41 min · 4,169 words · 1 December 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches tonglen, the practice of taking on others’ suffering in the breath and giving away one’s own happiness, as a way to develop compassion and loving kindness and to loosen self-cherishing. It covers how to begin with oneself and a future self, extend to others, and use everyday problems in this way. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-12-01
Duration: 42 min
UUID: c544fb64-c564-4551-9842-5952d8f25dd4
Words: 4,169
Or in a few years time they will get older and older and experience various kinds of sufferings. They will also lose their friends, have sickness and meet with what they don’t want to meet with, not find what they want to meet with, be separated with the things that they love and are attached to, and have all sorts of different problems and suffering, economic problems maybe. This person has them now and will have in the future, so we think of that and think how wonderful it would be if this person that I love, care for, could be completely free of all that suffering and its causes. So one really tries to feel that suffering of that person that we care for, not just vaguely think about it, but think about it until the feeling arises, and then we imagine taking that from that person in the form of this very thick black liquid or smoke and breathing it in. As one breathes in, one takes that on into one’s self-cherishing thought so that one actually feels it in one’s heart because that’s where the self-cherishing thought is somehow located.
Like if you walk along a dark street at night and you hear a noise, it’s all kind of no one’s around, but maybe it’s not such a great area to be in, and then you see someone up ahead or you hear something, and then some fear arises, and somehow this kind of shrinks into the heart. There’s this pulling into the heart. This is because this is the mind, the mind is based here somehow, and the self-cherishing is actually based here. That’s why we usually say, who me? So we try to breathe that pain and the causes of it, of this person we love, into the heart where the self-cherishing thought is, the heart chakra, not the physical heart.
And imagining that destroying our own self-cherishing, then we experience our own pure mind free of that self-cherishing, this blissful, clear mind pervaded by compassion and love, and then we breathe all those qualities out to this dear friend, and especially all our merit, the causes of our happiness in a form of white light going into that person, then we imagine them, all their suffering has stopped, they become happier and happier, healthier and healthier. Every good thing one imagines, every good thing happens to them, we can imagine them experiencing liberation and enlightenment. But if one doesn’t sort of believe in that part, well, that doesn’t matter, at least imagine them experiencing all good things of this life as one breathes in one’s own happiness into them. But the main thing is to try to make it real that one is actually feeling their suffering and actually giving one’s happiness away, not just a little bit of it, but all of it to that person. I’m imagining taking out all one’s happiness and all the causes of one’s happiness, so one doesn’t have any left, not a bit is left, and give it to the other person.
But see, the sneaky thing is, the way this meditation works when we do it with ourselves, with another person, and with many, is that strictly speaking, with one in breath you take in the suffering, and with the out breath you give your happiness. But I don’t know about you, but when I try it, that’s much too fast. It’s kind of a bit confusing. So as beginners, we think about it for some time, as we’re thinking about especially with the in breaths, for some time we take it in the suffering of our future self or this other dear friend, And then for some time we spend breathing out, on the out breaths, spend some time imagining giving out happiness. But then we alternate, so we don’t just leave it taking the suffering and giving away our happiness, but then again we take the suffering and give happiness.
So the two things are alternating. And eventually we can get to the point where on the in breath we take the suffering, and on the out breath we give our happiness. So by taking on the suffering, it’s a little bit painful, or should be painful, a little bit scary and difficult. But then in the next breath we give our happiness, but that makes us happy. By giving our happiness and imagining this person, our future self, or the dear friend becoming happy, then that makes us happy anyway.
So then we have the courage to take the suffering again, because we’re in a good state of mind. So we take the suffering which is a bit difficult, but we’re in a positive state of mind so it’s manageable. So then we breathe out our happiness again, but by visualising, imagining strongly the other person becoming really happy by that, it’s okay to give our happiness. We have the courage to do it, and so then we can take the suffering again. So by alternating like that, it becomes manageable to be able to take the suffering and give our happiness.
It’s a very sneaky, skillful method. So in this practice, of course, by imagining taking the suffering of others, then this is the practice of compassion. It’s the way to develop compassion, a very powerful and realistic way of increasing our compassion. And then imagining giving our happiness to others is the practice of loving kindness. It requires some loving kindness and it will increase our loving kindness.
So because in reality one can talk separately about loving kindness as this and compassion as that, In reality these two things always go together. The more loving we become, the more compassionate. The more compassionate, the more loving. So depending on our personality, we may want to put more effort into developing loving kindness specifically, but by concentrating on that we develop compassion anyway, we become more compassionate because these two things our mind go together, but also according to our personality, we may like to work more directly on developing compassion, but the more compassionate we become, we have to become more loving, cause these two things are part of the same they’re two sides of the one coin. Tonglen combines that, those two things, in a very powerful way.
