43 min · 4,633 words · 1 December 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaches that things appear to exist from their own side, under their own power, but cannot, because such independent existence is impossible. Illustrates this with a book, partless particles, and the self’s dependence on body, mind and causes. Explains dependent arising through the Madhyamaka Prasangika view, quotes Saraha, and ends with a recitation of the Heart Sutra and a dedication.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-12-01
Duration: 43 min
UUID: 29d8ebe3-0bea-422c-92dc-d6cdec150f2d
Words: 4,633
Never check for a moment. We don’t even know how to check-in most cases. And because of that we suffer because there’s the appearance of true existence there, that somehow things exist from their own side. The way things appear to us now, both the way I appear to exist and how people appear to exist, how all phenomena appear to exist, is that if we check up carefully, things, everything seems to exist in its own right, from its own side, in and of itself, it’s existing in and of itself with its own characteristics, that have their own quality, existing from their own side, in their own right. That’s how things appear to us.
Yellow flower appearing to exist as being yellow and flower and everything else in its own right. And it it may appear to us as beautiful flower, and the beauty seems to exist there in its own right, from its own side, under its own power, with its own characteristics. And so if that was the case, if things were like that, then they would be independent. We don’t actually see this phenomena as independent. But the way we do see it, as existing, having its own qualities from its own side, if that’s the way it existed, then the logical consequence is that it must be an independent phenomena.
Similarly, I, the I that appears to us that we grasp as being me, as real, seems to exist from its own side with its own characteristics, under its own power. And if that I if the I did exist that way, logically it would have to be an independent phenomenon. So this is how Lama Tsongkhapa so this is something we also have to try to investigate, the truth of that. Firstly we have to try and discover how things do appear to our mind Because these are the words that we have to try to match those words with our own experience. Wait, I’ll get totally confused.
I am already totally confused. I’ll just get more totally confused. What is this? It’s a book. Right?
It’s it’s obviously a book. There’s no question that it’s not a book. Right? How do we know it’s a book? Yeah, it’s got pages in it.
How do we know this is a page? How do we know that’s writing? No clever Buddhist answers please. Now just really from our own instinctive experience, not what we’ve learnt as good Buddhists. Because why are they letters?
Sorry? How do we know what a typewriter is? Sorry? Who’s talking? Yes.
Yeah. Okay. Some Yeah. Sorry. It’s very funny when you look at someone else and there’s someone else talking.
Yes. Yeah. We we we actually one of the reasons is we recognize it. We recognize it. But we also recognize it because it’s obviously a book.
It just seems to exist as a book from its own side. You know, this is if we don’t investigate, right? Because in our date, moment to moment experience of life, we don’t investigate things, we just kind of experience them uncheckingly and it’s just a book from its own side. It doesn’t require any intelligence or effort in our daily experience to know this is a book. So this is the type of thing that we should try to catch about how do we experience this.
And the words say that it it it is appearing to be a book from its own side. And if you look at it, like all of us here now, when we look at it, and because we see this image here, we almost know, oh it’s a book about Buddhism probably, because it’s got this image, this is a kind of Buddhist image here we recognise. So it appears from its own side to be a Buddhist book. Sure. Yes.
Also yeah. But that’s intellectually, you know, what happens but we’re just in our in our momentary experience. Yeah, because we recognized other books in the same way. But it’s not doesn’t have an appearance. No, you’re giving a Buddhist answer.
You never you know, you don’t think that in your when you’re eating soup? You don’t ask me what I mean. But you don’t ask yourself, we don’t ask ourselves. When when we eat the soup it appears look check, know when you eat soup, when you eat when we eat something it appears from its own side to be delicious or not delicious. Even the way we say things, know, oh this is good.
Like, oh I didn’t know this was good, I didn’t know it was good, it’s me it’s good. Oh, oh, Isn’t it? It’s something like that. So we have to try and catch that mind and understand what these words mean, that somehow we are caught in this ignorance. We do have it.
