is a flower. But a part of a flower is not a flower, and all the parts together are not a flower, they are the different parts of a flower. Are all the different parts of a flower a flower?

Well, you’re supposed to say yes and then I say and then I say no, they’re not. All the parts together are not a flower because all the parts together, if you put all the parts correctly together, again, what are they? They are the basis to label flower. There is the basis on which you label a flower. They are not the flower.

They are the basis for labeling a flower, calling something a flower. Is this a flower? No, it’s not a flower. Why isn’t it a flower? Why can’t we call it I can call this a flower, I can call it a flower, but calling it a flower doesn’t make it a flower.

Just giving something the label, the name flower doesn’t make it a flower. Right? Why this isn’t you can’t make this a flower by calling it a flower because it doesn’t have the right basis. This is the right basis, and on that basis, you can call something flower. But something and its basis are not the same thing.

Not this yeah. But there’s a real flower here. Look, there it is. But then, if you look again, all you can find is a part, and a part, and a part, and a part. But our mind keeps grasping at the fact that there is a real flower here from its own side, that’s how it appears to our mind.

And the point is you can’t we cannot understand that in five minutes, So, don’t worry, I don’t understand it either. I’ve been trying for twenty four years to understand this. I mean, one can say the words, but to get the experience is difficult, but it’s worth trying. Because our mind keeps grasping like there’s just that, and our mind keeps creating that again and again. There’s just this stuff, insubstantial, nothing to it, but our mind creates this thing that this is really there from its own side, independent of parts.

Because in our life, in our daily life, moment by moment, when we are not investigating, and no average sentient being goes around investigating, we don’t see a flower dependent on parts. We do not experience a flower as something dependent on its parts. We see, we experience some whole thing, a complete thing that is there from its own side. Check out, Is this true or not? So, to be able to even to check up correctly, we have to have a clear mind and an open mind.

Not saying, Oh, this is just a party trick. It can look like that, but what are what are we really seeing here? Because if you do investigate, look, there’s the flower, but look, if you look anywhere, if you look anywhere at this flower, you don’t see a flower, can only see a part. This is not the flower, it’s just the front of the flower. There’s also the back.

You can’t see the back. I can see the back. You can’t see the back. Wherever you look, can only see a part of something, but there seems to be something there that is not made of parts. This is what we have to check out.

And that is what draws our attention, this amazing thing that is there from its own side. When we get Excuse me, but if we look at its beautiful body, we look at the outside part, we don’t look at the inside part. That’s why we get attached, because we just look at the outside part and think it’s the whole, and therefore we get attached to it. If we looked at all the parts, we would not be so attached. And if we realized the outside part depends on the inside part, you see.

But please check up yourself, like everything we see is like that. There seems to be something, one thing there from its own side, but when we look, we can’t find it. It just parts. Something that is actually when we look, all we can find is something that is arising, depending, totally depending on its parts. Also, you know, we talked about it yesterday, it’s also depending on causes and conditions For it to actually come into existence and for it to continue to exist, it depends on many causes and conditions.

And also, it depends on parts, but we don’t experience it like that. We don’t see such a phenomenon. So then the next thing that we don’t see, here’s this truly existing phenomena, and existing from its own side, with its own characteristics, and we just simply know it as a flower. So this actually what we’re experiencing is the basis for something to be labeled a flower. So, if we call this a flower, it appears to our mind as a flower.

If we don’t call it a flower, if we don’t label it that, it cannot appear to our mind as a flower. But this doesn’t mean we just go around throwing these labels around. We are forced to call this a flower by our karma or our past imprints and instantly recognising this as this piece of vegetation, we instantly recognise it as flower, we instantly label it as flower, because our karma experiences force us to do that. But if that label isn’t there, it can’t appear as a flower. This does not appear as a flower to a dog or to a bee.

Is not a flower. I don’t know what it appears to as a bee, but maybe as something to eat. When we look at a flower, we don’t think of something to eat. But when a bee perceives this thing, it doesn’t label it a flower, it sees it, it perceives it, conceives it as a source of food. But if it truly existed from its own side, it would appear as a flower to a bee.

What kind of flower is this? This is not a trick question. Okay, okay. How many people know what this flower is called or think they know what it’s called? Any name, correct name.

Not many, yeah. So therefore, because most of us here don’t know what it’s called, it can’t appear as that flower. All it can appear is a flower, kind of pinky purpley flower. Yeah, that’s all it can appear. So would someone like to say what kind of flower this is?

It’s a Chrysanthemum. Now you have a new label, which you put on it, and now you see, through the power of a label, a chrysanthemum. Before you could only see some kind of pinky purpley flower, now we can all see a chrysanthemum, and every time we look at one flower like this in the future, we will see a chrysanthemum, just like that, Unquestionably, this is a chrysanthemum, and it will appear to exist that way from its own side. So, some people here saw a chrysanthemum, most people here did not see a chrysanthemum. If this was a truly existing chrysanthemum the way we think it is, we would all know it’s a chrysanthemum.