So then one simply extends it to to others. Like in one meditation session, can start with yourself, then a friend, then more friends, then some strangers. But again, as I said, with strangers, people at least you know in in some distant way. And then at the end of the session one may be brave enough to think of an enemy, one dislikes a little bit, and taking their suffering. Especially the suffering of that they don’t like me, you could take that on away.
So one can do that in one session, but to really develop Tonglen in a powerful way, would be good to spend really work on just me, the future me for some time, many sessions, and then then after some time, some effort, then stop take one friend, and then work on that for some time, and then take another friend, then another, and then another, and then some a stranger, and then eventually the enemy, and then a bigger enemy, and then start with more sentient beings, than all human beings, than all the animals, than all the preta suffering, and all the hell suffering, and then all the sufferings of people on the path to liberation, all the suffering of bodhisattvas. Because even bodhisattvas have some suffering and obstacles, so one can imagine even taking that. But you can’t take this Buddha as an object because Buddhas have no suffering whatsoever, and you can never, never, never take as an object one’s own guru. One can imagine taking obstacles from around the guru, but not you can’t imagine the guru having suffering and taking it. This is not possible, not correct.
You can practice white Tārā giving yeah, and things, sending nectar. But I don’t think you can ever think of the guru as actually being sick or having suffering. It’s manifesting, but not actually. So that’s the basic way of practicing Tonglen. And as I said, as Śāntideva says, to do it, don’t mess around, really get stuck into it.
Don’t kind of vaguely imagine the suffering, really try to make it real and powerful to shake self-cherishing thought. But not as a way we’re not trying it’s not some way to punish us that we have self-cherishing, therefore I should drown myself myself in suffering. The idea is to try and drown the self-cherishing thought, which is not drown the self-cherishing thought in suffering, but the self-cherishing thought is not me. Oh, okay. Just very briefly, there are other ways of also practicing Tonglen, is that whenever we have suffering in our life, a problem, a difficulty, some sickness, anything that we don’t want happening, then usually why this is happening is because it’s well, it is the ripening of negative karma.
So just uncontrollably negative karma ripens and it ripens as sickness, problems, economic problems, family problems, this and that. So we haven’t made this happen, but it’s happened. But to make it turn meaningful, this suffering, this problem into something really meaningful and actually a part of the path to enlightenment, we can imagine that this suffering I’m experiencing, for example, we have a headache or a cold, which is the ripening of negative karma, but we can imagine, we can do Tonglen where we imagine that this cold I have, this headache, this financial problem, I have consciously, willingly taken from other sentient beings, so that they don’t have a cold, so they don’t have to have the suffering of having a cold, a headache, a financial problem, losing their job, whatever I’m experiencing. So we imagine that, doing Tonglen that way. And then we think of all the sentient beings in the world, or at least the human beings in the world who right now have the same problem, I have a headache, a cold, some kind of sickness, some kind of financial worry, some kind of emotional worry, problem.
So you think thousands and thousands, millions, maybe even tens of millions of people have this same problem, maybe even worse than me. So one imagines the suffering of the problem I have as being I I’ve taken it on from others so they don’t have to have it. And not just now, but by bearing this suffering, whatever it is in my heart, may it become a cause for no one to ever have a cold, lose their job, lose their boyfriend, girlfriend, whatever the problem we have. So then and then we imagine again giving all our happiness, good health, and whatever the opposite to the problem we have to sentient beings. So by doing this strongly and sincerely, it makes our suffering meaningful, and it makes it meaningful to bear our suffering in a wise way, not getting angry with it and feeling victimised and getting upset and frightened and so on.
But we give ourselves the courage to bear this suffering because it’s the suffering of others. The reality is it may just be our own negative karma, but by thinking about it in a meaningful way, it becomes something that we can support and turn as a way to develop courage compassion, so we advance on the path. So this is another way of practicing Tonglen. Another way is whenever in our life whenever we see someone experiencing any kind of suffering, problem, difficulty, whatever it is, in that moment we can imagine taking it on ourself right now and the causes of it in the form of this black smoke liquid, holding it in our self-cherishing thought and breathing out to that person all good things, peace, happiness, contentment, calmness, patience, in the form of this white light. If we see two people arguing on the street, then we can imagine taking that suffering of that argument onto ourselves and breathing, imagining white light going into both people equally, so that they imagine them becoming calm, clear, patient, loving, and everything.
And it may actually become a cause for them to be like that, or at least for the argument to subdue if we send this very strong, loving, calm, clear light to them, and we imagine taking on that suffering. One can do this with another person’s disease, anything. Lama Zopa Rinpoche often gives this practice for people who have some kind of physical health problems, to imagine it as taking on that disease problem from others, and this can be a way, a very powerful way, to actually modify the intensity of the disease and even to cure it. This can be done, it’s possible. Any questions?