We may like to think and we may be very intelligent, educated people, whatever, but even if one is Einstein, even Einstein had this ignorance, probably, that saw things as existing from their own side. So we have to try and catch there’s these words existing from its own side under its own power and so on. So we have to try and catch from our own experience what those words mean. And because then we can start to understand that if things did exist that way, logically it means they are independent phenomenon. Right?
So that is the basis for why Lama Tsongkhapa said, the easiest way to understand the way things actually exist, to experience the empty nature of things, is to understand dependent arising. Because if we understand dependent arising, we understand that no independent phenomena can exist. There is no such thing as an independent phenomena existing in the universe. It is a logical absurdity for something to exist independently. The way we see things, experience things, like ‘see’ doesn’t mean with your eyes but also we do more or less with our eyes but the way we experience things as we experience them as existing from their own side, under their own power, with their own characteristics.
If this appearance corresponded with the way they actually existed, it would mean they were independent. And if we can then understand through understanding dependent arising that nothing can exist as an independent phenomena, then when we find the refuting object, the person that appears to exist from its own side, it appears unquestionably to have that appearance, but then through the power of understanding dependent arising, we can understand that although it appears this way, it could not possibly exist that way because it would have to exist as an independent phenomena. An independent phenomena cannot exist. So this is just a fantasy of the mind. I don’t know if I can do this correctly but we all understand that physical phenomena are made up of atoms and probably now there is a more modern version that there used to be the view, and probably we as very ordinary people, not delving into science so much although there may be some great scientists here, don’t know.
Anyway, used to be the view of a partless particle. That there is if break down physical matter, you must get to a point where there is the smallest particle which has no parts. Because this you can cut into parts, right? We all agree that, that’s obvious that this can be chopped into parts. But we tend to think that we must reach a point where you can’t chop anything into anything smaller otherwise it wouldn’t exist.
That there is something, an essential building block of the universe which is a partless particle. It may be unbelievably tiny but it is without parts. That is the view. This is also the logical consequence of believing in true existence. That there is world is made up of these tiny solid particles, real particles that can’t be broken down any smaller.
But two and a half thousand years ago Buddhist logicians said such a phenomena is utterly impossible to exist. Because if such a partless particle exists, tiny phenomena, there is no way another one could join with it to make a bigger phenomena. Because if it has no parts, and this other partless particle has no parts, there’s no way for them to join. And that they would actually merge with each other. There’s no part of this one that you can join with a part of that one to make a bigger one because they’re partless.
All they could do is merge and occupy the same space. So no matter how many partless particles you brought together, they would just emerge and occupy the one partless particle. Think about it. You have to have parts to touch. If it has no parts, and this one has no parts, how they join?
They would just merge as one thing and you keep bringing a million of them and they would just still merge with each other as the one partless particle. You couldn’t join them to make something bigger. And actually they would occupy no space because if that’s impossible to explain. Because as soon as it has any dimension it has parts. So a partless particle could have no size whatsoever.
Because as soon as it had a size it would have some parts. That’s part and that part, that side and that side, and that side and that side, top and bottom. It couldn’t have a top and bottom because it’s partless, so it couldn’t have any dimension whatsoever. So there ain’t such thing as a partless particle, solid stuff making up the world. It just appears like that.
Anyway, it’s good to think about. So anyway, if things did exist the way they appear, they would be independent. Independence is impossible. Independent phenomena are impossible. And if we check the I that does appear to us, it always appears somehow in relation to the body and mind.
We just simply can’t talk about me without taking into consideration at some level this body and this mind. Yeah. If we say, I am happy, we can’t say that unless the mind is happy. If we say, I am sick, we can’t say it unless the body is sick. If we say I am healthy, we can’t say it without the body being healthy.