Because this thing appears to exist independently of any label, we are not conscious that we conceive of this thing in some way. It just appears it seems to be telling us, I am a flower, I’m the pinkly purpley flower, I am a chrysanthemum pinkly purpley flower. It seems to be telling us that from its own side. You want to talk to everyone? Doesn’t it seem to be saying that to us from its own side?

If we don’t think about it when we don’t investigate in our daily life, we walk along the streets in the shops and these things talk to us. I am beautiful and desirable and I will make you happy from my own side. Yeah. I will fulfil your every desire. Things talk to us like that.

From their own side they seem to be like that. They do not appear as depending on the way our mind conceives them and gives them a label. If we don’t give it the label, it simply cannot appear. If our mind doesn’t conceive it in a particular way, it can’t appear that way. If we don’t give it a particular name, it can’t appear that way.

But as soon as our mind conceives something through the power of delusion and karma, it appears that way, from its own side. For example, also, what is that? A big marble. What is it? Okay.

We have somebody sees a what a big marble, Someone sees a relic? But please, what what what how does this appear to you? Someone say what you know, not no jokes, just seriously. A black ball. Shiny?

Someone else? What appears to your mind? Sorry? A round plastic. Round plastic.

Okay. A scatter ball. Something Dutch, yeah? Okay. So, we give different labels, but if this thing truly existed from its own side, we would know exactly what it was without a label.

If it really existed from its own side, we would know exactly what it was and what it’s made of. So, because you can’t see it properly, but so, for someone who looked plastic, someone who looked shiny, does it look like plastic to everyone? No. Glass? Stone.

Stone. Yeah, actually it’s stone. See, even if it was stone from its own side, you should know without being told. If it was truly existing stone, we would know. It’s actually obsidian, Mexican obsidian from Mexico.

Yeah, it’s Mexican obsidian. That’s what it is. That’s its label. Yeah, but you couldn’t see that. Why?

Very dumb, very dumb. Because it’s truly like it’s no different from this thing here, it’s no different in reality from this pillar here, from this flower. Everyone can tell me this is a glass, how come you can’t tell me what this is? It’s the same thing, it’s existing in the same way. No problem, this is a book, right?

We all got that one right, smart. Good class, book, got book right. Now children, what is this? Can’t tell. Why can’t we tell?

Because we can’t put the right label, it just all we can label it is round or black or shiny or something, and so we give it that label and that’s how it appears. But it’s also Mexican obsidian stone. But if it was really that from its own side, the way we experience things, we would know that instantly. We would know that instantly, just as there’s no question that this is a glass, there’s no question that this is a flower, there’s no question that this is a microphone. From our side, as we experience it without investigating, it appears from its own side to be that.

Check up. I mean, we have to check up our experience and try and discover how things appear to us. And we can start, maybe, to realize that the way things appear to us is not the way they actually are. So also, apart from being Mexican obsidian, one can label it, it’s round, which is true, roundish, it’s blackish, but it’s not actually if you look carefully, it’s not completely black, it has all these little light colors and stuff. And one can label it shiny, one can label it a marble, one could label it a ball, label it a relic, label it heavy, you know, but also we can label it beautiful.

We could label it beautiful or we could label it ugly or we could label it nothing much at all. We could label it valuable, not valuable, and we can label it mine. It’s mine. Yeah, we can label it mine. So, is the big problematic label when it becomes mine or me.

This is the most serious label that we put on things, or one of them, or especially beautiful or ugly. Yeah? When something appears beautiful or ugly, it appears to exist from its own side. It doesn’t appear to depend on that label. Where does that label come?

This is beautiful, beautiful flower. It’s beautiful. Where is the beauty? Where is the beauty? If you like, yeah.

Yeah, in the eye of the beholder, yeah. But, in the emotional moment, we don’t see the beauty in the eye of the beholder, we see it in the thing, it’s really there. We don’t see that the beauty depends actually on the label beauty, and we don’t experience that it’s our mind saying that, calling it that. Of course, we go around saying, I think this is beautiful to other people, but why do we say, I think this is beautiful? Because we think it is beautiful.

Because I see it’s beautiful, but from its own side. So, we see something here that is not there. We don’t see this thing as depending and totally depending on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind. That’s the only way this thing can exist, if you check. If there are no parts, where is the flower?

How can you have a flower without the parts of the flower? Is there a flower that is only one petal? I hope there’s not. It can only exist depending on parts, causes and conditions, and actually, most subtly, most profoundly, it can only exist depending on our mind perceiving it, conceiving of it, and conceiving it with a specific label. That’s the only way this phenomenon can exist for us, the only way.

Check up how else could it exist. But that flower that is purely dependent on all these factors, we don’t perceive. We see a flower that is not the product of causes and conditions, parts, or our mind. We experience a truly existing flower, and that is the source of all suffering. Because just as we see a truly existing flower that is truly existing, desirable or ugly or so on, the I that is experiencing it, we also experience as a truly existing I, existing from its own side.

But such an I can’t be found Because we ourselves are the validly existing I is totally dependent on causes and conditions, parts, and the labeling mind. We have the five aggregates. Just as you see, when you look at this, you see a flower, when you look at this, we see a person.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top