Yes. Right. Right. Yes. self-cherishing thought.
Yeah. But you don’t have to worry because if you send it to me, the valid merit gets it. But it’s okay to do things for yourself. It’s okay to do things for yourself. Why we’re in saṃsāra?
It’s okay to take care, but we shouldn’t put too much value on these things. It’s okay to go to movies, watch television, read books, listen to music, eat chocolate cake, lie on the lounge. It’s okay, but not all the time and think that’s all there is. It’s okay to do these things, especially with the Bodhicitta motivation. I am lying on the lounge for the sake of all sentient beings.
It’s possible to rest. This is what when we get hopefully this is a bit of time to talk about the perfection of perseverance, which is the mind taking joy in virtuous actions, which is a crucial mind to try to develop. Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, What we need at the beginning is the realization to meditate on the precious human rebirth and perseverance every day. So one of the things to cultivate in developing and in sustaining perseverance is the quality of relaxing, of knowing when to relax. One does virtuous things, puts lots of energy into doing good things, but then one needs to also take out a little time out to relax in order to build up one’s reserves to do more good things.
So that relaxing is a virtuous and necessary activity. So one can lie on the couch on the beach for the sake of all sentient beings. It’s possible. Two people can be on the beach, one is lying there with a total self-cherishing thought, and so is just wasting life. The other person is lying there even more relaxed, for an even longer period of time with even more suntan lotion and less clothes for the sake of all sentient beings.
It’s possible. But also this point about breathing out the black, all the negativities in the form of black smoke and breathing in the white, this is what is also good to do before doing Tonglen to give the courage of you. Breathe out all your fear of doing it in the form of the black smoke, breathe all all the courage of the Buddhas in the form of white light, and then one can do it. Also, have the Buddha on the crown of your head, the white light comes, washing away all the fear and misunderstandings and this and that, the golden light comes, blessing, giving courage to do it, and then one starts the practice. In front.
Oh, no, no, no. In which case, when we’re thinking about our future me, the self-cherishing thought is here, always here. It’s always to my self-cherishing now here. Into the heart, into the heart chakra here. You imagine it sort of going into the heart and Lama Zopa Rinpoche says, It’s like imagining the self-cherishing thought.
It’s like a rock at your heart, this hard mind, this incredibly hard, cold mind in our heart, and the self-cherishing comes and cracks it, destroys it. And we have to be careful not to send it to the real or whatever heart Right, this is the tricky part. This is the yeah. With the right motivation, can I ask three questions please? Okay, one at a time.
Sure. In the question and answer session with Lama Zopa Rinpoche, I asked a question on meditation on the environment, and he recommended the Tonglen meditation. In terms of the process, would you go through likewise emptiness self and others in terms of cherishing, and then move on to the environment, given a lot of environmental damage as a consequence of this self-cherishing? Yeah, you could imagine taking on the suffering of the beings in the environment. Could you not extend that to damage within the environment as a consequence of self-cherishing?
Yeah, sure, sure, sure, yeah, of others, yeah. That is explained in the mind training like the rays of the sun, that it mentions there. It between pages fifteen? Yes, yes, think so, yeah. Second question is, like with the nine round breathing, is there a recommended number of in and out breaths?
Oh no, no, no, no. You can do it as long as it and well, try and do it until it becomes powerful, And then if the mind is freaking out too much, then one maybe could stop, should stop. But if there’s a certain amount of kind of good shaking, one can keep it going. But one does have to be careful with it. I think the question you just answered and that was with respect to, is there a discourse anywhere else other than the meditation book that we have?
On Tonglen? Sorry? Is it in there? Oh, but it’s basically the same. Sogyal Rinpoche, yeah, the death and dying one, the living and dying.
Also very good is Pema Chodron, this nun Pema Chodron. She has some material on Tonglen, very good. There’s a Kagyu nun called Pema Chodron, she has books and tapes on Tonglen practice. Yeah, but I mean this is actual written, published material. Yeah.
But is it published? No. Think it’s a teaching right now. Oh, yeah. Sure.
Yeah. Yes. Sure. Sure. That some lamas get sick because of doing this practice, because of imagining taking on the suffering of others.
You don’t have to worry, the lamas say you don’t have to worry. But if you get sick, it’s good. It’s the sign of one’s practice working, it’s purification. Then one can rejoice. But that would mean that one has done it very, very powerfully, incredibly powerful.
And the other thing is that for people who are sick, there are cases of people of this sickness completely going because of doing Tonglen. Imagining taking more suffering on from others actually purifies the mind that is the basis for having the problem. Yes. Well, imagine it. No, it’s at the level of imagination.