But as we say that, we think that there is something, an I, that is not the body or mind, that is somehow existing from its own side under its own power. If if that is the case, which we’ve we’ve we’ve had a little experience of that when we sit and we think I am sitting, it doesn’t appear to be just the body. There seems to be something that is sitting here that is not just the body. And it’s not the mind because the mind doesn’t actually sit here. There is a mind with this body but we never think my mind is sitting here unless we think our mind is the brain.
But our brain isn’t really sitting here, it’s up there. It’s not sort of sitting. So we do feel that there is something more than just the body here. Yeah. And and also when we say I am thinking, it’s the mind that thinks that we feel that there is something other than the mind that is thinking, that is feeling.
It’s and that I that appears to be existing right now, somehow it it doesn’t even though we can’t, somehow it always does seem to be mixed up with the body and mind, somehow, still we grasp, if one checks more and more, that somehow it is existing from its own side with its own characteristics, from its own side. It’s it’s there. But if such an I was there, it would be independent of the body and mind. But such a phenomena can’t exist. So, in all schools of Buddhism there is the view of dependent arising, but the different philosophical schools have also different views of what dependent arising implies and means.
So In lowest schools, philosophical schools, all that dependent arising is basically referring to is understood in terms of effects dependent on their causes, that this is the main meaning of dependent arising, it means that things arise depending on their causes. So this is a very simple view of dependent arising because that fails to take into account that there are permanent phenomena. One understands dependent arising as things arising depending on causes, that only applies to impermanent phenomena. Impermanent phenomena depend on causes and conditions, so therefore they are dependent arising, but there are also permanent phenomena that exist such as space. But that isn’t included in that view of dependent arising, there’s no way to understand that space could also be a dependent arising from the point of the lower schools.
They only understand that something is a dependent arising if it depends on causes, but space doesn’t depend on causes. So it doesn’t appear to be a dependent arising. Appears to be a truly existing phenomenon. So then in some of the higher schools they do include the idea of permanent phenomena also being dependent arising because they argue that permanent phenomena such as space depend on parts, both directional parts and temporal parts. There is a previous moment, the present moment of space depends on the previous moment of space, and like that.
So space can also be understood, permanent phenomena can also be understood as dependent arisings. But it is only in the higher school of the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika where they argue that everything is a dependent arising because things either depend on causes and conditions or parts, but everything, every single thing depends on the mind and the way the mind labels. It depends on the label and how the mind labels things. So everything is a dependent arising. Nothing can exist independently.
Nothing cannot exist independently of the mind, totally separate, isolated from the mind. So if we can it’s it’s really important to understand what is meant from the Mādhyamika point of view of dependent arising because this is the most profound presentation of of dependent arising. So and it completely cuts through the idea that there could be anything existing independently such as me, a me, or any other phenomena, and that anything could have independent characteristics such as being independently beautiful, independently evil. Such a phenomenon simply cannot exist according to the Buddhist understanding and experience. So, for example, the easiest way of understanding dependent arising is how things exist depending on causes and conditions, impermanent phenomena exist depending on causes and conditions.
So, in the case of a table, it seems in one way very easy to understand that this table exists dependent on causes and conditions. Although it appears to be just here from its own side, we can understand that it’s not completely independent because it can only exist here depending on causes and conditions. Firstly by being built, depending on causes and conditions, being brought together. But also this point is not so easy to understand actually because Je Tsongkhapa himself said that when for the ordinary person, when they understand something exists depending on causes and conditions, for the ordinary person that is proof that the thing really exists. For example, if we make a cake or we make a table ourselves, we we know we made it depending on causes and conditions.
And because we know we made it, we’re convinced it’s real. There it is. There’s the cake. There’s the table. It’s really here.
Why? Because I made it depending on causes and conditions. This this this gompa is really here because it was built depending on causes and conditions. It’s not a fantasy, it’s really, really here because it’s existing on, dependent on causes and conditions. But actually, because it arises dependent on causes and conditions, it’s not it’s not truly existing.