No, it’s only in your imagination. It can be quite fearful that you could get the problem from it. I can use that to read it, but you have to be able to get it out at the same time? Yes. Yes.
But you’re not going to actually get sick. It wouldn’t have been taught otherwise. I’m not really sure if you can do it with dead people. I’m not quite sure on that. Possibly.
I know that there are some cases, certain practices you shouldn’t do with dead people, people your relatives and so on, certain things, but I’m not really sure about the Tonglen. Oh, okay. Some more questions? Yes. Oh, no, yes, that’s what you’re supposed to be doing.
It’s not your self-cherishing thought to do this practice. If the self-cherishing thought is very strong, we won’t do it. But so, it’s our wisdom compassion mind that does this practice and takes on the suffering and we put our wisdom compassion mind puts it on the self-cherishing thought. Because that is the source of our problem and we’re trying to show ourselves that this is what comes from self-cherishing. Yeah?
You hate suffering but you actually cause suffering. So this is what you’re causing. Cop this. You know? So I don’t how else does yeah?
Get that, you know, take that. Yeah? This is your fault. So but even in the case of taking other suffering, you know, our mind is so afraid of that and that prevents compassion developing. So we’re forcing the self-cherishing thought to say something it doesn’t like, so it collapses.
And then our wise compassionate mind can become more manifest. You say the blood light will come into your heart? Oh, you smoke, yeah. Does the white light come out from your heart? Yes, yes, yeah, but it comes in and then you breathe it out, but it’s coming from your heart, from your mind, yes.
Yes. Yes, definitely, definitely. This is acting as a the more powerfully we do it, and especially if it’s with people we have some strong connection with, by doing this it can act in some mysterious way as a condition for that person to get better. Or for them, even if they don’t physically get better, for their mind to be able to manage the problem better. Yes, yes, if you’re sick yourself, yes definitely.
Just like if you have a headache, you imagine taking on all headaches. Whatever sickness you’ve got, you imagine it’s the sickness of everyone in the world that you’ve taken, so therefore you bear it. That will take a lot of courage. Yes, yes, but that’s what it says, it takes a lot, but it also is the way to develop courage. If we can do it even a little bit, it makes the problem bearable, because there’s some meaning to experiencing it.
Because it’s not just for me, it’s for everyone, therefore I can bear it. It’s meaningful, this suffering is bearable because if I bear it, the longer I bear it, the longer others are free from it. So if we can put ourselves in that mind state, which is not easy, but if we can train to do that, then that makes any problem really meaningful. Yes, yes, also one would do the necessary things to take care of oneself. Yes, sure.
Yeah, definitely. Because you would also want other sentient beings to take Asperos and the right medicine as well. Yeah, good point, thank you very much. Because this is also I mean, what I think of it in terms of practicing patience with the enemy is it doesn’t mean you let the enemy hurt, actually physically hurt, you should also take the necessary precautions to stop the enemy physically harming you. But the main thing is to protect the mind from getting angry towards the enemy.
But you can still run, it may even be possible to hit the enemy on the head with compassion to stop them but without anger. The second practice, like you’re experiencing some illness or something, you’re actually breathing in suffering from people who are experiencing some illness. Yes. Yes. You breathe out.
Yes, yes, yes. You breathe out all imagined joy and happiness and one’s merits to others so they don’t have that and they become completely well and happy and blissful and everything. I think anyone who has taught you is okay, from a tantric point of view, this is for people who practicing guru devotion. The practice of guru devotion is seeing the guru as the Buddha. The person one has chosen as one’s guru, as a Buddha.
So a Buddha doesn’t have suffering. So you can’t take the suffering from a Buddha, so so you can’t take suffering from your Guru. But anybody who you just see teachings from? Yeah, that’s okay if you don’t see them as if you’re not doing that practice. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah, sure, sure. Yeah, absolutely. Okay, maybe we have a few minutes just to do a little Tonglen with our future self. So you could take as your object, either going back home in a few days, weeks, whatever it is, one could think of that as a beginner, oneself much later in this life.
Think of the suffering that could exist at that time, and realize it all comes from one’s own continuity of this present self-cherishing thought. Then we can dedicate the merit of this time, this effort of listening and practicing, to be able to completely reverse the self-cherishing thoughts and develop the courageous, compassionate mind that cherishes others more than self. Through this, may we quickly achieve the state of complete enlightenment that continuously and spontaneously perfectly works for the benefit of all living beings. May the precious Bodhicitta not yet born arise and grow. May that born have no decline but increase forevermore.
So then we can do the food offering practice. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- Kagyü
- The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.