It is existing, but it’s not truly existing from its own side. If it was truly existing from its own side, it wouldn’t depend on causes and conditions. We may make something, a painting or I don’t know what, a painting, a pot, a piece of jewelry, And we say, I made I made this and it’s and and it’s beautiful. It’s really beautiful. If it was really beautiful from its own side as it now appears, it couldn’t depend on causes and conditions.
But we think because we made it depending on causes and conditions, it’s really beautiful. But because it has arisen depending on cause and conditions, it’s it may be beautiful, but it’s not beautiful from its own side. It’s not really beautiful from its own side. It’s it’s depending on causes and conditions. And if it didn’t and if if if it if it was really beautiful from its from its own side, when the causes and conditions changed, it would remain beautiful all the time.
But you can see, one can check out if the conditions change, things change, the appearance changes. If if you look at something from another perspective, just physically move, it may no may not may not look as beautiful as before. You can’t see it properly, so it doesn’t appear so beautiful. But if it was really beautiful from its own side, no matter what the causes and conditions, it would always be the same. So because things exist, things can only exist, or impermanent phenomena can only exist depending on causes and conditions, but because they depend on causes and conditions, they exist, but they don’t truly exist from their own side with their own characteristics under their own power.
They are just existing moment by moment, depending on other things, and these things are changing all the time. So they have no essence, no findable essence. One can take an example of clothing fashions. At one point a certain type of dressing, clothing is considered fashionable, beautiful. And when we look at it, it appears from its side to be very beautiful, desirable, fashionable, etcetera, etcetera.
From its own side, not depending on causes and conditions. But it can only exist that way depending on causes and conditions. But it doesn’t appear to be that way. It appears to be really beautiful, desirable, up to date, the very best thing to have from its own side. If it was like that, if it was truly existing like that from its own side, the way it appears, when the causes and conditions changed, it it would not change.
It would always be fashionable. But how how long do things remain fashionable? Sometimes only a few weeks, a few months, one or two years, and then it’s out. But when we look at it, it appears from its own side to be the fashionable desirable thing. But then you look at all if as you get older, then you look at photos of yourself wearing things and you think, I used to wear that?
I can’t believe that. Yeah? It’s it’s kind of embarrassing. Yeah? But if if it if it really if it really was the way it first appeared to us, it would always look fantastic, up to date, the coolest thing to have.
But it can only appear that way depending on causes and conditions, and these are constantly changing. Similarly, with I, I right now appear to exist in a certain way, And and it feels like I exist this way completely from from my own side. But actually, it’s only I’m existing in this way depending on causes and conditions. But those causes and conditions are changing all the time, they don’t last. And when the causes and conditions change, I change.
But we don’t perceive that, we think I am really like this from my own side. We may feel now, now I am a great Dharma practitioner. Now during this month I have become a great meditator, great yogi, great bodhisattva from my own side and it feels like that from our own side. And we don’t recognize that it’s that I is can only exist depending on causes and conditions of being here, and when we go away from here, the causes and conditions are different and suddenly I am different, And the great bodhisattva somehow fades away. But right now it feels like, you know, this is this is just naturally me.
From my own side, I’m like this. It’s got nothing to do with anything else of being here and having the influence of being here and and so on. It’s got nothing to do with that. It’s me. But if that was me, the truly you know, if there was this truly existing me, no matter what the causes and conditions, how they change, I would always be the same.
Check out yourself, see what happens. Even things like the changing of the weather, when sunshine is out, I somehow feel more alive, happy and so on, more optimistic. But we’re not even aware of that. It just seems that’s me, that that’s this is me. This is the real me.
But this real me actually has arisen dependent on causes and conditions. When the condition goes away, the sun sets, especially during the day, day after day, no sunshine, the me is different. And then we tend to think, oh, this is me. This is this is me from my own side, I’m like that, miserable, depressed. But it actually is arising depending on causes and conditions.
And we think this is the real me in this body. Without this body I’ll still be me. But one day we’re going to lose this body and there won’t be this I because the I we feel is so real, so findable, so solid now, is arising depending on causes and conditions. So I’ll stop there. That’s a little bit to think about, about dependent arising of the first part of depending on causes and conditions.
So this applies not just to the me, the person, but everything. So we can dedicate the merit. Oh, maybe I’ll finish with this quotation. I like this quotation, I don’t know if it quite fits in. So as I was saying, everything is dependently dependent, dependent arising, is itself a dependent arising.
So even emptiness, the actual nature of the way things exist, is not an independent phenomena existing from its own side, it also is arising dependently. So the great Mahasiddha Saraha who lived in the ninth century AD said, Those who believe in substantiality, which is us, we believe in things being really substantial. Those who believe in substantiality are like cows. Those who believe in emptiness are worse. So if we think emptiness truly exists, we’ve made a big mistake.
It does exist but it doesn’t truly exist from its own side. Saraha Saraha. It said those who believe in substantiality are like cows. Cow are cows, yeah? Like moo, yeah.
Those who believe in emptiness are worse, have made a bigger mistake, yeah. So this teaching is not saying things do not exist, this is the most interesting thing, things do exist but they don’t exist under their own power, from their own side, substantially, inherently, truly, independently. Things are not illusions, they are like illusions. There are things that are totally illusions but this pillar here is not an illusion, it’s like an illusion. Actually the pillar we’re seeing now is an illusion.
The pillar that is actually there is like an illusion. So we can dedicate the merit that we may be able to quickly realize the final view of how oneself and all phenomena exist, and through this quickly achieve the fully enlightened state that continuously and effortlessly, spontaneously, perfectly benefits every suffering mother sentient being. May the precious bodhi mind not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore. Thank you very much.
There’s a note that venerable friend will come tonight and talk about Kopan plans, programs etc. At eight. Okay, thank you very much. Homage to the three noble jewels. Thus did I hear at one time the Bhagwan was dwelling on Vulture Peak Mountain in Rajagriha together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas.
At that time the Bhagavan was absorbed in a concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of profound perfection of wisdom and behold those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of Buddha, the venerable Shariputra said this to the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Avalokiteśvara. How should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activity of profound perfection of wisdom. He said that in the bodhisattva Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara said this to the venerable Shariputra.
Shariputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom should look upon it like this correctly and repeatedly beholding those five aggregates also as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty, emptiness is form, emptiness is not other than form, form is also not other than emptiness. In the same way feeling, discrimination and compositional factors and consciousness are empty. Shariputra, likewise all phenomena are emptiness without characteristic, unproduced, unceased, not defiled, not undefiled, not decreased, not fulfilled. Therefore in emptiness there is no form, feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odour, no taste, no object of touch and no phenomena.
There is no eye element and so on up to and including, no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance and so on up to and including, no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly there is no suffering, origination, cessation and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment and also no non attainment. Shariputra, therefore because there is no attainment, bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom, the mind without obscuration and without fear.
Having completely passed beyond error they reach the endpoint of nirvana. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly and completely awakened to unsurpassable perfect complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequaled, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as truth since it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared. Tadyatha gate gate paragate parasamgate bodhi svaha.
Shariputra, the bodhisattva, Mahasattvas should train the profound perfection of wisdom like that. Then the Bhagawan arose from that concentration, commended the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, saying: Well said, well said, son of the lineage. It is like that. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated, even the Tathagatas rejoice.
Having thus spoken to Venerable Shariputra, the bodhisattva, Mahāsattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding in their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, asuras and Gandharvas were overjoyed and highly praised that spoken by the Bhagawan. I prostrate to the gathering of dakinis in the three places who abide in the holy yoga of using space by your powers of clairvoyance and magical emanation, look after practitioners like a Buddha would a child.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.